Audrey rates the Cabinet

Audrey Young does her annual rating of the Cabinet. The first figure is for this year, and the second a year ago. Comments after each rating are mine not hers. And note am rating them on the basis of competence, not on whether I agree with their policies.

Helen Clark 7 (7) – I'd be a lower on the basis of the handing of election spending and

6 (7) – Here I would have Cullen higher. He has made less mistakes than Clark.

Jim Anderton 6 (6) – about right. Handling of forestry may push him lower though.

Steve Maharey 6 (7) – I would be no more than a five. Probably a four.

Phil Goff 9 (9) – can;t disagree. He also remains de facto Foreign Minister in some areas

Annette King 9 (7) – Maybe a bit generous but yes at least an eight.

Trevor 4 (6) – Deserves to go down for the stadium, but 4 is a bit rough. I would say 5.

Pete Hodgson 4 (4) – Hodgson was once the safe pair of hands. King kept health reasonably happy for six years and under Hodgson all turning wrong.

Parekura Horomia 5 (5) – Hasn't made a dick of himself lately so a 5 is about right.
Maori Affairs

Mark Burton 2 (2) – I can't think of anything he has achieved, but a 2 should be reserved for major disasters. I would be a 3 or 4.

Ruth Dyson 5 (5) – yep an average performer

Chris Carter 8 (7) – I would mark lower for Whangamata Marina – a 7 at best.

Rick Barker 5 (6) – I would make him a 3 or 4 for turning down the funding for Karori Sanctuary when anyone with political instincts should know you approve the venue where the PM launched the policy from.

David Benson-Pope 4 (3) – has been invisible, but this is probably a deliberate strategy

Lianne Dalziel 6 (6) – I might be a bit more generous and say a 7. I am hearing some positive stuff from business about her.

Damien O'Connor 2 (8) – sadly (as he is a nice guy) a 2 is the maximum one can give.

David Cunliffe 8 (8) – yep not only making good decisions in telecommunications but also handling Immigration as well as any Minister can

David Parker 6 (6) – about right

Nanaia Mahuta 5 (6) – makes Rock Barker seem dynamic as her predecessor in . A 4.
Customs / Youth Affairs

Clayton Cosgrove 8 (7) – Cosgrove has surprised many by his steady performance.

So if we take Audrey's ratings from top to bottom we have:

Phil Goff 9
Annette King 9
Clayton Cosgrove 8
David Cunliffe 8
Chris Carter 8
Helen Clark 7
Michael Cullen 6
Jim Anderton 6
Steve Maharey 6
Lianne Dalziel 6
David Parker 6
Nanaia Mahuta 5
Parekura Horomia 5
Ruth Dyson 5
Rick Barker 5
Trevor Mallard 4
Pete Hodgson 4
David Benson-Pope 4
Damien O'Connor 2
Mark Burton 2

Now it is interesting to look at some stats analysis. Audrey has an average grade of 5.58, while I have 5.53 (hmmn I have been fair). But a year ago the average was 6.05 – so a really clear trend.

Only three Cabinet Ministers improved their score, and each by one point only. Six Ministers declined, one by as much as six points.

Comments (31)

Login to comment or vote

Add a Comment