When will the recession end?

The Herald reports:

The views of Finance Minister Bill English and Prime Minister John Key on when New Zealand will emerge from the recession are in stark contrast.

Mr English said yesterday that he thought New Zealand was “unlikely to aggressively grow out of it”.

But Mr Key says that by this time next year New Zealand would be starting to come out of it “reasonably aggressively”.

Mr Key made his comment on March 22 on TVNZ’s Q & A; Mr English made his comments on the same programme yesterday.

Asked about the difference, Mr English said Mr Key “has always had a very positive view about New Zealand. I certainly wouldn’t want to say he is wrong but he is setting a high hurdle here and it’s our job as a Government to meet those expectations – that’s a feature of John Key’s leadership.”

To some degree the differences are not surprising, as there is a calculated division of roles where the PM is more aspirational and the Finance Minister more pessimistic, as he has to try and get back to a balanced budget over time.

But having said that, it is not helpful to have those different roles expressed quite so bluntly. The Government should have some set lines that all Ministers adhere to on the recession and eventual recovery – such as always talking about a range of scenarios. Now you may have the PM focus more on the more optimistic scenario and the Finance Minister more on the more pessimistic scenario – but you want them sounding like they are talking about the same country!

Oysters galore

For the first time ever, a day out with Cactus Kate had the food costing more than the alcohol. This is rare as Cactus only drinks good quality champagne. She is easily my most expensive mate.

We decided to lunch today at Shed 5, and did our little part for helping Southland survive the recession.

As we decided what to order for our mains, oysters were ordered for entrees. Now I am not actually a huge oyster fan normally, but these ones (Bluff of course) were just divine.

So oysters were ordered for the main course also. And again so very nice. It just wasn’t enough. So when the waitress came to take our dessert order, the look on her face was superb as we ordered ice cream and oysters for dessert.

Then after dessert, you can guess what we ordered for coffee – yes more oysters. They really were that good.

Shed 5 started to worry they may run out – they told us they only had 97 dozen, and that is probably now under 90 dozen. My strong advice to anyone who likes oysters is to head to Shed 5 this week before Cactus empties their stock.

Love does blind

lydiajordan

They say loves makes you blind, and this seems to be the case with Lydia Jordan.

The private school girlfriend of convicted murderer Haiden Davis clashed furiously with the family of his victim on a Bebo memorial page this week.

Seventeen-year-old Lydia Jordan, from St Heliers in Auckland, told the grieving friends and family of Augustine Borrell that she and her jailed boyfriend were as much victims as they were.

Umm no they are not. He chose to kill someone and you chose to be his boyfriend. The Borrells did not choose to have their son killed.

Jordan was educated at the $27,000-a-year Wanganui Collegiate School and is considering beginning a law degree next semester. She met Davis while he was on bail on the murder charge.

I can understand someone standing by a current partner, who commits a horrible crime. But why on Earth would you start dating someone who is on bail for murder?

She wrote on the page: “I’ve been nothing but polite to your family and I respect your loss but does that mean that someone else should lose their life over an accident? What good is it going to do to lock Haiden up for the rest of his life. We should be rehabilitating him … Everyone’s victims in this situation.”

The main purpose is to protect others from him. And rehabilitation has not worked so well to date with him – Davis already had a dozen criminal convictions by the time of the murder. And Davis in court showed no remorse swearing as he was led away.

Jordan was unrepentant and claims the presence of Borrell’s family in the courtroom influenced the jury to find Davis guilty.

The killing was not pre-meditated, she insisted, so her boyfriend should not have been convicted of murder. “It was a split-second thing – he didn’t plan to kill anyone. He was trying to protect his friend,” she said.

“I think it was really stupid because there was no evidence for a motive and it shouldn’t have been murder. I think it was, like, the Borrell family being there that put a lot of pressure on the jury.”

Yes how dare the familt of the victim turn up to court.

