The Blue Baron and Snoopy

dpf-007

There was a good crowd at the Backbencher last night for the unveilign of the new puppets. John and Bill were cast as the Blue Baron and Snoopy. Was very disturbing as John kept ticking Bill’s stomach (the puppet that is).

Also had Pita Sharples in a waka, and Roger Douglas as Rodney Hide’s puppet master.

John Key joked that he could have done with the machine gun in the plane at around 8 am yesterday. Bill joked about wanting to know about which National MPs had been seen in the Backbencher after Boycie revealed this is where Clark, Wilson and co plotted against Mike Moore.

And as the Dom Post reports, Rodney said:

“The great thing about having Roger Douglas in our caucus is that you get plenty of advice,” Mr Hide said last night.

“The advice is never contradictory because it hasn’t changed in 20 years.”

Afterwards around 60 of us went upstairs to hear about Obama’s first 100 days from a visiting US expert. Thanks to the US Embassy and State Department for helping make it happen. People seemed to enjoy it, and we had a good turnout of MPs.

After that we had Backbenches which was fun also. A good Wednesday night.

Growing concern with Obama’s deficits

AP report:

Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke urged Congress and the administration to cut record-high budget deficits, warning that they could erode investor confidence and endanger the economy’s long-term health.

Bernanke’s comments came as concerns grow at home and overseas about the United States’ mounting red ink.

Surprised it has taken this long.

The White House estimates that the government will rack up an unprecedented US$1.8 trillion (NZ$2.78 trillion) budget deficit this year. That would be more than four times last year’s all-time high.

Obama have pushed the deficit is so high now, I don’t think it can ever be tamed by his sucessors. Overall federal revenue is US$2.5 trillion so the deficit is around 66% of the revenue. So even if revenue grew at 5% a year, and expenditure never grew, it would take a decade to get rid of it – and no way expenditure won’t grow.

Treasury talks capital gains tax

Brian Fallow writes:

The Treasury has renewed its call for reform of the tax system, including the issue of capital gains from property investment.

It wants the system to have a broader base and lower rates, Treasury Secretary John Whitehead told an Institute of Directors function yesterday. “And at the risk of being chased down by an angry crowd with pitchforks and flaming torches, yes this should include consideration of moving the boundaries to tax more capital gains – for example on investment property – and shifting more of the tax base towards consumption,” he said.

Without changes to the tax system, there was a real risk that the Government’s revenue base would be unsustainable in the medium term, given growing international competition for capital and skilled labour, and an ageing population.

“A key priority has to be reducing effective marginal tax rates and increasing the rewards for effort. There is a growing view that the high mobility of our skills base means high personal income taxes are especially harmful for New Zealand’s growth and productivity,” he said.

I used to be fervently against a capital gains tax on investment property. Since the credit crisis, partly caused by rampant borrowing for property, I have started to change my mind.

So long as other taxes were cut, so overall tax revenue does not increase, I think the time is right to now take a serious look at capital gains tax. And I say this as someone looking to buy an investment property.

“I know there is a lot of passionate debate on this matter, but capital gains or property taxes would be beneficial for encouraging investment in productive activity.

“A more complete capital income tax base reduces the impact of tax distortions on investment decisions, thereby improving the allocation of capital in the economy.” And greater reliance on GST – aligned with reduced income and corporate tax rates – should help strengthen incentives for savings, he said.

I don’t expect the Government to say they are in favour of a capital gains tax. But I do hope they will allow Treasury to work on proposals for how one could work, so it can be debated in the fullness of time.

Whale and Goff

Whale Oil on Close Up last night talking about the Richard Worth scandal.

Whale reports that Phil Goff not only refused to go on with Whale – he also insisted that Whale be filmed earlier so they don’t share the Green Room, and then finally said he would not appear at all, if Whale was on the same show.

I find that quite ironic as on Check Point last night, Phil actually quoted “right wing bloggers” in our criticism of the initial press statement.

R v Worth

The Herald reveals some more details of the criminal complaint:

The person who complained to the police about former Government minister Richard Worth is an Auckland businesswoman, and her allegation is of a sexual nature.

Her identity is now fairly well known. She is a lawyer, which suggests a complaint alleging criminal offending would not be made lightly.

