Female MPs refuse the back seat

The HOS reports on how three female MPs walked out of an official visit to a CYF office, after a kaumatua attacked them for refusing to sit in the back.

It is outrageous that an official Government Department would insult MPs like this. It would be different if this was a marae, but this department is voted funds by Parliament and is ultimately accountable to it. The MPs did absolutely the right thing in refusing to put up with this PC nonsense.

To make it even worse there had been an agreement with CYF that there would be no powhiri and no seating. The MPs concerned had made it clear they didn’t want one and would not sit at the back if there was one.

So what we have is a Government Department which went out of its way to insult and abuse said MPs, reneging on the agreement not to have a powhiri.

Kiwibank Mortgage Rates

Just been looking at various tables at the wonderful Consumer Online website and peeked at their mortgage rate comparison.

Now Kiwibank rates, with one exception, are not lower than the other banks.

Their one year rate is 8.10% and two year rate is 7.75%. BNZ (whom I am with) are 8.10% and 7.60% respectively.

Now their floating rate of 9.00% is less than other banks, but because the floating rates are generally much higher than fixed rates, very few people have any or much of their mortgage at the floating rate.

Moral of the story is to check the comparisons carefully, and not to assume which institution is cheapest.

Who dun it?

In the IT and political industries, there is only one topic of conversation. Who leaked the Cabinet Paper to Telecom? I’ve heard around six different “well-sourced” suggestions.

Dr Cullen ruled himself out yesterday making the obvious point that as the announcement was meant to be the highlight of his budget, he should be last on anyone’s lists. He has ruled out his staff, as has David Cunliffe.

The HOS points out Helen Clark has refused to rule out the leak coming from her office. This might possibly be connected to the fact that one of her former senior staff has been working for Telecom as a lobbyist on this issue. Mind you, the person concerned is the last one I would expect to be involved in something like this.

We know it was deliberate, as the leak wasn’t by e-mail – ie an accidental mistyping of a name. We also know MED is ruled out as they did not have the memo from the Minister which was with the paper.

The SSC inquiry needs to identify the leaker quite quickly or pressure will continue to mount for the inquiry to be upgraded to either a select committee or commission of inquiry which has the power to force people to testify etc and subpoena documents.

Juha Saarinen also explains in the article that his blog post predicting a decision next week and that it would include unbundling was based on educated guesswork, not a single specific source. I had been convinced for several months that unbundling was definitely going to happen, and there was general speculation that Cabinet was at the decision making phase so this wasn’t an out of left field guess from Juha.

There is also a big difference between hearing a rumour that an option may be in or out, and the actual leak of the full cabinet paper. The former is common, the latter unheard of.

Museums the new dating place

The Powdergate deal

More culls

Remember how Helen attaced District Health Boards for culling their waiting lists. Well they are actually under orders to do so from her Government. Yes the Ministry of Health has set a target of 17,000 patients to be removed from waiting lists, with Canterbury DHB about to remove 2,000.

What a surprise!

The Dom Post reports that thousands of students have stopped making voluntary repayments on their student loans. This is of course entirely logical and expected.

It’s looking like annual voluntary repayment may have fallen by as much as $300 million. It is very possible that Labour’s policy will actually lead to total debt increasing, not decreasing, as it encourages students to take out debt and stay in debt.

Telecom TV links

In the black

I shoudl have blogged on Thursday that Dr Cullen announced on Thursday that for the first time since records began in 1972, the NZ Government has no net debt.

This is a great achievement, considering how at one stage the interest of our debt was one of our larger items of expenditure.

So who should get the credit? Well the 4th Labour Govt did many good things but fiscally they were as bad as George W Bush and ran operating deficits.

The person who should take most of the credit is Ruth Richardson who reversed a 20 year trend of increasing deficits. But highly commended goes to both Bill Birch and Michael Cullen who have kept the surpluses up.

