Alan Williams

I was sad to read on The Hive that Deputy MFAT Secretary Alan Williams has died of cancer.  Alan was the PM’s foreign policy advisor in DPMC for many years, including during my couple of years in the PMO.  He was hugely regarded by absolutely everyone and handled all sorts of crisis’s with serenity.

International Festival of the Arts

One of the many great things about Wellington is we get the International Festival of the Arts.  We also get the Sevens, Te Papa and the World of Wearable Arts while other cities get flower shows or something.

Readers may be especially interested in the session with Economics Nobel Prize winner Joseph Stiglitz. The Greens will love him as he is anti-globalisation.

Also Stiglitz appears with Doonesbury cartoonist Garry Trudeau in a discussion with John Campbell on the costs of the War in Iraq.

And for those wanting more light hearted and adult entertainment, there is La Vie.

UMR’s Mood of the Nation

UMR sent out on Friday their latest Mood of the Nation (not online yet) – an excellent read with lots of info.

umrpollavs.JPG

The above graph is their annual averages for each party since 1991. The recovery since 2003 for National is quite startling.

They also show their party vote support for each month in 2007.

umr2007.JPG

This helps explain why Trevor Mallard finally apologised to Erin Leigh.

They also measure net favourability ratings for each leader. I’ll give for each what they started and ended the year on.

  • Helen Clark from +26% to +15%
  • John Key from+15% to +42%
  • Winston Peters from -17% to +3%
  • Peter Dunne from -4% to -8%
  • Jeanette Fitzsimons from +15% to -1%
  • Tariana Turia from -19% to -25%
  • Rodney Hide from +1% to +4%
  • Pita Sharples from +20% to +1%

So Key and Peters the big movers up, and Fitzsimons, Clark and Sharples the big movers down.

Some interesting results on social issues also:

  • 78% say sex between unmarried adults is morally acceptable (hell, I thought it would be even higher than that, but in US it is only 59%)
  • 74% say a baby outside marriage is okay (54% in US)
  • 60% are okay with homosexual relations (47% in US)
  • 55% are okay with abortion (40% in US)
  • Only 9% say unfaithfulness in marriage is acceptable (6% in US)
  • 75% say divorce is okay (65%)
  • 49% say gambling is morally acceptable (63%)
  • 42% support the death penalty (66%)
  • 65% support embryo stem cell research (64%)
  • 54% support medical testing on animals (59%)
  • 10% are okay with polygamy (8%)
  • 9% support human cloning (11%) and 27% animal cloning (36%)

Most results are no surprise. I thought NZ would be higher than 60% on homosexual relations and abortion. Mind you this is a poll on personal morality, not on legality.

I’m f**king Matt Damon

Sarah Silverman is a very funny comedian in the US. She has been dating another comedian, Jimmy Kimmel, for several years. This week was the 5th anniversary of Kimmel’s show, so she made a special video for him for the show. About how she is f**king Matt Damon, and even has Damon starring in the video with her. It’s very funny, and Damon especially is great.

Labour’s confused message

John Armstrong gets to the nub of Labour’s problem:

Labour’s more immediate priority is bursting Key’s bubble. It is tying itself in knots instead.

Labour paints Key as Ruth Richardson in drag – someone who will reveal his true colours when he becomes prime minister and start pursuing National’s “hidden agenda”.

But Labour also portrays him as someone who does not seem to stand for anything.

He cannot be both these things.

I often wonder if Labour realises how contradictory its spin on Key often is. Sometimes they try and paint him as both an ideologue with a secret agenda and someone with no beliefs at all, on the same day.

Legal aid decision reversed

I think almost every New Zealand was appalled last month when they heard the news that the former partner of Karl Kuchenbecker, who was murdered by Graeme Burton while out on parole, was ordered to repay the $19,000 of legal aid costs she had occured in relation to the inquest into his death.

It pointed to a system where victims of crime get treated the same (or worse) than alleged perpetrators.

Now the decision has been reversed by the Legal Services Agency, which is a good thing. But it is worth remembering that the new rules which led to this, were only put in place 11 months ago.

Super Tuesday Party at Fordes

No action on Saudi blogger

The Hive points out there still appears to be no action taken by the NZ Government with regards to the Saudi blogger who has now been in custody for over a month.  Duty Minister Jim Anderton said he was asking MFAT for a briefing and nothing appears to have happened since.

