Superb Electoral Finance Reform Submission

I’ve been sent a copy of a superb 85 page submission on the Government’s Electoral Finance Reform process.

It’s been authored by four young lawyers and law students and the quality of their research and arguments is first class – they have 157 citations in the submission and make a strong argument for a lightly regulated system. I don’t agree with them, of course, on every point but I admire the scores of hours of work that must have gone in to produce such an excellent submission.

They make a strong case for anonymous political speech, citing important political works published under a pseudonym such as the famous Federalist papers published by Publius. Actual authors turned out to be 4th President James Madison, 1st Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton and 1st Chief Justice John Jay.

On spending limits, they make the point that Obama outspent McCain by $397 million but there are no indications that US citizens think this made Obama’s election unfair.

I won’t do the paper justice by trying to summarise it, but I would recommend those with an interest in this issue read it. You won’t agree with all of their positions, but I hope like me you’ll regard it as a wonderfully well researched and argued submission.

Reaction to Foreshore & Seabed Report

John Armstrong writes:

It is still early days and things could yet unravel over the detail.

But if politics is the art of the possible, then Finlayson’s and Sharples’ independent panel’s revisiting of the vexed question of ownership of the foreshore and seabed lays the foundations for achieving the seemingly impossible – an enduring cure for a longstanding political headache.

The panel’s review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act – required under National’s confidence and supply agreement with the Maori Party – has set solid benchmarks within which the two parties can negotiate the provisions of legislation to replace the law.

Good faith negotiations is preferable to unilateral retrospective legislation.

The NZ Herald editorial:

Six years does not seem a long time in the sweep of history yet it is time enough for a change in the political climate. The recommendation the Government received yesterday to repeal the Foreshore and Seabed Act seems unlikely to arouse the heat and fear that greeted the Court of Appeal’s 2003 ruling on Maori customary claims. Public opinion is probably no less committed now than it was then to the principle that public access to coastal attractions must not be compromised. But the constant assurances of claimants that access is not at risk appear to have become generally accepted.

And it is helpful the panel has stressed that at length.

Vernon Small writes in the Dom Post:

Politically, the report is a triumph for Tariana Turia and the Maori Party, and the involvement of National in any deal should help limit any Pakeha backlash.

(It is often easier for a party to make radical changes outside its traditional ideological envelope. Labour was able to go much further with privatisation and free-market reforms in the 1980s, before the public rebelled, than National ever could. National was able to get the Treaty settlement process steaming ahead under Sir Douglas Graham in a way that might have raised suspicion if Labour had been in the driving seat.)

Time – and other more pressing issues, such as the economic crisis – have helped put the debate into context.

It is just such a shame for us as a nation that a court ruling which found that, in some rare cases, iwi and hapu could have a set of residual customary rights amounting to freehold title could ever have been allowed to generate so much angst – and racial and political heat – as this one did. The two basic principles – that legal rights should not be unfairly seized and that access to the beaches and freedom of navigation would remain a general right – should have been indisputable.

Colin Espiner blogs:

I’ve just had a very quick read through the Ministerial Review of the Foreshore and Seabed Act 2004, which has been released under embargo until 3pm.

It’s three volumes long and runs to hundreds of pages, but in a nutshell what is says is this: the Foreshore and Seabed Act is discriminatory to Maori and should be repealed.

Hardly a surprise, given the panel was hand-picked to provide just such a judgment by the Maori Party – indeed, Pita Sharples threatened to sack it if it didn’t come back with such a finding.

The panel is savage about the Foreshore and Seabed Act, calling it “simply wrong in principle and approach”, discriminatory, and indeed so unfair to Maori that it considers that a Crown apology is necessary.

I have a smile on my face as I think of the look on all the Labour MPs faces as John Key gets up and apologises on behalf of the Crown to Maori – not for something done 150 years ago, but for the actions of Helen Clark’s Government earlier this decade.

The panel recommends a national settlement that gives Maori customary title to the foreshore and seabed, alongside specific usage and access rights to local iwi depending on their claim. It says some form of public right to access and navigation also needs to be written in.

It says that in the meantime, an interim act of Parliament should be passed repealing the legislation, setting up the process for the new system, recognising both Maori title and public access issues, and allowing the Crown to hold legal title until the whole thing is settled.

