Fuck You says the Governator

letter

This is the official veto statement issued by California Arnold Schwarznegger to a bill by Representative Tom Ammiano, a few days after Ammiano abused the Governator at a function.

The Governor says it is just a coincidence. However the odds of those seven letters randomly spelling Fuck You is 1 in 8 billion.

I say don’t mess with Arnie 🙂

Hat Tip: Weather Sealed

Vile Vidal

AP reports:

A French lawyer for director Roman Polanski, imprisoned in Switzerland, says a new bail offer will be filed today and it will be a “very, very significant” cash amount.

He is trying to buy his freedom. It is almost inevitable he will flee back to France, even if it costs him millions of dollars.

Andrew Bolt blogs on the support for Polanski from Gore Vidal:

Author Gore Vidal says he refuses to feel any sympathy for Roman Polanski’s rape victim, whom he dubs a “hooker.”

In an interview with The Atlantic, the controversial 83-year-old author of such books as “Myra Breckinridge” and “1876” says of the director’s sex scandal, “I really don’t give a [expletive]. Look am I going to sit and weep every time a young hooker feels as though she’s being taken advantage of?”

The young woman to whom he is referring is Samantha Geimer, who was a 13-year-old aspiring model in 1977 when she was drugged and raped by Polanski.

Even worse Vidal claims Polanski is being persecuted because he is Jewish! No it is because he is a rapist!

This is a great site – Tripit

I had never heard of Tripit, but saw on my Linked In updates that a couple of peopel I knew were using it, and beign curious I checked it out.

This is one of the most useful websites I have experienced. It basically allows you to enter in details of a trip, and it produces an itinerary that you can not just print, but share with family and friends.

You can also have it automatically place into your calendar all the major events.

But that isn’t what is so cool. It is the user interface.

Even entering in flights manually is easy. Just need the airline code and flight number and the date. It then looks up (for every airline in the world) the departure and arrival times, the type of aircraft, a seating plan for the aircraft, the terminal you leave from etc etc.

But even that is nothing compared to the e-mail interface. Just e-mail your airline tickets confirmation e-mail to their e-mail address, and they automatically add it to your trip schedule.

And you can do the same with your hotel booking confirmation. One e-mail, and they list your hotel, its address, when you can check in and check out, what room size you have.

Forward to Tripit a dozen of your confirmation e-mails, and bang your multi-week itinerary is put together.

It is also smart. It adjusts your check in time to take account of your flights. You can also add on things like rail or rental car bookings, tour packages etc. They have interfaces to over 500 tourism companies.

They also automatically generate local maps, including routes between airports and hotels etc.

This will save me heaps of time planning future trips. It just brings all your travel arrangements together in one place, and of course you can then access them on your iPhone or Blackberry also.

Gower on Collins

Patrick Gower is doing a series of reports on the performance of key Ministers. He starts today with Judith Collins, whom he gives an 8/10.

Frontline police feel Ms Collins is on their side. On a macro-level, they have watched her preside over National coming good on its promise to put more police on the streets of South Auckland. She has also taken their fears about organised crime seriously, as seen in last week’s joint announcement with Commissioner Howard Broad about seizing the proceeds of crime.

On a micro-level, she is a proud Police Minister. Her empathy with police life was noted when Senior Constable Len Snee was murdered in the Napier siege, and she recalled her own time as a “police wife” when husband David Wong Tung was in the police and she wondered whether he would come home from work or not.

I didn’t realise until that siege, that Judith had been a “Police wife”.

Corrections is rated more difficult:

The Corrections portfolio has been a graveyard for many a minister, and at some point Ms Collins will have to start taking responsibility for its problems if she cannot solve them.

Superannuation Options

I was reading through a submission by Michael Little wood in the 2001 Super Fund legislation, and what struck me was that New Zealand has never really had a proper public debate on how we want our “tier 1” public superannuation structured.

