Ralston not a rightie

Bill Ralston blogs:

Trotter takes the view that The Listener has rushed out and deliberately “retained a stable of journalists and columnists whose published material places them firmly on the right of the political spectrum”. He fingers as the key culprits writers Jane Clifton, Joanne Black, David Young, myself and Deborah Hill-Cone.

He notes:

The sad fact is when it comes to the political spectrum I tend to sit somewhere in the wishy washy liberal middle.

I’ve never voted National or Act and throw up at the thought of going Green or, worse, Progressive – so I suspect you can guess where my ballot has usually been cast.

So Bill has never ever voted National (or ACT) yet because he dares to sometimes criticise the current Government, people assume he must be a right winger.

This time I might consider National, mainly because I get that “time for a change” feeling and the Nats really are “Labour-lite” – Labour minus the hand-wringing political correctness that annoys the hell out of me.

I don’t know. Like many New Zealanders, I haven’t made my mind up yet.

Clark is certainly the most effective Prime Minister we’ve had in my lifetime, although she and her government appear to have run out of ideas and now cling to power for the sake of being there.

It’s a government that got sidetracked. Because so many in cabinet are academics or teachers the emphasis went on to process rather than delivery. Huge amounts of money have been thrown at social policy areas to little real effect other than stimulating a huge growth in bureaucracy and providing policy analysts with a mother-load of work.

I also think the government let blind ideology get in the way and it should have bought in tax cuts three years ago.

Does that sound right wing? Maybe.

I am not sure voting National once in thirty years qualifies as right wing, let alone membership of the Vast Right Wing Conspiracy.

In identifying a rabid right wing conspiracy in the media Chris is just following the government’s paranoid lead. The fiercely tribal Left are collectivist in nature, it tolerates no deviation, no independent thought and demands all toe the party line at all times.

Sounds like the Borg!

Chris Trotter and the Ninth Floor need to remember it is the media’s job to be critical, look for fault and expose government blunders. That’s our job.

I can proudly say I have infuriated every Prime Minister from Sir Robert Muldoon through to Helen Clark. I’ll put money on it that, if he takes power in November, I will have thoroughly annoyed John Key by Christmas. That’s not very right wing, is it?

I suspect Bill will prove himself right!

Anyway, I have to go now and polish the portrait of Sir Roger Douglas that hangs over the fireplace and get ready for tonight’s meeting of the cabal.

Welcome to the dark side Bill!

Owen Glenn on Campbell Live

Google 10 years old

The Herald calls Google the world’s most powerful 10 year old.

It brings back memories of AltaVista, the former number one search engine. It was amazing how quickly Google replaced it as the search engine of choice.

Google is powerful but not quite all conquering. When they launched Google Video, I thought that would dominate the online video market as they had the brand and resources of Google.

But You Tube kicked their butt, because they had a superior product. The “embed” function especially turned every blog into a gateway for You Tube and they gained massive market share over Google Video.

Of course Google then went and purchased You Tube. But it still shows that product is still more important than brand, and that Google’s dominance can not be assumed to last forever.

But having said that, I am a regular user of:

  1. Google Search
  2. Google News
  3. Google News Alerts
  4. Google Adsense
  5. Google Analytics
  6. Google Maps
  7. Google Images
  8. Google Toolbar
  9. Google Calendar
  10. Google Docs
  11. Gmail
  12. Google Talk
  13. You Tube

I have also played with Google Chrome and check out Google Groups very occassionally. So it is hard to see an Internet without a dominant Google anytime soon.

Wikipedia editing

The NZ Herald has a story on edits done to Wikipedia by Aaron Bhatnagar, highlighted a few days ago by Russell Brown.

Auckland City councillor Aaron Bhatnagar has been caught doctoring the online encyclopedia Wikipedia to paint his opponents in a bad light at last year’s local body elections.

