Headlines and Guilt

iPredict Column

This week’s iPredict column is done:

Buy of the Week
The Sun newspaper, after thee consecutive endorsements for Labour, has today endorsed the Conservatives for the May 2010 general election. And PM Gordon Brown has been fending off questions over prescription drug use.

Add to that the first poll since 1982 that shows Labour in third place, behind the Lib Dems, and you conclude the stock to buy is UK2010.CON.ABS which pays out if the Conservatives get an absolute majority. Current price is 70c.

Sell of the Week
OCR.INCR.APR10 has increased from 25c to 55c in the last fortnight. This has obviously been driven by the early exit from recession, as the stock pays out if Allan Bollard puts up the OCR before April 2010.

However I think the stock is overpriced. The reason is Dr Bollard has previously said he does not see any tightening before June 2010, and he has yet to indicate a change of tune. I’m holding onto my sell.

Spike of the Week
The Mayor.Brown stock has been at 32c for some time. Then Len Brown came out and said that he would welcome Sue Bradford as a colleague on the Auckland Council. The market saw this as a bad move, with his stock dropping to under 26c. It has since rebounded somewhat to 30c.

GST
There are two GST stocks. GST.UP.JULY10 is at 14c and as previously noted is highly unlikely. Still a good stock to sell in my opinion.

We also have GST.UP.JAN11 which is at 30c. For this to occur, the Government has to both decide to increase GST and implement it before the end of 2010. Now it is possible they could do so in the May 2010 budget and have it occur on 1 October 2010. 1 April 2011 would be easier, but GST up in election year could be politically unwise – even if matched by reductions in other taxes, All things considered 30c is about right.

Top Trading Stocks
The petrol price stocks have been the most active in the last week, with over $20,000 of trading. The new UK election stocks have gone down well with over $5,000 traded. In third place is the Roy Morgan poll stock.

Cheers,

David

Disclosure

David’s current iPredict positions are:

BROWN.RESIGN Short, DL.KING.09 Short, FASA04.REPEAL Short, GST.UP.JULY10 Short, LEAD.GOFF.09 Short, MAYOR.BROWN Long, MIN.DEPART2.09 Short, MP.ANDERTON Short, MP.PETERS.2011 Short, NAT.MAORI.09 Short, OBAMA.DISAP.4NOV Short, OCR.INCR.APR10 Short, OCR.INCR.JAN10 Short, PETERS.LEADER Long, PM.2011.NATIONAL Long, VSM.1STREAD Long, ZIM.MUGABE Short

How did Civil Defence communications do?

As I blogged in July, I attended a Civil Defence briefing earlier this year on how their Tsunami warning system works, so I figure it is worth reviewing what went well, and not so well.

Timeliness – a big tick for this one. The advisory was released well before the potential tsunami was due to hit NZ.

Media – NZ Herald and Stuff websites carried the info, as did Breakfast TV. Seemed to do well keeping media informed.

Website – Not so good here. The main Civil Defence website did say an advisory had been issued, but nowhere on the site could you actually get the full details of it. The media do not always get things absolutely correct, and people should be able to go to authoritative sources.

Radio – people were told to listen to their radios for any local evacuation instructions. I think at some stage this strategy may have to be revisited. With ipods, more and more people do not have or listen to the radio. To get through to younger people especially, the Internet and text messaging is going to be more relevant.

Twitter – Twitter was great as a way to alert people, and that is where I first heard about it. I suggested to Civil Defence that they should look at having an official Twitter account as it would have been good for people to be able to retweet an official advisory rather than second hand reports.

E-mail – I received the warning threat by e-mail at 8.06 am. That was 90 minutes before the first wave was due, so pretty good. Only complaint is the e-mail address they came from was [email protected] and that doesn’t look too official. Would be better for it to come from a govt.nz address.

Overall pretty good effort I though, as in by 0945when the first wave might hit, I would have thought most of the country was aware of the advisory.

Xero Update

Rod Drury has blogged:

We put out our first half operating update this morning.

Xero Operating Update to 30 September 2009

Xero has over 12,000 customers and now has customers in 50 countries. How cool is that!

Very cool. I say that as a user and shareholder. I also calculate $600/year income per customer and estimate income is now around $7 million a year.

