Hipkins apologises for smearing English

Stuff reports:

Public Service Chris Hipkins has apologised in the House to former finance minister Sir Bill English for dragging his family into an exchange over government contracts awarded to the husband of Foreign Affairs Minister Nanaia Mahuta.

Hipkins on Wednesday afternoon interjected during with an apparent reference to English's brothers being provided government appointments. This came after ACT David Seymour questioned the Government on the contracts awarded to Mahuta's family.

“Let's talk about Bill English's family, shall we?” Hipkins said, suggesting English's family members were treated differently because they were “white”.

Labour love to play the race card to defend themselves. But this has backfired on them, because the facts are so bad.

What Hipkins was referring to was the appointment of Mervyn English to a fixed term role in the Ministry of Health in 2011, to set up a Health Sector Forum.

Mervyn was a career public servant. He had spent six years as a general manager at the before the Health role. After that role, he held senior roles in the State Services Commission and DOC.

His brother, Bill, was not a Minister of Health.

Labour did actually question the appointment at the time, with Grant Robertson asking questions in Parliament.

The Minister immediately asked the SSC to investigate, and they found everything was done properly.

Now compare this to the Mahuta contracts:

  • None of the Ormsbys seem to have had a background in the public sector and only gained contracts once Mahuta was a Minister
  • They were given consulting contracts, not an employment contract
  • Three of the four contracts were in that Mahuta was a Minister
  • Internal reviews to date have found proper processes were not followed
  • The Government has spent months resisting an inquiry

So Labour playing the race card and trying to smear the English family over the Mahuta saga is very disappointing.

Comments (72)

Login to comment or vote

Add a Comment