It’s not a bad compromise, I have to say, and I’m actually pleasantly surprised. I’ve said before that a return to court could be a nightmare for all sides, and the whole thing would drag on for years.

The Government’s response in August will be interesting. Also interesting will be Labour’s response. Phil Goff has, to his credit, been supportive. However I hear one of his senior colleagues has been around the gallery trying to whip up reaction against the report. I wonder if Goff knows of this?

A non data capped plan from Telecom

The Herald reports:

Telecom is to offer an uncapped broadband internet deal but customers will have to trade off connection speed.

From next week a new $60 a month “all you can eat” plan will be offered with the compromise that downloads may be slower at peak times. …

Brayham said during peak hours – generally 3pm to 10pm – internet traffic “shaping” would target files consuming large amounts of bandwidth, which could include some music, movie and software downloads.

I think this is a great move. NZ is the only OECD country with no non data capped plans – finally we have one.

I have no problem with data capped customers getting priority speeds during peak times. File sharers often download overnight and are generally more worried about the data cap, not the speed – so long as it is reasonable.

Of course we have to see exactly how fast things go during both off peak and peak times, but if the service holds up Telecom could do well with this offering.

Kudos to French PM

I wanted an apology from the French Rugby Union (who took part in the cover up) but never thought the Bastareaud affair would become an issue for the French Government.

So one can only praise French PM Francois Fillon for an unexpected apology. Fillon is a huge rugby fan and this may have motivated him to intervene.

I hope he tears the French Rugby Union a new orifice, and that they do not just discipline Bastareaud but all those involved in covering up the false allegation.

Review recommends repeal of Foreshore law

The foreshore and seabed review panel has reported back. The report is 163 pages.

I blogged in March that I thought the appointment of the panel would lead to a recommendation the law be toasted, and I was right.

They make the point that the Government should have appealed the case to the Privy Council – something I have always said. Clark and Wilson ruled that out and decided to legislate (after just four days!) because they didn’t like the politics of appealing to a court they had said they would abolish.

They recommend the Act be repealed, and offer four options for consideration:

  1. Do nothing further – leave the Court of Appeal decision intact and allow claims to be made to the Maori Land Court.  This option is not favoured.
  2. Have a staged settlement with negotiations between Hapu/Iwi and the Crown – basically add this to the historic grievances to be settled. They say if this happens, there needs to be provision for public input to safeguard rights of access etc.
  3. A national settlement along the lines of the fisheries and aquaculture settlements.
  4. A mixed model that combines a number of discrete components: a national settlement, allocation of rights and interests, local co-management, and an ability to gain more specific access and use rights. This is preferred.

I’ve only skimmed the report but they seem to have gone to great lengths to stress that any settlement must guarantee access for all.

There are probably some considerable fish-hooks ahead, but at first glance the panel looks to have come up with a workable way forward. Legislating to remove property rights should be a last resort, not a first resort – as it was for Labour.

I love New York

It is my first ever visit to New York, and I now fully understand the “I love New York” brand. Only here for four days, but having a great time. Have caught up with some Kiwi friends in the Big Apple, and also made some new American friends!

ny1

This is what you see if you catch a NY taxi. You see your location on a GPS map, plus get the live news. Now that is cool – especially for someone like me whose brain wants to explode if stuck in a taxi with nothing to do.

I caught the train up from DC (definitely the way to travel if under five hours), and alighted at Penn Station.

ny2

My hotel is next to Times Square. Having seen it on the TV so much, it was cool to actually be there and just taking in the huge billboards, the screens and oh yeah the hundreds of free seats on the roads. It is the most vibrant place I have been to – absolutely humming. Would love to do a New Years Eve here.

ny3

This is at the New York City Information Centre in Manhattan. They have these giant interactive table displays with a giant map of New York. You touch the screen to see various places, landmarks and facilities and click the ones you are interested in. It then produces a customised map for you showing the locations you wanted, plus gives background one each of them. You can e-mail it to you (as I did above) or have it printed out.

I absolutely recommend to anyone doing the tourist thing in NYC to go to the Visitors Centre (the one at Bloomingdales) first and ask for Louise. Without doing a sell, she tells you all the stuff that you might want to do, can advise on where to buy things, and is just a superb Ambassador for the city – even though she is Chicago born. She has been out to NZ also, and loves Kiwiland.

