First dispatch online at NBR

My first column for NBR Online is up on their site. I forgot to give it a title, so it was given the simple name of “Dispatch #1”.

One extract:

In a sparse field, the winner is National’s ACC policy which gets a solid B. It would have got an A- but for some reason National is only pledging to “Investigate opening the Work Account to competition”. Good God, I hope the tax policy doesn’t become “Investigate reducing taxes”.

Comments can be left on the NBR site.

Leaky Homes

The Dominion Post editorial is on leaky homes:

In late June, the mayors of 14 cities agreed on a package of proposals to put to the Government. They estimate that 80,000 people live in homes that leak or are at risk of doing so, and put the bill for repairs at up to an eyewatering $2.1 billion. The estimate for Wellington alone is $132 million.

When news of the idea surfaced, Miss Clark was unsympathetic. The Government, she said, had “no liability whatsoever …” but went on to concede that homeowners were the innocent parties. It is those people whom the mayors profess to have front of mind because, according to Ms Prendergast, they are settling for 50 per cent or less of the repair costs in compensation.

It is no surprise that Clark is unsympathetic. She initially denied there was any widespread problem. In fact I think her words were that the issue was being manufactured by the Herald as a story they “keep banging on about”.

Back to the Future

The NZ Herald Politics Section today is a real back to the future.

One story from Oct 1999, one from Nov 1999 and two from Dec 2001!

One should read the story on how Clark will clean up Government and stop waste – is hilarious in light of where we are today.

Confusing figures on cost of universal allowances

Media reports on the costs of universal student allowances are somewhat confused. The initial story in The Press stated:

The paper shows that removing income tests on the allowance and providing it to all fulltime students would cost a total of $2.09 billion over four years.

The net extra cost of such a plan is $728 million after the existing costs of the scheme are removed, along with a forecast plunge in borrowing under the student loans scheme that might accompany such a plan.

Now this story is largely correct, but the confusion starts here because of two things. Firstly it wasn’t made clear the $728 net cost was over four years also, and the reduction in cost from $2.09 to $0.73 billion is attributed to both the existing costs of “the scheme” and a forecast plunge in borrowing.

I’ve obtained a copy of the Ministry paper, and the $2.09 billion “total net cost” actually already includes any savings from reduced student loans. The difference between the $728 million and the $2,094 million is merely the difference between the status quo and the “total net cost” of universal allowances. In 2011/12 it would be an extra $226 million of annual expenditure.

So what impact would universal allowances have on the student loans scheme? In fact fairly modest. Over four years there would be a reduction in operating expenditure of $107 million and a reduction in capital expenditure of $260 million. In 2012/12 the student loans scheme would cost the taxpayer $33 million less than if one had universal allowances.

So the original story while largely correct, was imprecise and had one aspect wrong. And then see how the story changed;

NZPA picked up the story, and as reported in the Herald says:

The Press said the $728m net extra cost of such a plan was based on removing existing costs of the scheme and factoring in an expected reduction in student loans.

NZPA have left off the all important fact that this is a cost over four years.

Then we turn to today’s Press editorial:

Figures from the ministry suggest that the total cost would be $2.09 billion over four years, although that could go down to a net cost of $728 million if student borrowing fell, as the ministry expects it might.

No no no. The $2.09 billion already takes into account a decline in student borrowing. The fall to $728 million is merely deducting the cost of current student allowances.

The Press are correct with their warning:

Voters will recall the Government’s assurance that interest-free loans would not greatly increase student borrowing. A survey of student borrowing shows, however, that since 2004 the average debt has risen 54% to $28,838. While not all of that is attributable to the interest-free nature of the loans, it does suggest that a considerable number of students (or their parents) are doing exactly what was predicted leaving their own money in the bank to earn interest and taking out a loan interest-free, at the taxpayers’ expense, to meet their educational costs.

And something the Ministry paper does not do is project any increase in student numbers, if allowances became universal. I suspect there would be an increase in numbers studying if this did happen.