The alleged offending is, as I understand it, at the more serious end of the scale. But I do not have first hand knowledge of this.

The Herald has learned the woman approached a National MP’s office “to update the PM” after going to the police two weeks ago.

A friend of the woman said last night that she was distressed but pleased police were investigating.

“She has faith in the police process and trust in the Prime Minister that nobody is above the law,” the friend said.

The Herald has agreed not to reveal the identity of the woman, the friend, or her associates.

The friend said the Korean woman told him “she had reported to the police alleging inappropriate behaviour by a minister towards her”.

I hope the Police investigate quickly, but thoroughly.

Mr Key said his office was contacted by a third party on Tuesday last week, two days before the Budget.

A member of his staff had investigated, and Tuesday night this week was the first time he [the PM] had spoken to Dr Worth about it.

“I think I acted as fast as I could,” he said. “People are entitled to a degree of natural justice … It took some time to get all the information that was required.”

Considering the long weekend, I am not surprised it took a few days to gather the facts.

Mr Key said Dr Worth should use the two weeks of leave he started yesterday to consult family and friends on his future as a member of Parliament.

Dr Worth is a list MP who lives in Epsom. If he resigned from Parliament, he would be replaced by the next person on the National Party list, Devonport dentist Cam Calder.

If I was Cam Calder I would not be planning any overseas trips in the near future.

John Armstrong writes:

Messy, messy. Seeing Richard Worth being dumped from his ministerial role yesterday was like watching a slow strangulation as the nature of the allegation made against him became more and more apparent during the day.

Worth’s alleged sins are not going to damage the Government in any serious fashion. John Key has made sure of that.

By questioning whether the National MP can remain in Parliament even as an irrelevant backbencher, the Prime Minister has effectively quarantined his now-former Internal Affairs Minister from the rest of the National Party.

I agree. Also Key’s body language and tone makes it very clear that he is offended, even disgusted, by what is alleged.

What went awry for Key yesterday was his seemingly futile attempt to avoid disclosing the reasons for Worth’s “resignation”.

Which I was critical of also.

Key is proving to be an even tougher disciplinarian than his predecessor, Helen Clark. She fired plenty of ministers, but in most cases indicated there was a road back into the inner sanctum after a suitable period of penance.

Worth received no such reassurance yesterday morning. He has yet to be charged with any crime. But he was not given the option of a stand-down from his portfolios while the matter was investigated.

Quite the opposite. Key was blunt. If Worth had not resigned, he would have sacked him for failing to meet the high standards set by the Prime Minister for his ministerial colleagues.

Rough justice perhaps. But politics dictate that Key deal with the matter promptly and decisively. With some reservations, he has.

Yep. No stand down. No path back. In fact a strong suggestion that he should leave Parliament.

Colin Espiner covers a different allegation against Richard Worth that Phil Goff raised with John Key around a month ago:

Prime Minister John Key investigated claims that Internal Affairs Minister Richard Worth offered a woman a job for romantic favours a month before police began investigating other serious allegations against him. …

Key confirmed he had received earlier allegations that involved Worth making a nuisance of himself with women.

Labour leader Phil Goff said he had privately raised concerns with Key last month about allegations regarding Worth’s “inappropriate political … and sexual behaviour” towards a woman. It was a separate matter to the one currently before police.

“The allegations were essentially that Dr Worth had offered a number of different positions that were within his gift as minister to this woman, with the overtones that this was in pursuit of romantic ambitions,” Goff said.

“One was as an adviser and one was as a board member within the responsibilities of Dr Worth but the overtones were that he wanted to develop a relationship with her,” Mr Goff said on Radio New Zealand.

Goff had told Key there was evidence to suggest “inappropriate” suggestions were made in a series of emails and phone calls.

“Why I went to the prime minister is that I’d received a complaint from a woman that I knew, who is a member of the Labour party so I’ll put that right out front, but I didn’t believe her allegations were politically motivated,” Goff told Breakfast.

Goff did the right thing in raising the matter privately.He was also probably counting on John Key behaving better than Helen Clark did when she had an Opposition Party Leader raise an issue privately about a Minister (Prebble re Samuels) – Clark attacked the party leader for raising the allegation with her.

