Treasury on BERL report

I covered a while back the evisceration of a BERL report into the social costs of alcohol. This report inflated the cost by around 3000% (or $4.6b), and was being cited by the Law Commission as rationale for all sorts of law changes.

NBR reported at the end of last week that Treasury has now expressed concern about thre reliance being placed on reports such as this (which costs the taxpayer $135,000). NBR quotes Treasury Deputy Secretary Peter Bushnell:

The Berl report into the social costs of alcohol being used by the Law Commission is work that doesn’t look like it meets the “normal standards you would expect”, according to Deputy Secretary of the Treasury Dr Peter Bushnell.

There were numerous problems cited in the report by its academic reviewers, including:

“I think the points they’re making are sound about adding the costs of production into the cost of it, and not counting any benefits. In a market if you’re selling something that people are prepared to pay for, then they’ve at least got that much benefit, otherwise they wouldn’t have bought the stuff. So if you exclude the benefits then you’re clearly only looking at one side of the story.”

And as I have said previously,far too many Government reports look at costs only, and not benefits.

However, the mere fact Law Commission president Sir Geoffrey Palmer is seeking out economic advice is positive, “because in the past lawyers often assumed that economics had nothing to do with it.”

That said, the onus should be on the Law Commission to be rigorous Dr Bushnell said.

“Sir Geoffrey’s reputation is reduced [if] he’s putting weight on something that actually doesn’t stack up. So the Law Commission ought to … build in processes that give adequate QA and so on.

“What we’re saying is it’s your reputation that’s at risk here. It doesn’t reflect well on the Law Commission if it … backs [work], that doesn’t have a sound basis.”

That is a pretty undiplomatic serve. Basically saying if you use shoddy reports you’ll get a shoddy reputation.

I’m actually a fan of much of the work the Law Commission does (I like the fact they are pro-active not just reactive) but Ministers will not be as inclined to listen to them if they don’t make sure any reports they use as justification hold up to scrutiny.

Editorials on State House Policy

The Dom Post last week said:

During last year’s election campaign, the National Party promised, if it won, to put the Kiwi dream of home ownership back within reach.

Part of its plan was to allow some state house tenants to buy the homes they lived in, while maintaining the state housing stock by reinvesting the money in replacement homes. It has since also committed to building another 1550 state homes over four years.

In February, it announced it would fast-track $124.5 million worth of investment in state housing by upgrading 10,000 homes and adding 520 others before July. This week, it went further.

From September, tenants can approach Housing New Zealand to discuss their purchase options, which might include their also benefiting from the state’s so-called Welcome Home mortgage guarantee scheme, which applies to low-income earners buying their first homes. …

But perhaps the most notable aspect of this policy is its stark difference from that which the last National administration implemented. Then, state houses were sold to tenants and not replaced, and Housing Corporation mortgages were on-sold to financial institutions. The state plainly wanted to get out of housing.

The motivation this time seems different. The Government of Prime Minister John Key, who began his life in a Christchurch state house, seems to be saying that state involvement must be a hand-up only to home ownership, and that those who can afford to move on should do so. It is to be hoped they take the hint.

And today’s Herald:

Tenants of state houses will shortly be given an opportunity to buy them. Housing Minister Phil Heatley has announced that houses will be offered to tenants at market valuations from September and Housing New Zealand will use the money to build new houses.

This news has been greeted with predictable disapproval from Labour, the Green Party and various advocacy groups who claim to be concerned for people in urgent need of a state house. Their preferred solution seems to be to spend whatever it takes to house everyone who cannot afford to buy a home. But since that would be an open-ended liability it is plainly impractical. So what else would the opponents of state house sales suggest?

Their policy on this issue is probbably the same as their policy on every issue – borrow and spend.

But historically, Governments of all stripes in this country have baulked at forcing comfortable state tenants to forsake their homes. These people are often elderly and settled and it would be cruel to uproot them. Since Labour and the Greens agree with the Government about that, why do they not support the gentler course of enabling these people to own their homes?

Well Phil Goff used to.

This perhaps hints at the critics’ real concern. As the Greens’ Sue Bradford put it, “Houses which are sold can be back on the market quickly, with investors and developers reaping profits. This happened in the 1990s,” she said, “and I’m sure it will happen again now.”

