General Debate 21 November 2026

Weird decision by TVNZ decsion not to have a political editor

TVNZ’s intention to abolish the role of political editor is weird and puzzling.

Sources with knowledge of the TVNZ news restructure proposal suggest the broadcaster is planning to have political reporters reporting through more general lines of management, similar to other specialist teams.

I think this would be a mistake. You want someone in the building who can assign stories, decide what is important to cover, and drive the team they work with.

For my sins I have known quite well all seven TVNZ political editors – Richard Harman, Linda Clark, Mark Sainsbury, Guyon Espiner, Corin Dann, Jess Mutch and Maiki Sherman. All extremely good at their jobs, and being TVNZ political editor does give you a certain status where you often get called on first in press conferences. With no political editor, TVNZ is likely to get fewer opportunities at press conferences. Also it means no point of contact for politicians wishing to discuss a story.

Linda Clark has written why she thinks it is a mistake:

The role is not just about being a reporter, or even about breaking stories. The political editor’s job is a complex mix of ringmaster, manager, translator, historian and commentator. Almost every story in a country of our size has a political angle and (whatever Auckland mayor Wayne Brown says) time and again, all roads lead back to parliament.  The political editor’s job is, at least in part, to understand how issues, people and parliament are connected because consumers of news want help to know what is important and what is worth their time. 

The political editor is probably most associated with live crosses filmed outside parliament. It ages me to say I was TVNZ’s first live cross reporter and on my first one I needed to steel myself with a shot of whiskey moments before we went on air. I came to appreciate that a good live cross is intoxicating enough. But it’s the smallest part of the job.

I recall at Linda’s farewell they ran a bloopers reel, including one of her doing a piece on Lambton Quay spoiled by a truck roaringly in wet weather. The curse words that came out of Linda’s mouth were hilarious!

As the leader of the gallery team, your own reporters need supporting, promoting and mentoring and in turn they support and teach you. All parliamentary gallery offices are cramped and pretty basic work environments and everyone is working under constant pressure for average pay. So, building a strong team culture is vital. News managers working in more spacious, well-designed news hubs have never understood the reality of political reporting; how grimy it can be, what it is like to be in such close proximity to the subjects of your reporting, the level of personal abuse, the constancy of political news. It’s a noisy, raucous, changeable business and you’re on your mettle all of the time.

All good points.

Mark Sainsbury also comments:

Former TVNZ political editor Mark Sainsbury has urged the broadcaster to rethink its plans to scrap the role, while also revealing how much political pressure comes with the job. 

Sainsbury, a New Zealand broadcasting and journalism hall-of-famer and TVNZ’s political editor from 2000-2006, said the parliamentary role was too important to lose in an age of media turmoil. 

“The role of political editor has always been a crucial one for all bureaus covering parliament but even more so for TVNZ,” Sainsbury told Media Insider.

The weird thing is the proposal won’t even save much money. Political Editor isn’t a management job where you just sit in the office and supervise people. They actually go out there and do the stories themselves. So you can make an existing reporter the political editor, without increasing headcount.

Will Willie be Labour’s Foreign Minister?

The Herald reports:

Labour MP Willie Jackson has labelled the United States ambassador to New Zealand a “clown” who should be kicked out of the country. 

The comments follow a verbal stoush US Ambassador Jared Novelly had with Wayne Brown after the Auckland mayor’s comments on China.

Wayne Brown says NZ should abandon democracy, leave Five Eyes and be more like China. The US Ambassador responds to that, and Willie demands the US Ambassador be kicked out of New Zealand.

Won’t Willie make a great foreign minister!

General Debate 20 November 2026

Domestic vs Overseas Specials

The Overhang has done a very in depth analysis of special votes, and has projected that the likely outcome is that Opportunity will be needed to govern. A key aspect of their analysis is that there are more overseas specials this year and fewer domestic specials, and the overseas ones are much more left leaning traditionally.