The other reason you should go to the Visitors Centre first is you can buy tickets for stuff like the Statue of Liberty and Empire State Building in advance. This can save hours of later queuing.

ny4

This is the lower part of the famous Central Park. very relaxing – reading a book under a tree during a spare hour.

ny5

Not much to see due to the construction but this is Ground Zero.

ny6

This is now displayed at Battery Park in the Downtown. It used to be displayed in the foyer (or nearby) of the World Trade Centre and while battered and dented, survived miraculously.

ny7

This is the view of Midtown and Downtown from the Empire State Building. And if you think that looks big, consider this is just part of Manhattan, which is only a small (but the best) part of New York City.

If you wish to go up the Empire State Building, I absolutely recommend you get a ticket in advance, rather than queue for a ticket at the building. But be warned – even without queuing for a ticket, it can take close to an hour to get to the top. You queue over half a dozen times – the security queue, the ticket check queue, the stupid queue to have a photo taken even if you don’t want one, the queue for a lift etc. But yes it is worth waiting for.

ny8

This is the view towards Uptown and the Bronx. You can just make Central Park out towards the left.

ny9

Until you look down you forget how high up you are. Those other buidings are actually pretty huge but are dwarfed by the ESB. Up until 1971 it was the tallest building in the world, until the World Trade Centre was built.

It has been visited by 110 million people.

Public Service Neutrality

Grant Robertson has blogged his concern about the Department of Labour advising staff they should not take part in a pay equity rally.

He has noted:

In recent election campaigns  I have noticed that public servants seemed to be getting inconsistent and inaccurate advice about how involved they can be in campaigns, including whether they could have hoardings on fences, deliver pamphlets or even be seen with a candidate.

I believe that the rights of public servants to participate in the political process as private citizens need to be protected, and if necessary clarified.  Of course their should be guidance as to how to ensure they can continue to serve the government of the day and avoid compromising their ability to provide quality advice and support, but the interpretation of that guidance should respect the professionalism of public servants and give them their hard won democratic rights.

So presumably he deplores as abhorent the sacking of Madeline Setchell from the Ministry for the Environment, because of her boyfriend’s job?

I mean Grant blogs about how he was able to work for MFAT and be a Labour Party campaign manager. Yet Madeline, who has never been politically active herself, got her career destroyed by Labour because of her boyfriend swapping jobs from journalist to working for John Key.

Hopefully Grant was also appalled by Erin Leigh’s treatment by Labour. Another public servant crucified.

And also I hope Grant was appalled that Setchell was also blacklisted from MAF, after they chekecd with Jim Anderton.

Really having Labour go on about public sector neutrality is like Charlie Sheen go on about monogamy.

DC Wrapup

I’ve now left DC and am in New York. I will be back in DC for their Independence Day party on the 4th of July. Before I move onto NYC stuff, a wrap-up of the political stuff in DC.

dc9

The US Capitol. Unlike NZ, the actual representatives have their offices elsewhere. I was surprised how easy it is to get into the Congressional offices. There is a security scan, but once you are past that you can just walk whereeveryou want, and pop into any office. Quite different to NZ where you need to be approved by an office to be allowed in the building.

Anyway first some general political chatter I picked up:

  • Even if there is a swing to the Republicans in 2010, no way they can win the House or the Senate back. Most of the Senate seats coming up in 2010 are held by Republicans and they have five incumbents retiring and only one Democrat retiring. Incidentially 23 of the 100 Senators are in their 70s, 80s or 90s – incumbency is useful.
  • Obama’s ratings remain high, but increasingly polarised.
  • The big and maybe only issue in 2010 will be the economy. Obama promoted the stimulus package on the basis it would stop unemployment reaching certain levels that have now been exceeded. The bailout of the banks is very unpopular also.
  • The Republican frontrunner for 2012 is Mitt Romney. Minnesota Governor Tim Pawlenty also a strong contender.
  • Sarah Palin is definitely going to try for the 2012 nomination. She won’t get it but may do well enough. A lot may depend on if Huckabee stands as they compete for support bases.
  • Near universal consensus that the US will be unable to ever have the Government get back into surplus and at some stage they will start printing money which will fuel inflation and devalue the dollar.

Back to the rest of the Freedom Forum. A number of excellent speakers.

