Clark announces school leaving age to 18

In a remarkable coincidence, Helen Clark has announced a policy in a similiar area and similiar to, part of what John Key announced yesterday.

She has announced an increase in the school leaving age to 18.

What is good is both National and Labour are saying that the status quo is unacceptable, and that no young person (under 18) should just be unemployed or on a benefit.  There is now consensus every person under 18 should be in work, study or training.

Clark also announced a roll-out of a youth apprenticeship scheme, after a pilot in 10 schools.

I’m not sure trying to do all sorts of training through schools will be the best model.  Are schools set up to train hairdressers etc if a 17 year old wants to train as a hairdresser instead of doing bursary physics, Latin and maths which they would fail at?

Letting 16 and 17 year olds choose the best provider rather than try and have everything done through their local school, would seem to be a better model for me.  But, maybe the model described by Clark will have more flexibility than first apparent. It looks like a 17 year old could still leave school to go undertake say a hairdressing course at polytechnic.  But presumably they would have to pay the $4,000 or so cost, while if I understand Key’s proposal correctly they would get that for free.

Sadly there are no details of the policy on the Beehive website, apart from the press release. Scoop has the full speech. One key quote:

Around half our current workforce does not have the education and skills needed to function fully in a knowledge economy.

Now some will use that to attack Clark as she has been PM for the last eight years.  But it is good the Government can admit to areas where they are failing, or if that is too harsh where different policies are needed.

Ironically a political historian tells me that a lot of the Clark proposal is taken from National’s 1993 Education for the 21st century proposal.  I don’t have a copy myself but it does ring some bells.

Anyway a good start to the year for voters.  We are getting offered different policy visions, so people can make an informed choice about which proposals they prefer – that’s what democracy is all about.

Ear “flicking” Dad prosecuted for assault

Most will recall how six police officers turned up when Jimmy Mason flicked his son’s ear for not acting safely on his bike.

Police have now announced he is being charged with two counts of assault.

Now we don’t know exactly what did happen.  Was it just a flick on the ear or something more serious?  What do the witnesses say happened? Was there bruising or bleeding?

This case will be closely watched.  If Mason did just flick his son’s ears, then the anti-smacking law will be vilified.  If on the other hand he seriously assaulted his son advocates of the law will claim this proves the need for the law.  It may of course come down to a he said vs they said.

Do the Right Thing on Ellis case

Some issues are beyond politics.  The Peter Ellis case and convictions are one of them.

I totally endorse the call for a Royal Commission of Inquiry into the Ellis case.  One needs the latitude a full commission of inquiry has, to deal with the public’s deep scepticism over this case.

It should be in the interest of all politicians for there to be confidence in the justice system.  The Ellis case corrosively undermines that confidence.  While convictions are not a public popularity contest, I know of almost no-one who thinks the Ellis convictions are safe.  And this is based on a massive amount of published research on the case.

Annette King is the Minister of Justice. It is a pity she will not consider the merits of the case herself (she cites conflict as she is also Police Minister) as I have considerable regard for her judgement and ability. I think she could and would see the bigger picture (it is not just about Ellis who is now free – it is about the wider justice system). Lianne Dalziel can not be delegated the case, so it will fall to Clayton Cosgrove or Rick Barker.

The Minister who deals with this needs to be able to consider the issues carefully using their own judgement. They should not merely ask officials for a report and rubber-stamp it. I can tell you now that of course the Ministry of Justice will oppose a Royal Commission  into the Ellis case.

I know many (not all) National MPs have a deep concern over the Ellis case. Katherine Rich and Don Brash helped lead the charge a few years ago for such a Commission. While I can in no way speak for them, I am sure National would in no way criticise the Government if it did hold a Royal Commission.  And I think all the minor parties would be supportive.

There will be a lot of partisan behaviour this year in the NZ blogosphere.  What would be great though is to have as many blogs as possible join a campaign for an Ellis Royal Commission.  We have one of the true experts on the case with Poneke, and could keep the case in profile by doing stuff ranging from all displaying a prominent graphic calling for the Royal Commission, to pledging to blog or link to a blog on the issue at least a fortnight or something. I am sure Poneke could generate enough material for us to link to or summarise.

