Candidate refuses to file expenses claim

NZPA reports:

A candidate who stood for the Human Rights Party in last year’s general election is refusing to submit his campaign expenses and says he is waiting to be arrested.

Anthony Ravlich stood in Auckland Central and gained 67 votes, 0.2 percent of those cast in the electorate.

Today he released an email he had sent to the Chief Electoral Office, telling it he was not going to complete the election expenses form “as a matter of principle” because his party’s policies did not receive any publicity in mainstream media.

Compliance with the law is not optional, based on whether or not you like the media coverage you got.

At least he has it all now. He won’t go to jail – he will be fined though.

Absolute hypocrisy from Labour over NZ Super Fund

I’ve been looking back through what Labour said when they established the NZ Super Fund in 2000, and it is gold. Their protests about the Government moving to reduce the level of contributions into the fund are hypocrisy of the highest order.  Let me quote from Dr Cullen’s Q&A when he launched it:

How will the government pre-fund future New Zealand Superannuation costs if there are insufficient surpluses?

The government will make contributions to the Fund from available surpluses. Where these are insufficient for making the required contribution a reduced contribution would be made.

John Key and Bill English are doing exactly what Michael Cullen said would happen. Not only do we have an insufficient surplus – we have a decade of deficits.

This also shows up those morons who argue the Fund is not funded out of surpluses, but is just like any other competing area of expenditure. In Labour’s own words:

The government will make contributions to the Fund from available surpluses.

And further:

What level of surpluses will the government need to run to pre-fund future NZS costs?

The actual contribution will be determined by the size of available surpluses. Future governments may, however, decide to make contributions at the required rate even when surpluses are less than this rate.

Once again a clear statement that the contributions are determined by the size of the surplus. And while they have indicated that yeah if the surplus drops a wee bit, you might have a slightly higher contribution than the surplus – there is absolutely no suggestion that if you are running a $6 billion deficit you’ll put in a $2 billion contribution.

Labour’s hypocrisy on this could almost enter the Guinness Book of Records.

But wait there is more:

What are the benefits of setting up a fund versus paying off debt?

We are balancing two fiscal priorities in paying down debt and pre-funding superannuation. It is important to keep government debt low and we have set out long-term objectives for debt that will ensure that it remains low. However, we believe we can achieve these debt objectives and smooth the costs of superannuation at the same time.

So the fund was linked to keeping debt low. Debt is now projected to increase by around $80 billion or so. It is set to treble in less than a decade.

Debate is now over.

TelstraClear kill off s92A Code

TelstraClear have killed off the TCF Code of Practice designed to try and get workable process around the deeply flawed s92A. They have said they will veto the code at the TCF Board. TCF rules allow any board member to veto.

I was initially pissed off at TelstraClear, because all the hundreds of hours of work put into the code are now wasted. But upon reflection, I think they have have done the right thing by stepping back and saying this law is just so bad, we can;t make it workable through a code. Their submission explains:

TelstraClear considers that there is a fundamental problem with the TCF being a party to any code of this nature, which is that the code would be based on flawed legislation. …

In TetstraClear’s view, any industry code would simply be an attempt to tidy up poorly drafted legislation. TelstraClear does not consider this to be the responsibility of the TCF. Indeed the best outcome would be if s92A was repealed. Failing that, it should be amended to address the above concerns:

So there will be no TCF code. The other ISPs can continue work on the code as an unofficial grouping, but it would be madness to have s92A come into force with no code in place.

The submission on the code are very interesting, and I hope MPs look at some of them. Take this submission from the leading IT jurist in NZ – Judge David Harvey. Judge Harvey is also the former Chair of the Copyright Tribunal so about as authoritiative as you can get on this area:

This section is poorly drafted and makes a number of unsupported assumptions, but in essence it suggests that an Internet service provider must develop a policy to cancel an existing contract as a result of copyright infringement.

The reality of the matter is that the cancellation or termination of the contract arises at the behest, not of the Internet service provider, but of copyright owners. Without significant justification in normal circumstances this could amount to an interference with economic relations and raises significant issues about the sanctity of contract.

Judge Harvey further concludes:

section 92A is unnecessary and gives rise to a situation where a person may be deprived of rights under a contract without proper legal process.

Does the Government really want to persist with s92A bearing in mond those comments, and that there will now be no TCF code?

If it had been Parliament’s intention to provide for a process whereby contract termination should take place, Parliament should have provided such process by legislation after proper consultation with all interested parties.

This is basically TCL’s point. You can’t ask private players to determine these rights when the law is so silent on details.

The Australian ISP Association has commented:

As mentioned above, we are aware that a concerted worldwide effort has been made by rights holders in the music and film industries over the past two years to lobby for the introduction of a ‘notice and disconnect’ scheme along the lines of that proposed in the Code. In spite of that, no ‘notice and disconnect’ scheme has been implemented anywhere in the world.

Yay, we could be first. In fact that is why the US groups are pushing so hard – they want us to be an international template.

In all jurisdictions (except France) where the introduction of ‘notice and disconnect’ schemes have been considered and consulted on by Governments, there is now a general move away from any scheme which requires ISPs to terminate internet accounts, on the basis of an allegation of infringement from rights holders.