Anyway back to what are the actual costs of universal allowances. As far as I can tell from the Ministry paper, the costs are:

  1. Gross costs of universal student allowances: $2,221 million/4 years or $657 million in 2011/12
  2. Reduction in operating cost of student loan scheme: $107 million/4 years or $33 million in 2011/12
  3. Net cost of universal student allowances: $2,094 million/4 years or $624 million in 2011/12
  4. Current cost of student allowances: $1,366 million/4 years or $399 million in 2011/12
  5. Net additional cost of policy: $728 million/4 years or $226 million in 2011/12

Note I don’t guarantee these 100% as the Ministry paper itself is not totally explicit with its calculations. But hopefully this gives a far better idea of the costs than the various media reports.

Veitch resigns

It was inevitable – Tony Veitch has resigned from both TVNZ and the Radio Sport network.

Regardless of the debate about what he did and didn’t do, the reality was he would be commercially unviable on air and shows featuring him would lose viewers/listeners and advertisers.

The next issue of course is what will the Police do. This is at the end of the day an issue about alleged criminal offending.

The Last Samurai

Writing for NBR

Later today I will be writing my first weekly column for NBR online. The column somewhat mischievously is called “Dispatch from Helengrad” and NBR have advised that it will be changed to “Dispatch from St Johnnysburg” if there is a change of Government!

The official blurb is:

Dispatch from Helengrad is a weekly missive from the nations capital. Each Friday morning it will reveal the best and worst of the week in politics, developing scandals from inside the corridors of power and a quick guide to the best political commentaries of the week.

David will also record any breaches of the Electoral Finance Act, confident that our politicians will break their own law frequently.

I’ll link through to my first column once it is online. Feedback will of course be welcome, and suggested items for inclusion are encouraged via e-mail.

Espiner on Inflation

Colin Espiner looks at what he calls the horrible inflation data:

Labour will be happy that this week’s truly horrible inflation data came out during the Parliamentary recess.

After all, the highest inflation in 13 years and the biggest quarterly increase in food prices since June 1990 isn’t something either Prime Minister Helen Clark or Finance Minister Michael Cullen particularly wishes to be quizzed on.

It’s amazing how quickly things have turned. It seems like only yesterday that ministers were asking each other patsy questions in the House so they could in turn stand and brag about record low unemployment, growth rates higher than Australia’s, or some other positive fiscal indicator.

It never ceases to surprise me how quick any government is to claim the credit when things are going well, and how fast it is to distance itself when things are not.

Take Cullen’s prepared lines yesterday: “It is important to remember that our economic challenges are not of New Zealand’s making. The global increase in the prices of petrol and food are outside New Zealand’s control.”

Now whether you agree with Cullen or not depends, I guess, on whether you subscribe to the free trade market economy we operate in. But assuming he’s right, it’s still ironic. Can you imagine Cullen saying, after delivering one of his whopping surpluses of yesteryear: “It is important to remember that our economic good fortune is not of New Zealand’s making. The global rises in commodity prices are outside New Zealand’s control.”

Um. Don’t think so.

So true. The reality is that international forces will always have more of an impact than anything we do domestically. However Governments can and do make a difference around the margins – especially by focusing on increasing productivity and havign sensible fiscal and monetrary policy.

However, Cullen can distance himself all he likes from the causes of inflation running at 4% and heading for 5%. He can blame all the Middle East unrest and growth of developing nations he likes for the fact that petrol is up a whopping 25% in the last year. He can moo about the rise in the value of dairy prices that has seen milk up 22% in a year and cheese 62% until the cows come home.

The fact is it’s happened on his watch and voters, rightly or wrongly, expect him to do something about it. Cullen recognised this yesterday, referring to the October 1 tax cuts package which, he said, “will provide some relief”.  Actually, as Cullen knows only too well, it will deliver very little.

The cruel reality of inflation is that the value of his $16 a week for the average wage-earner is eroding by the day. By the time October 1 rolls around, the increase in the price of petrol alone since the Budget would have accounted for half of the extra Cullen has promised. Fresh increases in the price of milk, bread, cheese, and fruit and vegetables will take care of the rest.

