Anderton for Christchurch Mayor?

The Press reports:

Political veteran Jim Anderton may yet run for the Christchurch mayoralty after earlier ruling it out.

Speculation is rife over who will be the Left-leaning 2021 group’s candidate to stand against Mayor Bob Parker.

Anderton yesterday refused to say if his name would be on the ballot.

“I can’t rule it out, and it is not ruled in either,” he said.

Despite being aged 72, Anderton would be a strong challenger to Bob Parker. If he won, I expect Megan Woods to stand for Labour in the by-election.

It would e very interesting for the City Councillors if Anderton did become Mayor. Anderton is well known as an autocrat who hates dissent, and believes decisions are best made by him, not by a Caucus. He even left his own party he founded because they refused to hand over supreme power to him.

So an Anderton-led Council could be a fairly unpleasant experience – not for the Opposition Councillors, but for his own team.

A new record for NZ media whore

Cameron Brewer is well known as the ranking media whore in New Zealand. His ability to get his name or the name of the Newmarket Business Association in the media is legendary.

I think he may have set a new record with this story though:

Ross Bay was yesterday ordained Anglican Bishop of Auckland.

His ordination and installation as 11th Anglican Bishop of Auckland took place in Parnell’s Holy Trinity Cathedral in front of about 1000 people.

Cameron Brewer, chief executive of the Newmarket Business Association, described Bishop Bay’s rise in the church as “meteoric”

He’s even worked himself into a story on the new Bishop of Auckland. Amazing.

The penis is too large

The Waikato Times reports that Phillip Stevens thinks the pictured genitals are too large:

His nine-year-old son had noticed the carvings as they entered the garden. “He asked us `is that a penis?’,” said Mr Stevens. “It was pretty obvious what it was, but as you go on there’s one with big testicles, then there’s one holding it. We tried not to make too big a deal of it, and just told them it was a bit inappropriate.”

He said nude works from European art traditions would not offend him in the same way as the genitalia were of more natural proportions.

So the problem is not having genitals on the carving, but that they were out of proportion!

A definite case of showing that size does matter.

Super Mum

Had a great night last night at a friend’s 50th birthday party. Shirley has always been one of these super mums, who just copes with everything including four kids. I remember once being at her place and she is simultaneously cooking dinner, making sandwiches for lunches the next day, mediating arguments between a couple of kids, making sure others are leaving the house with the right gear, and also the kids having three or four friends there too, so the general noise level resembled a rock concert. I would not have lasted half an hour.

Anyway just had to share a great story from her eldest, Katherine, which was regaled to use last night, that summed Shirley up perfectly. A few years ago Katherine was due at a recital, where she was to play the violin. She was due there at 7 pm for a 7.30 pm start and there had been huge delays due to a crash, so it was 7.25 pm and she was almost there when a police car pulled out and signalled them to pull over.

Katherine related how Shirley not only pulled over quickly, she jumped out of the car, ran towards the Police car hammering the windows. As we don’t live in the US, the officer didn’t shoot her, but wound down the window to have Shirley exclaim “Daughter due at violin recital, can’t be late, just wait here please and I’ll be back”. Shirley then jumped back in the car and took off down the road leaving behind a rather speechless officer.

20 minutes later Shirley returned to the spot, having got Katherine there just on time, to be annoyed the officer was no longer there. No doubt he decided one encounter was enough!

Just as amusing, for me, was when we left and my mate Chris was trying to wind Katherine up by suggesting that her brother David gave a better speech than her. Katherine’s response was along the lines of “But you’re a ginga, so who cares what you think”. Chris had no comeback to this.

The 11th Doctor

Grant Smithies at the SST writes:

I can happily report that he’s right. As a former fan who grew up during the reign of the second and third Doctors, Patrick Troughton (1966-1969) and Jon Pertwee (1970-1974), and who has watched the show intermittently ever since, I’d even stick my neck out and say Smith is the best Doctor I’ve seen. Better, even, than Tennant, the actor credited with revitalising the franchise.