Using the alias of Barzini _ a power-hungry psychopath from Mario Puzo’s novel The Godfather _ Mr Bhatnagar created entries for his Action Hobson opponents in the Hobson ward and made unflattering changes to the entry for Mayor Dick Hubbard.

After winning a council seat and watching Action Hobson councillors Christine Caughey and Richard Simpson go down to a C&R rout in Hobson, Mr Bhatnagar tried to remove the Wikipedia entries for his opponents at 3am the following morning.

An unrepentant Mr Bhatnagar yesterday admitted setting up and editing entries against his opponents on Wikipedia, but claimed everything he said was true, such as broken promises on rates. He said Wikipedia was self-regulating and a community where everyone could have a say. There were mechanisms to delete or rewrite entries. …

Mr Brown yesterday said anyone could edit an entry in Wikipedia, but the main barrier was ethical. There was a Wikipedia rule that stated it should not be used as a soapbox. “I think his behaviour is incredibly inappropriate. It was really the wrong thing to do,” Mr Brown said.

I agree that the editing was inappropriate. It wasn’t vandalism (this is vandalism), but it is inadvisable to make questionable changes to topics you have a vested interest in.

This isn’t an absolute. I’ve made some changes to articles on National and the 2005 funding controversy. But when they are political topics, I try and be extra careful that the edits are neutral point of view. Also I try to avoid edit wars by sometimes using the Talk page on a topic to propose a change. For example the debate over whether Adam Hamilton or George Forbes was the first Leader of the National Party (I say Hamilton, not Forbes).

UPDATE: A commenter has pointed to some Wiki vandalism done by IP address 122.57.62.181 and 125.239.124.113, where the author signed a comment on a talk page as philu. The Phil U who posts here has told me it was not him, he has never edited Wikipedia. He has also never commented here from those IP address which are on the Telecom network, and Phil is on Woosh. So I take his word it was not him, and the person who did the edits either signed his name falsely or maybe has the same first name and initial.

And don’t forget the Spencer Trust

The Herald reminds us:

Mr Peters said he was aware in May that the party had sought “legal advice” before deciding not to declare the $80,000 donation from the trust.

“I said you must go ahead on the legal advice that you’ve got, this is not a matter for the party parliamentary organisation, it is a matter for the organisation itself, and that is what happened,” Mr Peters told Radio New Zealand yesterday.

This is the same organisation whose President, Secretary and Treasurer have never heard of the Spencer Trust?

Despite being asked, Mr Peters has never said when he became aware of the Spencer Trust. On July 29, he told a press conference that he had no knowledge of what the trust was used for.

The Herald has learned from informed sources that Mr Peters knew about the trust, how much money was kept in it at certain times, and that he directed staff to get it to pay party expenses.

So Winston says it was a matter for the organisation, and he had no knowledge of what the trust was used for. No knowledge that is, except what its bank balance was and what bills to get it to pay.

The “someone stole Winston’s cellphone” suggestion

Reading the NZ Herald this morning, it strikes me how ludicrous Labour’s attempted defence of Winston was:

Yesterday Labour MP Russell Fairbrother, a member of the committee, suggested Mr Glenn may have confused Winston Peters’ with his youngest brother Wayne in a vital phone call about the donation.

Wayne Peters laughed out loud when told of the suggestion.

Wayne Peters had the right reaction. Poor Owen – first Labour MPs suggest he can’t tell Winston apart from Sir Howard Morrison, and then they suggest he can’t tell Winston apart from Wayne Peters on the phone.

Mr Fairbrother said he had no evidence to believe it was Wayne Peters, but had asked Mr Glenn “to test his evidence”.

Of course he had no evidence. It was a desperate attempt to find a way to clear Peters. This was not an off the cuff comment made once. Glenn was asked at length by Fairbrother and Cullen about whether Peters identified himself, what did Glenn mean by a first person conversation etc etc.

After the breakfast he called Mr Peters on his cellphone – he produced the phone record yesterday – to say yes to the donation and spoke to him for more than six minutes. The call finished about 1.32 NZ time.

