Sir Salman Rushdie

Helen Clark recently made Lloyd Geering a member of the Order of New Zealand. This was no doubt offensive to many Christians but bot a single Christian leader (that I can recall) even complained publicly about it. The only complaints were the odd letter or blog post (and they were not saying Geering should not have got the honour because he offended Christians, just that apart from his heresy trial his work wasn’t at the level you expect to be one of the 20 greatest living NZers).

Now compare this to Sir Salman Rushdie’s knighthood. He is an internationally acclaimed novelist who has won the Booker prize and won or been a finalist for numerous other awards. There can really be no disputing that his achievements qualify him for a Knight Bachelor – a long way off the equivalent of the ONZ (The UK equivalent is the Order of the Garter).

The reaction, maybe predictably, from some Muslim Governments and priests has been extreme, with the Pakistan Ulema Council bestowing on Osama bin Laden the title “Saifullah”, or sword of Allah on the grounds “We have awarded this title in reply to Britain’s decision to knight blasphemer Rushdie. If a blasphemer can be given the title ‘Sir’ by the West despite the fact he’s hurt the feelings of Muslims, then a mujahid who has been fighting for Islam against the Russians, Americans and British must be given the lofty title of Islam, Saifullah.”

Yes there is no difference between someone who writes a book and someone who arranges for planes to be flown into tower blocks.

The Press today says:

The renewal of death threats against Rushdie, in the wake of his knighthood, is testament to the effectiveness of the honour in reaffirming the right of free speech even when it wounds. The knighthood and the reaction to it refocus attention on the reality that Islamic fundamentalists are engaged in a struggle to oppose such liberties and impose their oppressive beliefs on the world. Their war is cultural and religious. That has been lost sight of as the fighting in Iraq has gained dominance in the headlines. It has shifted attention away from the threat of extreme Islam. Its aim was plain to all in the aftermath of 9/11. Now it tends to be forgotten as the war in Iraq worsens. The knighthood will not reinstate the war’s essential meaning, but it will remind people of the fundamental challenge tolerance faces.

And the Dominion Post on Friday says:

Readers worldwide would concur that there is plenty of room to debate the author’s style, his content, even his ability. So why is it that, when Muslim sensibilities are offended, adherents instead throng the streets to burn flags, destroy buildings and call for their fellows to strike someone dead? It smacks of ignoranceand bigotry. It also says that a frighten-ing number of fanatical Muslims still hanker after a worldwide caliphate, in which Sharia law prevails and apostates are dealt with cruelly. Most in the West, driven largely by a contest of ideas in which shibboleths are questioned, sacred cows slaughtered and demigods eventually found out, would not countenance such a scenario.

Tamihere on tug muscles

An amusing interview in the SST with John Tamihere. Some extracts:

He talked for a long while about “the middle-class capture of welfare programmes”, how he thought “private-public sector partnerships are absolutely essential to unlock the talent in this country”, and the necessity of raising teacher’s salaries “but the quid pro quo of that is that there has to be some performance measures. It’s just like state houses. They’re not a lifetime right. There’s only 60,000 of them. And you get into situations where there are four income earners in the place with a renter down the back! I know these sorts of things, because I’m in the community.”

Tamihere nails one of the flaws in the current housing policy.

Did he ever seriously entertain the chatter about becoming New Zealand’s first Maori Prime Minister? “No, never. Unlike some guys who… Like, there’s a little tug-muscle who stands for Otaki. Darren Hughes. And Clayton Cosgrove, too – from the time they’re 14, they’re destined. They know what they’re going to do. They’re fully focused.

Oh dear, I’m not quite sure what a tug-muscle is, but it doesn’t sound complimentary.

“I have the highest regard for Michael Cullen. Always will, regardless of what goes on. One, because he fascinates me with his intellectual rigour, secondly, his work acumen I found legendary, and thirdly, his door was always open to anyone in that caucus, and he would give you quality time. It wasn’t just – you know, my meetings with Maharey were just pointless!”

Indeed.

Mobile Termination Rates

TUANZ is quoted in the NZ Herald that in Australia the mobile termination rates have been cut to 9c a minute. This compares to NZ where they are 20c and it will take five years for them to get to 12c/14c for Telecom/Vodafone.

I recall that it is sometimes cheaper to call a landline in NZ from a cellphone in the UK than it is from a cellphone in NZ.

Rodney and Keith

The Herald on Sunday covers Keith Locke speaking at the ACT annual conference, on the topic of how you can disagree and still work together.

