Moreu on Winston

National’s Housing Policy

It should be of no surprise to anyone that National is not planning to go back to market rents for state house tenants. It was arguably the most unpopular (yet most misunderstood) of National’s policies in the 1990s. National did not plan to change back in either 2002 or 2005.

Phil Heatley has outlined some aspects of National’s policy.

Housing spokesman Phil Heatley told a Housing Institute seminar in Waitakere yesterday that National would give back to Housing New Zealand tenants the right to buy their houses.

They had this right until the Labour Party won the 1999 election.

Labour call this privatisation but I think allowing state tenants to buy the homes they may have lived in for decades is a great thing.

“If they purchase their state home, we will replace that home within the housing stock so as to lift someone else off the waiting list,” he said.

“We won’t be running down the state housing stock. We acknowledge that we need it.”

If one has income related rents for state houses, then there will be great demand for them and hence stock does need to be maintained or increased. I personally prefer housing assistance being delivered to low income households regardless of who their landlord is – but that is now what the public will accept, so one has to make the current system work.

Labour’s Housing Minister, Maryan Street, told the seminar that 9 per cent of Housing NZ tenants already paid market rents because of their high incomes.

So no social benefit is being generated by those tenants being in Housing NZ houses. In theory they should be evicted to make room for a lower income family. But that is politically unviable. But National’s policy of allowing them to buy the state house will allow a new house to be purchased which can be targeted to low income families.

UPDATE: The Green’s Frog Blog say they support the policy as sensible and a good system for getting people into their own homes.

NZ Bloggers Union

A blog for the NZ Bloggers Union has been launched. The Union is compulsory, just like student associations. They explain:

If you are reading this and are a blogger based in or from New Zealand, then you are automatically a member. No matter your political persuasion, you are all members and we will be YOUR voice for Election 2008 and we will be YOUR voice for any other issue that takes our fancy. There is an objection clause if you choose to not take up membership but you will need to apply to the NZBU HQ and we will decide each case by merit – but who would want to leave when you will have a collective voice against the evil forces during election time.

Now they have reasons for their compulsion:

1) We need to be compulsory so that we represent every blogger. If we were fragmented we could not claim to represent all bloggers and would lose our voice!

2) It needs to be compulsory because we provide services to our members and cannot have freeloaders.

3) Paying levies is just like paying taxation. We provide services just like a government does. You cannot opt out of paying tax just like you cannot opt out of paying levies.

4) If membership was voluntary, nobody will join and everybody will lose out.

5) The vibrant blogging community would die out if we didn’t have a compulsory bloggers union.

Those arguments sound very familiar.

The NZBU will speak for and on behalf of bloggers like Jordan Carter, Tony Milne, The Standard, Robinsod, 08wire, No Right Turn, Jafapete, Sonic, Frog Blog, Public Address as well as other bloggers from all political persuasions.

That’s very good of them to agree to be represented by the Bloggers Union. Oh wait they had no choice. Just like all those students forced to join their student union.

I believe Winston

Winston says that donations by wealthy racing industry families did not affect NZ First’s racing policy.

I actually believe him on this.

I generally have a firm view that money follows policies, not policies follow money. Unions donate money to Labour because they like their policies, Labour doesn’t design policies just to attract donations from unions.

But here is Winston’s problem. He has spent over 15 years alleging that policies do follow money. That MPs are venal and corrupt and will sell favours to donors.

So if people see something wrong with the Velas donating to NZ First, it is because of the climate that Winston and others have created.

Take National’s ACC policy. Now National introduced private competition to ACC in 1998, and had it as policy in 2002 and 2005 and again in 2008. National is a party which for 50 years has generally favoured more private sector involvement.

So I see nothing sinister in National’s ACC policy. But Winston and his mates allege (without foundation) that the policy was purchased by the insurance industry through alleged donations to National.

The mythical $1 million donation would seem an incredible waste of money to “buy” a policy considering National has had the same policy for over a decade.

So Winston is a victim of his own scandal-mongering. He can’t get away with a stance that other parties sell their policies to large secret donors, but he does not.

Winston says the donations are all legal. Yes indeed they appear to be. However it is apparent that arrangements were made to allow one family to donate in excess of the disclosure limit through (legally) routing it through different people and companies. Just as National has legally routed donations through its former Trusts. Perfectly legal, but designed to avoid disclosure of large donors.

So I do believe Winston in relation to the Velas. He has not (from evidence to date) broken any law and I don’t think he exchanged policies for donations.

But the reason people think that the donations may have influenced his policy, is beacuse Winston keeps insisting that is what parties and politicians do – sell their policies to donors. It is a classic case of tainted by your own rhetoric.

Winston’s computer code

PM of NZ has supplied this useful computer code:

>PROC DONATE()
> //open source rocks. no warranty. void where prohibited.