Key said he had investigated the complaints but decided there was no need to pursue the matters.

“I have had someone bring an allegation to me of that nature … and all I can say is I treated that allegation seriously. I investigated it and I was satisfied with the answers I received,” he said.

As I understand it, the later alleged offending is far far more serious than the earlier matter.  Goff says that the “overtone” of Worth’s conversations with the Labour Party member was wanting a relationship in exchange. This suggests it was not explicit and couldn’t be proven.

Who will replace Worth

iPredict has stock available. Current prices:

  • Nathan Guy 35%
  • Craig Foss 30%
  • Other 11%
  • Jo Goodhew 9%
  • Chester Borrow 6%
  • No replacement 6%
  • Tau Henare 5%
  • Worth reinstated 0%

I think Key will make an announcement sooner rather than later.

Backbenches tonight

Tonight at the Back Bencher from 9 pm. The panel is:

  1. ACT MP Roger Douglas
  2. Green co-leader Metiria Turei
  3. Labour Deputy Leader Annette King
  4. National Junior Government Whip Chris Tremain

Topics are:

  1. MP expenses
  2. The Budget
  3. Cell Phone Ban in Cars

Sooden whines

Do you remember Harmeet Sooden? The guy who went to Iraq to protest against the US, got kidnapped by terrorists, and then after his release blamed everything on the West and nothing on the terrorists. Well he is at it again according to the ODT:

The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade has decided not to act on a complaint by activist Harmeet Sooden about his alleged mistreatment in Israel last year.

He was detained for four days in June and then deported after being accused of being a threat to the country’s security.

Very sensible.

Mr Sooden holds both New Zealand and Canadian passports, but was travelling on his Canadian passport at the time.

In a recent letter, MFAT told Mr Sooden that it would not have expected to be notified of his detention as he did not enter Israel on a New Zealand passport.

Mr Sooden said the response raised “serious questions” for New Zealanders with dual citizenship who travelled on a passport of their other nationality. “I am a New Zealand citizen, and I would expect the New Zealand Government to act to protect its citizens overseas.”

What an idiot. If he is travelling on a Canadian passport, they won’t know he is a NZ citizen.

Mr Sooden said he was assaulted and injured, threatened, held in solitary confinement, and denied the right to legal counsel and consular representation before being deported on June 18 last year.

I hope the Canadian Government files a note of protest.

In November 2005, Mr Sooden, Briton Norman Kember, Canadian James Loney and American Tom Fox, who were all working with Christian Peacemaker Teams in Iraq, were kidnapped by a group calling itself the Swords of Righteousness Brigade.

Mr Sooden, Mr Kember and Mr Loney were released after 118 days, but Mr Fox was shot dead while in captivity.

Yet Mr Sooden has no problem with so called resistance fighters shooting his colleagues dead – it is not their fault – the West forced them to do it. But if Israel detains and deports him it is the end of the world.

May 2009 Public Polls

Thanks Michael

Maharey lives on

The Victorian State Parliament has, for some reason, a copy of the NZ Hansard Word Style Book on its website. This is for use by Hansard staff in conjunction with the 10th Concise Oxford Dictionary.

And look at what one of their entries is:

Maharey
a “Maharey”
“Mahareyism”
“Maharey principle” (to say one thing in Opposition,
then another thing in Government)
“Maharey principle 2” (to say one thing when in
Government, then another thing when in
Government)
“Maharey spin”

The Maharey Principle is immortalised!

As far as I can tell no other MP has an entry like this.

Latvian Fiscal Stimulus Package

MMP Quiz

Worth resigns

Just announced:

STATEMENT FROM DR RICHARD WORTH

“It is with deep regret that I have resigned my role as a Minister.

“I am resigning from the role for personal reasons.

“I tendered my resignation to the Prime Minister last night and he accepted.

“It has been a privilege to have been a Minister in this Government.

“I will not be making any further comment to the media.

“I have been granted two weeks’ leave of absence from the House.”

I will blog more details as they are known.

John Key says:

Prime Minister John Key says he has accepted the resignation of Dr Richard Worth as a Minister in the National-led Government.

“Dr Worth tendered his resignation to me last night, and I have accepted it.

