Unite and Rugby World Cup

The HoS reports:

McCarten said hospitality industry workers should be paid a minimum of $15 an hour and hotel workers get a cut of room-rate hikes.

An employer who sets a permanent wage rate on the basis of a one off event, won’t be in business for long.

Rates will be higher during the World Cup. And unions are quite free to ask for a profit share. In fact I like profit shares. But they normally go both ways.

If there is a month with little demand for rooms, and hence room rates are discounted 50%, would Unite be willing to accept lower wage rates for that month?

Risk and reward are linked. If you want extra reward, you need to accept some risk also.

The workers earned low wages and would be expected to work long hours and extra days during the tournament.

Now there is one key thing missing from that sentence. The statement that workers will get paid extra money for every extra hour and extra day. Hotels are not going to (or able to) make people work longer hours for the same pay. So workers will be getting paid more during the RWC – by working more.

“They’re talking about room rates of up to 10 times what they’re charging now, so there will be a lot of money around.”

There’s talk, and there’s actual bookings,

And Tourism Auckland chief executive Graeme Osborne said no one would be making “silly money” from the tournament.

The industry had emerged from a “tough” few years, and the average room rate was about $140 a night, lower than it was five years ago.

As I said,if you want more money during the peaks, will you also take less money during the troughs?

Hodgson to retire

I tweeted yesterday that I had heard a rumour that Pete Hodgson will announce his retirement this weekend, and the ODT confirms he has.

No doubt he will spend his last 18 months in Parliament trying to dig up H Fee Mark III on John Key, after the failure of H Fee Mark I and H Fee Mark II.

Asked if he thought he would be offered board appointments by Prime Minister John Key, Mr Hodgson said “No way”.

Thank God. Cullen’s appointment was bad enough.

I expect David Parker will get the nomination for Dunedin North. Despite being the MP for Otago for three brief years, he has always lived in Dunedin. Parker is ten years younger than Hodgson, and has performed pretty well in Opposition. In fact he might be a future Finance Minister in a Labour-led Government.

Advice from Keating

The Herald reports that Paul Keating once tried to teach Tony Blair how to hate his opponents. He also advised:

Keating also had some tips for Blair on economic issues, telling him that if he ever became prime minister he should avoid income tax hikes at all costs.

“Tony, promise me you won’t raise income tax. It’s death.

“Labour parties around the world have enough to contend with without hanging that round their necks. It’s not worth it.”

Luckily in NZ, Labour is suggesting they will campaign in 2011 on a policy to increase income tax for rich pricks.

Gregarious Groser

The Herald reports:

Trade Minister Tim Groser has been warned, after a complaint was made about rowdy drinking and disruptive behaviour by him and some members of a trade mission on a flight from Dubai in April.

But another member of the delegation has defended the minister, saying that if he had a few drinks they were “well deserved” after a stressful trip.

A complaint about the behaviour of the delegation and the minister on the April 30 flight was made to the Prime Minister’s office.

Chief of staff Wayne Eagleson spoke to Mr Groser on behalf of Prime Minister John Key, a spokesman for Mr Key said last night.

“The minister acknowledged there had been some drinking on the flight, but he felt his behaviour was appropriate,” he said.

“The Prime Minister made it quite clear through his chief of staff the expectations he had in terms of ministers’ behaviour.”

It is hard to say much about this story, in the absence of specifics. The complaint did not come from a fellow passenger, but from someone who heard about it from a fellow passenger.

Ministers (and all MPs to some degree) are always in the public eye, and have to act accordingly. This means no giving the fingers to people who steal your car park, and also means being a model passenger on flights.

Now as I said, there are no details about this flight, and the complaint was from someone not on the flight. It may be something quite trivial. Also a factor is that he was returning from a trip on which he learnt his mother had died while he was overseas.

Laws retires as Mayor

Michael Laws has announced he will stand down as Mayor of Whanganui, but is standing for both the Council and DHB.

I may be wrong, but I would not surprised to see Michael No 2 on the NZ First list next election, and helping run Winston’s campaign to get back in.

If they succeed, that will help Labour’s chance of getting back into Government, and Laws would be a Minister in a Labour-led Government.

