Biden’s health
Biden’s health has been very big news this week, around two issues – his dementia and his cancer diagnosis.
The dementia issue was front and centre because of two books released about the cover up over his declining cognitive ability. Adding to that was the release of the audio tapes of his interview with the special prosecutor:
Amid long, uncomfortable pauses, Joe Biden struggled to recall when his son died, when he left office as vice president, what year Donald Trump was elected or why he had classified documents he shouldn’t have had, according to audio Axios obtained of his October 2023 interviews with special counsel Robert Hur. …
The audio also appears to validate Hur’s assertion that jurors in a trial likely would have viewed Biden as “a sympathetic, well-meaning, elderly man with a poor memory.”
Democrats and Biden’s White House blasted Hur for his observations about Biden. They repeatedly insisted he was “sharp” and that Hur was politically motivated. But the audio from the five-plus hours of interviews indicates he and co-counsel Marc Krickbaum were respectful and friendly.
Those who attacked Hur for his observations should be ashamed. It is now apparent that not only did he not exaggerate, but if anything he was relatively benign. Hur told the truth, and was assailed for it by operatives who didn’t want the public to know.
Then in the last few days we have the news that Biden has Stage 4 metastasized prostate cancer. This is terrible news for him and his family. The fact he lost his eldest son to cancer makes it more horrible.
However sympathy for Biden doesn’t negate the public interest in whether he truly had no idea he had prostate cancer until after he left office. Some cancers are very fast moving, but prostate cancer is not. The Herald reports:
In interviews with the news media, some physicians raised the idea that Biden could have known about his condition while in office, saying it was surprising that the President – who has access to some of the best health care in the country – would not have learned about his cancer earlier.
“He did not develop it in the last 100 to 200 days,” Dr Ezekiel J. Emanuel, an oncologist who served as an adviser on the coronavirus pandemic for the Biden administration, said on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe”. “He had it while he was president. He probably had it at the start of his presidency in 2021.
“I don’t think there’s any disagreement about that,” added Emanuel, who noted that both Presidents Barack Obama and George W. Bush had reported being tested for prostate cancer.
There seem to be four possibilities here. They are:
- Biden had regular testing for prostate cancer and it never showed up and he had no idea at all that he had prostate cancer until a few days ago. This is medically very improbable.
- Biden was never tested for prostate cancer in the last few years, and he had no idea at all that he had prostate cancer until a few days ago. This would call into question the competence of White House doctors who never thought to test for prostate cancer. To be fair you don’t regularly test men over 70 because even if they have traces, they are more likely to die of old age than the prostate cancer as it is usually so slow spreading. However the fact Biden’s cancer has metastasized shows this was a terrible decision, if correct.
- Biden was tested for prostate cancer some years ago and tested positive. They did not want to reveal he had prostate cancer as it would add to concerns about his infirmity, so they deliberately decided not to have White House doctors regularly test for it. They figured it would probably not spread as quickly it did. If this is correct they sacrificed his life for his presidency.
- Biden and/or his family/staff were aware he had prostate cancer and were regularly testing and monitoring it, but decided not to release this information publicly
It feels a bit yucky discussing this, as Biden is highly likely to die from the prostate cancer (however it may be years, not months). But it is a legitimate part of the discussion about where the White House staff were covering up for his infirmities – both physical, and mental.
Reasonable people could disagree about whether Biden was able to do the job of President during his first (and only) term of 2021 – 2025. But it is crystal clear that Biden would have been absolutely incapable of being President for a full second term. The fact that they tried to do so, when they must have known he could clearly not remain mentally pr physically strong enough until 2029 reflects extremely badly on the Democratic Party.
One solution could be to pass a law requiring the President to undertake a comprehensive physical and mental examination, done by a panel of doctors (not just the White House physician). Maybe extend this to major presidential candidates also.