30 years House veteran Jim Sensenbrenner gave us a US political update. Sensenbrenner is one of eight Congressman from Wisconsin and won in 2008 with 80% of the vote.

We also had a UK politics update from British MP Philip Dunne.  While the Conservatives are well ahead in the polls, it is quite possible there will be a hung Parliament as Labour has an effective gerrymander with seat sizes. The Conservatives need to beat Labour by 5% to get more seats and by 9% to get an absolute  majority.

We has two expert speakers on the US healthcare reforms. There is considerable opposition to Obama’s proposals, but even less satisfaction with the status quo. One of the speakers was Robert Moffit who has been asked by two dozen states to help them with their healthcare systems.

On the economic side we were equally well served with an address by Stephen Moore, who founded the Club for Growth and is a member of the Wall Street Journal Editorial Board. Also heard from the former Secretary of Commerce.

The two highlights for me were Jonah Goldberg and Grover Norquist.

Jonah Goldberg is the editor-at-large of National Review Online and blogs many times a day at The Corner. He is a hugely entertaining and provocative speaker. He told us about how he got sick of being called a fascist and Nazi by left wingers for years on end, so it motivated him to write his book – Liberal Fascism. The book made No 1 on the NY Times best seller list.

Despite the irreverence of Goldberg, he also backs his thesis up with a mass of research about prominent hard left supporters of Italian fascism and German National Socialism before WWII. I’m not going to cover all the arguments here but am going to order a copy from Amazon as Jonah’s speech intrigued me enough to want to read his research for myself.

There is a wider issue Goldberg touches on – that is the tendency of the media and left to label anyone bad as “right wing”, such as Putin.

Grover Norquist (whom I’m met a couple of times previously) was the most relevant for me. Grover is arguably the most influential lobbyist on the right in the USA. Grover expanded on the main political battle is between coalitions. He aptly names them the “Leave Us Alone” Coalition and the “Takings” Coalition.

In the US, these get represented by the two major parties. Grover points out that the main parties have become these broad coalitions because of the US political system, quipping that in most European countries a party that polls 2% may get to pick the Prime Minister, while in the US a party that polls 2% is officially nuts 🙂

Grover says the prime motivation of members of the Leave Us Alone Coalition is they want the Government to leave them alone. Members tend to be taxpayers, business owners, gun owners, home schoolers, stock owners, Police and military, and communities of faith.

The Taking Coalition is (this is the US) trial lawyers, union leaders, government grant recipients, welfare beneficiaries and those who administer the “social welfare industrial complex”, government employees, Govt funded NGOs and businesses seeking favours for their business.

There is a strong parallel back to NZ, with this analysis. Those of us on the right have been well aware that the more people who become dependent on the Government, the more likely it is they will vote for a party that promises to tax other people more, to spend on the takers. The goal is a permanent majority of 60% dependent on the other 40%.

This is why Labour opposes the private sector at every opportunity. This is why families who earn over $100,000 now receive social welfare payments. This is why the state sector has grown so fast and so big. This is why Labour always go for inefficient universal benefits rather than targeted benefits. This is why they want to crowd out the private sector in education and health, why Cullen nationalised assets etc.

Whether or not you agree with Grover;s exact descriptions his thesis is correct. And long-term sucess for the centre-right in NZ will be determined by ensuring that there are more people in the “Leave Us Alone” coalition than in the “Taking” coalition.

Now this can be challenging. The “Taking” coalition has hundreds if not thousands of lobby groups and NGOs all demanding more money from taxpayers. There are very very few groups that speak up on behalf of the “Leave Us Alone” coalition. That is because most members of it – well they just want to be left alone – they only engage in politics when the Government annoys them enough (anti-smacking law).

No Right Turn on Labour’s OIA changes

Idiot/Savant blogs on the bill promoted by Labour to supress school assessment information:

There are a number of problems with this. In addition to being “class-based” (that is, targeting information based on its content or type rather than the interests its release might prejudice), it also categorically forbids release. And that has never been part of our OIA regime. While the OIA allows information to be withheld if there are good reasons for doing so, it doesn’t make it mandatory, and an organisation can always just release information if they feel like it. This amendment would forbid them from doing that. It effectively recreates the Official Secrets Act specifically for schools. The “justification” for this – that the public might “misunderstand” or “misuse” the information – is decidedly authoritarian.

