Kiwblog on Facebook

Herald on 90 day trials

The NZ Herald likes the 90 day trial period for small businesses:

The Government and the trade union movement do not see it that way. Labour Minister Trevor Mallard described it as “almost a charter for people to abuse newly appointed low-wage workers”. Such an interpretation betrays either a misunderstanding or an extremely cynical view of the aims and intentions of most employers. Why would they use it to sack employees without good reason when good staff are hard to find and much time and effort is put into training them?

Read the Hollow Men and Horowitz to understand why Mallard says this.

A more rational take on the proposed law is that it will encourage employers to give people a chance to show they can do a job. Most advantaged by this will be those who employers might otherwise be reluctant to recruit – the likes of new immigrants without good English, former prisoners, those wishing to change careers, young people without qualifications, and those with no recent work experience. National’s proposal would allow employers to take a chance knowing there will not be the prospect of complex and costly personal grievance procedures if there is a genuine problem.

Yep. With the best will in the world you sometimes just can not determine how someone will work out, until they are in the job.

This freedom has long been sought by small businesses. It was pinpointed as the “single most important change needed in employment law” by the Small Business Advisory Group, which was set up by the Government in 2003. The group identified employers’ fear of hiring new workers as a significant obstacle to business growth.

And business growth leads to more jobs, more tax, more wealth for New Zealand.

When National’s member’s bill was before Parliament two years ago, trade unions staged public demonstrations, terming it an intolerable attack on workers’ rights. In fact, New Zealand is the only OECD nation, apart from Denmark, that does not have a legal probationary period in some shape or form. Other countries have recognised the advantages to both parties.

This is hardly some hard right policy. All the leftie social democratic countries in Europe already have this in their law.

Union vs Union

A scrap between medical unions:

Ian Powell, executive director of the senior doctors union, defended the “inalienable right to strike” in a weekend speech. But he said it was being misused, and therefore undermined – to the detriment of patients’ safety – by unions clustered around Deborah and Terry Powell’s company, Contract Negotiation Services (CNS).

Ian Powell is certainly not the first person to note the effect of Deborah Powell on the health system – her unions do tend to strike without fail.

Ian Powell characterises the CNS unions as “bargaining agents”, in contrast to the “broader-based unionism” of his own organisation.

He told a dental conference on Saturday that bargaining agents focused on what they could “scratch out” of the health system, while unions like his also focused on what they could put into it.

“Regardless of motivation, seeing patients as weapons is an inevitable consequence of a bargaining-agent approach, whereas the broader unionism approach sees them as natural allies.”

Not unfair criticisms.

Deborah Powell accused Ian Powell of hypocrisy, saying his own union had come close to strike action.

“I suspect his motivation is to support the Labour Government, as the CTU unions seek to do.”

Also not unfair criticisms back.

I actually don’t like it when unions fight each other as it is just like the Iran-Iraq war – never knowing what side to back 🙂

Working for Families

It is disappointing but not totally surprising that National is not making changes to Working for Families in its first term.

There are two aspects to Working for Families which I don’t like. They are:

  1. Families with six figure incomes get what is effectively a welfare benefit
  2. The overall tax and abatement rate for parents earning above $60,000 is around 89% (39% tax rate, 25% accom supplement abate and 25% WFF abate off memory)

Now the solution to no 1 would normally be to just abate WFF at a faster rate. But that then makes problem no 2 even worse. So the other solution to no 1 is to have it start abateing at a lower level or to reduce the level of payment for everyone.

Now if one pursues the latter possibilities, you want to do it in a way where tax cuts compensate so no one gets a take home income drop. This is not the time to be reducing anyone’s take home income.

I suspect it just got too difficult to try and design such a scheme in Opposition. I actually worked in the early 2000s with Lockwood Smith on some potential tax formulas which could take into account number of children, and hence deliver all assistance just through the tax system. The problem is many families pay negative income tax, so that wasn’t possible. Plus I am not sure IRD would have appreciated having a parabolic equation as part of the tax code 🙂

My hope is that if National is elected, they will get officials to look at a way to restructure Working for Families and the tax system, and then go into the 2011 election with that as a policy for which they seek a mandate. The deadweight costs of high income families paying tax which just gets delivered back to themselves as WFF welfare is quite considerable. If we want to grow the economy faster than Australia we do need to reduce this “churn”.

McCarten on KiwiSaver law

Matt McCarten looks at the fight over the proposed law change to ban total remuneration packages from including the employer contribution to KiwiSaver:

My union, Unite, represents thousands of minimal-waged workers and few have joined despite a $1000 start-up from the Government and up to $20 a week tax credit.

That’s because someone on the minimum wage would have to contribute 48 cents an hour which they can’t afford when food and petrol prices are soaring.

And this law change will make it illegal to pay them more money if they do not go into KiwiSaver.