It’s a message I very much agree with. I enjoy working with people from vastly different political persuasions, on the issues we do have in common.

Nash vs Fairbrother

A war of words is underway in Napier where Stuart Nash is challenging incumbent Russell Fairbrother for the Labour nomination.

This is very rare in post Rogernomics Labour. Much more common in National with John Key, Judith Collins and John Carter all entering Parliament by winning the nomination off a sitting MP. Competition is good for the party, if not so much for incumbent MPs.

But in Napier, it seems pretty personal with Nash criticising Fairbrother like so:

“I don’t think Russell has shown the energy to win that back for Labour. It’s not because of his age. It is just that in the five years he has been there he has never shown the energy necessary to win that back.”

“My reaction is if it took five years and an election loss of a safe seat and me coming down to get you gee-ed up, then maybe you should have got gee-d up about five years ago.”

Key praises Clark and Peters!

O’Sullivan on Tranzrail

Both Lianne Dalziel and Winston Peters have spoken of forces who tried to stop the Securities Council action against Fay and Richwhite.

Fran O’Sullivan writes in the NZ Herald that evidence to support this claim should be put up, or at least details given to point investigators in the right direction. I agree.

In the Sounds

No more blogging today, and probably little over the weekend as I am down near Blenheim attending the 2007 Summer Sounds Symposium at The Vintners Retreat. Vodafone is only GPRS here so my connection is at 56K.

Looking forward to having a great weekend as the symposium has interesting topics and speakers, and a great range of participants.

sounds1.JPG

A photo taken this afternoon (and the sun is nicely out) of some the villas we are staying in.

sounds2.JPG

And a typical interior. Each has two large bedrooms with ensuites. Very pleasant for the reasonable price.

Are the parents 4real?

Pat and Sheena Wheaton are upset that DIA won’t allow them to call their son “4Real”.

They should in fact be delighted. DIA has saved them from being gruesomely stabbed to death by their son in 2020 when he turns 13 and he snaps after years of humiliation and abuse at school.

I recall similiar parental stupidity in the late 1980s when someone wanted to call their kid KZ7.

Aboriginal neglect

The NZ Herald has an AAP story on the unprecedented intervention by the Federal Government regarding the management of Aboriginal reserves in the Northern Territory.

There has literally been decades of neglect under the “banner” of self determination.

Howard is planning to ban alcohol and pornography on Aboriginal lands, due to their role in horrifiic child abuse in many Aboriginal communities. He is also bringing in welfare reforms dictating what one can spend welfare money on, and also linking it to children being educated. Also work for the dole to come in.

On the carrot side, there will be a programme of improving public housing.

Howard says:

“It is interventionist, it does push aside the role of the Territory to some degree. I accept that. But what matters more – the constitutional niceties or the care and protection of young children? We believe the latter is overwhelmingly more important.”

His moves have been welcomed by not only the Federal Labor Party but also the the National Indigenous Council.

Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows spoilers

Reuters reports that a hacker called Gabriel claims to have hacked a computer at Bloomsbury Publishing, and taken a copy of the seventh Harry Potter book – Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows.

Now the hacker may be making this up, so no way to know until you read the book. But for those who want to know what he claims is revealed, the info is over the break.
Continue reading »

Auckland Water Rates

NewstalkZB reports that an attempt to lower the Auckland water price increase from 9.1% to 5% failed by six votes to four.

So City Vision have a policy of reducing water rates, but given a chance to actually reduce water rates, they vote it down because they can’t find $6 million of savings or efficiencies in a $1billion organisation.

City Vision leader Cr Vern Walsh stated they need the money for Queen St and CBD upgrades – but they already are getting $144 million over the next 12 years from a special CBD targeted rate for this!

I think Auckland City Council and the VUWSA Executive could compete with each other for which has the most muppets on it.

The six Crs who voted for the higher water rates were

Mayor Dick Hubbard
Bruce Hucker (City Vision)
Vern Walsh (City Vision)
Richard Northey (Labour)
Neil Abel (City Vision)
Glenda Fryer (City Vision)

And the four who were defeated in asking for a reduction in water rates from 9.1% to 5%

Scott Milne (Citizens and Ratepayers)
Doug Armstrong (Citizens and Ratepayers)
Toni Millar (Citizens and Ratepayers)
Christine Caughey (Action Hobson)

Hone and the Dalai

Barry Soper was retelling to a few of us the story of how Hone Harawira took part in greeting the Dalai Lama. It’s so funny, I asked him to kindly send me a copy of his filing on it:

You’ve got to give it to the Maori Party’s Hone Harawira. If Luigi Peters is a political opportunist, as many think he is, then Hone’s the master at media manipulation.

