H2 off also

The Herald reports that H2, Heather Simpson, is also off to New York – on a short term basis initially.

This is a smart move by Clark. The UN bureaucracy is notoriously unresponsive, and Simpson is a very accomplished chief of staff. Probably fair to say she was more feared than loved in the Beehive, but a dose of fear into the UN bureaucracy is just what it needs!

The Herald reports that before working for Clark, Simpson was an economic lecturer at Otago University. Indeed, she was – she taught me first year economics.

Obama wins over Latin America

I’m not a fan of his economic policies. but I do admire the rebuilding of relationships that Obama is overseeing. The Herald reports on his sucess in Latin America.

The US can not be effective by force or economic power alone.

I suspect there will come a time when Obama will have to make some hard decisions, which will end the international honeymoon. But until that occurs, it is sensible to utilise the goodwill that exists while you can.

Back to Latin America, Chavez is a nasty piece of work who wants to rule Venezuela for ever. So one might say, why worry about relations with him. Well, if he is unable to cast the US President as the great enemy, it means his re-election may have to rely on actual achievements for his people, rather than a tide of anti-US nationalism.

Taito Phillip Field starts today

The first ever trial of a (now former) MP for bribery and corruption – relating to their office – starts today.

The former Labour MP faces 12 charges of corruption and bribery and 23 of wilfully perverting the course of justice.

The trial is expected to last 12 weeks, partly because so many witnesses will need interpreters.

As usual with trials, it is best if commenters leave the verdict to the jury.

Clayton Cosgrove at work

The HoS Editorial attacks critics of the proposed Maori prison unit:

It is dispiriting to hear the word “apartheid” bandied about in such circumstances. That word applied to a particularly loathsome kind of institutionalised racial oppression written into law in a specific time and place. Under the guise of separate development, it deliberately maintained one racial group as an underclass. Tackling the appalling Maori imprisonment rate cannot reasonably be seen as oppressive towards non-Maori.

Those who seek to depict it as an easy ride for which an inmate qualifies simply by virtue of his skin colour are being at least mischievous, if not reactionary.

So who is this reactionary critic, the HoS refers to? It can only be Clayton Cosgrove, whose PR said:

“Punishments for violent offenders who commit crimes against ordinary New Zealanders should not be based on an accident of birth and that is exactly what the Government is proposing.

“Targeted rehabilitative programmes delivered within the mainstream prison system are appropriate and their benefits should continue to be explored.

“Unfortunately the Government is not proposing to do this; it is proposing to develop an entirely separate set of punishments and of privileges based solely on race.

“Minister of Maori Affairs Pita Sharples stance is an insult to victims of crimes.

“A rape victim or victim of any violent offence should know that their offender will be punished equally no matter what their race.

“Dr Sharples seems to care little for victims of crime if he believes that allowing violent offenders to go flatting or be given special privileges based on race is an appropriate punishment.

As others have noted this was a total misrepresentation of how these units would work – no one would be sentenced to them. Towards the end of their sentence they may qualify to go there to increase their chance of rehabilitation.

Some commentators have compared Cosgrove’s outburst to Don Brash;s Orewa speech. Now personally I feel such a comparison is very unfair to Dr Brash (Brash never used such inflammatory language) but let us accept it is in the same vein . Now my spies have dug out a SST newspaper story from February 2004, in response to Orewa. Quotes include:

[MP] yesterday compared Brash’s rhetoric to that of Australian ultra-nationalist Pauline Hanson, who also used the “one people” line to argue against special treatment for Aborigines. …

“If Dr Brash continues with these coded messages of division, then you’re going to see that behaviour coming to a pub or a street near you. And that would be a tragedy.”

“If Dr Brash is not careful, his legacy to this country will be the politics of divisions, the Hansonite politics,” he said.

“Brash has gone too far. He’s Xeroxed off Pauline Hanson’s words and Pauline Hanson’s campaign strategy. Those words are a code for division, a code for unrest, a code that tore Australia down the middle.”

So who was this MP viciously attacking Don Brash for his Orewa speech, and comparing him to Pauline Hanson?

It was a Clayton Cosgrove MP.

So will Clayton Cosgrove MP compare Clayton Cosgrove MP to Pauline Hanson?

Is this new strategy approved by Phil Goff and Parekura Horomia?

In depth article on NZ blogging

Bid on the grapefruit

Clark resigned and gone

Helen Clark resigned as a Member of Parliament on Friday, and flew out to New York late last night.

