Watch NRT explode

Star Wars is 30

Tamaki wants non Christian immigrants restricted

I probably shouldn’t give him the space for his rants, but Archbishop Tamaki is saying members of other faiths should not be able to enter New Zealand unless they conform to certain standards and that their religions should not be regarded as equal to Christianity.

While there are some legitimate issues about extreme Islam and immigration, Tamaki is wanting to impose his version of NZ on everyone else.

I wonder if he also thinks atheists should be banned from entering NZ? Because they are probably a bigger threat to Christianity than the Buddhists!

A fight for civilisation itself

Lucyna declares that the attempt by the Catholic Bishop’s to get Southpark banned is a “fight for civilisation itself”.

It is, for without free speech we don’t have civilisation. The Bishops are trying to pull our civilisation down and pull us back to the dark ages. But to be fair thy are doing so within an established legal framework.

In fact Lucyna points to this by wistfully noting that “100 years ago the reaction would be far more aggressive than that of the Catholic Bishops today”.

Well indeed the world was so much more civilised 100 years ago. In most countries women did not have the vote.

Key does Wikinews interview

Blogging and PR

Police plan to charge Field with 14 counts of bribery

The Police have confirmed that they intend to charge former Labour Minister and MP Taito Phillip Field with 14 charges of bribery, relating to actions he took as a Labour MP.

They need the permission of the High Court to lay the charges under Section 103 of the Crimes Act. While I won’t make any prediction as to the outcome of any trial, I suspect it is highly unlikely the Police will not gain the Court’s permission to proceed to trial.

This is a very black day in the history of the NZ Parliament. Donna Awatere-Huata was enough of a black mark for facing fraud charges while an MP, but at least her fraudulant activities were primarily in her private capacity. Field is being charged over actions he took in his role as an MP. This is a new low.

Field must of course have his day in court, before one can proclaim guilt or innocence. But the charges confirm how serious this is and we already know his actions were grossly unethical, and that he lied to the Ingram Inquiry.

At this point in time, we should remind ourselves oh what our Prime Minister and Deputy Prime Minister said in defence of Mr Field.

On the 14th of September, in an attempt to bury the issue before the election, Clark said:

“I think the only thing he is probably guilty of is trying to be helpful to someone.”

Even worse is Michael Cullen. For at least Clark made her defence before the Ingram Report. But here is what Dr Cullen said *after* the Ingram Report came out, which was damning of Field:

So Mr Field has some matters to work through with the Labour leadership and the Labour whips. But he works incredibly hard on behalf of his constituents. He has people coming to him from all over Auckland for assistance, not just in immigration cases but in many other cases. He works harder on those matters than I suspect the entire National Party caucus does on constituency cases. If that is what he is guilty of, then I am sure he is happy to plead guilty to working hard on behalf of his constituents.

And of course as we all know, Clark set up the Ingram Inquiry with such a narrow terms of reference and such incredibly limited powers, that it was designed to fail.

And finally remember that Field was kicked out of the Labour Party not because he had shamed the NZ Parliament, not because he exploited vulnerable workers, not because he lied to the Ingram Inquiry, not because he behaved disgracefully, and not because he may be corrupt. He was kicked out for musing openly on the possibility of not standing for Labour.

Clark and Cullen tolerated the stench of corruption because they needed his vote. If Field is found guilty, it will be a shared verdict.

Decision on Taito Phillip Field announced at 10 am

The Police will announce their decision on whether to charge Taito Phillip Field at 10 am. I’m in a conference until around 1 pm NZST so suggest people check out the comments thread for what the decision was.

I’ve long maintained that I thought the actions of Field were highly unethical and disgraceful in his role as an MP, but that this does not necessarily mean he broke the law.

As an example it would be totally legal and ethical for a private citizen such as me to help people with immigration problems and work out a deal in exchange where they do some free work on one of my houses.

Now if it is an MP, it becomes at a minimum highly unethical, people there is a long standing public expectation that MPs help constituents without charging them for services. That is why they get a salary. But is it necessarily illegal? I haven’t thought so. But I wait the announcement with great interest.

The media speculation is that Field will be charged. But we’ll know for sure at 10 am.

A tribute to Communism

This five minute video is a good reminder of the evils of communism. It ignores the rhetoric and shows us that countries with all-powerful states, always end up with all-powerful supreme leaders. Repressive leadership is not an accidental by-product of communism, but a natural consequence.

The video has footage of the states that built walls with armed guards to stop their citizens from leaving, how in 1932 Stalin seized all food from the Ukraine for the collective good. Seven million Ukranians died – 25% of their population. Mao’s planned economy was even worse.

Just as we should never forget the Holocaust, likewise we should never forget the evils of communism.

What if we abolished the 5% threshold?

In the thread on Destiny, someone asserted that Destiny should be represented in Parliament as they got enough votes for one MP (they did not make the 5% threshold).