Jordan said her boyfriend’s life sentence would achieve nothing: “Like, when Haiden gets out and he’s 30, he’ll have no job or anything. So do you think he’s going to turn to a life of crime? Err, yes!”

It is sad she can not see her boyfriend has been living a life of crime for the last few years. 12 convictions by the time you are 20 is a shocking number.

She told her parents only shortly before the trial that Davis was her boyfriend – to her mother’s dismay. “I think mum is very disappointed. She thinks I am getting into the wrong crowd and stuff.”

And the mum is right. I’ve seen wonderful women destroy their lives, because of the men they choose, and being unable to realise that most criminals will never change their ways.

“I have such a good life, a privileged life. I feel I owe it back to the community to help Haiden.”

There are millions of ways you can help the community. Sadly, defending the actions of Haiden Davis is unliely to be one of them.

Parole (Extended Supervision Orders) Amendment Bill

I have no problems with the substance of the Parole (Extended Supervision Orders) Amendment Bill which allows child molestors to face parole type conditions for up to ten years after their sentence.

But I share the disquiet that this law change was done with no select committee hearing, especially when the Attorney-General has said that the law change was more than just fixing a technical error.

The best analysis of this comes from Claudia Geiringer on the Vic Law School Blog:

The government argues that in doing so, the Bill is simply re-instating the status quo that existed prior to 2007. It says that an amendment to the legislation in 2007 inadvertently restricted the reach of the regime, and that this Bill reverses the position. It seems that it is on this basis that the House gave leave for the Bill to be introduced and read on the same day. (Usually, Bills must sit on the order paper for three days following introduction before they can be read.) This avoided the necessity of the government bringing a contentious motion for urgency in order to push the Bill through, though presumably it would have done so had leave of the House been refused.

It is interesting that the House (including the Greens) gave leave for this to be done.

The Greens say they gave their blessing in this case because they had been told the legislation only made a technical change. Problem is, the government’s own senior law officer – the Attorney-General – disagrees. When the Bill was introduced, the AG tabled a report under section 7 of the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act 1990 in which he concludes that the Bill is inconsistent with a number of rights and freedoms contained in the Bill of Rights – the rights against retrospective penalties and double jeopardy; and the right not to be arbitrarily detained. His particular concern is a provision that will enable the Parole Board to impose conditions similar to home detention for up to 10 years following the expiry of the sentence. The AG does not agree that this power existed prior to 2007. He thinks the Bill before the House this week brings in that power for the first time. He also says that the breach of human rights is unjustifiable because there are alternative methods by which the same result could have been achieved. The Greens now say they feel they were tricked into supporting the variation from parliamentary procedure because they weren’t told in advance about the AG’s report.

The Greens could of course have asked to see a copy of the bill in advance before agreeing to grant leave for it to go through all stages.

I also suspect there was no “trick” involved. The Justice Ministry advice presumably was that this power always existed, while Crown Law disagrees (and the Attorney-General obviously concurs with Crown Law).  It is likely the AGs opinion was only known at the last minute, and that there was no deliberate holding it back.

Regardless there is a legitimate debate about whether this is a new power, being granted. And in that case, it should go to select committee to have that debate:

But whether the interpretation is right or wrong – and I haven’t had a chance to sort that out for myself yet – is not the point. This is a process question. When the Attorney-General issues a report under section 7 of the Bill of Rights, it is a signal to the House that there is an important issue to be addressed concerning the fundamental rights and freedoms of people within our borders. In New Zealand we haven’t opted for a system of judicial supremacy so our courts can’t strike down legislation that breaches our rights. Instead, we’ve trusted to the good sense and fair mindedness of our elected representatives. Our Bill of Rights asks them to be the custodians of the Bill of Rights, and a section 7 report is one of the triggers for them to take their responsibilities seriously.

The AG’s report is not the last word on the human rights implications of legislation – it is the first word. After carefully considering the matter, Parliament may disagree with the AG. It may consider that the AG has misunderstood the law; or that the limits on rights contained in the law are reasonable in light of the extent of the problem it’s designed to address. What is often lost sight of is that the Bill of Rights does not create absolute rights – it merely warns against legislation that breaches rights in a way that is unreasonable or unjustifiable.