> var depositaccount=$0; //type currency

> WHILE (OG_NOT_CONSUL)
> .. depositaccount = depositaccount + 100K
> .. TRANSFERBALANCE(anyAccount)
> .. DO_NOT_DECLARE()
> ENDWHILE

> CALL INTENSE_MEDIA_SCRUTINY(answer=NO)

> IF answer = yes
> .. IF Country=’NZ’ THEN
> .. . CALL PM(‘not my problem’)
> .. . CALL SPEAKER(‘no laws broken, nothing to see here, move along‘)
> .. . FREE WinstonFirst()
> .. ELSE //any other country in the world
> .. . suspect:=defendant
> .. . status:=guilty
> .. . punishment:=max(long_jail_term(‘corruption’))
> .. . TOAST(suspect, status, punishment)
> .. . CALL SNAP_ELECTION()
> .. ENDIF
> ENDIF

> IF suspect == ‘Liarbour Foreign Minister’ and country=’NZ’ THEN
> .. CALL INSTRUCT_LAWYER(‘deny all knowledge’)
> .. CALL MOUTH_OFF(‘abuse media’)
> .. CALL MOUTH_OFF(‘threaten to sue)
> .. CALL AFFAIRS_OF_STATE(‘Condi’)
> .. DONATE(startover)
> ELSE
> .. SERVE_TIME()
> .. REPENT()
> .. BREAKLOOP()
> ENDIF

> ENDPROCxx

Very well done.

H/T: Original concept done at Crime Doesn’t Pay – NZ Conservative

Chris Trotter’s stereotypes

I’ve been so busy with Winston, that I have overlooked Chris Trotter’s appalling column in the SST. It basically tries to scare people off voting National because of the company you will be keeping – the evil cockies, reactionaries and rich.

And let us look at how he describes them:

THE COCKIES: Backbone of the nation; earners of our overseas funds; selfish; insular; and possessed of an indefatigable sense of moral superiority over everyone whose front door looks out upon a street instead of a paddock.

THE RICH: Creators of wealth; makers of jobs; robbers of rights; bastardisers of culture; selfish; arrogant; and possessed of an indefatigable sense of moral superiority over everyone whose income is less than $100,000 per annum.

THE REACTIONARIES: Defenders of the faith; upholders of decent family values; sadistic; bigoted; deranged hankerers after a world that – thankfully – has long since passed away.

The only person in the article with a sense of moral superiority is Chris Trotter.

Imagine if a right wing columnist wrote a column sneering at the poor, the workers and the beneficiaries?

As a supporter of civil unions, prostitution law reform etc I’m hardly a reactionary, but I don’t label those who disagree with me on those issues as sadistic, bigoted and deranged as Trotter does.

Around 80% of Trotter’s columns are excellent and praised by right and left for their analysis.

But a growing number are to be blunt, just offensive – the justified corruption defence regarding the pledge card column and now this one.

Fairfax papers on Peters

Also some stories in the Fairfax group. First Martin Kay:

Prime Minister Helen Clark is seeking advice on whether Winston Peters should hand over the $100,000 donated by shipping billionaire Owen Glenn under rules requiring ministers to disclose gifts.

Miss Clark told Parliament she wanted to know if the donation, to help pay Mr Peters’ legal bills from his failed court bid to overturn the 2005 Tauranga result, counted as a gift under the Cabinet Manual.

Under those rules, ministers must relinquish gifts worth more than $500 unless they have the prime minister’s express permission to retain them.

This is Clark’s nightmare – that she has to decide whether or not it is okay for Peters to benefit from a $100,000 gift from a person who was lobbying him to be given a diplomatic appointment.

Clark initially said it definitely was not a gift under the Cabinet rules, so she is backing down from that position.

It will be interesting who she gets advice from. If it is from the Cabinet Office it will be pretty straight advice. If it is from Crown Law I predict it will say it is not a gift! Crown Law can be relied upon to please their client.

It is the first time Miss Clark has acknowledged the donation has a ministerial dimension after days of insisting it is an issue for Mr Peters and NZ First, not for her as prime minister.

Yep it is significant.

Colin Espiner writes:

Peters said he had broken no laws and he was also “confident” he had not misled Parliament.

He said that “big money” had been paid to dig up dirt on him, including by TVNZ, which had hired two detectives to investigate him.

Really. Someone should put that allegation to TVNZ.

NZ First MPs on their way into Parliament yesterday refused to talk to reporters, although deputy leader Peter Brown called out that he had “no concerns” about Peters.

I suspect Peter Brown could walk into a room where Winston is brutally stabbing someone to death, and cheerfully walk out of it and declare he has no concerns about Peters. There is loyalty, there is blind loyalty and then that special brand of it in NZ First.

Herald stories on Winston

Let us start with John Armstrong:

If that was not enough, there were further shockwaves with yesterday’s Dominion Post making fresh allegations surrounding NZ First’s handling of donations, questions about whether the racing industry source of those donations has compromised Peters as Minister of Racing and claims that taxpayers paid his lawyer’s legal bills through Parliamentary Service funding.

