Blogs Bits

  1. Trainee journalist Sandra Dickson blogs on why she is not going to become a journalist.
  2. Tumeke celebrate their 4th birthday. Congratulations. They even managed to keep going while the founder was in jail for sedition šŸ™‚
  3. Big News has an economic study of female circumcision done by one of the Labour candidates for Mt Albert. Is actually an interesting study.
  4. Bryce Edwards has a review of the 2008 election for the European Journal of Political Research.
  5. Not PC calls Greg Mankiwi illiterate for advocating a negative interest rate.
  6. A guest post at The Standard calls Perez Hilton illiberal for his attack on Miss California’s response to a question on gay marriage.
  7. Keeping Stock blogs on a Bobbitt
  8. Paul Walker fisks The Standard on Zimbabwe
  9. Adam Smith highlights what Labour’s friends say about being in the trenches with them.
  10. Whale Oil has a poster for “The Haliburton Candidate”
  11. The Standard doesn’t think it is a good idea for Phil Goff to criticise National for cancelling tax cuts, when everyone in Labour thinks they should be cancelled.
  12. No Right Turn lashes Kevin Rudd fo ruling out civil unions in Australia.

Economic Fitness

The NZ Institute has published an analysis of NZ’s lack of economic fitness, and that it is not all about the “recessionary flu”. The Institute notes:

Achieving a step change in New Zealand’s economic growth rate is essential to improve the fiscal position. Unless New Zealand radically improves its growth prospects, basic amenities such as quality free education, health services, environmental protection measures and security in retirement may be at risk.

Yep, we need more pro-growth policies. The recession is a good reminder of how important economic growth is.

Both tax and spending measures should also be on the table to control the deficit, to make room for growth-boosting policies, and to maintain and strengthen support for at-risk individuals through the recession to avoid creating a future social deficit.

A $10 billion a year deficit must be curtailed. The interest on public debt would indeed threaten education and health funding.

The next two proposed tranches of income tax cuts should be cancelled on the grounds that they would contribute to the structural deficit and likely do very little for growth.

Long term, tax cuts are part of higher growth, but I agree these one are unsustainable.

Other spending areas that have contributed to the increase in government spending between 2003 and 2008 of 1.6% of GDP should be carefully reviewed with the aim of achieving their objectives more effectively at lower cost going forward. These include: the Working for Families tax credit system, and health expenditure.

WFF is very inefficient. There is huge wastage or churn as you take money from taxpayers to give it back to the same taxpayers. Welfare should be targeted to those most at need.

The tax mix should also be on the table as part of a long-term rebalancing exercise. Creating new sources of revenue (such as from taxes on property) will create room to finance the cost arising from future demographic pressures. Another objective is to more lightly tax productive investment and savings (for example through gradual reductions in company tax and taxes on savings overtime), while making residential property investment less attractive. This will help to address the structural imbalances in the New Zealand economy.

This is a big call, but one that does have to be looked at.

P J O’Rourke

I am greatly looking forward to the dinner with and speech from P J O’Rourke tomorrow. I have read all his books.

I had to choose between PJ in Auckland or Louise Bagshawe in Wellington, as they are both speaking on Thursday evening.

If others I know are attending the dinner, why don’t we meet up for drinks beforehand? E-mail me to work out a time and place. I am staying near Sky City at City Life, so could use the hotel bar here?

Also for those interested, I am on Media 7 tonight talking with Russell Brown, Nat Torkington and Colin Jackson on the early days of the Internet. You can watch it in the evenng on TVNZ7 or watch it being filmed at Comedy Classic at 321 Queen Street from 5.15 pm to 7 pm.

Dr Cullen’s Maiden Speech

A reader asked if a copy of Dr Cullen’s maiden speech could be located as it was not online. I put out a cry for help,and someone has found a copy, so enjoy:

New Zealand Parliamentary Debates 23 April 1982, vol. 443, p 441-446

23 April 1982 Address in Reply 441

Dr CULLEN (St. Kilda): I rise feeling like the elusive “scarlet pimpernel” of the Labour Party. Members opposite, or at least some of them, have worked themselves into a righteous lather of trembling indignation about the left-wing academics in the Labour Party. At last, the “one and only” has stood up to be counted. The previous Opposition maiden speakers are not academics by their immediate former profession. I am the first Opposition speaker to be so. Three Opposition members might be classed as academics, but I am not sure about their qualifications: the member for Christchurch Central is a lawyer, and therefore qualified to make an income outside—and that may be an automatic disqualification; and the member for Te Atatu and the member for Mt Albert taught at Auckland University, but as an Otago man I am not clear about their status as academics. When the compliments about left-wing academics are thrown across the House I shall be grateful if they are addressed to me personally and not spread around in an unwarranted fashion.