Audrey Young blogs Haere ra. She notes it is a dignified exit:

If you think back to how recent Prime Ministers have departed, there is virtually no comparison: an embittered Rob Muldoon stayed and wrecked Jim McLay’s leadership of National; David Lange stayed in Parliament for another seven years, not undermining his successors, but not happy; Mike Moore’s presence on the backbench for three years was a monkey on Clark’s back; and Jenny Shipley made the awful transition from Prime Minister to Leader of the Opposition, which just didn’t work.

Jim Bolger managed his exit once the numbers were against him but negotiating your own appointment as US ambassador – competent as he was – was a tad undignified. Better though than staying on.

Palmer did bail out gracefully. He resigned as Pm a few weeks before the 1990 election and retired from Parliament also. Muldoon and Lange were both sad figures who stayed on too long.

Audrey also refers to my list of strengths and weaknesses, and says:

Achieving and maintaining unity was the most important, in my view, because all other achievements flowed from that, but how long the unity lasts after her departure remains to be seen. It won’t revert to anything like the bad old days.

I agree – unity is hugely important. And while Goff will face some challenges if the polls don’t improve, they won’t be factional driven challenges, more ambitious wannabe leaders.

But Clark’s departure today and Cullen’s in a couple of weeks will mean Labour can start the rows they are destined to have over the past, the future policy direction, and how to rebuild, though they will probably be delayed until after the Mt Albert by-election.

How Goff manages the debate will be a crucial test of his leadership.

Well at least with Helen going, Phil should now be able to make at least second place in the Preferred PM stakes!

Gender and Disaster Risk Reduction conference

No I have not made this up.

Steve Chadwick has put out a PR:

Steve Chadwick leaves this weekend for a Gender and Disaster Risk Reduction conference in Beijing, China. Ms Chadwick had been invited for her former roles as both Minister of Women’s Affairs and Chair of NZPPD. …

“The purpose of this conference will be to address and review progress and existing challenges in mainstreaming gender issues in disaster risk reduction. At present there is an unequal balance in how disasters affect men and women” said Ms Chadwick.

Hell I never realised earthquakes were sexist and discriminated. Mind you those bushfires have always been a bit old fashioned so I’m not surprised they are imbalanced as to how they affect women.

Here’s some decisions from their last conference:

Refrain from funding of extractive industries, such as mining, logging and oil and natural gas extractions that exacerbate climate change, poverty and gender inequality.

We should stop logging because it causes gender inequality.

Anyway I’m not complaining about Steve attending the conference. Like Alf Grumble, I’m wondering who she pissed off to be forced to attend as punishment. Alf says:

Good grief. If two days exposure to thoughts on gender issues in disaster risk reduction is the price to be paid, you can not regard this as a junket. It’s obviously a stiff punishment, but for what?

Probably for using the word “wellness”.

Actually, talking about “wellness” should be a capital offence, but two days in Beijing banging on about genders and disasters with like-minded drones comes close to next best (or worst) on the severity scale.

I would have thought it constitutes inhumane punishment!

Today’s Veitchness

The HoS report that Veitch has tried to take his life for the third time.

Another HoS story reports on the latest exchanges between the camps. And a third covers the debate on the altered references, and whether they have broken the law.

A fourth HoS story (yes four!) covers the end of the relationship and some e-mails showing friendly relations after the attack. A fifth HoS story has the text of an e-mail. And Kerre Woodham wants people to move on.  And finally in their seveneth online story, the HoS Editorial says Veitch should remove himself from the public spotlight. The editorial is right, but I note the newspaper is very happy to devote half the newspaper to him, if he doesn’t!

The SST is slightly more restrained. They report a psychologist saying both Veitch and Dunne-Powell need to move on and stop the pot shots. A second SST story looks at how Veitch courted the press. Michael Laws has his say. A fifth SST story covers the latest suicide attempt. And their sixth story has Rosemary McLeod telling Veitch to shut up now.

So 13 stories in our two main Sunday papers on Veitch. Please let it be zero next weekend.

NZ – China links strong

I almost didn’t blog these, because they are so positive, but it is probably worth doing so, as Key is new to Foreign Affairs. First we have Fran O’Sullivan:

The Prime Minister’s diplomatic team skilfully orchestrated the visit so that New Zealand’s vital business interests in China were enhanced.

Wen made clear that China has drawn a line under the tainted milk affair at Fonterra’s now bankrupt Sanlu joint venture and welcomed increased participation in its fledgling agriculture industry.