Those allegations were largely unsubstantiated, making it fairly easy for someone with Clark’s experience to bat away the resulting questions. She may have only brief respite, however. The confidence with which the newspaper made the claims suggests it has the documentation to back them up – with maybe more to come.

Indeed, and remember Phil Kitchin here is the journalist who exposed Donna Awatere-Huata and the Police misconduct in Rotorua.

Peters dismissed the article as “a smear campaign of unsubstantiated allegations”. But Clark realises, even if Peters won’t, that such responses are no longer satisfactory given the seriousness of the allegations he is facing.

Well they had a photocopy of a cheque on their frontpage. That seems to have a degree of substantiation. But as Armstrong notes, Peters has problems claiming it is all lies, because he said exacly that about the NZ Herald e-mail. He said they fabricated the e-mail and that they were lying and they were not.

She urgently needs to move this dreadful mess off centre-stage – both for her sake and Peters’. She has accordingly dropped big hints to relevant Government agencies to investigate the claims if they see fit.

Those agencies are an ever-lengthening list – Auditor-General Kevin Brady; the Registrar of MPs’ Pecuniary Interests, Dame Margaret Bazley; the Electoral Commission; Inland Revenue; Parliament’s Speaker and privileges committee; the Cabinet Office; and even – as Clark mentioned – the police.

Ever since the issues of Taito Philip Field, I have believed that NZ now needs an Independent Commission against Corruption that has powers to investigate all aspects of corrupt or highly unethical behaviour from Ministers, MPs and other very senior holders of public office. Having six different inquiries taking place like a fragmented jigsaw is not as good as one competent investigation with full powers.

I would love National to pledge to establish such a Commission. It would be a noble thing for them to do, as their own Ministers would be the first one to be subject to its scrutiny – but it is needed as we have seen in recent years with Field, Awatere-Huata, the various Immigration Service affairs, the Benson-Pope affair etc.

Audrey Young reports:

Questions were also raised in Parliament as to whether Mr Peters declared that his party had received substantial donations from the racing industry, where the Vela brothers are big players, before negotiating the post of Racing Minister with the Prime Minister.

And then proceeding to force Cullen to such generous funding of the racing industry that they ignored strong Treasury advice against it.

Incidentally while the Velas have New Zealand citizenship, like Owen Glenn, I understand they are (or were at least) officially foreign residents and only visitors to NZ for tax purposes . So once again the great crusader againgst foreign investment is revealed as having his major funders being foreign residents.

New Zealand First did not dispute reports that Mr Henry had been paid an amount from the Parliamentary Service last year but that is understood to have been for contracted work on the Electoral Finance Bill, not for litigation.

Jesus Christ – $45,000 for advice on the Electoral Finance Bill. Considering how often NZ First keep breaking their own law, they should ask for a refund.

But she appeared to be thrown by a question from Green Party co-leader Russel Norman on non-declaration of possible conflicts of interest.

He asked: “Can the Prime Minister tell us whether the Minister of Foreign Affairs was involved in negotiating the very substantial tax breaks that this Government has delivered to the racing industry; if so, in those negotiations, did he declare the very substantial donations that New Zealand First had received from the racing industry?”

After over a week of silence, it is good to see the Green Party finding its voice.

Mr Peters’ New Zealand First colleagues all took turns to ask questions focused on an aspect of his achievements as Foreign Minister.

This was so sad, I actually felt sorry for them. Like lemmings, one after another asked a pitifully sycophantic question to Helen lauding the fact Winston had gouged the taxpayer for more money for MFAT or the such. None of them were allowed to even try and engage on the central issue of the secret donations.

What was also interesting is that NZ First asked more than their four allocated supplementaries which means Labour must have donated some of their quota to their good mates in NZ First.

Mark Keating does an op-ed on the taxation issues around the donation. This is a fuller version of what I summarised yesterday. I did find this line very funny:

Mark Keating is a senior lecturer in tax law at (ironically) the Owen G. Glenn Business School of the University of Auckland

Heh.

Finally we have Rod Emmerson:

Just spot on.

Hilarious

If people want a laugh they should listen to Matthew Hooton and Laila Harre on Nine to Noon with Kathryn Ryan on Monday.

At one stage during the debate Matthew refers to Winston Peters as a charlatan. Kathryn suggests this is an inappropriate term for a senior Minister and MP. This of course leads Matthew to insist several more times that Peters however is a charlatan to Ryan’s growing frustration.

However it is game set and match hilariously when Laila Harre pops up at the end of the exchange and says that she also thinks Peters is a charlatan 🙂

Harre is absolutely firm on condemning Peters. One of those rare times her and Hooton are in broad agreement.

The tax on the $100,000

The media have started to look at the tax issues around the secret $100,000 donation. It is indeed quite probable that there is an unresolved tax issue around it.