If the system is working properly, though, what we should not be seeing is legislation being enacted in the face of a section 7 report without MPs and the public having had a proper opportunity to scrutinise it.

I concur. Personally I am one of those who thinks the law should be supported. I think child abusers do pose a different sort of risk, and post-release supervision is appropriate. In fact rather than being continued punishment, it may help save paedophiles from their own behaviour.

But that is a debate that should be held in a considered manner.

Hat Tip: Steven Price

No more Eating Media Lunch

It looks like there will be no more Eating Media Lunch. A pity as I loved their outraegous and offensive shows. Jeremy Wells does humour so well. I still recall the masses of complaints when they showed a sheep being killed and claimed it was Shrek. And also when they asked the Lord of the Rings stars how they had found “Kiwi *****”. You can just see the stars wondering if they misheard the question.

As offensive as Eating Media Lunch was, I have found something worse. Comedy Central has a “celebrity roast” and I recorded the first one on Pamela Anderson. They roastee is there along with their exes, friends, other stars and many comedians who all take a turn at poking the borax at them. Now this is not a show for the faint hearted. The roast is brutal. 95% I could not repeat here, but as an example it was suggested that Anderson appeared in Batman as the Batcave.  I can’t believe anyone would actually agree to take part in one of these.

Coddington on spin

Deborah Coddington writes:

Despite the article’s intro, stating: “By changing the law to allow private management of prisons, we are giving ourselves a choice, writes Judith Collins”, the Minister didn’t actually write it.

When I checked with her office, a spokesperson confirmed it was written under instructions from the Minister but was essentially her article.

This must be the least surprising revelation of all times – that Ministers do not personally write articles they approve. Next we will learn they also do not write all their own press releases and speeches.  How shocking.

On Monday, the same paper’s political editor, Tracy Watkins, wrote an op-ed political essay, with her photo and byline.

I strongly suspect that if Tracy Watkins hired some underlings to write her articles for her, telling them what arguments to push, then signed off on the final copy before hitting the send button to the editor and claimed sole credit, she’d be fired. As would I, and justifiably so.

That is because Tracy is a journalist, not a Minister. Tracy’s sole job is to write stories. A Minister has around 100 other things to do like set policy, and approve spending. A Minister is not a trained journalist or writer.

But most MPs can’t write to save themselves, that’s why they rely on their staff to do it for them. So are they being honest when they claim sole credit for authorship of stuff they don’t actually write, even if it is their political philosophy?

I don’t think they do claim sole credit. Anyone who follows politics would know staff have a significant role in any written material.

I know from experience how disgustingly busy an MP’s life is, but in 2004 when this organ’s editor offered me this column, his facial expression said, don’t flatter yourself.

I was chosen, he said, because I was the only MP he could trust to write my own material.

Because Deborah is a trained journalist with 20 years experience.

Someone else does the brush strokes, chooses the colours, the MP signs the painting, all hell breaks loose. Someone else writes the sentences, chooses the adjectives and verbs, the MP signs the article.

What’s the difference?

Massive. It’s like not knowing the difference between cheating in an exam, and having someone help you with your homework.

Q&A Tomorrow

Hilarious hypocrisy

A new low for stupidity

Stuff reports:

Police in Maine, USA, say seven teens and young adults have been arrested after a video was posted on YouTube that showed them setting off Molotov cocktails inside a vacated building and then rolled credits naming those involved. …

Police say the video, which has since been taken off the video-sharing website, showed the faces of the suspects as well as text naming those pictured. Each is charged with arson and burglary.

They should get extra jail time just for the stupidity.

Thank you to the Greens

I’m delighted the Greens are launching a major campaign to bring back the food police into schools.

This will remind everyone of the growth of nanny state over the last nine years.