I affirm my loyalty to the Queen, and her heirs and successors, whoever they may be.

Mr East: And to your old school, Christ’s College.

Dr CULLEN: And to my old school, Christ’s College. I am proud of the fact that my secondary education was not paid for by the taxpayers of New Zealand but by the farmers of Canterbury and Hawke’s Bay. I ripped them off for 5 years then, and I shall get stuck into them again in the next few years, so the honourable member should not bring that subject up too often.

The rest is over the break.

Continue reading »

Is he trying to be funny?

NewstalkZB reports:

Mr Goff says the person who should be most grateful for the legacy left by Michael Cullen is the current Finance Minister Bill English.

Oh yes, Bill gets up every morning I am sure and says to Mary “Boy am I glad Michael Cullen left me a structural $10 billion a year deficit”.

He gets in to work and tells his staff “Think how boring our job would be if Dr Cullen had not increased spending by $4.5 billion a year in his last budget”.

At Cabinet every week Bill reminds his colleagues of how good a legacy Dr Cullen left them, as he screws them departmental budgets down.

Goff should do stand up comedy if he really said that with a straight face.

Privatising Protection

Privatising Protection is the name of the second article written by David Shearer about the use of mercenaries. I’ve uploaded a copy of it – privatising-protection.

This one was written three years after the 1998 “Outsourcing War” article – in 2001.

What is really interesting is that in 2001 he was an Adviser to the New Zealand Minister for Foreign Affairs and Trade. And who was that? Phil Goff of course.

Now I have worked in a Ministerial office. I find it hard to believe you could be an advisor to the Foreign Minister, and submit an article to Chatham House on private military forces without the Minister giving it an okay. The article is summarised by Chatham House as:

When people in the world’s conflict zones need protecting, it is the United Nations which is most frequently charged with ‘doing something’. Often short of soldiers, it should be given another option, to call on professional military companies to provide human security – for a fee.

Pretty clear – advocates the UN hiring private mercenary armies. But as the NZ Herald reports, Phil Goff said just two years later:

Mr Goff conversely referred to mercenary work as “paid murder” in 2003, when introducing legislation banning mercenaries.

So did Goff know of the article before publication? If so, how does he reconcile it with his statement in 2003?

I give full kudos to David Shearer who is not resiling from his views:

He said he was still supportive of using private security forces for peacekeeping as a last resort.

“If you have got a situation where thousands of people are being mutilated and it’s your only option, then your first priority is the protection of women and children.”

I agree with Shearer. But Shearer has also advocated that they may have a useful role in countries with civil wars. He said:

As a result states’ monopoly on dealing with civil violence has persisted unchallenged.

So Labour argue the state has to be a monopoly in corrections and workplace accident insurance, but their likely Mt Albert candidate says there should be no state monopoly in dealing with civil violence or the military.

Now I agree with Shearer, but I can imagine it is going to be very uncomfortable for Labour when he is an MP.Ā  Everytime Goff or King gets up to accuse the Government of having a privatisation agenda, the Nats will laugh and remind them that they have an MP who supports privatising the army. And when you consider Labour’s entire strategy is to basically label everything National does is as privatisation, well Naional can’t wait until Shearer is an MP. Hell, they are probably tempted to endorse him themselves.

I mean look at his free market logic here:

Many factions are increasingly motivated by economic gain through the control of diamonds, gold or minerals. Why not award the concession to a company that will mine and protect the resource, thereby keeping diamonds out of the hands of rebels who will sell them to finance their war?

I love it – profit sharing with the mercenaries. This guy understands free markets and incentives and best of all has no ideological opposition to them. He sure is no Helen Clark.

Of course not being a woman may harm him. The Herald reported:

The Service and Food Workers Union’s northern region secretary, Jill Ovens, said the affiliated unions would not be endorsing any particular Labour candidate.

She said her personal view was that it should be a woman, as Labour no longer had a female electorate MP in Auckland with the departure of Helen Clark.

That is true – they don’t. Cunliffe, Carter, Hawkins, Robertson Goff and Su’a hold the other seats.

New Zealanders and the Census

I agree with the Dom Post Editorial:

Statistics New Zealand has a problem. It is trying to squeeze square pegs into round holes.

The square pegs are the people who identified themselves as New Zealanders in the 2006 census. The round holes are the ethnic categories into which it wants New Zealanders to divide themselves.

Three years ago 400,000 people ignored the categories set out in the census form and wrote New Zealander in the “other” category. By using other sources of information, Statistics NZ has been able to build up a picture of those who refused to tick its boxes. It says more than 90 per cent were of European origin and they tended to be male, slightly older, better off and better educated than the general population.

