This thorny question must have totally consumed Labour’s MPs at their recent caucus retreat.
I can’t imagine any back-slapping took place. More back-stabbing. After all, what is there for them to celebrate?
A sunny January?
Whether you like Key or not you have to concede that he’s one smart, pragmatic holder of the vast but crucial Centre ground.
And Labour’s only helping him by looking divided and hopelessly confused over the controversial trade pact, the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement.
No less than four former Labour Party leaders support the TPPA: Phil Goff, Mike Moore, Helen Clark and David Shearer.
They’re in the prime minister’s camp as leader Andrew Little takes his caucus towards the Greens.
Yep Labour once again shifts left.
The truth is, if John Key is a rabid Right-winger he’s disguised it well. He just wants to stay in power.
And Labour’s doing its best to help him by looking shabby, confused and divided.
This belated anti-TPPA posturing – too feeble and too late in the game – feels contrived and lacking in conviction.
I don’t know what Labour really stands for these days, and I’m sure, Goff, Moore, Shearer and Clark are struggling to answer that question too.
Labour is the gift that keeps on giving. Especially for Key.
Helen Clark must shake her head and wonder.