And even better, what lies in wait if a centre-left Government is elected in future. With NZ First dead and United Future down to one MP, it will be almost impossible for Labour to form a Government without the Greens.

I hope the Greens do not stop at school tuck shops. They should get really ambitious and propose the food police be given these additional powers:

  • Dawn raids of homes at breakfast times to check breakfasts are healthy and nutritious
  • Flying Squads to swoop on major supermarkets to make sure all unhealthy food is placed on the top aisle so no one below 5’6″ can reach it
  • Random audits of teenagers in public places to check their diet

Press on Worth

The Press Editorial:

The allegation against Worth was that, during his private business trip, he had encouraged Indian student pilots to train in New Zealand. His problem was that at the time he was a director of New Zealand Aviation, which has links to an Invercargill air training academy.

Labour seized on this as a conflict of interest and also said that he was referred to as a Government minister when he was in India, despite saying that his trip was private. After the allegations emerged, Worth did resign from NZ Aviation, after being told to do so by Key, but his initial decision not to do so after becoming a minister was naive in the extreme. By contrast, Cabinet member Tim Groser did take the advice of officials and resigned from the same company after he was made Minister of Trade and before a portfolio-related trip to India.

After years in Opposition all National’s new ministers, many of whom will have had business links before entering government, might have been expected to err on the side of caution when it came to conflicts of interest. They should have been well aware that even the perception of a conflict can be politically damaging to themselves and their party.

Indeed.  Once you are a Minister you should rid yourself of all your other interests, if possible. And those you can not should be passive or through a blind trust etc.

The attacks on Worth should also send a salutary message to all his ministerial colleagues that, although the new Government has enjoyed a political honeymoon, they must always remember that Labour will be targeting their weakest links and will ruthlessly exploit any real or perceived conflicts of interest. And if further conflicts do occur, it seems likely that Key will do more than just give the culprit a bollocking.

I think it is a very safe bet the next episode will have unfortunate consequences for the Minister.

Fitzsimons advice to Clark

The Herald Political Diary notes:

Just about all parties suspend politics for half an hour to honour Helen Clark for her appointment as United Nations Development Programme Administrator. She is given a standing ovation after John Key’s truly magnanimous speech and every leader’s speech is applauded as well – except that of Greens’ co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons who is not even applauded by her own MPs. In a piece of misjudgment, Fitzsimons lectures Clark on how she should do her job, concluding: “What we wish most for you is that in endless rounds of cocktail parties, travel, high-level meetings and negotiations to which you are no stranger, the most desperate people who rely on UNPD programmes to eat, to be housed, and healthy and educated are always top of your mind.” Does she really think cocktail parties are more important to Clark than the poorest and weakest?

No wonder Helen never let the Greens into Government, if this is how sanctimonious they get. The full lecturing speech is here.

Trevett on Maori Party

Claire Trevett looks as the Ministerial delegations for the Maori Party:

The announcement of the delegated responsibilities was barely noticed at the time. But for the Maori Party, it delivered the mana it was waiting for.

The full list of delegations is here. There hasn’t been a great deal of analysis of it, to date.

The list is extensive and, critically, delivers distinct areas of responsibility and funding in social policy that affect the lives of Maori people.

Among them, Tariana Turia has taken on responsibility for Maori and Pacific employment as well as the Government’s overall strategy on family violence.

In health, her focus includes provider development. But wider responsibilities include sexual health, diabetes, tobacco, communicable diseases and breast and cervical screening.

Pita Sharples is expected to find ways to address Maori over-representation in crime, as well as more effective rehabilitation of Maori offenders. In an area dear to his heart, he gets responsibilities for Maori education such as kohanga reo and kura kaupapa.

In some ways these areas are more significant than their main ministerial portfolios of Maori Affairs for Pita Sharples and the Community and Voluntary sector for Tariana Turia.

Indeed.

The challenge for the Maori Party is to deliver in areas it has long accused others of failing in.