Bauble Watching

Praise from all sides

The “Fresh Start” programme proposed by John Key for young offenders has been endorsed by both the conservative Sensible Sentencing Trust and the liberal Prison Fellowship. First the SST:

I think what John Key is putting out there is the first time I have seen a political party offer some constructive policy which I believe will turn this around.

And then Kim Workman from the PF:

Fresh Start, on the other hand, promises to use the most advanced expertise in youth offending that New Zealand has to offer, and describes an environment which provides a mix of accountability and support.

Graeme Dingle also is supportive:

Mr Key’s plan would let Youth Courts order young offenders on to mentoring programmes such as those run by Project K and Big Buddy.

Project K co-founder Graeme Dingle said this was “absolutely common sense”

And so is the NZ Herald editorial:

Those are the sorts of solutions the country needs to hear. The problem has become too serious for punitive measures that merely serve political postures. National has given evidence of solid research and settled on some practical steps.

Today the Prime Minister needs to do more than recite what her Government has done to deal with crime. Clearly it has not done enough.

That balance of both carrot and stick is what has made the package so palatable I believe.  There is a lesson there for other policy areas.

Poneke on John Minto

Poneke has an insightful post on John Minto.  I’ll quote much of it:

John Minto was one of the heroes of my formative years. 

At the time, I thought Minto was driven by the same kind of repugnance of the racist apartheid system that motivated the opposition of many other New Zealanders. Apartheid was a stain on humanity.

In 1995, Mandela visited New Zealand for the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting being held in Auckland. He was mobbed in the streets everywhere he went. He was a hero of almost everyone of my generation and of almost everyone who had marched against the Springboks 14 years before. The one anti-tour protester to whom he was not a hero was a profound surprise. I went to a meeting Mandela attended at the St Matthews in the City church in Auckland. To my astonishment, and dismay, John Minto, who was there, hectored the great man for not kicking private enterprise and transnational companies out of South Africa after apartheid ended. A bewildered Mandela asked Minto how he expected people to find work if their employers were banished. It was at that moment I realised Minto was not driven by opposition to racism but by opposition to the entire capitalist system.

Indeed.

OOXML

Colin Jackson blogs on the OOXML debate, as he is off to Geneva as one of three people representing NZ at a meeting of the International Standards Organisation. The standards issue has become a bit of a proxy for the wider Microsoft vs open source debate.

Incidentially at the network operations meeting in Dunedin last week, myself and Keith from InternetNZ presented on current policy issues, including OOXML. I quipped that I thought OOXML was my t-shirt size!

Reaction to Key Speech

The Herald has a story on the speech. The part that struck me was this:

Principal Youth Court Judge Andrew Becroft was quick to back Mr Key’s comments saying that, while it was not the job of a judge to commentate on political party policies, Mr Key’s comments were “measured and thoughtful” and comparable to what was being introduced in the Western world.

John Armstrong has a thumbs up:

Advantage Key. Whatever the Prime Minister has kept up her sleeve for her landmark speech tomorrow, it is going to have to be something pretty darned special to better John Key’s effort today.

As a piece of politics, the state of the nation address delivered by National’s leader comes as close to hitting the bull’s eye as you can probably get.

Not only does the speech meet the requirement that National start talking policy. It is overflowing with policy ideas.

It cannot be attacked for lacking substance. The speech shows National is much more serious about policy than it was at the last election. It successfully conveys the impression of a Government-in-waiting.

The speech’s big strength is that it is constructive rather than merely critical. Key lets the policy ideas do the talking rather than relying on overblown rhetoric to carry the attack to Labour.

However, Labour’s failings are the undercurrent driving the speech.

Be it youth crime or the economy or whatever, Key’s overarching theme for election year is that New Zealand can do better than it has under Labour’s rule. Today’s speech is the first in a long line of policy releases with which National will seek to answer the obvious question of how.

Vernon Small at the Dom Post is more guarded but says:

The message is not as punitive as some might have expected from National, but this is KeyNat not BrashNat.