LBJ on Youth Rates Bill

LBJ, a new commentator at Sir Humphrey’s, has done a first class job in analysing and explaining what the meaning and implications are of the Ministry of Justice memo which said minimum wage regulations made under the principal Act that are inconsistent with the Bill of Rights Act may be deemed ultra vires

This is a seriously useful analysis, and makes two things clear:

1) The hysterical press releases from EPMU and UNITE claiming they will be seeking years of back pay from employers, shows they don’t even know the law in this area – and I should not believe their claims in future.

2) Sue Bradford has managed to draft a bill so incompetently that it will not actually achieve what she wants it to.

I won’t even try to summarise the opinion – go read it yourself, except to say the Human Rights Act is the key Act here, not the Bill of Rights Act.

Cathedral Club with Dr Bassett

I mentioned a few weeks ago I was about to attend a meeting of the Cathedral Club, which meets every so often with a guest speaker over dinner at the Auckland Club.

We were privileged to have Dr Michael Bassett talk to us, and it was one of the best dinners I have been to – it lasted around six hours. Dr Bassett is one of those fascinating people you could never get bored talking to. He is a historian so you could talk about Prime Ministers from 80 years ago. He has served on the Waitangi Tribunal so has some unique perspectives about Treaty issues and he was also a member of the Fourth Labour Government and could talk about everything from Roger Douglas to the early partnership of Clark and Anderton, and why they split up etc.

Now it was all Chatham House rules so I can’t talk in detail about the conversation, but for someone like me interested in both politics and history it was superb. And each guest speaker gets asked to nominate who we should invite next, so the club never run out of guests.

Apart from the quality of the guest, the food and drink was also excellent. With pre-dinner drinks, some whiskey, wine over dinner and finally some ports it was a well lubricated night.

club1.JPG

Sentence is appropriate

Like many, my first reaction upon hearing that a sentence of only one year and 11 months was given to someone involved in the Bentley home invasion was outrage.

But once I read the story in full and realised the person being referred to took no part of the actual burglary, invasion or assault it is a very different matter. Almost two years for suggesting the burglary is definitely appropriate, and I note those who actually carried it out got nine years.

The Whig has much the same reaction.

Bloggers 1 Lawyers 0

Big News reports on how the lawsuit against a Maine blogger has been dropped. The state tourism agency’s ad agency was suing Lance Dutson because of criticisms he had made of them.

Once upon a time the small guy would have to have settled as they couldn’t afford a court fight and had no way to fight back. But 1000s of blogs exposing the the agency was doing, and the resulting publicity resulted in them backing down.

Qantas Awards

The awards are out but each media outlet tends to only report on the awards they got, so I have gone to the Qantas Awards website to find a list of all winners and finalists.

Even the website makes it bloody hard though, as you have to go to a dozen different pages to compile them all. However it is worth a visit just to get to see the photos that were considered for the photography awards.

Assault_jpg.jpg

This superb photo is from overall winner Simon Baker, a freelancer.

Now I may have missed one or two, but my rough count gives the following winners amongst the well-known publications:

NZ Herald 23
Sunday Star-Times 16
The Press 11
Dominion Post 9
North & South 6
The Listener 6
Metro 6
Herald on Sunday 5
Waikato Times 4
ODT 2
Sunday News 1
Southland Times 1

Now if we group them by type, we have:

Daily Newspapers

NZ Herald 23
The Press 11
Dominion Post 9
Waikato Times 4
ODT 2
Southland Times 1
BoP Times

So NZ Herald has done very well. Congrats.

Weekly Newspapers

Sunday Star-Times 17
Herald on Sunday 5
Sunday News 1

A knock-out win to the Sunday Star-Times.

Magazines

North & South 6
The Listener 6
Metro 6

A three-way tie.