The expectation they must perform in these areas is crystal clear. To Mrs Turia falls the task not only of “addressing” family violence but of “reducing the impact” of it.

Mr Key puts a premium on performance – and his support parties are not exempt.

He will also expect Maori ministers to toe the same line of accountability for how public money is spent, and Mrs Turia has already begun the process of measuring the effectiveness of each dollar.

By giving the Maori Party exactly what was asked for, Mr Key has put his faith in them to deliver on it.

The column is a very good read abotu some of the challenges ahead.

Stuff Blogs

Dear Stuff,

I used to enjoy reading your blogs. Then you deleted all the RSS feeds for them. Now I have no way of knowing easily when they have been updated.

Please can you give them all their own RSS feeds back.

UPDATE: It seems they are there but you have to go looking for them, rather than automatically suvscriing from their main pages

Thorndon New World

TVNZ had a story last night, featuring my local supermarket – Thorndon New World.

A Wellington supermarket is under fire for ordering workers to only speak English.

The Thorndon New World has told staff they may get a warning if they break the rule and a notice to staff posted on the supervisor’s kiosk spells out the English language policy. …

The notice says foreign languages make customers and staff uncomfortable.

One interesting aspect to this, not reported on by TVNZ, is that the local manager of the Thorndon New World is himself Asian. Now this is off memory and may be wrong now, but that makes it an interesting issue even more.

Personally I have no problems with people speaking other languages between themselves. In fact one of the things I like about London is how you hear dozens of different languages on the tube.

But is there a difference when you are working in a retail environment? Customers can get upset if they do not understand what staff are saying to each other – they may even be talking about the customer. As I said, personally I don’t give a stuff, but what is as a shop owner it is generating negative feedback?

I don’t think there is any question that in staffrooms, or if workplaces where you are away from the public, there should be no restrictions on language. But should an employer be able to insist on English if staff are talking within earshot of customers?

Personally I think Thordon New World over-reacted by putting notices up and threatening warnings. That is over the top and potentially illegal. If I was them, I would have just spoken to staff and told them to be mindful that any private conversations do not come across to customers as rude.

A Public Defenders Office?

Simon Power is reviewing legal aid:

Power said yesterday that he hoped a review of legal aid, to be undertaken by Dame Margaret Bazley, would consider the possibility of creating a public defenders office in New Zealand that could handle at least lower-level criminal cases.

Under such a system, lawyers working for the Crown would defend low-income earners or those who could not afford to pay for their own defence.

New Zealand has a Crown prosecutors office, but no such system for defendants. Public defenders are used in many countries, including the United States and Australia.

The Labour government introduced a trial public defenders office at the Manukau District Court last year, which was considered successful. The pilot programme has been extended for another year.

I’m all in favour.

It was unlikely the Government would scrap private legal aid entirely, with payments direct to lawyers still the most likely option for complex cases or murder charges where a Queen’s Counsel could be required.

Power said that while the review was not about cost-cutting, some lawyers were “gaming” the current system with unnecessary appeals and court appearances.

Labour deputy leader Annette King said the party would support a public defenders office.

Great. Make it happen!

Greens propose race based justice system

The Greens are proposing a race based justice system, as their solution to crime.

“Because Maori are more likely to be stopped and searched, arrested rather than cautioned, and receive higher sentences than Pakeha offenders, Maori crime and imprisonment rates are elevated,” Mrs Turei said today.

This is a cunning plan. They will cut the crime rate in half overnight by stopping Police from being able to search, arrest or imprison criminals who happen to be Maori.

“The establishment of a Maori justice system that runs alongside the existing legal system – using the education system as a model – will help to eliminate the impact of this systemic racial profiling, reduce the unjust imprisonment of many Maori and stem Maori reoffending.”

Why have a seperate justice system for Maori only? How about Asians? How about South Africans? Also can people choose which justice system they go on? If you are part Asian and part Maori, can you use just one system, or pick and mix the parts that most suit you as a criminal. I think giving choice of justice systems to criminals is very important.