The whole world except Judith Tizard has realised what a bad idea this is.

Auckland University says:

The main problem is in Section 92A of the Copyright Act which we believe should be removed from the Act or, if it is to remain in some form, then substantially redrafted with input from stakeholders as would have happened during a select committee process.

The Auckland District Law Society:

Section 92A represents a mechanism whereby the copyright holder, an unrelated third party, can interfere with the contractual rights between an ISP and a customer, where the customer is identified as a repeat copyright infringer. Under common law, that could, without significant justification, amount to the tort of interference with contractual relations.

This law is just as flawed as the Electoral Finance Act. When the former Chair of the Copyright Tribunal, the Auckland District Law Society and the country’s largest university says the law needs to repealed or amended, it is time to do so.

National did the right thing by delaying the introduction until a code could be completed. But we now know that unless the law is amended, a code is not going to happen, so time to introduce a bill amending or repealing the clause.

UPDATE: Also worth reading the submission from the Society of Authors. They are as pro-copyright as anyone, yet they say:

The NZ Society of Authors is concerned about the introduction of the proposed s92A of the Copyright Act 1994. Whilst we strongly support the need for measures to control repeat copyright infringement we feel that this clause is not ideal – it has been hastily written and we recommend the need for further discussion.

We feel that should Section 92A be implemented, it is imperative that the Code of Practice be effective and respectful of the rights to freedom of expression.

Radio NZ has said no disconnection should occur without a court order unless there is an independent body established by the Government to rule on any disputes.

And Internet giant Google has also made a submission:

Section 92A puts users’ procedural and fundamental rights at risk, by threatening to terminate users’ Internet access based on mere allegations and reverse the burden of proof onto a user to establish there was no infringement. …

Copyright law is often complex and context sensitive, and only a court is qualified to adjudicate allegations of copyright infringement. Indeed, in Google’s experience, there are serious issues regarding the improper use and inaccuracy of copyright notices by rights holders. In this context, the responsibility should not fall to ISPs to determine cases of infringement.

It is very relevant that Google has testified that many rightholders notices are inaccurate and indeed improper.

Waikato Times on ACC

Afters outraged e-mails from Hamiltonians that I did not include the Waikato Times as a major newspaper, I have relented and now include it in my daily read of editorials for anything interesting.

And if last week’s editorial is an example, that may be a good thing:

The ACC blowout is a terrible look for the former Labour Government. It will lead to either greatly increased cost for New Zealanders, a trimming of the service or, more likely, a bit of both.

I don’t think Labour get it. They were actually trying to attack the Government in teh House on ACC. They do not realise their moral authority on ACC is now zero. nada. zilch. They are wasting their questions on areas where National wants them to talk about so National can repeat how the average household under Labour would have been paying $47 a week more in ACC levies. I can already see the TV ads next campaign reminding people of that.

What is worse is that Labour knew before the election more funding would be needed but said nothing.

Technically they have been cleared by a ministerial report that came out this week. The report found Treasury wrongly thought it did not have to include the forecast shortfall in a pre-election financial update because it was not under consideration by ministers. Treasury Secretary John Whitehead said his department took responsibility.

But that shouldn’t let Labour’s ACC Minister Maryan Street and Finance Minister Michael Cullen off the hook.

Indeed. They deliberately avoided making a decision, so that it would not appear.

State-funded ACC has been an effective and successful way of ensuring Kiwis are compensated for loss of earnings through injury. National must now ensure that continues while fixing a mess primarily of Labour’s making.

Labour almost killed ACC off by bloating it. Annual costs doubled from under $1.5 billion to over $3 billion. National’s job is to save ACC so it is affordable.

Swann gets nine and a half years

I was very pleased to see Michael Swann get nine and a half years jail for his unprecedented fraud of $17m from taxpayers through the Otago District Health Board.

Despite what he says, he has shown no remorse. His pitiful attempts at a defence, that his company did deliver the services contracted showed that. At least Kerry Harford admitted guilt and remorse early on and his sentence of four years three months is about right also.

Look at Harford arguing to the end that what he did nas not so bad:

Mr Haig took issue with the victim impact statement which said the defrauded money could have been used for surgery or more nurses.

“My instructions are that is completely wrong. The money that was taken was health administration money.”

While there was no denying much of the money had been spent on property – “not spectacularly luxurious property I might add” – boats and cars, there was “no real champagne lifestyle”.

I hope the Parole Board don’t let him out halfway through. I don’t detect one hint of remorse.

The ODT editorial says:

First, the crimes of Swann, especially, were those of cunning calculation, carried out from a position of absolute trust and significant authority, involving a sum of money unimaginable to most people. …

Second, Swann and Harford robbed a public institution, not some private enterprise, and thus stole from all taxpayers, rich and poor.

Third, the institution was a hospital board, that is to say, an entity dedicated to the sick and injured, where no “profit” is expected and where every cent of income is desperately important – literally life-saving.

In the annals of so-called “white collar” crime in this country there has been no more despicable example.