This is a nasty regression from Labour, and one which undermines a fundamental part of our freedom of information regime.

I made a similiar point yesterday – this proposed law would make school assessment data more secret than security and intelligence data. The Government has the discretion to release security and intelligence data, but Labour want school assessment data to be prohibited from ever being released.

Such a wonderful commitment to open government and accountabilty for the $6 billion we spends on schools.

More Ministerial savings

The final rail loss

NZPA reports:

The final valuation of KiwiRail was $369 million – more than half the price the Government paid for it.

The Labour government bought TranzRail from Toll on July 1 last year for $690m. A provisional valuation in the government financial statements in September 2008 put the value at $442m.

Today Transport Minister Steven Joyce said the final valuation by PriceWaterhouseCoopers was $388.29m.

A Treasury report said a fair value for KiwiRail at the purchase date would have been $369.54m.

“This results in a final financial loss on acquisition of Toll NZ Ltd of $320m,” the report said.

It was the deal of the century – for Toll. This is the problem with politicians using our money to buy toys/assets. Cullen was desperate to buy – for political reasons, and Toll knew it. They outsmarted, outwitted and outlasted the Government in the negotiations and we paid for it.

Bellamys and Valentines

The Dom Post reports:

A meal at Bellamys – Parliament’s exclusive MPs dining room – costs about as much as a meal at a popular budget restaurant chain.

The recession has sparked fresh debate about Parliament’s in-house catering service being subsidised by taxpayers; it gets a $300,000 subsidy, though the full extent of the subsidy is worth about $600,000, according to Treasury papers.

That is once buildings, facilities, systems and management fees are taken into account.

Parliamentary Service argues that removing the subsidy would raise prices and lower demand.

Its menu shows that prices are on a par with popular family restaurant chain Valentines, at between $23 and $29 for a main, though side dishes are extra.

The price is not the only common factor between Bellamys and Valentines – the quality of the food is similiar also.

My long standing preference is to replace Bellamys with a food court. You could have a sushi bar, a sandwich outlet, a McDonalds, a Chinese outlet and MPs and staff would patronise the ones that provide decent food for them. Competition is what is needed.

General Debate 1 July 2009

Heather Roy on VSM

Heather Roy notes the latest ($175,000 stolen from CPSA) in a long line of thefts of student money and summarises recent cases:

December 1999 – Brendan McQuillan, president of Nelson Polytechnic Student Association, admitted stealing $8,004. November 2003 – Florence bailey, office manager of Massey Students Association, jailed for two years and three months after stealing $203,000. November 2005 – Victoria University Maori Student Association treasurer Wi Nepia jailed for stealing $161,000. 2005 – Otago University’s Te Roopu Maori, the Maori students’ association collapsed amid allegations of financial impropriety. Estimated fraud $21,000. April 2007 – Clelia Opie, officer of Victoria University Students’ Association, spends $6,000 on phone calls.’

Now there are not that many student associations in NZ. The fraud rate for them is hence staggeringly high. Heather notes:

The fact is that compulsory student association membership creates a pool of money and a lack of accountability on how that money is managed. Misuse of funds in a voluntary organisation would result in a loss of confidence by members in the executive. But in student organisations, despite frequent fraud and theft, students are still forced to pay union fees whether they want to or not. Student associations are also often plagued by accusations of advocating only the views of their executives rather than those of their wider memberships.

It’s a disgrace that National continues to force most students to belong to a students’ association.

More on Education and OIA

NZPA reports:

Mr Mallard today suggested a change could be made to the Education Amendment Bill currently before a select committee , or a separate bill could be drafted.

“I see it as a really good way of unblocking a problem that we’ve got,” Mr Mallard said this morning.

Quality information was important, he said, but it did not all need to be made public.

He did not think individual school information needed to be published.

“At the moment privacy reasons means that individual children or individual teachers information can’t be made public but school information could be.

“I think if we restricted that that would mean only national information was published so that we could test the system.”

The school information would be available for the Education Ministry and Education Review Office.

“So if there were major anomalies of schools going off the rails educationally that information would be easily available.”

This is such a wonderful idea by Trevor, I think we should take it further. We spend $6 billion in schools yet the rationale is that only the Education Ministry and ERA need to be able to access information on individual schools.

So lets extend this to the entire Government. It is unfair that the media sometimes publish unhelpful stories about a Government agency based on information released under the OIA. This can lead to undermining confidence in that agency.

