McGee on Electoral Commission

Former Clerk of the House and expert on Parliament, David McGee, has done a submission on the Electoral (Administration) Bill – mainly focusing on whether the Electoral Commission should be an Officer of Parliament.

I suggest to the Committee that they should get advice from Mr McGee, and am glad they did – even though in this case his advice differs from my preference.

McGee says in his submission:

In my view there is no question as to the Electoral Commission being important enough to warrant Officer of Parliament status. The constitutional arguments for that status that have been made to the Committee are compelling. Nor would I see creating the Electoral Commission as an Officer of Parliament departing from the principle of conferring that status jealously. The fact that the Commission was an Officer of Parliament would not open the door for others to obtain that position inappropriately.

But he sees pragmatic, rather than constitutional, problems:

  1. The Commission delivers a programme – organising a general election, unlike other Officers of Parliament that are more Auditors or checks.
  2. It may politicise the role of Speaker (as responsible Minister) further, and also the Speaker can not be held responsible for their performance through oral questions.
  3. With three Commissioners, would the Commission itself or the Commissioners be the actual Officers of Parliament – not well suited for a board model.

On the assumption the Electoral Commission remains a Crown entity, McGee looks at the proposed method of appointment:

I consider that (if a mandatory judicial appointee is not to be retained) the members of the board should be appointed on the recommendation of the House. (This would replace the consultation proposal in new section 4D(4)). There is nothing inconsistent in an ICE or non-Officer of Parliament being appointed in this way. The Independent Police Conduct Authority and the Judicial Conduct Commissioner are appointed following a resolution of the House, yet neither is an Officer of Parliament.

Appointment by Parliament is preferable to appointment by Minister only.

The fact that appointment is statutorily made on the recommendation of the House does not in itself mean that that recommendation will be unanimous or even bi-partisan. It can still occur on a straight majority vote. But, in practice, this has not been the experience with such appointments. Prior consultation has smoothed the way for non-contested resolutions. It has been suggested to the Committee that there be provision for a “super-majority” of 75% agreement written into the legislation. This would certainly ensure that any appointee had the confidence of the larger parties at least and is consistent with other super-majority provisions (the reserved provisions) in the Electoral Act.

My strong preference is for a double super-majority of 75% of the parties and 75% of the MPs.

But I do not favour this. I think that the House (through the Standing Orders Committee) has an opportunity to develop a convention – essentially a protocol – on non-Officer of Parliament appointments which are made on the recommendation of the House. After all if an appointment is important enough to involve the House there should be some expectation that an attempt will be made to achieve consensus on the appointment. As long as this device is not over-used (and achieving consensus is not easy and could stymie the appointments process if attempted too frequently) it is worthwhile having in place an agreed process for consultation on potential appointees and an understanding that a name will only be proposed if there is a considerable element of cross-party (not necessarily unanimous) support.

This is an interesting alternative. I did not realise that at present there is no requirement for agreement (beyond a simple majority) for roles such as the Ombudsman, and Auditor-General.

While such a protocol would be useful, I don’t see it as an adequate substitute for an actual legislative requirement of wide-spread parliamentary agreement.

The reason for this is it is much harder to repeal law than it is to ignore a protocol. Up until 2007 there was a protocol that major changes to the Electoral Act were subject to bipartisan consultation and agreement. Labour annihilated this protocol in 2007, and while Simon Power has reinstituted it, I would rather have a legislative safeguard to bind his successors.

Spending transparency

One of the unusual things about the Heatley affair was that the detail of credit card use were supplied to the media in the first place. Under Labour, all attempts to gain this info had been rebuffed, as Tracy Watkins explains:

The shame is that any of this happened. It is not much of a reward for the Government remaining absolutely true to its promise of greater openness and transparency.