And the timing couldn’t be better after a rash of recent headlines about teenage crime, including a 16 year old who allegedly killed a 22 year old in a dairy on Friday and the recent series of brutal bashings by a teenage gang on the North Shore.

Meanwhile Key has managed to keep most of his policy powder dry for the campaign proper, especially on tax and the economy.

Clever.

It will be interesting if what Clark talks about tomorrow will be a policy announcement which has been worked on and developed over time (as this one clearly was) or whether it will be a kneejerk announcement.

A great call

I was dropping off a data projector into Parliament this morning.  And as is often the case it was in one of those large metal suitcases which weigh half a ton and look like a bomb wouldn’t dent them (in fact they are just so they survive Air NZ cargo handling!).

As I’m about to walk in the main door, I hear (Labour Minister) Darren Hughes yell out from across the forecourt, “Is that the speech you’ve got in there”.   That was a bloody funny call I have to say. Especially if you could have seen the suitcase which does look a bit like a portable safe.

National’s Youth Plan

John Key has announced more details in his speech of National’s Youth Plan to get all young people in education, training or work – and to reduce youth crime. It includes:

  • A universal education entitlement for all 16- and 17-year-olds which will include non-school courses at a polytechnic, wananga, or private training establishment. This is to target the 8,400 16 and 17 year olds not in work, education or training.
  • Teenage parents will be able to do programmes incorporating childcare and parenting advice
  • give the Youth Court instead of the Fanily Court the power to deal with 12- and 13-year-olds accused of serious offences such as aggravated robbery and home invasions..
  • give the Youth Court the power to impose parenting orders (on parents of course), mentoring programmes (such as Project K) and drug & alcohol rehabilitation programmes (80% of youth offenders have drug or alcohol problems)
  • Extend maximum residential sentences for serious crimes committed by youth from three to six months (Government has said will do also, but not yet implemented)
  • Introduce a 12 month intensive “fresh start” programme which includes three months residential, building on the Limited Service Volunteers scheme whose numbers have reduced from, despite 70% going onto FT employment.
  • Allow electronic monitoring through ankle braclets for youth criminals who do not comply with orders

There’s a lot of detailed references and citations in the notes accompanying the policy. The Principal Youth Court Judge, Andrew Becroft, is referenced as estimating there is a group of about 1,000 young persistent offenders.  Key notes that for many the current youth justice system is working well, but he wants to tackle the really hard case, or in other words the “under-class”.

I like several things about this policy:

  1. It is not trying to pretend there is a silver bullet which will cure youth crime.  It takes a serious approach acknowledging one has to make lots of changes to real make headway with those hard cases
  2. It uses a mixture in “stick” and “carrot”. It is rare for one to work without the other.  Basically it is saying do as much as possible to help the at risk youth who can be helped, but also have more powers available to deal with the real hard-core.
  3. It’s a worthwhile investment.  The cost is estimated at $100 million a year.  That is a lot of money. But while there are many things I do not want my taxes spent on (giving money to people who earn $130,000 just because they have a few kids), I am very happy to have taxes spend on making sure no one under 18 is not in work, training or education.  And if it can reduce the number and severity of youth criminal offending, that will have very real benefits down the track.
  4. It isn’t trying to reinvent the wheel, but seems to be based on a lot of consultation and research with groups working in this area. That does not mean it will be universally popular or praised, but does suggest the issues for and against a particular policy have been well considered.

So it’s a good forward looking policy, aiming to make NZ better.  The election should be about a contest of policy primarily, so good to see National make a good first offering for the year.

Anti-Kiwiblog Demonstration

Dunedin South decided on Saturday

The ODT has a front page article on the battle for Dunedin South between Don Pryde, Clare Curran and David Benson-Pope, plus a couple of others.

Liek many, I am surprised DBP is fighting so hard to stay on as it is obvious he will never be a Minister again.  Perhaps he thinks re-selection followed by re-election will redeem his reputation.

A couple of people have suggested to me Curran is most likely to win.  We’ll find out on Saturday.