Air New Zealand has also won a departure slot at Beijing International Airport that will help it encourage more Chinese visitors to come to Auckland, arriving at around 6am rather than just before 3am.

Key’s meetings with the prime Chinese customers of some of New Zealand’s major firms will also help in easing some barriers to doing business.

Clark’s own high-level political skills and feel for international affairs enabled New Zealand to secure last year’s historic free trade deal with China. But now the FTA is into the “implementation phase”, Key’s business skill-set is proving valuable.

It is good Key is continuing Clark’s fine work with China.

And the NZ Herald Editorial:

John Key’s state visit to China was a potentially tricky one. The 12 months after the signing of a momentous free trade deal have not been plain sailing. Most notably, New Zealand was implicated in the contaminated milk scandal that swept through China, thanks to Fonterra’s involvement in the now-bankrupt Sanlu joint venture. It is a feather in the cap of the Prime Minister and this country’s diplomats that the Chinese say they see no reason to allow this issue to undermine relations. …

Premier Wen Jiabao told Mr Key he regarded China’s relationship with New Zealand as the “very, very best” it had been. It is reassuring that a tie skilfully built by the previous government continues to flourish despite some unforeseen hiccups.

As the US buckles under the weight of Obama’s spending, the Chinese economy will become much more important to us.

Please let it be over

Arrgh. I thought the trial would be the end of the Veitch affair. But no all the headlines again today.

First of all very stupid that Veitch used character references in support of him getting his passport back, in sentencing mitigation to the Judge. The Herald quotes an angry Dame Susan Devoy:

“To take those letters of support and use them for a different purpose is, in my opinion, a disgrace,” said Dame Susan.

“I was happy to write to get his passport back, I thought the trial would be in 2010 or later. It’s totally totally different to writing a character reference for someone who’s pleaded guilty to beating up their girlfriend. We’ve been used and manipulated.

Veitch has only himself to blame for the negative headlines in this case.

The Herald also has a Q&A with Kristin Dunne-Powell. Hopefully this will be the end of it, now that they both have “told their stories” but somehow I suspect the Sunday papers will be all over it.

Fullers raking in Goldcard Cash

I’ve been warning for sometime that the Super Goldcard is fatally flawed as it provides for free off peak travel rather than merely discounted. The moment you make something free you fuck up any incentive for rational outcomes.

The Herald reports that taxpayers have paid $750,000 to Fullers in just five months, in return for providing free off peak travel to Waiheke Island.

Now while once upon a time Waiheke was a place where only hippies lived, but it is now home to many of the richest families in Auckland. The 2006 census found only 294 families on Waiheke receiving NZ Super. So the taxpayer is going to end up paying Fullers around $1.8 million to pay ferry costs for 294 families.

Think how much good that money could do funding some hip replacement operations?

OECD 2009 Report on NZ

The full OECD report is here. One key aspect:

The country appeared to be on the right policy track with its earlier market-oriented reforms. But the policy focus on productivity and growth eroded during the years of economic buoyancy, while other countries advanced.

The 2000s were the wasted years. Complacency ruled, and the rest of the world left us behind.

Cindy gone

Paula Bennett has announced:

Child care and protection expert John Angus has been appointed Children’s Commissioner for six months while a permanent appointment is sought, Social Development and Employment Minister Paula Bennett said today.

“I have decided to make an interim appointment to allow time to find the right permanent appointee for this important position,” Ms Bennett said. “I am grateful that we have someone of Mr Angus’ ability and standing available while we work to fill the role long-term.”

John Angus is a former front-line social worker, and was later a senior public servant. More recently he worked on the review of the Children Young Persons and their Families Act 1989, and he led inter-departmental work on preventing child abuse and neglect for the Taskforce for Action on Violence Within Families.

“Mr Angus has high integrity and immense respect within the sector for the policy research and academic work he has done on child care and protection over many years,” Ms Bennett said. “He is regarded as thoughtful, considered and a safe pair of hands.”

Sounds very safe.

Ms Bennett thanked outgoing commissioner Dr Cindy Kiro for her commitment to children and young people over more than five years in the position.

“Dr Kiro has been a strong advocate for the rights of children, and she has left a lasting impression.

Well yes it has been a lasting impression. I doubt there has ever been such a divisive Commissioner before in that role, and hopefully there won’t be again.

The Children’s Commissioner should be one of our heroes. Others have done sterling jobs. Kiro, while I am sure absolutely doing what she thought was right, was a disaster. Far far too ideological, too lecturing, too divisive.