Requests under the Official Information Act for ministers’ credit card expenses have been made before. But what was new about this week’s release was the manner in which the information was provided. Minister’s credit card statements were supplied in their unvarnished form. Identical requests under the former government garnered nothing like the same level of disclosure; the information was supplied in table form, with totals ascribed to each minister and little more. The only checks that could be made were phone calls to individual ministers, asking them for an explanation as to why they had run up a particularly large bill in comparison to others.

The explanation from Internal Affairs was the way this particular request from The Dominion Post was worded. The more likely explanation is that ministerial credit card OIA’s, like most other skerricks of information relating to the last Labour government, had to pass through chief of staff Heather Simpson first. Ms Simpson’s iron fisted control and ability to spot a political bushfire from 100 miles away are legendary – she was so successful, National has adopted many of Labour’s strategies for political management. But in the case of this week’s OIA there was either a conscious decision made to set a new benchmark or National lacks anyone with the same powerful oversight and ruthless attention to detail as Ms Simpson.

But now the benchmark has been set, there is no going back. It opens the door to OIA’s for the unvarnished records of Labour ministers. But it would be surprising if it didn’t also make ministers think twice before they run up expenses on their credit card.

Perhaps the Dominion Post could reveal the exact wording they used, so that others can use it as a template!

A stupid idea

The Herald reports:

Australian Prime Minister Kevin Rudd says he will look into the idea of appointing an online ombudsman after Facebook tribute pages were defaced with pornography and offensive comments.

Pages set up to honour slain Queensland children Trinity Bates and Elliott Fletcher have been defaced in the past fortnight.

Independent senator Nick Xenophon has proposed the appointment of an online ombudsman to deal with such incidents.

“Specifically on Nick’s idea, let’s look at it,” Rudd told the Seven Network.

“The role of cyber crime and internet bullying on children is frankly frightening and we need to be deploying all practical measures.”

God knows what they think an online ombudsman will do, but I’d rather not find out.

The Facebook pages will have an owner who set them up. That owner has the ability to remove any offensive comments made on the tribute pages. No need for the state to intervene.

EPMU supports drink drinking pilots

How weird. The Herald reports:

A leading unionist has attacked Air New Zealand chief executive Rob Fyfe over the company’s “grubby deal” with police that has led to staff caught drink-driving being penalised twice.

Andrew Little, secretary of the Engineering, Printing & Manufacturing Union and also president of the Labour Party, said the police had circumvented privacy and information laws and the airline had co-operated. …

Mr Little said that “Mr Fyfe’s response was less one of management heroism and more one of anger that the grubby deal had blown up in the airline’s face”.

He said that under that deal, airline staff processed for drink-driving faced criminal prosecution, appropriately, but also had the facts disclosed to Air NZ, so it could “exact a second punishment, usually dismissal, for the same offence”.

So the Labour Party President EPMU National Secretary thinks that it is a despicable thing that the Police tell Air New Zealand if a pilot gets charged with drink driving. Presumably Andrew thinks that it is nothing for Air New Zealand to worry about, as the drink driving took place in a car instead of a plane. This means that it is only *after* a pilot has also flown a plane while drunk, that Air New Zealand should be able to take action.

Zero alcohol for under 20 drivers

The Herald reports:

The Government intends imposing a zero alcohol level on drivers under 20, Transport Minister Steven Joyce has confirmed.

He said today it was part of a package aimed at reducing the road death toll, which was 60 per cent per capita higher than Australia’s.

Mr Joyce said the zero alcohol level for drivers under 20 still had to be signed off by the Cabinet.

“I think it is likely to get through,” he said on Radio New Zealand.

Heh, I doubt Steven would be announcing it unless he knew it would get through 🙂

“We do need to take a systematic approach to the issues around young people dying on our roads.”

At present teenage drivers have a 30mg alcohol limit.

Mr Joyce said there would also be proposals in the package covering drivers up to age 24.

I am supportive of a zero blood alcohol limit for under 20 year old drivers.

The current limit of 30mg sends out a mixed message. It is close to a de facto zero limit (a couple of quick drinks could put you over) but it means that the message is you can drink a bit and drive.