And people know deep down Dr Cullen is not giving tax cuts to help people out. He cancelled tax cuts just over a year ago, and his u-turn on tax cuts was poll driven. Now u-turns are part of politics, but to then claim the u-turn as a virtue goes too far with some people. It would be like National trying to take credit for income related state rentals, when everyone knows they prefer market rentals.

We could always have a debate about it, if the Opposition would engage. Yet all I know of National’s plans for the economy is that it will reduce taxes, “cut red tape”, spend more on infrastructure, reduce government spending “so that interest rates track downwards” and improve education standards.

There’s almost enough apple pie in those statements to feed a starving family of five for a week. But the polls show voters are still happy with this level of detail from National, for the meantime anyway.

That’s a great line – enough apple pie to feed a starving family of five. And some truth in Colin’s criticism. He has however overlooked the fibre to the home policy which is a major point of difference with Labour, and is intended to be a significant foundation for lifting NZ’s productivity and economic growth.

Back Benches and Champagne

Another fun night watching Back Benchers yesterday. Cactus Kate was in town so we settled in early at 5 pm. Highly amusing as she berates the waitress for the lack of decent champagne available in the bar, and the bar owner being at the table next to us.  However the staff redeemed themselves by following the instruction to automatically bring out a new bottle whenever the existing bottle got below 20% full.

We ended up with a very mixed table with Kate (ACT), myself (Nat), Will de Cleene (Greens/ACT), a 9th floor staffer (Labour), a National Radio presenter and an Electoral Commission staffer. Made for a fun night, which once again ended up at Mighty Mighty in Cuba Mall.

Universal Student Allowances

Colin Espiner is now speculating that rather than increase student allowances to $350 a week, the Government may pledge to make existing allowances universal – or in other words remove parental means testing.

I have long supported getting rid of parental means testing as 24 year olds should not be assessed on parental income instead of their own.

The main reason it has not happened to date is competing fiscal priorities. The interest free loans policy is incredibly generous and costly, and it is hard to say that more money for tertiary rather than early childhood is the priority.

The gross cost of universal allowances is $2b over four years but this reduces to $728 million over four years when you take account of reduced borrowing. I’m a bit suspicious of those figures though as it sounds like one is contrasting expenditure and borrowing and they are not the same thing. Only the reduction in interest writeoffs should be counted not the reduction in borrowing.

If the net effect on the fiscal surplus is around $180 million a year then it is relatively affordable. If it is $500 million a year then in the current financial squeeze it would be quite irresponsible. That of course means it can’t be ruled out as Labour’s plan seems to be to wreck the Government’s books on the way out.

Fiji Elections

Back in March I blogged:

When I read that Foreign Ministers could not get an election timetable out of Fiji, but are hopeful there will be one next month, I am reminded of Charlie Brown trying to kick the football. Each time he goes for it, Commodore Lucy pulls it away!

This is still happening. There is no chance there will be elections by March 2009. In fact there is no chance of any free elections. Already the Commodore is talking of banning the former governing party, or members from it anyway.

Back Benches tonight

It’s Wednesday so it is Back Benches Day. Tonight we have:

  • Ron Mark, NZ First
  • Judy Turner, United Future
  • Sue Moroney, Labour
  • Chris Tremain, National

Issues for discussion are the death of Sgt Wootton, closing bars at 3 am in Auckland, banning telemarketers and did NZ First get the money or not.

The show is on TVNZ7 just after 9 am. Those who want to watch live are best to turn up to the Backbencher before 8.30 p.m.

National’s ACC policy

National has released its ACC policy. As expected they are supportive of opening the workplace account up to competition.

Now you will hear much misinformaion about what this means. It in no way means employees will have less rights to compensation in case of an accident. All insurers will have to provide the at least the exact same coverage as the ACC does.

What it does is allow employers to choose the best workplace insurer for them. Just as we do not force everyone to use the same car insurer or same contents insurer. Employers will also be able to purchase workplace insurance beyond the minimum requirements – something you can’t do through the ACC.