Just 12 months ago we had 2200 customers. As you can imagine there has been a huge amount of work going on behind the scenes to ensure that we scale all aspects of the business to deal with this level of growth. With the additional capital raised in May we’ve been able to gas up on development as well as build out our sales team with senior people in NZ, the UK and Australia.

Wow that is great growth.

We’re delighted we’ve been able to lock in our growth rate after our seasonal high of March and feel that we’ve put the foundations in place for the next step up.

Selling software to the vast and fragmented small business market is really hard. There are few companies who have cracked it. The way people are using the web is evolving quickly and we’re all just starting to understand the impact of social media. Over the last half we’ve experimented with a number of marketing and sales approaches to find what works in our space and in each country. I’ve really enjoyed this stage of the business and I think we’re evolving sales models and processes that work. There is no doubt we are still learning.

Our entire team have worked really, really hard over the last half. There is a buzz inside Xero as all the hard work we’ve been doing is beginning to pay off. We just love the feedback and hearing how people enjoy using our software.

Thank you to our valuable customers and partners. We really appreciate your support and the great ideas and feedback. Our list of things to do has not got any smaller. And thank you again to our shareholders who have given us the opportunity to build a company that we all at Xero are proud of.

For those interested, there’s a thread from earlier this week on Xero’s new pricing plans, and some Q&A with staff.

Jake Quinn on Bill English

I’m surprised and impressed. Former Labour Press Secretary Jake Quinn has done a fair and balanced post on Bill English. He has just gone up hugely in my estimation.

It’s time to leave Bill English alone. Labour and the press gallery have had a good run with it. Bill’s been embarrassed, he’s paid some money back and the issue will always slightly affect his credibility as Finance Minister. But enough is enough.

Bill’s home in Dipton has been in his family for 120 years. It’s on English Rd. It’s full of his stuff and he is the local MP. Some time ago he decided to have his family reside in Wellington so they could be closer together – his kids go to school there and his wife practices medicine there – it’s an honourable thing to do for someone planning a life in politics.

Bill has to maintain two residences because he has two homes, two rates bills, and everything else that goes with it.

Exactly. The regime is meant to neither advantage or disadvantage MPs. It would be different if Bill had sold or rented out his Dipton home, but he has not – as he says it has been his family home for 120 years, and will continue to be so once he leaves Parliament.

MP’s need to be ultra careful and conservative when it comes to what benefits and kickbacks they receive.Ā The public mood for lynchings is high, especially after the British MPs’ expenses scandal which led to numerous resignations.

Labour does need to be careful. For example a (very) senior Labour MP has his adult daughter live with him in Wellington. Does than mean he should lose his Wellington accommodation allowance? I don’t think so, but if you apply the standards Labour has applied to Bill, then maybe there are some double standards.

And again, if Labour and the media think it would be a bad thing if Bill had changed his trust arrangements to get a bigger taxpayer subsidy (something a QC has said did not happen), then where is the scruutiny over the practice of (at least) the Green MPs to have their superannuation fund purchase Welllington property on their behalf, as this increases what they can claim from the taxpayer from merely interest on a mortgage to full rent of up to $24,000 a year.

How much of a difference does this make. Well if the property has $150,000 on the mortgage and interest rates are 6%, the maximum you could claim off the taxpayer is $9,000. But by vesting the property in their superannuation fund, they can claim up to $24,000 in rent.

Now this is quite legal, but has escaped the same scrutiny.

Bill should have been more careful so deserves some of the criticism he has received. However, successive Speakers of the House, from both major parties, have signed off on his arrangements and the legal buck stops with them.

Indeed, Hunt, Wilson and Smith have all agreed he qualifies.

What’s more, his being in breach, if he is, is a technicality. He’s only in trouble because the allowance is called an ā€˜out of town MP’ allowance. If it was called the ā€˜MP’s who have a home in their electorate but choose to spend pretty much all of their time in Wellington’ allowance then there wouldn’t be an issue.

This has been the problem for Bill. Because the rules use the term “primary residence” he has been arguing Dipton is his primary residence, and the public have rejected the notion that the primary residence can possibly be a place you and your family don’t live in most of the time. It does not matter that under the rules, it can be – it fails the common meaning test.