Turning to some of the more major awards, the winners were:

Newspaper: THE PRESS
Daily Newspaper up to 25,000 circulation: BAY OF PLENTY TIMES
Weekly Newspaper: SUNDAY STAR-TIMES
Suburban or Community Newspaper: MOUNTAIN SCENE
Magazine: NORTH & SOUTH
Senior Reporter: TONY WALL, Sunday Star-Times
Junior Reporter: AMANDA SPRATT, Herald on Sunday
Senior Newspaper Feature Writer: TIM HUME, Sunday Star-Times
Junior Newspaper Feature Writer: TIM HUME, Sunday Star-Times
Senior Magazine Feature Writer: BEVAN RAPSON, Metro
Junior Magazine Feature Writer: AMANDA CAMERON, NZ Doctor
Columnist: FINLAY MACDONALD, Sunday Star-Times
Editorial Writer: ANTHONY HUBBARD, Sunday Star-Times
Cartoonist: ROD EMMERSON, The New Zealand Herald
Newspaper Investigation: THE PRESS – Transpower
Photographer: SIMON BAKER, Freelance
Single Picture: KENNY RODGER, The New Zealand Herald

Social Credit gains power!!

Fruits and Votes reports that the new Prime Minister of the Solomon Islands is Manasseh Sogavare and how his party is Social Credit.

Good God the funny moiney crowd are back in power! I still shudder at the thought they once were over 30% support in NZ polls.

England Local Body Elections

UK Labour has had its worst performance in English local body elections in over 20 years. They came third with 26% of the vote, Lib Dems had 27% and the Conservatives got 40%. David Cameron will be a very happy man.

The Conservatives won an extra 316 Council seats and now control 68 local Councils compared to 29 for Labour.

The Lib Dems made no progress at all, picking up only two extra seats.

Tony Blair has responded with a huge re-shuffle.

NBR on Telco Reform

It is very rare for newspapers to do front-page editorials. It is also very rare for the National Business Review to praise the Clark Government. However today on the NBR front-page they start with:

“The Clark Government is to be applauded for its guts in taking a scalpel to Telecom’s market dominance in an effort to lift New Zealand up the OECD broadband rankings”

I think this shows how broad and wide-spread the support for these necessary changes are.

NBR goes onto say “This paper is traditionally vehemently opposed to all but the lightest government regulation. We are proudly pro-business and as a result suspicious of government intervention.” This sums me up also. Regulation is a last resort, but it is a resort.

In the last twelve months especially Telecom has made strategic blunders of massive, even epic, proportions. I even tried to warn them of this back in November. Their actions gave little choice but to change the rules because they gamed the current rules to such effect. Sure they are entitled to do so, but they knew the risks that strategy entailed and more than anyone are responsible for new rules being introduced.

I could tell horror stories from ISPs about how Telecom, as a supplier to them, has done everything possible to frustrate them. Russell Brown has blogged on how they have a ticketing system which means they can arrange broadband access to a house in two days for Xtra but two weeks or more for other ISPs. It’s not about prices as much as service.

As good as these reforms are, I still don’t think they will solve the long-term problem of attitudes. And sadly there has been little incentive for Telecom to behave differently. That is why I believe the ultimate step of a structural separation of their wholesale and retail business may turn out to be necessary.

Such separation would mean you can actually do away with most of this regulation, as the two separate Telecom companies will have greatly different incentives. Wholesale to grow the overall market and retail to compete aggressively in it.

Telecom board and management may want to ponder how they managed to arrange a situation where many of the most anti-regulation advocates in NZ (NBR, Gareth Morgan, Fran O’Sullivan, myself, many top businessmen) got persuaded that regulation wasn’t only defensible but very necessary. That takes some doing.

Police Non-Prosecution

TVNZ reported last night that the Police considered Heather Simpson was the appropriate person to charge for Labour’s over-spending. They even concluded a charge would result in a conviction.

Yet they decided not to prosecute, on the grounds of lack of intent to break the law. Now this is legal incompetence of the highest level from the Police. Let me repeat Section 214B(3) of the electoral Act 1993 for readers:

Every person who directly or indirectly pays or knowingly aids or abets any person in paying for or on account of any election expenses any sum in excess of the maximum amount prescribed by this section is,

Commenters

I’m constantly surprised by the variety of people who turn up and comment on an issue on this blog. Several times academics have posted in relation to projects of theirs under discussion.