“He advised me of some private matters in respect of which he felt it appropriate that he should resign as a Minister. I accepted his resignation and have advised the Governor-General accordingly.

“I will not be making further comment on the matters he has advised me about.

“Dr Worth’s ministerial responsibilities will be temporarily transferred to Maurice Williamson. I will be making an announcement about permanent appointments to the portfolios in the near future.”

Now this is just ridicolous. You can’t have a secret resignation – or a resignation for undisclosed reasons. The Government is bonkers if they think the reasons won’t come out, let alone that they do not have a duty to disclose them. And refusing to state the reasons will keep it as a story for days and weeks, instead of a three day wonder.

If you resign as a Minister, you need to say why you are resigning. Not the full details, but at least some reason.

Worth was Minister of Internal Affairs, Land Information, Archives, National Library and Associate Justice. It will be interesting if his portfolios get dished out to other Ministers, or will there be an early promotion for a backbencher?

UPDATE2: The more I think about this, the more stupid it is not to state why he has resigned. As in majorly stupid. The public will wonder what the Government is hiding, the Opposition will assume the worst, the media will dig up dirt until they find the reason, and the Governments looks shifty. Before it is too late, the Government should arrange for either Key or Worth to explain why Worth resigned – the public have a right to know. Or they should at least leak the reson damn quick, so the story doesn’t go on for weeks and weeks.

UPDATE3: I am hearing that there will be a new Minister appointed and it is between Chief Whip Nathan Guy and Finance & Expenditure Select Committee Chair Craig Foss.

UPDATE4: Worth is the subject of a criminal investigation. This would explain why there are no details, but would have been easier if they had said this was the case from the beginning. NZPA reports:

Wellington police said today an allegation had been made against “a sitting member of Parliament”.

Police were conducting a preliminary investigation.

Prime Minister John Key accepted Dr Worth’s resignation last night.

Mr Key told reporters he would have sacked Dr Worth, had he not resigned. He confirmed it was criminal investigation.

It is the right thing that Worth has gone as a Minister of he is facing a criminal investigation.

Mr Key was alerted to the matter last week, before the MP told him about it.

Ouch. That would not be a good look.

Now no doubt in time the details of the investigation and any charges against Worth will be made public. He is of course innocent until found guilty, but I think it is fair to conclude his parliamentary career is all but over.

It is premature to speculate, but Cam Calder may end up an MP yet.

UPDATE5: Key has not been subtle at his press conference.

“All I can tell you is his conduct does not befit a minister and I will not have him in my Cabinet,” Mr Key told a press conference this morning.

“If he hadn’t resigned I would have sacked him.” …

Mr Key said an outside party had informed his office of the allegation of a “relatively recent” incident last week.

Dr Worth had not come to him about it.

Dr Worth has been given a two-week leave of absence from Parliament: “because I think he needs some time to reflect on his future and whether he intends to stay as an MP”.

Mr Key said it was up to Dr Worth to decide whether to leave Parliament, but if police laid charges he may be suspended or expelled from Caucus.

`Ultimately whether he stays as a member of parliament is a matter at this point for him to consider.

“I urge him to consider his own future, and take counsel with his own family and friends.

“It may be in the fullness of time he is not appropriate to be a member of parliament. But that is not something I can adjudicate on at this time.”

Mr Key said the resignation had nothing to do with those.

“The decision that has been reached today has been reached on the back of this incident and nothing else.”

The allegations sound pretty dire, to say the least. But great to see Key set such a firm line on behaviour. I remember Clark and Cullen defending Field for months.

I was probably a bit too harsh before in criticising the Government’s handling of this.  Key has now provided the reason for the resignation, without going into details which are a matter for the Police inquiry. The original PR though said no further comment would be made, and then Key does a press conference so I think the message could have been better – but can’t really fault Key’s response now.

UPDATE6: NewstalkZB reports:

The Prime Minister has dropped another bombshell on his way into the debating chamber, revealing it is not the first time he has investigated Richard Worth for allegedly harassing women.

Dr Worth has today resigned from Cabinet and is being investigated by police. Newstalk ZB political editor Barry Soper says it is clear from what John Key says, that it involves a woman.