Some of the issues one can debate are:

  • Eligibility Age (was also 65 in 1898 when life expectancy was 60)
  • Residency Eligibility (how long someone should have lived here)
  • Level (do you tie to CPI, median wage, average wage, GDP, )
  • Different levels by age – should it be at one level at say age 65 and a higher level at say age 68 or 70
  • Regional Variability – should the level vary based on where you live, to reflect living costs – as the Accommodation Supplement does
  • Income Testing
  • Asset Testing
  • Pay as You Go or Fully Funded
  • Level for singles as opposed to couples
  • Hospital Rates
  • Payments to overseas based people

But I don’t want to debate any of those options today. We’ll deal with them one at a time over the next few months. Just because the politicians are saying there will be no change, doesn’t mean we can’t have a debate.

The question for today, is what is the date at which any future changes should start to apply, or conversely for how long should we guarantee the current settings?

I believe it is very important not to make changes quickly. It is unfair on those who have already retired or are near retirement, who have made plans based on what the Government has said. This is also what provoked so much outrage in the 80s and 90s.

So this is not about what the current Government’s policy should be, as it has been made clear that is not going to change anyway. This is about when a future Government might want to make changes.

The cost of public superannuation as a % of GDP is projected to be the following by Treasury:

2010: 4.7%
2015: 4.8%
2020: 5.3%
2025: 5.9%
2030: 6.7%
2035: 7.3%
2040: 7.7%
2045: 7.8%
2050: 8.0%

I tend to think 2025 looks about right. If one started to change the age from 2025, that would mean those aged over 50 would still retire at 65, but under 50s would know it is likely to be older.

It is basically about balancing up minimising the impact of changes on those already retired or close to retirement, and the fiscal impact of any delays.

Up until what date do readers think the current scheme should be guaranteed to remain as it is? My pick is around 2025, but what do you think?

Bell Gully on Search and Surveillance Bill

The Belly Gully submission on the Search & Surveillance Bill makes some excellent points. It is attached here – Search&Surveillance_submission_Sep09[1]

Some extracts:

Bell Gully submits that the Bill’s premise that each of the government agencies to which it applies ought to share common search and surveillance powers is flawed. In particular, we are concerned that this approach grants broad powers of surveillance to some regulatory bodies where such powers are not justified by either the scope of their responsibilities or the nature of the offences that they are tasked with investigating. We consider that the investigative powers of a government agency should be appropriately tailored to the relevant regulatory context.

I think this is key. The Law Commission is generally very good at simplifying law, and in this case they have proposed a standard regime for all warrants and surveillance. But this is one of those areas where a standard regime may not be desirable – it is not a one size fits all.

Therefore the effect of Part 4 and Part 5 is to extend to non-police agencies (such as the Commerce Commission, the New Zealand Meat Board, the Ministry of Labour, and Local Authorities) the right to obtain a surveillance warrant, including the power to place a covert listening and/or recording device on private property.

Now these agencies already have the ability to get a search warrant. But this is also giving them the right to place covert listening or recording devices, and that is a step up from a search warrant. They note:

The installation involves the covert entry by a state agent into private property.

And I think Bell Gully make an excellent point about the difference between Police and other agencies:

The ability of a government agency to carry out surveillance in the ways contemplated by the Bill fundamentally changes the character of the relationship between the regulator and the regulated. Unlike the Police in their interaction with criminals, government agencies and regulators interact frequently with people and businesses in the relevant industry. It is therefore important that government agencies and those subject to their jurisdiction work to maintain goodwill.

The Police don’t have to maintain a relationship with the Mongrel Mob. But imagine what would happen if the Commerce Commission (legally) bugged Vodafone’s board room – there would be total hostility.

We note the Law Commission’s observation that, “the Police themselves expressed reservations to us about the desirability of this, believing that the activity might become too widespread and uncontrolled.” The Law Commission does not provide a detailed summary of the basis for the Police reservations. We suspect they reflect the fact that non-Police agencies do not have the checks and balances that exist in the Police culture of supervision, training and discipline, which constrain the misuse of surveillance powers. We share these reservations and suggest that the power to obtain surveillance warrants should only be granted where there is sufficient justification and robust supervision and training to minimise misuse.

