The Journey Home

Got to Tel Aviv at 11 pm Saturday night and crashed briefly at a place provided by Yani. Then had to taxi to airport at 3 am. The taxi did not turn up though, so Ebba and I ended up dragging out suitcases down the road onto the main street, where we managed to hail one.

At the airport, went through much much tougher security than I have seen anywhere else in the world. In one sense it was very reassuring that they take security so seriously, meaning you have a safe flight. On the other hand it meant I only hit the lounge 15 minutes before I had to go to the gate. The security process was:

  1. A 5 – 10 minute interrogation by a young female airport official while waiting in the queue for first x-ray. She asked me detailed questions about why I went to Turkey, Egypt, Kuwait, Dubai and Iran. When I said I had a friend working in Kuwait, she asked why was she working there and she didn’t even smile at my response it was because she earns three times what she would in NZ. Also asked me several times if anyone had given me anything to carry for them, as it could be a bomb.
  2. Then went through first x-rays of all luggage.
  3. Then had a total search of my suitcase (presumably based on my suspicious itinerary to date) which took ten minutes
  4. Then passport control. More questions
  5. Then a x-ray of my hand luggage
  6. Then a search with a wand of not just me, and the hand luggage, but also my shoes, my camera, my books etc.

While all the security was a hassle, it did mean at least I could be confident we would have an incident free flight. And Israel, of all countries, does need to be vigilant. If interested, see Wikipedia on El Al security.

Was sad to leave Israel, as it was such a fascinating place. There is a wonderful blend of racial backgrounds. Another country I am definitely going to return to. Very grateful to Davidi and Young Likud for their first class hosting, and to my European friends who made the trip so fun.

Flew to London, which took almost six hours. My ticket conditions meant I had to continue around the world, so could not take the much quicker eastern route back.

I had a standby upgrade request for the 11 hour leg from Heathrow to LA, but the flight was full. Annoying that one had to go through security scan, even in transit. The lounge there was quite nice, and got some work done.

Then landed at LA after 11 hour flight. They no longer allow you to access the Koru Club, if you are Star Alliance Gold, due to security restrictions. Very peeved as really wanted a shower. Then a 13 hour flight to Auckland.

Did get an upgrade to Premium Economy, which was my first time trying that section out. Biggest boon for me was a power supply as I worked on laptop entire flight catching up with emails, writing blog posts (including most of this one) etc.

Having the seats recline back more is useful, but also proved a hassle as the person in front put their seat so far back I could not use my laptop in front of me. But by chance luck was with me as I was in a window seat (despite a standing request for aisle seats). In premium economy they had a foot wide ledge (with storage space beneath them) next to the window. Not only is it great for storing papers and books (and even the laptop so I did not have to get it from overhead after takeoff, but it allowed me to use the area as a work station by balancing the laptop on my arm rest and a cushion propped up on my shoes on the ledge – a real no 8 solution 🙂

So my advice for travellers if to go for the window seat if in premium economy (or at least the upstairs section).

Got into Auckland at 7 am Tuesday and stayed overnight.

Franklin

Went to the famous switching on of the Franklin Road Xmas lights. 99% of the houses on the 1 km long road put up extensive lights and decorations. It’s a wonderful community initiative and the entire road was a party zone. They were even giving away free food.

I attended one of the parties, which was great fun. Damien Christie spent the night introducing me as David Farrier from TV3!

Woke up with a hangover around 10.30 am and almost missed my flight to Wellington.  I blame xxxxxxx.

Is good to be home, but have had wonderful month in a region I have long wanted to visit. And I must be one of a very few people who have done Iran and Israel consecutively in the same trip!

Blog Bits

  1. Bernard Hickey summarises the pros and cons of a land tax.
  2. Bryce Edwards covers the Listener’s 2009 power list in a very long post.
  3. Fiscally Conservative Kiwi adds his comments to the pros and cons of a land tax.
  4. Rob at The Standard loses faith with Obama, labelling him another war president. It is ironic that he announces a surge in Afghanistan just after getting the Nobel Peace Prize
  5. Clare Curran blogs on the European Parliament giving phone and Internet users more rights. Back home we wait to see if the Government will proceed with a law that allows termination of Internet access for copyright infringement.
  6. No Right Turn wonders if Phil Goff’s next move will be to encourage women to get back into the kitchen, and gays back into the closet.

Very cute

Fallow on Tax

Brian Fallow writes:

There was a whiff of incrementalism, even complacency, about Finance Minister Bill English’s comments to the tax working group’s conference on Tuesday. …

Had he been able to stay for the rest of the conference and listen to the presentation by some of the working group’s members he would have got a clear message that the tax system has deteriorated beyond the point where tinkering and tweaking are enough.

I hope the Govt does more than tinker.

From the standpoint of maximising economic growth and living standards, the worst things to tax are those which can up stakes and leave, like capital and labour.

Labour sees lowering the top tax rate as opportunity for the politics of envy. But it is about getting the incentives right.

Taxing consumption is better, but tends to be regressive.

Actually over someone’s lifetime, GST is not as regressive as people think.

The best, least-distortionary thing to tax is something which is immobile and the supply of which is not sensitive to taxation, like land.

If it allows income tax to be lowered, I support a land tax. Not only does it provide an incentive to get better economic use out of land, it also brings foreign land owners into the tax base.

One feature of the status quo English singled out as unacceptable is that, within little more than a decade, fiscal drag will have pulled someone on the average wage into the top tax bracket.

Our top marginal tax rate cuts in at a massively low level compared to other countries.

Climate Change head stood down

The Herald reports:

The chief of a British research centre caught in a storm of controversy over claims that he and others suppressed data about climate change has stepped down pending an investigation, the University of East Anglia said.

The university said that Phil Jones, whose emails were among the thousands of pieces of correspondence leaked to the internet late last month, would relinquish his position as director of the Climatic Research Unit until the completion of an independent review.