I may be wrong but all the indications are that it seems to be some sort of allegation of sexual assault. Now that is not confirmed, and no doubt the Police will in time say something, but I understand TV tonight is likely to report along these lines.

Dom Post editorial on Super

A somewhat mixed editorial from the Dom Post:

Last week’s suspension of contributions to the Cullen superannuation fund has made one unpalatable fact painfully clear. The age of eligibility for national superannuation is going to rise.

The suspension has not affected that fact significanly. It has always been likely at some future stage. Even Dr Cullen said so.

That is not what the Government says. Both Prime Minister John Key and Finance Minister Bill English say NZ Super will continue to be paid at a minimum of 66 per cent of the average wage from the age of 65.

And that will be the case while they are in office.

The reason the scheme will have to change is that there is a $31 billion hole in the government accounts. That is the hole that will be created over the next decade as a result of the Government’s decision to “temporarily” halt contributions to the fund established by former finance minister Michael Cullen to partially pre-fund the superannuation costs of baby boomers.

No, no, no, no. This is just crap. Even ignoring the reduced debt by suspending contributions, the impact on future superannuation is minimal. Taxpayers in 2050 will fund 91% of super, rather than 88%. The so called hole has minimal impact.

Our level of economic growth is what will determine future affordability.

Stopping contributions to the fund was the right thing to do. Despite the protestations of Labour, it makes no sense to borrow money to speculate on the world’s sharemarkets. Doubters should consider the performance of the fund since it was established in 2003 with the objective of exceeding the risk-free rate of return the interest rate on Treasury bills by 2.5 per cent. Its annualised rate of return is 3.26 per cent about half the Treasury rate and, in the year to April, the fund suffered losses of almost 30 per cent, more than double the average losses of retail managed funds.

Indeed. If the Fund had never been set up, NZ would be in a better position to fund future superannuation. That is a fact – not a projection.

Sure, the world is in the midst of the worst economic downturn since the Great Depression; sure, markets will eventually bounce back; but there is no certainty about which ones or when.

Politicians who think they can read economic portents are free to play the markets, but they should use their own money.

I think it is quite possible that there could be another crisis in five or six years when the level of US Federal Debt gets so high the Government effectively defaults by printing more money to pay its debts.

Goff’s record on jobs

Fran O’Sullivan reminded me on Saturday that Phil Goff was Minister of Employment from 1984 to 1990. I had forgotten this. I just remembered Phil as the man who introduced higher tertiary fees.

So everytime Phil Goff goes on about how the Government is not doing enough to reduce unemployment, we should look at how Phil did as Minister of Employment. And of course Phil did not have a global recession as a factor to deal with.

The Household Labour Force Survey only started in 1986, so we’ll compare 1986 to the end of 1990.

Well Phil managed to preside over the destruction of 97,000 jobs – falling from 1,623,000 to 1,526,000. Unemployment doubled from 71,000 to 150,000 – in percentage terms going from 4.2% to 8.9%.

Herald supports cellphone ban

The Herald editorial supports a cellphone use ban for drivers. I don’t agree of course.

Nonetheless, it is heartening to see Steven Joyce ready to act decisively to ban drivers from using hand-held cellphones. So dangerous is the practice and so widespread is the support for a ban that this issue should have been settled several years ago.

The practice is called dangerous, yet the actual accident rates from cellphone use is less than other distractions.

The appeal for a ban is based, first, on most people’s instinctive understanding that using a cellphone, whether for talking or texting, causes drivers to lose concentration.

Yes it does, but you can mitigate that risk. Talking to passengers can cause a loss of concentration also.

Virtually all comparable jurisdictions have stopped drivers using hand-held cellphones. Long ago, they dismissed the fuzzy notions that have delayed action here. Among those is the argument that cellphones are just one of a number of distractions, such as changing a CD or talking to passengers. But, unlike any other disturbance, cellphone use can be addressed simply. There is no need to treat it as just another distraction that must be tolerated.

Other distractions can be simply addressed. Smoking in cars can easily be banned. Stereo systems can be made illegal. Passengers can be banned. What is the logic to target cellphones only? What would be good to see is some research weighing up the costs and benefits of each type of distraction being banned.