The blogger, Fouad Al-Farhan, is being held without charges and without access to a doctor, lawyer or his family.

The Israeli Ambassador responds

The Israeli Ambassador has a column in the HoS responding to Matt McCarten.

It is a well timed article about terrorism, as the news is soaking in about how terrorists in Iraq used two mentally handicapped (Down’s Syndrome) women as suicide bombers, killing 91.  And this wasn’t an attack on some US military base – but on a crowded pet market.  Why would anyone attack a pet market? Well it seems “Sunni fundamentalists consider the selling of pets to be haram — forbidden on religious grounds.”

Anyway back to Israel’s terrorism problems – some extracts:

Would New Zealanders ask their Government to sit idly by while a terrorist organisation fires missiles on the towns of Tauranga or Hamilton? For this is what is being asked of Israelis – to sit idly by while the residents of their southern town of Sderot are fired on by missiles from the terrorist organisation Hamas.

… By stopping the passage of fuel, this slowed production by Gaza’s power station, which supplies only 30 per cent of the total power to the area. Israeli-based power companies continued to supply the remaining 70 per cent of electricity to the region. Of the electricity that was available in the area, Hamas chose to divert it to their weapon producing factories, knowing that ensuing suffering by the people of Gaza would inflame public opinion against Israel.

… Israel continues to allow humanitarian aid; food, medicine and other supplies into Gaza throughout Hamas’ reign. This continues even though border authorities have foiled, in the last two weeks alone, attempts to smuggle under the guise of humanitarian supplies, tonnes of fertiliser for use in making missiles. In any informed debate on the virtue of Israel’s actions, it is imperative to remember that the Israeli Government continues to aid those Gazans who are suffering under the Hamas regime.

The sad thing about Gaza is I want Israel to cede more territory to Palestine, in exchange for a peace deal.  But the lesson from Gaza is that giving up territory doesn’t reduce attacks on Israel, it just accelerates them. Does anyone seriously believe that if Israel withdrew to its 1967 borders, that attacks on them would stop? Hamas is sworn to destroying the Jewish state – not just reducing it in size.

Oram on the Economy

Rod Oram has some criticism for both National and Labour in his SST column.  First he gives praise to Labour for some of their economic policies:

Its achievements include the development of real understanding of New Zealand’s opportunities in a very fast-changing world economy; some programmes to help businesses and regions realise those; well-executed trade policy; rebuilding of vocational training; sensible regulation at last for telecommunications; a big increase in infrastructure spending; and a coherent energy and climate change policy framework.

But he also points out the shortcomings:

But its shortcomings are numerous too. They include a fiscal policy that is likely to become more not less stimulatory; reluctance to strike a better balance between spending and taxing; deepening bureaucratisation of health and education; refusal to embrace new ways to deliver services and investment such as greater roles for the private sector; and some cautious or muddled policy development and execution.

He then looks at National offerings:

On paper, the MPs on National’s economics team should be articulate and insightful on the global economy: Key and Craig Foss were successful in international capital markets, Tim Groser was a leading international trade negotiator, Simon Power and Bill English (a former Treasurer) represent farming constituencies and Lockwood Smith (a former trade minister) is a farmer.

But so far their output has failed to get beyond the generic and obvious about tax and regulation, useful issues in themselves but insufficient to change the direction of the economy. Two examples of their thin offerings were English’s five-point plan to National’s party conference last August and Key’s eight-point plan in his state of the nation speech this past week.

Hopefully, though, the full caucus started to do some more work on economic issues in its meeting in Rotorua in recent days. And hopefully English and Key will start giving more and better speeches on the economy as they try to make the case they should be New Zealand’s next finance minister and prime minister.

I think the economy will be a key issue this year, and indeed National do need to rise to the challenge from Oram and clearly articulate how their policies will be better, apart from the already acknowledged tax cuts.

Infrastructure investment especially is an area which presents some opportunities.

SST/FT special on John Key

The Sunday Star-Times and the Financial Times (London) have published a series of articles on John Key’s background.

The main article is here.  Some extracts:

His critics say the number-crunching, daredevil skills of his old job will not necessarily transfer to politics. However former colleagues say that what made Key an outstanding success in the brutally Darwinian business of banking was not his foreign exchange skills although they were more than acceptable.