The stolen e-mails do not prove a global conspiracy to fake data, but they do show that several leading climate change scientists have developed a siege mentality, where they see all criticism as invalid, and will go out of their way to denigrate and obfuscate those they disagree with.

Andrew Bolt quotes Lord Monckton’s take on the e-mails.

Some blogs have run a story that local NIWA data has been altered from the public data, but this has been easily explained by NIWA that what happened is their monitoring station moved from Wellington Airport to Kelburn, so the back series of data was adjusted to take account of the average difference between the two sites.

What NIWA did was absolutely correct in my opinion, and I have no issues with their professionalism. However the problem is that some of their peers overseas have had e-mails about changing data to make the case that temperatures are rising, and this rightly makes those sceptical even more sceptical. Trying to pretend the stolen e-mails are of no consequence is not going to work.

While some of the e-mails are benign, very dated, or out of context – there are some that quite appalling – especially references to keeping non supporting research out of the IPCC. It is hard to see how the author of that e-mail can remain involved with IPCC work in future.

UPDATE: Heh love this cartoon from Clint Heine:

PaperClipMan[5]

RIP Anna Woolf

Peter Cresswell has made the inevitable but very sad announcement:

Anna Woolf, aka Annie Fox, died today at 12:05pm.

As Mary Ann Sures said of Ayn Rand’s death, “now anger has gone out of the world. And it’s the world’s loss, and mine.”

Goodbye, Anna.

Anna’s bravery was quite inspiring. My thoughts go out to those who were closest to her.

The Golan Heights

isr6

On the sabbath we had brunch in the Hula Valley in the Golan Heights. We had “local” food pretty much every day, and I have to say it was damn nice. It’s a shame to eat your normal diet, when you are in other countries, but often you end up doing so if staying in hotels. Having a local guide really helps.

isr7

That sign is not just for show. The Syrians left a huge number of mines behind, and Israel decided it was better to just fence off some areas than try and detect them all (hazardous to the detectors)

isr8

Sweden doubles its defence force capability 🙂

isr9

One mine field has these cacti in them. I mentioned to the group that I would plant a mine at the bottom of the cactus so that if the mine doesn’t get you, then you’ll still be hit by hundreds of pieces of cacti. One of the others said they hoped never to have to go to war against NZ with that mentality!

isr10

A fairly major strategic battle happened on this hill. 20 Israelis died taking the hill against a mortar and very well defended trenches. They Syrian soldiers were very young and inexperienced and eventually fled a superior position. Our host mentioned that the Syrians were very much innocent victims in a conflict not of their choosing.

isr11

One of the trenches on the hill

isr12

Nearby was Fort Nimrod. Now this has nothing to do with any modern conflict but was established as a Muslim fort in 1300 AD or so. There are extensive ruins to look at, if you make the drive up to it.

isr13

More of the fort.

isr14

Down to the secret tunnel

isr15

Used the zoom lens to snap this little creature on a ledge below the fort. It looks like the little critter is about to jump!

isr16

We then went to Mount Bental. On the path at the top, they have entries from a competition to design children’s toys out of former military weapon. I asked if there was also a competition to design weapons out of children’s toys 🙂

isr17

And another

isr18

At the top they have a former bunker a a very nice café. The Hebrew word for in the clouds is Annan and for coffee is Kofi, so the café is called Kofi Annan, a nice play on the former UN Secretary-General.

isr20

Again this is regarded as a very strategic hill. You can actually see a Syrian city, and Lebanon is not far away. Contrary to what might assume, there is no border fence.

At one stage we we driving next to the Jordan. In fact we got so close my cellphone told me I was now receiving Vodafone Jordan.

isr21

Going down into the bunker.

isr22

This is at Qatsrin, and is the remains of a very early Jewish synagogue from 2,000 years ago.

isr23

At Janhnun we saw a great audio-visual show on the history of the Golan Heights, beamed onto a replacia model of them. Then afterwards we had a beer tasting of local beers. Yum.

isr24

A sunset over the Sea of Galilee. Beautiful.

isr25

Finally we visited Hamat-Gader where we saw some animals, had dinner, and dipped into the local thermal pools. Those leaving later on Sunday stayed the night at the Kefar-Ha Nassi Kibbutz.

We had an interesting debate about whether that fence was high enough to stop a determined crocodile.

We also saw a nine metre python.

isr26

A photo of the pool area. The main pool was hot enough, but the inside pool was an uncomfortable 43 degrees – maximum time recommended 10 minutes.

Cactus Kate on 2025

Heh. Cactus Kate calls Brash a wimp, and outlines her own policy agenda for increasing national incomes. Her proposals:

  • Restrict welfare to those unable to work due to disability
  • Sell all state houses in prime real estate areas, and buy new houses far away from the CBD on the basis most state house tenants don’t need to be close to the CBD as they don’t work
  • Abolish DPB and levy fathers directly for child support (unless unsafe). If mother under 25, means test on her parents income.
  • A flat tax rate of 10%
  • Have no tax at all for new companies employing at least ten people for their first two years
  • Raise GST to 15%
  • Abolish minimum wage and allow mass immigration of Filipinos to do low income domestic jobs, freeing New Zealand women up to engage in higher income jobs and/or leisure
  • Abolish public superannuation
  • Prioritise healthcare so those who smoke, drink excessively or are obese  got treated last
  • Abolish ACC for a fault based system
  • Surcharges for GP visits
  • Full fees for university courses with scholarships for top performers
  • No CGT, but a land tax and stamp duty

That should generate some debate!

Name supression and the musician

Tomorrow in Wellington is the R v the Internet seminar at Te Papa. The final programme is online, and I think there is a great lineup of speakers – and attendees.

The timing for the seminar has been very good, both with the release of the Law Commission’s recommendations (which is not a coincidence as it was timed to be just after that) but also the publicity around name suppression for the musician, which had even the Prime Minister asked at a press conference if he knew the name.