If an insurer does not have a state monopoly behind it, then it has incentives to work with employers to have safer workplaces. It is a win-win-win. Insurers pay out less money. Employers get cheaper premiums and employees have less accidents.

Labour will argue that OSH regulations provide the incentive to have safe workplaces. This is typical leftish thinking – all stick and no carrot. Now as it happens large employers are able to already get some incentives in terms of the accredited employers scheme which allows self or private insurance. This is about giving all employers that same choice.

National says in their policy:

There is little incentive (in the form of lower levies) for those who adopt good safety practices in the workplace, and there are no penalties for those who disregard good safety practices.

Because there is no choice or competition, there is no real transparency around the
operation of the scheme.

Employers provide the basic minimum cover for staff, as they are obliged to do. A more flexible scheme would encourage employers to buy more than the basic cover.

All good points. Having made those points I am surprised they are not saying they will definitely introduce the much needed competition, but just investigate it. I guess they are keeping options open in case it proves too difficult. At the end of the day they did so in 1998, so I am confident they will do so.

Finally they are also saying they will investigate the merit of introducing an independent disputes tribunal to end ACC’s dual role of judge and jury on disputed claims. I suspect there would be considerable support for that.

The Press on Peters

The Press editorial looks at the Peters-Glenn affair:

The spectacle of the leader of the New Zealand First party and Foreign Minister, Winston Peters, getting angry with journalists is nothing new, says The Press in an editorial.

It is a typical tactic, one learned from his mentor, Sir Robert Muldoon. When caught in a tight spot, get your counter-attack in first, Muldoon once said with a chortle. So when Peters reacted angrily this week to reports about alleged donations to his party from an expatriate billionaire, it was pretty much business as usual.

It is classic Muldoon tactics.

The matter also poses a problem for the Prime Minister, Helen Clark. She claims that it is not her concern and she is studiously declining all substantive comment. But as Foreign Minister, Peters has one of the gaudiest baubles in her Cabinet, and a problem for him is inescapably a problem for her. In this case, of course, it also involves a donor who has been a big contributor to the Labour Party and who may be again in the future.

And also suspected of being the person who offered the Maori Party $250,000 to support Labour.

Earlier this year, it was reported that he had also given money to New Zealand First. The report was given credence when New Zealand First’s president at the time, Dail Jones, said that a five-figure donation, which he described as closer to $100,000 than $10,000, had appeared anonymously in the party’s bank account.

It is worth recalling that Owen Glenn has previously said he has donated to another political party apart from Labour. So the e-mail is not inconsistent with what Glenn has said previously.

If an Opposition party were involved in this sort of scenario offshore billionaire, large political donations, leaked emails and so on one can imagine Peters’ response. With the shoe on the other foot, though, Peters has reacted badly. Rather than addressing the issue coolly and straightforwardly, as might be expected of a senior minister, and leaving it at that, he has allowed himself, yet again, to lose his temper with the media.

Indeed, he should do as Shipley did and front up and reveal the nature of his discussions with Owen Glenn.

Under the law on electoral finance as it stood at the time, it would have been possible for Glenn to have made his political donations in complete anonymity. If any went to New Zealand First, it is possible that Peters was unaware of them. Whatever the case, it should not be too difficult now to work out what happened and to resolve the confusions and contradictions raised by the issue once and for all. Rather than pointlessly getting angry with journalists, Peters should do that.

This is the obvious solution. Get Owen Glenn to confirm if the e-mail is real or faked. And if it is real get him to give details of how much did he donate, and to whom.

If he will not do so of his own accord, the Prime Minister should quietly persuade him of the benefits of doing so. Peters is the man she chose to be her foreign minister. Any questions concerning him inevitably reflect on her and her Government. More particularly, after the last election, both she and Peters made a great to-do about greater transparency in electoral finance and passed a greatly criticised law designed to bring it about. They should live up to all the fine principles they claimed to be espousing when they promoted that law.

The hypocrisy is immense.