I concur. Matt Smith is brilliant in the role. May he remain the Doctor for many years.

“The Eleventh Hour” was smart, it was scary, it was hilarious, it was even sexy; Doctor Who’s new companion Amy Pond (played by Scottish actress Karen Gillan) is hot beyond belief.

Amelia Pond may prove to be one of the most favoured companions. Romana is still my No 1, followed by Rose Tyler. Oh and K9 of course!

And yes Gillan is very hot. She makes gingas look good 🙂

ACTA goes public

Computerworld reports:

A controversial plan to crack down on online piracy and counterfeiting will be opened up to public scrutiny for the first time next week, when the negotiating text of a secret international copyright treaty will be made public, the European Commission said on Friday.

Negotiations over the past two years have been conducted in secret. Leaks of the draft text have sparked a public outcry, mainly because of how the text deals with online copyright infringement.

Countries involved in talks on the Anti-counterfeiting Trade Agreement (ACTA) agreed unanimously to make the documents available to the public at a meeting in New Zealand this week, the Commission said in a statement.

This is excellent news and a real win for those who have been pushing for transparency. Having the draft text out there helps people make informed submissions.

However, they don’t plan to reveal their individual negotiating positions.

Which would be useful also. However the release of a draft text means the Government can be asked questions relating to that text.

Mayor Jesus

The HoS reports:

North Shore Mayor Andrew Williams is facing fresh criticism after comparing himself to Jesus on the cross.

In an email about reports he urinated on a tree after drinking at a Takapuna restaurant, he wrote to councillors: “Two people were crucified at Easter – and one of them is me.”

And the SST:

“I now know how General Custer felt surrounded by a thousand Indians wanting his blood. But on this occasion me thinks that right will win through and the `dark forces’ will eventually be put down.”

Jesus and General Custer? So that is General Jesus Williams?

Whale Oil has obliged by providing a photo of General Williams.

Boy

Went with Auckland Girl to the movies last night to celebrate her 25th birthday, and saw Boy. I’d heard from several people it was very good but hadn’t planned to go out of my way to see it.

I was very glad I did see it as it was a quite delightful and entertaining film.

Most of all though, it was so powerfully New Zealand. Not just the Maori dimension, but everything from the tools in the garage, to the remote dairy, to the cars, to the landscapes, to the cannabis plantations.

Michael Jackson and Billy T James as cultural icons added humour to the film, and make sure you don’t leave the moment the credits start.

James Rolleston showed real talent as “Boy” and I also liked Taika Waititi’s depiction of his father. Not a hero, but not a total villain. In many ways a loser, but also moments of him being a great dad, when he played storm the barricades with Boy.

Waititi also wrote and directed the film. He is definitely a growing talent and I’d go see another of his films.

The Brooklyn Wind Turbine

The Dom Post reports:

The fate of Wellington’s Brooklyn wind turbine swings in the balance.

The 17-year-old turbine, New Zealand’s oldest and first commercially viable one, has not been operating for four months, as some of the machinery needs repair.

Meridian is reviewing whether it should repair, replace or remove the turbine, and plans to ask the community to help decide its fate.

For my 2c I think the turbine is a great icon for Windy Wellington, and it s a great excuse to take visitors up to its location to admire the view. I hope Meridian do keep it going.

The Cullen Fund

Vernon Small at the Dom Post reports:

Halting contributions to the Cullen superannuation fund has cost the taxpayer more than $30 million.

If full contributions had been maintained, it would have earned almost $50m more, calculations based on the fund’s returns to the end of January show.

Even accounting for the extra borrowing costs the Government would have faced to keep up contributions, that would still have netted taxpayers about $1m a week during the past eight months.

First of all, it has not “cost” the taxpayer anything. The taxpayer may have been able to make a gain of $30 million if it had borrowed more money, for the fund to invest. That is certainly true, but it is a potential gain only.