About eight minutes later, Mr Glenn received an email from Mr Henry saying “further to your discussion with my client at 1.30 NZ time I provide my bank details … “

Tonight Winston will explain how one of his staff members answered his mobile phone for him, impersonated Winston, negotiated the donation upwards from $70,000 to $100,000, immediately phoned or e-mailed Brian Henry to tell him about the donation, and then totally forgot to mention it to Winston.

Mr Glenn’s evidence about consulting Mr Williams contradicts Mr Williams’ claim that the first he knew of a donation was on July 12 – when the Herald published emails from Mr Glenn to PR man Steve Fisher confirming he had given a donation.

It is now apparent that Mike WIlliams, and in all probability Helen Clark, not just knew about the donation in 2005, but actually approved it. Owen Glenn was adamant on this point that he would not have donated without Labour’s okay.

This makes you wonder about who in Labour authorised the $250,000 offer to the Maori Party, in exchange for them agreeing to support Labour?

Mr Williams said last night his recollection was that they had discussed the likely outcome of Mr Peters’ electoral petition.

“I have no recollection of being asked or offering any comment on whether or not Mr Glenn should provide financial assistance to Mr Peters and I certainly did not discuss that possibility with anyone else.”

If people are having trouble working out who to believe, I suggest they re-read this post and this post regarding his performance on Agenda this year. Nine lies confusions in one interview. Plus the confusion he had over whether Owen Glenn had donated to the party since 2005. And the confusion last election over the pledge card when they told the Chief Electoral Office they would include it as an election expense and then recanted.

The short version

What happened today is very simple.

  1. Owen Glenn proved that he made a phone call to Winston Peters at 1.26 pm NZST on 14 December 2005. The call ended at 1.33 pm.
  2. At 1.40 pm on the same day – just seven minutes later – Brian Henry sent Owen Glenn the details of the bank account the $100,000 was paid into.
  3. A Paul Moroney swore an affidavit that Winston Peters and Owen Glenn did meet at Karaka in January 2006, that Owen Glenn told him of the donation to Peters, and that Peters thanked Owen Glenn for his help. Incidentially Paul Moroney is the brother of Labour MP Sue Moroney.

Anyone who thinks that somehow Winston Peters was not aware of the donation is not just naive or misguided, but fundamentally dishonest. The attempts by Labour to suggest that someone else may have answered Winston’s mobile phone, pretended to be Winston, arranged the $100,000 donation, passed the details onto Brian Henry – all without telling Winston – are so far fetched that journalists were having trouble not laughing out loud.

The big new information that got revealed is that Owen Glenn met with Mike Williams the day of the donation, sought his approval for the donation and is adamant he would not have made the donation without permission from Williams. It is almost inconceivable that Williams would not discuss such an issue with Helen Clark. We already knew she knew about the donation in February 2008 – she may in fact have known as early as December 2005. It will be impossible to prove what Williams told Clark, but regardless we do know that Mike Williams knew all about this from day one.

Whale Oil has the affidavits online.

The true sign Russia is heading back to the dark side

The Glenn hearing

We are all queued outside waiting to be allowed in. Huge amount of media here. No sign of Glenn yet.

Glenn has arrived and we are now in the room.

Glenn has just named Williams as having agreed helping Peters would help Labour.

Also tabled an affidavit from a witness to Peters thanking Glenn.

Glenn has confirmed again he would not have donated without having the ok from Mike Williams.

There is also a phone record showing a call to or from peters office phone around the time of the donation.

My God how desperate. Russell Fairbrother is suggesting he was accidentally talking to Wayne Peters who had borrowed Winston’s cellphone and sounds like him!!

Glenn says that Mike Williams was going to clear his donation with colleagues. It is unthinkable that would not include Helen. So she may have known since 2005.

Glenn says he likes Winston who is a great character. This is about telling truth.

Cullen also pushing the notion that someone else answered Winston’s cellphone and pretended to be him.