Matt McCarten on TV3 this morning referred to the Mike Moore’s supporters club as an example of a roup which can be affiliated to a politician but not a formal part of the party. Now Matt may well be on the right track here. I seem to recall a trust was set up many years ago to help pay Winston’s legal bills with the Winebox. Maybe this Trust still exists. And this could explain how both men are telling the truth.

If a donation was made to a trust such as this, then Winston would be right in saying no donation has been made to NZ First. Yet Owen Glenn may not realise the difference between donating to a trust which supports Winston and the actual NZ First party, and hence has a honest belief he has donated to NZ First.

Whale Oil also looks at the offer of the NZ Herald looking at the audited accounts of NZ First, and quotes from the NZ Institute of Chartered Accountants submission of the Electoral Finance Bill, where they pointed out it won’t cover situations where something may have been excluded.

He also note that at least one other media organisation has tried to take up Winston’s offer of a copy of the audited accounts, and they have been turned down. So the offer seems rather hollow.

More Iranian photoshopping

Readers will have seen the reports of how Iran actually photoshopped photos of their missile launch to cover up the fact one of them failed to launch. This was actually revealed by the Little Green Footballs blog. A good thing do as Israel is less likely to attack Iran now, having one quarter of Iran’s offensive capability is Photoshop!

Anyway Wired has some more photos from Iran. My favourite:

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Tearaway interviews the Leaders

Tearaway – a teen focused magazine, has done an election 08 special which includes interviews with Helen Clark and John Key plus celebrity lookalike photos. Key gets Pee Wee Herman as a 95% match, while Helen will be very happy with her 87% match to Katie Holmes.

I thought the interview responses were revealing. First:

If you just got a billion dollars what would you do?
Key: I’d buy a jet, a personal jet. And donate some to charity.

Clark: Probably give most of it away to development agencies offering education and opportunity and campaigns against HIV and AIDS in developing countries.

Heh I’d buy a bloody jet also. No-one could accuse John Key of giving a Crosby Textor answer to that question 🙂

What’s the happiest moment of your life?
Key: Probably getting married… I’ve been married for twenty four years… and it was a very happy moment.

Clark: Waking up after a good night’s sleep.

Waking up? Oh my God Helen really needs to get out more if waking up every morning is the happiest moments of her life. I thought it would be climbing some mountain, being elected to something etc – but no it is waking up!

Meanwhile John may face questions back home for why his wedding day is only a “probably” 🙂

Favourite subjects at school?
Key: Economics.

Clark: History and English.

How can anyone say economics was their favourite subject. My God. That’s like choosing accountancy.

I’m with Helen on picking History. I love history and don’t even think of it as work.

Hat Tip: The Standard

Wellington Power lines sold to Chinese

NZPA has reported:

New Zealand’s overseas investment watchdog has approved a Chinese conglomerate’s bid to buy Vector’s Wellington power lines network.

Vector sought approval earlier this year for the $785 million deal to sell 100 percent of the shares of Vector Wellington Electricity Network Limited to Hong Kong-based Cheung Kong Infrastructure Holdings (CKI) and Hongkong Electric Holdings Limited (HKE).

Now I don’t care at all who owns my power lines, but isn’t it ironic that the Government moved heaven and earth to stop a Canadian pension fund having a minority voting stake in Auckland Airport, yet has absolutely no problems with a Chinese business owning 100% of Wellington’s power lines?

Didn’t Helen Clark say ownership of such assets would be a defining issue for the election?

An appalling discharge without conviction

Some may disagree with me, but I am appalled that Owen Thor Walker has been discharged without conviction for his involvement in bot nets.

There is an argument that giving the young offender a dressing down and “harnessing his powers for good” is the sensible thing to do. I agree, this is often the case.

But in this case I think his offending was very different to say the person who hacks a few institutions just for the challenge of it. He spent two years helping run bot nets, and made $40,000 doing it. And he wasn’t conned into doing this by someone else. He in fact recruited others to help him. This was not just a kid having some fun. It was serious criminal activity. Bot Nets are arguably the biggest problem on the Internet – they are used for phishing, spamming, DOS attacks etc.

