Cheaper Eden Park upgrade confirmed

The Government has confirmed a cheaper upgrade of Eden Park for the 2011 World Cup, with 50,000 permanent seats, and at least 10,000 temporary seats.

On balance this is probably the best decision, as I blogged last week. It is a pity there wasn’t more advance planning so that options like Carlaw or North Harbour could have been properly evaluated.

I do note however that last week the TV leaked story (which came from the Government) talked of a $50 to $100 million cost for the cheaper option. This $190 million cost is a lot more than that and the full permanent 60,000 seat option is only double instead of triple that.

But how often will Eden Park have more than 50,000 people wanting to attend?

The interesting detail for me, is who pays for it. How much will ratepayers and taxpayers be putting in, as opposed to NZRFU etc?

Was it a four or not?

I wondered watching the cricket vs Aussie why, despite hitting a four when on 336, NZ only scored 337. The four looked clear as.

A thread on Public Address suggests the answer. As the batsmen had already done one run, before the ball crossed the boundary, the game was ended at that point and hence the four was never scored.

Seems somewhat unfair to the batsman.

Anyone know the rules well enough to cite them for this sort of situation?

Solutions not Slogans

The NZ Herald calls for solutions not slogans from the PM:

The meaning of the word “sustainable” was expanded from its common usage in public discourse – as a desirable objective of environmental economics – to include such sweeping concepts as family, community living standards, culture, values and national identity.

All of these, suddenly, were to become sustainable too. Just like industry, business and government. The incongruity of it was especially noticeable coming as it did immediately after Helen Clark had declared that the challenges of the 21st century required substance and not slogans.

By turning a specific term into a catchall buzzword she excited the suspicion that slogans were what it was really all about.

Almost a Darwin Award

Corruption at Rimutaka Prison

I am not surprised that there is corruption at Rimutaka Prison. The pleasant surprise is that the Corrections Department has admitted it.

The reality is that there is massive and widespread corruption in the prison service. There are of course some honest staff there but the culture of corruption is so bad, it makes it hard for them. This is one of the reasons why Labour’s killing off of the privately managed prison was so horrendously bad – it was a chance to escape the culture of corruption.

Now people may think this is me dramatising. Well let me repeat the words I got told over drinks many years ago by a Corrections official whose job was to brief incoming Ministers. The briefing was basically:

Minister, there’s just two things you need to know about prisons. The first is that prisoners are the lowest scum of society. They lie, they cheat, they steal, they bash, they torture, they kill etc. You can’t believe a single thing they say.

The second is that prison guards are the second lowest scum of society. they lie, they cheat …..

Now before I get lynched by current or former prison guards, I am sure he was exaggerating somewhat and that in no way applies to all guards. But it did illustrate for me the scale of the problems within Corrections. This was from one of their own officials!

An incoming Minister gets briefed by both his Department and also by the former Minister. I should also share the words of a former Minister to his successor:

“Whatever you do, never have the soup”

Heh.

There’s no easy answer to the prison problem. Personally I would make sure any new prisons set up were done with entirely new managers and staff – maybe from overseas.

Great game

Now that was a great game of cricket. Started to look good at 45 overs and I was thinking they’ll try and finish the job in the second to last over, and they did, giving NZ our 29th ODI victory over Australia. Still they have 75 wins over us.

When Australia batted to 336 runs, who would have thought we would win, but NZ got 337/5 with eight balls in hand. Both teams broke the record for runs scored in an ODI at Eden Park.

Also a record for NZ vs Australia in any ODI.

Super 14 Week Three Results

Not so good for me this week. Like everyone I got the Crusaders wrong, but also failed to back the Hurricanes. Overall only three out of seven games picked correctly, with two being the right margin also.

So I drop to 52,278= place globally. The bloggers challenge is up to 78 participants (Name: NZ Bloggers, Password: dpf) and I am just in the top half in place 32= with 73 points.

The best picker for the week was Peter McCaffrey who got 40/56 points. Peter also leads overall with 103 points ahead of Andrew Thompson on 98 and Michael Cameron on 92.

Globally we had 22 people get a perfect 56 points – one being R Smith, and he has 130 points in total to be No 1.

More Auckland Billboards

Fran O’Sullivan writes in the HoS regarding the billboards gone up over Auckland. I think I was first to cover these on Thursday, and since then many more have been e-mailed to me. Here’s another:

aklbb2.JPG

Fran points out the shoddy stats being used by the Council to justify their proposed billboard ban, and that the vast majoirty of complaints have been about real estate signs and sandwich boards – not billboards.

Also noted is how the hearings panel on the proposed ban is made up exclusively of Councillors who voted for the ban. Such independence!

Selwyn convicted of further fraud charges

Former blogger Tim Selwyn has had his jail term increased by a further two years, with a guilty plea to 146 GST fraud charges.