Their analysis is not just based on 2023 specials, but the last few elections. All models are based on assumptions, so it is impossible to know what will happen. I tend to think it is safer to just model on the last election, but at the end of the day, 2026 will have its own pattern. It is very safe to predict the left will make some gains, but the level of them will depend on whether it follows 2023 or or 2020 more etc.

Their model has NZ First and National losing a list seat (Nat can’t so create larger overhang) and Greens and Opportunity gaining one each. That would make it, before looking at electorate changes:

  • Nat/ACT/NZF 66
  • Lab/Gre/TPM 58
  • Opportunity 8

So a hung Parliament based on that. They also estimate there is a 60% chance Wairarapa flips on the specials and 51% Hamilton East does. This is based on higher party vote for the Greens, and lower for National flowing through onto candidate votes.

If either of those seats flip, then it goes from hung Parliament to Opportunity being kingmakers and being able to put Labour, Greens and Te Pati Maori in government, should they so choose.

Comrade Wayne

Stuff reported:

Auckland Mayor Wayne Brown says “democracy’s had its day” after recently visiting China and witnessing its rapid economic growth. …

Brown was asked by Stuff what the alternative to democracy could be.

“I don’t get involved in that sort of ideological shit,” Brown said.

“What’s working? China’s working. You know, in terms of economic growth and prosperity…

“With five eyes I have suggested we sell our seat to Japan. I can’t see anything in it for us.”

The comments by Brown are both amazing and not surprising. They are not surprising in that he seems to have contempt for voters and democratic scrutiny. But amazing in that he actually advocated ending democracy and abandoning the Western Alliance.

The US Ambassador to NZ had a very undiplomatic but amusing response.

Wayne always says Wellington should butt out of Auckland’s affairs. Perhaps he should take his own medicine and butt out of Wellington’s affairs!

General Debate 19 November 2026

Radio NZ has a spending, not an income problem

In the year to June 2023, RNZ’s income from taxpayers was $54.1m. In the year to June 2026 it was $67.3m – so 24% higher than three years previously.

Its problem is during those three years, it saw

  • Personnel expenses rose 38% from $34.3m to $47.2m
  • Operating expenses rose 58% from $20.3m to $32.1m

During that time where taxpayer funding rose 24%, pretty much every other media organisation in NZ has had funding plummet. Yet the Radio NZ board managed to increase their operating expenses by 58% in just three years.

Incredible

Murray River to Mountains Day 6 – Bright to Harrietville

The final day of cycling was also the best. Absolutely amazing views doing a round trip tp Harrietville.

Australian birds are so much more colourful.

A couple of kangaroos crossed the track ahead of us. Big fellas.

Just after we saw the kangaroos, we saw Emus. Definitely in Oz now Dorothy!

Cycling next to the road for a while.

The vast majority of the 56 kms was tracks like this.

And this.

After coffee in Harrietville, back to Bright for a late lunch at the Bright Brewery

Drove up to a couple of lookouts over Bright.

The local river is meant to have lots of platypus’ but they tend to only come out at night, so settled for this mural.

General Debate 18 November 2026

Whanganui DC – leave commercial ventures to commercial operators

The Herald reports:

Whanganui’s former flight school has dented the district council’s books but Mayor Andrew Tripe is not ruling out future commercial ventures. 

According to Whanganui District Council’s Annual Report, there was an overall deficit of $25.1 million for 2025-26 against a budget of $4.2m.

It said personnel costs were $2.33m higher than budgeted and “other expenses” were $19.67m higher.

They included a $14.06m write-off of investment in NZ International Commercial Pilot Academy (NZICPA), higher maintenance and response costs on roading assets ($1.72m) and unplanned expenditure on the demolition of 125 Grey St ($1.6m).

The Council lost over $1,000 a household in trying to run a commercial pilot academy. And rather than apologise for it, the Mayor says he might do it again!

General Debate 17 November 2026

Murray River to Mountains Day 5 – Myrtleford to Bright

Day 5 we started off through a local park in Myrtleford.

Cycling next to a river is so relaxing.