One aspect of the editorial scares me:

As to the difficulty of establishing its criminality, it is notable that when first presented with suspicion of what seemed initially to be highly complex circumstantial evidence, the Dunedin police declined to investigate.

The Serious Fraud Office, with its special skills and powers, was finally the agency to put Swann and Harford behind bars.

The Police would not investigate????

And Labour tried to abolish the SFO and transfer its functions back to the Police! Thank God for a change of Government.

Stupidity

I know the “subsidy” by the Government (taxpayers) is not at much as some would want, but that doesn’t excuse this stupidity by Labour Party President EPMU National Secretary Andrew Little:

The Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union said the pay out was “underwhelming”.

“Unless employers are willing to meet this subsidy with a substantial top-up of their own it’s unlikely to be accepted by workers,” national secretary Andrew Little said.

“As far as the EPMU is concerned, this will be a bottom line.”

This staggers me. Andrew is saying that employers should pay employees more money to work less hours as a way to stop businesses going broke and/or having to lay staff off.

If your staff hours reduce by 10% yet your staff costs only decrease 5%, the company is arguably in a worse position – they have lower productivity as they are effectively now paying a higher hourly rate.

Luckily the CTU is being more rational:

However, the Council of Trade Unions welcomed the announcement, saying the union’s members wanted to protect employment and the package provided “a real basis for business and unions to work to save jobs”.

“We will always advocate that the package could have included a higher rate of pay. But the government contribution was essential to make this idea acceptable to workers,” CTU president Helen Kelly said.

The CTU does also say they would like employers to contribute:

“We expect responsible employers, who will also benefit from this scheme in terms of retained staff, and reduced costs associated with redundancy, to also make a contribution to the lost wages, since clearly there are benefits for businesses that do this.”

But the difference in tone and substance is significant. The EPMU is saying they will have nothing to do with the scheme unless employers pay staff to not turn up to work. They say it is a bottom line.

The CTU far more rationally says “Hey this is a good scheme, we would like employers to contribute, and think it benefits them to do so”.

Anyway the EPMU has made itself clear. Any site where they represent workers should be prepared for big job losses, as they won’t co-operate with helping save jobs.

This is one of those situations where people might ask what hat is Andrew wearing when he condemns the scheme, as oppossed to the CTU that welcomed it?

Do as I say, not as I do

Labour and Greens are going on about how awful it is the Government has killed off the carbon neutral public service programme run by the Ministry of the Environment:

Nick Smith points out:

The Carbon Neutral Public Service was just a feel good slogan cooked up by the previous Government. Its only achievement was to cost this country millions of dollars. Ironically, since the programme was launched by the previous Government, emissions from the Ministry for the Environment increased from 656 tonnes in 2005/06 to 766 tonnes in 2007/08.

That is hilarious.

Humans tend to cause carbon emissions. So the quickest way to have a carbon neutral public service to to sack everyone 🙂

Diplomatic Appointments

Trans-Tasman has just put out a special newsletter with some exclusive news:

The Trans-Tasman Political Letter reports Jim McLay will be NZ’s permanent representative to the UN in New York. McLay will take up the post when the present ambassador Rosemary Banks finishes her term in May.

This is a very interesting move. Normally political appointments are made as Ambassadors to countries.I would not call them a cruisy job because they do have work to do, but it is a pleasant job shall we say.

The permanent rep to the UN is a very full on busy role. None of the perks of being an Ambassador – you’re stuck in UN meetings all day.

This implies that the Government wants a rep who can display political leadership within the UN – suggesting that maybe the Government intends to get involved with efforts to reform the UN.

Hopefully this may mean the Government will withdraw NZ’s bid to be elected to the discredited Human Rights Council.

Foreign Minister McCully has indicated he wants the current professional diplomats in Washington (Roy Ferguson) and in London (Derek Leask) to serve out their terms.

So no political appointments there for now.

Interviews to find a successor for retiring MFAT CEO Simon Murdoch will begin in Wellington next week.

The name most people put forward is the DPMC CEO Maarten Weavers.

Meanwhile, Trans-Tasman says former PM Helen Clark is on the three-person short-list for the post of director of the UNDP. The Govt has been seeking international support for her appointment and is understood to have gained the support of Korea, which could be influential on the thinking of the current UN Secretary-General. Clark had a one-on-one meeting with the Korean president Lee Myung-Bak in Auckland.

The Secretary-General is from Korea, so that is significant.

Conversation on Copyright

The Dom Post reports:

The Labour Party will invite organisations with an interest in copyright law to informal talks this month.

Communications spokeswoman Clare Curran says the goal will be to try to thrash out agreement on the wider issues of copyright, following controversy over section 92a of the Copyright Act, which would oblige internet service providers “in appropriate circumstances” to cut off “repeat copyright infringers”.

The talks would help Labour form a view about what it would do when it returned to power.

“There should be a group talking about the big issues. Someone has got to take the initiative.”

I’m not just saying this because it is an issue I am involved in (and have been invited to the meeting), but it is a good example of what Oppositions should be doing.

Opposition can be pretty soul destroying. As you see National reverse previous policies you’ve implemented, it is demoralising. Trust me – have been there. And it turns the public off to have almost everything the Government does (which they generally campaigned on) attacked by the Opposition – it sends a message of “We still think we are right”.