I also am skeptical of the line that he has such superior skills to everyone else, he must be hired by the “good guys” or they will be at a disadvantage. The NZ technical community alone probably has hundreds (or more) of people who would be capable of setting up and running a sophisticated bot net operation. They just choose not to take part in criminal activities. I don’t think you reward someone for having no ethics.

Now I am not arguing Walker should have been sent to jail. That would be silly. And I am mindful he is autistic. But a discharge without conviction should (in my books) be used for extremely minor criminal cases like shoplifting or say $200 of taxi chit fraud. This was not a minor case of offending. It was two years of dedicated offending where he made lots of money, he recruited others to help, and he caused damage to over one million people.

We now have clean slate legislation. If he stayed clean for seven years his conviction would be wiped effectively.

My concern is not Walker per se, but the signal it sends out to the cyber-criminals that running Bot Nets and phishing etc are not real crimes, and if you do them you’ll just get told off. That is what appals me.

Well done Helen

Helen Clark’s lobbying of the UK Government has paid off and New Zealanders with UK grandparents are not going to lose their right to gain ancestry visas allowing them work and live in the UK for up to five years.

It would have been a disaster if this had been scrapped. The Kiwi OE to London is (I think) a hugely important part of growing up.

You only do direct PM to PM lobbying on the really big issues. This was one of those where that was appropriate and necessary, and I am sure it had an influence on the decision not to abolish them.

Strange tactics from Peters

The Herald reports that Winston Peters has told the PM directly that he denies any donation from Owen Glenn to NZ First, and continues to suggest the e-mail the Herald printed is fabricated.

I am puzzled that he is directing all his anger at the NZ Herald, and not any towards Owen Glenn. The obvious solution for Peters is for Owen Glenn to confirm what Peters has said. Why has Winston not picked up the phone to Owen Glenn and asked him if the e-mail is true, and if so why did he say he gave a donation when he didn’t?

The attacks on the Herald Political Editor personally are in my opinion a huge blunder. The gallery have memories of Muldoon when he tried to bully individual journalists and they tend to band together when an MP tries to destory the career of one of their own.

The reality is that any media organisation would have run a story based on that e-mail. And it is a fact that four days on from its publication, neither Owen Glenn nor Steve Fisher have in any way suggested it is fake or forged. To the contrary they have both made statements that are consistent with the e-mail – not inconsistent.

In 1999 Jenny Shipley faced questions over a the issue of having dinner with Kevin Roberts. Jim Anderton falsely accused her of agreeing to give Saatchis the Tourism Board contract at that dinner in exchange for free work on National’s campaign.This was a malicious lie as the dinner happened after the decision on the Tourism Board contract – in fact she had never met Roberts or talked to him prior to the granting of the contract.

Now she fronted up on that issue to the media and the public and revealed the nature and timing of her meetings with Roberts, and even what was discussed at the dinner!

With this far far more serious issue, surely Peters should do the same and answer the following questions:

  1. How often has he met with Owen Glenn?
  2. Has he ever discussed a donation with Owen Glenn?
  3. Why has the Government changed its position on not needing a Consul in Monaco?
  4. What indications were given to Owen Glenn regarding Monaco?

Peters seems to think that simply claiming the e-mail is fabricated, deals with the issue. But if the e-mail is fabricated, why has Owen Glenn not said so?

Helen Clark can contact Owen Glenn either directly or through Mike Williams. He is her largest donor. Why doesn’t she call on Owen Glenn to talk to the media and confirm whether or not the e-mail is real or not, and if so why he stated he donated to NZ First?

Glenn will not refuse a request from the Prime Minister to front up and tell the truth.

The other question for Clark and Williams is whether or not they are still happy to accept large donations from Glenn. Williams a few months ago said he was. You see if Clark is saying she beleives Winston, then that casts huge Glenn in a very bad light. It implies he is a liar or a fantasist. Why would you accept money from him if you beleive that about him?