So using Labour’s logic, I propose that only national information for the entire Government be published in future. Only Treasury and Ministers need to know individual agencies information.

So if you ask under the OIA how many staff at your agency earn over $100,000 – then the only response will be “The Government in total employs 7,201 staff who earn over $100,000” rather than listing it for each agency.

There is no need for us, according to Labour’s logic, to know the details of each agency. We can trust Treasury and the Government to take action if there is a problem.

There are other ways Labour’s new principle can be implemented. It is unfair that death rates in hospitals can be compared. This is unfair to larger hospitals that take on the more critical cases. So in future it will be illegal to publish information about deaths in individual hospitals. The Ministry of Health will collect this data and they will act on it if any hospital goes off the rails.

It also seems to me it is unfair that people can compare the levels of rates between different local authorities. A simplistic comparison is bad as different Councils provide different facilities. So again taking Labour’s principle forward, Councils will no longer reveal what their level of rates are. The Department of Internal Affairs will monitor Councils and let us know fi any go off the rails.

There are so many examples. It is also unfair to prison guards at a particular prison that their escape rate can be compared to other prisons. After all it does not take into account different security classifications.  To prevent the public from making an ill informed comparison on a league table, we will not publish individual prison escape levels.

Readers might like to post in the comments more examples of what should be removed from the OIA under Labour’s new principle that the publci are too stupid to know and compare, and that the important thing is the Government Departments have the information for their use.

UPDATE: Someone has emailed me a copy of Labour’s OIA Bill. It only allows schools to share information with the Ministry of Education and the ERO. This means that schools would not be able to give NCEA information to the NZQA!

Also Labour’s bill bans schools from voluntarily releasing their overall achievement data. It is a giant Orwellian step backwards and reminds us all that Labour is concerned about the teachers unions, and not parents or students. The bill says:

Despite any other provision of this Act, organisations including, but not limited to schools, the Ministry of Education and the Education Review Office, must not publicly release school level assessment information.

This makes school level assessment information more secretive than security information held by the SIS. You see the SIS are allowed to decide what information they release. Labour’s bill would see the Government and schools lose any discretion over publishing assessment information.

National should run full page advertisements in every newspaper with copies of Labour’s bill, explaining how Labour wants to ban the publishing of school assessment information. I’m seriously – they should hit some donors up for $100K and it will knock Labour down a good 5% or so. I suppose there is no need when they are 20% ahead, but this is a huge blunder by Labour.

A justified coup?

I’m not sure any coup is ever justified (Fiji is an example of the problems you get when you set a precedent) but the situation in Honduras is fascinating.

The (former) President of Honduras, Manuel Zelaya, was deposed from office yesterday when the Armed Forces seized him and threw him on a flight to Costa Rica.

Now normally one would condemn this absolutely. And indeed the UN, US, EU and other countries have all condemned it.

But maybe in this case the Armed Forces were not totally wrong. You see Zelaya has been acting unconstitutionally and it seems there was nolegal way to impeach him.

Zelaya has been elected to a four year term that ended at the end of 2009. The Constitution of Honduras makes it very clear you can not stand for a second term – ever. Article 239 says once you have been President you can never be President (or VP) again.

The constitution is so adamant about the one term limit, it says that if you promote a change to that clause, you lose your public office immediately and can not hold office again for ten years.

And Article 42 goes further and says anyone promoting the President staying in office beyond on term loses their Honduras citizenship. So I think we can conclude they don’t want their politicians to do what Chavez did in Venezuela and use his thugs to initimidate the population into changing the law to allow him to become President forever.

Now Zelaya was organising a non-binding referndum to start on the day he was deposed. The referendum was to on whether to call a National Assembly to rewrite the constitution.

Now the referendum has been ruled illegal by the Supreme Court and oppossed by Congress, the attorney general, and the top electoral body. Despite this President Zelaya asked the military to conduct the referendum. The General in charge refused as the referendum had been declared illegal and unconstitutional. The President then sacked the General. The Supreme Court reinstated him.

Zelaya then led a citizen march to take possession of the referendum materials. Some stage after that the military deposed him from office. The Supreme Court has come out and said they ordered the army to do so, and the Congress (which is controlled) by Zelaya’s own party unamiously voted to remove him from office (even though they do not have this power).