The Left does not like the idea of any property becoming a source of private profit, and Ms Bradford has the gall to accuse the Government of “ideology”.

Amusing if it wasn’t so sad.

The policy looks to be good for the tenants, good for their neighbourhood, good for those waiting for a state house, good for the taxpayer, the building industry and the economy. Good for everyone, in fact, except those who live on constituencies of state dependence.

Take a bow Labour and the Greens.

Stephen Cook vs Herald on Sunday

I got this e-mailed to me:

HERALD ON SUNDAY IN EMPLOYMENT RELATIONS AUTHORITY

The controversial and much-rumored-about court case between award winning journalist Stephen Cook and his former employer the Herald on Sunday – where he was employed as assistant editor until earlier this year – has been assigned a hearing date

This week’s hearing will be open to the public.

Date: 2 July, 2009

Time: 9.00am

Location: Employment Relations Authority, Level 10, The 280 Centre280 Queen Street, Auckland central.

Counsel for Stephen Cook – Chris Comeskey

Counsel for the Herald on Sunday – Champan Tripp

Cook is the former Assistant Editor of the HoS. His last articles appeared in late September 2008. Ironically he won a 2009 Qantas Award for feature writing for an article on the pain of parole.

He attracted some controversy in when he pressured Debbie Gerbich (who had complained about Brad Shipton) into giving an interview, amidst revelation that she was advertising for bondage partners. Gerbich later commited suicide.

There has been some interesting speculation on the nature of the parting of the ways, and the court case sounds most interesting.

Dole rules

The Herald reports:

Two economists are calling for a fundamental rewrite of New Zealand’s welfare system because of the numbers of people being made redundant who can’t get the dole because their partners are still working.

When I read this, I thought to myself that I bet one of the economists is Susan St John.

Dr Susan St John of Auckland University and Keith Rankin of Unitec say the system is based on “outmoded social concepts” such as assuming that everyone lives in single-income families where dad goes out to work and mum stays home with the children.

I don’t think the system is based on those assumptions. I think a change with what Dr St John proposes would be both unaffordable and inefficient – it would be more middle class welfare and tax churning.

Going from two to one incomes is not nice, and many families struggle I am sure. But that can’t be compared to a zero income family. The unemployment benefit is for families where neither partner is (significantly) working.

The Government already has massive deficits and debt. This is the silliest time to be proposing making it worse – in my opinion. Any extra welfare payments have to be borrowed and eventually paid back by future taxpayers.

Espiner on Mallard vs Lockwood

Colin Espiner blogs on Mallard vs Lockwood:

Initially Mallard seemed to be suggesting taking a motion of no-confidence in the Speaker, but later said on his blog that Labour would “wait for a better case”.

I think he and his colleagues need to draw a deep breath and wait for a considerably better case.

Lockwood Smith is the best thing to happen to Opposition parties since Question Time was invented. He is easily the most fair, unbiased, and straightforward Speaker Parliament has had in years.

High praise.

In sports parlance, he’s a ref who plays advantage and isn’t always on the whistle. When Mallard took a frankly pathetic point of order yesterday to complain that Key wasn’t addressing the chair when he was speaking, but had his back to him, Smith shut him down quick-smart, saying he was more interested in what the Prime Minister was saying than how he was standing.

That’s what I like about Lockwood Smith. He doesn’t suffer foolish or pedantic points of order. He’s all but stamped out the tabling of press releases. He requires ministers to answer, not just address the question. And he doesn’t yell “order” every five seconds for some minor transgression.

For years people have used the ability to seek leave to table a document as a method of scoring an additional point. You would say something like “I seek leave to table the Minister’s press release of xx in which he says how poor people should move house”. Lockwood has no power to refuse to seek leave on behalf of a member, but often reminds the MP seaking leave to table such a document that the Standing Orders Committee has noted this is an abuse of standing orders as you should only seek leave to table a document MPs do not alreay have access to.

This has massively reduced such frivolous tablings, which means more time for actual questions and law making.

Overall, Labour should thank its lucky stars Lockwood Smith is the Speaker and quit moaning.