However, the government statistician warns, in a discussion document issued this week, that if the number who ignore its official classifications continues to grow, the data collected in future ethnicity surveys will be rendered unusable. Good.

I don’t go so far as to say that is good (as I am a major user of said statistics) but I think that many in society are saying they do not regard themselves as purely European. And in fact over time many New Zealanders will have a mixture of European, Asian, Maori and Pacific ancestry. As a country we inter-marry between ethnicities far more than others.

I know people who have British and Maori ancestry. They don’t identify as either European or Maori.

According to Statistics NZ, the data is vital for the development of public policy. It is used to address social and economic inequality associated with membership of particular ethnic groups. Perhaps policy makers could try just addressing disadvantage.

Statistics NZ also suggests those who define themselves as New Zealanders are confusing ethnic and national identity. They are not. It is Statistics NZ that is confused.

According to the government statistician, an ethnic group is one which shares some or all of the following characteristics: a common proper name; elements of common culture such as religion, customs or language; a unique community of interests, feelings and actions; a shared sense of common origins or ancestry; and a common geographic origin.

The reason growing numbers of people are choosing to identify themselves as New Zealanders is because that is what they are, not just in a legal sense, but in a cultural sense.

I think a reasonable case can be made that “New Zealander” is a new emerging ethnicity – not just a nationality.

They are a group whose members have a common proper name, New Zealanders; share a common language, a version of English in which Maori terms and phrases are becoming increasingly common; share common values and interests; and share common origins and ancestry. The majority were born in this country, as were the parents and grandparents of many. There is nowhere else that they call home and no other group of people with whom they identify more closely.

Many Maori words have become “mainstreamed” as part of NZ English.

If what Statistics NZ really wants to know is the racial composition of those who identify as New Zealanders, that is what it should ask for although it might not like the response.

And that may be the way forward. Ask one question on ethnicity and another on racial composition.

But if it is genuinely interested in the ethnic makeup of New Zealand, it should open its eyes. A unique national identity is taking shape. It is one that incorporates elements of Maori, European, Pacific and now Asian culture. Home for its members is not on the other side of the globe. It is here. The language that is spoken is not the Queen’s English or Samoan or Cantonese, it is New Zild. And the values held by its members are not the values of London or Apia or Hong Kong, but of the Hutt Valley, South Auckland, Southland and Wellington.

That is something to celebrate, not to fret about.

Not all New Zealanders would see their ethnicity as New Zealand. Many Maori identify primarly as Maori. First generation Asian immigrants indetify as Asian. The second and third generations far less so, I would say.

Vector and co

Another good development yesterday in the fibre broadband project. As I blogged Telecom put forward a couple of constructive proposals.

Vector announced yesterday:

A group made up of lines companies and local fibre companies has been formed to support the Government’s vision of introducing ultra-fast fibre broadband to New Zealand.

Vector Chief Executive Simon Mackenzie said that the NZ Regional Fibre Group brought together the collective wisdom and experience of several different regional operators with expertise in open access networks.
ā€œWe welcome the opportunity to submit on the Government’s Broadband Investment proposal which will leap frog New Zealand to world class broadband.
This is also very exciting, and shows good leadership. Potentially lines companies have the ability to do some areas a lot cheaper than telcos.
Members of the New Zealand Regional Fibre Group include Vector, Aurora, Northpower, Waikato based WEL Networks, Unison, PowerNet, Christchurch City Networks, Network Tasman, and Velocity Networks.
That covers a fair bit of NZ!

Fighting Back in Tokoroa

A great story from Tokoroa:

Mr Pearce said the disguised robber entered the shop as it was closing just before 10pm, produced the rifle and demanded cash.

As he was making his threats, one of the staff members who was watching from inside a nearby chiller surprised the robber and attacked him, and a fight between the robber and two staff began.

A brave and risky move, but sometimes you get an opportunity and the risk is worth it.

The fight continued through the back door into a service alley, where the offender was overcome and fell to the ground, and his firearm was taken by one of the staff members.

So far so good.

“The offender has attempted to retrieve his firearm so a shot was discharged by the staff member to scare the offender away,” Mr Pearce said.

A pretty stupid offender. He’s just had his gun taken off him, and been subdued and he thinks they will just give him his gun back. Very sensible of the staffer to fire a warning shot.

“He has continued to advance on the staff member and another shot was discharged.

“The staff member concerned has told police that he believes he has shot the offender in the legs with this second shot, mainly due to the scream the offender let out.”

Yes the scream would be a good indicator.

Mr Pearce said the robber left the scene on foot. A police dog was unable to track the offender more than a few hundred metres from the scene.