Tim has now amassed a not inconsiderable list of convictions, ranging (off memory) from electoral fraud to identity theft, to property damage to GST fraud. His sedition conviction is still silly and unnecessary, but he isn’t exactly a poster child for lawful behaviour.

Worse of all, his once thoughtful blog has been reduced to 50 posts a week on how George W Bush is Satan. I used to read every word Tim wrote, but now my eyes glaze over after a few words from his replacement blogger.

A busy boy

Lindsay Mitchell highlights the death notice for a 35 year old Levin man.

What is unusual, apart from the charming nickname of “Mr Pimp” is his family. He comes from a large family, having ten siblings. But by age 35 he has already had eleven children by three different women – one being his wife and one being his partner.

Oh and his kids have already had three kids of their own.

So the question is, if each of his ten siblings also had eleven children, and each of them has eleven children, how big is the extended whanu and how many tonnes of carbon emmissions will they be responsible for?

And a final bonus point for the total amount of government money received every year by the family.

Bye Bye Beyer

It is worth noting that Georgina Beyer left Parliament this week – certainly more noteworthy than Lesley Soper replacing her.

G-Man highlights how when asked what contributions she had made to politics, she cited her election as sending a message around the world.

This is all too true that Georgina is far more famous for getting elected than for anything she has done in her seven years as an MP.

Now apart from her being in the wrong party (my ideal Parliament has 90 National MPs, 34 ACT MPs and six Green MPs 🙂 I was pleased Georgina got elected. It was somewhat remarkable that a transsexual former male prostitute could be elected to the NZ Parliament, especially in a rural electorate. I think it says a lot for voters judging not on the basis of someone’s sexual past but on the fact she had been an okay Mayor of Carterton.

But by the same standard any candidacy for Mayor of Wellington should be judged not on the fact she is transsexual, but on her record as an MP. And that record is dismal. Compare her to another Labour MP who might seek a Mayoralty – Tim Barnett. Barnett has helped get two controversial bills through Parliament, has been made Chief Whip, been an effective Select Committee Chair etc. He would be a credible candidate for Mayor of a major city. Georgina would not be.

She is of course free to stand. But if the left don’t want Kerry Prendergast to be re-elected, I hope they can find a candidate who actually could govern a billion dollar organisation.

Ethical Investing continued

In this thread, where I stated there are no companies the NZ Super Fund should not invest in, I was asked:

“Is there anything you don’t feel comfortable with the New Zealand Government investing in?”

Well personally I don’t like them investing in organic farming but that is different to me saying they should be banned from doing so.There is a difference between what you approve of and whether you should ban it.

The fact is 95% of the world’s companies would be viewed as unethical by someone. That is why legality is a better basis.

Personally I doubt I would personally ever buy shares in a tobacco company. My conscience wouldn’t sit comfortably with it. But I don’t want to impose my views on the NZ Super Fund.

Another commenter said the Super Fund should take account of corporate governance and reporting standards, holding Enron up as an example.

I absolutely agree corporate governance is vitally important, and should be part of a decision whether to invest, as it affects performance.

The issue of reporting is more complex. Enron for example signed up to all the hoop-la about triple bottom line reporting and produces many reports showing how wonderful they were and what good corporate citizens they were.

One of the things I have learned from courses run by the Institute of Directors, is that almost the only report you should believe is the cashflow statement. The statement of earnings and statement of financial position can be easily changed by reclassifying expenses as assets etc. Trust the cashflow – it does not lie.

Innocent until proven guilty

Matthew Hooton deals nicely with Clark’s spin about not having been able to act against Field as he is innocent until proven guilty.

If a teacher or a doctor ends up having sex with a distressed student or patient then we do not need to know anything else – we know that the teacher or doctor is wrong. Similarly, if a person who approaches their MP for help ends up tiling that MP’s investment properties for below the minimum wage then we do not need any more information – we know that that MP has abused their position.

If these are the standards we should apply, then Clark and Williams had all the information they needed 18 months ago to act against Field. Their inaction was a disgrace to the labour movement.

Labour has tried to say it is an issue of “innocent until proven guilty” but the criminal standard is surely not the one we should apply to our MPs, and it is not the one that Clark and Williams are applying to Field now.

As Clark has said, Field’s actions were “unacceptable, unethical and immoral”. She indicates she has believed this from day one.

Hooton them makes the obvious conclusion:

That Clark did not act against an MP who, in her judgement, was “unacceptable, unethical and immoral”, suggests she sees these qualities as unexceptional in her Labour Party.

She may well be right. “Unacceptable, unethical and immoral” is exactly how to describe her own office’s conduct over the election spending affair.