I think Thompson is genuinely outraged that KiwiSaver discriminates on age. Workers under 18 and over 65 don’t get the scheme’s subsidies. Mallard claims that as youth rates have been abolished and as older workers are entitled to Government superannuation that somehow makes it acceptable. Well it’s not. It’s clearly discriminatory and unfair.

So this is the head of the Unite union agreeing the the EMA Northern that the scheme dsicriminates agaianst the poor, young and old!

It is an outrage that young workers and older workers who pay their taxes are not allowed to join a scheme their colleagues can. Thompson’s view, which has some merit, is that the workers who aren’t entitled or can’t afford to join KiwiSaver don’t get the subsidy and therefore, effectively, an employer is paying some workers a higher benefit than others.

Exactly. The overall costs to the employer should be the same.

The only way the scheme would be fair was if it was compulsory for all employees so any contribution by employers would be paid to everybody.

It is becoming close to de facto compulsory and I suspect it will become compulsory at some stage.

If KiwiSaver became widespread it would inevitably lead to the weakening and abolition of universal superannuation.

KiwiSaver is privatisation of superannuation by stealth. The poor and those unable to take up employment will miss out and will end up with some state-funded pauper’s pension.

I support KiwiSaver partly because it is an effective privatisation. And McCarten is right that it will inevitably lead to a move away from the current universal publicly funded superannuation scheme. A 25 year old today will earn more money in retirement from KiwiSaver and NZ Super than they will during their working life. That is nuts, and inevitably public superannuation will be made less generous as more and more people have KiwiSaver.

I accept that the Government and trade unions don’t trust employers not to use their compulsory contribution as leverage in contract negotiations. But it seems better-off workers can receive a taxpayer subsidy as well as their employer’s subsidy while their poorer colleagues get nothing.

Indeed. Employers should be able to offer a total remuneraton package where if an employees chooses not to go into KiwiSaver, the employer can pay them extra cash.

Kiwiblog’s 5th birthday

Kiwiblog is five years old today. Contrary to what many may think I was not one of the early bloggers. I got into it six to twelve months after it started to get relatively popular. My inspiration was the now dead NZ Pundit, which I got addicted to reading every day.

One day I decided to give it a go myself and Gordon K kindly set me up on his server alongside NZ Pundit.

It has been somewhat weird that in five years it is now the activity I am most associated with, when it is in fact still just my hobby.

So what are the stats for the last five years:

  • 10,702 posts
  • 342,229 comments
  • 1,424 unique tags
  • 2,972 registered commenters
  • Approx 9,500,000 visits
  • Over 2.5 TB of data downloaded

Kiwiblog should hit visitor number 10 million in September!

50% off gym memberships

The annual FitnessNZ 50% of gym membership promotion for new members starts tomorrow, and Kiwiblog readers are getting an exclusive early opportunity to take advantage of it, as the site is now active.

The rules are that it is open for anyone who is not a current member of a gym, nor has been a member in the last 12 months (nor has take up the promotion in 2006 or 2007). You can buy a membership for someone else provided they qualify (even if you do not).

Gym memberships are often $1,000 a year, so this can save $500 or so. A great opportunity to finally take out the membership you have been thinking of.

I’m not getting paid to promote this. As not one cent  of SPARC (ie taxpayer) money is being spent on the promotion, I’m happy to support it as a private sector public health initiative.

The Condi Rice visit

It would be churlish not to acknowledge that the visit to NZ of US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice was a good thing, and primarily happened due to Winston’s personal efforts.

Peters said he wanted to focus on improving relations with the US, and he has suceeded in this to a reasonable degree. Some of it is fortunate timing (as China gets more aggressive in the Pacific we become more useful to Washington) but he has been able to pursue a closer relationship in a way a Labour Minister would not and could not have.

Rice even referred to NZ as an ally. Now that may not be a change of policy, but it still has some significance. As we fight with the US in Afghanistan it is ludicrous we can not officially train with them, and it is time for the US to drop the silly little ban which is againgst their own interests.

Less likely is significant movement on a free trade agreement. Rice has just six months left in office. Obama appears to be against free trade, and even if McCain wins the new Congress is looking to be highly protectionist.

Having the US use NZ, and specifically Winston, as a small non threatenign proxy for the West in dealing with North Korea was quite inspired and again Peters did well there.

So Winston was at his best charming Dr Rice this weekend. I am unsure if he will do so well on Tuesday trying to charm Sir Robert Jones!

More on Spencer Trust

The HoS quotes former NZ First staffer (and commenter here) Rex Widerstrom:

Peters has said he has “no involvement with that trust” administered by his brother, but former NZ First staff member Rex Widerstrom told the Herald on Sunday he was prepared to swear an affidavit stating the trust was set up around the time of the Winebox Inquiry to funnel anonymous donations from people who wanted to support Peters’ various legal battles.

He said he had the opinion that during his time with Peters there were occasional discussions in the NZ First parliamentary offices about the Spencer Trust, and he was absolutely convinced Peters had knowledge it existed and what its function was.