So even the Police are not that keen on having a score of Govt agencies with the ability to bug people.

We believe that the better approach may be for non-Police agencies to refer serious offending to the Police and request that the Police obtain a warrant on their behalf.

Yes.

If any other submitters on the Bill want to send me their submissions, I’m happy to read them and as appropriate blog them. I think it s very important the Bill not be reported back without significant amendments.

Comment No 500,000

AECT Results

The left failed to win a single seat on the Auckland Energy Consumer Trust, according to the provisional results:

  1. Karen Sherry (C&R) 22,752
  2. Warren Kyd (C&R) 22,129
  3. Michael Buczkowski (C&R) 21,665
  4. James Carmichael (C&R) 21,140
  5. William Cairns (C&R) 16,793

The leftie Powerlynk ticket got votes ranging from 7,839 to 13,180 so it wasn’t even close. They actually lost the one trustee they had – Shale Chambers,

The centrist John Collinge led Just Power ticket ranged from 10,099 to 13,071 so also beat out most of the Powerlynk candidates.

There were 16 candidates, 13 of whom were standing on a ticket. Powerlynk got places 6, 8, 9, 11 and 14.

Whale Oil points out the Powerlynk team had prominent endorsements from Len Brown and Mike Lee on their pamphlets. Now of course this was not an election over the entire region, but it is a significant result all the same.

All you can eat music

Chris Keall at NBR reports:

In the US, some of the biggest tech buzz of the year has been generated by Spotify, an online music service that lets you stream an unlimited amount of songs via the internet each month, for a set fee, rather than buy tracks or albums individually on the iTunes model.

Last month, a similar service was launched in Australia, called Bandit.fm.

Now, Bandit.fm is set to migrate across the Tasman with a New Zealand launch set for late November.

The new service will let you stream (that is, play but not save) an unlimited number of songs each month for $9.95, payable in advance by credit card.

That is a great move, and the pricing seems very reasonable.

McFarthest

The Daily Telegraph reports:

It lies between the two tiny hamlets of Meadow and Glad Valley in South Dakota, from where it is at least two hours drive to the nearest Golden Arches.

The calculation was done by artist and technologist Stephen Von Worley, who mapped the 13,000 McDonald’s in the lower 48 states. Alaska and Hawaii were excluded.

From the “McFarthest Spot” the distance to the nearest McDonald’s is 107 miles as the crow flies and 145 miles by car.

The results mean that a hungry motorist is always within a full tank of petrol of a McDonald’s restaurant anywhere in the continental United States.

This reminds me of driving through Queensland once. There were huge distances between towns, and on one road we saw a sign that said 180 kms to the next McDonalds. Then later on 127 kms to the next McDonalds. Then 82 kms to the next McDonalds. Then 49 kms to the next McDonalds. And 14 kms to the next McDonalds and finally 2 kms to the next McDonalds.

Let me tell you it was the most brilliant marketing. By around the 49 km away mark we were all fixated on getting to a McDonalds and by the time you are 2 kms away, you can’t imagine anything else otehr than going to McDonalds.

The other clever signs I recall from that trip, was one is a small town. It said:

We have three cemeteries and no hospital. Please slow down.

Now that was effective!

A good thing about KiwiSaver

I had lunch yesterday with three of my staff at Curia. Two of them are at university and one has just graduated.

Over lunch we got onto KiwiSaver, and all three of them started talking about which KiwiSaver Fund they are with, how much they have earned, what the rate of return has been, and how they aim to use it to help get their first house mortgage.

Now one can debate KiwiSaver at the macroeconomic level – about whether there should be employer subsidies and Government subsidies.

But what struck me, was the difference it has made at an individual level. I can’t imagine before KiwiSaver, three young women (who still have massive student debt) would be talking about their investments, who is getting the best rate of return etc. Developing that culture of savings and investment literacy at an early age is possibly KiwiSaver’s greatest claim to fame.

