I got a crush on Obama

National on ACC

Jordan condemns National’s policy to reintroduce competition into the provision of accident compensation insurance as “destroying the ACC system”.

I’ve never worked out how one form of insurance (accident compensation) is so different from medical insurance, car insurance, contents insurance etc etc.

Jordan claims:

“The reason ACC works is because it shares the cost of risk across the whole of society. If one allows private firms to cherry pick low risk claimants, one ends up with a residual, expensive public scheme that can’t afford decent provision for those who need it most.”

This shows a total lack of comprehension over how providing choice of provider works. Firms can not pick individual claimants. Individual employers (not claimants) are simply able to get quotes from companies other than ACC for their accident insurance provisions. Such policies must be for the same level of cover as ACC currently providers.

McCarten on polls

Matt McCarten makes the very valid point that the most important gap is not the one between National and Labour, but between National and Labour/Greens which is only a single figure lead.

He is right.

National can not assume that any party except ACT will choose them over Labour. Well Future NZ will but their chances seem bleak with no electorate seat. A Labour/Green/Progressive/Maori coalition is quite likely and one may even have a Labour/Green/Progressive/Maori/NZ First grouping to overcome.

However the National Labour gap is not without some relevance and use. Take the example results below:

National 46% 55
Labour 30% 36
Maori 4% 5
ACT 2% 2
NZ First 5% 7
United Future 2% 2
Green 10% 12
Progressive 1% 1

Now in theory National might not get to form a Government. National/ACT/United Future is 59 seats. Labour could do Labour/Maori/NZ First/Green/Progressive with 61 seats.

But think about the public reaction if the party on 30% gets to form a Government instead of the party on 46%. I would say there would be a huge backlash against MMP.

Parties like the Maori Party or NZ First might prefer to do a deal with Labour, but may realise that the party with 14% more of the vote should get to form the Government and will support that party, even though not their first choice. It’s one thing to choose the smaller party when the gap is only 2% or even 6%, but if the gap is huge, it will have some effect.

So McCarten is right that the key gap is between the centre-right and the centre-left. But the National/Labour gap also is of some importance.

Anti-spam law

Lawyer Fiona Campbell gives advice in the Herald on Sunday on the new anti-spam legislation which comes into force on 5 September.

Fiona reminds us that the law applies to not just e-mail spam but text (SMS) and IM spam (or spim). By coincidence I just complained to Telecom this morning about text spam I was getting from 4162 that kept asking me to ask Zoltar a wish which would have then had me paying them $5 a message. I look forward to being able to prosecute such bastard scammers in the future.

The Department of Internal Affairs is the agency with enforcement powers under the Act, and for the last few months have been establishing and hiring staff for the unit. I’ve been on the steering committee (in my InternetNZ role) overseeing this, and have been really impressed with how they operate, putting together project plans, comms plans, risk registers, IT requirements for the new unit. It’s been extremely well managed. A big focus in upcoming months will be on education and outreach – especially to businesses to explain how the Act works.

My only disappointment is that ritual dismemberment is not on the list of available penalties for spammers.

Students and KiwiSaver

Michael Littlewood looks at the pros and cons of KiwiSaver.

He had one suggestion which was novel I thought. Students should max out their interest free loans, and stick it into Kiwisaver. They’ll get tax credits for it, and get a return on the money the taxpayer has lent them.

Littlewood also picks up the point I have bene making about how KiwiSaver will affect National Super in the future:

However, the biggest issue concerns New Zealand Superannuation’s future. The Government says NZ Super will be unaffected. Really?

On reasonable assumptions, a KiwiSaver on the national average wage for 40 years will end up with about $320,000 in today’s money. That’s the annuity equivalent (for a male at 65) of about $22,000 a year after-tax for life (inflation-proofed). Of that, about 33 per cent has come from taxpayers. Using today’s NZ Super, our KiwiSaver’s total income will be $36,407 a year or 105 per cent of after-tax, pre-retirement pay.

Future governments could say taxpayers have helped pay for the KiwiSaver nest egg so why should the full NZ Super be paid?

An interesting calculating that the average person will have a higher income in retirement than they have had while working, with the combination of KiwiSaver and NZ Super. This I suggest makes it a near certainty that NZ Super will be changed in years to come – either converted fully into KiwiSaver, or means tested, or modified to an inflation linked benefit instead of wage linked benefit.

Nothing beats foreign affairs for PMs

If I was a conspiracy theorist nut I would be tempted to think the PM arranged for the mad Commodore to expel our High Commissioner. Because a PM likes nothing more than dominating the news on foreign affairs, which most NZers are united on.

This applies not just to the current PM. I remember being in Government and that everytime the PM headed overseas for some diplomacy, the polls would rise. Unless someone was mucking things up back home.