Editorials 4 June 2010

The Herald wants some trams to play with:

On a broader canvas, cities such as San Francisco and Melbourne are closely identified with their trams.

Auckland chose another route when it removed trams from its streets.

Now, more than 50 years later, they are being readied for a comeback on the city’s waterfront in time for next year’s Rugby World Cup.

They can be successful here as well, but only if other developments in the Wynyard Quarter provide a suitable underpinning. …

The Press focuses on water:

The granting of final approval this week to the Central Plains Water irrigation scheme should now let the proposal finally get under way.

The process by which the decision was reached has been long and impassioned and has wound up costing about twice what was originally estimated.

But along the way, the scheme has been rigorously scrutinised. About 2000 submissions were considered by the independent planning commissioners.

It has been much modified in the light of criticism that was made of the original proposal, and it is now much less ambitious than first intended.

In the end, though, the potential benefits have now been weighed by the planning commissioners against any adverse effects it will have on some people, and the final assessment is that the scheme will be good for Canterbury.

The Dom Post talks promises:

Mr Key has now been burned twice in a matter of weeks for taking positions he cannot defend.

The first was the Crown’s negotiations with Tuhoe. Whatever the Government is saying publicly, it is obvious Tuhoe was led to believe that ownership of Te Urewera National Park was up for negotiation. As Mr Key belatedly realised, it should not have been. But the fallout from Mr Key abruptly removing the park from the table has soured relations between National and the Maori Party and created a fresh source of grievance for Tuhoe.

Mr Key’s second false step – actually it was his first – was his pre-election promise, given both to this newspaper in response to a question from a reader and during a TV3 leaders’ debate five days before the election, that Kiwibank would never be sold. The promise conflicts with National’s policy on state-owned enterprises – that none will be sold during this term of government but that sales could be considered in future.

Key has now restated that Kiwibank will not be sold – not just during this term. He had little choice once he realised that his pre-election statements about sale were not just about the first term.

Key has gone to great lengths to keep faith with the electorate. What he is finding now though is that he should have been more careful with what he said pre-election. It is my belief that no leader should ever give a permanent guarantee on an issue. They should give commitments for the upcoming term of Parliament, but should always retain the right to campaign on a different policy at a future election.

The ODT asks if Peter Bethune is a hero or a victim. Some might say neither!

It is possible to feel strongly opposed to Japanese whaling in the Southern Ocean yet uneasy at some of the actions taken in opposition to it.

That’s me. I joke that the only people I hate more than the whalers are Sea Shepherd.

He continues to blame the captain of the larger vessel for a sudden change in course and a direct attempt to ram Ady Gil, such that a collision became unavoidable.

The exact sequence of events – who did what to whom – remains masked in confusion amid claim and counterclaim, the only certainty being there was a collision and, consequently, the unsalvageable Ady Gil later sank.

It was no surprise. The whalers have never had a collision with Greenpeace or other protest ships. Only Sea Shepherd who have a long history of trying to ram other ships.

It is hard to know at this distance the extent to which his tearful supplication to the Japanese judiciary on Monday was for their benefit – or that of the world at large.

Many activists tread a fine line in their efforts to invoke sympathy for the cause, often teetering but a small mis-step from achieving precisely the opposite.

Nobody, least of all those who believe Japan’s “scientific whaling” in the Southern Ocean to be bogus and unacceptable, would wish a prison sentence on this singular activist; but there might be those prepared to concede he appears, by his actions, to have asked for one.

I hope he does not get a prison sentence, because that is what he wants.

More honours for Nancy Wake, except NZ Govt

The Dom Post reports:

Wellington-born Nancy Wake – aka The White Mouse – was the Allies’ most decorated servicewoman of World War II, and the Gestapo’s most-wanted person.

Now she has been recognised with a new “heritage pylon”, unveiled by Wellington Mayor Kerry Prendergast in Oriental Pde yesterday.

Ms Wake, who was born in Roseneath but left New Zealand as a toddler, was living in France when Nazi Germany invaded during World War II. She joined the French Resistance and was smuggled to England for specialist training.

In 1944 she was parachuted back into France, where she co-ordinated the efforts of thousands of fighters and fought alongside them.