If Clark thinks the e-mail is fabricated by the NZ Herald, then she must be appalled that Owen Glenn has not stepped forward to clear her Foreign Minister. Again why would you accept money from someone who is willing to let her Foreign Minister be smeared on the basis of a fake e-mail?

If Clark and Peters want this issue to go away, then they have to ask Owen Glenn to speak up. All he has to do is answer the following questions:

  1. Is the e-mail fabricated or real?
  2. Did he make a donation to NZ First or anyone associated with NZ First directly or indirectly?

If the answer to (1) is it is fabricated – then the Police must be called in to investigate this henious crime. The people responsible have massively defamed Peters and Glenn and must be identified.

If the answer to (1) is it is real, then Glenn has to detail whether or not he was telling the truth in a private e-mail to his PR advisor. Was he joking? Was he mistaken? Did he invent the whole episode?

And if the answer to (2) is he was not lying to his PR advisor in a private e-mail, but telling the truth as he saw it – he needs to state what size donation he made, who it was made out to and who was it delivered to. Maybe it was someone else in NZ First who didn’t tell WInston. Maybe he donated through some intermediaries and NZ First did not realise he was the ultimate source?

Now all these details won’t even be necessary, if Owen Glenn will simply deal with the first point. All he needs to do is confirm the claim by WInston Peters that the e-mail is fabricated or fake. Helen Clark and Winston Peters should call on him publicly to confirm or deny the authencity of the e-mail.

Just Deserts

Yes I have weaknesses, and Shortland Street is one of them. Hey when working at 11 pm doing poll analysis, you need something on in the background!

So anyway, for those who do watch it. Wasn’t it great seeing Callum get his just desserts yesterday. The actor does a great job makes the character so loathsome.

20/20 Impact ’08 Seminar on Identity

The 20/20 Communications Trust is having a series of seminars as part of their Impact ’08 series.

One of these is Monday 21 July at the Wellington Railway Station (part of the growing Vic Uni empire). It is from 12.00 pm to 1.30 p.m. and in Room RWW224 on Level 2.

The seminar is on (online) Identity and associated issues and implications. The panel speaking are:

  • Rosemary Du Plessis (who will Chair the session from Christchurch) is an Associate Professor of Sociology from Canterbury University
  • Eamon Daly will participate from Christchurch.  Eamon is an ethics researcher and advisor .
  • Stephen Bell a ComputerWorld journalist with interests in identify and privacy issues.
  • myself
  • Laurence Miller, Deputy State Services Commissioner for ICT

I will be focusing mainly on the combination of identity and location services and the potential impact of these for good or bad.

If you have an interest in this area, you are welcome to attend. Just let Don Hollander know for catering purposes.

The big bribe?

Homepaddock quotes Colin Espiner on what may be Labour’s big bribe:

It is understood Labour is considering a massive boost to the student allowance scheme, including a payment of some $350 a week for study courses of 35 hours a week or more. That would put student allowances far ahead of any other standard benefit payment. It would cost a lot of money, but may not have the same impact as interest-free loans did in 2005.

This would of course be popular with students, but not graduates so much. How many courses are over 35 hours a week? Not the BAs that is for sure 🙂

Where I would like to see a change to student allowances is parental means testing. I think it is quite wrong that students in their 20s are means tested on their parents income instead of their own. That would have been a far more logical thing to do than interest free loans which just encourage unnecessary borrowing.

The real sign!

Peters still considering appointing Glenn Consul

So much for Helen Clark’s claims the Owen Glenn affair has nothing to do with her. The NZ Herald this morning shows that just a few weeks ago Owen Glenn was still lobbying to be appointed NZ’s Consul to Monaco, and not only is he still writing to Winston Peters about it, but the pair appear to have met to discuss the possibility in Europe in May.

This makes the issue of whether or not Owen Glenn has made secret donations (as he claims to have done) to her Foreign Minister’s party, an issue for her as Head of Government. He is dealing with Peters not just as NZ First Leader but as Foreign Minister.

Will Winston claim the letter quoted in the Herald is also fabricated?

Will Helen publish a price list for other diplomatic positions?