Adam Smith institute on standing up to bullies

Sam Bowman at the Adam Smith Institute makes the point:

Bullies succeed by making their victims fear them. The bully may be stronger than the victim, but he does not constantly use force against them. It is the fear of violence or humiliation that makes victims in the way the bully wants them to. …

Terrorism often operates in the same way. Very few terrorists could ever to win in a full-scale war against their victims, so instead they do shocking, frightening things. Yesterday's attack on the Charlie Hebdo offices was a very significant example of this, because the terrorists' apparent goals (‘avenging the Prophet' for blasphemous cartoons) seem ridiculously trivial compared to the lengths they were willing to go to to achieve them.

It is now clear that Western journalists who blaspheme against Islam may be murdered where they work. And most Western journalists don't really want to blaspheme against Islam anyway. It's rude, and it's rude against a group that does not have much power in the West. …

But if a bully tells you not to do something, sometimes you should do it even if you didn't really want to do it anyway. Defiance of the bully is very important to rob him of his power over you, and – just as important – to show to others that bullying is not effective.

And specifically:

Simply talking about how unafraid we are of terrorism is an empty, weak reaction.Cartoons that show the power of pencils are worthless. No Jihadi is disturbed by any of this. What disturbs them is to show in our actions that they do not have the bully's power over

Media who refuse to publish the cartoons are showing the bullies, that bullying works.

Comments (52)

Login to comment or vote

Add a Comment