One of the best things one can do in Opposition is to connect and listen to people. It is an opportunity to frame up policies and positions without being captive to past policies. Every Opposition Spokesperson should be getting around to meeting as many groups and individuals in their portfolios as possible. And not just inviting them in to your office – but going on the trail and visiting them – get out of Wellington.

Anyway back to this copyright conversation. It is a good example of sensible Opposition politics. Use a short-term issue (s92A) to start a conversation on a longer term issue (copyright law in the Internet age), and show you are listening.

s92A is just one flash point in the clash between technology that allows perfect high speed digitial copying of well basically everything, and traditional copyright laws. The challenge is to get a copyright law thet reflects the reality of today’s world, yet still protects the economic interests of rights holders.

Details announced for nine day fortnights

John Key has announced details of the nine day fortnight plan to help struggling businesses:

  • Available to 1,600 businesses with more than 100 employees. Those businesses employ 580,000 people.
  • Available from March 27, 2009 through until December 31, 2010 – but only for up to a six month period within these dates.
  • Government’s contribution of five hours at $12.50 will be paid direct to employers to give to the workers it has negotiated a voluntary agreement with to reduce work hours to a nine-day fortnight.
  • Will be available to up to 10 employees for each averted redundancy.
  • Will apply to employees who have been full-time for the two months preceding going into the scheme.
  • Is anticipated to be picked up by between 20,000 and 25,000 workers, making the approximate cost $16 million to $20 million.

I am glad it is targeted and temporary. To some degree this is the Government paying in a bit of money, to allow employers, unions and workers to negotiate some reductions in hours to prevent redundancies. This is a useful reminder of how important flexibility in the labour market is.

If someone earns $30,000 a year and they drop down to nine days a fortnight, then their gross wages will drop from $1,151 to $1,036 a fortnight.  That is a drop of $115 a fortnight. The Government’s subsidy will give them back $63 a fortnight leaving them with a gross income drop of $52 a fortnight. So at $30,000 the Government picks up 54% of your day off, and you pick up 46% and you are guaranteed not to be made redundant.

$52 a fortnight is still a reasonable drop in income. But hey it is less than what the ACC levies were looking to rise under Labour!

What will be interesting is the impact of Working for Families. One of the problems of WFF is the abatement rates for it plus the accomodation supplement means that effective marginal tax rates get close to 90%. So certain families could have the main incoem earner go from $50,000 to $70,000 yet only have net income increase by $1,200 or so (figures off memory). Not that is a very bad thing, but for once it may work in favour of some families – if your income drops by going into a nine day fortnight, then the abatement rates will work in negative and may keep you at close to your old net income.

The Government should get IRD and WINZ to do a online calculator tool where people can work out what happens to their net income if they go onto a nine day fortnight.

The real issue re Peters car

The media has rightfully focused on DIA trying to cover up the situation around Winston’s non-returned and non-purchased Ministerial car.

But there is a bigger story. And that is around the petrol. Yes I know that sounds trivial, but let me explain.

Being tardy returning your car is not a hanging offence. Many of us are tardy doing various things. It is a bad look, but not a deliberate action.

Being tardy paying for the car is also not a hanging offence. Many individuals and businesses have paid bilsl late. Again not a great look, but not a deliberate action.

But as Whale Oil points out, Winston was using his Ministerial fuel card to pay for petrol well after the election. He used the card on the 19th of November and 29th of November and 10th of December.

Now the election was 8 November and the new Government sworn in on 19 November. That means Winston was morally wrong to use the fuel card after 8 November and legally wrong to use it after 19 November.

Unlike the car not being returned, which can be explained away, using a Ministerial fuel card when you are not a Minister is a very deliberate decision. You go to the petrol station, fill up the car, and get asked to pay. You have a choice. You can pay cash. Or you can pull out the Ministerial fuel card and use that.

This is arguably a criminal offence. I recall a former MP got into some serious trouble some years ago when he used parliamentary taxi chits after he was no longer an MP.

Assuming Peters remains Leader of NZ First, maybe someone can ask him at his next press conference why did he choose to charge petrol to a Ministerial fuel card a month after the election?

The dangers of increasing the minimum wage

Kiwi Pundit reports this warning from Obama’s State Department:

In January, Honduran President Manuel Zelaya increased the minimum wage 60 percent, raising monthly wages from US$ 181 to $289. As a result, an estimated 15,000 people have been laid off in urban areas. This number is expected to steadily increase as businesses cannot afford the new mandatory wages. Remittances from Hondurans in the U.S. have also decreased throughout 2008.

Some analysts predict increased crime in Honduras due to citizens unable to find legitimate sources of income. Many unemployed Hondurans could look to kidnapping for ransom in order to obtain large sums of money for a small amount of planning and effort. As the disparity between economic classes continues, wealthy Hondurans or foreigners of affluent appearance conducting business in Honduras could continue to be targeted at a higher rate.

May that serve as a lesson for those who think you can make everyone richer simply by increasing the minimum wage.