He recalled one conversation between Peters and ex-staffer Sarah Neems when Neems asked Peters if a donation should go into the Spencer Trust and Peters agreed it should.

So Winston has nothing to do with the Spencer Trust apart from the fact his brother runs it, his staff collect money for it and he decided if donations get paid into it or not?

If it is for legal expenses rather than party expenses, then this calls into question even more his declaration of pecuniary interests. If this is a second secret trust to pay his legal bills, it should have been declared.

Another former NZ First staff member – who did not want to be named – said it was his understanding the name “Spencer” was decided on because of Peters’ great admiration for his namesake Winston Churchill. Churchill’s middle name was Spencer and for years his photograph hung in Peters’ Wellington office.

I’ve had many people pint this connection out to me. Of course the mere possibility Winston may have named the Trust doesn’t mean he has anything to do with it!

Horowitz on Mallard

I blogged on Friday about how the infamous quote:

“Political war is about evoking emotions that favour one’s goals….while mobilizing passions of fear and resentment against your opponents.”

was not advice to Don Brash on what to do, but in fact David Horowitz describing what the left do in America.

Now Trevor Mallard, commenting on National’s industrial relations policy last night on TV3, delivered a very well scripted soundbite, which seemed to be following the Horowitz interpretation of the left-wing playbook to perfection. It was delivered in one burst, but I have broken it up into phrases below, with imagined commentary from Horowitz.

Mallard: What this does is implement John Key’s promise to lower NZ wages.

Horowitz: Good work: don’t debate the issue, just misrepresent it by dredging up an ancient lie.

Mallard: It does it by lowering the wages of people when they are sick.

Horowitz: Excellent – make something up, scare people, keep working on the fear and resentment.

Mallard: By taking their holidays away.

Horowitz: Outstanding, you didn’t even smirk as you lied to the camera.

Mallard: And through the fire at will provisions.

Horowitz: Nice – you didn’t mention the 90-day aspect, and you avoided mentioning the ‘hire’ part of it, and didn’t smirk. Branding it the ‘fire at will provision’ will make many fearful, even angry, about all this. Most importantly, you didn’t make any attempt to actually debate the policy issue. Go to the top of the class.

I think we will use the “Horowitz angle” to examine many of Labour’s statements during the campaign.

An eye witness account of the $25,000 donation

Radio NZ has talked to Professor Malcolm Wright who worked for Sir Robert in 2005. They report:

Professor Malcolm Wright, who worked for Sir Robert three years ago, says he recalls Mr Peters and a staff member visiting Sir Robert for drinks in 2005, where the issue of a donation was discussed.

“Sir Robert was opposed to making a donation. In the end, though, he agreed that he would. There had been a higher sum asked for, and Sir Robert said: ‘Well, I’ll give you $25,000 for mateship’, which Winston agreed to, and they shook hands on that.”

Professor Wright says he was told some days later by one of Mr Peters’ staff members to make a cheque out to a trust, although he cannot recall its name. He says Sir Robert thought the money was going to New Zealand First.

Now it is worth remembering that Professor Wright was a first hand witness to this. Peters has made it clear he is going to attack Jones’ credibility and recall. But Professor Wright seems very clear on the salient details.

A tale of two coups

There are two coups in the air – one in Australia, and one in the United Kingdom. Let us take the UK one first.

As Labour MPs face decimation, Gordon Brown’s position is perilous. He may become the first UK Prime Minister since Neville Chamberlain to never face a general election.

The Telegraph reports:

Gordon Brown is being openly undermined by Cabinet ministers who are now publicly questioning his future as Prime Minister.

The Labour Party has no option but to replace him as leader or face certain defeat at the next general election, said one.

“We cannot go any lower,” the minister said, following Labour’s disastrous defeat in the Glasgow East by-election, one of the biggest upsets in political history.

“We are at rock bottom. The evidence is there for all to see. We are not a one-nation party any more. We are now a no-nation party. We cannot win in Scotland, we cannot win in England, we cannot win in Wales.

“There is only one thing that can be done, and it’s a change of leader.”

Another Cabinet minister added: “It has just moved from possible to probable that Gordon will be toppled.”

Apart from losing one of their safest seats, Labour is 22% behind the Conservatives in the latest polls – this would give them a 236 seat majority.

What will be interesting is who replaces Brown. It may be a poisoned chalice.

The other mounting coup appears to be in the Australian Liberal Party.

Peter Costello served as Deputy Leader and Treasurer to John Howard for over a decade. Howard refused to stand aside for him and when the Libs lost the 2007 election, it looked like Costello’s career was also over.

He did not contest the leadership post-Howard, realising Kevein Rudd could be expected to serve at least two terms, and that he was unlikely to survive to become PM one day. So he did not stand and made noises about retiring.

