Relative Spends Add this story to Scoopit!.

Says it all. Emerson in the NZ Herald.

No TweetBacks yet. (Be the first to Tweet this post)
Tags:

50 Responses to “Relative Spends”

  1. infused (410) Says:

    Good one haha.

  2. PaulL (3090) Says:

    $1.5 billion?

  3. Murray (4521) Says:

    Hidden costs, extras, lunch and a taxi ride home. It all adds up Paul.

  4. dave strings (608) Says:

    Go you good thing

  5. Rocket Boy (163) Says:

    Nice to see the Mars probe gets mentioned on this site! Normally kiwiblog is a science free zone.

  6. Murray (4521) Says:

    Yet not a geek free one.

    Interesting.

  7. GPT1 (1025) Says:

    Brilliant

  8. getstaffed (4596) Says:

    Hilarious !

  9. NoCash (151) Says:

    What good is sending a probe to Mars for Labour? They already have the “green” creatures by their side. On the other hand, an old train set shows they care for the poor… right?!

  10. ghostwhowalks3 (387) Says:

    Nasa spent a lot more than that.
    They used a lander from a previous cancelled mission ( which went way over budget) but had a lot of hardware completed. It only needed the software to be updated and the cost of the launcher into space which would be most of the ‘$400 mill’
    Consider it a double Fisking

  11. PaulL (3090) Says:

    gww3. Its a freaking cartoon.

  12. aardvark (312) Says:

    Makes a mockery of the government’s claim to be right behind the push to create a knowledge-based economy in NZ doesn’t it?

    If just a portion of the money spent on that delapidated toy train set were invested in some of the creative and innovative ideas generated by smart Kiwis, the payback would be *enormous* and we wouldn’t remain so reliant on shipping bags of milkpowder over vast distances using an increasingly expensive resource (transport fuel).

    How long before the government wakes up and realises that unless NZ develops a robust KBE, the cost of transport is going to kill many of our existing export industries as well as the tourism industry?

    Why are they still playing “head in the sand”?

    I fear that by the time the penny drops, it’ll just be too late.

    Too many of our best and brightest will already be working in Oz (or elsewhere) and the few we have left will find it even more difficult to get venture capital — because so much of NZ’s GDP will be tied up in supporting the jobless in the wake of more factories closing and shifting operations to China, Thailand, Indonesia or wherever the labour is cheapest.

    Instead of worrying about who’s doing what at luxury resorts, how about paying attention to the critical issues that will determine whether we sink or swim as a nation in a world where transport costs make the mass export of physical products very, very expensive.

  13. NoCash (151) Says:

    What good is sending a Mars probe for Labour? They already have the “green” creatures by their side. On the other hand, an old train set surely shows that they care about the poor… right?!

  14. ghostwhowalks3 (387) Says:

    meanwhile also in the US…
    “By using railroads, we are achieving some economy on fuel,” said Dan England, chairman of C. R. England, a family-owned company based in Salt Lake City that runs 3,600 tractor-trailers and now regularly loads 350 of the trailers on railroad flat cars to get them from, say, Chicago to Los Angeles.
    NY Times

    Fancy that using the railroads to carry the trucks AND their load

  15. Falafulu Fisi (398) Says:

    Aardvark said…
    Too many of our best and brightest will already be working in Oz (or elsewhere) and the few we have left will find it even more difficult to get venture capital.

    Yes, correct. In the last few years, I know some of the best PhD candidates from University of Auckland School of Engineering , Physics Department, Computing who had been whisked overseas with good job offers in their respective fields. They couldn’t find work here, since their fields are so specialized that those industries are only available overseas. From what I’ve heard from their supervisors, most of these candidates went to present their papers in symposiums & conferences, where agents of big corporations are scouting for talents in these sort of events. One guy (Physics Department) got 2 different job offers from different competing vendors (Corning Corporation & Lucent Technologies) in the same morning, just after he came down from the podium after his presentation. Agents were waiting in the foyer to harass him for his signature. This guy specializes in optical tele-communication systems (fibre-optics & opto-electronics). He returned to the country, submit his thesis, and then took off again. Another guy from the Robotics Division at the School of Engineering, Mechanical Department , was offered a job by a Microsoft agent (which he accepted) even before the conference started. Apparently, the Microsoft agent told this guy, that they (Microsoft R&D US division) had read a previous paper of his , which was published in the IEEE Intelligent Information and Engineering Systems journal, which they were impressed with his new proposals & developments described in his paper. Microsoft R&D US were initially going to approach him at Auckland University, but they happened to notice his name on the Berkeley conference attendees list, so they thought to approach him there. Same thing happened, this guy came back, completed & submitted his thesis , then took off to Redmond (Microsoft). His supervisor at the Engineering school told me, that him and his former student (now Microsoft employee) had patented their new development (algorithm) via the UniServices (Auckland Uni commercial branch), he feared that Microsoft was really aiming to steal their (him and his student) idea and developed it into commercial use by Microsoft. I have only described 2 cases here, but there are more knowledgeable & bright NZers that we have lost to overseas big money.