Hooton on Joyce

By coincidence Matthew Hooton’s column in NBR today (print edition only) is also focused on the successful Steven Joyce. I’ve stolen a couple of paragraphs to blog here:

Steven Joyce first became prominent when he helped pick up the pieces after National’s 2002 disaster but was not embroiled in any of the infighting that followed. Many, including me, doubted the wisdom of his appointment to Cabinet before he had even been sworn in as an MP, but Mr Joyce has met Mr Key’s expectations and exceeded those of everyone else.

In Mr Joyce, Mr Key has entrusted his personal priorities of sorting out New Zealand’s shocking transport and IT&T infrastructure, and he is deeply involved in decisions about Auckland governance.

Associate to Bill English in Finance and Infrastructure, it is to Mr Joyce that the prime minister will turn when the government hits a major crisis.

Key and Joyce have a number of similiarities – in that they both have 20 years or more of commercial experience, and both very sucessful when in business.

Web browsing makes you more productive

Stuff reports:

Workers who surf the web online can relax – employees who regularly sneak a peek at Facebook or shop online during office hours could actually be more productive.

Melbourne University’s Dr Brent Coker says workers who surf the internet for leisure, known as ‘Workplace Internet Leisure Browsing’ (WILB), are more productive than those who don’t.

A study of 300 employees found 70 per cent of people who used the internet at work engaged in WILB.

“People who do surf the internet for fun at work – within a reasonable limit of less than 20 per cent of their total time in the office – are more productive by about nine per cent than those who don’t,” said Dr Coker, from the university’s Department of Management and Marketing.

If this is correct, then Kiwiblog is doing its part for increasing workplace productivity!

Cork Count Result

Somewhat overdue, but we have the results of the annual cork count.

corkcount20092

The middle jar was the one to be guessed. the left hand one had 512 closures (272 corks/240 stelvins) and the right hand one 496 closures (388 corks and 108 stelvins).

corkcount2009

And despite appearances, the numbers were up. 517 closures made up of 122 corks and 395 stelvins.

The closest guesser online was Andrew W at 524.

Can we make 550 this year or will the recession bite?

Get your own guide god

Stuff reports:

A puppy called Halo did official duty today as Prime Minister John Key helped support the annual Red Puppy Appeal.

The Royal New Zealand Foundation of the Blind appeal aims to raise a $1 million a year for guide gods – a service not supported by the state.

Well as a secular state, one would expect the state not not provide any guide gods.

If one can get a choice of guide gods, I’d quite like a Sif.

Fight crime at birth says Tamihere

The Herald reports:

West Auckland’s Waipareira Trust wants access to hospital maternity wards to start tackling the “drivers of crime” from birth.

The trust’s chief executive, John Tamihere, plans to use a summit meeting on the drivers of crime at Parliament today to propose a radical devolution of welfare funding to community groups.

He wants to be funded to cut youth offending in Waitakere by 5 or 10 per cent by target dates, rather than to work with young offenders only after they have committed crimes.

Sounds good to me.

Mr Tamihere said the current response to crime was ineffective.

“The problem is that there are 173 groups in Waitakere City putting their hands up for youth-related matters. Furthermore, all their services run nine-to-five, not from 10pm to 6am when all the shit happens.

“We are going to roll out a service in the next three months looking at that, and we have 85 Maori wardens and we’ll start to come together.”

He said the trust was “negotiating access to the maternity wards” to start working with problem families from birth.

Those first few years are critical in determining if someone is likely to have a life of crime or a life of work.

A mixed week for National

I call it a mixed week for National in my NBR online column. My calls:

  • Best Play of the Week: Steven Joyce gets an A for the fibre to the home policy
  • Worst Play of the Week: Nick Smith get a D for the PM reading about a possible plastic bag tax in the newspaper
  • Scandal of the Week: Labour get a B for the Richard Worth Indian trip scandal.

Feedback and comments can be made at NBR.