At some stage in future the rule should probably be amended to just asking whether or not the MP resided outside of Wellington before they became an MP, and whether or not they still own a property outside Wellington, which is not rented out or used by others.

A very fair post by Jake. His co-blogger Jeremy Greenbrook-Held balances it up by doing the normal partisan rant. He hysterically demands Bill must resign or be sacked and also gets numerous facts wrong. Not even worth fisking it is so puerile.

Plan for dealing with disruptive kids too late says PPTA

The Dom Post reports:

Education Minister Anne Tolley unveiled plans at the Post Primary Teachers’ Association (PPTA) national conference in Wellington yesterday to put 12,000 parents of disruptive kids through parenting courses and give 5000 teachers from low-income areas extra training to deal with violence.

PPTA president Kate Gainsford said the plan was “a step in the right direction” but was not enough to help secondary teachers already dealing with disturbed and violent students.

“It’s a great idea, we won’t see the results for another decade, and that’s just too late,” she said.

Hmmn, who has been in Government for the last decade? Is the PPTA saying Labour should have done this in their first year of office, rather than leave it to National to come up with solutions in their first year of office?

“It needs to be supplemented at the adolescent level now.”

That would be nice, and it is tough for teachers with disruptive adolescents. But in an era of limited funding, the targeting of the scheme at kids when they are much younger will have the most impact in the long term.

Caption Contest

Revolution

An idea for Yellow Pages

An article in the Herald about how Yellow Pages sees 018 calls as a declining business due to increased cellphone use where people store common numbers.

This is true, but got me thinking of a new business model.

When someone rings your cellphone you see their name if they are in your contacts, otherwise only their number.

Wouldn’t it be great if Yellow Pages teamed up with the telcos so that if you get a call from a number not in your contacts, it shows you the name that number is registered to – if it is in their public directory.

I would happily pay a monthly fee for that service.

TSO changes overdue

I doubt there has ever been a better (or worse) case of unforeseen consequences that the former Telecom Kiwishare, now known as the Telecommunications Service Obligation.

It had the best of motivations – to protect rural New Zealanders whose phone lines could be deemed uneconomic by requiring Telecom to still provide them with flat rate local calling at at an inflation adjusted price cap.

The first failure has been the price cap. The cost of telecommunications has dropped massively over two decades. But guess what happens if you have a law that says Telecom can increase line rentals by no more than the rate of inflation. Well not only do they not drop prices, almost every year without fail they increase line rentals by the rate of inflation. A price cap becomes a price target.

The second failure was its effect on competition. It not only kept competitors from offering services to rural NZ, it made them fund Telecom for its so called “uneconomic” customers. Tens of millions of dollars went from struggling competitors into Telecom.

So after years of discussion, we’ve finally had decisions to make changes, by Steven Joyce. They are:

Currently Telecom receives approximately $70 million per annum largely to compensate it for supplying local service to rural customers.Ā  This money is sourced from the industry via the TSO levy which is paid by market participants (including Telecom which contributes approximately 70%) on a market share basis.

Mr Joyce says he is concerned by the lack of transparency around where this money is spent and whether rural customers are benefiting from it.

“The existing TSO levy has been in place since 2001 and has been a source of considerable controversy within the industry. A recent review of the TSO had identified that the current methodology for assessing how much the TSO commitment was costing Telecom a year was flawed.

The current TSO levy methodology counts the costs Telecom incurs but does not include the full range of benefits Telecom derives from the TSO.

The government is proposing to change the methodology for how much Telecom is compensated for uneconomic customers.Ā  By counting both the costs and the benefits of the TSO it is likely that the TSO levy will reduce to zero for the foreseeable future.”

The non inclusion of benefits was a cause of considerable angst for the competitors who paid $21 million a year to Telecom. This decision has near universal support.

However the telcos are not getting to keep all the money they used to pay:

“We’re proposing to fund the $300 million rural initiative through a combination of direct government funding and revenue from a more transparent and effective industry levy than the current TSO levy.”

The government will provide a direct contribution of $48 million and further interim funding of up to $52 million.Ā  The remaining funding will be sourced by replacing the existing TSO industry funding with a more transparent contestable industry-wide mechanism that focuses on developing rural telecommunications.