If there is an element of controversy about Mr Joyce’s proposal, it lies in its restriction to hand-held cellphones. Much research has noted that the safety issue is not so much the holding of the phone as the decreased concentration caused by the conversation. If so, hands-free connections are equally dangerous. Nonetheless, it is fair to suggest that cellphones have become an essential instrument, especially for tradespeople. It is probably too late to ban them altogether, and the use of hands-free connections, which do not involve drivers looking down to make calls, probably represents a reasonable compromise.

And here is where I think the Herald’s arguments fall down. After stating all the reasons why cellphones should be banned in cars, they then agree it is not practical as cellphones have becom essential, and instead only ban hand held cellphones – despite acknowledging they are probably just as dangerous.

So the roads will be no safer, but we will feel we have done something. Wooly thinking which I expected better of from both the Government and the Herald.

Either have the courage of your convictions and ban cellphone use entirely, or don’t target them at all, and focus on a wider clampdown on all distractions.

NZ most peaceful nation on Earth

The 2009 Global Peace Index is out, and NZ leads the world!

The top ten is:

  1. New Zealand
  2. Denmark
  3. Norway
  4. Iceland
  5. Austria
  6. Sweden
  7. Japan
  8. Canada
  9. Finland
  10. Slovenia

Interesting how many of these top ten have violent pasts – Austria and Japan, and Slovenia more recently.

The bottom 10 are:

  1. Iraq
  2. Afghanistan
  3. Somalia
  4. Israel
  5. Sudan
  6. Congo
  7. Chad
  8. Pakistan
  9. Russia
  10. Zimbabwe

In 2008 NZ was 4th, so an improvement.  The authors say:

New Zealand is ranked the nation most at peace of the 144 ranked in the 2009 Global Peace Index. Its rise from 3rd position in 2008 is partly explained by an increase in the score for political stability, following the election of a new coalition government in November 2008. The centre-right National Party has a strong popular mandate and a robust parliamentary majority by New Zealand’s standards, putting the new prime minister, John Key, in a good position to push through his agenda. The rise to first position is also related to the fall of Iceland from the top spot last year, which reflects the deterioration in its indicators of political stability, the likelihood of violent demonstrations and perceived criminality in the wake of the banking collapse that engulfed the economy in September.

They also cite our good relations with Australia. I wonder if another under-arm incident would lower our ranking 🙂

I can’t wait for the Bruno movie

The all female jury

Okay so the Xue case has an all female jury. How unusual is that?

Well roughly it would happen once in every 4096 juries. An all maje jury will occur with the same frequency so a same sex jury will occur every 2,048 times on average.

However women are actually 52% of the adult population, not 50%. If you adjust for that, then an all female jury will occur one time in 2,558.

More on super costs

At midday I blogged about the hysterical nonsense claims that a suspension of contributions to the Super Fund would endanger future superannuation. In fact at worse it means that future taxpayers will pay 92% of future superannuation, instead of 89% – a mere 3% difference.

Now to show how trivial this difference is, look at this answer in the House today:

Peseta Sam Lotu-Iiga: If the Government were to make no contributions to the fund for another 11 years, how would the future cost of pensions compare with that expected when the fund was established?

Hon BILL ENGLISH: Whether there are contributions to the fund, and for how many years they are made, has no effect on the future cost of pensions compared with what was expected. When the fund was established back in 2000, the Government did projections that showed that by 2021 the total cost of New Zealand superannuation plus contributions would be 6.75 percent of GDP. Today’s projections available on Treasury’s website show that the total cost is now 5.43 percent of GDP in 2021. Maintaining New Zealand superannuation has actually become more sustainable because of changes in assumptions relating to demographics and rates of return.

So the cost of future superannuation as a percentage of GDP has dropped in relative terms by 19%. And this suspension of contributions increases the future tax burden by just 3% or so.

Yes one can make a but of a difference around the margins by pre-funding through a Super Fund. But the overall sustainability will be decided by economic growth, and demographics.

How to reduce obesity in children

Paul Walker blogs another example of unintended consequences:

Results suggest that [child care] subsidy receipt is associated with increases in BMI and a greater likelihood of being overweight and obese.

I await the Obesity Action Coalition to call for reduced child care subsidies to fight obesity!

Hooton and Harre on Super Fund