As a result, I think Parliament is a much more smooth-running and frankly democratic place.

Smith has thrown out far fewer MPs so far than his predecessor Margaret Wilson, and it was always odds-on that Mallard would be the one to finally go.

Colin is assuming that the Labour Opposition are glad to have a Speaker that has made Ministers more accountable and increased the public regard for Parliament.

I am not so sure that is a wise assumption. I would go further and suggest many in Labour hate the fact Lockwood is regarded so well by the gallery and those in the public who follow Parliament. Don’t think that Labour welcomed the changes Lockwood introduced. It was not only National Ministers who protested them. Senior Labour MPs on several occasions asked Lockwood to reconsider his new interpretation that Ministers must answer the question if it is a clear primary question with a potential factual response.

Hunt and Wilson were amongst the most partisan and well connected Labour MPs. They were tribal Labour. Imagine how galling it must be to senior Labour MPs to have even some of their own supporters talking about how great Lockwood is doing and by comparison how bad Wilson and Hunt were?

Those senior Labour MPs will also know that Lockwood’s forcing Ministers to answer questions will (ironically) actually help the Government as the sight of arrogant Ministers being asked “How many unemployed people are there” and refusing to actually give an answer is part of what creates the impression of time to go.

Finally the fact it is Lockwood that has proven so popular as Speaker will also chafe some in Labour. They opposed his nomination, and he has always been a target for certain Labour MPs.

So I think Labour are going to actively look for opportunities to try and attack Lockwood, and possible even no confidence him. They, I suspect, would be more than happy to go back to the old days, if they can.

Great viewing

As people will know Labour has attacked National’s decision to let state house tenants buy the homes they live in. Well some clever sod at National found a report from 19986 when the then Labour Minister of Housing proudly announced exactly the same policy, and raved on about how wonderful it will be.

Who was the Minister of Housing then? Our own Phil Goff. So enjoy the video of Phil Heatley having fun with Goff in the House.

It does reinforce the point I made last week about Goff being an enigma. I’d like to know what he really thinks about allowing state house tenants to buy their own homes. Does he really think what he announced in 1986 was a mistake?

MacDoctor on Labour and Health

MacDoctor nails it here:

If you were wondering why Labour spent so much extra money on Health without actually improving the health of New Zealanders, nor their access to services, puzzle no longer. Ruth Dyson reveals all. She is complaining that some of the health promotions that were dear to Labour’s heart have been cut or seriously curtained. Things like cancer “control”, heart promotions and the diabetes “get checked” programme. …

No, Ruth, these are NOT frontline services. They never were and they never will be. These are all Labour’s attempts at preventative health promotion and, as such, provide no health service at all. This is not to say that preventative health is necessarily useless, just that they are not frontline services. They are not delivering medicine, they are delivering social change. At least, they might be delivering this.

That is a great line – they are not delivering medicine, they are delivering social change.

That does not mean all public health activies are not worthwhile, but they are not the same thing as actually giving someone an operation, a prescription etc.

The biggest problem with all of these preventative health schemes is that no one appears to have bothered to examine whether they are making any difference. Labour’s attempt to monitor results of these campaigns (now removed from the health reporting list by National) were so wishy-washy and soft, that it was impossible to tell from the data whether they were successful. That does not seem like a good use of taxpayer dollars to me.

Take the diabetes programme “get checked”, for example. This programme, unlike most, actually has links to hard data like blood results, blood pressure readings and hospital admission rates for diabetes and diabetic complications. All the hard evidence shows that the programme has made virtually no difference to the quality of diabetic control.

Huge amounts have been spent on programmes that *might* improve health outcomes. But what data there is, is patchy.

Diabetics who normally don’t attend their regular check-ups don’t abscond because they can’t afford it, they don’t come in because they can’t be bothered. Diabetes is one of those diseases that kill you slowly, like high blood pressure (only worse). People don’t like to see the doctor unless they are sick. So they don’t. All that “get checked” does is make it cheaper for the people who would have regularly attended their doctors for diabetic monitoring. It is a subsidy for diabetics. Nothing more, nothing less.

More middle class welfare.

There is nothing wrong with this. It is just not something you want to fund at the expense of real frontline services like outpatient visits and elective surgery.