Comments are disabled as I am heading out drinking and not got time to delete and moderate the comments that will no doubt ensue.

iPredict on Mt Albert

iPredict has some Mt Albert stocks. They are its first conditional contracts where you balance up both the probability of someone being a candidate, and if they are a candidate what percentage of the votes they will get for their party. An explanation from their blog:

Specifically, we will run contracts that pay $0.01 for each percent of the vote won by National or Labour candidates in the by-election conditional on a specific candidate being selected.

For example, we will run a contract that pays $0.01 for each percent of the vote the National Party wins in the by-election conditional on Melissa Lee being the National candidate.

If Lee is not the National candidate the contract pays nothing.

The reason conditional contracts like this are valuable is that they provide a forecast of which candidate will maximise a party’s vote share before candidate selection has occurred. That tells the party who they ought to select.

The interpretation of the price of a conditional stock price in this context is as the product of a) the likelihood candidate X will be selected, and b) the party’s vote share given that candidate is selected.

For example, let’s say Candidate X’s objective chance (however defined) of winning the National candidacy for Mt Albert is 60%, and National’s vote share in Mt Albert if that Candidate X is selected is 45%. What should the conditional stock trade for? $0.6 x $0.45 = $0.27.

Now let’s look at their actual stocks. First they have a simple stock called MTA.LEE which is the probability Melissa Lee will be the National candidate. Before I purchased 200 shares, they were trading at 85.8c, so the market was saying an 86% chance Melissa would be the candidate.

Then we have MTA.LEE.NAT which is at 39c. You divide 39c by 86c to calculate the projceted vote for National if Lee is a candidate, which is 45%.

And MTA.LEE.LAB is also at 39c. So the market is saying (for now) that if Melisssa Lee stands for National, the result will be very very close.

They also have a MTA.TWYFORD. This is at 53c, reflecting greater uncertainity over the Labour nomination.

Wine sales in supermarkets

The ODT reports:

Labour MP Lianne Dalziel has called for supermarkets to “lose the right” to sell alcohol because the practice of making a loss on alcohol products in order to entice people into their stores was behind a “significant number” of alcohol-related issues, she said.

“These people are pouring alcohol into our streets,” she said.

Ms Dalziel said the 1989 decision to allow wine into supermarkets was the “most dangerous, low-reaching, appalling decision that Parliament has ever made”.

Really? Wine is our problem? I’m sorry, but I think beer and spirits play a far far bigger role in alcohol abuse and related violence and crime, than being able to buy a bottle of wine with your groceries.

I buy most of my wine direct from vineyards, but it is nice to sometimes be able to grab a bottle when at the supermarket. And Lianne want to make this illegal?

Greens still mourning loss of food police

The Greens are still in mourning for the loss of the food police:

School tuckshops are selling 14 per cent more junk food such as pies and sausage rolls than last year, sparking calls for the reinstatement of healthy eating guidelines.

The Green Party released its annual school food survey yesterday.

It showed a 14 per cent rise in pie, hot dog, sausage roll and hot-bite sales compared with the year before.

More than half of the 50 schools surveyed sold donuts, cookies and cakes while 42 per cent sold chips.

The Green Party says the survey results show an urgent need for the reinstatement of the School Food Guidelines ditched by Education Minister Anne Tolley this year.

Hmmn 50 schools. What sort of margin of error do you get from just 50 responses? It is +/- 14.3%.

Tolley told The Press schools were still required to promote healthy food and drink options and she trusted school boards of trustees to make appropriate decisions.

No, no, no. Teachers must be forced into becoming the food police. We need audits, inspections, dawn raids. You can not trust the people!!

Green Love

Over at NBR, I look at the winners and losers from the National-Green MOU, with that scoring Best Play of the Fortnight.

Worst Play goes to Clayton Cosgrove for his scare mongering over an initiative to reduce Maori reoffending.

And Richard Worth manages to keep the title for Scandal of the Week, and I comment on how Labour’s allies in calling for Worth to go, are some of the right wing blogs (not Kiwiblog), not so much the left wing ones.

Comments and feedback can be made at NBR.

NZ Herald on Maori prison unit

While Labour is attacking it, the NZ Herald welcomes the Sharples proposal:

As Dr Sharples envisages it, a 60-bed unit would be established in an urban centre close to educational services and jobs. The inmates would earn places by learning to speak Maori and prove their good intentions by becoming literate and working for charitable or community projects.