Incidentally with regards to that case, some commenters were of the view that the entertainer did nothing wrong, as the complainant went into the alleyway. This Sunday News article provides the victim’s perspective:

THE family of the teenage girl attacked by a prominent entertainer have broken their silence branding the incident “animalistic” and his permanent name suppression “totally disgusting”.

Victim Brittany Cancian last night described the musician as a “disgusting, self righteous pig”.

The 17-year-old was with friends in central Wellington on March 5 when two of her friends were led away with the drunken man around 3.30am.

Brittany’s mother Racheal, of Lower Hutt, said her “caring” daughter was attacked by the man while checking on her friends.

“I think he’s an animal, when I heard what he had done I thought it was animalistic. He wasn’t at all gentle about it,” Racheal said.

“What happened has absolutely been downplayed. She never followed him down the alleyway she went to see that her friends, who had followed him, were okay.

So this was not a girl going down an alley wanting to kiss him.

“She has quite a caring heart and she wanted to check on her mates and when she went around the corner he grabbed her.”

Auckland District Court heard earlier this month how the famous entertainer asked Brittany and her friends to “kiss my balls” before he grabbed the teenager’s head and pulled it towards his crotch.

His genitals brushed across Brittany’s face. The man admitted a charge of inducing an indecent act but was discharged without conviction by Judge Eddie Paul. He was given permanent name suppression because naming him would affect his record and concert ticket sales.

I think he got off lightly.

Racheal said police never asked her or Brittany if they wanted the man’s name suppression application opposed.

Court documents reveal police maintained a “neutral” position on the matter.

It is unfortunate the victim was not given a say. I sometimes wonder whether victims should be given their own counsel in court cases – to represent their interests.

Commission president Sir Geoffrey Palmer said if recommendations in the report had been adopted by Government prior to the musician’s court appearance, he “certainly would not” have received suppression.

“He would have to show extreme hardship and that is very difficult to do … that is hardship out of the ordinary, not ordinary hardship and that is a much higher threshold than the law currently provides.”

“We all have to have a quality before the law. The person who is a grave digger has to be treated the same as a person who is an All Black.”

On this issue I very much agree with Sir Geoffrey.

iPredict this week

My iPredict column:

Whanganui

Does someone out there know something about the outcome of the name for Wanganui City? CITY.BOTH pays out $1 if both Wanganui and Whanganui are declared official names (like Aoraki and Mt Cook). The stock had been at 15c for around six weeks and on Monday started to shoot up to 24c, where it is now today.

Turnbull gone

Malcolm Turnbull lost the leadership of the Australian Liberal Party 41-42, making traders in AUS.TURNBULL very happy. The history of the stock has been interesting – at 40c to 50c up until late November. Then on Friday 27 Nov it went up to 76c. The price then dropped back later in the day to 63c before settling down at 72c. On Monday it climbed to 91c, but dropped back to finish the day at 84c. And then on the day of the leadership vote it traded back at 91c, until the result came out, giving some people a nice quick profit.

Does Brown have momentum?

MAYOR.BROWN will pay out if Len Brown wins Auckland’s top job in 2010. He has been at 30c for around three months and dropped away to 22c on the 15th of November. The stock recovered to 26c and then on the Friday the 27th of November spiked up to 52c. Someone seems confident of Brown. The price has now dropped back but is stable at 34c, up a bit from where it used to be.

Nats thrive in tough times

PM.2011.NATIONAL has been at 66c for some time. Possibly someone heard the Colmar Brunton poll results early as on Saturday it went up to 69c, and since then hit 72c on Monday. This seems to reflect sentiment that if Labour can’t close the gap despite the tough times, the next election is looking safer for National.

Most Traded Stocks

AUS.TURNBULL topped the market with $12,700 of trades. The CONFNOV09 stocks had $16,000 of trades between them, and then the petrol stocks at $6,400.

Cheers,

David

Disclosure

David’s current iPredict positions are:

BROWN.RESIGN Short, CITY.WHANGANUI Long, DEP.GOFF.2010 Short, DEP.KING.2010 Short, DL.KING.09 Short, FASA04.REPEAL Short, GST.UP.JULY10 Short, LEAD.GOFF.09 Short, MAYOR.BROWN Long, MIN.DEPART2.09 Short, MP.ANDERTON Short, MP.PETERS.2011 Short, NAT.JAN10.VLOW Short, NAT.MAORI.09 Short, OBAMA.DISAP.1MAR Short, OCR.INCR.APR10 Short, OCR.INCR.JAN10 Short, OCR.INCR.JUL10 Short, PETERS.LEADER Long, PM.2011.NATIONAL Long, UK2010.CON.ABS Long, UK2010.CON.MAJ Short, ZIM.MUGABE Short

Links to stocks in this commentary: CITY.BOTH, AUS.TURNBULL, MAYOR.BROWN, PM.2011.NATIONAL, AUS.TURNBULL

Justice Wilson

The Attorney-General has announced:

Attorney-General Christopher Finlayson said he had confirmed today that the Judicial Conduct Commissioner has received a complaint relating to Justice  Wilson’s failure to recuse himself from a Court of Appeal case despite the nature and extent of his financial relationship with counsel in the case. …

“The matter is now with the Judicial Conduct Commissioner,” Mr Finlayson said. “The law requires that the Commissioner makes a preliminary examination, during which he may make any enquiries and look at any relevant court documents.”

“At the end of the preliminary examination, the Commissioner must either dismiss the complaint, or refer the complaint to the Chief Justice, or recommend that the Attorney-General appoint a Judicial Conduct Panel to inquire into any matter concerning the conduct of the Judge.”

This is no minor thing, as Justice Wilson sits on the Supreme Court.

The Press editorial also touches on him:

The Supreme Court’s decision last week to recall a decision it made earlier this year, and direct a new hearing of an important case because of concerns about the risk of the appearance of bias by one of its own judges, is unprecedented in New Zealand.

Which does show the system works.