But things have changed. Brendan Nelson has been a very unimpressive leader, while the ambitious Malcolm Turnbull is mistrusted by many of his colleagues.

But why would Costello be reconsidering just because of that? It si because he thinks he can beat Kevin Rodd at the next election. Now Rudd is still very popular and ahead in the polls, but his focus on stunts is starting to gain negative publicity. But more relevant is the economy. Costelle presided over a decade of economic growth. If the Australian economy is not in good shape in 18 months time, then Costello will be seen as proven economic manager who could win against Rudd.

This is not as certain as Brown being a goner. But Costello is showing all the signs of keeping hos options open:

PETER Costello will map out an ambitious reform agenda in his political memoir – including a pathway to a republic – giving him the platform to launch a bid for the Liberal leadership.

The former treasurer will use his much-anticipated autobiography, to be published in October, to outline a list of priority reforms.

He will also lay out challenges facing Australia in a move to distance himself from John Howard’s “conservative” agenda.

And if things go well there may be a NZ leadership election later this year also!

The Last Lecture Professor dies

Inevitable and sad, but on his way out he touched tens of millions of people.

Randy Pausch has died aged 47. He is most well known for his last lecture, which is one of the most inspiring works I have encountered.

I’ve blogged it once before, but for those who have not seen it, here it is again.

It will be one of the better ways you can spend an hour.

Media on Peters

The failure of Peters to close these issues down was obvious on TV One last night. Their political editor, Guyon Espiner, is usually reluctant to be categorical on an issue, but he made it very clear that he saw the press conference as avoiding all the relevant questions.

Young and Trevett in the Herald report:

Serious credibility questions remain for Foreign Minister Winston Peters after he failed yesterday to throw any light on what happened to a $25,000 donation given by Sir Robert Jones in 2005 for Mr Peters’ NZ First Party.

Sir Robert said he was dismayed at what Mr Peters said yesterday and believed a police complaint will follow shortly – although he said he would not be making it.

If the Spencer Trust will not tell Sir Bob what they did with his money, he should demand it back as it was given on condition of helping NZ First’s election campaign.

He predicted that Mr Peters was “going to die on his own sword on this matter”.

Mr Peters said the police would not be “so naive or uninformed or unprofessional” to investigate the matter.

That sounds like close to a threat to me?

He also said that Roger McClay – a former adviser to Mr Peters – asked for the cheque to be made out to the Spencer Trust.

Wayne Peters had sent Sir Robert a receipt from the Spencer Trust.

So Winston’s staff member asks for the money to go to the Spencer Trust and his brother recepits the money yet WInston claims like Sergeant Schultz to know nothing.

Mr Peters protested his ignorance of the Spencer Trust yesterday and said Sir Robert was wrong.

“Bob’s memory is failing him here.”

Mr Peters said he had not solicited the donation, as Sir Robert claimed.

So who did? Can Peters explain why Jones would donate to the Spencer Trust?

He said he had no involvement with the Spencer Trust, that he did not know what the trust had used the money for, and that he had not spoken to his brother about the trust.

There are so many people he does not speak to. His lawyer over his legal fees, his staff over their fundraising activites on his behalf and his brother over the trust set up to support his party.

Maybe next he will deny even knowing his brother?

The NZ Herald Editorial:

Rather than answer that or any other question yesterday, Winston Peters said he was “not required” to disclose anything about the Spencer Trust. “New Zealand First is not going to subject itself to demands not required of any other political party or leader.”

That is nonsense. If any other party or leader had asked for a cheque to be made out to a mysterious trust and never accounted for it, Mr Peters would be scandalised.

Exactly.

Corruption is a word seldom heard in political debate here except from him – often, ironically, on the subject of undisclosed contributions. It rolls off his tongue much too readily when other parties’ dealings are under discussion.

We do not propose to treat him as he treats others. We will not believe there is wilful dishonesty unless it is proven beyond doubt. The very suspicion of corruption is poisonous to public confidence in government and politics. To spread such poison without proof does almost as much harm as corruption itself.

What is becoming clear to me is we need a very powerful investigative body that can deal with suspected wrong-doing by the powerful.

John Armstrong:

Trying to bring Peters back into the real world – rather than the fantasy world he has been inhabiting for the past fortnight – is not an act of kindness. It is an act of necessity to stop NZ First’s downward spiral taking Labour with it. …

This time Peters’ usual response to crisis – the bluster, the diversions, the smokescreens and games over semantics – are not going to suffice. …

But Clark holds all the cards, not Peters. Were she to sack him, Peters technically could pull NZ First out of its support arrangement with Labour. But the only loser from that would be NZ First. Jumping ship would make it look like NZ First put Peters’ ego ahead of stable Government. It would demonstrate that NZ First can never be trusted to stay the course. It would be electoral suicide. …

The question is how mant weeks will Clark let this carry on for?

Kitchin and Watkins in the Dom Post:

Sir Robert Jones has accused Winston Peters of “lying” about a $25,000 political donation.

