If Tony Veitch was Winston Peters

Tertiary scholarships

The position of the Human Rights Commission on whether scholarships reserved for women only are still appropriate will be interesting.

Women now significantly out perform men in education. It isn’t even close.

The research found that in 2006, 63 per cent of bachelors degrees went to women and 37% to men. While around 38% of New Zealand women were now finishing tertiary education, only 28 per cent of men did the same.

This is a massive imbalance – women out number men by more than 3:2 in the degrees stake.

NZUSA national woman’s representative Analiese Jackson said it was too early to start withdrawing support for women. “Women have only been able to participate in the numbers that they have now because of these scholarships.”

First of all it is nonsense to claim the scholarships have been critical in getting to the level fo women’s participation we have today. Societal changes have been the far far larger factor.

Some people do not like affirmative action type policies at all. Others like me can be supportive of it when there is a problem that needs addressing. I think many programmes go too far, but I think some can be productive.

However this is a very different case. Not only are women no longer under-represented. They are leaving the men for dead. The whole purpose of pushing for equality is to know when you have achieved your goal. There are still issues for women in many areas of society, but tertiary education under-representation is not one of them.

If anything there is a case for male only scholarships!

Editorials on Peters

The NZ Herald editorial first:

Only Winston Peters knows why he decided to deny receiving a donation from the hapless (and utterly respectable) expatriate benefactor Owen Glenn. As Mr Peters’ admission now reveals, he was in no position to deny it. He may not have been aware of the identity of donors to his legal aid but he was aware that his lawyer has been fundraising for this purpose for many years. That fact alone should have made him more circumspect when asked whether he had received any money from Mr Glenn.

Smart media may want to ask Winston how many times has he met with Owen Glenn, and did he meet with Owen Glenn in Sydney in 2006? And Owen Glenn of course is known as the soul of discretion, so he never mentioned his donation at any of these meetings.

Now he looks very foolish – and worse, in the eyes of many. It was one thing to make a denial without checking all possible sources of his financial support, and flourish a silly sign to news cameras, but Mr Peters did not hear alarm bells even when the Herald discovered an email in which Mr Glenn asked a public relations adviser, “You are saying I should deny giving a donation to NZ First? When I did?”

The logicial response would have been to ask Owen Glenn why he sent that e-mail and what he meant by it. That is the one thing he went out of his way not to do.

A wiser man would have run a quick check on all sources of funds related to his personal political activities and his party. Instead our Foreign Minister descended to baseless and disgraceful allegations of his own – against the integrity of this newspaper, its editor, and our fair-minded political editor, Audrey Young.

Yep. He called Audrey Young a liar, and suggested they had fabricated the e-mail.

“He did not make a donation to the NZ First Party,” he said of Mr Glenn, “he made a donation to a legal action he thought justified”. Later, at his party’s 15th anniversary conference, Mr Peters maintained this desperate distinction. “Not one cent went to NZ First and not one cent went to me,” he insisted. “A donation was made to a legal case which is a massive difference … “

No, it is not. He brought a case against the election spending of the MP who captured his Tauranga seat. The law hears those actions in the name of individuals, not parties. Had the petition succeeded, the beneficiaries would have been Mr Peters, if the seat had been restored to him, and his party, since an electorate gives a party more secure representation in Parliament. Mr Glenn obviously believed he was contributing to NZ First and to all intents and purposes, he was.

I have had a lawyer confirm to me the electoral petition is in the nameof Winston personally, and hence the expenses of that petition are his personal expenses. Winston’s claim this is somehow different to a donation to him is like some sleazy US politician claiming they never took a cent from a major lobbyist – but the lobbyist did buy them a new car, paid off their mortgage and flew their family for a holiday on their private jet.

In a legal sense the money was not a donation to NZ First, but Owen Glenn obviously did not see the difference.

The Press weighs in:

For bellow and bluster as they might, Peters’ admission at the end of the week, after months of denials, that he was in fact the beneficiary of a $100,000 gift from the offshore billionaire Owen Glenn is deeply humiliating. Peters continues to insist that the way the gift was made leaves him entirely blameless. That is a view that not many outside the party will share. …

Peters says he knew nothing about the gift until he was told by his lawyer early this week. This means that all the time Peters was engaging in bullying and offensive abuse of those who were seeking the truth about the matter, he did not engage in the kind of straightforward inquiries that would have revealed it.

And the most obvious inquiry was to ask Owen Glenn what he meant.

The second most obvious inquiry was to ask Brian Henry “Hey Brian you know that $100,000 you got for my legal bills. Was that Owen Glenn?”.

How the donation was made

Very interesting to look closely at the words in the media from Brian Henry and Mike Williams this morning. In the Herald:

Winston Peters’ lawyer says a tip-off led him to approach billionaire Owen Glenn for a large donation to the NZ First leader’s legal bills.

