The assets sale petition that failed (but can be re-submitted) had the highest number of non valid signatures of any CIR since the 1990s. I was interested in why this was the case so requested documents from the Office of the Clerk, Electoral Commission and Stats NZ under the OIA.
There were 393,778 signatures submitted. They needed 308,753 to make 10%. Stats NZ found the estimated number of valid signatures was 292,291 with a standard error of 2,579. That meant 26% of signatures were invalid. Stats NZ commented:
The probability of there being enough valid signatures in the full petition given the results of our sample is (negligible) less than one in a billion.
So why were so few signatures valid. The sample stats were:
- Signatures checked 28,127
- Unique electors 23,031
- Ineligible signatures 4,909 (not on electoral roll)
- Illegible signers 21
- Duplicate 166
Now that level of duplicates may not sound high, but that is the number of people found as duplicates just in the small sample tested. If you checked the entire sample, you would get far more. Stats NZ estimates that all up, 11% of those who signed the petition signed it at least twice. That is a very high proportion, and significantly higher than any other CIR where the figure has ranged from 5.1% to 8.8%.
The proportion of ineligibles was 17%, and the range in other CIRs has been between 12% and 18%. So the key difference with this CIR was not the proportion of ineligible signing it – but people fraudulently signing it more than once. 11% means one in nine signers signed it twice!
There is a case to be made that if you sign a petition twice, both signatures should be struck out – rather than just one of them. Just like with double voting.
Incidentally I didn’t sign the petition any times. To the best of my memory I’ve never signed any CIR petition except the one for a referendum on the flag.
Maybe when the Greens spent all that taxpayer money on hiring people to (get people to) sign the petition, they should have told them to tell people to sign it once only.
It will be interesting to see how many duplicates are there when they resubmit the petition in two months. If they target the same people and areas as the previous 12 months, then they may end up just getting more duplicates.
My thanks to the agency staff who compiled the info for my request.Asset Sales, CIR, referendum, Stats NZ