The staffers acted totally appropriately. They did not shoot him to stop him escaping – only to stop him taking the gun back off them.

Police did not encourage victims being robbed at gunpoint to fight back as these victims did, he said.

Of course not. No doubt the Police will now charge the staffers. But rest aassured if they do, the jury will throw it out, as they always do.

The Dom Post has more:

Mr Jiang said yesterday that he was not a hero. “I was not scared. I would do it again. I hate these people. I will never give them any money.”

Yay.

Leading Edge Losses

I’m not an Auckland City ratepayer, but if I was I would be asking questions of Auckland City Council about accountability, after losses of $2.5 million at The Edge.

I don’t think City/Regional Councils should be making commercial decisions on underwriting soccer games or musicals.

That is different to supporting sport or the arts. Relatively happy for there to be sponsorship of subsidies of facilities – that way it is for a fixed known amount.

But why would you have 20 or so elected politicians deciding whether or not you agree with the Edge’s Board that 62,000 to 78,000 people will attend a musical?

English language skills

The Herald reports:

A Chinese nursing student is taking her tutors and university to the Human Rights Commission, accusing them of failing her in her final year of her bachelor of nursing course because of her accent.

“My tutors failed me because they said the way that I speak meant people couldn’t understand me, and they said it meant I will not be able to provide proper care to patients,” said Linda Tang, 42, who last week decided to drop out of her course at Unitec because she believed the tutors were making it impossible for her to pass.

“To say my English is not good enough is just an excuse. I feel that what they have done is discriminatory, especially to the Chinese, because we are penalised not for our lack of knowledge or ability, but simply because of how we talk.”

I feel very sorry for Ms Tang who is obviously keen to be a nurse. But the ability to communicate in English is important, and some accents can make it very very difficult for others to understand. No easy answer here as it is very difficult to change an accent, but in a medicla profession, oral communication can be vital.

Ms Tang, who holds a bachelor of english degree and is a former English lecturer at a university in China, said she was confident of her written English ability. Before enrolling at Unitec, Ms Tang said she was a bilingual teacher at Kingsland Institute and taught English to other immigrants.

Which makes it surprising that her oral English was not deemed good enough. One can’t judge withotu hearing, but you would hope she was given feedback early on about the need to improve, rather than just be failed at the end when everything else is okay.

“Maybe I can’t speak English like a Kiwi, but I am bilingual and also speak Mandarin and surely that must be seen as a plus in nursing rather than something negative,” Ms Tang said.

“If Unitec fails Chinese students for not being able to communicate properly in English, Kiwi students should also not pass because they cannot communicate with hospital patients who speak other languages.”

Umm no, English is an official language, and the primary language in NZ.

As I said, a sad case.

Swine Flu confirmed in NZ

NZPA reports:

Director of Public Health, Dr Mark Jacobs announced tonight that results from some of the Rangitoto College party who tested positive to Influenza A on Sunday, have also tested positive for Swine Flu H1N1.

Results from three of the samples were received earlier this evening from the World Health Organization regional laboratory in Melbourne and all tested positive for the same strain of Swine Flu. Testing continues on a fourth sample.

On the basis of these results, we are assuming that all of the people in the group who had tested positive for Influenza A have Swine Flu. As a result we are continuing with the current treatment which has been based on this assumption.

As they say in Dad’s Army, “Don’t Panic”

Labour making it up

Good God, I never realised that Labour’s regard for the truth was so remote that they literally just sit around and invent things. Labour has put out the press release quoted below:

National begins dirty tricks campaign in Mt Albert

Press Release by New Zealand Labour at 5:37 pm, 28 Apr 2009

National’s dirty tricks have started even before Labour has selected a candidate for the Mt Albert by-election, Deputy Leader of the Opposition Annette King said today.

First of all don’t you enjoy the hypocrisy of the party that was behind the attempted H-Fee smear, to talk about dirty tricks. Did Annette never notice Mike Williams over in Melbourne?

National and John Key’s dishonest attempt to discredit one of eight potential Labour candidates shows the Government’s eyes are off the ball when they should be focusing on peoples jobs and the upcoming budget.

“National has trawled through research papers written by David Shearer dating back to 1998. The papers looked at the use of private security in war torn nations where innocent civilians, mostly women and children, were dying and there were no better alternatives.

“They’ve fed this information to their right wing blogging friends.

Amazing – she just invents this from thin air. Let there be no mistake, I got the material from no one in National, in Parliament or the Government. I would be very happy to swear an affidavit before a JP to this, or undertake a polygraph. No one in National even pointed me towards this, and the first John Key would have known about this I suspect is when the media asked him for comment.