Anyway she seems to enjoy beating up the Commodore even more than she does Mercury Energy. A target with far more potential over time!

KiwiSaver Fee Comparisons

Gareth Morgan has a useful site which allows you to compare the fees changed by various KiwiSaver providers. He is a provider himself but the site has been independently audited.

Of course fees are only one aspect of choosing a provider. The tract record on average returns is more important to me.

Ihug Mail

A frustrating day yesterday without e-mail. The Herald reports on the unhappy customers.

What was unusual is that it was not just a case of being unable to download e-mail. One couldn’t even use webmail to see what was there. And once the problem was fixed, I ended up getting around six copies of the delayed e-mails.

Grrrr.

High risk and violent but on home detention

Home detention is a useful corrections tool. And inevitably some people placed on it will abuse the privilege (which it is).

But why,oh why, would you put on home detention a man who was assessed to be at high risk of reoffending, and had a violent past.

Amusing that Paris Hilton can’t get home detention, yet violent likely to reoffend prisoners in NZ can.

New City Vision leader also supports water fee increases

How confusing.

City Vision roll Bruce Hucker as their leader because he supports increases in the fees for water. They replace him with Vern Walsh.

Today Vern Walsh confirms he also supports the fee increases.

What the hell is in the water up there.

The Herald also can’t work out what City Vision is doing.

Fiji gets worse … again …

Some promising sounds have been made about Fiji returning to democracy and having elections, but one has to judge them on actions, not words, and it is all dismal.

The expulsion of the NZ High Commissioner (an incredibly serious thing to do to a Government) comes on top of killings, beatings, and attacks on freedom of speech. The Commodore is quite insane and I don’t see any path out of the disaster he is heading towards.

Journalist Barry Soper broke the story this morning, and told us during the segment we do with Willie Jackson on Good Morning that it really seems a major factor was the Commodore feeling slighted at a rugby game. Normally you would laugh and say it couldn’t be, but we are not dealing with someone with a full deck of cards.

Our sanctions are still pretty half hearted. We should pull in favours with the US and UK to get the Security Council to resolve to stop using Fijian peacekeepers. If you do that, I predict within three months the Commodore’s poor and starving troops will be handing him over to be arrested.

Now 49 all

Labour and National now both command 49 votes in Parliament with Gordon Copeland giving his proxy vote to National on everything bar supply and confidence.

What Copeland has done goes well beyond what is normally involved with giving a party your proxy vote. He has effectively said he wants to be treated as the 49th member of National’s Caucus (not that he will be attending meetings).

Normally if an Independent MP gives a party his proxy vote, he or she still claims discretion as to how it is cast. For example Labour has Field’s proxy vote, but he tells them how to cast it for him. Only if he does not say, do they cast it as they see best.

But Copeland has effectively said he will be bound by decisions of National’s Caucus on all non confidence and supply issues. That is not something I can recall being done before by someone not a member of said Caucus.

In the end it seems to be branding. Copeland hopes that Future NZ can attract 5% support as a conservative Christian coalition partner to National (which has heathen liberals like myself :-). He wants there to be no ambiguity about what party Future NZ would support.

Future NZ would certainly be a much more moderate or acceptable partner than the Christian Coalition was in 1996, or Destiny Church would be ever ever ever, but personally I hope the National Caucus never has to make compromises along the lines of “Party X will vote for the budget, if we agree to promote chastity instead of sex education”. But in the end it is up to the public – if they put a party in Parliament, one has to work with whatever the numbers are.

In terms of my list of preferred coalition partners for National, where would Future NZ be:

1 ACT
2 United Future
3 NZ First (without Winston)
4 Maori
5 Future NZ
6 Greens
7 Labour
8 NZ First (with Winston)
9 Progressive
10 Destiny

Green logic

Russel Norman is upset with Katherine Rich for opposing the food police. He says:

Does the National Party think its ok to use the state to force parents to send their children to an institution that then feeds them food that is bad for their health? Or are they now in favour of making school voluntary because it is too nanny state-ish to force parents to send their kids to school?

My response:

1) It is only compulsory to attend classes at school, it is not compulsory to buy food from the school tuckshop. Not even NCEA has credits for this activity yet.

2) Even if it was compulsory to buy food from the tuckshop, kids can choose from the variety for sale.

3) Very few foods are intrinsically unhealthy in moderation. A student might bring his or her own sandwiches and fruit lunch to school 19 out of 20 days, but once a month want to buy a pie. A pie a month is not unhealthy. A pie a day probably is.

Race based seats survive

Instinctively I don’t like electoral systems where participation is divided up on grounds of race. Fiji gives a good example of the perils from that approach.