Will Winston sue Sir Robert for defamation? I suspect not.

Mr Peters lashed out yesterday at what he labelled a campaign of “innuendo and character assassination”. He insisted he had done nothing wrong after revelations by The Dominion Post that Sir Robert’s $25,000 cheque for NZ First was not disclosed to electoral authorities.

In response, Sir Robert accused Mr Peters of talking “rubbish”. “I’m very sad that Winston has now resorted to blatant lying,” Sir Robert told The Dominion Post.

It really was a mistake for Peters toget into a scrap with Jones.

But his version of events, in relation to the circumstances in which the $25,000 cheque was given, is completely at odds with Sir Robert’s.

The tycoon said Mr Peters had approached him seeking money for NZ First a month before the 2005 election. Sir Robert said he signed a blank cheque and one of his staff later made it out for $25,000 to the Spencer Trust.

Sir Robert said: “I would have been happy if he [Mr Peters] had spent the money on what it was intended for – NZ First … but this Spencer Trust, I’d never heard of it till it was drawn to my attention this week.”

I think people would be shocked to learn exactly how much money the Spencer Trust has had donated over the years – and with never a cent of it declared as having been donated to NZ First. So either the Trust is sitting on a huge bank balance or it has been spending the money in some way to benefit NZ First.

And that expenditure may constitute an effective donation in kind which should have been declared. If they paid for advertisements on their behalf it certainly would. If they paid the wages of campaign staff members then less clear cut. The issues of legality are almost impossible to determine without actually knowing what the Spencer Trust has spent its money on.

Arrest Rewards

AUSA has retracted its $5,000 reward for anyone who makes a citizen’s arrest of Condoleezza Rice. I suspect someone pointed out to them their liability if a student trying to “win” the $5,000 got seriously injured doing so.

The AUSA President, David Do, who offered the reward is an active Labour Party member and a former Princes Street Branch Chair. Maybe a journalist can ask Helen her view of her party members trying to get the US Secretary of State arrested? [UPDATE: David Do tells me he resigned his Labour Party membership last year]

I’ve been told that the even bigger dicks in VUWSA has gone and offered a $10,000 reward – if true this would be from compulsory student fees.

The Canterbury student politicians seem more sensible, quoting the UCSA Blog:

As a student association, is this really their core business? Does arresting Condi help students in any way?

It’s crazy shit like this, which casts doubt on the credibility of Student representatives/politicians, and really hampers the effectiveness of our core responsibility, which is to represent students at our respective Universities.

Meanwhile Whale Oil offers his own $5,000 reward for a citizen’s arrest:

Popular and competent blogger Whaleoil has followed the lead of the Auckland University Students Association in offering a $5000 reward for the arrest of a well known criminal who has recently entered New Zealand: Winston Peters.

Cameron notes:

“And just before Peter Low gets on the phone, the competition is not open to triad gangs,” adds Slater.

Heh. For the avoidance of doubt I will point out the post is satire, not a literal accusation of criminal behaviour!

Jones vs Peters

This latest issue is coming down to a credibility test of Peters vs Jones. Now whenever two people are giving contradictory statements that can not be reconciled, I look at motivations. If one of them is lying, then why?

I just cannot see a logical reason for Sir Robert to not be telling the truth. What does he have to gain? Plus his version of events has been backed up by Professor Malcom Wright, his former General Manager, who now lives in Australia. Sir Robert says he had donated up to $250,000 to Winston/NZ First/Spencer Trust/Brian Henry Legal Fund over the years. This doesn’t seem like the actions of someone who would try to destroy Winston’s career by lying about said donations.

The Dominion Post has revealed that Ross Meurant collected cheques from the Vela Family for Winston/NZ First/Spencer Trust/Brian Henry Legal Fund and Sir Robert (plus other sources) have confirmed Roger McClay also collected money for Winston/NZ First/Spencer Trust/Brian Henry Legal Fund.

Now both these men were close friends of Winston’s, but more to the point were employed in his parliamentary office. The rules over what you can do as a parliamentary staffer are open to some interpretation – but there can be no doubt you should not be going around meeting potential donors and picking up cheques off them. Maybe someone will argue they did this in their spare time. But the significance is they worked for Winston personally – not the party. The Party President and Party Deputy Leader both say they have never heard of The Spencer Trust. Are we to believe that staff in Winston’s private office somehow magically found out about it, from someone other than Winston, and on their own initiative decided to go around soliciting money for it?

Board Appointments

The Herald picks up on the stacking of half the new Transport Agency board with Labour affiliated politicians.

In the last few months almost every Labour Party activist in the country seems to be picking up taxpayer funded board jobs.

Now I have never advocated that those with political involvement and experience should be ineligible for board appointments. And in some cases it can be useful to have a board member with some political saavy. And likewise it is understandable that a Minister will want perhaps one or two people on the more critical boards who understand politics to the degree that they can help the Board avoid actions which will put them on a collision course with the Government.

