Nicholson quotes Jeanette
Fed Farmers President Don Nicholson says the Mackenzie Basin dairy farming application should be given a fair hearing under the RMA. He notes:
Putting the location aspect aside as something for the commissioners, is “loose housing” a terrible corruption of the New Zealand “brand”, as Dr Russel Norman MP, the Green Party co-leader makes it out to be? Not according to his colleague, Jeanette Fitzsimons MP. His former Green Party co-leader was so impressed when she saw a “herd home” in action, that Ms Fitzsimons entered the following words on her website about good farming stories: “I must admit I was prejudiced about herd homes before I saw this one – NZ is known for grazing its animals outside all year round – surely we don’t want to coop them up in barns away from the light and the sun and the fresh grass? However now I’m a complete convert. The high roof is translucent and lets in lots of light. The overhanging sides are open so there is air movement through but rain and cold winds are kept out. The cows are free to move around, and there is fresh hay or silage under the eaves around the outside edges of the barn for them to feed at will. If I had any doubts about the animal welfare side of things, it was dispelled when I saw them waiting in the race to get back in again out of the rain.”
Don also notes the proposal is for 18,000 cows over 16 separate farms – not in one gargantuan farm.
December 22nd, 2009 at 9:09 am
Don Nicholson is being very mischievous here. Jeanette made the clear distinction between herd homes and factory farms almost two weeks ago when the Feds first attempted to publicly misconstrue her support for herd homes:
December 22nd, 2009 at 9:22 am
“That’s why I just ask this – please give the applicants and the hearings commissioners all a fair go under the RMA.”
Nicholson is carrying out the same kind of public opinion campaigning that he is complaining about the Greens partaking in.
There is a well-established RMA hearing process, this has been in place for a long time now, and based on the submissions for and against that are presented to the hearing. Not on any general aura of BS out here in the wider world. So what Nicholson is really saying is “please don’t raise environmental objections to this.”
And if Toad is correct on the “Herd homes”/”factory farms” distinction, then Nicholson is a bullshit artist for that quote of Fitzsimons, and consequently DPF is carrying out dog-whistling services on behalf of the general anti-green movement.
December 22nd, 2009 at 9:49 am
Here’s another quote from Jeanette showing just how valuable her opinions actually are:
Oh the humanity.
December 22nd, 2009 at 10:20 am
Nicholson is being disingenuous, and you’re being incredibly lazy to not actually read what JF said, DPF…there’s a fundamental difference between Factory Farming and Cubicles (which is what the MacKenzie Cartel want) and herd farming, which is not able to be intensified to extent that Federated Farmers want…
December 22nd, 2009 at 10:55 am
Off the Feds go again. Interesting to see they’re going for the ‘reasonable’ approach this time.
I’ve been following this avidly and the issue of cubicle farming (or free-stalls or factory farming or whatever you want to call it) seems to have cross-over appeal. A majority of farmers are against it as are the urban liberals. So I can’t understand why Fed Farmers aren’t voicing the views of the majority of their members? Maybe this is just knee-jerk anti-Greens stuff from them? Maybe it’s because they see an opportunity to influence further amendments to the RMA?
They’re being disingenuous in two aspects. As XavierG notes, referring to the MacKenzie Basin proposals as ‘loose housing’ and using a quote about ‘herd homes’ is misleading. These farms aren’t about ‘keeping cows warm in winter, and cool in summer, and happy all year-round’. They are about keeping cows inside 24/7 for 8 months of the year to make money! So get real Fed Farmers, not all of us urbanites are stupid!
Also, The Don knows that these proposals are likely to go through under the RMA process. That is because the process is reductionist – each application is for a specific activity e.g. building a concrete pad, and each activity when viewed in isolation is unlikely to declined. However the farmers I have spoken to are concerned about two things – the length of time the cows will be indoors, and the fact that across the rest of the country we’ve invested in pastoral farming and that is the lowest cost form of farming for the country as a whole. Therefore this bears a look at the national level – David Carter is already looking at the Animal Welfare Stuff but no-one is looking at the big picture stuff i.e what impact will this have on pastoral farmers in the rest of the country! Nick Smith turned down the opportunity to call the proposals in. Maybe he needs to revisit that decision?
December 22nd, 2009 at 11:32 am
extremely lazy, dpf
December 22nd, 2009 at 12:13 pm
The article did not have a link to Jeanette’s word for me to follow through, or a date reference for it. If there is a link I will normally click through to check context. Commenters here have added context which is how blogs should work.
December 22nd, 2009 at 12:18 pm
By the way, Don N is on the National Animal Welfare Advisory Committee (NAWAC). Isn’t it a bit of worry that he doesn’t seem to know the difference between herd homes and cubicle farming?
March 20th, 2010 at 11:14 am
You can read all about Jeanette waxing lyrical about a herd home that is actually the name of a commercial product and not a system of farming:
http://www.greens.org.nz/goodfarmstories/mike-moss-and-madeline-rix-trott
If you want to see what a loose house farm is like, either Google “loose housing” or for a NZ example, check out Close-Up and TV3 from last December:
Close-Up:
http://tvnz.co.nz/close-up/look-inside-cubicle-dairy-farming-3310023/video
TV3:
http://www.3news.co.nz/Canterbury-farmer-defends-cubicle-farming-/tabid/309/articleID/134223/Default.aspx
I’ll let you make up your own minds up. Getting this information isn’t hard as Don’s reference is to the Greens ‘Good Farming Sttories’ that easily comes up if you put that into Google!
Hope this helps.
David Broome