Ms Wake – codenamed the “The White Mouse” because of her ability to elude capture – at one point was No 1 on the Gestapo’s most wanted list, with an offer of five million francs for anyone who dobbed her in – or killed her.

In London, in 2006, she was presented with the New Zealand Returned Services Association’s Badge in Gold and life membership, for her services in the Special Operations Executive during the war. It was the first time her work was recognised by her country of birth.

She was, however, already the Allies’ most decorated servicewoman, collecting bravery awards from France, England, Australia and the United States. Ms Wake, now 97, lives in England.

Sadly the NZ Government still refuses to grant Wake an honour. I’m pretty dismayed that the powers that be seem to have got captured by officials who are more worried about the precedent an honour would create, rather than see it as an opportunity to honour an amazing woman who gave up a life of luxury and privilege to fight evil. The reality is that if NZ did grant Wake an honour, it would be in fact NZ gaining more doing so – proudly claiming Wake as a Kiwi. And Wake herself has been reported as saying she still has her NZ passport, and considers herself more Kiwi than Aussie.

Good on Wellington City Council for honouring Nancy Wake. Maybe that will shame the New Zealand Government into doing the same.

Greens abandon Bradford, she claims

The Dom Post reports:

Former Green Party MP Sue Bradford has abandoned plans to run for the Auckland super-city council, saying she has been left high and dry by her party.

The Green Party is gathering in Christchurch today for its annual conference. Ms Bradford will miss it for the first time in 12 years.

“I don’t have a role there,” Ms Bradford said. I’ve lost my place to stand with the Green Party.”

She had seriously considered running for a place as a councillor on the super-city board but had reluctantly backed out.

“I came to see that I didn’t have the support of Labour and the Greens.”

A pity in a sense. The thought of Sue as Deputy Mayor would have galvanised many people to vote, just to vote against her.

Keeping the register accurate

The Taranaki Daily News reports:

MP Jonathan Young failed to declare to Parliament a pecuniary interest in a company in which he holds a directorship, triggering a “please explain” demand from the Labour benches.

Mr Young, National MP for New Plymouth, is a director of Seaview Super Trustees Limited, a firm he says “carries his trust’s properties”, and for which he is listed by the Companies’ Office as holding a 50 per cent shareholding. The other 50 per cent is held by his wife, Maura. Another director listed, without a shareholding, is North Shore accountant Mark Thompson.

Parliamentary rules require that MPs must declare any interest where they hold a directorship or more than 5 per cent of the voting rights.

Labour MP Pete Hodgson said that at the very least, Mr Young “had some explaining to do”.

He does. It clearly should have been disclosed. However I am not aware of any “gain” from non disclosure, and think that the omission would be accidental.It sounds like it is associated with a trust which he did declare.

A similar apparent non disclosure comes from Shane Jones. It was reported in July 2009:

The New Zealand United States Council is sponsoring a visit to Washington DC by Hon Shane Jones and Craig Foss MP, respectively Chair and Vice Chair of the New Zealand United States Parliamentary Friendship Group in the 49th Parliament. …

In Washington DC 20-23 July Shane Jones and Craig Foss will meet their counterparts from the Friends of New Zealand Congressional Caucus

Now if we turn to the Register for the year ending 31 January 2010, we find:

Craig Foss:
United States of America – representing New Zealand-US Friendship Group. Contributor to travel:
NZ-US Council (USA domestic airfare). Contributor to accommodation: NZ-US Council.

And when we turn to Shane Jones we find:

Shane Jones
Rarotonga – play in New Zealand Parliamentary rugby team in match against Rarotongan
Parliament team. Contributor to travel: Air New Zealand (subsidised airfare). Contributor to
accommodation: Parliamentary Rugby Club (subsidised accommodation).

So Shane has failed to disclose the funding from the NZ-US Council.

Now like with Jonathan Young, I don’t think there is anything sinister about it. But maybe Pete Hodgson will be calling on Shane Jones to also “explain himself”. That is when he takes time off from pursing H Fee Mark II.

Also of note is that bloggers pointed out Chris Carter failed to disclose his trip in January 2010, to St Kitts and Nevis to observe elections. Carter has now filed an amended disclosure, including this.