However I can understand (even if not agreeing) why some people are reluctant to remove the Maori seats in Parliament. Taking something away unilaterally, after 100 years of having them, can cause resentment. Nevertheless I hope one day we will do as the Royal Commission recommended and abolish them, instead lowering the threshold for party representation. It would be preferable this is done with widespread consensus.

However what I can’t understand is why on earth Labour decided to introduce further race based seats at local government level. It was not a step in the right direction in my opinion. While well intentioned, such seats can only become divisive over time. Where does it end?

So it was disappointing that Tony Ryall’s Local Electoral (Repeal of Race-Based Representation) Amendment Bill failed its first reading last night by 56-62. One can only be amused that No Right Turn labels a bill to repeal race based local body seats as “bad, racist legislation”. No, that’s the current law.

The vote on the bill was:

For 56

National 48
NZ First 7
Copeland 1

Against 62

Labour 49
Green 6
Maori 3
Disunited Future 2
Progressive 1
Field 1

If United Future had voted in favour (which I am sure 95% of their voters would have wanted them to) and ACT had voted, it would have survived to select committee. People should make sure they ask United Future candidates why they support race based seats for local bodies.

Classic

Transtasman reports the following House exchange:

Clayton Cosgrove’s tortured attempts to pronounce Chris Auchinvole’s name in Parliament on Tuesday night caused the National Party MP to take a point of order. “It’s an old Scottish name of Gaelic origin and it’s OCK IN VOLE. You can rhyme that with whatever you like.”……

Heh heh. You have to love West Coasters!

Causes of Inflation

consumption.JPG

An interesting press release from Bill English yesterday which had the graph above attached to it.

Since 2004, when the Reserve Bank started raising the official cash rate. the growth in private sector consumption has noticeably declined. While growth in public sector consumption has remained high at close to 5%.

In some ways this is no surprise. Higher interest rates do affect the private sector. However if inflation is pushing people wages up, it increases the Government’s tax take, and the Government just keeps spending more and more. In fact now the Government has no net debt, the higher interest rates are, the more money it makes.

Prebble on Mercury

Richard Prebble asks some hard questions regarding Mercury Energy:

I see some suggestions that Mercury Energy is privatised. An understandable mistake. No one watching Helen Clark on TV attacking the company would realise that her Government via Mighty River Power is the owner.

The State Owned Enterprises Act empowers the Government to order the SOE not to cut off the power. The media might ask why Cabinet is not considering this.

We know the answer.

The law requires the Government to compensate the SOE for the cost of any directive. Cabinet is willing to pass a regulation putting the cost on consumers who do pay their bills, but would not think of putting the cost on to its budget.

A better question is why are publicly owned companies less responsible than private?

I think the reason is that a private company could not afford the bad headlines Mercury has received around the world. Mighty River’s share price will not fall because it does not have any.

As minister I found state businesses were prepared to take risks that no private company would take because management knew that their owner had bottomless pockets and could, if necessary, just change the law.

Helen Clark has also not mentioned in her attacks on Mercury Energy that Cabinet has been demanding dividends above what the directors recommend. When your owner is screwing you for every cent, no wonder the company is hard on non-payers.

The directors should have asked questions about the company’s disconnection policy. They would have discovered that Mercury had ignored advice to change its disconnection policy.

An examination of the board reveals an ex-archbishop and directors who appear to be there for politics, gender and race, rather than for their commercial experience. Helen Clark might apologise to the Muliaga family for her political appointments.

It appears the failure of the SOEs is not just that they are less socially responsible than the private companies. They are also less commercially successful. A study by Treasury found the private power companies are out-performing the Government-owned.

Just saying the private sector is better does not explain what has been going wrong. When they began, the SOEs were very successful, outperforming the stock exchange average. We have lost something.

There is something wrong in the culture of Mercury Energy. The company’s initial response was to deny any responsibility. Refusal to accept responsibility is always a sign of a poor culture. Part of a successful culture is fronting up to mistakes and taking responsibility.

If Helen Clark won’t admit as owner she has some responsibility why should anyone else admit to any? Indeed, why would anyone successful in business be an SOE director when Helen Clark publicly snubbed the representatives of Mercury Energy outside the Muliaga home?

They say there are no bad dogs, just bad owners. It is not the SOE model that has failed, just its owner.

The howls of outrage can now begin …

Dom Post on Corrections

Today’s editorial pulls few punches:

It is hard to imagine how the ombudsmen’s investigation into prisoner transport could have been more damning.

Corrections Minister Damien O’Connor is said to be alarmed to find out that standards drawn up in 2004 for the safe transport of prisoners had not been introduced. Instead, they were eventually dropped because they were impossible to meet. However, that does not appear to have stopped the department previously giving the ombudsmen the impression that the standards were being implemented, something that has left them “most disturbed”.

At worst, that means the department misled the ombudsmen. At best, it means its communications were inept. Neither proposition is acceptable. What is clear is that the department is dysfunctional.