The Apprentice – New Zealand

I’m with Cactus on this.

I can’t see the cream of NZ’s aspiring business leaders applying to be The Apprentice just to earn a six figure salary working for Terry Serepisos.

Most business graduates reckon they will be earning $100,000+ before they are 30 anyway.

But it is not just about salary. The US Apprentice worked so well as people would do anything to work for the Don. Not so much for the US$250,000 salary but for the prestige, and more importantly the wealth of contacts you gain. Working for Trump will get you through almost any door.

I think Serepisos has been very successful, and like what he has done with the Pheonix. He isn’t a bad choice for the role, but the problem is that with one or two exceptions there are no good choices.

Unlike the US, you don’t need to work for a top businessman, to gain access to top business and political leaders. We are a small enough country that people see them all the time.

So what was needed was a strong personality. Bob Jones would have been ideal 20 years ago. It would have been the best viewing possible.

HoS on Labour

The HoS discloses another Labour MP, Iain Galloway-Lees, was involved in their internal polling operations. No suggestion he did anything wrong – just that he helped recruit volunteers and was in attendance.

More damning is the editorial, titled Labour loses moral compass.

This is a time, not for elegant mendacity, but for simple truths.

Senior Labour MP Rick Barker ran a publicly-funded political poll from his Parliamentary office last month.

And, when confronted last week by a Herald on Sunday journalist, he initially denied knowledge of any polling.

To me, the poll itself is not that significant a story – but the denial and attempted coverup is what has pissed off the media.

This was dishonesty.

It was dishonesty of the sort that former Labour Cabinet minister Lianne Dalziel displayed, when she denied knowledge of a leaked immigration report in 2004. Yet that was a foolish deceit, made by an impassioned minister in the heat of the moment. Dalziel, at least, had the grace and integrity to resign from Cabinet.

No such integrity is shown by the Labour Party under Phil Goff.

Ouch.

Rick Barker refuses to admit his intent to deceive. And worse, his party’s parliamentary leadership has largely backed him.

Labour, it seems, has lost its moral compass.

Labour has focused on defending the poll, but has failed to address the more serious issue of Barker lying to the media.

They conclude:

Goff has just cowered and, when confronted by political reporters outside the Labour Caucus room with nowhere to hide, obfuscated.

Labour’s leader must now stand up and take responsibility for the deception that was conducted with funds entrusted to him by Parliament.

Barker should be sacked from all his Caucus responsibilities. Hughes, too, must be left in no doubt about how repugnant his rationalisations are.

These, then, are the simple truths that are demanded of Labour’s tarnished leadership.

And these are the truths Labour has forgotten.

I actually feel a bit sorry for Labour over this. Normally this would be a one day story. But there is a bit of a political news vacuum, so it has ended up in the media most of the week. Part of this is because of their inept response to the story, but part of it is just bad timing.

Did he tell them he wants to increase their levies even more?

The HoS report:

It was, perhaps, Phil Goff’s first Triumph in quite some time.

A thousand bikers roared their disapproval at proposed ACC levy hikes yesterday – along with Labour leader Phil Goff on a brand-new motorbike he had bought shortly before.

I’m betting that Phil didn’t tell them that the increase was due to his former Government increasing coverage and a resultant $4.6 billion liability blowout.

I’m also betting he didn’t tell them that the modest pruning of coverage done by National, he has vowed to reverse. This means that levies will increase even faster under Labour.

Labour are trying the maxim that you can’t fool all of the voters all of the time, but you can fool some of the voters. They are campaigning against both levy increases and decreasing coverage.

Most ten year olds can work out you can’t both cut revenue and increase expenditure.

Hand held cellphone use in cars now illegal

The Herald has some details of the new law:

You can not answer or make phone calls with a handheld phone while driving.

Creating, sending or reading texts, email messages or video messages, while driving, is banned.

Making genuine emergency 111 calls is permitted. This includes *555 calls used to report dangerous driving.