Which is what Tony Ryall is sensibly targeting.

Labour’s singular failure in health is their constant focus on what would be nice at the expense of focussing on what is truly needed.

Dead on target here.

Nobody is saying that heart prevention programmes are invariably a waste of time. We may demonstrate that they may be very useful indeed at reducing long-term heart disease. But it is not right that a dozen people should die because they can’t get heart surgery in time in order to fund a social intervention. Particularly one that does not have demonstrable benefits.

This is how Labour managed to double health spending but almost make no impact on waiting lists etc.

2009 Freedom Forum

From Thursday to Saturday, DC time, I have been at the 2009 Freedom Forum – an annual event put on by the International Young Democrat Union.

Today we heard from Manda Zand-Ervin who heads up the Alliance of Iranian Women. They work with women inside Iran helping them to establish the foundation of a civil society and trying to publicise to media the plight of the women and children of Iran.

Women actually had equal rights in early Iran until around 623 AD when it become Islamic. Before the 1970s Islamic takeover women again had managed equal rights but now count as one-half of a man. Women do not get the custody of their children, do not have the choice in their clothing, residence, leaving the house, working, education or travelling without the permission of their husband.

Girls are “allowed” to marry is nine. Men can divorce the women at any time they wish and can marry several wives in addition to them. Girls inherit one-half of that which boys do.

One area of non discrimination though is hanging – around 200 women were hanged in 2008. And Iran sits on the Human Rights Commission dealing with women’s rights.

We also had a speaker from Cuba – a relatively young guy who left only a few months ago. He had been a pro-democracy activist so hadd been arrested and beaten up by the state on numerous occassions. Finally it got so bad he got out.

Chatting to anouther Cuban, I found out there is actually a law in Cuba which translated basically is for “pre-criminal social dangerousness”. Yes they actually convict you for pre-crimes – just like in minority report!

We do not realise how fortunate we are in the freedoms we take for granted – but the price for them is vigilance.

Loving DC

This is my third visit to DC and as always, I am loving it. Not because of the politics – but the city itself. Unlike many major US cities, DC is a delight to be in. There are no massively tall buildings blocking the view (due to the 1899 Heights of Buildings Act that stops buildings being taller than the Capitol or the width of the adjacent street plus 20 feet).

You can walk around much of DC, or use the Metro. I’ve found the taxi service variable but a lot cheaper than NZ – the maximum fare for anywhere within DC is $18!

Also so many good bars and cafes. I am staying with a friend near 18th Street in Morgan-Adams which has lots of bars and cafes.

But most of all I love the parks and the monuments. So much heritage here.

dc1

A state of FDR and his dog. I am very amused that I just tried to Google the name of his dog and the filter at the Heritage Foundation (a conservative thinktank where I am today) blocked it as a banned term!! 🙂

I have got around that and discovered it was Fala. His name was used as an identification question during the Battle of the Bulge!

dc2

Also part of the memorial which was established just a decade ago in 1997.

dc3

Most people should recognise Lincoln at the Lincoln Memorial.

dc4

This is the view of the National Mall from the Lincoln Memorial at the south end of it. The US Capitol is at the far end.

dc5

The Korean War Memorial.

dc6

A very apt saying – one we forget too often.

dc7

The WWII Memorial is in the middle of the National Mall and is even more recent than the FDR memorial – established only in 2004.

dc8

And everyone should know 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue.

Political Spectrum Quiz

Wrong wrong wrong

Chris Trotter repeats one of the great myths of the Labour left as he makes excuses for Labour legislating away the rights of Maori to go to court:

But, of course, your enemy’s enemy can just as easily be your enemy too – and in the case of the foreshore and seabed debacle this was especially true. Labour’s erstwhile deputy-leader, Michael Cullen, was telling no more than the truth when he pointed out that his government had no room to manoeuvre over the Foreshore & Seabed Bill.

From the moment the Court of Appeal’s decision was announced, Labour’s pollsters began to register a rising level of anti-Maori feeling in the Pakeha population. Clearly, it would require a strong, bi-partisan effort to withstand such political pressure. Of course, National’s pollsters were picking up the same racist vibes as Labour, but, rather than stand against them, the strategists surrounding National’s new leader, Don Brash, opted to exploit them.