It amazes me that Labour is so embarrassed by these revelations, that they feel the need to just invent whoppers.

“Instead of this, John Key should be getting his staff to tackle real problems like job losses and the struggling economy.

Again nothing to do with the PM or his staff. Annoys me when people always credit them for our work! I know Labour is anti private sector, but maybe they can not comprehend the idea of people doing stuff on their own initiative.

“Why are they trying to dig dirt on one of the nominees, I predict that by the weekend they would have gone through the whole eight. Unlike National, we don’t yet know who our candidate will be. We are having a competitive selection process which will not be completed until this weekend.

And I urge all Labour delegates to vote Shearer. Far from this being dirt on him, I think it is great he supports a role for the private sector in wars and the military. The problem of course is that his sensible views stand in stark opposition to Labour who are against the private sector being involved in most things.

And I am also bemused how it is considered “dirt” to re-publish an article Mr Shearer wrote in a publicly available journal. Does Labour think there is something wrong with people knowing the views of its candidates on important policy issues? This is not some personal private issue which is embarrassing to Shearer – it is not digging up share transactions – it is a public article on a matter of public policy.

“I hope it’s not a sign of the tactics National plans to adopt for the campaign. Labour is committed to fight a strong, clean and fair by-election

Insert Tui billboard – just like their general election campaign no doubt.

“John Key should stop spending his time on negative politicking and concentrate his efforts on how the budget can address the real problems facing New Zealand,” Annette King said.

Annette – nothing to do with John. Honest. Ask him. Ask me. Give us a polygraph test. Drug me with sodium pentothal. You’ll get the same answer.

The articles by Shearer were found almost by luck in fact. Someone mentioned something to Whale about something Shearer had once written. He mentioned something to me. I asked a couple of friends with access to academic databases to try and fnd something, and one of them found it on an academic database and sent it to me.Ā  Total time on it was around ten minutes.

David Shearer on Mercenaries

Phil Goff has been shifting Labour more towards the centre, with the departure of Helen Clark and Michael Cullen. He is attacking National for not sticking with tax cuts, he let Clayton Cosgrove attack over Maori prison units and he is refusing to back Maori seats on the Auckland Council. Plus Labour are backing most of the RMA changes and voted to repeal the EFA.

But the extent to which Goff wants to pull Labour away from the left astonishes even me. As we all know, David Shearer is his hand picked candidate for Mt Albert – his former school friend and Ministerial advisor.

Now David shares none of the antipathy most of his Labour colleagues do towards the private sector. Most of them don’t want the private sector involved in corrections, work accident insurance, health or education. They say it has no role in core state functions. Us on the right are more relaxed and support private sector involvement if it is efficient and delivers good outcomes.

Anyway, while searching for Shearer’s Lincoln university thesis on Maori values and environmental decision-making (as had heard it was interesting) we came across a couple of articles David Shearer had written for foreign policy journals. And what are they on?

“Outsourcing War” and “Privatising Protection”

Let us first look at what he says in “Outsourcing War” published by “Foreign Policy” in 1998:

The principal obstacle to regulating private military companies has been the tendency to brand them as “mercenaries” of the kind witnessed in Africa 30 years ago,rather than to recognize them as multinational entrepreneurs eager to solidify their legitimacy

Legitimate multinational entreprenurs instead of mercenaries. Now that is music to my ears. Not quite so sure how aligned that is to current Labour Party activists and MPs.

Shearer goes on to recommend:

Consequently, regulation can be best achieved through constructive engagement.

I agree – far better than banning them. But Shearer has an even better idea:

The prospect that private military companies might gain some degree of legitimacy within the international community begs the question as to whether these firms could take on UN peacekeeping functions and improve on UN effort.

An excellent idea. I am sure the new UNDP Administator would whole heartedly agree that UN peace keeping forces should be replaced by Executive Outcomes and Sandline. I do hope someone asks her her view.

There is no denying that they are cheaper than UN operations. EO cost Sierra Leone’s governmen$t35 million for the 22 months it was there, versus a planned UN operation budgeted at $47 million for eight months.

And is it any more moral for the UN to be using Fijian peacekeepers than private mercenary armies?

Military companies may in fact offer new possibilities for building peace that, while not universal in applicability, can hasten the end to a war and limit loss of life. Moreover there is no evidence that private-sector intervention will erode the state.

Despite the commercial motives of military companies, their interventions, if anything, have strengthened the ability of governments to control their territory.

I think Rodney should grab David Shearer for ACT. I want this man to be our Defence Minister.

The full article is here – shearer-outsourcing-war. I’ll blog the second article tomorrow.