A tax lawyer has helpfully made the following points to me:

  • Normally gifts are not considered to be income but it can extend to include “gifts” given for extra services or additional benefits beyond expectation.
  • If Owen Glenn gave the $100,000 as a mark of satisfaction with Winston’s past services as an MP or in the expectation of some future benefit to be bestowed, then the money would constitute income.
  • It is irrelevant that the money was paid to Brian Henry and not to Winston personally. The Income Tax Act is very clear that, as it was Winston’s legal bill that was being paid, it would be his income.
  • Bank and lawyers’ trust account records are not protected by legal privilege. The Tax Administration Act expressly states IRD can have access to all financial records. There is no “privilege” in payments, only in legal advice.
  • Even if the secret donation is not treated as income for Winston, and is a “genuine gift” then the Estate and Gift Duties Act applies.
  • A gift of $100,000 would attract gift duty of $12,850.
  • When a gift is made, the Act requires the person making the gift to pay the duty within three months.
  • If the giver does not do so, the liability automatically passes to the recipient who must then pay the gift duty.
  • A failure to do so constitutes a criminal offence under the Tax Administration Act.
  • Interest and penalties on any gift duty not paid on time would have more than doubled the original $12.850 owing.

Now assuming it is seen as a gift and not income for services provided, it is possible Owen Glenn paid the gift duty. If he did not then it sounds unlikely it has been paid, as Henry and Peters keep arguing it is not a gift. That means the liability would still be resting with Peters.

A busy week

Has been a busy few days. In the last week or so I have:

  • Spoken to the Kapiti Rotary Club
  • Done a TV3 Sunrise interview
  • Done an interview for One News
  • Also a longer interview for TVNZ7 News at 8
  • Been on Agenda
  • Spoke to a 20/20 Comms Trust/UNESCO seminar on the impact of Identity and Location Services
  • Interviews on Newstalk ZB and Radio Live

Agenda went well I thought. Danyl made an interesting comment:

There was a weird bolsheviks v mensheviks vibe to the Rodney Hide appearance on Agenda this morning. The two ‘commentators’ were National activist David Farrar and media village idiot Deborah Hill-Cone, both of whom are sympathetic to ACT ideology (if not the party itself). They grilled Hide aggressively over his failure to grow the party – much more so than any independent or left-wing analysts would have done.

When I am in roles like this, I think I probably do push harder those I am more naturally in agreement with. I remember also pushing Gerry Brownlee when he appeared quite hard on the Brian Connell issue.

Danyl also notes:

And the fix appears to be in in regards to the Agenda book club, with the book on Jim Bolger being won by former Bolger staffer and Agenda commentator David Farrar! Highly suspicious!

Heh the prize was for knowing the nickname of the Air Force plane Bolger used to fly on – Spud One of course!

The seminar yesterday at Vic (Pipitea) was fascinating – both in terms of content and the technology involved. We were luckly to have the Government’s overall CIO speaking and the proposed online identity verification service sounds just nifty.

The seminar was connected by access grid to four other sites. Vic’s Kelburn campus and also Otago, Canteerbury and Auckland Universities.

This is it in action. The video linkup was excellent and good quality. Sadly the audio failed for us and all the other campuses could hear us (which was okay as the speakers were in Wellington) but we could not hear them. We coped with a mixture of sign language and e-mails.

My contribution was on the benefits, risk and issues around the combining of identity with location (GPS) services. I am hugely keen on the benefits but there are some potentially nasty aspects which will post challenges.

Congratulations Keith

Quote of the Week

Scrubone comments on a new blog called The Hairy Armpit which is meant to be rather offensive. It is being talked about a bit because Russell Brown was happy to link to it but not happy to link to Whale Oil.

Personally I don’t care who links to who, but I did love Scrubone’s description of The Hairy Armpit:

The irony was that it was a post from Russel at Hard News where he refused to link to Whaleoil. Frankly, if you turned Cam into a women, feminist, cut of a leg or something to make him really mad then removed his remaining inhibitions and decency via a combination of “P” (Ice for you foreign looking types :P ) and acid then you’d get the Hairy Armpit.

I now have a visual image of Cameron as a one legged woman high on P and acid!

Garner calls on Peters to resign

Yay at long last TV3 Political Editor Duncan Garner is blogging, and he says what he thinks on it:

To believe Winston requires you to believe the unbelievable.

Like;

When Winston Peters held up the big NO sign in February in response to questions about whether Glenn had donated money, Winston’s lawyer Brian Henry didn’t pick up the phone either before and after – and say arrrrhhhh, Winston, he flicked us 100k 18 months ago.

And remember this so called policy of Henry’s is not required by any outside force. It is in fact just a decision made between him and Peters that allegedly he would not tell Peters who donated. Now the reason you would do this is to protect Peters, but when it becomes clear that more damage is being done by not telling him, it is almost unthinkable he would not have told him earlier.

Peters credibility has been damaged. He’s turning defence into attack. It’s all he’s got left. Helen Clark’s silence is remarkable but not surprising. She needs him if her Government is to make it through to the election.

Remember when Phillip Field’s discretions were only “judgement issues” according to Helen Clark. Lets see what the judge says about those “judgement issues.”