The Orewa Speech delivered by Brash in January 2004, and the extraordinary shift in political allegiance from Labour to National that it accomplished, destroyed any hope of a bi-partisan approach to resolving the issues raised by the Court of Appeal.

I’ve seen Labour push this version of events often, and am disappointed that Chris has fallen for it. Quite simply it is a lie, and the dates prove it.

  1. Thursday 19 June 2003 – Court of Appeal announces decision
  2. Monday 23 June 2003 – Clark and Wilson announce they will legislate to prevent any applications for title

Yes Labour announced the legislation just four days (or two working days) after the court of appeal decision. I’m sick of the fucking lies about Labour backing down under a nasty Don Brash led campaign that finally forced Labour to legislate.

Labour announced legislation as their first reaction – not their last. They panicked – totally. Thursday they hear the decision, and within 24 – 48 hours they would have resolved to recommend to Cabinet they legislate.

Even more stupid is the attempts of the left to portray Labour’s decision as being linked to Brash’s leadership and his Orewa speech. The dates for those are:

  1. Brash becomes Leader on 28 October 2003 – 127 days after Labour announced they would legislate.
  2. Brash’s Orewa speech was on 27 January 2004 – 218 days after Labour announced they would legislate.

Is it too early for jokes?

Guess not:

When Farrah Fawcett got to heaven God said to her

“Farrah, because you have been such a good person throughout your life I will give you one wish”

Farrah thought about this and replied

“God, I only want one thing and that is for the children of the world to be safe”

God agreed to Farrah’s wish and killed Michael Jackson

Blog Bits

  1. The Dim-Post on how John Key will use Gandalf the Grey to save the economy.
  2. Tracy Watkins expresses concern that some Ministers are already using the “It’s operational” excuse to avoid comment.
  3. Iain Lees-Galloway at Red Alert is blogging his trip to the UK Parliament. This is a very smart thing to do, and other MPs should consider similiar when they are on taxpayer funded overseas travel – let the public get live updates of what you are doing.
  4. Aaron Bhatnagar blogs the Auckland City Council submission on the new Auckland Council.
  5. Blaise Drinkwater blogs some recent Electoral Commission decisions. The most significant is that Laboru declared a major donor (over $20,000) six months later. But they escape prosecution as the time limit for prosecution expired.

Electoral Finance Submission

I was hoping to blog this over the last week but got too busy so have had to write it all in the last 36 hours.

Anyway for those interested my submission is here – electoral-finance-reform-submission-form-final-dpf.

The very high level summary of what I advoctaed is:

  1. Agree with six principles but under equity makes it “manifestly unfair” rather than merely unfair. Also add 7th principle of simplicity.
  2. Ban all anonymous donations (except those under $100 as not practical to record every cent), and abolish protected donations regime through Electoral Commission.
  3. Retain transparency and disclosure of donations through an intermediary such as a trust.
  4. Proposed disclosure threshold for donations remain at $10,000/year but also require disclosure if donations exceed $25,000 over a three year electoral cycle.
  5. No limit on donations from a single source.
  6. Donation levels should be inflation adjusted.
  7. No restriction on who can donate, so long as significant donations are disclosed.
  8. Against any additional public funding of parties or their campaigns
  9. Would ban all advertising from parliamentary or Government funds during the regulated period, except essential advertising approved by Auditor-General.
  10. Restrict the current broadcasting allocation to parties not in Parliament as parties in Parliament already have a massive advantage with their media profile, their MPs, their parliamentary staff and their parliamentary budgets. Suggest $200,000 per non parliamentary party be allowed.
  11. Political parties (and third parties) should be allowed to purchase their own broadcasting time and advertisements.
  12. TVNZ and RNZ should not be required to give away free broadcast time for party broadcasts.
  13. Advocate new additional transparency requirements for political parties – that they report a summary of all donations received by band – ie x donations from $0 to $100, y donations from $101 to $1,000, z donations from $1,001 to $10,000  etc. This will allow an overall picture of how a party is funded and would have exposed the false imagine NZ First portrayed as solely funded by cake stalls etc.
  14. Campaign spending limits should be based on emperical evidance of what amount of money is needed to effectively communicate with all voters. Suggest $50,000 for electorate campaigns and $5 million for party campaigns. Note this includes the broadcasting allocation so effectively moves the limit from $3.5 million to $5.0 million – which is what it would be anyway if it had been inflation and population adjusted from 1996 when last set.
  15. Spending levels should be inflation and population adjusted.
  16. Would like a fixed election date and regulated period to start 90 days before that. If not possible, then have regulated period start 90 days befroe expiry of the House or on a fixed date such as 1 September. Must not have a retrospective regulated period.
  17. Have a narrow definition of election advertisement so it does not capture personal communication of views etc.
  18. Generally exempt communications on the Internet as this is information people seek out. Exception is paid advertising on the Internet.
  19. Require advertisements to be authorised but allow names and addresses to be listed on Electoral Commission website.
  20. Have a voluntary registration regime and spending limit for third parties or parallel campaigners. Provide incentives for third parties to register – such as binding rulings on advertisements, but not make it compulsory as experience of EFA is this is hugely resented.
  21. Suggest threshold for registration (if compulsory) is $50,000
  22. Spending limit (preferably voluntary) to be 20% of a party’s limit or $1 million.
  23. Combine electoral agencies and let them take cases direct to Court without Police.
  24. Allow electoral agency to give binding rulings like the IRD
  25. Also allow agency to impose automatic fines for minor breaches such as late returns.

