The battle for Mana

October 9th, 2010 at 2:41 pm by David Farrar

The has done a profile of the candidates for Mana, and also an article about the race to win, which includes quite a few comments from me. I thought I would use the blog to expand on my printed remarks and out a bit of context around.

First if all, I have consistently said that the chances of a National win are low (but not of course non existent). I say this for two historical reasons:

  1. This particular seat, and its predecessors, have never been won by National. Now that is not a guarantee – Nikki Kaye broke a 95 year old lock Labour had on Auckland Central. But it is a seat which is consistently Labour.
  2. No Government has won a seat off the Opposition in a by-election for at least 80 years – if not for ever. I’ve checked back to the 1930s.

The article quotes me:

He said the Government’s popularity meant there was little impetus to vote. is a Labour safe seat. “Is there an incentive to give a government that already has a majority an extra seat?

This is why I think no Government has even won a seat off the Opposition – because they don’t actually need it. If people want to change the party that represents them locally, they tend to do it to send a message they are unhappy to the Government. It is harder to motivate people to vote to send out a message they are happy, and like the Government.

Now again this is not to say it isn’t possible, but that the incentives are harder for the Government than they are the Opposition.

The way for National to win, or at least reduce the majority, is not to only frame it as give National an extra seat because John Key is a good PM. The message needs to also be about who will be the best local MP for Mana.

“Hekia will pull `I will be a better MP’. People who have met Hekia and like her, could well respond. But you don’t get to meet the entire electorate.

The context of this is that when people meet Hekia, they are normally very impressed with her, and the more people she meets the more votes she will get. I think her career and background make her a considerably stronger candidate and MP than . That is not to say that won’t make a fine contribution if given the chance – but Hekia has a very formidable record of achievement, and a strength of character which I believe will see her become a Minister in the next term.

But the reality is it is very hard to meet every voter, or even half of them. And those who don’t meet Hekia, will then be faced with the question “Why do we vote to give the Government an extra seat”. That is the difficult part.

John Key’s smile only goes so far.

I really must restrain my sense of humour. This was short-hand for the PM is a popular Prime Minister, but being popular doesn’t necessarily mean voters will want to take a seat off the Opposition and give it to the Government as a thank you note.

So yes the chances of National achieving two historic firsts – winning Mana and a Government gaining a seat off the Opposition in a by-election is remote. But it is not nil, and the way to improve the odds is to have as many voters as possible meet Hekia and decide they want her as their local MP. She would be an outstanding electorate MP if given the chance.

Tags: , , ,

5 Responses to “The battle for Mana”

  1. jaba (2,142 comments) says:

    and she is a looker, that should help

    Vote: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 You need to be logged in to vote
  2. Graeme Edgeler (3,289 comments) says:

    The way for National to win, or at least reduce the majority, is not to only frame it as give National an extra seat because John Key is a good PM.

    The key for Hekia to win (or at least give herself the best chance) is to promise electing her won’t get National an extra seat. If she promises she won’t resign as an MP before the official results are announced, she could become MP without Conway Powell being the real winner by coming in as a replacement list MP.

    Vote: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 You need to be logged in to vote
  3. backster (2,172 comments) says:

    The name ‘Parata’ is well known and generally respected throughout the electorate, but most avid supporters are probably on the Maori roll in order to support the Maori Party.

    Vote: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 You need to be logged in to vote
  4. rouppe (971 comments) says:

    I think National supporters or those happy with the current government should give National another seat. Act are imploding, and do we really want to rely on the Maori Party for continued governance…? Every seat held helps in the regard…

    Vote: Thumb up 0 Thumb down 0 You need to be logged in to vote