Instead what set him apart were essentially political and managerial skills. He was unusually good at charming colleagues and clients, and rallying staff around him.

“He is a real people person very sociable. We would send him in to deal with the hardest and most difficult clients,” recalls John Kelly, a blunt American who was one of Key’s bosses when Key was head of global forex for investment bankers Merrill Lynch in London.

While most successful traders in the financial world tend to be introverted, extremely brainy or thrive on taking crazily big bets, Key had never been a “typical” trader.

“He is one of the most balanced people I know. He doesn’t flap around under pressure,” says Steve Bellotti, Key’s immediate boss at Merrill Lynch.

“I suppose a lot of FX [foreign exchange] guys do tend to be inward looking, but John is a lot broader than that. He has real leadership skills. That was what made him really stand out.”

Pretty good stuff.  Key, no doubt, does have considerable number crunching skills, but the best analyst is not always the best team leader, and his former bosses seem to be saying his skills were far more than just making the right currency calls.

What is unusual, for a profession in which loathing is the standard social currency, is that it is hard to find any traces of enemies that Key may have made. His career appears to be devoid of the scandal, bitter feuds or outrageous ego-flaunting incidents that are typical of the profession.

Finance Minister Michael Cullen famously called Key “a rich prick” late last year. He was right on the first point, but if Key were a prick, you’d expect him to have collected a few more enemies on the way.

The high stakes and tribal nature of investment banking mean the head of a successful team, such as Key, is often hated by others in rival teams. And those with sufficient character to rise to the top are often aggressive, forceful individuals with polarising personalities.

Key’s lack of enemies won’t stop Labour trying to find some I am sure.  I fully expect during the election campaign someone will emerge to complain the Key was once rude to them or unsympathetic to them, 25 years ago.

The SST also has a timeline of Key’s life. The early years are the only interesting parts (the rest is a list of jobs) with his father dying when Key was six , leaving his mother in debt with three young children.  He met his future wife Bronagh when he was at school and married her when he was 23, so looks like he doesn’t even have any bitter ex-girlfriends as potential skeletons!

SST on secret donations

The SST has an article suggesting National urged many donors to make donations before the Electoral Finance Act was passed. This is hardly surprising.

I’m not sure of the exact date, but I think in April the Electoral Commission will publish the donation returns of the parties.

The article makes the common mistake of referring to disclosed donations as all funding.  It also ignores the $10,000 annual non disclosure limit which would allow someone to still donate $66,000 over three years without having their identity revealed. While donations over $10,000 make up much of a party’s income, they (or at least National) also get tens of thousands of small donations and sub which over a three year cycle would probably exceed $4 million or so.  I’m all for a law which requires disclosure of the large donors, but worth remembering they are not the only donors.

HoS Editorial

The HoS editorial looks at the speeches last week:

… As to the substance, National leader John Key has certainly had the better of the early exchange of blows. He needed to. Since assuming the party leadership he has struggled to shake the image of being something of a policy lightweight, a financial-market whizz-kid who, for all his protestations about being poor-born, is out of touch with the real world. His speech in Ellerslie on Tuesday was short on anything resembling oratorical flourish – a demagogue this man is not – but it revealed a leader keen to grapple with the issues close to voters’ hearts.

… The fact that his suggestion of a boot-camp-style “Fresh Start” for young offenders has been well-received by both sides of the law-and-order debate – the hardline Sensible Sentencing Trust and the liberal Prison Fellowship – is an indication of how deep and widespread anxiety is. In the working-class neighbourhoods where Labour has always been able to count on electoral support; in the blue-ribbon National strongholds; and in the liberal centre ground, people are ready for leadership in this matter.

That makes it 4-0 in the editorials.

Trotter on Clark

Chris Trotter in his SST column writes on a similar theme to his midweek column – how the anti-smacking bill helped seal Clark’s fate. Extracts:

Labour had been returned to office on the strength of its socially conservative working-class base. State-house tenants most of them parents had turned out in their thousands to stave off a National win. It was their votes that had purchased Clark’s ticket to a third Victory Ball. And where they came from, you danced with the person you came with.

But then Sue Bradford sashayed on to the floor with her anti-smacking bill.