For teenagers, whose crash stats are appalling, a simple message does better – simply if you are the driver, you should not drink at all.

Axe the tax

Labour’s current campaign for “ordinary New Zealanders” is “Axe the Tax”.

Now 95% of New Zealanders will take this as meaning that Labour want to axe GST. After all it is not called “Stop the hike” but “Axe the tax”.

So Labour are trying to make people believe that they stand for axeing GST. Sure not in the small print, but if you see that big bus go by with “Axe the tax” on there, that is the impression you will get.

So how much would Labour have to put up personal tax rates, to compensate for an axed GST. Well GST brings is around $9.6 billion from the private sector.

Now assuming Labour would not want to increase the two lower tax rates or the company tax rate, it means that Labour would be able to align the 33% tax rates and the 39% tax rate. They would both have to increase to 86%, so that any money you earn over $48,000 you only keep one seventh of it.

Maybe Labour may want to reconsider having such a misleading campaign slogan?

UPDATE: Some sharp eyed readers have noted that the campaign, its bus, etc are all funded by the taxpayer from the Leader’s fund. Now it is a legitimate expense within the rules, but it would be ironic that if Labour do axe the tax, then the current level of taxpayer funding to parliamentary parties may have to be axed also 🙂

Collusion and Criminal Sanctions

If you are in Wellington you may be interested in a seminar on Monday evening by the Law & Economics Association of New Zealand (LEANZ)
and Bell Gully on

The efficiency of collusion and criminal sanctions in New Zealand

Speakers are Professor Lewis Evans, Victoria University of Wellington abd Victoria Heine, Partner, Chapman Tripp.

It is at Bell Gully, HP Tower, 171 Featherston Street, Wellington, 5.30 pm for 6.00 pm start, followed by refreshments.

Your can RSVP: [email protected]

Topic background: On January 27 the Justice Minister released a discussion document proposing to criminalise cartel activities such as price fixing and bid rigging. In this seminar, Professor Evans will consider efficiency aspects of the Minister’s proposal, in particular the efficiencies which can arise when competing business co-operate, and the difficulties officials can have in separating beneficial and harmful co-operation. Commenter for this one hour session will be Victoria Heine, Partner at Chapman Tripp.

A punishment fitting the crime

news.com.au reports:

THE owner of a goat allegedly raped is demanding the two accused make traditional wedding arrangements.

State media also said the two young men accused of having sex with a goat in central Mozambique faced criminal charges.

The young men, whose names and ages were not released, were caught in the act by police and arrested outside the rural town of Mbucuta in central Mozambique, the website of the state broadcaster said.

“One of the young men was naked and holding the goat’s head, and the other was having sex with the animal,” witness Mario Creva told Radio Mozambique.

District prosecutor Leonides Mapasse said the two would face trial for simple larceny.

The goat’s owner may also file a civil suit against them, he said.

The owner was demanding the young men pay him damages and initiate a traditional wedding ceremony by paying “lobolo,” a dowry, a family member told Radio Mozambique.

Well how’s that for restorative justice, and making the punishment fit the crime? I’m glad that someone is thinking of that goat.

McCarten on Israel

Matt McCarten writes:

It seems we can’t get over the myth we’ve created of the little plucky nation of Israel defending itself against the Islamic hordes intent on destroying them.

The fact is Israel has the fourth largest military machine in the world and is the only nuclear power in the region.

Is Israel a little nation? Well it is around 20,000 square kilometres in size. That’s a bit smaller than Vermont – one of the smallest states in the US.

And Israel’s four neighbours have a land area of 1,290,000 square kilometres. That is around 60 to 65 times the size.

Are there Islamic hordes intent on destroying them? Yes. Not all Islamic countries and definitely not all Islamic people, but a fair few of each. It is probably the only cpuntry on Earth that

Does Israel have the 4th largest military machine in the world? No. For number of active personnel they are ranked 34th. And even if you include reserves they are still only the 20th largest.