Has just said Peters is very skilled at asking for donations. Remember Peters says he nevers solicits donations.

On Radio NZ later today

National Radio is going to have me on at around 4.40 pm today (during Jim Mora’s panel) to report on impressions from the Privileges Committee hearing with Owen Glenn. It might be earlier if things wrap up earlier.

I doubt I can update from the hearing (which is a pity) so NZ Herald and Stuff are probably best places to look for reports.

The hearing may be not very exciting. Winston is not appearing. Owen Glenn will repeat what he has said in his earlier statements. He may not have documents to prove it, because receiving a phone call by its nature tends not to be documented, and it did happen three years ago. What will be interesting is whether the Labour MPs aggressively go after Owen Glenn and try and discredit their largest donor in order to protect Winston.

Williams was on Owen’s boat

Just had confirmed from a second source indirectly that Mike Williams was on Owen Glenn’s boat – not months ago but only a few weeks ago. Williams has confirmed this it seems.

The story is he was visiting donors in London (imagine the fuss if National’s President flew overseas to solicit funds) and decided to pop on over to see Owen.

I wonder what interesting topics they may have talked about!

Student election winner disqualified

The Otago Daily Times has a story on how Jo Moore has been disqualified, after winning the OUSA 2009 Presidential election.

Moore won in mid August, with a 122 vote margin over her closest rival.

The Scene has details of the complaints – she had a keg party the day before voting closed, and around 15 people voted at the keg party on a couple of laptops there. The rules say a candidate can not be within 20 metres of a polling booth, and it seems this now includes laptops!

This is not the first time an incumbent executive has disqualified a sucessful Presidential candidate. VUWSA did the same a few years ago. There is no natural justice process involved – and in the case of Moore she does not get a re-election – the losing candidate is now declared the winner – very different to electoral law where a sucessful candidate who breaks the rules triggers a by-election not an automatic victory to the loser.

Miss Moore said she understood a complaint that she had been within 20m of a polling facility during voting had been upheld, and it had also been suggested she had overspent the $1000 limit for election campaigning.

She disputed the findings and said she had receipts for all her election spending.

The latest appeals process had breached the principles of natural justice because she had not been advised about it and had been given no chance to provide any evidence on her own behalf, she said.

A lot of people do not realise there is no requirement for a compulsory student association to act democratically. In fact OUSA once abolished presidential elections, and replaced the President with a King. It was a joke – but a totally legal joke that lasted around six weeks.

It is almost irresponsible of Pariament to have given powers of compulsory membership to student associations but no obligations to be democratic or accountable.

General Debate 9 September 2008

For any discussion. I am going to try and get a seat at the Privileges Committee hearing this afternoon, but may not be able to as I suspect the visitor seating will be very full. If I do, I’ll try and do an update once it finishes, but it might not be until just before six.

Silly Gordon

There are only 11 questions in the House today. Why? Because Gordon Copeland forgot or failed to submit his question.

He only gets to ask a primary around once every month, so this was probably his last question before the election. Almost as bad as missing the vote on the anti-smacking bill!

Old Bollock Road

The Dominion Post reports on the blooper that saw Old Bullock Road given a road sign that said Old Bollock Road.

It was also on One News last night. A journalist has e-mailed me suggesting that it was an extremely mischievous news editor who decided to assign the story to Heather du Plessis-Allan 🙂

The Wellington City Council has said they are going to take special care not to make mistakes with the folowing streets – Dorking Road, Volga Street, Wanaka Street and Virginia Grove!

Christian the Lion

Saw this on Stuff, about a lion released into the wild in Africa and what happened when the two men who used to look after him as a cub sought him out. It all happened 40 years ago but is going to be turned into a film.

Damn amazing.

A third policy released by Trevor

This is getting rather untidy for National. Trevor Mallard has released a third policy on behalf of National. Luckily for National all three – Environment, Conservation and Research Science & Technology have been pretty low key, but it is not at all a good look.