And finally a comment on carbon neutrality:

That’s because it’s unachievable and absurd. Only in countries where people are starving has it ever been attained. And even if we achieved it at unimaginable cost, we’re a small country and it wouldn’t delay climate change for a single hour. Climate change is a global issue, and in global terms we emit almost no carbon at all.

Greens debate allegiances

The Greens are debating not committing to only Labour prior to the next election, and negotiating with both National and Labour if they hold the balance of power.

From a Green point of view this is entirely sensible, and something I myself have advocated in the past. Labour have treated them like doormats because they have said they could never ever go with National. Hence they have no bargaining power.

So stating publicly you will consider National, will greatly increase the leverage with Labour if they are in a position to form a Government.

But don’t anyone think there is any real chance of a National-Green coalition. Most Greens are either communist background (Locke, Bradford, Norman) or hard-left. You possibly could do a deal just on environmental policy but you could never ever agree on economic policy, trade policy, defence policy etc etc,

As an example in the interview Sue Bradford demands National renounce and apologise for their previous actions. Yeah sure, right after Bradford apologises for the atrocities of the Chinese Communist Party.

So it is a smart move for the Greens, if they take it. But anyone who seriously thinks the Greens would vote in favour of a National Government is very mistaken.

Rod Oram on Clark and carbon neutrality

An excellent analysis by Rod Oram in the SST on how carbon neutrality might make or break Helen Clark.

The steps announced so far, such as requiring bio-fuels to account for 3.4% of the energy content of petrol and diesel by 2012, are incredibly modest. Meaningful progress will require making some very tough, fundamental decisions such as pricing the use of carbon across the economy, capping emissions and enabling a large-scale carbon trading market to develop.

This is key, I, for one, am not going to let Clark get away with claiming progress towards carbon neutrality without confronting those tough decisions. NZers deserve and need to know that this goal will require massive costs on NZ businesses and NZers, not just some PR gimmicks.

I’ll give the Greens credit. They are quite willing to front up and say yes we will have massive congestion on the roads in order to reduce car use. Yes we will reduce our national income and growth in order to reduce carbon use. Yes we will reduce exports and imports to reduce carbon costs of freight etc.

Labour I suspect is trying to have it both ways.

For my part I am not convinced that reducing carbon emissions is going to be as effective as mitigating the effects of climate change. I want an honest analysis of the costs of NZ becoming carbon neutral, so we can have a sensible debate.

Moreover, the prime minister is unwise to invoke the spirit of the nation’s anti-nuclear stand in suggesting carbon neutrality could be an equally powerful shaper of national identity. While it was brave to go anti-nuclear, particularly in the face of US hostility, it was relatively easy. It was a passive, one-off act. All we had to do was deny ourselves the dubious benefits of nuclear power and weapons.

In contrast, carbon neutrality will require decades of multiple, often challenging, actions. Many will require us to give up something, at least in the short term.

Again an excellent point. The nuclear free decision was a one-off which didn’t affect every day NZers. But Clark’s vision of carbon neutrality will involve tremendous pain.

SST reveals One News poll results

The Sunday Star-Times has published what it believes to be the results of the One News Colmar Brunton poll, which will be on TV One tonight.

Unless done with the permission of TV One, this is somewhat unethical – akin to breaking an embargo on a press release. This is the second time TV One has had their poll results published in an alternate medium before they themselves broadcast. The last time it was TV Three, which really annoyed them.

It has been a long standing tradition that results of polls get known informally within the ‘beltway’ 24 to 48 hours before publication. This means you can get responses from parties (this can be left to a few hours before publication) and also journalists can prepare stories in advance, or even obliquely refer to the poll (eg “a poll out this weekend is expected to be more bad news ..”)

Funnily enough, as a blogger I once considered whether I could or should publish poll results as I hear them. I generally don’t get them directly from the news publisher, so could publish without retaliation. But I concluded it would be unfair to the news publisher who has commissioned and paid for the poll. It will be interesting to ascertain if the SST publication is done with or without the blessing of One News.

I find it interesting how I semi-automatically consider me bound by the normal journalistic conventions, even though I am not a journalist. As another example the Halberg awards are announced under embargo the morning of the evening broadcast. I could have blogged who the winners were, but again didn’t. But at some stage the whole concepts of embargoes and the Internet may prove to be incompatible.

So far so good for Clark

I commented on radio yesterday that so far this week has gone pretty well for Helen Clark in terms of Taito Field. She’s had three wins:

1) Managed to provoke Field into saying something stupid so they could use that as a pretence for moving against him

2) He has now resigned from Labour, avoiding a very messy expulsion battle (National knows from kicking Winston out how hard this can be)

3) Labour still have his vote on confidence and supply, for now

John Armstrong writes that Clark will not be banking on keeping it, and I agree. The story is not yet over.