The Ministry of Justice will pubish a summary of submissions in the near future and in August a proposals paper. Will be very interested to see them.

Why do the left hate the private sector?

My weekly column at NBR looks at the Labour and Green opposition to state house tenants being able to buy the homes they live in, and ponders why the left seem to hate the private sector. I conclude:

If the left continue with their kneejerk hostility to the private sector, I am predicting an easy re-election for the Government. I am sure John Key is looking forward to having Phil Goff explain in a Leader’s debate why Labour are against state house tenants being able to buy their own homes.

Comments and feedback can be made at NBR.

Advice for Phil

There was an interview with Phil Goff in the Weekend Herald. First of all I can’t resist a swipe:

He’s been the leader of the Labour Party for seven months now and I wanted to know how he thought he was doing. He says the Mt Albert byelection was the first big test of his leadership. I say the handling of the Richard Worth issue was.

We got into a circular argument over why he called the Labour Party woman at the centre of the row “strikingly beautiful”. I want to know why on earth he said it; he can’t see what my problem is. He says it was absolutely relevant because “that was one of the things that made her attractive to Dr Worth”.

How could he possibly know that? Does he think only strikingly beautiful women get hit on?

Now he has to make the giant leap from robot (he teased me by asking how I voted in the byelection, so I’m teasing him back) to human being. Because, I say, staying on message is used as a criticism of his personal style.

“That’s one of the challenges of moving from being a member of caucus to leader – people want to know more about you.” He has to make himself interesting. “I have to make myself more public. People are asking of me: ‘We want to see the full human being …’ I’ve never felt I’ve had to go and sell myself as a fully rounded person that people want to know about.”

For my 2c I think this is right. Goff’s public profile is almost universally of him as an MP, and almost nothing of Phil Goff the man. What do I mean by that?

Well to take just one (superficial) example – I don’t even know the name of his wife. Now I know it isn’t meant to be about your family, but the public likes to know little thinsg such as Jim’s wife Joan had nine kids and was a devoted mum, and Jenny’s husband Burton was a basketball player and banker etc.

Now if someone who follows politics as religiously as me doesn’t even know the name of Goff’s wife, I can assure you almost no one in NZ knows her name. Now the name of Mrs Goff is a trivial issue, but it is an example of how NZ does not yet know Phil Goff except as a former (and competent) Minister.

He had the misfortune to become Labour Leader the same week John Key became Prime Minister. All the normal profiles were not done.

Goff should have an interesting story to tell. He was a Minister in both the 4th and the 5th Labour Government. Unlike Clark and Cullen though he was no rebel against Douglas – he was a loyal follower. But I don’t know what he actually believes in. At present he sounds like a clone of Helen Clark – against any private sector involvement in well almost anything. He needs to explain how a Goff-led Government would differ from a Clark-led Government. Yes I know the rank and file activists still love Helen, but she only got 33% of the vote in 2008 – Goff will not grow that unless people understand what he stands for. I would be fascinated to hear Goff on (for example) the five best things the 4th and 5th Labour Government each did.