    Such knowledge could be retained in New Zealand, if Venture Capitalists are willing to fund top notch guys as described in my example above, to start a business here.

  16. tom hunter (642) Says:

    Normally kiwiblog is a science free zone.

    Not at all. I’m sure you will find the denizens of this blog are very interested in:

    - GPS directed falling objects

    - Difficult to detect planes

    - Jihadist watchers

    - And No Dong nullifiers

    Not to mention, coming to a future possibly near you – directed energy devices!

    Who said science was boring!

  17. sonic (2674) Says:

    The proble only cost $438 million?

    Care to add how much the launcher that took it into spce cost? or how much the control room running the mission costs a day.

    Who is costing these things for Emmerson, a bunch of ex-blue chip accountants? the guys from Bear Sterns?

  18. Lance (271) Says:

    Falafulu Fisi
    It’s more than just that.
    The entire environment here knocks innovators, makes them jump through hoops and then reluctantly administers measly little piddling grants/investments.
    The message is, if you want good money in NZ, play rugby or something, work for the govt at the consultant level, or grow something valuable.. everyone else fuck off.

  19. getstaffed (4596) Says:

    sonic, you can hire you own forensic accountant to get the truth, or just laugh at the absurdity of the comparison. i would imagine that the probe ‘cost’ well north of $1b… but then so did the rusty old train set. whatever… that cartoon is pretty funny IMHO

  20. He-Man (270) Says:

    Even a rusty old train is of more use to me than some stupid lego toy that flew to Mars.

  21. RRM (1734) Says:

    Not that a space probe on Mars is going to be very effective at mundane tasks like (say) moving milk to the fonterra plant in Hawera or getting me to work every morning, but hey if that cartoon helps you all keep the hate going then yay for that!

  22. getstaffed (4596) Says:

    He-Man…. perhaps they’re both equally as useless?!? But think of how many more beneficiaries we could have created to mop up the $1b if Cullen hadn’t pursued his 6yr’s old fantasy. Oh the waste.

    Perhaps we could put Cullen in the next Mars probe. After 10 months of talking to himself even he might become sick of the sound of his own voice.

  23. tom hunter (642) Says:

    Ground control to Rocket Boy…….Come in Rocket Boy…… Do you acknowledge, Over?

    A fellow representative of the New Left wishes to discuss the relative merits of science and exploration to humanity.

    Please discuss with each other off-line, or at least off this blog.

    I think the intellectual left are taking over this blog

  24. Lance (271) Says:

    He-Man
    None of this innovation / exploration / research rubbish aye!

    I guess the hugely complex systems in your cellphone just happened by itself, the sky transmissions have nothing to do with space and pacemakers are just another toy.
    All that crap about quantum mechanics is useless when we know a few good rugby playing blokes with chainsaws were the real inventers of the computer.

  25. dad4justice (5745) Says:

    With names like she man, sonic and rocket boy lurking about the area, who said that Martians couldn’t be driving the engines in the alien Dr Caustic Sullen train set.

  26. stephen (3407) Says:

    And still, we’re consistently ranked as having one of the most business friendly regulatory environments in the world…

  27. dad4justice (5745) Says:

    Stephen, tell that to the many redundant freezing workers this year.

  28. Lance (271) Says:

    Stephen
    And where to do we rank for R+D……. yea…. we suck.

  29. Rex Widerstrom (2406) Says:

    stephen says:

    And still, we’re consistently ranked as having one of the most business friendly regulatory environments in the world…

    Yes, and a brothel is one of the most sex-friendly environments in the world. But just letting a handful of people screw anyone else if they have enough money may well be “friendly” but it’s far from desirable.

    I’d imagine, from your other comments, that you’d be amongst those who decry “big business”. Yet our “environment” does nothing to foster innovation, R&D and growth amongst small business (who employ most of our workers) and in many cases creates a hostile environment for them.

    But if you’re a multi-national wanting to flog off a rusty trainset to a dipstick Finance Minister, then yes I guess we’re very friendly.

  30. Murray (4521) Says:

    This is another important technological step needed to help develop new systems and help us progress to a point when we can send the greens, ghostwhotalkscrap, chronic and all the rest of them back to their home planet.

    The poor little dears have no place on ours and are like fish out out of water.

  31. labrator (615) Says:

    “By using railroads, we are achieving some economy on fuel,” said Dan England, chairman of C. R. England, a family-owned company based in Salt Lake City that runs 3,600 tractor-trailers and now regularly loads 350 of the trailers on railroad flat cars to get them from, say, Chicago to Los Angeles.
    NY Times

    Fancy that using the railroads to carry the trucks AND their load

    Los Angeles metropolitan area is home to nearly 12.9 million people
    Chicago Metro population 9.5 million people.
    Road distance from Chicago to Los Angeles = 3250 kilometres
    Valid comparison to New Zealand?

    Great cartoon!