The new telecommunications development levy to replace the TSO levy would look to recover around $50 million per annum over the next six years – about $20 million less than is currently the case.

“When the government tenders for the provision of rural broadband it will be an open and competitive process, with full transparency on where the money is spent,” says Mr Joyce.

So around 70% of the old levy will still be collected, and used to fund rural broadband. This part is less than popular with the telcos, but very popular with Federated Farmers.

A more purist model would be to have the Government fund rural broadband development directly (if one accepts there is an economic gain in doing so), but the model announces is quite cunning because competing telcos are still pretty happy to be funding $15 million a year to a fund which is contestable and will actually increase broadband infrastructure, than $21 million a year to Telecom merely to maintain the status quo.

Telecom of course does not do so well as it used to collect $21 million for doing basically nothing, and paid $49 million to itself for the same thing. It will now pay around $35 million to the Government for the contestable fund. Some consolation to Telecom, is that they are in the best position to win most of the tenders for using the funds.

The Herald reports:

Vodafone chief executive Russell Stanners said it was time for reform of the TSO.

“The TSO regulation was introduced with the best intentions but has become a millstone around the neck of the industry.”

Telecom said it had been part of an industry-wide push to secure reform of TSO arrangements.

“This reform is long overdue and needs to be based on principles of contestability, transparency and technology neutrality,” Telecom chief executive Paul Reynolds said.

“It is equally important that any subsidies applied to fund services to uneconomic customers are borne equally by all consumers, and not just Telecom’s.”

Federated Farmers welcomed the plan but said it was approaching it cautiously until more details were known.

Pretty much everyone agreed on the need for reform, and most will say this is going in the right direction.

The Telecommunications Industry Group (TIG) said the plan amounted to a $252 million industry tax.

“The Government has just replaced one form of taxation with another, in an industry where prices are dropping, margins are tight and customer expectations are increasing,” said TIG chief executive Rob Spray.

They are right, except of course it is replacing what was an even higher $350 million industry tax. It is a move in the right direction with both a dropping of the amount levied, and a change in what it is used for.

Economist blog Progressive Turmoil, blogs favourably on the decision, and has a neat little graph too.

This is what Winston and the Greens oppossed

The Herald reports:

A year ago today New Zealand’s free trade agreement with China came into effect.

The results so far show it to be a big success, says New Zealand Trade and Enterprise’s general manager for North Asia, Rod McKenzie.

New Zealand exports to China climbed to more than $3.3 billion in the year to June 30 – an increase of 61 per cent on the previous year.

Clark and Goff did very very well with the China FTA. I regard it as their finest foreign policy achievement, even though their own Foreign Minister campaigned against it.

Award cutting CEO had just returned from European junket

I blogged yesterday on how the Radio New Zealand CEO Peter Cavanagh informed all his staff that they would not be entering the Radio Awards this year, as the costs of submitting entries is too high for their constrained budget.

Roar Prawn reports that the same CEO has just returned from Amsterdam where he had been attending the International Broadcasters Conference. Rooms at the closest hotel are 310 euros or $630 a night.

Death Toll thought to be 100

40 dead was bad enough, but the death toll in Samoa, and to a degree Tonga,Ā  is now thought to be 100.

Around 15,000 are homeless, at least temporarily.

Samoa has a population of 179,000 so if this was NZ it is would be the equivalent of around 2,410 dead and 360,000 needing shelter.

You can donate online to the NZ Red Cross appeal here.

No awards for Radio NZ staff

An e-mail sent to all Radio NZ staff today:

2010 New Zealand Radio Awards

This is to advise you that due to budgetary constraints Radio New Zealand has – reluctantly – withdrawn from this year’s New Zealand Radio Awards. As you know, Radio New Zealand’s funding was frozen in this year’s Budget and we have been forced to implement a range of cost-saving measures to offset an increase in non-discretionary overheads totalling $1.5 million in the current financial year.

Unfortunately the New Zealand Radio Awards carry significant entry costs for Radio New Zealand and the decision to temporarily withdraw has been made to protect expenditure on core services. This decision will be reviewed after the 2010 Budget.

Peter Cavanagh
Chief Executive and Editor-in-Chief

I understand the staff are less than impressed.