Kerr on Jobs Summit

Roger Kerr writes about the jobs summit:

In the lead-up to the Summit there were some predictable outbursts.

Veteran anti-globalisation campaigner Jane Kelsey hyperventilated. She saw the Summit as “a Trojan horse for the business sector” and likened it to the 1984 economic summit which was apparently “a carefully orchestrated piece of pageantry chaired by Ron Trotter” (actually David Lange – academics should get their facts right).

Professor Kelsey should calm down and watch Slumdog Millionaire. It is a rags to riches story of entrepreneurship in the new India, the product of sweeping moves to cut taxes, liberalise trade and deregulate business.

India needs to go further to lift up more of its poor, and it is unlikely to abandon globalisation any time soon.

Developing countries are arguably the biggest winners from globalisation – it allows them to sell their goods and services for a fair price.

And interestingly, even though the election only four months ago was largely about economic directions, no one argued that the government was heading in the wrong direction with its economic policies.

Opinion polls also suggest a majority of the public supports its return to more conventional and less interventionist economic policies.

There were no calls for more fiscal stimulus. Participants seemingly understood that the existing stimulus is large and that any further boost could put our credit rating at risk. This would raise the cost of borrowing for all New Zealand firms and households.

That’s an interesting observation. I certainly agree that the level of fiscal stimulus is about as large as we can manage, without dooming future generations to huge interest costs on public debt.

Politically, the Summit can be seen as an extension of the government’s moves to have a relationship with the Maori Party and a dialogue with the Greens, and many other inclusive initiatives.

This is a far cry from the tribal ‘We won, you lost. Eat that!’ style of government of recent years and augurs well for a better consensus on national directions.

Very different.

Free off peak travel “safe”

It is absolutely no surprise that the cost of “free” (ie we pay) off peak travel for pensioners has been increasing. NZPA reports:

During the four months to January, free trips increased from 585,842 to 667,594.

That meant monthly expenditure rising from $1.24m to $1.52m, and the total was $5.5m.

A continued increase in the uptake could stretch the budget beyond $18m in the first 12 months.

Making things free fucks up all rationality around incentives. Free tertiary courses led to scams all over the country. Free transport is doing the same.

Transport operators are treating this like a printing press. Every pensioner they can persuade to travel, they get paid for by the taxpayer. And the marginal cost of an extra passenger on an off peak service is basically zero. So they are spending all this money from the taxpayer on advertising to encourage even more pensioners to travel with them.

NZPA continues:

Questioned about this, Prime Minister John Key said the scheme was obviously successful.

“We will be funding the increase,” he said.

That is not what I call a success. It is about as successful as the dopey schemes run by universities and student associations where they hand out free cash to students in “hardship”. And surprise, surprise – every year the scheme is so successful they need more money.

Four editorials on Corrections

This is getting to be a habit. Two days in a row, and all four major dailies again have editorials on much the same subject.

This time we will start in the South with the ODT:

There was some evidence taxpayers had been saved money by private enterprise: one study showed the cost of keeping an inmate in a high security prison run by the Corrections Department at the time was $72,000 per year; the cost in a minimum security prison was $54,000, and the cost in the privately-run remand prison $43,000 a year.

The Treasury also told the Labour government that the Corrections Department was unlikely to run the remand prison for a cheaper price. Nevertheless, it was taken over by the department. At the time, the co-leader of the Maori Party, Tariana Turia, commented the prison had operated “extremely well” under private management.

Today, we have record prison inmate numbers, about half of whom claim to be Maori, and an exceptionally high recidivism rate. The state system is clearly far from properly addressing their rehabilitation. It is this failure that needs to be the focus of the Government’s attention, rather than whether private enterprise can do a better (read cheaper) job.

The ODT is wrong to interpret better as meaning cheaper only. The private managed prison has lower levels of drug abuse and violence – both major factors into recidivism I would say.

Yet, what do we find in the most recent review of the department, by commissioner Ian Rennie: the Labour government failed to provide anywhere near enough funding to pay for required extra parole officers; it refused to pay for the much-needed 10 additional psychologists; it refused the department’s request for more funding to meet just “satisfactory” standards of service.

I think the ODT overlooks the Auditor-General saying very very clearly that any lack of resource can not explain the massive breaches of their own procedures and policies, that resulted in incraesed risk to the public.

Next The Press:

The minister had no doubt expected that this latest report would lead to the sacking of Corrections’ chief executive, Barry Matthews, by Rennie, who is technically his employer. Matthews had refused to resign.

But to Collins’ chagrin, the report said that sacking Matthews could not be justified. Rennie acknowledged that non-compliance with parole management procedures was too high, but said there had been recent improvements.

His report also pointed to the increased workload of the department and said that requests from Matthews for more staff had been rejected by the previous government.

This finding might create the suspicion that the head of the public service bent over backwards to clear the chief executive, and Collins is certainly correct to say that most New Zealanders do not have confidence in the department or Matthews. But, realistically, Collins had no real choice but to grit her teeth, accept the findings of a report which she had ordered, and promise to put more resources into Matthews’ department.