  32. ghostwhowalks3 (387) Says:

    Distance from Wairarapa to taranaki, less than 200km . Milk trains run every day rather than tankers going all the way AND running back empty. Log trains run through out the NI.
    Coal trains are lined up btween the West Coast and Lyttleton, the single track is at capacity ( Coal mining is now twice the tonnage that it was in 1945)

    more details on polar lander from nasa
    http://www.nasawatch.com/archives/2008/05/the_actual_cost.html

  33. ISeeRed (137) Says:

    tom hunter: how could you neglect to mention global warming/climate change? The, er, “science” of that is frequently debated here. :-)

  34. aardvark (312) Says:

    > And still, we’re consistently ranked as having one of the most
    > business friendly regulatory environments in the world…

    Yeah, right up until you try to raise some finance for your hi-tech venture, then you find that we’ve got such a distorted economy that every man and his dog is investing in unproductive things like property.

    That sucks.

  35. Steve (845) Says:

    What NASA has done is research for a growing need of tecnology in a modern age.
    A rusty train set provides 5/8 of fuck all.

  36. Steve (845) Says:

    Once upon a time there was a young girl named Helen who bought a donkey
    from a farmer for $100. The farmer agreed to deliver the donkey the next
    day.

    When the farmer drove up the next day, he said, ‘Sorry miss, I have some
    bad news. The donkey is on my truck, but I’m afraid he’s dead.’

    Helen replied,’ Well then, just give me my money back.’ The farmer said,
    ‘I can’t do that. I went and spent it already.’

    Helen said, ‘OK then, just unload the donkey anyway.’ The farmer asked,
    ‘What are ya gonna do with him?’

    Helen said, ‘I’m going to raffle him off.’ The farmer exclaimed, ‘You
    can’t raffle off a dead donkey!’

    But Helen, with a big smile on her face, said ‘Sure I can. Watch me. I
    just won’t tell anybody that he’s dead.’

    A month later the farmer met up with Helen and asked, ‘What happened
    with that dead donkey?’

    Helen said, ‘I raffled him off. I sold 500 tickets at two dollars a
    piece
    and made a profit of $798.00.’

    Totally amazed, the farmer asked, ‘Didn’t anyone complain that you had
    stolen their money because you lied about the donkey being dead?’

    Helen replied, ‘The only guy who found out about the donkey being dead
    was the raffle winner, when he came to claim his prize. So I gave him
    his $2
    back plus $200 extra, which is double the going value of a donkey, so he
    thought I was a really great girl.’

    Helen grew up and eventually became the Prime Minister of New Zealand,
    and no matter how many times she lied or how much money she stole from
    Kiwi
    voters, as long as she gave them back some of the stolen money, most of
    them thought she was a great person.

  37. Paul Marsden (623) Says:

    ghostwhowalks3 (303) +0 Says:

    May 29th, 2008 at 10:59 am
    meanwhile also in the US…
    “By using railroads, we are achieving some economy on fuel,” said Dan England, chairman of C. R. England, a family-owned company based in Salt Lake City that runs 3,600 tractor-trailers and now regularly loads 350 of the trailers on railroad flat cars to get them from, say, Chicago to Los Angeles.
    NY Times

    Fancy that using the railroads to carry the trucks AND their load”

    Yes, fancy that. But um, err…..ever heard about the size of our tunnels??

  38. Patrick Starr (3499) Says:

    “Distance from Wairarapa to taranaki, less than 200km”

    NZ taxpayer real cost about $600 per klm

    228 million kilometers to Mars ,
    US cost about $1.90 per klm

  39. Murray (4521) Says:

    If I give you 20 bucks can we just put Cullen in orbit?

  40. Rex Widerstrom (2406) Says:

    20 bucks oughta do it Murray. I’ll go you halves, but I bags I get to drive the 4-wheeler.

  41. Murray (4521) Says:

    Sweet.

  42. Murray (4521) Says:

    SHOTGUN!

  43. Patrick Starr (3499) Says:

    Excellent Rex, notice its a woman pilot? (the guys aren’t silly)
    I’d like to see them demo it on Parekura Horimia first

  44. dad4justice (5745) Says:

    Patrick; No rocket is available to man that can propel Mr Horimia anywhere.Even space has a limit.

  45. Patrick Starr (3499) Says:

    D4J I think the slingshot would only have a skeleton left in its return, and China would be saturated with brown fatty rain

  46. dad4justice (5745) Says:

    Patrick – Mr Chinaman says, yuck, brown rain drops keep falling on my head and the red army would mobilize a 200 million strong army to smack some monks over.

  47. Patrick Starr (3499) Says:

    we could send Nome as a peace keeper – he’d confuse the fuck outta them

  48. dad4justice (5745) Says:

    A nome pill a day keeps the rogered idiot at bay.

  49. Mr Dennis (348) Says:

    Sure it is a funny cartoon. But frankly even a rusty old train set is a better use of money than a spaceship off on a futile search for life on a planet that time and again has been shown to have no life. What a waste. Give me trains any day.

  50. Duxton (331) Says:

    Steve @ 1758:

    You bastard! You made me piss myself!

    Classic!

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.