It was The Dalai Lama’s day at Parliament yesterday. He was whizzed around the political parties whilst the leaders of the two main ones did a diplomatic dance.

So he made his way around the minors with the main event being one staged by Prissy peter Dunne in Parliament’s Grand Hall. Prissy Peter stood at the top of the Parliamentary steps for some considerable time, awaiting the Dalai’s arrival.

Hone had just been out for a run and inquired of journalists on his arrival back at Parliament what all the fuss was about. He was told the Dalai Lama was about to arrive and be greeted by the leader of United Future.

“Cool,” said Hone, “I’d like to meet him too,” and with that he scrambled up the steps in his gym shoes, track pants, T shirt and stood alongside Prissy Pete who shuffled sideways. But Hone stood his ground and as the prissy one descended the steps to welcome the Tibetan spiritual rock star, he stole the show bursting into a Maori welcome and even hongied the gentlemanly monk as he reached him near the top of the stairs.

Prissy Pete quickly grabbed one of The Dalai’s sacred hands, the other was about to be clutched by Parliament’s protocol officer. But like a gun slinger, Hone got there first and guided the monk to the masses.

InternetNZ Elections

Bradford wants voting age lowered to 16

Sue Bradford has announced she plans to submit a bill which would lower the age of voting from 18 to 16.

Yes you can’t trust a 16 year old with the decision whether or not they can buy a pie from the school tuckshop, but you should give them the vote!

This is part of a global Green push, no doubt motivated by self interest that much much more of their voters comes from younger voters. Greens are pushing for this in Australia, Austria, Netherlands and the UK.

But that does not mean it is necessarily a bad idea, just because the Greens are pushing it for selfish reasons. Let’s first take a look at the situation around the world:

Of the 223 countries I can find data on, 192 have a voting age of 18. 21 countries have an age from 19 to 25 (Uzbekistan).A total of ten countries have a voting age of under 18 – five at 16 and five at 17. They are:

16

Austria (from 1 July 2007)
Brazil
Cuba
Isle of Man
Nicaragua

17

East Timor
Indonesia
North Korea
Seychelles
Sudan

Now of course in several of those countries, voting is more symbolic than actual. cough North Korea cough.

So very few countries have an age of under 18, and Austria is the only OECD country which does. But should NZ?

I personally am a huge advocate of young people getting involved in politics and voting. I think it is great when young people take an interest in politics. I certainly started following politics at eight years old.

But I do not think there is a good case to lower the voting age to 16. At 16 most people are in their 5th form at school. Only a small minority show much interest in politics. Most are concerned with passing their exams and pretending they have had sex.

Sure one can argue for 16. You can also argue for 12? Or even eight? I mean at eight years old I had a view on who to vote for. All age restrictions are somewhat arbitrary. So the issue is, which age has the better justification?

At 16 most of your rights are only partial and need parental consent. You can have sex, and can leave school and home.

At 18 you have finished the full 13 years of school. At 18 you are no longer deemed a child under the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child. You can not bet at the TAB until 18. You can’t marry without parental consent until 18. Generally you can’t get a benefit until you are 18. You can’t buy cigarettes or alcohol until 18. You can’t rent a flat in your own name until 18. You can’t even operate a credit card or cheque account in your own name.

If the law says one can’t do all that until 18, I can’t see a case for saying one gets to vote. I supported the drinking age being the same as the voting age. If you lower the voting age to 18, then you should lower the drinking age, tobacco purchase age, gambling age etc etc. Does Sue Bradford think 16 year olds should be able to go to Casinos?

The Young Nationals have said that the voting age should remain 18, noting:

At the age of 18 we are deemed to have ‘come of age’ – that is when we can purchase alcohol, smoke and get married without consent. By that age the vast majority of young people are independent and ready to make an informed decision.

In comparison, the majority of 16 and 17 year olds are still dependent on their parents and in full-time education. To allow young people to vote at such a young age risks many casting their vote on a whim.

In that respect any move to introduce civics education into the national curriculum statements has merit.

Mr Patterson says that the Young Nationals have faith in the youth of New Zealand, but that Ms Bradford’s proposal is a step too far; “at 16 young people should be left to enjoy the twilight years of their childhood”

I think that sums it up nicely. The NZ Herald readers seem to agree. No Right Turn supports 16 though.