Making or receiving calls if the phone is “secured in a mounting fixed to the vehicle” is allowed. This typically means a cradle, or fully integrated systems. But the driver can only manipulate a securely mounted phone “infrequently and briefly”.

Earphones, headsets and mouthpieces attached to phones can be used, provided the driver does not hold or manipulate the phone.

You can use music functions, provided the device is mounted.

Using a phone if stuck in traffic because the road is blocked by an accident or other cause is permitted.

This does not apply when drivers are “stationary in the normal flow of traffic, such as approaching intersections, traffic lights or roadworks”.

Using a phone while on a bike or motorbike is not allowed.

I can’t disagree with the phone on a bike rule!

The law won’t affect me as my phone bluetooths into my stereo, but I still think it will just force a lot of costs onto people, and not decrease the road toll. It will be interesting to see in 2010 how many crashes still cite cellphone use as a factor.

Sustainability

An interesting article in the Herald:

But however highly consumers may rate green issues, there is no doubt National’s return to power has seen an easing in the pressure on business to make sustainability a high priority. The change is evident in organisations such as the Electricity Commission and the Energy Efficiency and Conservation Authority. Says one Wellington insider: “They’ve completely flipped their positioning – now it’s all about being the choice of the consumer. Before it was regulatory. Now it is much more about encouraging manufacturers to use more energy-efficient light bulbs, not compelling them to.”

And that is a good thing. And I say that as someone who has been using those lightbulbs before Labour trie to force us to.

The game has changed for New Zealand businesses, says Brown. There is a new Government which is none too keen on the word “sustainability” and there is a recession, so money is tight. “But it’s a myth that to be sustainable there has to be a cost to the bottom line. Sustainability helps business efficiency.” Many New Zealand businesses, she maintains, are still “blissfully unaware”.

It is unfortunate that some businesses do see sustainability as costing more, because in many circumstances it doesn’t.

R v Hide

The case for and against Rodney Hide over using the international travel subsidy for long serving MPs to have his girlfriend accompany him.

The case for the defence:

  • He has already paid for the perk through a lower salary. The Remuneration Authority deducts 100% of the average value of the international travel perk (around $6,900 per MP) from their salary. The Authority also deducts around $4,000 from MPs salary to cover the 45% of spouses domestic travel deemed of personal benefit.
  • Up until 2009, it was almost automatic that Ministers would have their partners travel with them. This has only become an issue because John Key has changed the rules.
  • It is not hypocritical to oppose something but take benefit from it. Many people think the pension should be means tested, but they don’t turn it down when the reach 65 all the same.
  • Most men, if they had a girlfriend like Louise, wouldn’t leave her at home alone while they were overseas in case she changes her mind while you are gone 🙂
  • Rodney, like most Ministers, works 70+ hour weeks, and gets very little family time as it is. This is why traditionally Ministers get to have partners travel with them, and we should not begrudge it
  • Two weeks is a long time to go without sex 🙂
  • One overseas trip a year, with a partner, for a Minister is hardly troughing
  • The trip was approved by the PM, and within the rules.

The case for the prosecution:

  • Any other year it would not be such an issue, but this was done during a recession when Ministers are campaigning for spending restraint
  • The PM had made it clear he did not think the taxpayer should generally fund partners on overseas trips. It didn’t matter that he approved the trip – that was because he can’t set policy for how MPs use their parliamentary entitlement.
  • You used to be known as the perk buster – that means yes you do have to be a martyr.
  • The public hate hearing “It was approved and within the rules” when MPs write the rules.
  • After the fuss over Roger Douglas, one should have known that the ACT Party Leader, of all people, needed to be like Caesar’s Wife – beyond suspicion.
  • No one is saying your partner shouldn’t travel with you – it is a matter of who pays for it.

I think I have covered all the major arguments for and against. I would point out that most of the media have not really mentioned the aspect about the average cost of the international travel perk being deducted from an MPs salary.