Yes Clark has a fine track record here.

Auditor General Kevin Brady should investigate Peters. He’s nailed Labour before. He’s got the guts to nail Peters. The IRD should look at the tax status of the donation. The Privileges Committee should start its kangaroo court – at least it would provide some theatre.

Agreed.

Peters may have used up his nine lives. He voted to end secret and covert funding – yet took it on the side. Indeed, it was so secret, we’re meant to believe he didn’t even know.

He should resign. The saga is a disgrace. And on his way out he should apologise to the NZ Herald Political Editor Audrey Young who broke the story.

That is a big call, but a correct one. If after the revelation he had admitted the public has (as John Key puts it) been misled by him, then maybe it is survivable. But his outrageous continuing attacks on the NZ Herald for exposing his secret donation are the worse form of bully boy politics.

Imagine if the Exclusive Brethren loving Nats had denied getting 100k then coughed up under pressure.

Would Peters go easy on John Key? Would Helen Clark stay silent, muttering, “it’s a party matter”? You know the answer.

And imagine Phil Goff? I think his head would actually explode as he shouted himself hoarse on it!

Is the Dominion Post also a liar?

Winston Peters labelled the NZ Herald Political Editor a liar, and is still calling on her and the Editor to resign. No-one can quite work out what for, but he is insistsing they should apologise to him and resign, despite the fact their work exposed the secret $100,000 donation to pay off Winston’s legal bills.

Now it seems they are also calling the Dominion Post liars. Today the Dom Post reveals:

The Dominion Post can reveal Mr Henry also received at least $45,000 for legal services – paid for by Parliamentary Service funds last year.

They seem very certain of their claim.

Asked to comment on whether taxpayer funds were used to pay Mr Henry, Mr Peters said through a spokesman: “That is a lie.”

Well who is telling the truth?

Incidentally it can be quite legitimate for parliamentary funds to include legal expenses – if they are tied to their parliamentary duties. But NZ First has not claimed that any payments to Henry were for legitimate parliamentary purposes. They have claimed there was never any payment at all.

It would be very unfortunate for them if the Dominion Post has proof to back up their claim!

Ansell and ACT part ways

The Herald reports that John Ansell is no longer working on the ACT campaign. It doesn’t sound like a big bust up, just one of those disagreements over the extent of the role not being what was wanted.

It will be a blow to ACT as John is very highly regarded for his creative nous.

Ironically sort of good news for me, as John has done work for the anti-EFA campaign and we still have a wee bit of money left over which we need to spend before the election!

The hypocrisy of Peters

Claire Trevett in the NZ Herald does a first class job of skewering Peters with his own hypocrisy:

If Winston Peters had succeeded in getting a bill for tough disclosure laws through Parliament in 1995, he could now have found himself jailed by his own law.

Ouch.

Mr Peters has spent his career railing against secret donations, including presenting a bill to Parliament in 1995 which required disclosure of all gifts and donations above $500 from individuals and companies.

The Disclosure of Political Donations and Gifts Bill covered all kinds of donations to MPs, candidates or parties and any who failed to declare them faced jail for up to 12 months or fines of up to $20,000.

Wait, wait – let’s just make the law retrospective!

The bill was part of a campaign against links between big business and political parties that Mr Peters openly admitted was to “seriously damage the ability of the National Party to raise funds from corporate supporters without that fact becoming public knowledge”. In its first reading, he said “comprehensive and timely disclosure” of gifts and donations was essential to bring “undue influence … out of the shadows”.

So let us make sure we have this right. Peters proposed a law to bring donations out of the shadows, and then when the NZ Herald sucessfully exposes a $100,000 donation to his legal expenses, he calls on them to resign in disgrace?

“It seeks to reassure the public that influence cannot be bought when policy is formed before an election, that the voting intentions of those they elected cannot be subverted by powerful interests and that governments, once in power, cannot be improperly influenced by money pledged towards their re-election.”

Hmmn, improper influence. You mean such as having someone lobby to be given a diplomatic appointment who has publicly donated the PM’s party $500,000, secretly loaned them $100,000 interest free and secretly paid off $100,000 from the Foreign Minister’s legal expenses?

Or do you mean offering a small party $250,000 to support the Government after the election?

However, it is not the first time money from unknown sources has appeared to pay Mr Peters’ legal funds. In 1997 a mystery donor paid Mr Peters’ $125,000 bill in the Selwyn Cushing defamation case after Mr Peters was fined $75,000 in costs and $50,000 in damages for comments he made about Mr Cushing.

Seeing Brian Henry has revealed who donated the $100,000 in 2006, maybe he could reveal who paid the $125,000 in 1997?

Mr Peters has also criticised parties for appointing donors to Government-selected positions.

He said giving jobs in return for political donations was “the way it goes, unfortunately, in this country”.

He said a separate commission should be established to appoint people to such positions.