The alternative would be for her to tell Rennie that she could not possibly work with her chief executive, which would virtually force the commissioner to replace him. Yet after being cleared by the latest report, Matthews would almost certainly have sought a substantial payout, especially as he had two years of his $375,000 a year contract to run. That would have been politically unacceptable.

Yep. In one sense Barry Matthews has been put onto probation rather than given a recall!

The Dom Post:

Strip away the verbiage and State Services Commissioner Iain Rennie’s report on Corrections Department accountability can be read two ways.

Either it is an elaborate exercise in buck-passing chief executive Barry Matthews cannot be held accountable for his department’s failings because the last government woefully under-resourced it or it is a charter for mediocrity: departments should not be expected to follow their own procedures.

To be fair to the last Government, I understand funding for Corrections has been:

99/00: $427m
08/09: $965m

Departments always say they want more money. Corrections has had its budget double and they still couldn’t follow their own procedures in the *majority* of their own cases.

Protecting the public is the department’s No1 priority. The Burton case should have have served as a wake-up call to all within Corrections. Mr Matthews has devoted extra attention to high-risk parolees since the Burton case, but it is surprising that he appeared to be unaware of the extent of his department’s failings till the auditor-general conducted his review.

It is almost as surprising that Mr Rennie does not consider that a sackable offence. The department’s failure to follow its own rules put public safety at risk.

In standing by his beleaguered chief executive, Mr Rennie has made himself accountable for the department’s performance. If the department continues to fall short of public expectations, he will find that an uncomfortable position.

That is very true.

And finally the Herald:

The Corrections Minister’s instructions to the State Services Commissioner, Iain Rennie, were quite explicit. He was to “establish who is accountable for serious failings identified by the Auditor-General’s report into the management of offenders on parole”. By any yardstick, Mr Rennie has failed miserably. He has found no one accountable in terms worthy of justifying dismissal. That includes the chief executive of the Corrections Department, Barry Matthews, and the parole head, Katrina Casey. And there is not a murmur about who else, among the problem-plagued department’s staff, should be held accountable for these “serious failings”. The Government’s quest for public-sector accountability seems to have passed Mr Rennie by.

To be fair to Mr Rennie, he is hamstrung with our employment laws that basically do not allow you to sack people just because they have failed at their job.

His report is the more abject in that he confirms the department has been failing to make the grade. Corrections’ internal standard is 85 per cent compliance with its own parole management procedures. Last December, it managed 80 per cent. Further, Mr Rennie judged that the department could have moved earlier last year to manage the potential risk to public safety caused by far more offenders being placed on community-based sentences.

But he excuses these grave shortcomings by pointing to improvements in performance. Compliance with parole management procedures had dipped as low as 60 per cent in November, 2007, he notes. What he does not mention is that this was almost three years after Mr Matthews took the Corrections reins. It was also about the time community-based sentences came into force, a move that necessitated the training of new probation officers. This innovation may, as Mr Rennie suggests, be a mitigating factor. But it is not an excuse. It should not distract from the long-term problems under Mr Matthews’ watch.

As I said previously, the improvements in performance had better continue.

John’s new fan

preityzinta

Stuff reports:

John Key’s half hour date with a Bollywood superstar is winning front page headlines in cricket and movie crazed India.

Preity Zinta has met the prime minister along with the Indian cricket team and is star struck.

“John Key is so young and so charming,” she is quoted in both the Times of India and the Hindu newspapers.

“It was a pleasure meeting him. He’s extremely dynamic and so much loved by the people. So down-to-earth and so interested in India and Indians.” …

She said she was surprised at “how clued-in” Mr Key was to Indian politics he is to the happenings and developments in our country.

Tough job being Prime Minister sometimes 🙂

Slam and Dunk

Two hilarious moments in Parliament. First we had Anderton wasting his one question a month, trying to be pious as usual:

Hon JIM ANDERTON (Leader—Progressive) to the Prime Minister: How many jobs will be created for unemployed New Zealanders as a result of the reinstatement of the titles of Knight and Dame Grand Companion in the New Zealand honours system?

Hon JOHN KEY (Prime Minister) : None will be created and none will be lost. The member misunderstands the purpose of reinstating the titles.

A nice swat away. But Anderton persists and persist and finally we get:

Hon Jim Anderton: What items on the list of things the Government has made its higher priorities in Government will do the most to reduce the impact of global recession: bringing back knighthoods, a national cycleway, or privatising prisons?

Hon JOHN KEY: All three can play a part in helping our economy to grow. I am surprised, I have to say, that Mr Anderton has come down to the House today with this primary question. Funnily enough, I took a moment out of my busy schedule to have a look through the archives, and I noticed that in 1997 the Hon Jim Anderton introduced the Exceptional Service Honour (Posthumous Recognition) Bill. He sought to have that bill passed, and, lo and behold, the bill—which he waxed lyrical about, but I will not bore members with it—would have conferred an honour with the status of a knighthood. That was what the bill was trying to do. Jim Anderton not only tried to create his own new honour, with the status of a knighthood, in 1997; he actually had tried it once before, in 1991.

Hilarious. Anderton twice introduced a bill to give the equivalent of a knighthood to someone who died in WWI 90 years ago, and he is stupid enough to them try and ask a question complaining about the Government “wasting” time on knighthoods. To say people were laughing is putting it mildly.