Amusingly Lockwood Smith also forgot to disclose gifts of a kilt and a vase, which he also included in an amended disclosure!

Target rightfully slapped by BSA

The Herald reports:

TV3 consumer affairs programme Target has been ordered to pay nearly $40,000 after it wrongly accused an Auckland cafe of selling food with a high faecal coliform reading. …

Target wrote to Cafe Cezanne’s owners telling them a chicken sandwich from their cafe had tested positive for faecal coliforms. However, the letter contained incorrect information about the date of purchase.

The owners questioned whether the sample was from their cafe but Target went ahead with the broadcast.

The programme was forced to apologise the following week after it found a mistake had been made in labelling the samples, and the show broadcast a statement saying: “Due to a human error by a former Target staff member coding the results, we cannot confirm which cafe produced this high faecal coliform count”.

This is the worse part of what Target did. Their original appalling error was bad enough, but their so called apology actually made it worse by leaving open the possibility the cafe was Cezanne, when it could not have been.

I really don’t know why it is so hard for some media companies to simply say sorry without reservation and make a full apology.

The full BSA decision is here.

I recommend people with an interest, read it. You’ll be in no doubt that the BSA got this one right. Target could well have destroyed the cafe’s reputation and business.

The starting point for payment of a successful complainant’s legal expenses is 30%. The fact the BSA ordered Mediaworks to pay 100% speaks volumes about how serious this was. They also ordered them to apologise not just on Target, but on all the Mediaworks radio stations, and to take out an ad in the Herald. That may help restore the damage done to Cafe Cezanne.

Both Fair Go and Target are great shows which have provided many benefits to consumers. But they have to be beyond reproach in the way they collect and analyse data, and in this case Target fall way short. Hopefully they will learn from this, so there is never a repeat. This means not just a change in procedures, but also in attitudes. Their treatment of the cafe owners was arrogant and their initial apology grudging.

The Environmental Protection Authority

The Herald reports:

A new, independent environment agency has been hailed by green groups as a big step towards improving environmental management.

Environment Minister Nick Smith announced details of the Environmental Protection Authority yesterday, pleasing lobbyists who hope the agency will play a leading role in the Government’s new-look environment regime.

Environmental Defence Society chairman Gary Taylor and Sustainability Council executive director Simon Terry applauded the decision to make the agency a Crown entity with its own board, at arm’s length from political influence.

“The Ministry for the Environment never had the necessary teeth,” said Mr Terry.

Also pleased was Parliamentary Commissioner for the Environment Jan Wright.

She said last month that environmental monitoring was so haphazard that it was impossible to tell whether the country was getting cleaner or dirtier.

New Zealanders may disagree on some issues such as mining, but most Kiwis are supportive of robust environmental monitoring and protection. The EPA should prove far more able at this, than the Ministry was.

Oh yuck

The Herald report:

A sexual abuse trial was aborted after a juror revealed he became aroused while listening to evidence from the alleged victims.

The elderly jury member was one of 12 people hearing a case in an Auckland Court this week about the sexual abuse of two teenage girls.

The Herald has been told the jury was sent home early on Monday after the man said he was distressed by what he had heard during the first day of evidence.

On Wednesday, Judge Mary Beth Sharp questioned the jurors about how they were coping.

It is understood she was told the male juror had confided to his fellow jurors that he had been sexually aroused by the victims’ evidence but had coped on Tuesday by wearing a condom in the courtroom.

Rather yucky. Some people can’t control what they do or do not find arousing, but you can exercise some mental self-control, and you certainly don’t respond my wearing a condom to court. I suspect some deeper issues here.

Friday Photo 4 June

Hmm…what a week :/

Noting my affection for the scalier things in life, today’s photo is of a crocodile (plus some bonus flies if you are so inclined)

This girl is an estuarine crocodile- photo taken up in the Adelaide River of the Northern Territory.

As always, clicking the image will bring up a larger version. The mud on the head is from the river bottom where she has been resting.

RIP Bernie Galvin

A PR from Treasury:

Treasury Secretary John Whitehead today paid tribute to former Secretary Bernie Galvin, who passed away yesterday.