Forest & Bird double dating

The Royal Forest & Bird Protection Society of NZ have a bit of a green coup this weekend. They’ve got both the Prime Minister and the Leader of the Opposition addressing their AGM in Silverstream this weekend.

Helen fronts up on Saturday while John Key speaks at the end of the conference on Sunday.

I suspect once upon a day they may have struggled to get either leader, let alone both of them. Neither party wants to be seen as slack on the environment and conservation!

Incomes 2001 – 2006

Jordan highlights some census data showing how incomes have risen between the 2001 and 2006 censuses with the median income up 32%.

Now of course gross incomes have actually risen. There has been a reasonable level of economic growth.

But first of all one should note (which Jordan did do) that some of this is inflation, which was 13% over that period. So the real increase over five years was 16.8% or 3.4% a year. So in real terms median income went from $18,500 to $21,600 or a $3,100 increase.

Now out of interest what happened to personal income tax over that time? Oh it increased by 42.3% or $7.2 billion (total direct taxation went up 54%). Anyway personal taxation alone on average (and yes median is different but no data for that) went up by $2,300 per adult. Now that does not take account of inflation’s effect on taxation but likewise I have also not covered the fact people have been spending more than they earn, which would counter that somewhat

So yes incomes have gone up. That happens when you have economic growth. But both inflation and taxes have eaten up a reasonable chunk of that increase, so that the net real increase in income is not that huge for a five year period.

The Redistricting Game

In NZ electoral boundaries are set by the Representation Commission which mainly comprises of neutral civil servants, namely:

A District Court Judge as Chair
The Chief Electoral Officer
The Government Statistician
The Surveyor General
The Chairperson of the Local Government Commission (not strictly neutral but non voting)

Plus there are two political appointments by Parliament to represent the Government and the Opposition. Some criticise those roles, but I think it gives a dynamic to the deliberations which is useful, and they are clearly a minority.

It’s a system which works very well.

The United States is an example of a system which does not. This is not because they deliberately designed it that way, but is a consequence of being a Federal Government. The Census determines how many House Reps each State gets, and it is totally up to each state as to how they draw the boundaries. You can not pass a Federal Law appointing a panel of Judges to do it.

Now sadly in many States, they have it done by the State Legislature or a panel of State Reps. And for many decades they have gerrymandered the boundaries to the advantage of either the incumbent Federal MPs or the party which controls the State House. This is why generally 80% or so of House seats are not competitive (in NZ only 35% would be truly non competitive).

One can’t just blame the politicians for this. The Governator in California proposed that a panel of judges get to do the redistricting, but this was rejected massively by the voters. There was a very effective attack campaign against the proposal showing three senile Judges trying to draw boundaries and not even realising they were working on a map of Texas not California.

Anyway the House gerrymander is one of the bigger flaws in the US political system (which does have many positives). Now someone has put together an online Redistricting Game which allows you to try out your own gerrymanders. It’s great fun and almost addictive. I’ve managed to turn a Democratic seat into a Republican seat at both the basic and advanced levels, and also managed to create an entirely new seat with a Republican majority but also a 65% Cuban-American population so that it complies with the Voting Rights Act. One of the few restrictions on redistricting gerrymanders is the requirement an ethnic minority can’t be discriminated against by (for example) creating three seats where they are say a 25% minority in each seat, when a more logical seat would have them in a majority.

Hat Tip: No Right Turn

Bain to be retried

Does it matter?

National mid-year party

Delayed blogging today as I only got home at 2 am after National’s mid-year Caucus party. And didn’t even crash until 3 am as for some reason I thought ringing my friend Anna in Germany was a good thing to do at 2 am. Amazing what one thinks is a good idea after a few drinks.

As one can be expected it was a lively affair, despite the traditional Karaoke being replaced by a DJ/Jukebox. Still lots of dancing until the wee hours.

Very amusing chat with Green MP Keith Locke. Keith (who is probably the most left-wing MP in Parliament) proclaimed that he was attending because he wanted to be thought of as National’s 50th MP. Heh heh.

The place was packed. By the end of the night I had had my drink (sadly mainly red wine) spilt on me four times as people bumped into you. Luckily I was not wearing a white shirt. I also was responsible for one spillage onto someone else (sorry Rachel).

Was reminded by one friend that it was exactly four years ago at this party she met her now husband. That was one of the better parties!