You can not automatically assume that any additional investments would have achieved the same return as the existing investments. An extra $2 billion may have been invested in a stock that did not do so well, or may have meant a higher average price for buying such stock.

It is fair enough to talk about a potential gain or that was missed, but that is not the same thing as stating that potential gain as a loss let alone a cost. That is a sloppy short cut.

Also it is worth reminding people that reward is always linked to risk. One could borrow $10 billion a year to invest in stocks, and probably get a good return on them. But it would also be risky.

What we don’t know if whether or not we would have got a credit downgrade, if the Government decided to continue to borrow money to invest. And if we had, then that would have had a very real cost on every New Zealander.

It is also worth noting that over the entire life of the fund, the rate of return is still below the risk free rate of return. The NZ economy would be hundreds of millions of dollars better off if the fund had never been set up, and the money used to repay debt.

Key counsels Harper on sex scandals

Amused to read this by Audrey Young:

How did you feel about being caught up in the middle of an incredible scandal in Canada?

Well, given that it dominated all the questions on the Canadian side [of the press conference], it shows that universally sex sells. I don’t even claim to understand it nor could I even understand the question, given that it was in French. But it sounds interesting.

Perhaps Prime Minister Stephen Harper asked for your advice because you sacked a minister, Richard Worth, last year and didn’t tell the media why?

It wasn’t lost on me that there were similarities.

Did you pass that on to Mr Harper?

I did actually.

I always wondered with Prime Ministers talked about when thet got together. It seems is it something like this:

NZ PM: Well I had one Minister who had this thing for Asian women – he even tried sleeping with a Labour Party candidate.

Canadian PM: Ha – I can beat that. I had a female Minister who was arranging threesomes with prostitutes for her and her husband.

NZ PM: But my one used taxpayer money to fly his girls to Wellington

Canadian PM: Well my one used her own money, but to buy cocaine

NZ PM: Okay, you win

Back to Audrey’s story:

The King of Jordan came over and saw me. He has absolutely perfect English. Obviously educated in England, in one of those public schools I’d say.

A very English accent. He said to me he’s keen to come to New Zealand. He wants to bring his motorbike and drive down the South Island. He’s apparently famous for it. He apparently drives his protection people absolutely crazy.

Heh I can just imagine it – the King of Jordan hooning along the South Island. And with diplomatic immunity I’m guessing he’ll be doing 200 km/hr on the Canterbury Plains.

President Ron Paul?

Fans of libertarian Ron Paul have got very excited by this Rasmussen poll:

Pit maverick Republican Congressman Ron Paul against President Obama in a hypothetical 2012 election match-up, and the race is – virtually dead even.

A new Rasmussen Reports national telephone survey of likely voters finds Obama with 42% support and Paul with 41% of the vote. Eleven percent (11%) prefer some other candidate, and six percent (6%) are undecided.

Could a 77 year old libertarian from Texas really beat Obama?

Five Thirty Eight puts it into context:

But as regular readers of this website will know, the person conducting the poll can have a profound impact on its results. Rasmussen, in particular, has had a substantial Republican-leaning house effect thus far this year. Perhaps they will turn out to be right (although their idea of trying to apply a “likely voter” model 2.5 years in advance of an election is dubious). But it would be wrong to take a Rasmussen poll (or any other) at face value without taking into account this context. …

After adjustment for house effects, Obama’s lead over Paul is not 1 point but more like 10. This result is closer to that obtained by a PPP poll in November, which had Obama ahead 46-38 against Paul (PPP’s 2012 polls have also had a very slight Republican-leaning house effect.)

Paul’s 9.9-point deficit is not awful — it’s better than of Newt Gingrich (-12.2), Jeb Bush (-13.4) or Sarah Palin (-14.4) do — but lags behind the performance of Mitt Romney, who is just 5.6 points behind, or Mike Huckabee, who is down 6.6. It also lags behind the performance of a so-called generic Republican, who is actually slightly ahead of Obama.