Though locked in at night they would be more like flatmates than inmates, sharing facilities, learning to live together, associating with their families, the community and their victims. All going well they could be released after four months.

It sounds more like a pre-release hostel than a prison and the cultural element might be no more intensive than the Maori focus units already operating inside five prisons. They were set up with Dr Sharples’ help 11 years ago and their inmates have recorded a reoffending rate about 7 per cent lower than the general prison rate. Since the units probably attract the better-motivated inmates, the improvement does not seem startling.

Clayton Cosgrove has outraegously scaremongered that this is some sort of seperate prison that Maori would get sentenced to. As the Herald points out it would merely be a specialist unit for suitable prisoners nearing release. A number of prisons already have pre-release units where prisoners flat together and learn some living skills.

A stand-alone unit may be a long way from adoption and National may remain sceptical of its worth. But it owes the Maori Party a concession, especially after ruling out Maori electorates for Auckland’s proposed Super City.

Actually I think the quid pro quo for no Maori seats will be signing the UN declaration on Indiginous Rights.

The criminal rehabilitation unit sounds better than building another prison and probably cheaper. As Dr Sharples has said, at $80,000 a year to accommodate someone in prison it would be cheaper to put them in a hotel. The unit will sound too much like a motel for many. But it would be run by a Maori committee involving local iwi or hapu. It is the sort of initiative that can enhance the autonomy and mana of many besides the inmates concerned.

Like Judith Collins, I am pragmatic on this. Will it reduce Maori reoffending, and lead to less victims of crime? If so, then worth supporting. Just like specialist units deal with sex offenders – the final stage rehabiliation before release should be targeted as there is no one cure all method of rehabilitation.

I don’t guess there will be an apology?

The Herald reported yesterday on various donations to candidates and included:

A mystery entity called Toorak Chambers also gave $3000 each to National MPs Simon Bridges, David Bennett, Todd McLay, and Lindsay Tisch.

When questioned, one of the recipients said it was linked to the National Party and referred the Herald to the party’s headquarters.

They today cleared up the mystery:

Meanwhile, the mystery of $3000 donations to several National MPs from “Toorak Chambers” has been cleared up. Toorak Chambers is an incorporated society which owns a building in Hamilton.

The “donations” were effectively a dividend from profits to the members – National’s central North Island electorate branches.

As a political party is an unincorporated society, major assets such as buildings are always vested in an incorporated society as this is a legal body corporate. So basically the “donations” are rental income. Nothing sinister at all. Toorak Chambers even has its accounts online. The constitution is also online, making it very clear it is the property arm of the CNI Region of the National Party.

Nothing wrong with the Herald reporting of Toorak Chambers. It was responsible, and once they had the full info, they published it.

No Right Turn jumped to conclusions:

National’s response to the Electoral Finance Act, or any attempt to regulate political donations, is to claim that transparency is enough. Then, in practice, they evade and undermine that transparency, using corporate fronts to shield the identity of donors. These are the actions of a dishonest, hypocritical, dirty party with something to hide.

We await the unreserved apology. I am not holding my breath.

It is 1984 in Fiji

The Herald has an example of the media censorship now occurign in Fiji. It is like they are in Orwell’s 1984:

THE REAL STATEMENT

Statement by Commissioner Louis Michel on the situation in Fiji:

Louis Michel, the European Commissioner for Development Co-operation and Humanitarian Aid, expressed deep regret and disappointment regarding recent regressive developments in Fiji; in particular the abrogation of the Constitution, the sacking of all judges, the delay of general elections until 2014 and the curtailment of freedom of speech.

Commissioner Michel said: “These developments are unacceptable for the international community. Commitments must be respected. An early and inclusive domestic political process leading to a return to constitutional order and democracy in Fiji will allow us to provide assistance to Fiji, at a time when global economic prospects are becoming increasingly difficult.”

THE CENSORED REPORT

EU ready to assist Fiji
Fiji’s largest donor the European Union has again extended a helping hand.

Louis Michel, the European Commissioner for Development Co-operation and Humanitarian Aid, today said the EU wants to assist Fiji “at a time when global economic prospects are becoming increasingly difficult”.

The EU is looking to provide substantial financial support to rescue the sugar sector and help restore the economy.

Once again it does not matter how much one does or does not agree with the Commodore’s purported aims. This sort of censorship should and must be resisted. Media and press freedom is even more important than the right to vote in my books – the right to communicate, the right to just know the truth is paramount. A Government that arrests journalists (and bloggers if it could work out who they are) for reporting the truth has no redeeming qualities.