To Clark, the case against smacking was morally self-evident. But to Labour’s conservative working-class supporters it represented the lofty condescension of a childless politician who clearly believed she knew more about raising kids than they did.

Clark knew her working-class base didn’t want her to pass the bill and they knew she knew. But she passed it anyway.

The prime minister hadn’t listened to them even worse, she’d taken them for granted. Instead of dancing with the Pacific Island, Maori and poor Pakeha voters who had saved her career, she’d waltzed off with the bill’s middle-class backers. Labour’s most loyal supporters could hear Helen chortling at the oh-so-sophisticated humour of her academic mates and somehow they just knew she was laughing at them.

So now they’re over her: finally and irrevocably. Many are saying they’ll vote for John Key, but in the end they’ll probably just stay home on election day and watch the Labour Party lose.

They’re determined to give Helen Clark the damn good smacking she deserves even at the cost of punishing themselves.

I agree with Chris Trotter that the anti-smacking bill is part of Labour’s problems.I wouldn’t underestimate how much teh refusla to reduce the tax burden has hit them also, with the announcement late last year being seen as insincere and too late.

Ropati Case

The HoS has an interview with the accuser, who says she is pleased she complained to the Police, despite the not guilty verdict.

Kerre Woodham writes about drunken sex, a topic one must acknowledge she is a world expert on 🙂

Jonathan Marshall in the Sunday News reports that police are considering charges against the accuser relating to use of drugs.  I think it would be regrettable if they did so, as this will discourage complainants from telling the truth.

And finally in the SST, it is reported that the Ropatis are considering a private prosecution against the accuser. I think they would be very foolish to do such a thing – it would appear very vindictive.

Curran wins Dunedin South nomination

As expected, Clare Curran has won the Labour nomination for Dunedin South, and is almost certain to become an MP.

Successful challenges to sitting MPs is not unknown in National.  Three of the current caucus challenged a sitting MP to win the nomination off them. However this is the first time in recent history I can recall a successful challenge to a sitting Labour MP. In one sense, David Benson-Pope may have made history.

Clark will be pleased with the decision. It would not have been a good look if Benson-Pope had won.

Happy Tree Friends

Even Noelle McCarthy takes the piss

I don’t think anyone could call Noelle McCarthy a tool of the vast right wing conspiracy. She is a former bFM host and has also been on NewstalkZB. Her Irish accent almost makes it worth listening to talkback (almost, but not quite). Anyway her column in the Herald today:

Into this climate of Endtimes come the mystical burblings of our politicians. On a visit to the scene of the latest shootings in Flat Bush, the Police Minister attributed the recent spate of violence in the area not to any of the usual suspects like drugs, or drink or gangs or tagging or even “the parents”, but rather to the altogether more poetical combination of the hot summer and a full moon.

Yes. The sun and the moon. My own transgressions under this particular conjunction of elements tend more towards the carnal than the murderous and bloodthirsty, but who am I to argue with the reasoned and expert analysis of the minister in charge of police? It’s certainly a new way of explaining social ills. One that has more in common with the world view of Medieval peasants perhaps, but definitely entertaining nonetheless. I look forward to hearing more of our politicians and public servants explaining daily contretemps in this manner. How much more fun to hear about arson due to fire breathing dragons?

I think we are going to hear a lot more about the sun and the moon this year. At the next Reserve Bank briefing, a brave journalist should ask Dr Bollard whether he thinks the sun and the moon are partly to blame for high interest rates.

Anti-spam plugin

For the last couple of weeks I’ve had an anti-spam plugin, Askimet, working.  It has caught 1,154 comment spam to date.

Sometimes it will catch normal comments as spam.  It seems to do this especially if you use a windowslive e-mail address or if you post a large number of comments.  No big worry if this happens, as I’ll clear the comments when I am next online and check the spam queue.

Wellington Sevens

sevens1.JPG

Took this photo yesterday on Victoria Street. Great costumes but one wouldn’t want to be sitting next to them!

The Dom Post has a two minute slideshow of some great costumes. Also a photo gallery here. I’ve pinched below a couple of the best Dom Post ones:

sevens2.JPG

They deserve a prize for that one. Love the coloured legs.

sevens3.JPG

And what beats Bavarian beer maids!