Backbenches tonight

  • Peter Dunne, United Future
  • Charles Chauvel, Labour
  • John Hayes, National

Topics include becoming a republic and paid parental leave.

They film at Backbencher live from 9pm tonight – but people turn up from about 7.30 to get a good spot and primed.

Watch on Freeview 7 or Sky 97 or online Ā tvnz.co.nz/backbenches

Banned by the ODT

Classic

Maori Party 2008 Campaign

NZ on Media

Fran O’Sullivan had what I consider a really good idea, during her speech on political blogging yesterday.

Part of the discussion was around the increasing commercial pressures on newspapers, and their diminishing resources to do investigative journalism etc.

Fran said she thought it was very unbalances that the Government (taxpayer) funds some media through NZ on Air, but this is restricted to broadcasters only.

She advocated that NZ on Air should become NZ on Media, and all media should be able to apply for worthy “local content” projects whether they be TV, radio, print or Internet.

I think that is a concept with some merit. First of all it does make for a more level playing field. But also because a contestable funding pool for print (and Internet) journalism could help turn around the decline in quality research intensive journalism (which is often not commercially viable).

Now as print and Internet has much lower costs than broadcast, I don’t think opening up the field, would lead to a huge amount of money being drained from the broadcasters. Maybe a couple of million out of the tens of millions they grant every year.

Note this is not about increasing the total amount of funding for NZ on Air, but increasing the range of eligible applicants.

Someone like No Right Turn could (for example) have applied for a grant for his research and series of posts on the sedition laws (which helped lead to the law being unanimously repealed).

A newspaper could apply for a grant of say $25,000 to allow a journalist to spend three months working on a story about (for example) the immigration system.

There would be some challenges such as editorial independence, but I think it is a proposal worth considering. Why should TV and radio retain exclusive rights to NZOA funding?

It is worth mentioning that NZ on Air does sort of fund stuff on the Internet – the very worthy NZ on Screen archive of iconic NZ TV shows. However that is funding Internet storage and access of TV shows, which is different to funding contemporary material regardless of medium.

Fisking Jacinda

The Hansard of the first reading of the VSM bill is now online. If I have the time, I want to respond to all the MPs who spoke out in favour of compulsory membership, but for now will just respond to Jacinda Ardern’s speech, as the version of history painted is now one I or my colleagues remember.

Jacinda said:

Unlike the member who is in charge of this bill, I can speak from some experience, having attended a university that looked at voluntary student union membership. I was at Waikato University in the 1990s. I was not a student politician—I want to make that clear—I was a student. I was an observer of what happened, and I voted in the election that eventually led to that university being the first in 70 years, I believe, to go voluntary. I inform members of this House that it was the first university to go back to universal membership, because it learnt that it was a disaster to move to a voluntary system.

Now Jacinda has one thing right. WSU was voluntary, and now is compulsory. But far from VSM being a disaster that students rejected, the return to compulsory membership happened due to the machinations of the then Vice-Chancellor – former British Labour MP Bryan Gould.

You see what Jacinda doesn’t tell you is that Waikato students voted to go voluntary in 1996 by 63% to 37% in a referendum . The supporters of compulsion tried to overturn that the following year with another referendum, which VSM also won easily.

Undeterred they tried again in 1999 in a referendum (triggered by the current law) and got thrashed. VSM won 78% of the vote, in a turnout of around 30%.

So what happened? In 2000 the University, headed by former British Labour MP Bryan Gould, scheduled a further referendum upon receiving a petition late in the year. They scheduled it for a short three day period at the beginning of study week for exams. And they only gave students one days notice of the vote. Their own staff advised against this, and said there should be two weeks notice.

Turnout fell from 30% to around 10%, and compulsion won on its fourth attempt in an election that Iran or Afghanistan would be proud of. I mean at least they get more than one days notice of a vote!

Jacinda’s claim that Waikato students rejected VSM, in fact reminds us of how flawed the referendum model is. Apart from the philosophical objections to having 51% being able to force 40% to join something, you can’t get a fair vote on most campuses. Even if your Labour mate the VC doesn’t schedule the vote to favour the forces of compulsion, you generally have the students association having 100 times the resources of those supporting VSM. More on that another day.