Now this tip-off could have been from Winston or from Mike Williams. Also of note if Henry says he solicted the donation while Winston Peters in his February perss conference said that they never approached or asked anyone for money. Of course what Winston meant was they never solicit donations to NZ First but they go hell for leather for personal donations to his legal fund.

Brian Henry said last night he asked the Monaco-based businessman for help after another donor did not deliver.

How many secret donors have there been?

“We made it well known around friendly political circles – or I did – that I was looking for a donor.”

Doesn’t that sounds like a perfect description of Mike Williams?

Mr Henry said he could not recall who had advised him to contact Mr Glenn when the original funder of the legal action fell through, but it was not Mr Peters.

Nor was it Mike Williams, the president of the Labour Party which has also received Glenn donations.

“I can’t off the top of my head remember who it was who told me to call him.”

Oh of course. You can not remember who told you to go hit Owen Glenn up for $100,000 but you can recall it wasn’t Winston or Mike Williams.

Mr Henry said no fund or account for Mr Peters’ legal bills existed.

“The position is that the money is used to pay an existing bill, full-stop.

There is no fund. There is no cash sitting in a balance anywhere. There are bills to be paid.”

Now this is fascinating. Because paying off a bill on behalf of Winston Peters is effectively a donation to him, and there are definite tax implications for that. More on that later.

But let us turn back to the requirements of the Register of Pecuniary Interests:

a description of all debts of more than $500 that were owing by the member that were discharged or paid (in whole or in part) by any other person and the names of each of those persons,

So Brian Henry has just confirmed the Register is incorrect for Winston Peters. And Winston would have been well aware that his legal bills had just dropped by $100,000. Plus it is possible he gets Brian Henry to file his annual return, so any excuses for an incorrect return are shot.

Mr Henry would not discuss why he had not alerted Mr Peters about the donation in February, when Mr Peters denied Mr Glenn had made a donation.

It was of course logical and sensible to let your close friend and client remain in the dark.

Asked about pecuniary gain, Mr Peters told NZPA he did not believe he had benefited personally from the arrangement whereby his legal bills were paid by anonymous donors and he paid the shortfall.

Mr Henry concurred last night.

“There is nothing I am aware of where someone contributing towards a bill you have incurred needs to be declared.”

These men are lawyers? They have to be kidding. They think paying a bill on behalf of someone is not beneficial. Hey let’s pay off Winston’s mortgage for him – that doesn’t count also.

What they say also is directly contradicted by Standing Orders and the Register of Pecuniary Interests.

Henry’s insistence that paying off Winston’s bill isn’t a donation to Winston strongly suggests he did not pay tax on that donation. I suggest a question the nice Peter Dunne, Minister of Revenue would be in order:

“To the Minister of Revenue: What is the position of the Inland Revenue Department as to liable tax if an individual has another individual pay $100,000 debt on their behalf”

Also yet to be resolved is if that $100,000 donation was in any way linked to the large closer to $100,000 than $10,000 sum which appeared in the NZ First bank account in December 2007?

A five poll weekend

Curiablog has the details of the five polls out over the weekend. Four national polls and one in Ikaroa-Rawhiti.

The time and size weighted rolling average now has National at 51.5% and Labour 33.1% – a 18.4% gap. If one takes just the latest four polls into account it is 50.8% to 33.9% – a 16.9% gap. The average gap in June was 23% so a definite closing.

All about John Key

As many will know the Herald had three staff spend around half a year interviewing close to 100 people about John Key for their unauthorised biography. Like the Sunday Star-Times found with their earlier investigation of John’s work career, there are no dark hidden secrets. Well unless you count learning to play golf at age 10 as he had determined it would be useful for his future business career 🙂

The Herald had a remarkable eight full pages on John’s background and family. It is part of politics to have some of that focus (mind you I can’t recall one ever so detailed as this) but it is probably a bit unsettling to have so many people talking about your family and early days. I’m one of the few who probably read the full eight pages, and what struck me is what a remarkable woman John’s mother was.

A lawyer’s view

Have had many interesting e-mails on the Winston issue. One of them is from an lawyer and has some interesting aspects:

As a lawyer, I am fully aware of the personal nature of legal expenses / Court costs.  They are a personal liability, which must be satisfied by the client (no different than the personal liability for your mortgage). It is beyond doubt that, by having his personal liability for legal fees and Court costs paid for him, WP has personally benefited from the donation.

Indeed. It will be interesting to ascertain (if one can) the exact legal nature of the fund the donations go into. Is it a legal trust? Is it a lawyer’s trust fund? Is it an unincorporated society?

By definition, lawyer’s trust accounts are NOT subject to legal professional privilege.  So be ready when the media are told that further details are protected from legal privilege – because they are not. For instance, see s 20 of the Tax Administration Act 1994, which expressly states IRD can have immediate access to all legal trust accounts as privilege does not apply to them (there is no “privilege” in payments, only in legal adice).