Mr Galvin headed the organisation from 1980-1986, a time of volatility that featured the repercussions of the second oil shock, the devaluation of the dollar in 1984, the end of the Muldoon era, and the economic reforms of the 1980s.

Mr Galvin, who came from a staunch Irish Catholic background, had a strong sense of social justice and was highly intelligent, Mr Whitehead said.

“He did try very hard to encourage economic debate within the organisation, and much of the work that informed the 1984 Budget was done under his watch, and with his active leadership.

“His time in what became the Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet was really groundbreaking,” Mr Whitehead said. “He and Robert Muldoon invented it, and he staffed it with the best people he could find. The agency did make a material difference in ensuring that the public sector worked more closely together.

“He will be remembered with great admiration and much affection.”

One of our greatest public servants.

New Deputy Police Commissioner

Judith Collins has announced:

Viv Rickard has been appointed the Deputy Commissioner of Police (Resource Management), Police Minister Judith Collins announced today.

Deputy Commissioner Rickard (Te Arawa, Ngati Porou and Ngati Whare) was previously Assistant Commissioner, National Operations at Police National Headquarters in Wellington.

The Governor-General makes the appointment on the recommendation of the Prime Minister. The appointment is for a five-year term which begins today.

“Deputy Commissioner Rickard is a hugely respected Police officer who brings 25 years’ experience, including nine years on the Police Executive, to this important role,” Ms Collins said.

My understanding is that this appointment will be well received by police officers.

Rickard also becomes the first Maori New Zealander to reach the rank of Deputy Commissioner in the Police.

Further on bot

Thanks to the many people who e-mailed or commented regarding my bot request. Rather than reply individually (yet), I figured I would explain more about what I was thinking of.

Tumeke, Open Parachute and Half Done all publish ratings of NZ blogs. A great service they provide, and I hate to think how much time it takes up.

The Tumeke ratings are based on:

  1. Daily visits
  2. Technorati links
  3. Average posts/week
  4. Average most comments on a post/week

Half Done ratings are based on:

  1. Alexa global rating
  2. Alexa NZ rating
  3. Technorati authority score (no of incoming links)

Open Parachute ratings are based on:

  1. Visits/Month
  2. Page Views/Month

What I have in mind is a ratings site which combines the best of all three sites using a bot that could scan all NZ blog sites and pull up data for each blog from publicly available sources so that people don’t have to spend hours and hours producing the ratings. What are the criteria I would use:

Visits

  1. Total Visits for Month – this is the hard one. This data can be reverse engineered from Alexa but Alexa isn’t the most reliable. If sites use Sitemeter, then this could be automatically read, and Alexa is no Sitemeter.
  2. Total Page Views for Month – as above
  3. Total Unique Visitors for Month would also be useful, but unlikely to be available without access to Google Analytics for a site

Links

  1. Alexa Sites Linking In
  2. Technorati authority score

Posts

  1. No of posts in the month

Comments

  1. No of comments in the month
  2. Average comments/post
  3. No of unique commenters

One could then develop a formula along the lines of calculating each stat as a percentage of the average for that stat over all blogs. So if the average no of posts in a month is 50 and you post 150, then your score is 3.0 (or 300%).

Finally you’d weight the criteria. I’d suggest:

  1. Visits 40%
  2. Links 25%
  3. Post 20%
  4. Comments 15%

One could also weight the sub-categories if you really wanted to.

So the idea is that one could just feed a list of sites into the bot, and hey presto it would dig up the raw data which could be exported to Excel, where they could be converted to scores and ratings.

I don’t have a budget for this, as it is non profit. So my preference is bored geeks wanting a challenge. If none of them exist :-), then I can probably throw some dollars at it, but it won’t be a lot.

Feedback is also welcome on the proposed data to be collected, and suggested scoring and weightings.

Greens Selection and Ranking

I blogged previously about how some Green Party members had taken out advertisements in newspapers urging members to support a rule change requiring the members to have more say in the ranking of the Green List. At the moment their involvement is at the discretion of the Executive.