Anyway for those who want more info on what really happened at Waikato, a colleague of mine has put together a summary which is below:

One favourite myth of opponents of voluntary membership concerns the voluntary era at the Waikato Student Union (1998-2000) and the impact of three years of voluntary membership on the association. Labour MP Jacinda Ardern referred to WSU during her speech on the first reading of the Education (Freedom of Association) Amendment bill last week. Let’s have a look at her claims.

But first some history and background.

Jacinda claims that Sir Roger’s bill follows previous voluntary membership bills from, in her order, Tony Steel, Donna Awatere-Huata, and then Michael Laws. She has the order wrong. Michael Laws introduced his members’ bill in 1994. It went to select committee in 1995 but lapsed in 1996. The Steel and Awatere-Huata bills were two separate members’ bills that were simultaneously drawn in May 1997. The Awatere-Huata bill did not receive a second reading. The Steel bill was passed in August 1998, but only after a compromise, promoted by some New Zealand First MPs, led to the introduction of referenda as the means to determine whether membership would be compulsory or voluntary.

WSU’s move to voluntary membership happened prior to the passage of the Steel bill. In September 1996, following two years of campaigning by voluntary supporters, WSU members voted 987 to 591 to make membership of WSU voluntary from 1 January 1998. In August 1997 compulsory supporters called another referendum in an attempt to overturn the 1996 decision. This was unsuccessful and students voted to confirm the introduction of voluntary membership. In 1999 there was another referendum, this one triggered by the Steel bill. This time 1984 students voted voluntary, 561 voted compulsory, from a total turnout of 3051. So much for NZUSA’s claim that students don’t want voluntary membership.

Voluntary membership at WSU ended in questionable circumstances. By 2000 WSU had a pro-compulsory president. His executive collected signatures for another referendum but waited until October and the final meeting of the academic year before presenting the petition to council. The referendum was held on 16-18 October. At the time, David Penney, a former president of APSU, the national polytechnic student association and then a university employee, pointed out the problems with the timing of the referendum saying,

the University will have less than one day to officially notify students of the vote, normal practice two weeks; maximum voter turnout may be undermined by the timing of the vote, which is recommended to take place on the first three days of study week when on-campus numbers are low; the integrity of the process may be undermined given the short lead-in time.

Jacinda also claimed that WSU’s return to compulsory membership ā€œhappened only after all of the services that (Waikato) students had benefitted from had collapsed.ā€ According to Jacinda the collapsed ā€œservicesā€ were foodbanks, emergency housing and a hardship fund. Trouble is WSU never provided any of these things. Waikato students paid (and still pay) separate levies for health and counseling, student buildings, and food, bars and the recreation centre. The university collected levies for these three areas and none of them were affected by voluntary membership.

WSU owned half a dozen rental properties but these weren’t emergency housing. Prior to 1996 they were, however, rented out at below market rates and often to executive members and their mates. In 1995 WSU attempted to justify the use of student money to buy houses by claiming that if they owned enough properties they could eventually force down Hamilton rental prices. I doubt if WSU members were aware they were funding a Waikato version of a Polish shipyard.

Jacinda’s in good company when it comes to making false claims about WSU. In 2000 Steve Maharey complained about the ā€œmillion the voluntary purists at Waikato fiddled awayā€. However an examination of WSU’s balance sheets shows WSU’s equity during the three voluntary years fell by $4000; from $578,000 (1998) to $574,000 (2000). I hope Steve’s not using the same calculator at Massey.

Over the next few weeks I’ll be looking at more of these myths.

Praise for the PSA

PSA National Secretary Richard Wagstaff blogs:

A shift in the right direction

The news that Treasury is looking to save 30% of costs and increase productivity in the public sector by centralising back office services may surprise some people. …

While the PSA is concerned for the interests of individual staff caught up in the process to centralise these functions, there is sense in bringing back a whole of government approach to much of the states activities, including the back office functions.

All too often unions are seen as instinctively anti-reform, no matter what its merits, and anti anything that may save money.Ā  I’m pleased to see the PSA take a more nuanced position on this issue.