This is what is interesting. A generic Republican candidate beats Obama by 1.9%. But the moment you name a specific candidate, Obama leads by 5% or more. At this stage I think Obama will be re-elected – due to the lack of electable Republican candidates. But if they do find someone without serous baggage, then it is definitely game on.

Back to the Rasmussen poll, the Tea Party movement gets stronger:

Twenty-four percent (24%) of voters now consider themselves a part of the Tea Party movement, an eight-point increase from a month ago. Another 10% say they are not a part of the movement but have close friends or family members who are.

The TP movement was derided or ignored for months, but it has become the most powerful grass roots movement in recent times. It dwarves liberal counterparts such as Move On.

When it comes to major issues confronting the nation, 48% of voters now say the average Tea Party member is closer to their views than Obama is. Forty-four percent (44%) hold the opposite view and believe the president’s views are closer to their own.

Again, there may be some house bias, but that is still a powerful result.

Rudd’s PMs Office

The Daily Telegraph reports:

KEVIN Rudd has downplayed reports he and his ministers treat staff like dogs as a near-record employee burnout of almost 60 per cent in just more than two years has been revealed.

Despite Mr Rudd pledging to tear up former prime minister John Howard’s hated WorkChoices, 262 ministerial staff – from a total of 444 positions – have departed since Labor came to office.

Three ministers have recorded staff turnover of more than 100 per cent, with Youth and Sport Minister Kate Ellis having 13 departures from a staff of 10. At least one was a part-time university student while several others left to have families.

The Prime Minister himself has lost 28 staff, with Government insiders describing his office as resembling a “transit lounge”.

Rudd is well known as being near impossible to work for. He dreams up crazy ideas and demands they are implemented within days, and has temper tantrums when they are not. His own colleagues resent his style, almost as much as his staff do.

But Mr Rudd said the high pressure of a political office meant it couldn’t be compared to the private sector.

“It’s a tough life. People often have to relocate, there are crazy hours, it’s very intense, people are on the phone wanting X, Y and Z done in a short period of time,” he told Fairfax radio today.

“But I go back to the simple fact: We are elected by the Australian people to do a job.”A staff working year is probably like a dog year, that is it’s probably worth seven years in normal life.

“So if folks stay with me for three or four years, that’s probably 28 or 30 years or more in actual time.”

This is spin. Jobs in Parliament are definitely tough with long hours and an ever changing array of issues. And MPs demands can be frustrating as travel and appointments often change at the last minute. This is why the turnover rate is higher than the normal 10% private sector.

However 60% over two years is very high for any Ministerial office, let alone the PMs Office. The PMs Office is sort of top of the food chain, and it has to be pretty bad for people to leave the office after just a year or two. Most people wait for an election.

Taking John Key’s office as a comparison, I think John has had only two staff leave in two years. One to go overseas and one to have a baby. So Rudd’s claim of a 60% departure rate being normal, is not the case.

Some former staff are privately seething at his management style, claiming he can fly off the handle at a moment’s notice.

Never good to have former staff slag you off. Most former staff of a PM stay ferociously loyal.

Brooklyn Group CEO Brian Russell also queried why Government advisers had left in droves.

`You shouldn’t be having 100 per cent turnover in any team. If you’ve got autocratic management, lack of direction – basic fundamentals – especially in a small group, people will leave,” he said.

Bingo.

Editorials 16 April 2010

The NZ Herald looks at Canada’s dole:

New Zealand is somewhat unusual among OECD nations in having a non-contributory scheme that pays unemployment benefits directly from general taxation. But it shares a common need to seek ways of reducing unsustainable welfare spending, and to encouraging the jobless to return quickly to the workforce.

For those reasons, it is more than appropriate that the recently established Welfare Working Group will look at alternative means of financing unemployment compensation, including those based on pre-funding some benefits through insurance. Most notably, this will involve the examination of Canada’s employment insurance scheme.