Now it is possible the Army’s action will prove detrimental in the long term. Already they have imposed censorship, and mishandled some diplomats. But from all accounts Zelaya all but forced them to act – and they may have stopped him from doing a Chavez.

The lession for nation states might be to always have clear impeachment procedures in your constitution.

Arrogant French

The Dom Post reports:

The French embassy refuses to apologise for damage to Wellington’s reputation from Mathieu Bastareaud’s false assault allegations, despite a scathing article penned by its ambassador.

You can read the Ambassadors’ article for yourself here. He said:

More serious is the assault against a French rugby player in the street, on the grounds that he is French and identified as one of the best French player. At least, this is how the local press reports the event. We thought rugby was safe from such behaviour which, alas, plagues other sports. Supporters’ passion cannot fully explain this incident. Maybe the assailants took literally an article entitled “Ten reasons to hate the French”.

Is one of those reasons their arrogance and inability to say sorry?

The Dom Post editorial also makes some good points about the cover-up:

The players who entered the hotel with him and the team doctor who stitched him up almost certainly know the real cause of his injury, and so probably do coach Marc Lievremont and manager Jo Maso. Why else delay for 48 hours before telling the world?

New Zealand and France have a long and rich history on and off the rugby field. On the field it is a relationship marked by equal parts brilliance and skulduggery – both admired qualities in rugby circles. But, off the field, the skulduggery should stop.

Bastareaud has apologised to the New Zealand Rugby Union and Wellington for his lies. The French rugby union and team management should do the same to try to repair the damage done to Wellington’s name by their complicity in the Bastareaud Affair.

The lies told were not that of a sole player. Management approved the lie and attempted cover up and the French Rugby Union should discipline those responsible and apologise. If a NZ team did what the French did, the senior management would be sacked.

Sky online

The Herald reports:

Pay television giant Sky is planning to hit the pause button on its Sky Online site, saying the service does not make sense in the current New Zealand broadband market.

Fellet said: “We did this to make subscribers feel better about our service but it has not been a great viewer experience.”

Viewers were using up their broadband capacity and then becoming unhappy with Sky when they passed data limits and their internet service provider (ISP) dropped them back to dial-up speeds.

I agree such a service will be greatly limited by data caps. But assuming Sky hosts its content locally, and hosts it in a site that peers with the major ISPs, I would have hoped that such local traffic could be excluded from data caps. It is the international bandwidth that is the big problem.

TVNZ was the first broadcaster in Australasia to launch a full online catch-up service and nearly all of of its prime-time shows are available through this service. Each week nearly 250,000 New Zealanders stream 1.5 million shows to their homes, Paris says.

Some TVNZ traffic has been through a relationship with the state-owned ISP Orcon, which has allowed its subscribers to access the TVNZ ondemand website without affecting data caps.

Orcon executive Scott Bartlett said data caps remained an impediment partly because there was only one “pipeline” from New Zealand allowing internet traffic from the United States – the source of a lot of internet traffic.

He said there were also issues over Telecom charges for data transfers.

This is why peering locally is so important. People should be able to download locally without it affecting their data cap.

Iran to probe Neda’s death

Reuters report:

President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad has called for a judicial probe into the “suspicious” death of a young Iranian woman who has become an icon of opposition protests against a disputed election which he officially won.

Ahmadinejad sent a letter to judiciary chief Ayatollah Mahmoud Hashemi-Shahroudi requesting a serious investigation to help identify “the elements” behind this month’s killing of Neda Agha-Soltan, the official IRNA news agency said.

Oh God – this will be hilarious. Will they blame it on Mossad or the CIA? Maybe MI5 as the Brits are the current targets. We’d better be careful – you can’t rule out they will conclude the NZ SAS was disguised in the crord and killed her.

The one thing I think we can rule out is that the investigation will conclude she was shot by Iranian state security forces.

Maybe they’ll blame it on a meteor fragment?

For those who have not seen the video, here’s a You Tube of it. It is only because so many people saw it through You Tube etc that the Iranian Government hasn’t been able to deny it happened.

The public can’t be trusted syndrome

I’m appalled at the attitude from the principals’ union that they may not report results from national standard tests, because shock horror they might be made public.

Even worse Labour is advocating a law change, so that the public can be blocked from being able to obtain this information under the Oficial Information Act.