And Mr Peters would like to nominate Mr Owen Glenn and Mr Brian Henry to sit on that commission 🙂

$150,000 from the Velas to NZ First

Phil Kitchin’s investigative prowess is at work, as he reveals up to $150,000 of donations to NZ First from the Vela family to NZ First or Winston Peters.

A special investigation by The Dominion Post can reveal that a series of donations from accounts linked to the Vela family – heavyweight operators in the racing and fishing industries – and totalling at least $150,000 were made to the party.

But NZ First sources say nothing like that much Vela money was deposited in the party’s bank account.

Well they seem to have so many. Their main account. Then the secret one that not even Party President Dail Jones knew about. And then the other secret one for Winston’s legal expenses.

The Vela family has an estimated wealth of $180 million, according to the National Business Review’s 2007 rich list.

The cheques from Vela family fishing and thoroughbred companies were written out to NZ First from around the year 1999 to 2003.

Hmmn isn’t Winston Minister of Racing? And hasn’t he delivered a massive amount of money to the industry? And he has been very involved in fisheries issues also as an MP.

The Vela donations were made in accordance with electoral laws, which allow sums of less than $10,000 to be donated anonymously.

Yes and no. If over a calendar year they exceeded $10,000 from the same source then they must be disclosed.

It is understood most of the cheques were collected by Ross Meurant when he worked for NZ First as an adviser to Mr Peters.

Mr Meurant, a former National MP, was at that time also a fellow director and shareholder of Digital Global Maps Ltd with Philip Vela, a senior family figure.

It is understood Mr Meurant sometimes worked out of Vela’s offices at Te Rapa, Hamilton, while advising Mr Peters.

Meurant was actually employed by The Parliamentary Service, not NZ First. It is an usual situation to have a parliamentary employee collecting money for a party. It is also unusual to ave a barrister touting for money to pay his own legal bills!

The cheques were understood to be for amounts of $10,000 or less – which meant they did not need to be declared, unless the party knew it was receiving more than $10,000 from the same company or person in a calendar year.

Yes.

The Dominion Post understands the cheques were written out to NZ First from Vela bank accounts including PJ Vela, PM Vela, Vela Fishing, Vela Quota Number 1 and Number 2 accounts and Pencarrow Stud.

Now if these were all seperate legal entities – ie seperate companies and people, then they avoid disclosure. But if they are just seperate bank accounts for the same entity, then you have to add them together.

The ones I would be interested in are Vela Quota Number 1 and Number 2. Are they seperate companies or seperate bank accounts for the same company?

Unanswered Questions

So much to report today, so where do we start. Say the Herald:

The Prime Minister gave cautious support to Winston Peters last night as fallout from his about-face on his $100,000 donation continued.

Helen Clark also risked a backlash from the volatile New Zealand First leader and Foreign Minister by publicly saying that the Owen Glenn email the Herald published had been “right” in that Mr Glenn believed he had given money to Mr Peters.

The fact Peters is still vilifying the Herald, despite the reality their work led to the disclosure of the secret donation, is very ugly and must be unsettling many of his own MPs, let alone Labour ones.

Asked if Mr Peters’ story was credible, Helen Clark said yesterday: “I’m in a position that Mr Peters is an honourable member [of Parliament] and I must accept his word unless I have evidence to the contrary.”

Well there is considerable evidence to the contrary. Not slam dunk proof, but enough to pose real credibility issues. Does Helen Clark really really think Owen Glenn never ever mentioned his donation (or at least the intention) to donate during one of their many meetings? Does that fit in with the Owen Glenn she knows?

She noted that Mr Henry backed what Mr Peters had said, and he had professional obligations to the Law Society.

Mr Henry is not a party to any private conversations between Glenn and Peters.

National leader John Key has urged Mr Peters to apologise to the Herald and to the public.

“Clearly he has received a donation and he has either misled the public wittingly or unwittingly.

It is good to see National directly criticising the behaviour, and I think the terminology is very wisely picked. Rather than get into semantics about whether Peters told the literal truth, they have focused on the fact the statements were misleading (a true statement can be very misleading).

The Herald has five unanswered question:

  1. What did Owen Glenn think he was giving $100,000 to?
  2. Did Owen Glenn ever talk to Winston Peters about making a donation?
  3. Who told Winston Peters’ lawyer to approach Owen Glenn for a donation?
  4. Why did Winston Peters not ask his lawyer if the rumoured Glenn donation had paid legal fees before Mr Peters held up the NO sign?
  5. Why did Winston Peters’ lawyer not tell his client about the donation when Glenn was publicly lobbying for the Monaco job in February?

I have many more such as:

  1. Who was the cheque actually made out to?
  2. What actual bank account was it paid into?
  3. When was it paid?
  4. Was the close to $100,000 amount in Dec 2007 mentioned by Dail Jones connected to this donation?
  5. Was tax paid on the donation?
  6. What caused the Government to review the 2004 decision not to have a Consul in Monaco?
  7. How often has Owen Glenn and Winston Peters met, and when?

Was it worth it?