The group’s chairwoman, Paula Rebstock, has already pointed out one obvious benefit of such insurance. “Right now, if you are in a relationship with someone and you become unemployed, the chances are you would not be entitled to a social welfare benefit,” she noted. “But if you are involved in an insurance scheme and you have contributed then you would also be in receipt of an unemployment benefit for a period.”

A very worthwhile point.

In Canada, workers pay premiums of 1.73 per cent of insured earnings for benefits if they lose their jobs, and employers contribute 1.4 times the value of employee premiums. The amount received by an unemployed worker and how long they can stay on the insurance depends on their previous salary, how long they were working and the local unemployment rate. The scheme is operated by Service Canada, a government agency, and sits alongside the welfare system, as would be the case if it were adopted in this country.

Just so long as we don’t get ACC to run it!

The Dom Post warns “celebrity” directors:

News this week that the Securities Commission has filed civil proceedings in the High Court at Wellington against four finance company directors – including two former justice ministers – highlights yet again the risks associated with celebrity endorsements.

They have also filed criminal proceedings.

If mum-and-dad investors need to do more due diligence, not only about the independence of the financial advisers they consult but also about the companies they might invest in, the so-called celebrities who lend their names to the letterheads of those companies need to do so, too.

Reputation is everything to those with integrity. To have one’s name dragged through the courts is unpleasant, undignified, and undoes all that went into creating a reputation in the first place. Sir Douglas and Mr Jeffries will be most unhappy this week. Former deputy prime minister Wyatt Creech and former police minister John Luxton, too, must rue the day they agreed to serve on the Blue Chip board, even though they quit before it went under. Famous one-time All Black Sir Colin Meads surely squirmed when Provincial Finance, about which he said publicly: “Solid as, I’d say”, keeled over.

Due diligence is all important. I’ve been on a panel interviewing prospective company directors and the good ones turn the interview around and do due diligence on the company to make sure it is a company they wish to be on the board of.

The ODT remembers closing the gaps:

In 1999, the Labour Party threw into its election campaign mix the policy objective of diminishing the widening gulf between Pakeha New Zealanders and those of Maori or Pacific Island ethnicity – as evidenced in a variety of well-publicised statistics.

These included prison populations, employment figures, health outcomes, income levels, educational achievement, and intergenerational benefit dependency in all of which areas Maori and Pasifika peoples were shown to fare poorly compared to the rest of the population. It labelled the policy it would devise to address such disadvantage “Closing the Gaps”. …

In practice, it seems funds which would otherwise be distributed through a range of social services will be channelled through centralised Whanau Ora providers in an holistic approach to troubled and vulnerable families’ needs – bulk funding for social betterment.

This may erase some duplication of administration costs, but is equally likely to prove problematic in monitoring and measuring effectiveness. It is also unclear at this point just what the policy will cost.

An end to taxpayer funded pledge cards

Over at NBR (subscriber section) I blog:

Documents released under the Official Information Act this week reveal that both the Cabinet and the Parliamentary Service Commission have approved a law change to amend the Parliamentary Service Act 2000, to prevent a repeat of electioneering materials such as Labour’s 2005 pledge card being funded by the taxpayer.

This will be welcome by many, especially when you realise the current law.

The current law still allows Parliament to fund blatant electioneering material so long as it does not explicitly solicit votes. A parliamentary party could spend half a million dollars on billboards and newspaper ads promoting their election promises in the week before the election, and send the taxpayer the bill – even though Parliament had been dissolved a month earlier.

I expect we will see a bill implementing the change in the next few weeks.

Full details of the proposed change are at NBR.

Canadian Dairy Industry

Audrey Young reports:

New Zealand does not want Canada joining negotiations for the Trans Pacific Partnership agreement because Canada wants dairy products exempted from any deal, Prime Minister John Key said in Ottawa last night.

“The sticking point is Canada wants to exclude dairy, and that would be unacceptable to us,” Mr Key told the Herald.

I did not realise how protected Canadian dairy is until I read:

Canada, which has about 13,000 dairy farmers, runs what is called a supply management framework to control supply and demand and it even runs a quota system for cows. Farmers cannot just increase their herds if they want.