We (the taxpaying public) spend almost $6 billion a year on the school system. They are meant to be accountable to parents and the community/public. And instead they are demanding a law change to hide what their performance might be, backed by Labour.

I don’t care much one way or another about league tables.  Certainly the Government has better things to do than publish such things.

But there is a massive difference between whether or not the Government should publish something, and whether or not it should prevent members of the public from obtaining information on a school and publishing it in any form they like.

It is appalling arrogance to demand that such information be suppressed because you can’t trust the public to interpret it properly. That is the start of the slippery slope to an Orwellian country.

If someone wants to go to the trouble, they should be able to publish “league tables” on schools on as many criteria as they want.

One organisation could do a league table based on drug offences at school. Another could do a league table based on the level of “voluntary” fees. Another could do a league table based on suspensions for misconduct. And another could do a league table based on the average number of years experience of teachers. And shock horror someone might do a league table based on exam results. And hey someone else might do one based on exam results, but adjusted to take into account socio-economic factors in their home zone. And yet someone else might do a league table based on sporting success.

The answer is not less information, but more. If you don’t like a league table compiled by an organisation, then criticise it, or do your own one. If you think the media’s reporting of local results is sub-standard then blog about it.

But whatever you do, don’t support Labour’s plan to exempt schools from the Official Information Act to keep the teacher unions happy.

UPDATE: No Right Turn has already blogged on this also, and pleased to say he agrees that what Labour is proposing is wrong.

An even better option

The NZ Herald says:

Thus there may be a case for compensating a household when one of the earners becomes unemployed in the current recession. Two Auckland economists have called for a relaxation of the rule that refuses the dole to a person whose partner is earning even a modest income. They point out that this is inconsistent with the taxation system which treats couples as separate income earners.

They have not drawn the obvious conclusion, though, that a better solution might lie in changing the tax system. If couples could combine their incomes for a tax assessment, and each be taxed for half of it, the loss of one income would reduce the tax on the other, delivering an appreciable benefit to the household. …

This proposal, known as “income splitting”, deserves consideration for reasons wider than unemployment. If it was adopted as a permanent feature of income tax it would be fairer than the present system for couples in which one partner chose not to be in paid employment.

So the Herald says a better option that allowing people to go on the dole if their partners are working, is income splitting.

I’m not a big fan of income splitting as it will lead to all sorts of “false couples” in order to income split, but I have an even better option that achieves the same end without the perverse incentives.

A flat tax rate. Then there is no need to income split. And you just have a guaranteed minimum family income for low income earners.

Ministerial spouses paying their own way

The Herald reports:

Labour ministers had often travelled with their spouse – allowed if the Cabinet approves of the travel.

However, Mr Key has told his colleagues that things are different because of the tough economic times. …

“I made it clear to my ministers I didn’t expect them to take their spouse and, to the best of my knowledge, they haven’t. If they have, they’ve paid for it.”

He said there were possibly some exceptions on trips to Australia.

“In every other instance, I’ve told them if they want to take their partner, they can do it, but they pay for it. When I went to China, it’s well documented I took Bronagh and I paid for her.”

That’s definitely a change of policy.

While one can only applaud restraint in a recession, I would caution against a blanket ban on spouses travelling with Ministers (unless they pay their own way). It can be difficult enough keeping a marriage together when you don’t spend the week together – and certain Ministers such as Foreign and Trade travel so much, they would never see their spouse if they din’t sometimes accompany them.

Now as it happens in the Key Minstry both those Ministers are not currently married, so not so much of an issue. But as I said a blanket ban on spousal travel could be unfair.

From what I read though, it is not quite a blanket ban – more a expectation with permission needed for exceptions.

Madoff gets 150 years

The defence wanted 12 years, the federal probation services suggested 50 years, but Bernie Madoff got the maximum 150 years. He’ll be 221 when he’s released!

His fraud included fabricated gains of US$65 billion (close to the NZ GDP) and he literally destroyed thousands of lives.

Up until 1991 he operated legitimately, but from then on he never made any legitimate investments – he just ran all money through his business bank account and used new investors to pay out on existing ones. How he survived 17 years of audits I don’t know. Even some basis confirmation with claimed investments would have picked this up.

Madoff has refused to co-operate with authorities, and it may never be known how much, if anything, the rest of his family knew.