Whichever staffer dug that piece of info up, deserves a jellybean.

Then we had Sue Moroney going on about pay equity to Pansy Wong. And I loved this exchange:

Sue Moroney: Why did the Minister ignore a protest on this issue by school support workers in Hamilton on Friday, and then, just minutes later, tell the Hamilton International Women’s Day Symposium that the gender pay gap was too large in New Zealand and she wanted to do more, when her Government is actually guilty of doing less?

Hon PANSY WONG: I hardly ignored the handful of protesters in Hamilton. I actually told them to please take care and not get too wet.

Wonderful answer. She told them not to get too wet.

The Crunchie Train Robbery Ad

Those born after the 70s may not recall this advertisement but it was a classic. There was a short version and the full version. People used to hang out waiting for the actual full version, it was so popular. I’m not quite sure why, but it was absolutely iconic and memorable.

Hat Tip: Gonzo

An inspiring UK Labour MP

This article in the Daily Mail was written by Tom Harris, a UK Labour MP in Glasgow. Oh what I would give to hear such words here:

The benefits culture remains Glasgow’s shame, and it is not confined to my city; many other post-industrial areas of Britain suffer the same malaise of second and third generations of families being brought up to believe a life on benefits is acceptable.  …

Politicians are not expected to talk about moral absolutes. Raising questions about other people’s choices, after all, could offend someone and nothing is less acceptable these days than causing someone offence.

I certainly seem to have offended a lot of people in the past few days.

I was severely criticised by some on the Left and a number of women have contacted me to say they felt insulted, pointing out that since becoming single parents at a young age, they had gone on to further and higher education and made a success of their lives.

Which is brilliant. I have nothing but admiration for them.

But I was very specifically criticising our acceptance of those young women who lose all their educational and career opportunities because of their pregnancies and who spend the rest of their lives on benefit.

That is the challenge – to criticise welfare dependency, without being seen to criticise everyone who has been on a benefit.

So why are so many on the Left angry at me?

For some it is because they don’t feel it is a problem; they believe that, as a rich society, we can afford to fund this ‘lifestyle choice’.

Others are uneasy at a Labour politician making judgments about other people’s choices; I have ‘no right’ to put greater value on one person’s choices than on another’s, it seems.

In NZ, you would be out on your ear.

But I’m attacking no one. I am pointing out that we have an unacceptably high level of teenage pregnancies. I am stating a fact that, for many of these young women (and far fewer young men), parenthood will mean fewer opportunities and a higher chance of life on benefits.

There is no doubt that raising yet another generation of young men in fatherless homes is a recipe for social disaster.

Yes, I’m generalising and, yes, there are plenty of homes where the absence of a violent, abusive father is a blessing to the mother and children. But common sense dictates that, in general, children benefit from having the love of a mother and a father.

Yet what kind of society have we created when the above statement will inevitably be seen by some as offensive, narrow-minded and intolerable?

As for the accusation of giving comfort to the ‘Right-wing’, when did it become ‘Left-wing’ to tolerate such a colossal waste of lives?

Why is it ‘Left-wing’ to allow millions of people to remain on benefits instead of working? When did ‘Labour’ stop meaning ‘work’ and start to mean ‘benefits’?

Comrade Bradford needs to talk to this poor misguided soul.

There are many others who believe the gradualist approach to moving people off benefits and into work is the right way to go.

But my instinct tells me more radical measures will have to be introduced to see the step-change needed to make a real difference to the number of claimants. …

But if more extreme measures, such as financial penalties for long-term claimants, need to be implemented in future, they will need public support. That means being absolutely honest about the scale of the problem and the devastation that long-term benefit dependency can cause.

Devastation is the right word. We have a welfare state to be there for those in temporary need, and also for that small minority who can never be self sufficient. But the problems caused by families never knowing a work culture is immense. It shows in our crime and our education stats. And our child abuse stats.

As I said, how reassuing to hear such words from a Labour MP – even one from Glasgow! His majority by the way is 10,802 – he got 47% of the votes to 19% for the Lib Dem candidate.

A Public Service Manager speaks out

A compelling guest blog from an anonymous public service manager at Public Address. It is a must read for those who do not understand the culture of the public service. Some extracts:

On top of that, we’ve seen lots of Head Office bloat in the last few years. Rooms of endless meetings going on and on about “Vision” and “Strategy” … interesting how the best private sector firms don’t stuff around with all that. I have a feeling that we felt a bit inadequate because we didn’t have all the things that CEOs in big private businesses get to play with – you know, HR strategies and Corporate Compliance units. We just had a thing called The Law, which we have to carry out.

I saw this thing in a book once about how people in the institutional banks in the UK used to get posted if they weren’t doing too well: FILTHK (Failed In London, Try Hong Kong). I have to wonder if people who fail in the private sector sometimes end up being posted to Wellington (and it is a noticeably Wellington issue…). To be clear, I don’t think these people are malicious or stupid. I just think they are, well, a bit distant from reality. They’ve started to believe the management books and “Best Practice” guides.