While one can’t know for sure, how Trevor got hold of the policies, his fanciful suggestions of an anti-Key faction in Caucus leaking to him are more a wet dream, than reality. And even if there was such a faction, they would never ever leak to Trevor – they would leak to journalists. Almost every National MP (and staffer) would rather cut off their left testicle/breast than leak to Trevor.

It is likely that all the policies were together and either left somewhere or maybe accidentally e-mail to a wrong recipient. This happens more often than you might think. It could be that some third party got hold of them accidentally and is feeding them to Mallard.

There is the possibility it is somone acting maliciously – for example someone with system administrative privileges to Parliamentary Service servers. I’m not saying it is, just that is one of a number of possibilities.

But regardless a nuisance and distraction National could do without.

The Dom Post’s front page

Great to see the Dominion Post put Paula Tesoriero on the front page for her Paralympic Gold Medal and World Record.

Only Paula can be focused enough to win the gold medal and spastic enough (I say that in a loving way) to crash on her victory lap and land on her chin! That’s our Paula!

This was Paula’s “best” event but she is also competing in the 3000m tomorrow and 25 km race later in the week.

Fans and friends of Paula might like to vote for her at TVNZ’s Outlander page. The Paralympian with the most votes wins a Mitsubishi Outlander. You also go into a draw to win an Outlander, by voting.

Telethon returns

Yay, TV3 is bring back the Telethon. Those who did not live in the Telethon era can’t imagine how big these were – almost all of NZ got involved. I suspect today they will not be so big, as we are all busier, but good on TV3 for giving up 22 hours of broadcast time to help KidsCan.

NZ Herald on electoral finance

The NZ Herald editorial addresses electoral finance issues:

The last rites on the Electoral Finance Act were read last week when the head of the Electoral Commission, the body charged with enforcing it, declared the law was having a “chilling effect” on public participation in the imminent election. The next day Justice Minister Annette King announced the review.

And Annette King still refuses to discuss how the law of common sense became the law of chilling effects.

The review is plainly designed simply to give the Government’s election campaign a response to the inevitable criticism it will incur for the Electoral Finance Act. It will say it always envisaged a post-election review to iron out problems with the new law, but when the legislation was passed in December it promised to appoint a review panel early this year. Had it done so, the exercise might have been credible. It is rather late now.

Yes why does it take nine months to appoint a panel? I think the Herald is right in labelling it a campaign stunt.

National, if it forms the next government, will have to replace the Electoral Finance Act with something better than the opaque rules that preceded the act. It ought to hold an all-party conference to draw up questions of political finance to be put to an independent commission.

I would hope there are public discussion papers, and open seminars on the issues. A National-led Government should consult with all parties on electoral law proposals, to try and repair the damage Labour has done to our constitutional conventions aound the Electoral Act.

It ought to be wary of political academics who are inclined to believe that the public purse should fund everything to do with elections.

Taxpayers already finance most of the activities of parties in Parliament, giving them too much advantage over those not already in the House.

I agree. One way to even the odds might be to redirect the broadcasting allocation away from the parliamentary parties, so that only parties without existing MPs are eligible to receive taxpayer funds for their broadcasting. The parties in Parliament have the huge benefit of three years of free publicity through their MPs but over $10 million a year of funding for their parliamentary parties.

It is healthy to have new parties break into Parliament (something only ACT has managed to date without the benefit of an existing MP). So giving each non parliamentary party $100,000 to $150,000 would help them have a decent chance against the existing parliamentary parties.

The costs of ETS

Brian Fallow looks at the costs of an ETS. It all depends on the price of carbon. Treasury is budgeting $23 a tonne, but a last minute change to the scheme has pushed this up to a likely $50 per tonne, and by 2020 it is predicted the cost will be $70 a tonne. For now we will go with $50 a tonne.