Good God. Canada runs it dairy system, like NZ runs it schools!!

Telecom’s woes

The Herald reports:

Telecom plans to slash 200 management jobs by mid-year, and more lay-offs are likely as the company seeks to slash its costs.

Never good when a company cuts jobs, but often necessary. Very tough on those in the affected areas.

The job losses within its 8000-person workforce are part of a programme announced last year that aims to slice more than $500 million from the business’s costs by 2013.

Mr Reynolds said $113 million had been cut last year, and a further $244 million was expected to be cut this financial year.

200 out of 8,000 is 1 in 40 jobs gone, but as they are all management jobs, then the ratio will be considerably lower.

In a related story:

Telecom is seeking relief from the Government on its regulatory obligations in the face of pressure on earnings.

I’m somewhat supportive of this, but the key is timing. As a fibre network is built, access to the copper legacy network will become less important, and access conditions can be reduced. But one needs that fibre network to be reasonably progressed, before one can start to strip back some of the copper network regulation.

UPDATE:

Tom Pullar-Strecker writes in the Dom Post:

Telecom has caved in to Government pressure and will consider splitting into two separate companies.

This would make it more likely that the Government’s $1.5 billion plan to roll out ultrafast broadband to three-quarters of homes will get off the ground.

I’m not sure it makes the fibre to the home plan more likely. I think it makes Telecom’s chances of winning the bids more likely.

After playing chicken with the Government over the ultrafast broadband contract, chief executive Paul Reynolds blinked first and said the company was open to working with the Government on a “full range of approaches”.

I’m not sure I quite read that as saying they will consider splitting. If Telecom is open to spinning Chorus off (which would be a good thing), they should make it clear, as it will improve their chances (in my opinion) with the fibre to the home initiative.

Driving License Changes

The Herald reports:

The minimum legal driving age could yet rise to 17, after the Government moved yesterday to have it raised from from 15 to 16 by the middle of next year.

The Cabinet yesterday approved the rise to 16, which is part of the Government’s 2010-20 Safer Journeys project.

The project also includes encouraging 120 hours of supervised driving for a restricted licence; learner drivers now do about 50 hours.

Young drivers could also face restrictions on how powerful their cars can be, and tougher penalties for breaching restricted licence conditions.

I think the move to 16 is sound, especially as the school leaving age is no longer 15. It also is more consistent with the general regime we have that young NZers get a partial set of rights at 16 (sex, driving, marriage with parental consent etc) and get most of their full rights at 18 (voting, drinking etc).

The 120 hours of supervised driving to get a restricted is sensible also.

C&R Candidates for Auckland Council

This morning Citizens & Ratepayers announced an initial 11 candidates for the Auckland Council. They are:

Albany Ward

Linda Cooper is a current Waitakere City Councillor and was second highest polling in her ward. A former nurse.

Josephine Kim was the first Korean women to gain a NZ law degree

Albert-Eden-Roskill

Chris Fletcher is the former Auckland Mayor, and quite a coup for C&R that she is standing on their ticket.

Paul Goldsmith is a current Auckland City Councillor.

Franklin

Des Morrison, of Nga Puhi affiliation, worked for NZ Steel for 32 years and is currently on the Frankin District Council, where he was second highest polling in his ward.

Maungakiekie-Tamaki

Alfred Ngaro is a New Zealander of Cook Island descent and people tell me he is a real star in the mould of Sam Loti-Iiga. He has been active in the community sector for 20 years and has a huge network of people behind him. In 2009 Alfred Ngaro was awarded a Sir Peter Blake Emerging Leader Award for his contribution in the Tamaki Transformation Programme

Orakei

Doug Armstrong is in his third term on Auckland City Council and is well known in his role as Finance Committee Chair. A former CEO of Unitec.

Te Irirangi (Howick)

Dick Quax is also well known. He received 17,000 votes for Manukau Mayor and easily topped the poll for the Pakuranga ward.