Clinton vs Obama

gallupdems.JPG

It is now looking likely John McCain will emerge as the Republican nominee.  The Democratic nomination is still much more closely fought, and this Gallup poll series of nationwide voting preferences shows a clear trend.  I think Obama would be happier in Super Duper Tuesday was another week or so away, rather than middle of next week.

The graph is taken from Andrew Sullivan’s site. It is worth noting though that other polls don’t have it quite so close. The RCP average of all polls has Clinton 8.6% ahead. And more importantly the state poll averages have Clinton leading in most of the big states except Georgia. However they are not winner take all states, so it may not be enough to put Clinton over the line.  The withdrawal of Edwards helps though.

It is worth reflecting that with Edwards out, history will be made with the Democratic nominee – either the first woman or the first African-American.  Both are welcome steps – even though that is not reason by itself to vote for either of them.

Frozen for five minutes

Debate on bail laws

For the last 18 hours or so, I’ve been having a vigorous debate on whether Labour’s changes to the Bail Act, which make it harder for bail to be denied, are a good or a bad thing with a final year law student.  The debate has been via text message and I’ve lost count of the number of messages, but it only paused for a few hours overnight.  Debate by text message is fairly challenging as you have to make your case in a score words or so.

My basic argument to her is that the old bail laws, if anything, made bail too easy rather than too hard.  So making bail even easier flies in the face of logic.  We see the awful consequences in this article with the murder of a two year old by a man already on bail for another homicide.

Now she has argued that the threshold did not change, just that statute law clarified what was already case law.  But I don’t accept this as the rationale for the new law was to reduce the number of people in prison on bail, so it is designed to change the threshold.

Graeme Edgeler has a very informative post on the bail laws (and I suspect he agrees with my law student, not me, on the issue). I found it interesting that someone only loses the presumption they will get bail, if they have previously received 14 or mail prison sentences.  Now that is not 14 or more convictions – but 14 or more actual prison sentences.  Hell I would argue that a threshold of three or more prison sentences would be enough to change the presumption from getting bail to not getting bail.

Remember there are 18,000 court cases on hold because because of outstanding warrants against defendants. And that was before they made it even easier to get bail. And the last study of offending while on bail found around 20% of people on bail reoffend.  Again this suggests the law was making it too easy to get bail, not too hard.

And as reported here, not even breaching your bail conditions can be taken  into account, and one offender was arrested four times in one week, kept getting bail. Yes if you breach your bail conditions, but commit no other offence, then you can’t be remanded into custody.  So what does this mean – that bail conditions are effectively voluntary.

In fact if you read the concerns of the Police on the new law, it isn’t even so much just the new threshold, but the removing of breaching bail conditions as a reason to rescind bail.

Audrey scores the Leaders

Audrey Young reverts to her school teacher past, and assigns grades to Helen Clark and John Key for their recent homework speeches.

Below are her grades, by category, for Clark, and then Key:

  • Subject Choice: 7 vs 9
  • Substance: 8 vs 8
  • Preparation: 6 vs 9
  • Content: 7 vs 8
  • Delivery: 5 vs 5
  • The Big Sell: 4 vs 8
  • Overall: 6.1 vs 7.8

So they draw on substance and delivery, but Key gets the nod on subject choice, preparation, content and the big sell.

I’ve yet to see a single media commentator disagree with the consensus, that John Key did significantly better.  But of course this may be due to what Poneke labels the gallery hunting as a pack, but in this case the editorials have also all gone Key’s way and they are not normally done by gallery journalists.

More Labour candidates

In an article mainly on David Benson-Pope, the Herald reports towards the end of the article, that Labour has now completed all selections in Auckland. As predicted by the Herald a few months ago, Conor Roberts is a candidate – for Rodney, and Jordan Carter is standing in Hunua. Both are former Presidents of Young Labour. Conor is one of those guys you want to hate – just because everyone raves on about what a nice guy he is.  Sadly he is actually that nice. Obviously I know Jordan well, and he is a very capable political operator. Now neither are at all likely to win their seats, but will be interesting to see how they go with list rankings.

I’ve updated my list of 2008 candidates. If anyone can supply the names of the Labour candidates for Botany, East Coast Bays, Helensville and North Shore that would be appreciated. Annoyingly neither Labour nor National have their candidates to date listed on their websites.  This would be a useful feature seeing it is election year!