I’ve now got a copy of the current “process” for Green candidate selection and list ranking. It is attached here – GP Candidate Selection and List Ranking process April 2007-1

This is not part of the constitution adopted by the members. Unlike National, which has almost all parts of the process in the party’s rules, the Greens have left it up to the ruling Executive to determine the rules and process. Very top heavy for a party that claims the opposite.

First the Executive established a Candidate Selection and List Ranking Committee. Now in National the List Ranking Committee has two thirds of its members appointed directly by grassroots members at party conferences.

The Greens Executive appoints the entire Candidate Selection and List Ranking Committee.

This committee has the power to block a member from being a candidate if they do not think candidates will make a positive contribution to the Greens.

This is considerably more centralised than in National. The National Board does have a veto over candidates, but it is used very very rarely and only for patently unsuitable candidates – normally if people have criminal offending etc.

The interviews with potential candidates to determine suitability are done at local level with a pre-selection committee of nine, five being electorate members, two regional reps and two national reps. The locals have the majority on the pre-selection committee.

So in two major ways the Greens are significantly more centralised than National.

Then we have their list ranking. They have three stages of list ranking, compared to two for National. National is:

  1. Regional rankings done by grassroots delegates at party conferences
  2. The five regional lists are combined into one national list, and adjusted, by the national list ranking committee – two thirds of whim are elected by grassroot delegates at regional conferences.

The Greens process is:

  1. An initial rating by the Co-Leaders, Co-convenors, Policy Co-convenors, Candidates and one or two delegates from each electorate. (Rather weird to have candidates themselves voting)
  2. A ranked list is sent out to all members, who rank the candidates. The inital rankings are very influential, but members sometimes change them (for example they promoted Mike Ward last time).
  3. The Executive on the advice of the CSLRC can then adjust the result of the member’s ballot.

I do like giving all members the vote, and think this is good. Easier to do of course in a smaller party.

Now in terms of what these adjustments are, the Executive has left no room for doubt. They have quotas for everything. The Executive has decreed the following:

  1. a minimum of 10% of candidates shall be of Maori descent
  2. a maximum of 60% of candidates shall be male; a maximum of 60% of candidates shall be female
  3. a minimum of 40% of candidates shall be from the North Island; a minimum of 20% of candidates shall be from the South Island
  4. a minimum of 10% of candidates shall be under 40

Overall the Executive is very powerful. They appoint the CSLRC which can stop a member from being a candidate, and gets the final say on the party list.

But it doesn’t stop there. The entire process is at their discretion. Again, in National there are scores and scores of rules spelling out how candidate selection and list ranking works. The Executive has to follow these rules. In the Greens, the Executive has basically unfettered discretion.

The fact some members have taken to advertising in newspapers for a rule change, suggests a few members want this changed.

Small on Key

Vernon Small writes:

It is hard to know whether to laugh, cry – or maybe cross your legs – when the prime minister is prepared to reveal off the cuff at a press conference that he has had a vasectomy.

Like his “joke” about being on the menu at a Tuhoe dinner, it has gone around the world, but this time he hit the right note.

It is testament to his extraordinary confidence and openness – unless you are so cynical as to think it was planned – that he is prepared to take such risks in the interest of a self-described “self- deprecating” joke.

His skill and wit may not be as sharp as David Lange’s, but he has the same ability to beguile his listeners. Unlike Lange, he rarely if ever turns his wit on others in a cruel way.

Which is one of the reasons he is very popular. I’ve never detected in Key the contempt and hatred for his opponents, that often exists amongst Prime Ministers.

It must be the cruellest cut of all for Labour that, at a time when the Government is on the back foot over so many issues – from the impact of the Budget on middle-income families to mining on conservation land to the seemingly transparent “blind trust” Mr Key’s lawyers have constructed for him – he can still ooze such easy ordinariness.

His approach – apparently instinctive – is not, as many would have it, simply a willingness to take calculated risks. It has now become an integral part of “brand Key”: ability mixed with the everyday; a man who can run the country and – that most valuable of attributes for many Kiwis – not be up himself.

I recall a few months after the election a couple of gallery journos saying how Key hasn’t changed at all since becoming Prime Minister. They were expecting him to do so, but he hadn’t.