Jami-Lee Ross is on the second term of the Manukau City Council, and is known for his tireless campaigning.

Waitemata and Gulf

Michael Barnett, the Auckland Chamber of Commerce CEO will probably be up against Mike Lee in a Battles of the Big Beasts. Michael has been a member of the Auckland Regional Council for several terms.

Whau

Noelene Raffills has been on the Auckland City Council since 2000 and was the top polling Councillor for the Avondale-Roskill Ward.

Not that I think it is a huge issue, but some try to portray C&R as all white men in suits. Of the 11 candidates, two are of Maori decent, one Korean and one Cook Islands. And 4/11 are women. Reasonably diverse.

Editorials 15 April 2010

The Herald enthuses over Queens Wharf:

It has been a long and tortuous road but, finally, an acceptable plan for the use of Queens Wharf during next year’s Rugby World Cup has been arrived at. “Party central” will be in a temporary structure on the site of one of the wharf’s two cargo sheds. This has two compelling pluses: the sprucing up of Queens Wharf for the Cup festivities for as low a cost as possible, and the demolition of both the unsightly sheds, an essential precursor to the wharf later being developed to its full potential.

All that is required for the World Cup celebrations is a gathering point. Little needs to be done. A temporary structure housing television screens and places for eating, drinking and dancing will suffice. Solidly constructed, it will easily withstand the buffeting of a wet and windy spring. The swept-up development advocated until recently by the Government was always unnecessary, as well as becoming constrained by time. It could also have resulted in the wharf’s final development being compromised for the benefit of a one-off event.

I tend to agree. People just need shelter, screens, sausages and drink and it will work.

The Dom Post calls on Australia to accept the WTO ruling on apples:

Australia has led New Zealand apple growers a merry dance for 89 years. Now the jig is up.

A World Trade Organisation disputes panel has found that Australian fears that fireblight, a bacterial disease found in some New Zealand orchards, can be transferred from mature New Zealand apples to Australian fruit trees are groundless.

It is past time for the Australian Government to show some leadership on the issue. The ruling is an embarrassment to a government that trumpets the cause of free trade in other arenas, Australian scientists who have lent legitimacy to an illegitimate argument and Aussie growers who appear to believe they cannot compete with their New Zealand counterparts.

Rather than prolong the process yet again, Australian officials and growers should sit down with their counterparts in New Zealand, agree a sensible regime, and develop a marketing strategy that will benefit growers on both sides of the Tasman.

Trans-Tasman believes that the Governments are working on an agreement which would be a good thing.

Private Prisons to return

Delighted to see the new Wiri prison will be openly tendered. Not only may it cost less, but more importantly it provides opportunities to have a lower escape rate, and a higher rehabilitation rate.

Now Labour have said:

Locking people up in jails is a job for the state, not for private businesses whose prime motivation will inevitably be to make money out of a PPP venture, says Labour Law and Order spokesperson Clayton Cosgrove.

As usual, they put ideology ahead of any potential gains. But let’s rewrite their press release to show how stupid their statement is:

Prosecuting criminals is a job for the state, not for private businesses whose prime motivation will inevitably be to make money out of prosecutions, says Labour Law and Order spokesperson Clayton Cosgrove.

Prosecutions are just as much a core part of the criminal justice system, as are prisons. And we already have what is effectively PPPs in the crown law system.

The Crown Law office sets policies and standards for prosecutions, but contracts private law firms to do most of the prosecutions. Those private law firms make money out this arrangement.So why is Labour not calling for prosecutions to be nationalised?

Labour’s great weakness is their inability to put aside ideology to do what is best.

Some may accuse National of doing the same, but I can point to a specific counter in the law & order field.

Criminal defence work is also effectively privatised at present. It is done by private lawyers and law firms. However National is supporting and expanding the Crown’s Public Defender Service, as it has found in this case it can produce better outcomes. This is effectively nationalising a small part of something that was previously done purely by the private sector.