As expected, I woke up late this morning and in the rush to get ready for TV cut myself shaving. Luckily the TVNZ makeup staff are very good at covering self mutilations!

Politically, had some interesting conversations, mainly with journalists around political management, or the lack of it from the Government. As I have often said, they were damn good at this up until a year or so ago.

But the 20 free hours of early childhood education fiasco is a prime example of what one can only call political incompetence. This should be an incredibly popular policy. They are spending something like $150 million to help working families with over a thousand dollars a year for their childcare costs. Yet somehow they have managed to turn it into a PR disaster.

They should be saying “No in some cases it doesn’t cover all the costs, but we’re damn proud that we have made a major contribution to helping working families, and a partial subsidy is a hell of a lot better than no subsidy at all”. But no, they keep playing semantic games trying to insist it is totally free for all parents, and they just piss off everyone – parents, ECEs, and the media. It’s not just an own goal, it’s what one journalist called the “Maharey reverse Midas touch”.

Chatted of course to a few National MPs also. Was pleased to see that while there was an air of optimism, there was no complacency at all. People know that as great as a 17% lead in the polls is, they only have a 5% to 7% lead over the non CR parties, and that is the clincher.

What I also found encouraging was the attitude (and I stress this is based on general chatting at over drinks, not a formal party position in anyway) that even if National was in a position to govern in its own right, many see the merit of trying to build as broad a Government as possible. I certainly support such an approach, because that can increase your longevity in Government.

Anyway a great night. A big thanks to all the staff who not only organised it but spent much of the evening passing around the large amount of food and drink. And even more pleasing I can report that there were savouries and sausage rolls, which no doubt the Government will soon be banning. The only thing missing was Cheerios!

Electoral Funding Symposium

Spent all day Friday up at Victoria University attending a symposium on electoral funding put on by Transparency International and the VUW Institute of Policy Studies.

I enjoyed asking Transparency International, when they asked people to consider supporting their work, if they accept anonymous donations 🙂

Overall I found it a pretty balanced day. Most of the people there probably regard money in politics as evil and something to be heavily regulated, but there was a surprisingly healthy diversity of views. One participant pointed out how the US is arguably the most heavily regulated in the world, yet the one most influenced by money. By restricting donations to parties and candidates, the money just flowed instead to advocacy groups.

We also had two Speakers there – Margaret WIlson and Doug Kidd.

The Chief Executive of the Electoral Commission, Helena Catt, talked about (amongst many things) how the Electoral Act was still basically a FPP document, modified for MMP. This is very much the case with electorate candidates who break the Act able to lose their seats, but no penalties at all for parties which break the Act. I suggested that one option was to give the Electoral Commission the power to deduct votes from a party’s result, for the most serious and flagrant breaches of the Act. On balance I think this would be giving the Commission too much power, but at present they have none against parties – only against individuals.

Dr Joo Cheong Tham from the University of Melbourne spoke on Australian laws. He made a useful point that one should be debating political financing as a whole, not just party funding or campaign funding.

Andrew Geddis from Otago University (Trevor Loudon has an SAP on him) did a pretty comprehensive presentation on issues within the current law. He was with Steven Price of the Coalition for Open Government. Andrew did not propose his own answers, but did very well in covering all the questions.

Both agreed with me that the current restriction on parties being unable to buy their own broadcasting should be abolished, and broadcasting spending should just be included in a party’s overall expenditure limit (which would need to increase to reflect that).

Former National General Manager Steven Joyce spoke. He supported ending anonymous donations over the disclosure limit (mainly because then people couldn’t scare monger about the sources of funding). He also made the point that for those people who think people can “buy” policies, he’s never found anything able to compete with an MP’s own belief in the value of their own ideas and proposals. Heh very true. He said if you have state funding it should not be based just on the votes at the previous election as this may always advantage the incumbent Government, but it should be done like the Electoral Commission does broadcasting allocations – looking at current polling support also.

Steven though the current level of $10,000 for disclosure was fine. He also made a pretty vital point that future campaigns may be fought on You Tube by supporters as much by parties through ad buys, and all this regulation may get overtaken by technology.

Richard Northey, a former Labour MP (and party presidential candidate) had a somewhat strange presentation. He praised the performance of NZ Post in running the Electoral Enrolment Centre but was critical of The “Justice Department” for the operations of the Chief Electoral Office and Returning Officers. So his solution was to transfer the Chief Electoral Office to NZ Post. Yes he seriously advocated the a commercial trading enterprise should be in charge of running our electoral system. Would be amusing if we ever sell NZ Post one day – NZ would have its first privately owned electoral system!