Labour’s tactics at the moment are pretty fucked. They do not understand the difference between opposing a hugely popular new Government (and PM) and opposing a third term tired Government. The tactics National used against Labour from 2005 – 2008, are not (yet) going to work against National.

If Goff wants to become PM one day, he should do the following:

  1. Do a series of puff pieces in the women’s mags etc. Have us learn more about Phil Goff. Do some extended interviews with the weekly newspapers.
  2. Dampen down the negative tactics. The handling of the Choudary allegations was clumsy at best.  Labour is far too focused on “beltway” issues and not issues that matter to voters.
  3. Start outlining what Goff believes in, and how it differs from both Helen Clark and John Key.  This will not be without risk but is necessary.
  4. Do a reshuffle within 12 months and promote some of the Class of 2008 to more senior positions, and go into the next election with a shadow cabinet that doesn’t look like the one thrown out three years earlier.

As I said before, Goff at the moment is a enigma. And people don’t vote fr enigmas. Being a competent Foreign and Trade Minister doesn’t impress a lot of voters. They want to know more than that.

Brain drain slowed

NZPA report:

Immigration statistics show the brain drain has slowed dramatically over the past year, the Government said today.

Departures of New Zealand citizens to Australia were down 34 per cent and departures to the UK were down 26 per cent, Immigration Minister Jonathan Coleman said.

The decrease in departures has been significant. I’ve charted the monthly comparisons for the last six years.

pltdepartmay09

The May 2009 figure is lower than even May 2004.

Where in the world is Mark Sanford?

Mark Sanford is the Governor of South Caroline, and a few days he basically went walkabout without telling anyone.

The media here have been full of the story of the missing Governor. His wife said she had no diea where he was, even though it was Father’s Day. His Lieutenant Governor had no idea, and didn’t know if he was Acting Governor or not.

It has turned out Sanford decide to do a solo hike of the Appalachian Trail.If he had told people this in advance it would not have been a big issue, but no one knew – not even his security staff whom he gave the slip to.

Especially amusing is the fact that one of the days he was off hiking was National Hike Naked Day, so the TV networks have been speculating that he Governor may be nude hiking.

UPDATE: His staff lied. He was actually in Argentina where he was bonking a woamn he is having an affair with. I thought it very weird his wife did not know where he was. Sanford was seen as a potential 2012 Presidential candidate and was Chairman of the Republican Governors Association.

Home ownership for state house tenants

The Dom Post reports:

State house tenants will be able to buy their homes from September.

And all low-income first-home buyers could be in for a boost as the Government considers increasing the cap on Welcome Home mortgage guarantees by up to $70,000.

Housing Minister Phil Heatley said the state house sales scheme would be available to most tenants, with Housing New Zealand instructed to use the proceeds to build new homes where they were needed.

Allowing and encouraging state house tenants to own their homes is a great idea. From dependency to ownership.

Final Mt Albert Result

The final result is in for Mt Albert and David Shearer almost cracked 10,000. His majority of 9,718 is (off memory) the second largest for Labour in any seat.

Turnout was a very low 47.8%.

David Shearer should be declared elected on Monday 29 June, and presumably sworn in on Tuesday 30 June.

The final list of votes in order was:

  1. David Shearer, Labour 13,260
  2. Melissa Lee, National 3,542
  3. Russel Norman, Greens 2,567
  4. John Boscawen, Act 968
  5. Ben Boyce, Bill and Ben 158
  6. Dakta Green, ALCP 92
  7. Simonne Dyer, Kiwi 91
  8. Judy Turner, United Future 89
  9. Julain Pistorius, Libertarianz 39
  10. Jim Bagnell, Independent 24
  11. Ari Baker, Independent 15
  12. Anthony van den Heuvel, Human Rights 13
  13. Malcolm France, Peopel before Profit 13
  14. Jackson Wood, Independent 9
  15. Rusty Kane, People’s Choice 5