If the normal rules of politics apply, Mr Key’s greatest asset will in time, as voters tire, become his greatest weakness. What is charming will become glib, what is light-hearted will become clownish and a light touch will become lightweight.

There is a risk there, but Key can also do serious. At business meetings especially I’ve seen him talk about business and economic issues with a level of detail I doubt any other PM could ever meet.

Messsage for Monty

Editorials 3 June 2010

The Herald wants an FTA with Russia given priority:

Last year, New Zealand exports to Russia were worth $187 million, a modest sum even if well up on the $51 million of a decade earlier. As Russia has a population of 142 million, those figures hint at the potential of a free-trade pact.

But more telling still is the fact that not so long ago, New Zealand enjoyed thriving commercial arrangements with the former Soviet Union despite an often strained diplomatic relationship, not least over the invasion of Afghanistan.

But Keith Locke supported that invasion, so maybe we should make Keith the free trade negotiator for Russia 🙂

The Press supports the creation of a new bank:

The proposal to merge three finance organisations to create a new locally owned bank is a timely one.

For the finance institutions themselves, it is an opportunity, driven by necessity, to turn themselves into stronger, more robust entities, particularly after the turmoil of the last three years or so.

For investors, looking to diversify their investments away from the great Kiwi stand-by, domestic real estate, it could provide a worthwhile and productive place to put their money.

And for borrowers, particularly small-business owners who have complained of being cold-shouldered by unsympathetic banks during the financial crisis, it could provide a friendlier, more knowledgeable lender to local business. …

The three entities involved – Pyne Gould Corporation’s finance arm Marac Finance, the Canterbury Building Society and the Southern Cross Building Society – are established names in finance.

They have not been unscathed by the upheavals of the financial crisis, but they have survived it with credit ratings still at very respectable levels for non-bank institutions.

Two have BB+ ratings and the other a BB rating, which is at the high end for entities that are not banks.

But still not great. The acceptable grades are:

  • AAA : the best quality borrowers, reliable and stable (many of them governments)
  • AA : quality borrowers, a bit higher risk than AAA
  • A : economic situation can affect finance
  • BBB : medium class borrowers, which are satisfactory at the moment
  • BB : more prone to changes in the economy
  • B : financial situation varies noticeably

Once you start to get into CCC and below, institutions are officially vulnerable.

The Dom Post talks off shore drilling:

But for recent events in the Gulf of Mexico, the Government would be making more of a fuss of Brazilian oil giant Petrobras’ decision to explore for oil and gas off the East Coast of the North Island.

The world’s fourth-biggest energy company, a world leader in offshore drilling, this week won the right to explore about half of the Raukumara Basin, which extends north and east of East Cape. The company will spend up to US$118 million (NZ$174m) over the next five years gathering seismic data and drilling an exploratory well.

The project will create jobs and draw international attention to New Zealand as a potential source of petroleum.

But the big gains will come if Petrobras makes a commercial find. Already the petroleum sector generates about $3 billion a year in export revenue. Energy Minister Gerry Brownlee has estimated that figure could rise to $30b by 2025 if preliminary estimates of New Zealand’s petroleum resources prove to be correct.

Which would make a huge difference to our standard of living, and ability to fund health and education services.

However, celebrations this week have been muted by the ongoing disaster in the Gulf of Mexico. Six weeks after an explosion on BP’s Deepwater Horizon rig killed 11 workers, the well 1.6 kilometres beneath the sea is continuing to spew between 1.9b and 3b litres of oil a day into the gulf, polluting the fragile Louisiana coastline, threatening fisheries and destroying the livelihoods of fishermen and tourist operators.

For that reason it is essential that the promised overhaul of New Zealand’s health, safety and environmental arrangements for offshore petroleum operations is completed well before any deepwater drilling begins.

Agreed.

The ODT looks at Facebook and privacy:

Facebook, once a small, “free” social networking site for university undergraduates to share personal information, has become a vast subdivision on the information super highway.

It is expected soon to reach a landmark figure of 500 million registered users.

This would make it the third largest country on Earth, bigger than all but India and China.

On Monday this week – “Quit Facebook Day” – Canadian campaigners urged people worldwide to remove themselves from the site.