This got me wondering about what the Parliaments would have looked like, if the 5% threshold had been abolished. Working backwards:

2005

Labour 50
National 47
NZ First 7
Greens 6
Maori 4 (3 + 1 overhang))
United Future 3
ACT 2
Progressive 1
Destiny 1

Likely Govt: Still Lab/Prog/NZF/UFNZ = 61/121

2002

Labour 49
National 25
NZ First 12
ACT 9
Greens 8
United Future 8
Progressive 2
Christian Heritage 2
Outdoor Rec 2
Alliance 2
Legalise Cannabis 1

Likely Govt would be Labour/Prog/Greens/Alliance = 61/120

1999

Labour 48
National 37
Alliance 9
ACT 9
Greens 6
NZ First 5
Christian Heritage 3
Future NZ 1
Legalise Cannabis 1
United 1

Likely Govt would be Labour/Alliance/Greens = 63/120

1996

National 42
Labour 35
Alliance 12
ACT 7
NZ First 16
Christian Coalition 5
Legalise Cannabis 2
United 1

Likely Govt would have been National/NZ First/ACT 65/120 or National/NZ First/Christian Coalition = 63/120. A Labour/NZ First/Alliance Govt of 63/120 is a possibility also as the chance of only a two party Government with National no longer exists.

Where did the $4b go?

The NZ Herald reports on how the Minister of Health struggled to say what improvements in health we have had for the extra $4 billion a year he spends in the portfolio.

Hodgson did try and claim credit for decreasing infant mortality and increasing life expectancy, but these are trends which have been in place for over 20 years, and If I recall correctly, the rates of decrease and increase have actually slowed down in the last few years.

Stupid NZ Herald Editorial

I do wish sometimes the leader writer/s at the NZ Herald would think about what they write.

Today’s editorial is called “Don’t mix politics and super” and basically it calls for National to commit to the terms of Kiwisaver by 1 July. Now I don’t necessairly disagree with the conclusion, but it’s this line I have to take umbrage with:

Let’s put superannuation savings beyond political opportunism once and for all.

Hello, What do you call the changes Labour has made, without consultation, but naked political opportunism?

Let’s be in no doubt. The changes to Kiwi Saver are radical and major. They shatter the consensus that did exist on superannuation. They seriously undermine the argument for the Cullen Fund and universal wage indexed non means tested superannuation at age 65.

So the gall of demanding that National sign up to them in a matter of weeks, on the grounds that superannuation savings should be beyond political opportunism, is just staggering.

Personally I prefer political parties not to make policy up on the hoof.

As it happens I actually think National should retain most of the details of Kiwi Saver. It is de facto compulsory private savings and over time will replace public super as the major source of retirement income. This will allow the Cullen Fund to be converted into individual savings accounts in a decade or so. In fact NZ First and ACT have already come out advocating this.

Earning $60,000

As most people know the percentage of adults who are subject to the 39% envy tax has increased from 5% to 14%. And the latest Stats NZ data tells us why.

The following classes of employees have average earnings of greater than $50,000 (which means a significant proportion would be over $60K).

* Mining
* Electricity, Gas & Water
* Wholesale Trade
* Transport & Storage
* Finance & Insurance
* Property & Business Services
* Govt Admin
* Education

Final Super 14 Rankings

Well the Super 14 is all over. No NZ team in the final of course which was disappointing.

91 people were in the NZ Bloggers challenge. I was in 13th= place with 410 points. The top ten were:

1 dj_krysus Mark Montgomerie 444 610
2 graemet G T 435 1675
3 TheEdge Graeme Edgeler 427 3756
3 Whale-Oil Whale Oil 427 3756
5 click_here MATT Not telling 421 6462
6 Budgieboy Brian Burgess 420 7060
7 pandasport Andrew Thompson 419 7632
8 Span Span . 417 8878
9 otagomatt06 Matt Porteous 416 9569
10 nicgavstar Nick Gavey 413 11876

Well done those people.

The Christian Vote

Destiny NZ is claiming they may make Parliament as they are outpolling Progressive in the polls. Well yes St Jim does only have 0.1% support but he holds and electorate seat. Destiny also claims they were the highest polling party not to make Parliament.

This is true in that they were in 9th place with 0.62%. But that is a long way from 5%.

Now what were all the Christian based party votes last election:

United Future 2.67%
Destiny 0.62%
Christian Heritage 0.12%
NZ Family Rights 0.05%

That is a total of 3.46%. And I doubt all the United Future vote as a Christian vote. So the chance of either Destiny or Future NZ making it next time is basically nil.

DPF

Great VSM News

This is excellent news.

Australian Labour has put freedom ahead of self interest and said it will not overturn, if elected, voluntary membership of student associations.

Australian student associations used to forcibly collect $155 million a year from students. Even in NZ the combined budget of the student associations is several times larger than the Business Roundtable.

Aussie Labor is looking at a charge, funded by loans, for student facilities and services. This could be a backdoor attempt, but it’s still a welcome step forward.

Ironically I was meeting some people on Sunday to discuss VSM, with Heather Roy having a private member’s bill “in the ballot” to bring this fully in here. National supported VSM in the late 90s and I hope they will do so again, when in office.