There was some suggestion on other blogs, and linked here, that the amount of travel credited to partners may be wrong. I don’t think the Herald did have it wrong, and I’ll explain.

If an MP is a Minister, then Ministerial Services basically pays all his or her travel expenses as an MP. They don’t try and work out are you travelling as a Minister or an MP, because that would be a nightmare administratively.

But Ministers also do show travel expenses from Parliamentary Service. That is not the cost of their parliamentary travel, but generally the costs of their family’s travel and/or any use of the subsidy for long serving MPs on private travel.

Kevin Hague on National Penis Day

Reason No 187,265 why me working for Hitler would have been a bad idea

I tend to crack jokes a lot, even at fairly inappropriate times. Luckily I’ve never been sacked for it. Unlike Fritz Darges. He has just died aged 96, and was one of Hitler’s closest aides. But look at what got him sacked:

But Darges misjudged the “warm-hearted” FĂźhrer deeply during one conference at Rastenburg on July 18 1944 – two days before a bomb plot nearly succeeded in killing him.

During a strategy conference a fly began buzzing around the room, landing on Hitler’s shoulder and on the surface of a map several times.

Irritated, Hitler ordered Darges to “dispatch the nuisance”. Darges suggested whimsically that, as it was an “airborne pest” the job should go to the Luftwaffe adjutant, Nicolaus von Below.

Enraged, Hitler dismissed Darges on the spot. “You’re for the eastern front!” he yelled. And so he was sent into combat.

I thought the retort was very good. But what sort of grump was Adolf to not just sack him, but send him to the Eastern Front for whimsical retort!

Sadly Darges still worshipped him:

Darges died on Saturday still believing in the man who engineered the Jewish Holocaust as “the greatest who ever lived.” His memoirs will be published now in accordance with his will.

There will be a lot of interest in his memoirs.

Dom Post on Free Trade

The Dom Post editorial:

The gloom merchants and flat earthers who dispute the benefits of free trade agreements should examine a set of figures.

They are the figures showing the difference between New Zealand’s trade with China before the FTA between the two came into force in October 2008 and after it came into force. In the year to October 2008, exports to China totalled $2.2 billion. In the next year, they were $3.5b.

At a time when New Zealand is being buffeted by shockwaves from the global economic crisis, the deal has buffered jobs and boosted incomes. The political parties that voted against it – NZ First, the Greens and the Maori Party – should hang their heads in shame.

Can’t say it better than that. They are the enemies of our exporters!

Cellphone age of use

The Press reports:

Teenagers who prefer texting to talking have driven some parents to call for a minimum cellphone ownership age of 14.

“Parents are worried teenagers are losing the ability to properly communicate with eye-to-eye contact,” said Shanti Ravichandran, of Auckland’s Unitec, who has surveyed parents’ attitudes to teenage cellphone use.

She said the use of text language was “overpowering” among teenagers, with some even using it in school examinations.

Ravichandran, a Master of Computing graduate, said 52 per cent of the 115 parents or caregivers she surveyed felt there should be a minimum age of 14 for cellphone ownership.

How effing ridicolous. The last thing NZ needs is an age limit for using or owning a cellphone. What next – a state imposed curfew at 9 pm, or a mandatory go to bed at 9.30 pm?

Those 52% of parents are very welcome not to allow their kids to own a cellphone. But they shouldn’t try and decide for all families what is best. Decisions should be made by families, not the state.

I know many parents who find it incredibly reassuring that their kids have a cellphone, as they can contact them 24/7.

Parents’ main concerns about cellphones were text bullying, addiction to text messaging and the negative impact on communication skills, she said.

“Because it is so discreet, teenagers are doing it under their sheets and they’re not getting enough sleep.”

So the solution is to send in the Police to arrest them?

Herald on Govt’s first year

This weekend it is the Herald’s turn to do a big feature on the Government’s first year in office. Multiple article to quote.

John Armstrong starts with what I think is the most important aspect:

The first Herald-DigiPoll survey since last year’s election shows close to 80 per cent of respondents rated the Government’s performance in dealing with the effect of the global recession on New Zealand as good, very good or excellent.