I am also receiving detailed information on the tax implications, which I will publish when finalised.

Peters unrepetent

There is now no doubt the e-mail published by the NZ Herald was not a forgery. And few would doubt that the publishing of that led to the revelation that Winston Peters had personally benefited by a $100,000 donation from Owen Glenn to his legal costs.

Anyone with has campaigned on transparency would say that the NZ Herald has done nothing wrong in publishing a true e-mail which resulted in the public gaining knowledge about a secret donation.

So I, and others, was wondering about whether Winston Peters would be man enough to apologise to Audrey Young for calling her a liar, and maybe even to her editor Tim Murphy for calling for them both to be sacked.

Alas the Herald on Sunday reports:

Yesterday Peters renewed calls for Murphy and Young to “do their duty and resign”.

Isn’t that incredible? The man literally has no shame.

Anyway NZ First is now officially the party in favour of large secret donations to top up MPs pay. No, seriously. This is what Brian Henry said:

He said politicians were “poorly paid” and needed donations, and he would continue to fundraise.

“They’ve got a temporary job, and they can’t afford litigation. They just don’t have the money.”

Yes Winston is very poorly paid on $200,000 or so a year. And his poor temporary job has only lasted 27 weeks. I’m sorry I mean 27 years (out of the last 30).

And as for being able to afford litigation. Well I’m sympathethic to MPs who get sued doing their job and need help with the costs of defending a lawsuit. But it is worth nothing that of Winston’s 14 law suits – almost all are him suing other people – not getting sued.

Audrey Young blogs yesterday:

Here at the party convention at Alexander Park he has held perhaps the most graceless press conference he has ever held, and that takes some beating.

And No, to the dozens of inquiries: Peters has not apologised for the personal abuse levelled at me last Monday when he employed the bazooka strategy – fire so many missiles at somebody else that people forget what you are supposed to have done. Though I did receive one from a very decent member of the caucus.

There are some decent MPs in NZ First and I suspect they are very distressed to find out that all their railing against secret donations in politics only applies to everyone but their Leader.

I wonder why he was able to find the answer to the Glenn donation question in July when in February after apparently exhaustive questions were asked about the $100,000 Dail Jones thought he had seen in the party’s accounts, no answers were turned up.

This is one of those big unanswered questions. Is the $100,000 donated to Peters’ legal fund in 2006 the same close to $100,000 sum that went into a NZ First account in late 2007. If the money has even temporarily gone through an official NZ First bank account, then there are serious implications.

Bill Ralston has his say:

Winston Peters’ embarrassing admission, despite months of blustering denials, that he had received a $100,000 donation from businessman Owen Glenn poses some real risks, not only for himself but for several other political players. …

Instead, he will be wriggling under reporters’ questions about his party’s murky funding structure and what exactly Glenn may have wanted in return for his generosity.

It is obvious from a leaked letter from Glenn published in the Weekend Herald last week that Glenn clearly believes he is still in the running for the honorary consul-general role in Monaco, a position Peters, as Foreign Minister, has the power to grant.

Peters has said they have not yet decided if they even need a Consul in Monaco. However the Government in 2004 clearly  decided they do not. So why is the Government reviewing a very recent decision, apart from the fact a wealthy donor has said he wants the job?

A good question is what role did Williams play in backing the expensive Tauranga electoral petition after the last election?

It was that legal action, along with 13 cases since 1991, that ran up the legal bill that Glenn helped pay off.

It is understood Williams did a lot of the calculations on election spending by National’s Bob Clarkson that Peters’ lawyers used to try to challenge his election.

There was indeed talk of Williams helping with the unsuccessful petition. Was Mike Williams the person who arranged for Owen Glenn to donate to Winston’s legal expenses?

And finally the Herald on Sunday Editorial:

The trouble with occupying the moral high ground is that the only way out is down. New Zealand First leader Winston Peters has spent the weekend of his party’s 15th-anniversary conference trying to finesse his late, lame admission that expatriate billionaire Owen Glenn did, in fact, make a $100,000 payment, the existence of which Peters has so vehemently denied.

But what is plain is that he did not tell the whole truth about the matter.

Indeed it is only due to the NZ Herald, and other media, that the truth has come out. And Winston’s position is they they should be sacked for having got the truth out of him.

They then post a very valid question:

But why should he know nothing of contributors to funds that assist his personal legal battles? If a Chinese wall is to be erected at all, it would be much more logical that it be around the party accounts, with which Peters appears to have been more familiar than his erstwhile president. And in any case, Glenn’s email makes it plain that he thought he had contributed “to NZ First”.