Hat Tip: Back in 15

Mike Moore on Australia vs NZ

Former Labour Prime Minister, and WTO Director-General, Mike Moore, talks about why so many Kiwis are moving to Australia. Some of his key points:

* 100 Kiwis a day leaving to Australia
* In OECD ratings Australia has gone from 17th to 7th and NZ from 20th to 22nd
* Per capita income is one third higher in Australia
* Tax is lower at every income level but the top one
* Wages are rising in Australia, after tax, at twice the rate of New Zealand
* Apologists say, with some truth, that Australia is enjoying a mineral boom, but service sector job growth is expanding at four times the jobs in mining, and the drought has shaved 1 per cent off growth, pushing up commodity prices to New Zealand’s benefit
* Australia has concluded a preferential trade deal with the US; New Zealand has not yet begun. Australia is in full negotiations with a trade deal with Japan; New Zealand has not even done a formal study

Moore also explicitly criticises National, as well as his implicit criticism of the Government.

He ends by saying we need to study why one in four NZers now live overseas, compared to one in 20 Australians.

Transtasman Therapeutics Products Authority takes another blow

Another blow to the Government’s plan for a costly and bureaucratic Transtasman Therapeutics Products Authority.

Before the last election the Health Select Committee unanimously recommended against the Authority. NZ First and United Future said they were against it.

Then after the election they did a dirty and pledged their support for it. That gave the Government 61 votes to 60 in favour. But since then Taito Phillip Field and now Alamein Gordon Copeland has said they will vote against it, so the vote is nor 59-62 against.

Psychic money repaid

Former VUWSA Women’s Rights Officer Clelia Opie has repaid to VUWSA the $6,000 of phone calls to 0900 psychic hotlines she made.

She is very fortunate she has got away with just repaying the money. Most organisations would call the Police in for $6,000 of unauthorised toll calls.

Lucifer

Weta Workshop has been appointed to do special effects for a film called Lucifer, detailing his fall from grace.

As the Catholic Church demanded the Da Vinci Code film be started with a message reminding people it is fiction, will they also demand the Lucifer film have a disclaimer that this is not the real Lucifer?

Helping Fijian Bloggers

A group of NZ bloggers, including me, have put out a release calling for the NZ Govt to condemn the Fijiian military Government for its acts of violence and censorship against Fijian bloggers. We have also offered hosting and mirroring in NZ if needed.

Well done to Tze Ming Mok for proposing this initiative, and David Haywood for co-ordinating it.

The Fiji Times has an article on it.

Not in Hawaii – yet

Grrrr. Flight from Auckland is delayed by four hours due to an engineering fault which occurred as we we taking off. We had ferried into position and started down the runway and then suddenly the familiar feel of acceleration was replaced with a definite braking sensation and we stopped.

They hoped to fix it in a few minutes but then after around 20 minutes said there would be a four hour delay and maybe a new plane, so we disembarked. I became very popular with some fellow travellers as my airpoints status allows me to take six guests with me into the Air NZ Lounge.

This now means we will arrive at the hotel at around 3 am. Ouch.

In Hawaii

I’m out of NZ for around a week attending, and speaking at a conference in Hawaii. The conference is the Pacific Rim Policy Conference, and they expect around 100 or so leaders of American and Pacific thinktanks.

The conference starts early every morning, over breakfast, but happily concludes at 3 pm each day, so I hope to get some relaxation in around Waikiki.

Helping the rich!

A comment in another post got me curious. How does Kiwi Saver affect people at different income levels compared to National’s 2005 tax policy?

On $50,000 you get $2,370 from National’s tax cuts and $670 more or $3,040 from Kiwi Saver. Fairly close. Note with tax cuts you are getting all your own money back and with Kiwisaver it is a mixture of taxpayer money and employer money.

For someone on $100,000 there is not much difference. National’s tax cuts would give you $4,770 and Kiwi Saver $5,040.

But go to a Marketing Manager on around $130,000. Under National they get $4,770 and Labour gives them $6,240. That is around $1,500 more.

A General Manager on around $220,000 gets $4,770 from National and $9,840 from Labour. An extra $5,000.

A CEO on $350,000 would get $4,770 from National and $15,480 from Labour. An extra $10,000.

And the CEO of Telecom would get $4,770 from National and $61,040 from Labour’s Kiwi Saver. Theresa/Marco thanks you for the extra $56,000.

Dr Cullen has given an unprecedented windfall to those on ultra-high salaries. He will be the toast of highly paid employees everywhere.

Mayor becomes CEO

Goodness – this is unusual. The Mayor of Hamilton has become the CEO.

Nothing wrong with this per se, so long as he recused himself from any involvement in the appointment process.

We had a similiar situation at InternetNZ a few years ago when the incumbent President sucessfully applied for the senior staff position. We were extremely careful that they were quarantined from all involvement in the process, even excluding input into the job description. In one sense it is a huge hassle when it happens because it adds a degree of complexity and sensitivity to the employment process, but on the other hand, excluding such as application may mean you don’t get the bets person for the job.

What is important is you don’t do it the way it was done at Maori TV a few years ago when the Chair of the Selection Panel declined all the applicants, and then was appointed himself.

Air NZ is another example of someone going from governance to management, as Ralph Norris did.