The Herald reports:

Fewer than half New Zealand’s young children are thought to be still protected against the meningococcal disease epidemic, despite a $200 million mass vaccination campaign.

So we know the cost. What are the benefits?

The centre’s clinical director, Dr Nikki Turner, said yesterday the mass campaign was justified,”because we are talking about a reduction in disease and deaths in children … “

Obviously a good thing, but more specifically:

Statisticians have calculated that in the two years after it started, the vaccination programme prevented 54 cases of disease and 1.7 deaths.

Now it seems very heartless but agencies over the years have a value for a human life, so that decisions can be made on whether a particular road improvement or new drug etc is worth investing in. It used to be $2 million and I think might now be $5 million. Someone out there will know.

Is $200 million a good investment for preventing 2 deaths and 54 infections? Purely on a numbers basis, it is arguable it was not.

Now again, this may seem a harsh judgement. But the reality is, money is limited. Another way to look at it, is could more lives have been saved if the $200 million had instead been spent on elective surgery or Herceptin?

Now I am not saying conclusively the campaign was a bad idea. One should not decide those things off a newspaper story. There will be a mass of data to be considered. But on the face of it, it does appear to have been of debatable value for the investment.

No Right Turn on Peters

Idiot/Savant at No Right Turn calls for Peters to be sacked:

The Prime Minister responded today to Winston Peters’ admission that, contrary to his earlier denials, he had been $100,000 by Owen Glenn, calling it “embarrassing”. It’s a little more than that. Not only did Peters violate Parliament’s Standing Orders on the declaration of gifts (something which Rodney Hide will be complaining about today) – he also violated Cabinet guidelines. The Cabinet Manual has extensive sections on Ministerial conduct and the acceptance of gifts. The short version: Ministers must clearly distinguish between their personal interests and their Ministerial roles, declare all pecuniary interests, and refuse all gifts except from close family members. This includes both cash and donations in kind: …

He should have declared it, and then relinquished it. He did neither. And this is something no Prime Minister should accept. The Cabinet rules on gifts are there for a real purpose: to prevent corruption, and the perception of corruption. Peters has blatantly violated those rules, and for that he must either offer his resignation or be sacked.

Plus he should be made to pay the $100,000 back. Unless Helen authorises him to keep it as a golden handshake.

Unfortunately, I rate the odds of the Prime Minister having a spine on this about as highly as I rate those of Parliament’s “all powerful” (where do the journalists get that phrase from?) Privileges Committee finding that Peters violated Standing orders. The realities of MMP mean Peters has a gun to the Prime Minister’s head – she can’t fire him, regardless of his egregious behaviour, unless she wants her tenure as PM to end prematurely in a messy coalition collapse. Unfortunately, this means she and her party get to go down with him, because I do not think that the image of a PM permitting Ministers to receive donations in brown paper bags from people who want favours from them is one the public will accept.

Clark will show no spine on this. But I think she will regret this. She should live up to her many words of the need for transparency in political financing.

I have to say I would like National to be somewhat more forceful on this also. I understand targeting Clark (esp as Peters is away) and her responses is the main priority for the Opposition, but they do need to be very very clear that this sort of behaviour would not be tolerated in a National-led Government where it is okay for Ministers to personally benefit by $100,000 from someone seeking favours from them.

I/S is right that one of the weaknesses of MMP is MPs in minor parties can get away with behaviour, other parties could not.

As for the Privileges Committee, let’s look at that. I am assuming that there is absolutely no doubt the Speaker will have to refer the issue to them. The threshold is merely that here is a question to answer, and no one could possibly argue there isn’t at least a question to answer. This is not the same as saying the verdict is beyond doubt. Until we know who the cheque was actually made out to, and which bank account it went into, one can not be conclusive on these things.

So who makes up the Privileges Committee. Let us first look at who is on there will will try hard to make the thing go away:

Labour – Cullen, Dalziel, Fairbrother, Swain – 4
NZ First – Peters (will be a sub for him – any other MP except Dail Jones I predict) – 1
Greens – Turei – 1

Some may argue Turei will show integrity and actually support motions to order copies of the accounts, invite Owen Glenn to testify etc etc. But considering the silence of the Greens to date, I am not optimistic.

Now who on there may reasonably be regarded as likely to vote for a full investigation?:

National – Brownlee, Guy, Mapp, Power (Chair) – 4
United Future – Dunne – 1
Maori Party – Harawira – 1
ACT – Hide (will be Roy if he makes the complaint) – 1

So by a 7-6 majority (or 8-5 if I am pleasantly surprised), the Privileges Committee should be able to exercise some independence from the Government line. Peter Dunne is a Minister of course but I actually have considerable faith that he will be offended by what has happened and want a full accounting.

Because of this the Government will be lobbying Margaret Wilson furiously to find a way not to send it to Privileges Committee. But the problem they have is that this is a near perfect fit as a question of privilege. The paying off of a debt on an MP’s behalf is explicitly listed as an item for inclusion in the register. Winston and Brian Henry have both admitted the debts are in his name and he is liable for any shortfall. And the burden of proof here is not beyond reasonable doubt – just that there is a question to be answered.