They are the only nuclear power, but sadly not for long I suspect.

It is a pity the three strikes law will not be retrospective

The HoS reports:

The country’s youngest convicted killer is the subject of a new police complaint, accused of indecently assaulting two female journalists.

He is fresh from a one-month prison sentence after admitting wilfully damaging a television camera – the latest in a string of offences including assault.

Bailey Junior Kurariki was released from prison in May 2008 after being convicted of the manslaughter of pizza delivery man Michael Choy in 2002.

He was set strict conditions by the Parole Board after being released four months early, but police and the Department of Corrections have not been able to stop his repeated offending.

The new indecent assault claims follow a visit by two female Herald on Sunday journalists to Bailey Junior Kurariki’s Auckland home on Thursday.

The employees, who the newspaper has chosen not to name, said the 20-year-old behaved in an erratic and distressing manner during the interview.

Statements record Kurariki exposed himself to the women, masturbated in front of them and groped them before they could escape the house.

In hindsight it is a pity he was only convicted of manslaughter, not murder, as a life sentence would mean his parole can be revoked at any time.

I guess we are just going to have to wait until he has killed, raped or bashed enough people, to lock him up for good.

The Chile tsunami

The earthquake in Chile was an 8.8 – the 7th = strongest earthquake ever recorded. It was 500 times the strength of the Haiti quake, which shows how vital strong buildings are in mitigating effects – so far only 140 dead.

I was pleasantly surprised to receive text messages from Civil Defence alerting me to the tsunami advisories. I got them by e-mail also, but text messaging is far more effective as you tend to check a text immediately.

Civil Defence also now have a Twitter account, and Twitter is a very good medium for such announcements as people can retweet them quickly. Well worth people with Twitter subscribing.

The website has the latest advisory. The only area facing possible evacuation was Banks Peninsula.

China and climate change

Stephen Franks blogs:

Take a look at this NCPA collection of sobering figures (drawn from the work of a physics professor at UCAL Berkeley) for an explanation.

  • China’s emissions intensity (CO2 per dollar of GDP) is five times greater than that of the United States.

President Hu Jintao plans to reduce China’s CO2 emissions per unit of GDP by 4 percent per year for 5 years. If carried on it would reduce China’s CO2 emissions intensity 70 percent by 2040. But even if it works:

  • If China cuts its emissions intensity 45% it will still surpass the U.S. in per capita annual CO2 emissions by 2025.
  • Indeed, every 10% cut in U.S. emissions would be negated by one year of China’s growth.
  • Because China’s economy is growing by 10% p.a. a 4% cut in intensity is actually a 6% annual increase in emissions.
  • CO2 emissions are increasing similarly in India and other developing countries – far surpassing rich countries’ output.
  • Even if China and India’s goals are met – and other developing countries make similar cuts- total atmospheric CO2 would rise from 385 parts per million currently to 700 parts per million by 2080

The leaders of China and India can not risk constraining their growth, even if they were persuaded that they should give higher priority to CO2 emissions.

I did my own calculations a few weeks ago:

China said it will “endeavour” to cut the amount of carbon produced per unit of economic output by 40 to 45 percent by 2020 from 2005. The “carbon intensity” goal would let emissions keep rising, but more slowly than economic growth.

Now even putting aside the fact China won’t agree to any verification of their emissions (ie they can simply make up their figures), what does their pledge mean.

Let us assume that their business as usual case is that emissions will increase in line with economic growth.

Now their GDP in 2005 was US$2.24 trillion. In 2020 it is estimated to be around US14.6 trillion. That is a 640% increase in GDP.

Now if their emissions intensity is 40% less, then the increase in emissions will be 385%.

So China’s pledge is they will only increase emissions by 385% by 2020.