The NZ Herald editorial says Labour have been let off the hook undeserevedely, noting:

At no point has principle played a part in Labour’s handling of allegations about the Mangere MP’s dealings with prospective immigrants

Clark needs 61 votes to pass laws. Her options are:

Labour 49
Progressive 1
Greens 6
NZ First 7
United Future 3
Maori Party 4
Taito Phillip Field 1

The logical more centrist alliance of Lab/Prog/NZF/UNFNZ used to be 61 but now is 60.
And the logical more left alliance of Lab/Prog/Greens/Maori used to be 61 but now is 60

This means that unless you keep Field voting with you, neither of those alliance can pass laws, so they need to get either Maori or Greens to vote centrist or get NZF or UFNZ to vote more left. Most likely scenario is Maori voting centrist I would say.

Funding Internet TV

Pleased to see NZ on Air is considering making productions intended for Internet viewing eligible for funding assistance.

A short 10 minute clip can get more people seeing it on You Tube than on TV, especialy outside of prime time.

The comment:

Independent producers were sceptical of the NZ on Air proposal, saying the internet had removed the traditional scheduling and promotion that ensured Kiwis watched shows, instead lining them up for direct competition with content from the rest of the world.

is an interesting one as it is true traditional scheduling is dying in favour of content on demand. Why one should resist this though, I don’t know.

Falling hospital efficiency

Some people have criticised me for referring to health as a blackhole where you can keep throwing money in, and get little in return. But this is not just hyperbole from me.

The Dom Post reports on an analysis which says:

Hospital efficiency plummeted during Labour’s first two terms, with almost three dollars of extra spending needed to get one dollar’s worth of extra benefit.

The analysis finds hospital efficiency fell by 7.7 per cent from 00/01 to 03/04, while between 1997 and 2000 efficiency increased by 1.1 per cent.

Greens pay it back

Well done the Greens who have just paid back the $87,192 of illegal expenditure identified by the Auditor-General.

The Herald helpfully gives us the total state of play:

Paid

* Greens: $87,192.
* Act: $20,114.
* National: $11,912.
* Maori Party: $54.

Agreed To Pay But Outstanding

* Labour: $824,524.
* United Future: $71,867.

Refusing to pay at this stage

* New Zealand First: $157,934.

Only 136 days until 30 June.

Busy busy busy

I think I have been overly ambitious with my schedule while in Auckland. I always try and fit as much in as possible.

Hence yesterday I had meetings at 11 am, 12.30 pm, 2 pm, 4 pm, 5 pm and 6 pm. Today it is meetings at 9 am, 10 am, 11.30 am, 1 pm and then fly back at 3.30 p.m. Each meeting is in a different location so getting to know Auckland well!

No accountability for young offenders

For years both NZ First and National have been calling for the age of criminal responsibility to be lowered. Labour has been refusing.

Yesterday however the debate turned. No less than the Chief Family Court Judge has said young offenders are not being held accountable for their crimes:

“Twelve-year-olds, many of whom are committing quite heavy crimes, need to be more accountable than the present system is able to make them,” he said.

“What concerns me about the present situation is that for every 12-year-old criminal there is a victim. It’s the victim I am more concerned about.”

This is a stunning statement to be made by the head of the youth judiciary.

Hopefully the Government will now take action.

The billboards strike back

aklbillboard1.JPG

Heh. Bruce Hucker and his killjoy friends are trying to ban billboards from Auckland City. Seems like the billboards have decided to fight back, based on this photo I took while driving along Fanshawe Street.

You have to love the placement especially, right below the United Travel billboard. Are there any other billboards like this up in Auckland? E-mail them in.

Miss Alice suspended

Miss Alice, aka Rob Moodie, has been fined $5,000 and suspended from practising law for three months for contempt of court. The Justices say he was on the verge of being disbarred but they accepted his sincere motivations.

As most people know Moodie published an army report on the Internet after being denied permission to do so. He had a lot of public support for his actions, but what many may not have realised is that he had opportunities to appeal that decision to the Court of Appeal and maybe even the Supreme Court. He broke the rules of evidence, rather than appeal the decision. I’d be more favourably inclined towards him if he had exhausted all his legal options.

Moodie claims he will give up the law and write a book instead.

The full 30 page ruling is online here. Worth a read.

Valentine’s Day

Auckland is all booked up this week, so when booking my accommodation the *only* room I could get in Auckland for last night was a valentines special. Great i thought – spending Valentine’s Day alone in a hotel room with one of those insufferable baskets of fruit or something wishing me a romantic evening.

But turned out even worse than that. My last meeting finished at 8 pm so four of us decided to grab a quick buffet at the hotel restaurant. The waitress found it hilarious that four guys were dining together on Valentines Day, and made a point of asking how we were enjoying our valentines dinner etc.