It not only raises doubts about the judgment of the judge involved but it also re-ignites debate made at the time the Supreme Court was established about whether, with judges drawn entirely from New Zealand’s small legal talent pool, such problems are unavoidable. There is little question that, at the least, the episode is a serious embarrassment for the Supreme Court. …

At the time, the judge was a new appointee on the Court of Appeal. He was soon afterwards elevated to the Supreme Court, after an extremely short time on the Appeal Court and ahead of other more experienced and more intellectually distinguished Appeal Court judges. This lapse inevitably raises a question about whether he has sufficient sensitivity of judgment to entitle him to sit on the country’s highest court.

I will be interested to see the report of the Judicial Conduct Commissioner.

Crash and Burn

My God, you can tell I have been overseas for the last month. Barely scraped a pass with 8/15 in this week’s Dom Post politics quiz.

One mark less and it would have been hara kiri!

It’s been a long time since I have been told my performance was adequate only – well politically anyway 🙂

Editorials on Legal Aid

Three editorials today on the legal aid review. First the ODT:

Even by her own straight-shooting standards, Dame Margaret Bazley came out with all guns blazing in her Legal Aid Review Report. …

The review, by any measure, is a stunning indictment of the legal profession.

Dame Margaret is one of the country’s top public servants, a former head of the Department of Social Welfare, and is no stranger to conducting such reviews.

Her inquiry of police conduct following the Louise Nicholas furore was similarly hard-hitting, if not quite so unconstrained in its vocabulary.

So it must be held that, as dramatic as it is, her choice of language is deliberate and reflects the gravity of the situation as she sees it.

What I find hilarious is Labour coming out saying how shocked they are, and demanding the Government act. These problems are not new.

The Herald says:

Last Friday, Dame Margaret Bazley produced her damning report on criminal legal aid. By Monday Justice Minister Simon Power had obtained the resignations of most of the administering board, the Legal Services Agency, and the Government decided that day to shut it down. We are not used to such dispatch.

Indeed. What happened to the days of reports gathering dust on book shelves? Simon Power is no ditherer.

And the Dom Post:

Dame Margaret’s report is remarkable for its language – reminiscent of her blunt 450-page report into police conduct, in 2007 – and implicit dismay that a system formed to assist the most vulnerable is operating so poorly, and being manipulated by colluding defendants and legal-aid lawyers. It is littered with references to “widespread abuse”, “taking backhanders”, “entrenched” positions, “poor relationships” and even, “should be disbarred”.

Government reports tend to be diplomatic in their language. The comments are remarkable. It is unfortunate that the wrong doers are spoiling it for the vast majority of legal aid lawyers who are responsible, and in fact take a pay cut when doing legal aid work. One of the solutions may be to pay more per hour for legal aid work, so it doesn’t attract the “bottom of the barrel” so to speak.

When this public servant – the term suits her so well – finally chooses to retire, she can do so knowing the profound effect she has had on the ethics of important parts of New Zealand life. She helped bring compassion to psychiatric hospitals, she redirected the efforts of social welfare agencies to work with entire families, she reformed the unionised nonsense that was the NZ Fire Service, and then administered a hefty kick to the New Zealand Police.

She might be hoping now, however, that she doesn’t need a legally aided defence lawyer in a hurry …

Heh indeed.

Fran on Key

Fran lets loose:

John Key’s celebrated faux pas at his first National Party conference as leader (“Under a Labour Government I lead … ) was portrayed as simply an inadvertent slip born out of nervousness.

But after Key’s outright panning of the Don Brash-led 2025 Taskforce report his 2007 slip-up is starting to look almost Freudian.

What I would like to know is how the Government thinks it will close the gap with Australia, if it does not adopt some of the recommendations of the 2025 Taskforce. The gap will not close by magic. Action is needed, not rhetoric.

Brash and his four taskforce cohorts: former Labour Finance Minister David Caygill, Wellington economist Bryce Wilkinson, Icebreaker CEO Jeremy Moon and Australian Productivity Commission part-time member Judith Sloan, were deliberately cute in delivering Key and English a ready rationale for cutting spending back to 29 per cent of GDP.

This after all was the level of core Government expenditure registered in 2004-2005 before former Finance Minister Michael Cullen opened the floodgates on social spending.

All it required was for Key and English to start taking the axe to some of Labour’s sacred cows, urgently review some major spending programmes, and get serious about setting measurable goals to turn this economy around.

No one is underestimating the political difficulties in making such substantial change. But unless substantial change is made, New Zealand will not catch Australia. Ever.

The 29% goal is not politically possible by 2012, but that is no reason not to have it as a longer term target. Or to have a slightly higher target. Or something. What is not acceptable is having no target. I want both National and Labour to say what their target is for spending as a % of GDP, and for them to offer different targets so we have a choice.

A factor which English seemed to concede yesterday by saying the 2025 goal was merely “aspirational”.

Aspirational means they did not mean it.

Problem is the top Government duo reckons its options are constrained because they don’t want to break National’s 2008 election pledge to keep Labour’s own big-ticket election bribes such as interest-free student loans and the expansion of Working for Families which Key had demonised as “communism by stealth”(before the 2005 election).

And I accept no breaking of election promises. But that doesn’t mean the other recommendations can’t be implemented, and it also doesn’t rule out National having a more flexible set of policies for 2011.

Hone stays

The Herald reports:

Maori Party MP Hone Harawira has apologised again for comments made in an offensive email and is allowed to remain with the party following three weeks of debate over his future. …

Mr Harawira began a media conference in Wellington to outline what action the party was taking with an apology – this time more fulsome than his previous effort.

He apologised to both Maori and Pakeha for the comments, saying they were “insensitive, hurtful and unnecessary” and had caused much grief.

He also acknowledged he was responsible for damaging his party, saying it had spent four years building up credibility and good will.

“My comments have derailed much of that credibility and set back our efforts to build bridges for our people into the future.”

A split from the Maori Party would have been a lose/lose for the Maori Party and Harawira in my opinion.