And being realistic, if a Minister has several candidates of equal quality, then the one personally known to the Minister will be at an advantage.

Now having defended some appointees with a political background, why am I critical of the latest rash of appointments? No not just because it is Labour. I will give some guidelines I think all Governments should use, and that National also has broken in the past.

  1. Never have those with political connections forming a majority or even close to a majority on a board. That threatens good governance. National was guilty of this in the 1990s when I think every single member of the Lottery Grants Board was National connected. Now sure that only doshes out money but it is a very bad look. If a board has more than a couple of persons with political connections, then it loses credibility.
  2. Unless someone was already a professional company director (or widely seen as possessing similar skills), they should not be appointed to more than a couple of boards. An individual should not have so many appointments that they earn a close to or higher than six figure income from board appointments. The appointment of Di Yates to four separate boards is an example of that. If they put her on only one board, no-one would probably grumble (except her fellow board members) – but four boards is ridiculously venal.
  3. Appointees must bring genuine value to a board – their appointments must be based on merit, even if they have political connections. Appointments are always somewhat subjective but there are some clear differences in competence. For example I wouldn’t criticise the appointment of Garry Moore to the Transport Board as he has significant governance experience. But I can’t see how the appointment of Christine Caughey is in any way based on merit. The same for Di Yates on on Food Standards Authority – they were so desperate to justify it they had to include living in Waikato as a credential.
  4. The more important a board, the more critical it is that the apointees be top class. I don’t get particularly worked up about an appointment to the Waikato Sports Trust or the Lottery Grants Youth Committee etc. But the boards of the large SOEs are critically important, as are the top regulatory boards. The Electricity Commission has been stacked with Labour affiliates – which is a massive concern. And this week I have focused on the Reserve Bank Board – a prime example of a board which needs the highest calibre of appointees, and those who can bring some real value to the area of monetary policy.

No-one should think a National-led Government is never going to appoint some of its former MPs, or others politically connected, to various Boards. Of course they will. But if appointments are in line with my proposed guidelines, then they should face significantly less criticism.

The Obama Phenomenon

The crowd of 200,000 which turned out in Berlin to hear a mere candidate for the US presidency confirms that Obama is more a phenomenon than an ordinary candidate. I struggle to see how he will lose unless he majorly stuffs up. His flip-flops on the surge in Iraq are not going to be sufficient.

The speech was Obama at his best in a presentational sense. Almost every line drew applause. Now I can look at the content and be sceptical of such puffery as ridding the world of nuclear weapons and wanting Jews and Arab to work together, but as a candidate he can get away with such stuff. I do still wonder how he will go in office (ih he wins) when he has to actually make a tough decision.

But if he wins, it is clear he will be an extraordinarily popular United States President globally. And while they don’t vote, it will be refreshing to have a President who has global popularity. It may benefit both the US and Obama’s presidency.

But the flipside is the curse of expectations. When those tough decisions do confront Obama, and he does do something which is unpopular globally – the backlash may be even worse as people could feel a sense of betrayal.

Obama is only 4% ahead of McCain, but he will well ahead in the electoral college vote, and he is receiving twice as much coverage as McCain. This is arguably the result of an uncritical gushy media, but I can’t see it changing.

Winston’s response

NZPA reports on Winston’s response:

Television New Zealand News has shown Mr Peters saying he has no involvement with the Spencer Trust, into which Sir Robert Jones paid $25,000 when he believed he was giving a donation to Mr Peters.

Mr Peters also said Sir Robert was wrong when he claimed Mr Peters had asked him for the donation.

Mr Peters told journalists they should ask the Spencer Trust what they did with the money.

“I have been advised by party officials at the time that there is nothing NZ First is required to disclose arising from the Spencer Trust,” Mr Peters said.

The headline is that Peters has suggested Sir Robert’s memory is fading. I suspect that was very unwise of him.

He has issued a press release:

1. The Glenn contribution went to my barrister Brian Henry. As soon as I learned of it I informed the Prime Minister and alerted the media.

But he never thought to ask Brian earlier if the mystery $100,000 donor was Owen Glenn.

2. The issue of taxation on this contribution is without merit. Legal experts have said so.

Which legal experts? Opinion is divided as far as I can tell. In the end not that big an issue as the IRD will form its own view.

3. No gift duty is payable. Gift duty is based on the laws of the country where the donor is domiciled.

See earlier post for differing views on this.

4. No declaration of pecuniary interest is required. This was made clear by the official advice given to Nick Smith as he revealed in the House this week.

Not at all. In fact Nick Smith did declare a beneficial interest.

5. The Vela cheque is lawful.

I don’t think anyone has suggested it wasn’t. The issue is the hypocrisy of hiding your large donors when you rail against other parties that do the same.

6. The Robert Jones claim that he gave $25,000 to New Zealand First?

– The cheque was made out to the Spencer Trust.
– The cheque was not made out to New Zealand First.