Worse, there is little reason for the public to have confidence for believing that Mr O’Connor and corrections chief executive Barry Matthews are the right men to fix things. They are responsible for a department that has failed time and again. The time for tolerating those failings is long past. Both men should consider themselves on notice.

I think it is beyond being on notice. That might have been the case two years ago but nothing has improved.

Will Clark meet the Dalai Lama?

NZ of late has not had a great record in standing up to pressure from China. Journalists have been evicted from Parliament, Mayors have stayed away from cultural shows the Chinese Government doesn’t like.

Now the latest challenge is the visit of the Dalai Lama. Will the Prime Minister allow the Chinese Government to dictate who she does or does not meet?

City Vision starts to implode

City Vision in Auckland seems to be imploding. Last night they rolled Bruce Hucker as the leader of the City Vision ticket. He remains Deputy Mayor though.

But get who they have replaced Hucker with? Richard Northey and Vern Walsh. Now what is Cr Walsh most known for?

aklbb2.JPG

Maybe if they were more careful with their spending, then Dr Hucker wouldn’t have needed to try and put water charges up so much to cover the spending.

Bloody subs

If I see a headline of “Row over abortion committee” I expect it to be reporting on some big argument that has happened.

Instead it merely reports that today there will be a nomination for membership of the Abortion Supervisory Committee, and an MP is proposing an alternate member to the Government’s.

Hardly a row, and definitely not past tense.

A gay bomb

Hilarious. No Right Turn has the news about how in 1994 the USAF sought funding for a bomb which would “cause enemy soldiers to become gay, and to have their units break down because all their soldiers became irresistibly attractive to one another”

Think if that bomb had been developed. Think if it got dropped on an all female university hostel. Think of the merchandising rights 🙂

Ski Holidays

Scott Adams on Rational Evil

Another interesting post from Scott Adams:

I used to think America needed to change its foreign policy if it had any hope of ending terrorism. That sort of opinion is never better than a reasonable guess about what is most likely. But it seemed to me that even terrorists have specific objectives, and if they achieve those objectives, they stop terrorizing.

My thinking was that the terrorists were asking for things we’d be better off giving them anyway, for our own selfish reasons. For example, Israel is strong enough and wealthy enough to no longer need our support. And it’s unclear that our heavy footprint in the Middle East is guaranteeing us more oil and less terrorism. It seemed like a win-win scenario to give the terrorists what they were asking for, since the only impact on us is saving some money. Or at least it would save me from transferring my wealth to the pockets of U.S. military industries.

Recently I changed my opinion. While I think there was a period in the past when a different foreign policy would have brought us to a different point, we don’t have a time machine. We are where we are. And where we are is totally fucked.

The problem is with the loose cell structure of Al-Qaeda, and the fact it has become a lifestyle for its members. If we remove all the original reasons for Al-Qaeda’s existence, I believe they would find new ones. It is unlikely the members of terror cells would decide to quit and become insurance salesmen.

While the cell structure of Al-Qaeda is an excellent way to wage war, it’s a bad way to stop a war. If all the existing cells around the world made lists of their reasons for being terrorists, and compared those lists, I think they’d look very different except for the parts about hating Israel and the United States. If the leadership of Al-Qaeda told its cells to disarm, half of the cells would just splinter off and keep on terrorizing. It’s permawar.

This leads me to Israel. I used to think Israel was making a mistake to occupy disputed land and give their enemies more reasons to attack and fewer reasons to make peace. Again, perhaps if we had a time machine there was a period in history where that was true. But we’re long past that. Now I believe there is sufficient perpetual hatred against Israel that it would be irrational for them to offer any concessions.

Sadly Adams may be right. I still think that one has to try, and have Israel return to its pre 1967 borders, but I suspect the terrorist attacks will in no way abate, once this happens.

Kill the Cows!

A while ago I joked that if NZ was to get serious about carbon neutrality, we should simply start shooting all the cows,

To my surprise, my joke has become near official policy of the Greens, and of No Right Turn.

They are both critical of plans for the dairy industry to grow by 4% a year, as this will probably lead to increased carbon emissions.

So from this I can only assume that if technology can’t decrease the average emissions per cow, they favour killing off the cows in order to reduce emissions.

Why is this such a stupid thing to do? Well its stupid both economically and environmentally.

Economically, artificially restricting out major source of export income is just going to make us all poorer.

But environmentally, it’s damn silly also. Because even if we decided to get out of the dairy industry all together and shot all our cows, this wouldn’t magically stop the demand for dairy products and beef and lamb etc. So what would happen is other countries would increase their dairy/cattle production. And it’s likely, as our industry is relatively efficient, that total emissions would increase even faster.

I must be careful about joking on this blog in future – more of my jokes may end up as Green party policy!!