Abbott new Liberal Leader

A massive upset in Australia. Not so much that Malcolm Turnbll got roleld as Liberal Leader, but that his successor is Tony Abbott.

news.com.au reports:

TONY Abbott has rolled Malcolm Turnbull to take over the Liberal leadership in a spill forced by deep divisions on the Opposition’s climate change policy.

Mr Abbott, Mr Turnbull and Joe Hockey contested a three-way spill at a special partyroom meeting in Parliament this morning.  Mr Abbott won by a single vote, 42-41.

Mr Hockey – who had been expected to win in a landslide – was eliminated in the first round of voting.  That sent Mr Abbott and Mr Turnbull into a head-to-head vote for the leadership.

But those deep divisions remain.  Yesterday Mr Hockey was demanding a free vote to decide Coalition policy on climate change early next year, if he were to agree to take on the leadership.

That angered right-wing Liberal powerbrokers and prompted Mr Abbott to stay in the race for the top job.  Turns out that was a good call.

A very good call. But the real winner is Kevin Rudd who will easily win re-election now I would say.

The vote to have a contest was 48 to 34. Then the first round ballot was Abbott 35, Turnbull 26 and Hockey 23. Turnbull almost got wiped out on the first ballot. Abbott picked up seven votes from Hockey and Turnbull picked up 15, for a final result of 42-41.

Abbott is a brawler, but hard to see him attracting widespread support to become PM.

Well done Trevor

Trevor Mallard knocked a very impressive 30 minutes off his 2008 time for the 160 km Taupo Cycle Challenge.

In 2008, Trevor got 5:35:32. This was at the 50th percentile for male competitors so dead on the median.

In 2009 Trevor’s training got him 4:58:40. This is the 22nd percentile for male competitors. That is a huge improvement. All that training paid off.

The 2025 taskforce recommendations

The 2025 taskforce made a total of 48 recommendations for initiatives that will help close the income gap with Australia. The media will probably only highlight half a dozen, so I thought it would be useful to list them all here, and add my thoughts to them.

1. Government operating spending (as measured by core Crown operating expenses) as a share of GDP should be reduced by 2012/13 to 29 percent, the same share as in 2004 and 2005.

I think a target of 29% of GDP for operating spending is an excellent target, and will probably do more than anything else to help lift national incomes. There is an overwhelming amount of evidence that countries with the state at 25% to 30% of GDP grow much faster than those with larger burdens.

It is worth noting that 29% is what we had in 2005, so it is not a level unknown to us. The problem is that as surplus grew, Dr Cullen grew spending even faster in his desire to avoid tax cuts.

However it is not politically possible to achieve it by 2012/13. I would think by 2017 (end of three terms) might be possible, without causing major disruption.

2. Beyond 2012/13, government spending as a share of GDP should be reduced materially further. To achieve this, the level of core Crown operating expenses per person should be capped in real terms.

I generally support a cap in crown spending in per capita inflation adjusted terms. However this may restrict options too greatly as new technologies in medicine (that are expensive) might become unaffordable.

What I would suggest is for spending per capita to increase no more than CPI+1%.

3. The Public Finance Act should be amended to require the Minister of Finance to specify publicly a medium-term target for core Crown operating expenses, either in real per capita terms or as a share of GDP. In each Fiscal Strategy Report, the Minister of Finance should be required to report publicly on steps being taken to ensure that that goal is met.

This is very sensible, and even if 1 and 2 are not adopted, we should require Governments to be transparent about their spending plans.

4. The Government should undertake an in-depth examination of the scope for further institutional changes to strengthen long-term spending discipline. Examples of such institutions could include a Taxpayer Bill of Rights and/or an independent Fiscal Advisory Council.

Agree, so long as they are effective in standing up for taxpayers, and adding to fiscal discipline.

5. Expert taskforces should be established to scrutinise each major area of government spending, with a view to proposing more effective models for delivering those services that the public sector will continue to fund.

To some degree this has already been happening.

6. Processes for evaluating government spending should be materially strengthened, including greater use of rigorous and transparent cost-benefit analysis for both new spending proposals and periodic reviews of the value that is being obtained from existing spending programmes. Enhancing the quality and rigour of such analysis should be a key priority for the Treasury.

Agree.

Specific

7. Ambitious welfare reform measures should be undertaken as a matter of priority to reduce the very large number of people of working age currently receiving welfare benefits.

I agree. At a minimum we should do what Bill Clinton, a Democratic US President, did.

8. Early steps should be taken to lower the actual and prospective costs (as a share of GDP) of New Zealand Superannuation. The eligibility age should be increased progressively, with increases linked to ongoing improvements in life expectancy, and for some years payments should be indexed to the CPI rather than to after-tax wages.

Firstly the Government has said it will not do this, and I don’t want the Government to become one of broken promises. But I certainly expect a future Government to increase the age of eligibility in line with age expectancy. I’ve not yet received the data I need to make a call on whether part of superannuation (maybe from age 65 to 70) should be linked to CPI instead of average wage.

9. Remaining KiwiSaver subsidies should be abolished.

I do support retaining KiwiSaver with matching employer contributions. That provides enough incentive for people to take it up, so direct state subsidies are not needed. I think KiwiSaver has worked well for encouraging a savings culture amongst younger NZers especially.

However again the current Government got elected on a series of promises, and as much as ACT voters may not like it, it is not going to break its word on current commitments. But such changes do not have to happen before 2011. There may be room to seek a mandate for some of these changes at the next election. If one does not get a mandate for such changes, then you will get wiped out at the election, and have them reversed anyway – a lose/lose.

10. Health:
a. A funder-provider model should be reintroduced in the hospital sector, allowing much greater
private sector involvement in the provision of taxpayer-funded services.

I support greater private sector involvement, but I don’t think the sector could handle another major reform. And again, there were specific election commitments here.

b. Universal (unrelated to income or health status) subsidies for doctors’ visits should be abolished.