Now their level of emissions in 2006 was 6,103 million tons. So China’s projected increase in emissions is around 23,000 million tons. …

In fact China’s pledge to reduce intensity by 40% means their total level of emissions in 2020 could be as high as 33,000 million tons.

And you know what. That is more than the rest of the world produces today. The world, excluding China, produces 22,000 million tons. With China it is 28 million tons

So the entire world could go carbon neutral, and China would still push world emissions up 20% from 2006.

This is the reality the world faces. It does not matter what the USA does, what the EU does, even what India does. Global emissions are going to increase significantly, just from China alone.

A reply

From Stuff:

OPINION: Mohsen al Attar responds to criticism by Chris Trotter of his Auckland University law course.

Last week, Chris Trotter dedicated his column to assailing an advanced international law course – Colonialism to Globalisation: International Law and the Making of the Third World – I teach at the University of Auckland law faculty.

Trotter was springboarding off a recent blogpost on the same topic.

That would be me!

Anyway good to see a response.

I conclude with a word of thanks. As the debate about my course (and my person) has gone viral, so too has enrolment. At this stage, I am pleased to report we have doubled our numbers from last year – and, at this rate, may even reach maximum enrolment by week’s end – meaning that far more students will be exposed to a Third World perspective on the relationship between colonialism and international law.

I should get a share of the capitalist profits from the course!

Q+A this week

Q+A is tomorrow at 9 am on One.

  • Rodney Hide is the main interview on the ACT conference, their agenda, their future and relationship with National
  • Paul Reynolds is interviewed by Paul Homes on the XT outages and 111 problems
  • Panel this week is Michelle Boag, Mike Williams and Therese Arseneau

ACT Conference

I’m attending the ACT conference as media. First speaker this morning is Alan Gibbs.

Gibbs, like many on the right, started life as a dedicated socialist, and was active in Wolfgang Rosenberg’s New Left Club. He saw the light after visits to Yugoslavia and East Germany.

Gibbs talked about how the liberal market solution is often counter-intuitive. That instinctively people want to block Chinese imports to protect New Zealand manufacturers, even though almost everyone knows logically free trade is better.

He whacked at National for refusing to sell Kiwirail, and indeed refusing to sell any state assets at all. That got more resonance than his next statement about how the assets that most need to be sold are the public hospitals.

Overall a very interesting, if some what disjointed, speech about liberalism, markets and democracy. Gibbs also made a plus for more direct rather than representative democracy, through Internet voting on bills proposed by MPs.

In an aside Gibbs also said he thinks countries should go back to the gold standard. Hopefully someone will ask Don Brash what he thinks of that.

Vodafone moves in

The Herald reports:

Vodafone will today announce a fresh offensive to capitalise on Telecom’s ongoing woes.

Paul Brislen, Vodafone spokesman, said the company would refund any Telecom customers penalised for switching mobile phone providers.

Under the deal to be announced this morning, angry Telecom customers can change to Vodafone and keep the same phone number – and be credited the amount they are charged for breaking their contract.

That amount varies but in one case, Mr Brislen said, a customer had to pay $1500 to leave Telecom.

The aggressive attempt to snatch business and consumer customers comes as Telecom faced more problems yesterday.

The cost of these outages to Telecom must be well into the tens of millions of dollars when you consider the compensation, the lost customers, the scaring off of future customers, the damage to Telecom’s reputation which may affect stuff such as the fibre to the home rollout etc etc.

I speculated on radio yesterday that while the focus for now is on fixing the faults, and not finger pointing, there must be a reasonable chance in the future of a law suit between Telecom and Alcatel-Lucent. Obviously it all depends on the contractual arrangements, but when companies lose so much money due to technical failures, there tend to be fallout.

How big could any lawsuit be? I don’t think one could rule out $100 million or so.

Student Loans access

The Herald reports:

Tertiary students who fail more than half their courses may lose their student loans as the Government moves to crack down on abuse.