Yes party leaders should be kept away from the party’s accounts, but it is arguable he actually needs to know who donated to benefit him personally. And make no mistake paying off his legal bills has the same effect as giving him cash directly – a bigger bank balance for Peters.

Blog Bits

Stephen Franks blogs on the battle to save Crossways in Mt Victoria. I will be blogging on this myself during the week. It will be a tragedy if Mt Victoria loses what has been a focal point for the community. The City Council is justifying its lack of support by saying residents have lots of cafes nearby unlike suburbs further away from the city centre. A very very weak argument.

Keeping Stock blogs on an alarming suggestion by Auckland lawyer Catriona McLennan on Nine to Noon. She suggests that in rape trials, the burden of proof should be on the accused to prove there was consent. And this is not just a throw-away remark – she actually argues in favour of it against Kathryn Ryan for some time.

Whale Oil has been threatened with defamation by a lawyer acting for Pearl Going, who objects to comments he had made on her. The material has been removed from his blog after the blog hosting company was also threatened, but copies have sprung up on a dedicated blog hosted overseas.

I don’t intend to comment of the substance of the allegedly defamatory material, but would note that pressuring hosting companies to remove material, even after the blog author has asserted it is not defamatory and is willing to defend it in court, is not a particularly sensible tactic as it is so easy for the material to appear elsewhere – as has happened. Also of interest is that the lawyer for Pearl Going is Steven Price, who was very critical of the Listener for threatening the Hot Topic blogger with defamation.

This should not be taken as a suggestion that defamation laws do not or should not apply to the Internet. Of course they do. But more the appropriateness of targetting blog hosts if the blog author is willing to stand by their words and accept legal consequences for them.

The Dim Post has more satire, this one on how Winston is handling the Owen Gelnn scandal:

  • Monday 2:00 PM: Hires two identical twins as press secretaries, one of whom always tells the truth while the other always lies.
  • Wednesday 11:30 AM: Announces to press conference that he will explain everything but in doing so will be forced to reveal the secret surprise ending to Battlestar Galactica. Political media beg him to remain silent.
  • Thursday 6:35 PM: Notifies Speaker Margaret Wilson that he is officially changing his alignment to Neutral Evil.
  • Friday 10:30 AM: Recieves report back from Department of Statistics confirming that proportion of New Zealanders with IQ below 90 is still greater than 5%. Laughs heartily. Tells rest of country to go fuck themselves.

Heh.

Liberty Scott pings Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn for his comments on Gordon Brown approving a state funeral for Margaret Thatcher when she dies. The offending quote:

“On the plus side, it will at least give her victims a final chance to throw excrement and rotten fruit at her as she goes past“

As I/S goes on about how some on the right are often poisonous, spiteful and bitter, this quote brings to mind stones and glasshouses.

David Cohen looks at a case for Nicky Hager:

A column containing acidic opinions about a powerful political media personality mysteriously fails to show up on the author’s regular spot on her newspaper’s website. Another major news outlet, after allowing criticisms to be made of the same public figure on one of its shows, hurriedly issues a grovelling clarification. Does this sound like a case Nicky Hager ought to be investigating?

It would indeed if it weren’t the slightly inconvenient fact that the media power broker in question also happens to be the same gent.

What you have to believe in to believe Peters did not know

Brian Henry and Winston Peters have said that until yesterday Winston Peters did not know Owen Glenn donated $100,000 to pay Winston’s legal bills. Now this is impossible to disprove unless someone leaks some more e-mails.

But we can look at how credible this is, so people can make a judgement. For politics is about credibility.

Now if one is to believe that Peters did not know of the donation from Glenn until Friday, you have to believe all of the following. Note – not just one of the following- but all of it:

  1. Owen Glenn found out about the “Legal Expenses Fund” from someone other than Winston Peters.
  2. Glenn found this out despite almost no one who actually lives in New Zealand knowing about it.
  3. Glenn chose on his own whim to donate to the Legal Expenses Fund rather than NZ First.
  4. Glenn never ever mentioned to Winston Peters he had donated or intended to donate to his legal expenses fund. Glenn is of course known as the soul of discretion.
  5. Glenn managed to get contact details for Brian Henry from someone who is not Winston Peters.
  6. The fund which has been running since 1991 has raised a total of $200,000 of which the $100,000 donation constitutes half in one swoop, and he never asked nor suspected who the donor was.
  7. When the media reported Owen Glenn in February 2008 as having donated to another party, Brian Henry never clicked that he was referring to the $100,000 Glenn gave Henry for Peters’ legal fees.
  8. Winston Peters never thought to check if the large $100,000 donation his lawyer had received could be the donation being referred to by Owen Glenn in February.
  9. Brian Henry let Winston go into a press conference and deny that NZ First had received any money at all from Owen Glenn – not even a dollar, and did not feel he had an ethical, moral or professional duty to tell him of the personal donation to Peters’ legal expenses
  10. That Brian Henry was aware the Winston Peters was considering appointing Owen Glenn as Consul to Monaco, and did not think the fact Glenn had donated $100,000 to Peters’ legal expenses was something that should be disclosed.
  11. After the NZ Herald on 12 July printed the e-mail from Owen Glenn, Brian Henry still said nothing to Peters despite it being glaringly obvious what he was referring to.
  12. There was some legitimate reason Winston Peters did not do the obvious when the e-mail was printed and contact Owen Glenn to ask him if the e-mail was real, and what the hell he was on about?
  13. That Winston Peters never wondered why Steve Fisher was so desperate to make sure Owen Glenn did not contradict what Peters said?
  14. Even after Brian Henry saw Winston denying everything, claiming the e-mail is fabricated and calling Audrey Young a liar, he still didn’t think he needed to urgently inform Winston that the e-mail was correct (from Glenn’s perspective)
  15. That during all this time, Winston Peters never wondered if the mystery $100,000 donation for his legal fees could be from Owen Glenn, and that it all came as a total surprise.
  16. It took Brian Henry seven days to manage to talk to his close personal friend and long standing client, to let him know that he had information which verified the e-mail in the Herald.

Now if you do believe all of the above, I’d like to take you to San Francisco where I have some real estate to sell you.

Issues MPs should be looking at

Some may think that there is less of an issue for Peters having had the donation go to pay for his private legal expenses, rather than to NZ First itself. I am of the view this makes things much worse for him.

NZPA reported:

He said that since 1991 he had been involved in 14 legal actions which had been partly funded through donations, and Mr Henry had “a firm policy” of not disclosing the source of donations.

“I have never been told the source of these donations but have personally met the shortfall which has amounted to many hundred thousands of dollars,” Mr Peters said in a statement.

Now this makes very clear that the secret donation was effectively a donation that benefited Winston Peters personally. If they had not received that $100,000 then Peters by his own words would be making up the shortfall.

The first issue this may raise is the tax status of the donation. Peters is not a charity, and the donation is well above the limit for personal gifts. Who exactly was the donation made out to? What account was it paid into? Who controls that account? What is the legal personality that received it? Was tax paid on it if tax is liable?

The next issue is the Cabinet Manual. First some general clauses:

2.52 A Minister of the Crown, while holding a ministerial warrant, acts in a number of different capacities:

  1. in a ministerial capacity, making decisions, and determining and promoting policy within particular portfolios;
  2. in a political capacity as a member of Parliament, representing a constituency or particular community of interest;
  3. in a personal capacity.

2.53 In all these roles and at all times, Ministers are expected to act lawfully and to behave in a way that upholds, and is seen to uphold, the highest ethical standards. Ultimately, Ministers are accountable to the Prime Minister for their behaviour.

So the question for the Prime Minister is has her Minister of Foreign Affairs acted in a way which has upheld the highest ethical standards in not just their ministerial capacity, but also their political and personal capacity.

2.55 All members of Parliament are required to disclose certain assets and interests in an annual Register of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament. This register, administered by the Registrar of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament, is designed to promote accountability and transparency by identifying personal financial interests that might influence members of Parliament.

We will come back to the Register of Pecuniary Interests.

2.56 Additional requirements apply to Ministers’ interests. Conflicts of interest may arise between Ministers’ personal interests and their public duty because of the influence and power that Ministers exercise, and the information to which they have access, both in the individual performance of their portfolio responsibilities and as members of the Executive.

In other words the bar for Ministers is even higher than for MPs.

2.59 Ministers themselves are responsible for proactively identifying and reviewing possible conflicts of interest and ensuring that any conflicts of interest are promptly addressed by taking one or more of the measures set out in paragraph 2.70.

Note the requirement to be pro-active in identifying conflicts. This may mean things like asking your lawyer who donated $100,000 to you.

2.78 The Standing Orders require members of Parliament to disclose to the Registrar of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament any gift accepted over a prescribed value, currently $500. This declaration includes hospitality and donations in cash or kind.

So a donation is a gift, and must be declared if over $500.

2.79 Ministers who accept gifts worth more than the prescribed value must not only disclose them to the Registrar of Pecuniary Interests of Members of Parliament, but also must relinquish them, unless they obtain the express permission of the Prime Minister to retain them.

Now it gets interesting. The PM gets to decide if you get to keep the gift. So Helen has to decide whether or not Winston can keep the $100,000 that was donated towards his legal expenses.

Now let us look at Standing Orders, namely Appendix B:

4(1)(d)Every return of pecuniary interests must contain the following information as at the effective date of the return: the name of each trust in which the member has a beneficial interest, and

And also let us look at the Register as at 31 January 2007,

4 Beneficial interests in trusts
WRP Family Trust

So if the bank account it was paid into is an actual trust fund that helps pays Winston’s legal bills – it is not listed as required.