Domestic Violence Advert

This advertisement featuring Keira Knightley has been banned in the UK as it is “too violent”. Madness they allow all sorts of violence in the TV shows, but won’t allow an ad that shows domestic violence.

It is a good ad – shows the brutality. And the end scene make me think of a certain recent case in NZ!

Hat Tip: Frog Blog

Glender Fryer campaigning

Labour aspiring candidate for Mt Albert Glenda Fryer put out a release yesterday:

After receiving news that francisee Chander Satija was to have the Sandringham Post Office and Kiwibank closed down, Cr Fryer wrote a letter to NZ Post and met with Auckland representativesĀ to ask them to reconsider their decision.Ā Ā NZ Post undertook to do this.Ā  NZ Post have yet to give Mr Satija their final decision. …

Concludes Councillor Fryer ā€œ I know the franchaisee Chander SatijaĀ Ā  has given NZ Post over 500 letters from local people saying how much they depend on the services of the post office and bank.Ā  Many locals feel they also want to show their faces and stand behind the only bank in Sandringham to tell NZ Post they love their local services and don’t want them closed down. ā€œ

So that evil NZ Post is closing down the Sandringham Post Office and Kiwibank. Maybe Glenda should lobby some of the Directors. Perhaps a Mr Shale Chambers? It should be fairly easy for her to lobby him, as he is her husband.

Telecom proposes national fibre solutions

Telecom has released today their proposal to the Government for how best to utilise the $1.5b available for fibre to the premises.

Their first option is an acclerated fibre roll-out by Chorus. Milestones would be:

  1. All 93 hospitals connected within 30 months
  2. 2,000 schools connected within 30 months
  3. Remaining 600 schools (including those outside the 75% zone) within 36 months
  4. Possible extensions to medical centres, pharmacies, libraries, maraes and community centres
  5. Would build fibre to all new homes in the 75% coverage area (at present only builds to developments of at least 50 lots)
  6. Extend the fibre network to pass more homes, and subsidise connections into individual homes.
  7. Have shorter cooper loops to increase speeds to non fibre homes on VDSL2

It would see the Government investment and their existing investment co-ordinated (not competing) so there is no over-build. All infrastructure would be open access and dark fibre would be made available to all comers.

It is not promising full fibre into every home, but it is advancing a lot towards that goal.

Their second option is to have the Crown Fibre Network Company to contract Chorus to build a national fibre ducting network of up to 10,000 kms home. So they will not provide the fibre, but will provide the duct for it. Now ducting is estimated to be 80% to 85% of the cost of fibre deployment (off memory) and a lot of people say that it is only the ducting that needs to be open access.

Service providers would fund the actual fibre connection to the premises.

Telecom also offer some hints that they could be willing to sell off some or all of Chorus (which would make their proposal extremely attractive). They say they are open to “alternative partnership models”.

Really pleased to see Telecom put forward constructive and viable proposals. It will be fascinating to see who else steps up to the plate.

Life under Labour’s Lianne

Look at what fun we have to look forward to if Labour gets back into office. This is what Lianne Dalziel wants:

  1. Increased tax on alcohol
  2. Ban supermarkets and grocery stores from selling alcohol
  3. Increase purchase age to 20 for off licenses
  4. Most bars and nightclubs to be forced to close at 1 am
  5. Bottle stores to close at 8 pm

Lianne forgot the one about needing your parent’s permission to be out after 9 pm if you are aged under 30.

Dom Post on court fines

Dom-Post today:

The Justice Ministry is playing with fire.

A review of its structure obtained by The Dominion Post reveals it is contemplating rejigging its fines system to concentrate its collection efforts on those most likely to pay.

It should abandon such foolishness before it undermines public confidence in the entire justice system.

The ministry’s tentative plans for the “segmentation” of ministry debtors are contained in a document called Structure of Operations in the Ministry, Proposals for Consultation.

The document says work is under way to “focus enforcement effort where it is most effective and to avoid expensive enforcement actions which drive up the overall cost of collection without necessarily resolving the debt”. In plain English, that means letting the worst offenders get away with it.

From a business point of view, concentrating the ministry’s resources in areas where they will generate the greatest return makes eminent good sense. Offenders at present owe $790 million in fines. Almost $450m of that is overdue, a significant amount owed by habitual defaulters who have no intention of ever making good on their debts. Why squander scarce resources on hardcore offenders when others can be persuaded more easily and more cheaply to pay up?

The answer is that the Justice Ministry is not a business. It is the body charged with administering the justice system.

Public confidence in the system requires that all citizens be treated equally, both when they appear before the courts and, if they are convicted, after they have been sentenced.

If the ministry abandons, or eases up on, its attempts to recover fines from the worst offenders it will make its own job more difficult by encouraging offenders to regard the payment of fines as optional, but worse than that it will reduce respect for the law.