This week on the smoking lawsuit thread, the director’s of ASH and the Smokefree Coalition lobby groups both posted. The Drug Founation head has posted here several times.

Just noticed today the co-author of the organ donor bill has posted on the thread about that bill.

It’s one of things I really enjoy about blogging – that you can get direct dialogue with key players rather than just read about competing media releases in the paper.

Anti-Spam Legislation

The Commerce Select Committee has started to hear submissions on the anti-spam legislation. A report from yesterday is in the Dom Post.

I’ll be submitting, as part of the InternetNZ team, next Thursday morning.

The NZ Herald coincidentally has a column from Canadian Internet Law Professor Michael Geist on the need for anti-spam laws and how technology alone can’t win the fight. Neither will legislation alone. As always there is no silver bullet but a range of measures needed. Personally mine would included televised lynchings but I’m told that may be against the Bill of Rights Act also 🙂

More on Telecom

The Dominion Post Editorial has endorsed the Government’s broadband package saying “the Government’s move the right one”.

The NZ Herald editorial is also very supportive, and in fact compares the moves to the toppling of Saddam Hussein’s statue in Baghdad! They call for Telecom to “accept the new reality and put all its energy into competing for customers” noting “Telecom is being asked no more than to compete in what, internationally, is the telecommunications norm” and concluding “It is about time”.

The NZ Herald reports on investment plans by other ISPs, which all sound good, and yesterday’s Dom Post had a profile of David Cunliffe and his rising start within Labour.

Much coverage is on the leaked Cabinet paper, with it being described as “the most serious in modern New Zealand history“. Telecom are claiming they will co-operate yet they have *destroyed* the paper which would have been the most easy way to track down who leaked it. They also refuse to say if they will reveal the source if known to them. I wonder if they destroyed the envelope it came in also as that may have handwriting or fingerprints on it.

If the leak did come from a Ministerial Office (and I consider that most unlikely) the staff member would be sacked faster than one can blink, and his or her Minister would probably be obliged to offer their resignation also.

UPDATE: Telecom have clarified that they only deleted copies of the paper sent to them, and have kept one document which they will hand over. Unsure if they kept the original which may have fingerprints or a copy of it.

Youth Rates

The Ministry of Justice has published an opinion that the current regulations setting a different minimum wage for 16 and 17 year olds to 18+ year olds may be ultra vires as a breach of the Bill of Rights.

This is just an opinion, and has no legal status, but if a court agreed with the opinion, this would be huge. It would mean that for 16 years youth rates had been established in such a way as to be unauthorised. This would be a huge embarrassment to the Department of Labour which has drafted the Act and the Regulations.

Two unions are already pledging to sue *employers* for up to six years of back wages for those who got youth rates. This is misguided to put it even mildly. As the youth rate regulations have been deemed legal for 16 years, you can’t blame an employer for relying on official government advice that they are legal.

Incidentally in this debate on youth rates, I should point out that while I am a strong defender of there being a separate minimum youth rate, I personally as an employer don’t have different pay rates based on people’s age (and I do have a number of employees under 18). But what works for me and my business is not the same for all employers.

Parental Advice from Cactus Kate

Moussaoui not to be executed

Zacarias Moussaoui, convicted in a US court in connection with the 911 terrorist attacks has not been sentenced to execution but rather life without parole.

I am very glad of this outcome.

Moussaoui wanted to be executed. He wanted to be the great martyr, whose name would be known for generations as the only person killed by the US for the 911 attacks. This decision means he will not die a martyr. He will die in 40 years time in a small jail cell, with no friends and in near total obscurity.

For Moussaoui living in a US jail will be far worse than death.

I don’t suppose they can only feed him bacon in jail can they?

Do you Helen take Winston …

0,1445,234525,00.jpg

Well done to Winston for being a good sport and turning up for the unveiling of new puppets at the Backbencher for himself and Helen Clark. As you can see they make a lovely couple 🙂

Helen herself didn’t turn up – I think it is the first time ever a politican has refused to unveil their puppet. Guess she wasn’t too keen on the imagery of her and Winnie.