Now let us look at Section 7(b)

a description of each gift (including hospitality and donations in cash or kind but excluding any donation made to cover expenses in an electoral campaign) received by the member that has an estimated market value in New Zealand of more than $500 and the name of the donor of each of those gifts (if known or reasonably ascertainable by the member),

Now even if (and it is a big if) Peters did not know the name of the donor, he did know there was a $100,000 donation towards his legal expenses and this was not declared. He should have declared an anonymous donation towards his legal expenses. He actually did not have to disclose the amount – but he did need it disclose the existence of it.

Now maybe you argue he did not receive the donation himself so let us turn to 7(c)

a description of all debts of more than $500 that were owing by the member that were discharged or paid (in whole or in part) by any other person and the names of each of those persons,

And we have been told these donations were to pay his legal bills and expenses. So it should have been declared under either 7(b) or 7(c). Unless you argue that the money went into a trust with a separate legal personality – but if that is the case then the trust should have been disclosed in Section 4(1)(d).

So who should sort this out. Here is one possibility:

15 Auditor-General’s review and inquiry
(1) The Auditor-General will review the returns provided under clause 14 as soon as is reasonably practicable.
(2) The Auditor-General may inquire, either on request or on the Auditor-General’s own initiative, into any issue as to whether—
(a) any member has complied, or is complying, with his or her obligations under this Appendix

So the Auditor-General could investigate. There is also another option:

Without limiting the generality of Standing Order 399, the House may treat as a contempt any of the following:

(h) as a member, knowingly providing false or misleading information in a return of pecuniary interests:

So an MP could ask the Speaker to refer the issue to the Privileges Committee. My suggestion would be both avenues – ask the Auditor-General to investigate and ask the Speaker to refer the issue to the Privileges Committee.

People may claim Peters did not know about the donation. Even if one accepts he did not know Owen Glenn made the donation, he did know that his legal expenses shortfall had suddenly reduced by $100,000 and failed to disclose it.

But also to the point, his lawyer Brian Henry would beyond any reasonable doubt be very very aware of the requirements placed on Peters by the Cabinet Manual and the Parliamentary Standing Orders. As his lawyer he would I suspect have professional and ethical obligations to make sure returns filed were correct and that Peters was in possession of the necessary information to make correct returns. I think there are as many questions for Mr Henry as Mr Peters about this.

So the issues are:

  1. Does Helen Clark think her Minister of Foreign Affairs has upheld the highest ethical standards in his ministerial, political and personal capacity?
  2. Will Helen Clark allow Winston Peters to retain the $100,000 gift from Owen Glenn – it is her decision as Prime Minister.
  3. Can the PM explain why the Government has reversed or is reviewing its position from 2003/04 on not needing a Consul in Monaco?
  4. Will an MP file a matter of privilege with the Speaker before the next sitting of the House on Tuesday?
  5. Will the Auditor-General investigate on his own initiative?
  6. Will the Inland Revenue Department investigate the tax status of the donation?

Poll Results

Curiablog has the details of the latest two polls, and will cover the two TV polls expected tomorrow. Also a Marae-Digipoll out tomorrow on Ikaroa-Rawhiti.

The graphic showing the rolling average hasn’t yet shown as updated, even though a new one has been uploaded. The WordPress site seems to cache material for a while and then suddenly the new one appears. So it should update soon.

Joan Peters

Death is never timely, but the death of Joan Peters is unfortunate timing especially as it comes in the midst of other issues for Winston.

That should not detract from genuine sympathy for the death. Despite being in her late 90s she was obviously still very much active, and with 11 children a special form of saint.

Dom Post on Walker case

I blogged earlier in the week that I thought the discharge without conviction for undesirable as it sent out a message cyber crimes are not real crimes.

The Dom Post Editorial agrees today:

Wander into a university, take to its computers with an axe and you’re likely to have some tough questions to answer, a conviction on your record and somewhat dimmed employment prospects, The Dominion Post writes.

Do the same thing using zombie armies of computers unleashed in the vast hunting grounds of the Internet to turn vulnerable PCs into spam-spewing monsters, give yourself a cool name and you can expect to stroll out of court. You’ll have an unblemished record because a conviction would dim your bright career prospects, a pat on the head from the judge for your high level of skills, and job offers galore – including from the police who caught you.

Yep a double standard.

We can but wonder what would happen if the approach taken by Justice Judith Potter, who discharged Owen Thor Walker without conviction after he pleaded guilty to six serious cyber crimes, was taken up across the board.

Young scamps who convert cars could be sent out on the roads to help motorists who have misplaced their keys. Producers of high-grade cannabis could be redeployed into the horticulture industry. Those skilled in the arcane art of cooking up particularly potent batches of P could be dispatched to the universities to help teach chemistry courses. Those most successful in peddling it could share their marketing skills in the same way.