Only 50 per cent of domestic students who started studying for bachelor’s degrees in New Zealand in 2004 finished their degrees within five years – suggesting that up to half of the country’s 145,000 bachelor’s students will fail or drop out.

Student allowances are chopped if students failed more than half of their courses in the previous year, but there is no requirement to pass courses to keep getting student loans.

I can see this changing very soon. However I think one will want some ability to access loans if say a student drops out, enters the workforce, but a few years later wants to return to finish their degree.

Mr Joyce pointed to research showing 41.5 per cent of New Zealand’s tertiary education budget went into student loans and allowances, compared with an OECD average of only 17.6 per cent.

He told the Weekend Herald he wanted to shift funding to pay for more tuition places. “I’d like to see more money going into actually training EFTSs (equivalent fulltime students) and I’m looking around for opportunities to deliver that in 2011,” he said.

The budget will be interesting.

Polls and Prediction Markets

I attended on Wednesday night the launch of “Key to Victory” which is the normal post election campaign review book edited by Stephen Levine and Nigel Roberts.

I find these books so fascinating, I was even reading it during the speeches!

Bryce Edwards has reviewed (h/t iPredict Blog) a chapter by Shaun McGirr and Rob Salmond on what sources of information best predicted the election outcome. Was it an individual poll, the iPredict markets or the polls of polls.

The amount invested in iPredict was considerable:

  • $64,500 was traded over the likely nature of ‘the Maori Party’s post-election relationship with National’
  • $25,800 was traded over the Wellington Central battle between Grant Robertson and Stephen Franks
  • $132,100 was traded over whether ‘there will be a National prime minister after the 2008 election’
  • $413,000 in total was invested in election-related predictions

And how did iPredict do”

So, how accurate was iPredict in 2008? McGirr and Salmond conclude that although iPredict overestimated the eventual support for both Labour and National, it was more accurate any individual polling company.

And the individual polls:

In reality in 2008, McGirr and Salmond found this to be the case – with Colmar Brunton and DigiPoll exaggerating public support for National, and Roy Morgan exaggerating support for Labour (p.264).

So which polling companies were most accurate and inaccurate? McGirr and Salmond say that TV3’s TNS poll was the best (as it was in 2005 as well), and Fairfax’s Neilson pool was the poorest.

The TV3 poll is the one that currently shows a 27% gap! Mind you they are now with Reid Research, so there may be a different methodology used now.

Then they look at the polls of polls published by three outlets – NZPA, Rob (at 08 Wire) and myself (at curiablog).

In addition to the five opinion polls, some observers attempted to average out the idiosyncratic errors of the individual polls by aggregating them into a “poll-of-polls” using different methods. The New Zealand Press Association simply took the average of the estimates of the six most recent polls, while The New Zealand Herald took the average of the last four polls. Two blog-based polls-of-polls – one run by David Farrar of New Zealand’s premier political blog Kiwiblog, and one hosted at a smaller blog [run by author Rob Salmond] called 08wire – weighted more recent polls with larger sample sizes more heavily (p.257).

And how did the poll of polls do?

McGirr and Salmond say that ‘Poll-of-polls consistently performed well during the 2008 campaign, outperforming most of the opinion polls and the prediction markets’ (p.270). They therefore advocate that both the media and public should pay much more attention to this highly accurate source of political information.

Tis has prompted me to update the poll of polls widget, which is below.

Salmond ranks the different outlets for their accuracy to the final result. In order they were:

  1. NZ Herald poll of polls 6.1 (error from result)
  2. NZPA poll of polls 6.8
  3. Curiablog poll of polls 8.1
  4. TV3/TNS poll 9.6
  5. 08 wire poll of polls 13.6
  6. iPredict 15.7
  7. TVNZ/Colmar Brunton poll 16.8
  8. NZ Herald/Digipoll poll 19.8
  9. Roy Morgan poll 20.8
  10. Fairfax/Neilsen poll 29.6
  11. NZ Political Stockmarket 109.5

The NZ Political Stockmarket used virtual money, so it shows what a difference real money can make.