Barely 20 per cent rated the Government’s response to the recession as not good or poor.

And this is the major issue voters have focused on. Not use of urgency, not the Super City, not RWC broadcasting, not any of the numerous beltway issues. Not to say handling of those issues is not worthy of focus, but they are not critical to the average voter.

In another article, Armstrong reviews Key himself:

Key’s sheer ordinariness has fooled opponents into making first impression assumptions that there is little substance behind the confident, smiley face he presents to the world.

Key would not claim to be an intellectual. But he is very bright. Those who have worked closely with him speak of a capacity to absorb mountains of information and a laser-like capacity to focus on what needs to be done.

I would almost call Key a data sponge. He loves soaking up information from numerous sources, and reflecting on it. He is constantly thinking, and analysing.

He is anything but ordinary. The chief executive of New Zealand Incorporated is nothing short of a political phenomenon.

As one Beehive operative of long experience puts it, Key is rewriting the rules of New Zealand politics. That is a sweeping statement. But it goes some way to explaining why public support for National – confirmed in today’s Herald-DigiPoll survey – has climbed to unprecedented highs for a ruling party in its first year of government and, just as crucially, continues to remain at that level.

The challenge for the Government is to build its own brand to complement Key’s strong brand.

Key cites his Government’s fulfillment of manifesto commitments and steering the country through and (he hopes) out of economic recession as crucial in consolidating support for his party. Cabinet ministers readily acknowledge, however, that National’s post-election dream run is overwhelmingly down to Key’s strong rapport with voters – especially females who shunned National in the past.

It is rare for a centre-right party to do well with female voters.

Labour Party insiders grudgingly agree, but with a subtle twist in the language: National’s popularity rests on Key’s popularity. When the latter starts to fade, the former will quickly evaporate.

As I said above, I agree with them that the popularity is largely Key. But that may change over time, as other Ministers become better known. Also the other Ministers have generally been doing quite well in their portfolios – what is lacking is more a coherent all of Government brand.

Or so Labour prays. Labour, however, has made a bad habit of underestimating Key.

And they still are.

One of the principal ways he is seen to be rewriting the rules is by applying a “will it work” test to policy proposals rather than first asking whether they sit comfortably with National Party ideology. Key’s willingness to search for ideas outside conventional boundaries is in tune with an electorate less hung-up about ideology than in the 1980s and 1990s.

Key has centre-right values and instincts, but he sees them as a guide not a straitjacket.

This may irk some colleagues who see the vast gap between National and Labour in the polls as a rare chance for National to adopt a more radical and right-leaning prescription. …

Key seems to have no difficulty with either proposition. However, he is extremely wary of breaching National’s 2008 manifesto. He believes it is vital that voters feel confident they can trust National in government.

I’m one of those who want to see the Government be more bold, and indeed use that vast poll gap while we have it. But it isn’t about being more “right”, it is about fighting battles that are important to our future such as tax reform, the union stranglehold in education, state sector reform etc. But I agree any reform has to be consistent with the election manifesto. But there are plenty of areas where initiatives were not ruled in or out.

Dunne also noted that “references to what happened in the 1990s, let alone what side one was on during the Springbok Tour or, heaven forbid, the Vietnam War are utterly irrelevant to the values of this new generation, as Helen Clark found out dramatically last year, and Phil Goff is continuing to find out”.

The battles of yesterday.

Though Goff is an effective communicator, Key operates on another level. Unlike some politicians, he never talks down to people. He instead likes to disarm his audiences – no matter how big or small – by kicking off proceedings with a witty anecdote. More often than not, the joke is at his own expense. And deliberately so. The self-deprecation helps to break the ice.

A typical example was a recent meeting with youngsters at a riding school. Praising their ambition to represent New Zealand in show-jumping at the 2016 Olympics. Key turned to their proud parents, telling them “and you’ll be able to watch it all on Maori television”.