One can only agree.

Blogs & Mt Albert

There has been quite a bit of chatter about the role of blogs in the Mt Albert by-election, so I thought it would be useful to put them in perspective as I think people are over-reaching.

Matt McCarten wrote on Sunday (and Laila Harre also said much the same on radio yesterday):

What is disheartening is that Labour’s action wasn’t from a place of principled strategy but the result of hysteria generated by their political opponents.

I salute the right-wing bloggers, who mischievously instigated a destabilising campaign against Labour by writing that National could win Mt Albert if Twyford was the Labour Party nominee. Twyford is a current list MP. Their genius was in pointing out that if Twyford won – as was widely assumed – then Judith Tizard, as the next-highest place list candidate, would be entitled to return to Parliament to replace Twyford’s vacant list spot.

The bloggers claimed that Twyford’s campaign would be overshadowed by the furore of the supposedly unpopular Tizard slipping back into Parliament.

Privately, none of the bloggers believed that their strategy would amount to much, but were incredulous when certain media players started taking it seriously.

What gobsmacked the bloggers particularly – and fatally for Twyford – was that the Labour Party panicked.

Poneke goes even further and credits me with all sorts of “machinations”.

While I think the blogs have played a role in Mt Albert to date, I think people over-state that role. I’ll start from the beginning.

When I first blogged on the Tizard timebomb in December, I didn’t invent it out of thin air. I did hear from someone in Labour that it was an issue they were looking at. Back then, to be fair, I don’t think they were overly concerned, it was more “We need to work out how to deal with this so Twyford can stand”.

I then went away did a bit of research, and blogged on this issue, also pointing out the next four on the list after Tizard were almost as problematic also. Incidentially during this time I have never attacked Judith personally – I’ve just pointed out she didn’t have a positive public appeal.

Now there is debate about whether the Tizard timebomb was real or not. Did Labour panic over nothing, or was it a real threat? Actually it as a bit of both – it is all about probabilities.

Other bloggers like Danyl M make the case that as 45% of NZers don’t even know Phil Goff is the Leader of the Labour Party, then it is ridicolous to think that many residents in Mt Albert would know who is next in line on the Labour list, let alone have it affect their vote. And he may be right.

But what Danyl can’t dismiss is there was a chance that in the absence of major policy issues, there could be a lot of media focus on the Tizard timebomb, especially with coverage from the bloggers.

Let us say there was a 90% chance that Tizard being next List MP in would not be an issue, only a 10% chance it would be. Labour may have decided that is an acceptable risk.

What bloggers did do, is increase that risk. They didn’t invent it out of thin air. It only works, because it has some credibility. But by highlighting the issue, we may have increased the risk of it becoming a major issue from say 10% to 20% – and that 20% may have exceeded Labour’s comfort level.

The other role the bloggers played, is that rather than allow Labour to work out a quiet behind the scenes compromise with Judith, we made sure it played out in public to some degree.

So yes the bloggers did have some influence over Labour’s decision regarding Mt Albert, it is considerably less than McCarten, Harre and Poneke ascribe. At the end of the day, it was a real risk.

Likewise over the selection of Norman as a candidate. Yes I did push that concept, but I dont think one should confuse correlation with causation.And the advice is generally what is best for the Greens – they do need to be less of a lapdog for Labour, they do need an electorate seat. It is not at all impossible Norman could win the seat, if they push strategic voting such as happened in Epsom in 2005 and Wellington Central in 1996.

My advice is not necessarily beneficial to National. A strong Green candidacy could push National into third place. Also National probably would have preferred that nothing be said about the Tizard issue until after Twyford was selected. They would have loved having Tizard back in the House to torment Goff over as an example of rejuvenation.

Even if National somehow win the by-election (something I regard as very unlikely – it is Labour’s safest seat, we are in a recession, and a Government has not won a by-election off an Opposition in at least 70 years) then it would finish Goff off before the 2011 election, and if you did a poll of National MPs they would prefer Goff remain Leader.

So yes blogs are having a bit of influence, but it is over-stated generally. And no it is not some sort of master campaign plan – more livign true to the motto of Fomenting Happy Mischief.

In line with that, I have this banner from a reader:

for-june-13

Cullen valedictory

Michael Cullen’s valedictory will be at around 5.30 pm Wednesday. His departure leaves Phil Goff as the sole survivor of the 1981 intake.

Love him or hate him, Cullen has been one of the funniest debaters in the House in recent years, and I hope he will not disappoint in his valedictory. If it is as dispassionate as Helen’s, I’ll slit my wrists.