Here is where he just won’t front up, and just states a truism. Everyone knows who the cheque was made out to. The issue is why NZ First representatives are soliciting money on behalf of NZ First and asking for it to be paid into The Spencer Trust.

Is Peters really saying that Sir Robert Jones decided on his own initiative to donate $25,000 to a trust he has never heard of, and that it is unlinked to NZ First?

And never mind the hypocrisy of his attacks on other trusts.

– I have been advised by party officials at the time that there is nothing New Zealand First is required to disclose arising from the Spencer Trust.

Your own President and Deputy Leader say they have never heard of The Spencer Trust so how could they know anything about what the Spencer Trust may have done on behalf of NZ First?

7. Neither I nor my barrister has any involvement with the Spencer Trust.

Note the careful use of language. He says “involvement”. That doesn’t mean he doesn’t know exactly who has paid money into The Spencer Trust and what that money has been spent on. Knowledge is not involvement.

And what Winston doesn’t matter is that his brother runs the Trust. Are we to believe this is a coincidence? And can Winston explain why members of his parliamentary staff were soliciting money for the Spencer Trust?

8. The claim that the 1997 Cushing case settlement of $125,000 was paid by an anonymous donor is untrue. I paid the costs and have offered to show the reporter in question the details. This offer has not been taken up and no withdrawal of the claim has been published.

However it is a mystery who paid the $40,000 costs to Bob Clarkson in the 2005/6 case?

I can’t wait for Sir Robert’s reaction!

NBR on tax on Owen Glenn gift

A fascinating article in NBR (offline) on what Brian Henry says regarding tax on the Owen Glenn gift:

Mr Henry said last Friday that he had solicited the money from Mr Glenn. He told NBR this money was paid directly to him as accounts for costs – basically an arrangement for fees incurred in a case to date.

As I understand it, it is highly highly unusual for a barrister to get paid directly, let alone to go out seeking donations for his costs.

He said these were treated just as fees would be and so tax had been paid on the amount. “It’s my fees. It goes into my fees bill that goes to the IRD in the usual way.”

This is of course expected. You get your fees paid and you pay income tax. But that is separate to whether there is gift duty.

However, he said that Mr Peters had no legal obligation to pay him fees incurred in the legal proceedings and so there was no donation that was needed to be declared under Parliament’s register of pecuniary interests.

Essentially, Mr Henry said, there was no debt until he issued a final invoice (called a “fee note”) to the instructing solicitor in the case, who would invoice Mr Peters. However, he admitted Mr Peters had paid him directly in the past as a contribution to legal costs.

Brian Henry is arguing that as he had not actually issued an invoice yet, then there was no debt and no gift. But I am unsure if the lack of an invoice means there is no debt- the debt is incurred I would have thought when you contract someone to perform services for you – even if not yet invoiced for it. Otherwise thousands of people could rort the tax system by having someone pay for services on their behalf before an invoice is issued for it.

The substance is would Winston Peters have ended up paying an extra $100,000 to Brian Henry if Owen Glenn had not donated on his behalf. Absolutely. Both Henry and Peters have said he picks up the shortfall.

“There doesn’t have to be an invoice – he can pay on account of costs. He says I can afford to pay you this today and I say thank you.”

However, Bar Association president Jim Farmer QC said interim payments should not be accepted by barristers except for work actually done.

“A barrister must render a fee note if he wants to be paid,” he told NBR.

Sounds like Mr Henry’s practises are highly unusual, to say the least.

Sources close to the litigation in question – where Mr Peters tried to overturn the 2005 election result in Mr Peters‘ former seat of Tauranga – say Mr Peters “really had his bacon saved” when money came in for costs.

That’s because the respondent, National MP Bob Clarkson, had threatened Mr Peters with bankruptcy proceedings after the $40,000 costs order in favour of Mr Clarkson was not met within three weeks.

And that is an interesting aspect. What if some of the $100,000 went to the court costs not just Henry’s expenses. How can you claim that is not a gift?

Also if Peters was in dire financial straits, doesn’t that make it more likely he would have been in the loop?

NBR inquiries have turned up some uncertainty about how the costs award to Mr Clarkson was paid.

“I gave him about three weeks,” said Mr Clarkson. “Since he’s got a lot of rich friends I thought it’d take about three weeks. It didn’t turn up so we sent a note saying that proceedings would be taken if it wasn’t paid. And the money turned up.”

The cover letter with that payment was from Brian Henry, and the money was paid by a bank cheque. But the bank cheque meant the issuer could not be identified. It was not a bank cheque issued under Mr Peters‘ instructing solicitor’s trust account.

So either Owen Glenn or maybe even a second secret donor paid the court costs to Bob Clarkson? This just simply has to be investigated.

For his part, Mr Henry can’t remember where the payment for the costs order was made from. “I couldn’t answer that.”