The authors conclude that media outlets should not just report the individual poll results when they commission a poll, but also publish regular info on a poll of polls and on iPredict.

Incidentally I will probably review and tweak the curiablog methodology a bit when I have some spare time.

VIP Transport

The Dom Post reports:

Labour leader Phil Goff will cut back his use of chauffeur-driven Crown cars in favour of much cheaper taxis after he ran up a $70,000 bill in three months.

But he is questioning the cost of the ministerial BMW limousines.

Mr Goff, who as Opposition leader has the use of the cars, said he would write to Prime Minister John Key and Internal Affairs, which runs the VIP Transport Service, challenging the service’s fees, which rose significantly last year.

The latest publication of MPs’ expenses shows Mr Goff spent $69,657 for the cars in the last three months of last year, although almost all of it was incurred in July, August and September. It showed up in the returns for the last quarter of 2009 because of a delay in Internal Affairs billing the Parliamentary Service, which pays MPs’ travel and accommodation expenses.

Having access to VIP Transport is a bit of a mixed blessing with these expense disclosures.

Ministers (and others like Phil Goff) get charged a per hour rate of $90 and a  per km rate of $1.25 by VIP Transport, as a book-keeping exercise. The charge covers the capital costs of the fleet of cars and score of drivers.

Now the actual marginal cost of using VIP Transport is very small – almost just petrol. It would cost the taxpayer more if a Minister takes a taxi (which results in an external charge) than using VIP Transport (where the driver is on full salary regardless of whether or not they are driving at that moment in time).

If a Minister (or other person entitled) said they will never ever use VIP Transport, then they would be able to reduce their fleet size and number of drivers. But just using taxis some of the time will reduce the cost apportioned to a Minister internally, but probably not reduce the overall cost to the taxpayer.

It is a bit unfair on Phil Goff that he gets shown to have such a large expense against his name. For the reality is that his use of VIP Transport doesn’t really cost the taxpayer the amount shown. Most of those costs would be incurred regardless of how frequently he uses them, as their costs are mainly fixed, rather than marginal.

Greens fail IQ test also

At 11.14 am the Greens put out a press release saying:

This was going to lifting mining protection from half a billion hectares of land with high conservation value, but would now only propose lifting protection from around 7,000 hectares.

Radio NZ made the initial error between 7 am and 8 am. NZPA picked it at 8.24 but made a correction within around half an hour. I blogged on it at 9.24 a.m. Yes despite that the Greens don’t even stop to think that half a billion hectares is around 20 times larger than the total land area of New Zealand.

Does no one at the Greens know how big a hectare is and that there is no way we have half a billion of them?

That was quick

The Dom Post reports:

A unemployed man trying to stop Manners Mall from becoming a bus-only road says his dole has been cut after he admitted he had no intention of getting a job.

Activist Benjamin Easton, 49, also revealed he had not had a job interview since he went on the dole nearly three years ago.

He met Work and Income for a work test yesterday after telling The Dominion Post he was on the benefit deliberately so he could bring the “people’s challenge to the courts” and that he was “perfectly capable of earning”.

Mr Easton said last night he had received a letter from Work and Income telling him he did not meet eligibility criteria and his benefit had been stopped as of yesterday.

One hopes this is an isolated case, but who knows. The vast majority of people on the dole are looking for work, and would much rather be working. However what we don’t know if how big is that minority who see it as a lifestyle.

Mr Easton said losing the dole would force him to move out of his $135-a-week Wellington City Council flat. “If they knock me off [the benefit] I will go back to living on the street.”

No he is not being forced to live on the street. He is choosing to, because he has chosen not to make himself available for work.

The activist has taken cases on a range of issues including an Environment Court appeal against the council’s $11.1 million Manners Mall bus route project.

“If I don’t do this then there isn’t anybody else to do it. I am the only person who knows what it is I am talking about.”

Now that is quite possible!