Another 10/10

Tsunami Warning

Civil Defence has issues a rare tsunami warning. Stuff reports details:

A tsunami is radiating across the South Pacific following a massive 8.3 magnitude earthquake near Samoa and will hit New Zealand later today. …

The Hawaii center’s updated timings for the arrival of a tsunami in New Zealand are:

East Cape at 9.44am

Gisborne 10am

North Cape 10.12 am

Napier 10.40 am

Wellington 10.50 am

Auckland (east coast) 11.12 am

Auckland (west) 11.39 am

Lyttelton 11.55am

New Plymouth 12.17pm

Nelson 12.23 pm

Dunedin 12.31 pm

The Ministry of Civil Defence and Emergency Management said there was a tsunami risk to New Zealand from the earthquake.

The ministry has issued a tsunami warning for New Zealand coasts.

Ministry director John Hamilton said that the ministry had alerted the country’s regional Civil Defence Emergency Management (CDEM) groups, police, fire service, Ministry of Health, Department of Prime Minister and Cabinet and other government agencies.

The ministry has activated the National Crisis Management Centre and was co-ordinating central government response.

The CDEM sector was activating its emergency plans.

Regional CDEM groups were working urgently with local authorities, local emergency services and local media to warn and if necessary evacuate coastal areas at risk.

Detailed evacuation advice would come from local authorities and local emergency services.

If told to evacuate people should, where possible, take a radio and cell phone with them, along with essential items such as glasses, hearing aid and medicines.

Note that so far there is no advice to evacuate.

Tom misses the point

Tom Pullar-Strecker misses the point, in my opinion, with his column that the Govt should ban using mobiles for satnav. He wrote:

Last week, The Dominion Post asked the Transport Ministry whether it would illegal from November to use mobile phones as satellite navigation aids in cars.

The initial response from spokesman John Summers was confusing and ambiguous. But pressed for clarification, Mr Summers consulted colleagues and came back with a clear answer:

“You asked whether a driver can look at a navigation system on a mobile phone even it is securely mounted. The answer is to this is no, not while driving.

“Under the Road User Amendment Rule 2009, you can use a mobile phone held in a cradle (including those that double as a GPS device) while driving but only to make, receive or terminate a phone call. Ā You cannot use them in any other way such as reading a GPS map, reading email, or consulting an electronic diary.”

I would contend that was a sensible and considered position, and that Transport Minister Steven Joyce’s decision yesterday to cave in from pressure from gadget-fans and amend the rule was a mistake.

I contend it was the exact opposite, and the Minister inserting some common sense into the rule making.

Mr Joyce said it was not the intent of the rule to make it illegal for motorists to use the satellite navigation or music functions of their cellphones, “provided these are mounted in the vehicle and are manipulated infrequently”.

He met with officials and instructed them to “amend the rule accordingly”.

Mr Joyce appears to have Ā thereby explicitly sanctioned people taking their eyes off the road and looking at instructions on their mobile phone, and tinkering with it, while their vehicle is in motion.

That is arguably more dangerous than people using unmounted cellphones to answer calls, the problem the rule change was originally designed to tackle.

Well I’m no fan of the cellphone ban anyway, but there is a big difference between using a device to chat to someone not in the car, and using a device to tell you where to drive.

If Tom thinks there should be no tinkering in cars, will he support banning all car radios?

How long does Mr Joyce believe it would be safe for people to take their eyes off the road? Say it takes 2 seconds to absorb the visual information from a smartphone doubling as a SatNav. In that time a car travelling at 50km will travel 27 metres.

That could be the two seconds during which a child steps out in front of the vehicle.

But here is where Tom misses the point.Ā  The Government has never intended to ban the use of GPS devices in cars. If we did so, we would be the laughing stock of the world as the most common consumer use of GPS is for car navigation. And imagine the impact on tourism as tourists are told they can not use GPS to find their way around – but instead have to use maps.

Incidentally far more dangerous for a driver to be looking at maps while driving, than a GPS device.

You see the stupidity of the draft rule is that using your cellphone for GPS navigation would have been illegal, but using a dedicated GPS navigation device would not be illegal. Now it is, and was, daft to differentiate. An iPhone, for example, has just as large a display screen as some dedicated GPS devices.

This makes as much sense as having a rule saying you can’t use your cellphone to take photos, but you can use a normal camera. Laws and rules should not be based on the technology, but on what it is used for.