  • Inflation to increase by around 0.7% per year for the next two years
  • Retail electricity prices to increase by 20%
  • Petrol prices to increase by 12c/litre
  • Reduce payout to dairy farmers by 50c/kilo (once agriculture fully in the scheme) or 6%

As Fallow notes:

It would be a perverse outcome for the global climate if growth of the pastoral farming sector in New Zealand were hobbled by climate change policy here, only for the demand for dairy products and meat it might have satisfied to be met instead by production elsewhere in the world whose carbon hoof-print (emissions per litre of milk or kilogram of meat) is greater.

So the ETS exempts livestock emissions altogether until 2013 and taxpayers will continue to pick up the great majority of the bill (up to 90 per cent) until at least 2019.

Agriculture is not the only sector where the NZ ETS may simply lead to production transferring off shore, which will result in even worst environmental outcomes, and a drop in income for New Zealand.

Lie #9,087,425

From the NZ Herald:

Mr Peters did not return calls last night. Despite being asked, he has never said when he became aware of the trust. On July 29 he told a press conference that he had no knowledge of what the trust was used for.

So he said he had no knowledge of what the trust was used for.

The Herald has learned Mr Peters was aware of how much money was kept in the trust at certain times, and that he directed staff to get it to pay party expenses from 2005 onwards.

This is no surprise.

But the trust’s existence was kept so secret it paid over $100,000 in bills that senior party officials did not even know they had.

The Spencer Trust’s bill payments for the party included $87,648 in 2006 – but the party’s president, secretary and treasurer from that time yesterday said they had no idea the bills even existed, yet alone that they were paid.

The Deputy Leader is also on the record as saying he had never heard of The Spencer Trust. So that doesn’t make it hard to conclude who did. Meanwhile Helen says that Winston should not be held liable for the mistake of the staff in the party head office. First of all the party head office is his Ministerial bauble suite, and secondly no Officer except Peters even knew about it.

Glenn sounds prepared

The Herald reports:

The billionaire said he had brought two staff members with him and they would be at the hearing today. He would make a statement to the committee and then be available to be questioned.

Mr Glenn said he had brought some corroborative evidence – “such as we can looking back over three years, as much as we could establish”.

The hearing will start after question time, so probably around 3.30 p.m.

It will be interesting to see what happens on iPredict today.

PM Labour sold at 1.20 this morning for 26.89c. Now if Owen Glenn says that Helen Clark asked him to donate to Peters (I am using this as an example not saying it happened) then that price will probably drop significantly.

MP Peters is the one most likely to move. These shares will pay $1 each if Peters is back in Parliament, either on the list or through winning an electorate. It sold yesterday for 33.92c. If Glenn nails Peters, then I also expect that price to drop.

Remember anyone aged over 18 can buy and sell shares. I’ve just purcchased some PM National shares at 75.03c. You can also do buys and sells in advance at set prices, so the deal will happen once someone is willing to meet your price.

Paula wins gold!!!

Woo hoo. Paula Tesoriero has just won the gold medal in the 500m time trial at the Beijing Paralympics.

She also set a world record with her time of 43.281 seconds.

This is a huge achievement, especially when you consider where the power has to come from for Paula:

Paula Tesoriero has disabilities in both her legs – an artifical left leg as she is missing part of that leg and no ankle on her right leg. She uses a carbon leg while competing and relies on her thighs to power the bike.

You won’t beleive how many legs she has broken in training!!

Well done Paula (and hubby Chris). Really inspiring. I’ve known Paula since she was 18 and she’s always been amazing, but considering she only took up serious cycling a few years ago, the results are extraordinary.

NZ First have until 30 September to file new returns

The Electoral Commission has given NZ First until 30 September 2008 to file new audited returns for 2005, 2006 and 2007 and explain why the ones they filed are incorrect.  Then they will decide what to do. The Police have announced regardless they are investigating the complaint over their 2007 return.

If I was the NZ First Auditor, I would be very very nervous about signing off any new return unless they get a personal undertaking in writing from the Leader and the President that all relevant financial records have been supplied.