It is a culture issue. Wellington has a very peculiar culture in terms of workplaces – very very risk averse.

Another good example is all the law around careful management of public money. Great intentions, but combined with a culture that says “the auditor is always right [and believe me, they’re not most of the time – if you can’t do, teach. And if you are really crap, become an auditor] then you end up in a situation where stupid rules are put in place so that rather than have someone take responsibility for a decision, a committee is formed and reports are written. This means there’s a thing called an ‘audit trail’ so you can completely fail to identify who stuffed up if something goes wrong.

We call it “all hold hands and make a decision”.

Decision making by committee.

I recently heard of a situation where a project was completed ahead of schedule, on time and under budget. Much of this was that the person running it didn’t bother waiting for pointless meetings and reports. Instead he just got on and did it, thereby saving the taxpayer two hundred thousand dollars. The audit report on the project flagged it as being very “high risk” in a number of areas. The best bit was the audit report was completed after the project was finished! So they knew it had worked at the time of writing! Did this guy get a medal for being pragmatic and sensible? No, he gets called in for a Stern Talking To. Will he ever try and do anything like that again? I doubt it. And we’re all poorer.

I can’t emphasise how absolutely focused the public service is on risk – to the detriment of most other things. Risk management and mitigation  is very important, but one can’t operate without risk.

Here’s one of my favourites. There was an article in a law newsletter recently that held up a case of a sacking by the IRD as a perfect example of how to get rid of a useless employee. I’m guessing they went through committees and panels to appoint him in the first place. I expect there were several people who thought he shouldn’t have been hired, but they hired him anyway, because after all they’d followed “The Process”.

Reading between the lines, when they realised he simply couldn’t do the job they started The Process of sacking him. It took three years, and then another four years in court. Eventually he lost. But this is held up as the perfect way to sack someone! If it had been the private sector he would have been out on his ear and awarded a few grand by a tribunal. On our side of the fence we spend (I’m guessing) hundreds of thousands of dollars on The Process, because the CEO (and minister) might get beaten up in the press over the payout.

Sacking someone for incompetence in the public service in near impossible. You can soend years documenting every mistake they make, and you will still have to fork out money to stop them taking a personal grievance.

When we buy stuff, there are laws to say how it must be done. These have been around for years. They were designed to reduce the cost of stuff ups. Interestingly, what they’ve done is replaced the chance of a cost blow out with a guarantee of spending far more than necessary on paperwork and “Governance”. In the private sector, a typical project budgets 15 – 30% of cost for management and administration.

In the public sector it starts at 30%. Because the rules a blindly applied, it means there’s a minimum set of paperwork for everything. These aren’t meant to be applied across the board, but woe betide you if you get caught out trying to save some money and then an Issue arises. Years of habit and cover-your-arse have developed a generation of public servants who live by meetings, committees and reports. And a bunch of auditors who NEVER say “it was pleasing to see that processes were not followed unnecessarily, thereby saving the taxpayer X million dollars”.

I think National is going to make some difference with public sector spending. But I doubt it can change the underlying culture as it is too ingrained.

Worth reading the full post.

Bye Bye Expressoholic

Sad to read in the Dom post that after 18 years, Expressoholic is closing.

Many fond memories of Expressoholic – often after movies. A very good venue for dates also, due to its location. Meeting for coffee at Astoria means you want to talk business with someone. not date them. Meeting for coffee at Expressoholic means that if it goes well, one can go down the street for some non-caffeine drinks afterwards!

It won’t be the same without it!

The 9 day fortnight

Starting to see some details around the vexed question of who pays for the 10th day if workers go on a nine day fortnight.

Obviously the business can’t still pay staff for the tenth day, when the whole idea is to help businesses survive by reducing their costs. Having them pay the same wages for one less day’s work would make things worse, not better.

So that leaves either the workers not getting paid for the tenth day, or the Government paying.

As usual, John Key looks to be heading towards a pragmatic compromise, according to Tracy Watkins in the Dominion Post:

The Government has ruled out a wage subsidy on the grounds of cost, but is considering an allowance based on a “benchmark”, such as the average or minimum wage.

Government sources say a 100 per cent wage subsidy for the lost day’s pay is too expensive and would send the wrong signals to business, which might see it as an opportunity to trim wage costs by getting the Government to pick up the tab.

The minimum wage is $12.50 an hour which is $100 for an eight hour day. So the Government would be paying around $2,600 a year to a worker on their day off. If 100,000 workers go onto this scheme, then the cost is $260 million a year plus admin costs.

Some unions have said they want it higher, such as the median wage. The problem with that though, is some employees who earn less than the median wage will actually get paid more by having the tenth day off for training, than is otherwise the case.

In the long term is is silly to think a sustainable business model is to have the Government pay 10% of the wages of every worker, to save businesses model. If that is a good idea, then why not have the Government pay 100%.

So the key is that it has to be temporary and targeted. It arguably is not economically efficient – but if it can avoid unemployment hitting double figures, that will reduce the downstream effects in terms of crime and benefits etc.

I am nervous about the ability of the Government to target it only to firms that really need it. They team that has to implement this will need to be very good.

Political Trivia Quiz of the Day?