Cycled up to a lookout over Myrtleford.

Easy cycling on on good surface.

Rail trails which take you away from main roads are so great.

Lots of vineyards around.

Talking of vineyards, had a nice lunch at one six kms from Bright. A platter and some wine tasting with a great view. Very civilised.

Heading into Bright, a cool Butterfly bridge.

The final trail into town, where we will be for the next two nights.

Without the Māori seats, National would probably not have an overhang

The Māori seats didn’t only produce an overhang for the left, but their existence helped National have a seven seat overhang on the right.

This is because if Māori on the Māori roll were all enrolled in general seats, National would win far fewer. Based on the provisional results, this is what would happen in marginal National-held seats if there were no Māori seats.

  • East Cape from +16% to -18%
  • Hamilton East from +1% to -11%
  • Hamilton West from +6% to -10%
  • Kapiti from +5% to +1%
  • Napier from +19% to +5%
  • Nelson from +3% to 0%
  • Northland from +21% to -5%
  • Rangitikei from +15% to +5%
  • Rotorua from +17% to -9%
  • Takanini from +6% to -1%
  • Wairarapa from +0% to -7%
  • Whanganui from +19% to +5%
  • Whangarei from +3% to -12%

So National would probably lose nine seats, and maybe a further four.

So abolishing the Māori seats would get rid of both overhang on the left and the right. I am not advocating this, just pointing out that this would be the outcome.

General Debate 16 November 2026

Murray River to Mountains Day 4 – Beechworth to Myrtleford

Highlight of the day was spotting this koala bear in a tree just next to the cycle trail. I don’t think I’ve seen a koala in the wold before – has always been in zoos or reserves.

A collection of galahs and little corellas, both types of cockatoos. They were mainly flying overhead and hard to take a photo of, but then we saw this lot in a paddock.

So far this was my favourite day. Lots of variety on the trail. A long down hill at the beginning, and then many kms across the country.

Overtook these cyclists.

A cool bus shelter at Everton, a very small settlement that consists of a store and a bus shelter!

Very peaceful cycling away from traffic, and even other cyclists. Very few people around during the week.

The Phoenix Tree greets you as you enter Myrtleford.

An outdoor snakes and ladders board.

Bird mosaics down by the river.

Almost at the motel.

My mobile office in the afternoon.

Around 50 kms today. A bit of rain again in the morning but sunny by mid afternoon.

How did the Herald Poll of Polls go?

I blogged some time ago that the Herald Poll of Polls was producing nonsense results as it said Opportunity was ahead of ACT, despite every single poll showing the reverse. They justified it on the basis of assumptions about momentum.

The results shows their model was not high quality.

ResultHerald Poll of PollsVariance
National29.2%27.7%1.5%
Labour29.4%26.8%2.6%
Greens13.3%13.6%0.3%
ACT10.9%9.5%1.4%
NZF9.8%11.2%1.4%
Opp6.0%9.0%3.0%
TPM0.6%1.5%0.9%

As you can see they had Opportunity 50% higher than what they actually got. They also had ACT and NZ First both significantly lower, and TPM significantly higher.

I’m a huge fan of poll of polls models in theory. But one that actually contradicts the actual polls is not a good model. And it misled potentially hundreds of thousands of New Zealanders by insisting Opportunity was 50% higher in support than they actually were. This could well have had a non-trivial impact on how people voted.

Perhaps Opportunity should declare the cost of the Herald Poll of Polls as an election expense on their return?

General Debate 15 November 2026

Murray River to Mountains Day 3 – Beechworth to Milawa

Day 3 starts with an easy track out of town.

This wallaby crossed the track ahead of us. Very cool to see a wallaby.

After a long downhill stretch, it levelled out.

Lots of birds around.

Had a coffee break in Wangaratta (reminded me on Dannevirke) and then carried on to Milawa.

The Milawa mustard store.

Had lunch at this cafe in Milawa, which is next door to the cheese factory (highly recommended).

A transfer back to Beechworth where we had a spicy meatball pizza at the local pub.