Walker is young and autistic, which were no doubt factors. However these should have been factors in sentencing not a total discharge without conviction.

Hill Cone on ACC

Those who are against choice and competition for ACC should read Deborah Hill-Cone. Many small business owners will have similar experience:

Last year I paid my premium using internet banking. This was not easy as I had to ring them up to get the bank details – they refuse to put this on the invoice although surely it must be a popular way of paying bills these days. After I had paid it I received a letter saying I still owed the money. When I rang their call centre they told me to ignore the letter. Next, I received a letter from some debt collectors. This time when I rang ACC’s call centre they rummaged about and uncovered the till-now unknown fact I had two levies, one for me and one for my company (both for the same amount, hence the confusion) and I had only paid one. I immediately paid the other and thought the matter had been resolved, until I received a letter from ACC with a cheque saying I had paid double what I owed and they were sending half the money back. Argh.

I couldn’t face explaining ACC’s own error to them so I just tore up the cheque and figured we were square – bad idea, since it led to a another round of debt collector letters. Come to think of it, I am just hoping that the $887 is all I owe and there isn’t another premium lurking.

Considering stress is now considered a worplace hazard, it sounds like ACC is Deborah’s biggest OSH risk 🙂

Young on Peters

Audrey Young says the focus next week will be on Clark more than Peters due to the death of his mother. She is amazingly restrained in her story considering Winston Peters defamed her (he called her a liar) and tried to destroy her journalistic career:

Prime Minister Helen Clark is likely to feel the brunt of Opposition heat over the New Zealand First donation issue when Parliament resumes in three days.

It is apparent that she did not exert herself too much to get to the bottom of contradictions between what Winston Peters and Owen Glenn said – except to get an assurance from Peters that his party did not receive a donation.

We now know on the record that Glenn made what is effectuvely a personal secret donation to Clark’s Foreign Minister. He covered $100,000 of Winston’s legal expenses for him. And then proceeded to get lobbied by the man who is also Labour’s biggest donor to get himself appointed Consul. At the same time Mike Williams lobbied Helen Clark on the same issue, and the Government seemingly abandoned their previous position that there was no need for a Consul in Monaco.

Clark will no doubt be asked how having Ministers in her Government received secret $100,000 donations fits in with her claims of seeking transparency through the Electoral Finance Act. And even though this secret donation happened before the EFA was passed, it would have been able to remain legally secret even if made under the EFA.

Other questions to Clark may be around the Ministerial declaration of interests. Is it policy of her Government that Ministers do not have to delcare personal secret donations of $100,000 so long as their lawyer doesn’t tell them about the donations?

It is also interesting that those champions of electoral transparency, the Green Party MPs, have so far not said even one word on this issue. Could you imagine the legions of trees which would have been destroyed by now if this had happened in a National-led Government?

A quote from Winston

“It has everything to do with it. I say to Dr Mapp that is why we want to know who is backing National, because we are not going to have the kind of covert money that is destroying democracy in some countries in the Pacific today.”

– Rt Hon Winston Peters during the third reading of the Electoral Finance Bill, railing against “covert money”

Glenn donated $100,000 for Peter’s legal expenses

The truth has come out. Winston Peters has announced that Owen Glenn donated $100,000 in 2006 towards the costs of the Tauranga electoral petition.

Peters has said he knew nothing at all about this donation, until he was told today by his lawyer Brian Henry.

Amazing that Owen Glenn would know how to donate to the legal fund, and would never have mentioned at all to Winston that he had done so. And amazing that the legal fund is so robust that $100,000 turns up in it and you never ask your lawyer where it came from.

Anyway for a start Winston Peters owes Audrey Young a huge apology.

Friday Relaxation

If you’re bored at work on a Friday and need some stress relief, try these games I got e-mailed. They are both small excel files. In bang-bang you get to shoot people with a gun and in flitzebogen with a bow and arrow.

They’re not Grand Theft Auto 4, but they are free and fun and somewhat addictive!

Oh and if you actually own a long bow or a sniper rifle, and playing these games will make you more likely to go on a murderous rampage, then please don’t play. Unless you live in Palmerston North.

Another great authorisation statement

DPF on Agenda

I’ll be one of the two panelists on Agenda on Sunday (10 am TV One). Deborah Hill Cone is the other.

The main guest will be Rodney Hide on the future of ACT. Also Shaun Brown (former TVNZ journalist) on the French Nuclear Testing over Mururoa Atoll that he witnessed and the anti-nuclear protest under Kirk.

There is also a feature on the Dunedin South electorate and Clare Curran and David Benson-Pope.

