Weird decision by TVNZ decsion not to have a political editor

TVNZ’s intention to abolish the role of political editor is weird and puzzling.

Sources with knowledge of the TVNZ news restructure proposal suggest the broadcaster is planning to have political reporters reporting through more general lines of management, similar to other specialist teams.

I think this would be a mistake. You want someone in the building who can assign stories, decide what is important to cover, and drive the team they work with.

For my sins I have known quite well all seven TVNZ political editors – Richard Harman, Linda Clark, Mark Sainsbury, Guyon Espiner, Corin Dann, Jess Mutch and Maiki Sherman. All extremely good at their jobs, and being TVNZ political editor does give you a certain status where you often get called on first in press conferences. With no political editor, TVNZ is likely to get fewer opportunities at press conferences. Also it means no point of contact for politicians wishing to discuss a story.

Linda Clark has written why she thinks it is a mistake:

The role is not just about being a reporter, or even about breaking stories. The political editor’s job is a complex mix of ringmaster, manager, translator, historian and commentator. Almost every story in a country of our size has a political angle and (whatever Auckland mayor Wayne Brown says) time and again, all roads lead back to parliament.  The political editor’s job is, at least in part, to understand how issues, people and parliament are connected because consumers of news want help to know what is important and what is worth their time. 

The political editor is probably most associated with live crosses filmed outside parliament. It ages me to say I was TVNZ’s first live cross reporter and on my first one I needed to steel myself with a shot of whiskey moments before we went on air. I came to appreciate that a good live cross is intoxicating enough. But it’s the smallest part of the job.

I recall at Linda’s farewell they ran a bloopers reel, including one of her doing a piece on Lambton Quay spoiled by a truck roaringly in wet weather. The curse words that came out of Linda’s mouth were hilarious!

As the leader of the gallery team, your own reporters need supporting, promoting and mentoring and in turn they support and teach you. All parliamentary gallery offices are cramped and pretty basic work environments and everyone is working under constant pressure for average pay. So, building a strong team culture is vital. News managers working in more spacious, well-designed news hubs have never understood the reality of political reporting; how grimy it can be, what it is like to be in such close proximity to the subjects of your reporting, the level of personal abuse, the constancy of political news. It’s a noisy, raucous, changeable business and you’re on your mettle all of the time.

All good points.

Mark Sainsbury also comments:

Former TVNZ political editor Mark Sainsbury has urged the broadcaster to rethink its plans to scrap the role, while also revealing how much political pressure comes with the job. 

Sainsbury, a New Zealand broadcasting and journalism hall-of-famer and TVNZ’s political editor from 2000-2006, said the parliamentary role was too important to lose in an age of media turmoil. 

“The role of political editor has always been a crucial one for all bureaus covering parliament but even more so for TVNZ,” Sainsbury told Media Insider.

The weird thing is the proposal won’t even save much money. Political Editor isn’t a management job where you just sit in the office and supervise people. They actually go out there and do the stories themselves. So you can make an existing reporter the political editor, without increasing headcount.