UPDATE: Former Chair/Spokesperson of the Young Greens, George Darroch, has blogged. He notes:

David Farrar correctly notes that left blogs have for the most part have ignored the Winston Peters donation scandal. And so far, that has included this blog. I have no ordinary desire to write about that man and his party, they disgust me enough that I feel dirty even mentioning their names.

If you lie with the dogs, you’re sure to catch fleas. Labour made their bed, they shouldn’t expect sympathy.

Now, Labour Party activists will tell me that they had no options after the 05 election. I don’t believe them. The Māori Party talked with the Labour Party after the election about coming to an arrangement, most likely support on confidence and supply.  It would have meant the Labour Party being humble, certainly, and the repeal of the Seabed and Foreshore Act. There would have been other things that were hard to swallow. The relations between Clark and Māori Party in the years previous, and the fact that Labour’s biggest donor Owen Glenn had also patronised the party by offering $250,000 in return for a guarantee of support probably didn’t help.

It is a very valid point. Helen Clark chose Winston over the Maori Party and the Greens. She never even tried to negotiate a deal with them.

NZ First opposed Pecuniary Interests Register

I’ve just dug up the Hansard relating to when Parliament created the Register of Pecuniary Interests for MPs. The only two parties against were NZ First and ACT. Some quotes:

PETER BROWN: … This is a case of much ado about nothing. There is little corruption in politics in this country, and the corruption that has occurred has been targeted, found out, and exposed. We do not have to have this sort of carry-on in order to declare a war on corruption. It has no relevance to that, at all. As I said, this is a nosy parker amendment to the Standing Orders. …

This measure is a sop to the Greens. I hope it is the only one, because they will disappear at the end of this Parliament, and we can forget all about them. This measure is unnecessary; it is a mistake. It will encourage nosy parkers, and in the longer term it will discourage able people from putting their names forward to stand for Parliament. New Zealand First opposes this measure vehemently.

I am sure that opposition was indeed vehement.

The silence of the left

It has now been over two and a half days since the explosive news that Owen Glenn did donate $100,000 – to Winston Peters’ legal expenses. Regardless of the legal issues over technicalities this is a major political issue regarding transparency – especially as Glenn was lobbying Peters (and Clark via Williams) for a diplomatic appointment.

So how have the major left wing blogs covered the issue?

The Greens’ Frog Blog has not said a word (except for a humourous reference in passing) yet has managed almost a dozen posts on other issues . And what of the Greens MPs? Russel Norman spoke volumes on National’s secret trusts. Has he not been motivated to even say a single word of concern?

Russell Brown devotes oh one paragraph to it today, and expresses no view at all on the rights or wrongs. He merely finds it funny that it involves a stolen e-mail. On that issue Russell might note that Owen Glenn has not in any way claimed the e-mail was stolen or that he is upset it was. He may like to reflect on why that is!

No Right Turn has, as expected, condemned it. While sometimes I get very upset with his posts (and I am sure vice verssa) he does consistently show the difference between a principled left blog and one which doesn’t want to upset mates in Government.

Tim Selwyn at Tumeke puts himself in the same category as No Right Turn, with his post.

The Standard has managed five posts since then, and of course none at all on the issue. When they do blog, it will be to say that it is all nothing to do with Helen.

The self-proclaimed funny and cool 08wire (run by a recent former staffer for Clark) hasn’t managed to find anything funny to say on the issue.

It would be too much to expect Labour candidates Grant and Jordan to have commented, but how about Tony Milne?

The Progressive’s unofficial Prog Blog has said nothing on the issue.

Some of the smaller blogs have commented I am sure – I’ve only had time to check the larger ones out.

The correct way to do it

Nick Smith also has a trust fund to help with his legal expenses. Unlike Winston, Nick’s expenses are because he is being sued, not because he initiaties law suits himself.

Anyway if you look at the 2008 Register of MPs’ Pecuniary Interests, Nick declares a beneficial interest in the Freedom of Speech trust. He has complied with the requirements of Standing Orders.

Helen Clark and Winston Peters are both claiming that having someone pay $100,000 of your personal legal bills does not need to be disclosed. Now even putting aside the legal arguments over that, consider the hypocrisy of their position.

Are they both really saying that there is no public interest in having someone who is lobbying the Government for a diplomatic appointment, knowing that he has donated $100,000 to her Foreign Minister?

And then consider all their claims about the need for transparency in political financing. Hypocrisy isn’t the half of it.

Peters against foreign investment

Winston Peters has proposed a fund to help stop foreign investment in New Zealand, by buying assets itself.

So let us be very clear of his party policy:

New Zealand First is opposed to foreign investment into New Zealand, unless it is foreign investment into the legal expenses of our leader, in which case it is welcome so long as it is anonymous.

All clear now?