But his real bombshell was as he explained his idea of an anonymous donation. He explained it is where a businessman hands you a large cheque and says “I wish to be anonymous”. This of course is a totally illegal practice, if correctly described, and the lawyers in the room were stunned. Mike Williams looked very unimpressed with Cr Northey. Northey also supported the Labour line on having spending limits apply for all of election year (something I regard as a hideous attack on freedom of speech). Oh yes he also misunderstood the role of the Auditor-General and the Electoral Act.

I won’t cover all the Party Presidents, as No Right Turn has done this so well. I agree with him the Maori Party President was rambling and useless (on this issue).

ACT’s Gary Mallett was pretty controversial for saying he regarded it as a bad thing to even be discussing limits. He did have useful points (also made by Bryce Edwards) that the amount of money a party spends has remarkably little (but some) effect on their vote.

National’s Judy Kirk made a point often overlooked by those who think all parties are funded from large corporate donations. She said National’s membership fully funded the party’s operating expenses (not campaign expenses), and even put a price on them of $4.2 million over three years. She also said membership was at a 17 year high. I have stated this many times – National gets most of its money from the tens of thousands of members and supporters who donate a relatively modest amount. The amount of large (declared) donations over the last three years was only $2.38 million which all goes to the campaign.

Labour’s Mike Williams spoke in favour of restricting third party advertising, such as that by the Exclusive Brethren. I asked him whether he would also support much higher penalties for Electoral Act breaches, such as the $1 million maximum fine proposed by the Campaign for Open Government. I was delighted that he replied yes, and hope that the Government’s bill will include proper penalties for Electoral Act breaches.

No Right Turn also covers the earlier speakers. What was amusing was the number of people who came up to me asking who was No Right Turn, as he was registered under his real name, and they wanted to meet him.

There are certain issues, ‘almost’ everyone seems to agree on. They are:

* Banning anonymous and trust donations (over the disclosable level)
* Higher penalties for breaches of the Electoral Act
* Having parties as well as individuals liable under the law
* Increasing the cap for electorate candidates
* Having the broadcasting limit incorporated into the overall spending limit
* Simplifying the number of agencies involved with elections and complaints
* Better transparency on third party campaigns

Issues on which there were significant disagreement:

* Greater public funding of parties
* The level at which donations need to be disclosed (views range from $500 to $10,000)
* The level of the spending cap for parties
* The period of time the cap should apply for
* Whether third parties should have spending caps, and how much
* Whether negative campaigns by third parties should be allowed
* How changes to electoral law should be consulted on (most were critical of Govt’s actions to date)

I’ve probably missed a few. Anyway a very worthwhile day and kudos to the organisers. The real shame was that the Government has not yet released their proposed bill – that was meant to be the focal point of the debate. I guess they have not stitched up the numbers for it yet.

New definitions of “free”

The “20 free hours” early childhood policy is a perfect example of why people are cynical. Labour keeps claiming that parents can get 20 free hours. A National MP pointed out that if McDonalds used “free” in the way Labour does, they would claim to be have free hamburgers, but a $3 charge for the cardboard box. Absolutely.

The latest novel interpretation of free is to have an early childhood centre require parents to enrol for a minimum of seven hours a day, as the “free” hours are for a maximum of six per day. And to use that seventh hour to charge a fee to make up for the funding shortfall for the other six hours.

If the Government told the truth and said that the 20 hours are not free, but heavily subsidised, they would probably get plaudits for that. Because the subsidy will help many parents. But their insistence on continuing with Orwellian definitions means that their credibility just gets hammered. Stupid, stupid, stupid.

Stupid zoning policies

I went to Island Bay Primary School for six years. It was a great school and I had a great time there being a goody goody who was not just bell monitor, but tuckshop supervisor, road crossing person, assistant teacher with the primers etc etc.

Anyway it seems to still be a great school, because more and more parents want their kids to attend. But alas out centrally controlled education system can’t allow a school to become popular and keep expanding its size, if there are other schools with capacity. Nope parents can’t have a choice – they must be sent to the other school.

So the Ministry of Education is going to shrink the Island Bay school zone. Mothers like Leonie Wilson who are fifth generation Island Bay will not be guaranteed to be able to have her two year old attend Island Bay Primary along with her older sister.

Island Bay Primary School has the space for extra classrooms. It should be allowed to expand, rather than force local kids to go to other schools.