One of his former press secretaries has a tribute to him in the Herald. It covers some of the complexities:

For many in the public, reconciling the man seen visibly angry in a controversially broadcast exchange with Guyon Espiner with the man visibly moved at the signing of the Central North Island forestry settlement is not an easy task.

How do you make sense of the formidable policy mind who amazed senior officials when he designed the expansion of KiwiSaver on a couple of sides of A5 (complete with costings) with the infuriated figure who labelled John Key a “rich prick”?

I’ve referred to Cullen as a flawed genius previously and will try and cover this in more detail later in the week.

Pagani on NZ Aid

Josie Pagani, a former Comms Manager at NZ Aid, writes on aid politics:

Foreign Minister Murray McCully is close to announcing a u-turn in New Zealand’s aid. He wants to move our aid away from its goal of reducing extreme poverty, back towards a less defined goal of “economic development”.

I would hope the two goals are complementary, not in opposition to each other.

The difference between “poverty alleviation” and “economic development” in some of the poorest countries is not a bright line. How are you meant to set up your own business and trade your way out of poverty when you can’t read and write, and you have no clean water and no roof over your head?

I would advocate that aid which provides shelter, food and water is part of economic development as you can’t have people contributing towards an economy without these things.

This proposed change in our aid represents misguided politics. It has been pitched by Mr McCully as a struggle between the non-government organisations like Oxfam and World Vision, who want the focus to remain on poverty reduction; and those who support business, and economic development instead.

This is a false dichotomy.

It’s true, there is some silliness in the aid community. Some aid experts don’t believe in growth – that’s why you end up with incomprehensible policy areas called “pro-poor-growth”.

This is one of the things I like about Josie – she is willing to concede “silliness” rather than pretend everything is perfect with the status quo.

It took years of political effort to make poverty reduction the focus of aid. The goal holds rich countries accountable.

For example, it stops countries like Portugal or France using aid to protect the Portuguese or the French language in their former colonies. That might be a great idea, but it isn’t aid.

But Mr McCully couldn’t say that encouraging the French language in Cote d’Ivoire isn’t contributing to economic development. The focus on poverty also holds the governments of poor countries accountable for using aid to actually reduce poverty. Signing up to a goal of “poverty reduction” is more likely to prevent the kind of situation in Ethiopia a few years ago – then, Prime Minister Meles Zenawi used funds to set up a trucking business (“economic development”) to deliver food across the country.

The company was owned by his own family, and tended to deliver food only to Zenawi’s home region of Tigray, while other parts of Ethiopia went hungry.

I would hope that NZ Aid wil avoid giving money to corrupt politicians, regardless of its mission. Mind you, in the Pacific it is probably near impossible. I recall the Austrian DFAT briefing that described one Pacific Premier as having a nickname of Mr 10% as that was his cut on all government contracts.

We give aid because we are good global citizens, doing our part to make a difference for the most desperately poor in the world.

Mr McCully should keep the focus strongly on poverty reduction, and keep NZAID as a dedicated agency with an undiluted focus on doing our bit towards that very important goal.

I wonder if there is not some sort of compromise here, such as an aim of “poverty reduction through economic development” as that would cover the Minister’s worry that the cirrent goal is too wide, and also cove the concerns of Pagani and others than not all economic development alleviates poverty?

UPDATE: I should point out (as should have the Herald) that Josie was No 3 on the party list for the Progressive Party at last year’s election.

Airport security

Very pleased to read:

Expensive upgrades of airport security are unlikely to fly, with Prime Minister John Key taking a cautious approach.

An alleged hijacking attempt last year prompted a review of aviation security which found unscreened passengers and carry-on baggage were a high-risk area but that the threat of terrorism was “very low”.

The review said greater screening of crew and carry-on baggage would be the best way to increase security, at an estimated cost of $5 a passenger.

Other options included strengthening cockpit doors, security committees at airports and enhanced training and education for airport workers.

Mr Key was asked about the recommendations yesterday morning. He replied: “Whether you want to go to full screening at all of those 10 airports [reviewed], I think that’s something that you’d proceed with caution on.”

The Government is to decide on security measures next month.

Transport Minister Steven Joyce last week raised concerns about adding costs in tough economic times but said some measures, such as reinforcing cockpit doors, made sense.

The great thing about flying on the smaller regional flights is not having the ridicolous screening. Introducing it because of one mad woman would be a massive over-reaction. What next – x-ray machines on every bus stop in case someone hijacks a bus?

Also can Steven Joyce have a talk to Wellington Airport and tell them to move their security x-ray machines from the current locations, to before the Koru Club- as is the case in Auckland. It is incredibly inefficient as it doesn’t allow those who arrive early to get through screening early.