Wellingtonians vote early and vote often

Ben Thomas on Winston

Ben Thomas has an excellent column in NBR today. It is not online, but here are some key extracts:

Union leader and former Alliance president Matt McCarten told TV3’s Sunrise programme that journalists were asking the wrong questions: that Peters could be believed when he assured them New Zealand First had never received a donation from Glenn.

That still left open the possibility, McCarten suggested, that Peters had a “leader’s fund” operating separately from his party and its accounts.

Indeed. McCarten is right that the questions need to be more focused.

A leader’s fund is nothing particularly sophisticated or technical in itself. It could mean a trust is set up to handle deposits from donors – or cake stalls – or these days it may mean just an additional cheque suffix on a politician’s online banking account. Or it could be handled by a close confidante or employee of the leader, who would probably not hold an official position in the party.

Hmmn a close confidante or employee.

So the possible existence of a New Zealand First leader’s fund is one possible explanation for why Glenn seems sure he donated money to New Zealand First but why Peters denies it.

New Zealand First’s president Dail Jones was corrected by Peters in February about where some cash – “closer to $100,000 than $10,000” – had come from last year in the party’s accounts.

What is interesting is that as far as I know, Jones has never publicly recanted from his view.

The question of whether Glenn donated to the party directly (if at all) is not a trivial one. In its 2007 donations returns to the Electoral Commission the party did not disclose any donations over $10,000.

And filing a false return has very serious penalties.

But if a donation over $10,000 was received anonymously, and New Zealand First didn’t disclose that to the Electoral Commission, then it breached the Electoral Act (that act still covers donations disclosures for the 2007 year). That’s an offence punishable by a $100,000 fine.

And up to two years in jail if done knowingly.

NZ First claimed it could not file its donations return while the leader, Peters, was out of the country. Yet the return disclosed no donations over $10,000 – that is, it was empty. That would seem to be a fairly straightforward document to sign off and one that could be accounted for without consultation with Peters.

I can’t think of any other party that would have the Leader involved in what is merely a statutory return.

The Electoral Commission has not made a decision on New Zealand First’s late return.

No, but they have on every other party that had a late return. They all got let off because they had “reasonable excuses”. The lack of a decision on NZ First suggests they are awaiting further information to determine if their excuse was reasonable or not.

It’s a murky position. And the public and media’s best efforts to trust Peters are not helped by his continued lack of disclosure around the role Tauranga man Tommy Gear plays in New Zealand First.

Indeed.

He was later found to be a staff member of Peters‘ office, although not in the Parliamentary phone directory. He also shares the same address as Peters on the electoral roll.

So WInston officially resides with Mr Gear. Sounds like hs is both a close confidante and a employee.

Should the census include sexual orientation?

An interesting article in the NZ Herald on the issue of whether there should be a question in the census on sexual orientation.

As someone who uses census data a lot, it would be incredibly interesting to have reliable information on sexual orientation demographics. There is almost no “hard” data anywhere in the world on how many people are gay, lesbian or bisexual. The old “common” figure of 10% is now widely seen as too high and 4% is thought to be closer.

Some will say, why should we even have demographic data on sexual orientation. Well for the same reasons we have data on gender, age, ethnicity, income, and location.

Now I’m one of those who wouldn’t care a fig if the census asked me my sexual orientation. However I can understand that it would be seen as pretty intrusive or worse by many respondents, and could affect the overall Census data.

And there is some potential for real problems to be caused in families. If you are bisexual and haven’t got around to mentioning this to your wife, then having her see you having ticked it on your census form isn’t the best way to let her know 🙂

Even if one got over the issue of alienating some respondents with such a question, a complicating issue is how do you define heterosexual, homosexual or bisexual.

Many homosexuals (well of those I know) have had sex with women. However they do not see themselves as bisexual. It was just a phase they say 🙂

The Dominion Post looks at this issue:

“Behaviour” describes whether someone’s partners are of the same or opposite sex; “identity” – their view of themselves as heterosexual, homosexual or bisexual; and “attraction”, which sex or sexes they are attracted to.

Again it is not as simple as people may think. A surprisingly high number of women (again based on people I know) have actually had sex or made out with another woman. But they don’t regard themselves as bisexual. It was just experimenting for many of them.

If I was designing the census I guess I would use the “attraction” definition as identity is so variable and behaviour may just reflect lack of opportunity or follow through.

Also please don’t turn this thread into a debate on what you think of homosexuals or lesbians. This is about whether we should have reliable data on the prevalance of various sexual orientations.

First dispatch online at NBR

My first column for NBR Online is up on their site. I forgot to give it a title, so it was given the simple name of “Dispatch #1”.

One extract:

In a sparse field, the winner is National’s ACC policy which gets a solid B. It would have got an A- but for some reason National is only pledging to “Investigate opening the Work Account to competition”. Good God, I hope the tax policy doesn’t become “Investigate reducing taxes”.

Comments can be left on the NBR site.