They, and many others, were riled about the way in which they felt their privacy was being purloined for profit.

Quite why they should have been so surprised is another matter: you do not pay upfront to belong to Facebook, but the company must make ends meet – and a tidy profit – somehow.

That “somehow” is no great secret.

The site sells advertising to companies tailored to the defined demographics of its users.

The “footprint” they create in their Facebook activities is like gold to advertisers and marketers who will pay accordingly.

I was talking last night to someone about Facebook, with the idea being that if a user is aged under 18 then their privacy settings are set by default to not share data with anyone but friends.

The funeral crasher

The Dom Post reports:

A fake mourner who repeatedly gatecrashed Wellington funerals was so keen on the food that he brought along tupperware containers to fill up and take home.

The “grim eater” attended up to four funerals a week during March and April before he was stopped.

+1 for ingenuity
-1 for tackiness

The man, thought to be aged in his 40s, went to different churches and venues around the eastern suburbs, including Miramar, Rongotai and Kilbirnie.

“We saw him three or four times in a week. And certainly he had a backpack with some tupperware containers so when people weren’t looking, he was stocking up.”

The man was “always very quiet and polite, and did as the rest of the mourners did in paying his respects”.

I would have thought it is easier to get food from the City Mission, than crashing funerals.

He stopped coming after one staff member took the man aside, telling him he could still come to funerals but could not take food home with him.

But was he allowed to fill himself up during the service?

Naked revenue gathering

The Dom Post reports:

Speeding motorists used to driving 10kmh over the maximum speed limit will not get away with it this weekend, as police trial a zero tolerance policy to cut road deaths.

Police say New Zealand’s 10 per cent tolerance zone is higher than other countries, and cutting it could help change the attitudes of motorists who claim lives.

How many road deaths are caused by people driving at 56 km/hr in a 50 zone? Or 106 kmhr on a multi-lane motorway?

This is naked revenue gathering, which will see thousands of people fined for driving just over the speed limit, unaware that the tolerance has been lowered.

I supported a lowered tolerance around school buses and crossings. There t makes sense. Hell I tend to slow down to 30 km/hr around a school bus or crossing.

But a blanket lowering of the tolerance is about meeting ticket and/or revenue quotas.

The Automobile Association predicts the move will anger motorists unaware of the change, or driving with inaccurate speedometers.However, as another life was lost on our roads yesterday, national road policing manager Superintendent Paula Rose said police needed new weapons to change driver behaviour. “There can be no excuses. We are killing our people and we want it to stop.”

Bullshit. Road safety policy is a balance between safety and convenience. If the only focus was the road toll, then we would simply have a law requiring all vehicles to be fitted with a device that limits the maximum speed to 30 km/hr.

What I want to hear from the Police is the research they have done to conclude that lowering the threshold (which has been in place for around 30+ years) will be effective.

AA motoring affairs manager Mike Noon agreed that roads had to be made safer, but said the tolerance existed to allow for speedometer error, which could occur when motorists changed their tyres.

Speedometers were not checked during warrant tests and it would be difficult for motorists to measure such small speed differences.

To keep within the zone, they could end up spending more time on the wrong side of the road while passing, so police would need to enforce the change carefully, Mr Noon said.

The Police don’t eve use discretion any more for people passing slow moving traffic, even though it is basically impossible to do it legally. If a vehicle is driving at 90 km/hr, you will need two kms of clear road to safely pass them without exceeding 100 km/hr.

I am dismayed that once again changes are being made to road safety enforcement, that is not backed up by research showing this is a problem area. The Government is going for the easy targets, not the effective ones.

First they banned cellphones in cars, despite the research showing other distractions cause more accidents.

Secondly they seem highly likely to lower the blood alcohol limit from 0.08 to 0.05 despite the research showing only one death from drivers aged over 25 with a blood level between 0.05 and 0.08.

And now they have decided that the real problems out there are the motorists going 5 km/hr hour over the posted speed limit, who must be fined and demerited. Despite the fact I can guarantee you the number of accidents caused by people driving 5 km/hr over the speed limit on straight roads is minimal.

And what is the bet that if these measures don’t work, we will be told then even more measures are needed.