Heh. More seriously I recommend anyone who has not seen Key do a Q&A, should attend one of his meetings. He really engages with the audience, and as John A says, never talking down.

Yet, a year on from the election, it is still difficult to discern the direction in which the Government is going. Presumably it knows, because it is a very busy Government. It would be useful if it told the rest of us.

If Key has a major flaw, it is in not drawing the big picture often enough.

I agree. I don’t think it has mattered much this year, for it has been a crisis year – fighting the recession. But as that fades as an issue, people are going to want to hear more about closing (or at least slowing) the gao with Australia.

Key’s power is at its zenith. But how does he intend to use it? What legacy does he want to leave? The next 12 months will be true measure of his prime ministership, judged on what is done to get his promised “step change”in New Zealand’s economic growth.

I think the 2010 budget is very important, even more so that the 2011 budget.

Claire Trevett reports 78% of NZers back the series of cycleways.

Patrick Gower talks to Rodney Hide about working with John Key.

John Armstrong also reviews Bill English.

Claire Trevett talks to Tariana Turia:

Do you still have that level of trust in National?

Yes. What I’ve enjoyed the most is our ability to be upfront with one another and be straightforward on issues. I have never found that they’ve said one thing to me in a meeting and done another.

I recall what John Tamihere said about how Cullen used to treat coalition partners!

Have there been difficult choices?

When you can see value in what is being proposed but there’s always downsides to it. We’ve had to think really carefully about ACC, the Emissions Trading Scheme, and adult education courses.

For example with the ETS, it’s been difficult to try to balance the interests of iwi – whose major focus is forestry, fishing and farming – when on the other hand we’ve got really poor communities who are going to have to pay and they’re not the ones causing the problems.

There are very few policies that don’t involve balancing the trade-offs.

Jon Johannsson talks leadership:

I believe we are watching an unusual prime ministership take shape. Key’s skillset is vastly different from what we’ve seen before. We’d possibly have to go all the way back to the entrepreneurial Julius Vogel in the 1870s to find an apt comparison. Vogel put in vital and much-needed infrastructure to connect New Zealanders with each other and then with the rest of the world. Vogel’s legacy is a hugely significant one in our politics. If Key could affect a 21st century equivalent – meaning nothing short of major structural transformation to better position New Zealand during its transition to an information-age economy – his future legacy would be assured.

And Key has pushed hard on infrastructure. But the structural transformation is not there – however stuff like the fibre to the home initiative may be part of that.

Key has also grasped that our politics is going through a non-ideological phase, which explains why much of the criticism of his Government’s performance has come from ideologues on either side of the spectrum. His acceptance of much of Labour’s policy inheritance reinforces this judgment. Keeping its promises, which National has largely done, thereby establishing long-term trust with the electorate, has given Key the prerequisite platform needed for greater freedom of action in the future.

Absolutely. You have to earn trust, to then have greater freedom of action.

But to return to where I began, Key’s larger context; his political vision has been quite parsimonious in my view. There is no overarching narrative that tells us where Key intends taking us or what policy mix will best maximise our future progress and choices.

Transforming education (surely the best incubator for our future economic prosperity), leading our democracy (think: the electoral referendum, the Treaty, republicanism), and how to best protect water, our most valuable strategic resource, are being managed, not led, in an entirely ad-hoc fashion.

I think this is fair criticism.

Finally John Roughan:

The most impressive member of the Cabinet is a complete newcomer, Steven Joyce.

He is doing the infrastructure projects, notably the duplicate broadband network, as well as those in his primary portfolio, transport.

He’s done the little things, like the car cellphone ban on which the previous government dithered for years, and the big things like the Waterview connection, which I thought was wrong but he put me right.

I remarked to the Dominion Post for their review that I thought John Key’s best decision was probably appointing Steven Joyce to such critical portfolios. The fibre rollout was Key’s signature initiative, and speeding up infrastructure investment also a iconic issue for Key. And Steven indeed is no ditherer.

Of course I still think he is wrong on the cellphone ban!