This I strongly agree with. Subsidies should be targeted to those who most need it. It is ridiculous that Eric Watson gets subsidized doctors visits. And it is very inefficient to tax people to then just give them that money back in subsidies.

c. Subsidies for prescription pharmaceuticals should be substantially reduced, with those in generally good health and not on low incomes paying the full price up to a cap.

Again, I generally agree, but with a note of caution that middle income families can’t afford a big increase in the costs of medicines. But a total cap may help with that.

11. Education:
a. The substantial increases in subsidies since 2005 for early childhood education and day-care should be reversed.

Again this was an election promise, so I don’t see change there. As a general rule I much prefer spending in the area of early childhood than tertiary but I don’t know enough about whether the increased subsidies have just rewarded families already using day-care facilities, or has allowed lower income families to access day-care.

b. A funder-provider model should be adopted for the school sector, allowing new providers to enter, with all-up per student funding equivalent to that for existing state schools.

Yes.

c. In the meantime, governance and accountability structures in the school sector need to be reformed to provide better incentives for stronger performance and greater accountability for teachers, principals and schools.

Too generic to say aye or nae too.

d. Government-imposed fee caps on university fees should be abolished.

I have long advocated these should go.

e. Market-based interest rates should be reintroduced for student loans.

This won’t happen as again it was an election promise, but for the future it would be sensible to have a policy of at least charging enough interest to cover inflation. Otherwise we are effectively paying people to borrow money they don’t need.

f. Governance of the public tertiary sector should be reformed, including exploring the rationalisation of the non-university sector and the establishment of universities as independent foundations.

Possibly. Need more details.

g. A full review should be undertaken to identify, and recommend reform of, those areas in which various government education agencies (Tertiary Education Commission, Education Review Office, Ministry of Education) have become overly prescriptive, and to explore other, less intrusive, monitoring and accountability options to achieve policy ends that pass a cost-benefit test.

Again, need more details.

Taxation
12. Average tax rates should be substantially reduced, as ambitious expenditure restraint permits. Cutting core Crown expenses to 29 percent of GDP would, for example, allow the maximum personal tax rate, and the company and trust tax rates, all to be reduced to 20 percent.

The Government’s goal is to get the top tax rates down to 30%. Let’s do that first and then look beyond.

13. Serious reforms should be undertaken to reduce the high effective marginal tax rates facing many middle income taxpayers with dependent children as a result of the abatement provisions of the Working for Families tax credit scheme.

Absolutely.

14. Reductions in average tax rates should be achieved by reducing income taxes, and doing so having regard both to the importance of administrative simplicity and minimisation of tax avoidance on the one hand, and to the evidence that taxes on capital income can be particularly detrimental to economic performance on the other.

Agree.

Government assets
15. All businesses owned by central government which are operating in markets where competition is actual or feasible should be sold.

I agree, but note again the Government has a clear election policy. I just hope that for 2011 they have a more flexible policy. At a minimum I would like to see some SOEs take in minority private sector shareholdings, so they gain the discipline of being a listed company,

16. Local governments should be strongly encouraged to sell their trading enterprises.

Agree, but not always one size fit all.

17. To strengthen governance while businesses remain in public ownership, an independent Crown Commercial Appointments Commission should be established, to be responsible for making recommendations to Ministers for Board positions on all Crown commercial enterprises and for vetting and publishing suitability assessments of all appointees to such boards.

This seems a good idea, and should be under the OIA, so if a Minister refuses a recommendation this will be transparent.

18. The New Zealand Superannuation Fund should be wound up and its assets used to reduce gross government debt.

I agree, but again note the clear Government policy means this won’t happen.

19. Congestion charging should be introduced in central Auckland and in any other cities where a cost/benefit analysis supports doing so. Full road-user charging, differentiated by place and time of road
use, should be introduced as it becomes economically efficient to do so.

Strongly agree. Here I am with the Greens. Road users should pay for the costs of roads.

20. Rigorous and transparent cost-benefit analyses should restored to the prime place in guiding decisions on all public capital spending, including infrastructure spending. All such cost-benefit analyses for projects involving the outlay of more than $50 million should be formally reviewed by Treasury.

I would have thought this is already the case.

21. Mining:
a. A governance framework should be put in place to facilitate the best economic use of those mineral resources in which the Crown has a direct ownership interest (under both land and sea).

Not sure what is meant by such a governance framework but I support better economic use of our mineral base.

b. Mining developments on or under sensitive Crown land should generally be permitted provided that they pass a full cost-benefit analysis.

Agree, but recognizing that costs must include conservation, environmental and tourism costs. Applications should be decided on a case by case basis.

c. Development of mineral resources should be undertaken by private operators, with the Crown securing its financial interest through appropriate royalty-type arrangements.

Agree.

Regulation
General
22. A Regulatory Responsibility Bill should be enacted, based on the draft proposed in the recent report of the Regulatory Responsibility Taskforce.

Agree.

23. Property rights should be added to the list of rights specified in the Bill of Rights Act.

Also agree. It would be great to have Crown Law advising Parliament if proposed laws breach property rights of certain individuals or groups.

24. Substantially improving the quality of regulatory impact analysis being undertaken before legislation is introduced and/or government regulatory powers are extended should be treated as a matter of high priority by Ministers and central government agencies. Such analysis should be an integral part of all policy development and review processes, to ensure that the full costs and benefits, to all sectors, are appropriately and rigorously factored into government decision-making.

Agree, and I think Rodney has underway.

25. An independent Productivity Commission should be established as a centre of microeconomic and regulatory analytical expertise. The Commission should be authorised (and resourced) to undertake reviews of matters referred to it by Ministers, and of issues it identifies as requiring further in-depth analysis and research.

Have long advocated an independent Productivity Commission. The Australian one has performed well with bipartisan support.

Specific
26. A high quality independent taskforce should be constituted as a matter of urgency to review resource management law from first principles, including identifying the policy goals that should be served by such legislation and assessing the best ways of achieving those goals.

I am unsure how much this differs from the RMA reviews underway.