Mr Peters‘ instructing solicitor in the case, Dennis Gates, would not comment when asked by NBR if the payment was with money out of his solicitor’s trust account.

It just gets murkier and murkier.

Paul Walker on food prices

Paul Walker takes a long hard look at the causes of global food inflation. He looks at the three theories:

  1. Newspapers have cited an internal World Bank document as having found that 75% of the price increase was due to biofuels
  2. Several governments and commentators see speculation as a major driving force.
  3. Widely held view has it that rapidly growing food demand in the emerging economies is pushing up global food prices.

So how does theory 2 hold up:

Yet, there is no hard evidence that “speculation” has added much to the price increase on spot markets. After all, it is only when “speculators” actually buy produce on the spot market that they can drive up the price, and this would have to be reflected in growing stock levels – but stocks appear to have declined throughout the period of rising prices

So how about theory 3 – blame China and India:

Food demand in China, India, and other emerging economies is rising as their incomes grow. However, domestic food production in most of these countries is growing in parallel. China, for example, has been a consistent and growing net exporter of cereals (including rice). The Agricultural Outlook expects China’s net cereals exports to decline only very gradually in the coming decade. For India, the picture is similar, though there was significant variability in its net trade position in the past. In short, growing food demand in the major emerging countries cannot be held responsible for the rise in world market prices for cereals.

So that leaves theory 1 – biofuels:

The use of agricultural products, in particular maize, wheat, and vegetable oil, as feedstock for biofuel production has expanded dramatically in recent years. Between 2005 and 2007, i.e. in the period when food prices began to explode, nearly 60% of the growth in global consumption of cereals and vegetable oils was due to biofuels. Global output of cereals and vegetable oil did not decline during that period, but just grew slower than the rapid expansion of use.

In a situation of depleted stocks and very low demand and supply elasticities, this gap between use and output growth has pushed prices up very strongly.

And the conclusion:

Thus we find that there cannot be much in the way of doubt that biofuels are a significant factor in the rise of worldwide food prices. Add to this the fact that other research suggests that biofuel support policies are disappointingly ineffective on environmental grounds, then it should be clear that governments need to reconsider their support for biofuels. But many governments, including New Zealand’s, seem to want to push ahead with such policies despite the kind of evidence Tangermann brings to bear on the issue.

Stefan Tangermann, quoted by Walker, is Director of Trade and Agriculture for the OECD.

Gordon Brown is a goner

UK Labour have lost the Glasgow East by-election despite a 13,507 majority. This seat was in their top 5% in terms of size of majority – 25th safest.

They are calling for a recount as the majority is only 354, but that is a reasonable amount to overcome. The Scottish Nationalist Party (SNP) are in the lead. The Conservatives are fighting the Lib Dems for third place. This is Glasgow!

If the loss is confirmed, Gordon Brown will not survive until the election. Tony Blair must be smiling. Already the knives are out.

The secret NBR column

My second online column for NBR in on their site. Following the example of NZ First, its name is secret.

The full column is quite long. My choices for this week were:

  1. Best Play of the Week – the EMA Northern Campaign against the KiwiSaver changes at an A-
  2. Worst Play of the Week – Allan Bollard gets a C- for putting up the cash rate before he has inflation under control
  3. Scandal of the Week – I’ll leave people to guess which which scandal I gave an A+ to
  4. Patsy of the Week – went to the entire NZ First Caucus who got a collective A for sycophancy
  5. EFA Breach of the Week – a D- to the suggestion from Steve Pierson that the EMA campaign was illegal
  6. Blog Analysis of the Week- Idiot/Savant gets a B+ for his reasoning on why Winston should be sacked

Oh and I’ve already been called a fascist in the comments!

National policy

NBR have an NZPA story on National’s policy programme. Details are:

  • Tax policy to be released in first week of the campaign – is locked in and takes account of worsening economy
  • KiwiSaver policy and Working for Families policies to be released
  • These would be minor changes to current settings only
  • Planning for a 8 November election
  • Would introduce an RMA Amendment Bill within 100 days of office
  • Aims to make the Emissions Trading Scheme a priority and pass legislation within nine months of office
  • Stressed no change to the $1.5 billion fibre to the home broadband infrastructure proposal

All sounds good.

Missing candidate

The only seat I don’t have a candidate for is Waikato – for Labour. I’m sure there is one. Can someone helpful let me know who it is.

Tracking down candidates is not that easy. National now have them all on their website, but Labour don’t list any candidates who are not MPs (they can’t as their site is taxpayer funded).

ACT list only eight candidates at this stage. I’ve actually met them all!

The Maori Party do not seem to list candidates at all, like Labour. And the NZ First candidates are even more secret than their donations.

United Future have the most helpful list so far. They have 22 candidates to date.

The Greens have a list of candidates, but ordered by list ranking, not electorate. 48 selected to date.

The Progressive Party has only one candidate 🙂