Around 65 kms today. First part downhill. It rained for the last couple of hours, so sped up to get Milawa quicker.

Not quite as nice scenery as Day 2, which was far more through the bush. Today went past a lot of NZ looking farmland, and was next to main roads for a while. Still very enjoyable though.

Why the tobacco black market must be stopped

The Post reports:

Meanwhile, CCTV footage supplied by a local business appears to show a young boy on a bicycle selling illicit cigarettes from a bumbag.

A man who interacted with the boy estimated he was just nine or 10 years old.

He said it had become increasingly common to see young people selling tobacco and drugs in Papakura. On a previous occasion, he had seen another school-aged child selling bulk cartons of Double Happiness.

The tobacco black market has exploded in recent years due to poor policy decisions by Government. And this is the result.

“In a cost of living crisis, it makes no sense to hit heavy smokers with a tax increase. The concern is that smokers won’t pay it. They’ll instead turn to the gangs supplying illegal, unreported and unregulated smokes,” said Kaushal.

The evidence is crystal clear that this has happened.

Hoek strongly disputes that reducing excise is the solution.

I don’t support reducing the excise tax, but I do support freezing it. Further increases will just fuel the black market.

Instead, she argues the nicotine content of cigarettes should be substantially reduced, making smoking less “satisfying” and encouraging smokers to quit.

Of all the many many dumb things to come out of Otago University, this is arguably the dumbest. People smoke because of the addiction to nicotine (the tar kills them, not the nicotine). Reducing the nicotine content in legal cigarettes will be the stupidest thing possible as it will drive even more people to the black market.

General Debate 14 November 2026

Murray River to Mountains Day 2 – Beechworth to Yackandandah

A nice sealed path heading out of Beechworth.

More traditional rail trail path.

A lot of sculptures about.

Around 25 kms along.

Osbornes Flat, around 36 km done.

I just love being totally aware from normal roads and traffic.

Heading down hill.

A nice cider at the Yack Hotel, after a pretty easy 45 kms.

RIP Dai Henwood

The Herald reports:

Beloved Kiwi comedian, author and advocate Dai Henwood has died after his six-year cancer battle.

He was 48.

Henwood, known for his regular appearances on Kiwi shows like 7-Days and Taskmaster, was diagnosed with stage 4 bowel cancer in 2020 and went public with the news in 2023.

There are two types of comedians. Those who are funny, and those who are not. Henwood was in the former camp. He was extremely talented, and from all accounts a great person.

He comes from an arts background, with his parents being a huge part of the success of Circa Theatre in Wellington. It is so sad he died so young.

Thought go out to his family, friends and colleagues.

Murray River to Mountains Day 1 – Beechworth

Am in Victoria for a week cycling some rail trails as my post-election holiday. Day 1 saw us drive to Beechworth, where we will be based for three nights. Beechworth is a historic town, famous for gold mining and Ned Kelly.

This is the Old Beechworth Gaol, where Ned Kelly and many others were imprisoned. Amazingly it was still operating up until shortly after 2000.

A standard room.

There were many hangings at the prison, and you can see where they took place. The tour guide was full of history about some of the more famous inmates, including “stars” of the Underbelly TV series.

The old Beechworth Post Office.

One of several historic hotels.

A monument to the gold rush and the famous Golden Horseshoes incident from 1855 when a newly elected Legislative Council member Daniel Cameron rode through the main streets on a horse shod with real golden horseshoes, to celebrate.

This has now become an annual festival and parade, with a new pair of golden horseshoes ridden every year.

Talking of elections, I predict this bloke will win a seat as I have seen scores of his posters around the place, and zero for anyone else!

Many of the houses here have wonderful gardens – a mini Christchurch.

An Australian White Ibis, Lots of magpies around, but thankfully also many other birds.

The old gunpowder battery storage where gunpowder for mining was safely stored. Designed to funnel a blast upwards in case of an accident.

A view from a nearby lookout.

One of the original cottages.