27. When determining the zoning of land for residential purposes, local authorities should be required by statute to take explicit account of any differences between the price of residential-zoned undeveloped land and the price of other undeveloped land in similar areas. These differences should be reported on by local authorities each year, with a strong presumption that scarcity of zoned land, as reflected primarily in price differences, should prompt action to increase the supply of residential land.

Sounds sensible. Land scarcity is what partly has led to a runway property market.

28. A system of tradable water rights should be established urgently.

Agree in principle.

29. Labour market:
a. Labour law should be amended to strengthen the freedom of negotiation between workers and their employers, including, for example, streamlining provisions governing dismissal of workers, and putting less emphasis on procedural matters.

Agree. The 90 day grievance free period for small businesses seems to be working very well with no horror stories about it.

b. Statutory provisions allowing enforceable mutually-agreed probationary periods for new employees should be extended, from the current maximum of 90 days for those working for small firms to a maximum of 12 months for employees of firms of any size.

That goes beyond my comfort level. Maybe 6 months for small firms, and 90 days for larger firms. Generally a dud employee can be detected fairly early on and 12 months seems too long to me.

c. For employees earning in excess of $100,000 per annum, employment relations should be governed by the standard provisions of contract law rather than by the Employment Relations Act.

That is what the situation was before the ECA for all non union employees. I would want to see data on how many employees over $100k are using the ERA provisions to see if there is a problem.

d. The youth minimum wage should be reinstated as a matter of urgency, and minimum wage rates should be reduced to the same ratio to average wages that prevailed in 1999.

I agree on reinstating the youth minimum wage. The abolition appears to have been a disaster with the blowout in youth unemployment through the recession. I do not support turning the clock back on the adult minimum wage but agree there should be a ratio of the minimum to the median wage.

30. Immediate notice should be given that from 1 January 2011 all remaining tariffs will be removed.

Agree, Disgraceful the Government has extended them to 2015.

31. Foreign investment restrictions should be further reviewed, starting with a strong predisposition that a much more liberal regime should be introduced.

I think this is underway and has been mainly implemented.

32. Emissions trading legislation and any future emissions reduction targets the Government adopts should be independently monitored and periodically reviewed. Such reviews should focus on monitoring the economic impact of any carbon abatement goals, and the impact of chosen abatement regimes (here and abroad) on prospects for achieving the 2025 goal.

I think this is in the ETS legislation.

33. A review of the Commerce Act should be undertaken, with a focus on restoring the primacy of economic efficiency considerations and long-term consumer interests in the design and conduct of competition policy.

Seems sensible.

34. The Government should strongly encourage the transformation of Fonterra into a conventional company structure with fully-traded outside capital, using any appropriate instruments at its disposal.

Don’t know enough to comment.

35. Zespri’s monopoly on the export of kiwifruit to markets outside Australia should be removed.

In principle I agree.

The North of Israel

On Friday we went up north. First stop was the Caesarea National Park, which has the ruins of the city set up by King Herod.

isr1

The park has lots of ruins, and also a good museum explaining the history of the area.

isr2

A group shot by the harbour. It was constructed to be a major port – around 100,000 square metres in size. The constructed a reef by dropping bales of volcanic ash into the sea, which turns them into solid concrete.

isr3

We then went to the Aaronsohn House. They were a family who operated as a spy network in WWI for the British against the Turks.

27 year old Sarah Aaronsohn was captured and killed herself after four days of torture, so she would not reveal her colleagues.

isr4

Despite being way north of Jerusalem, we ran into a Cabinet Minister. She is with the Labor Party, and I think has the commerce facility. Despite Davidi being with Likud, he is very good friends with the Minister – they were hugging each other when they ran into each other. Israel is a very small place, like NZ.

isr5

We then went to the old city of Tsefat (aka Zefat and Safed). On the way we visited a couple of war memorials. At most tourist sites they have a machine which will play an audio recording in Hebrew or English. They were really good to listen to – giving you a five minute history of what happened there.

Tsefat is a very old city, and many Orthodox Jews live there. Almost every second building is a synagogue. It is one of four holy cities, along with Jerusalem, Hebron and Tiberias. We saw the (outside of the) former home of Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, who left in 1948.

Direct Democracy

This story from Switzerland is a prime example of why direct democracy, rather than representative democracy, can be a bad idea.

Switzerland became the first country in Europe today to vote to curb the religious practices of Muslims when a referendum banning the construction of minarets on mosques was backed by a solid majority.

The surprise result, banning minarets in a country that has only four mosques with minarets and no major problems with Islamist militancy, stunned the Swiss establishment …

This is simply a horrendous decision. Freedom of religion is a fundamental human right, and should not be at the whim of referenda.

The campaign to ban minarets was described by the country’s justice minister as a “proxy war” for drumming up conflict between ethnic Swiss and Muslim immigrants. But the ban was supported by a majority of 57.5%, 20 percentage points more than predicted in opinion polls in the run-up to the vote.

This is interesting in that many back the ban, but did not want to admit to it. The advantage of parliamentary votes is they are public and people have to stand by their vote.

There are problems in Europe with Islamic extremism and non-integration. But the solution is not to ban minarets on mosques, targeting an entire religion.

2025 Taskforce Recommendations

Yet to read the full paper, but the Herald reports major recommendations are:

Dr Brash revealed 35 recommendations today but the centrepiece was to reduce government spending to 2005 levels of 29 per cent of gross domestic product by 2012-13.

This could be done by:

* Reducing benefit numbers through “ambitious” welfare reform;

* Ending Kiwisaver subsidies;

* Scrapping the New Zealand Superannuation Fund and using the money to pay off debt;

* Raising the age of superannuation eligibility; and

* Cutting universal subsidies for health and education.

Of these savings, $7 billion would be used to reduce all income and business taxes to a top rate of 20 per cent.

Dr Brash said unless tax and spending were slashed the Government’s “ambitious” goal could not be achieved.

“There may be some other cunning plan, but I am not aware of it,” Dr Brash said.

He said the proposed cuts were “not a massacre”, but a winding back of spending that had not been effective since 2005.

The taskforce’s other policy prescriptions included:

* Reducing the minimum wage and reintroducing a lower minimum youth wage;

* Changing employment laws to make it easier to sack workers;

* Extending probationary employment periods to a year for all workers;

As I type this I am literally on board NZ1 to Auckland sitting by the gate in Los Angeles. The wireless can still pick up the Koru Club signal – just. Will blog my thoughts on the different recommendations on Tuesday when back home.

Likud and Zionism

The rest of Thursday was learning about some of the history of Zionism and Likud specifically.  The first stop was the Menachem Begin Centre. Begin, who signed the peace treaty with Egypt, was effectively the third leader of the revisionist zionism movement. The modern founder of zionism was Theodor Herzl, and then Vladimir “Ze’ev” Jabotinsky led the revisionist faction, which Begin then led.

Begin died in 1992, and usually tops the polls of most admired former prime ministers. However for most of his career he was a terrorist/freedom fighter (depending on point of view) and was very much a political outcast until the 1970s.

The centre in his name, obviously is very favourable to him. They have a very nice set of displays, and audio-visual effects. The tour guide, who works for the centre, was a young Canadian girl who emigrated to Israel just two years ago, leaving her family behind.

Begin was a leader within the Irgun, and there is no doubt by today’s standards some of what they did would be called terrorism – especially the murder of the Sergeants. The British response was not much better.

There was also the infamous bombing of the King David Hotel, and to this day, there are bitter different points of views between the UK and Israel on it.

Not once in my time in Israel did I hear any demonisation of the Palestinian Authority. The two countries that were always criticised were in fact Britain (for former acts) and Iran (for current support of Hamas, Hizbollah etc). Britain was as much the enemy in the mid 1940s, as was the Arab states.

After the war of independence, tensions between the Ben-Gurion Government and Begin’s Irgun were massive, and in fact led to some bloodshed. Begin’s decision not to retaliate is said by his supporters to have prevented a civil war. Ben-Gurion seemed to despise Begin and would not even mention his name for several decades.

In 1977 Begin broke the 30 year monopoly of the Labour Party on power and became Prime Minister. His entire career had been as a hard liner who was against turning over any of the occupied territories to its neighbours. Yet he signed a peace treaty with Egypt in 1979, which set the precedent of land for peace, handing over the entire Sinai peninsula. He won the Nobel Peace Prize along with Anwar Sadat and Shimon Peres. His peace treaty was bitterly opposed my many in his own party.

jer19

The signatures on the final page of the peace treaty.

He also bombed the Iraqi nuclear reactor in 1981, and in 1986 approved the invasion fo Lebanon, which eventually led to him retiring in 1983. He was a recluse until his death in 1992. One of the reasons for his popularity is he was seen as a simple man of the people – and refused to be buried on Mount Herzl, but instead on the Mount of Olives next to two young Irgun fighters who killed themselves in jail to avoid execution by the British.

jer20

A view of old Jerusalem from the Begin Centre.

After the centre, we went to the West Bank. It was fascinating to see first hand parts of the occupied territories. Two things struck me. The first is how big the West Bank is, and how much room there. It is not some crowded area like Gaza. The second is how close many Palestinian and Israeli cities and settlements are to each other. Don’t think there is some nice straight line you can draw between the two.

Much of the West Bank will form a future Palestinian state. But it is not as simple as just going back to the 1967 boundaries. Even the Palestinians say they are not expecting Israel to abandon major cities in the area. What is likely to happen is that any area Israel keeps, might be replaced with some territory elsewhere from sovereign Israel. This can be made into a win-win but the devil is in the details.

wb1

A typical shot of the West Bank.

wb2

This is at the top of a strategically important hill in the 1967 war. The military are very reluctant to give up this area, as they say they could not prevent an invasion from reaching major cities without it. That is of course their point of view.

wb3

Below is a Palestinian town.

wb4

A photo of the group, in the West Bank. Regardless of the politics of the area, it was a fascinating place to view.

Then we headed to Tel Aviv where we visited the Jabotinsky Institute. This was the only part I did not enjoy much. It mainly consisted of a lecture on Jabotinsky, and the presentation was too zealous – mainly about how all the other Zionists turned out wrong and Jabotinsky was right. Was interesting to learn about him (I had never heard of him before), but what should have taken one hour took two and a half.

We then checked into out hotel in Tel Aviv. Now the hotels generally in Israel had been three star ones to keep costs down. The total cost for the six days was only 500 Euros, and that included hotels, food, travel, driver, and entry tickets.

Now the hotel in Jerusalem was very basic (probably a 2 to 2.5 star in reality) but okay to sleep in. But the hotel in Tel Aviv was a 0 star. You opened the door and immediately saw a cockroach. Not in just one room, and the first three rooms we opened. We gave up after that. Also I noticed the beds had just sheets on them, no sleeping covers. We eventually worked out based on the neighbourhood that this is one of those hotels that you normally rent by the hour.

We staged a walkout and found a much nicer one down the road. The owner actually got offended we were leaving. She was lucky we did not report it to the health authorities for demolition. Yuck. On the plus side it allowed us to hassle our host greatly about how he tried to book us into a prostitute hotel.

Then Thursday night was night clubbing until around 2 am in Tel Aviv. It has a active party scene. I had to cut out early to write my NBR column 🙁

What I gained most from the day is understanding that the issues around Israel did not start in 1948 or 1967. The zionist movement grew out of the late 1800s, as a response to the discrimination and worse of the Jewish populations in almost every country on Earth. People will disagree on whether or not the response was the correct one, but it is simplistic to see it as merely to provide a homeland after the events of the Holocaust – the move for a homeland had been steadily underway for some decades. Most of the planning happened when there was no Palestine – when the area was part of the Ottoman Empire.

Today Israel is an established fact, and there is little doubt there will be a Palestinian state at some stage. But under what conditions, and what boundaries is a long way from being resolved.