Last year’s Borat complains about fun police

Colin James on can Key do it?

Colin James notes:

Sir Robert Muldoon had to wait 15 years after coming into Parliament to make Prime Minister. Jim Bolger took 18 years. So did Helen Clark. Can John Key do it in a bit over six and set a record?

Colin them looks at the necessary strategy for Key to retain his lead:

First, discipline. Not for decades have National MPs been so concerned to be on message. They want to win, sense they are going to and accept the necessary self-restraint. The parallel is the iron unity Kevin Rudd instilled in his Australian Labor Party.

Second, paralleling Rudd again, no targets for Labour to score easy points. Nuclear ships, a critical turning point in 2005, have gone. Iraq has gone. “Privatisation” (of state-owned enterprises) has gone. The Exclusive Brethren have been sent to purgatory. Maori-bashing is out. Climate change is in.

Even the usual Labour clincher that National will cut social services carries less weight after a year of damaging attacks on the Clark regime’s public health services. Labour’s “eviction” notices which swung state house dwellers’ votes in 2005 will cut less ice now that National is led by a onetime (brief) state house tenant.

Third (Rudd again), three or four distinguishing points, preferably painting Key and National as the future and Clark and Labour as the past.

All sensible stuff – discipline, burying toxically unpopular issues and a few simple but important points of difference.

Fourth, a positive, prime ministerial Key. That requires Bill English and other MPs to do most of the attacking. It requires Key to work (and he has been, a little) on his sloppy elocution and over-folksy general presentation, in order to project gravitas …

Fifth, a credible front bench. There is work to do and the word is it will be done. Some on the front bench cannot expect to be there in a Key Cabinet.

Sixth, good relations with small parties.

No 4 is well in train, and No 6 is relatively healthy in that ACT, United Future and Maori parties all seem to have a positive relationship with National, while not of course agreeing on all issues. Russel Norman’s outrageous attacks on Bill English’s integrity mean that the Greens are only serious about Labour (which means once again they will get few concessions).  And as for NZ First, who can know?  Winston Peters and Jim Bolger absolutely loathed each other to a degree only a Bosnian Serb could relate to, yet they did a deal.  If NZ First does make it back, who knows.  One big issue is will Peters pledge (as he did in 2005) to give the first priority for negotiations to the largest party?

Finally, worth looking at No 5.  There are some frontbench National MPs operating extremely well, and will form the backbone of a Cabinet if they win.  There is also some good talent in the new intakes who need some experience to be safe and competent Ministers.  They may not become Ministers in 2008 but will start to get grumpy if they don’t make it in 2011 (if National wins both times obviously).  This will put pressure on some of the MPs who have been there for a while.  Key will have a challenging job managing the tensions, but it isn’t one he should shy from.   No-one has a divine right to the front bench, or to becoming a Minister, or even to staying a Minister for an entire Government’s term.

Obviously the short-term issue is to have a strong front-bench in Opposition, and spokespersons who can develop good policy.  I don’t see a huge need to have any major changes before the election, even though there may be some tinkering.

The real challenge will be, if Key becomes PM, does he has a huge Ministry of 30 or so people like Clark or go for quality over quantity?  The more Ministers you have, the more targets for what would be a pretty strong Labour Opposition.  Also Key will need to avoid the mistakes Clark made of leaving renewal to near the end of her third term. Even if National says gets nine years in Government, MPs should not expect to be Ministers throughout,except for a couple of key personnel. Renewal will need to start at the end of the first term, not subsequent terms.

KiwiSaver most benefits the rich

Waikato University (yeah I know, try not to laugh) has done research that shows KiwiSaver will increase income inequality and most benefit the rich.

Now this is true.  Take for example a property investor whose company makes many millions per year.   He has a choice of paying the profits to himself as dividends or as salary (or a mixture of both). With inputted dividends it works out much the same eventually.

Now with KiwiSaver he has a real incentive to pay himself more in salary, due to the tax deductibility of the employer contribution.

You see if he pays himself $1 million a year, then he will put in $40,000 a year as the employer contribution.  Now normally that would attract 39% tax, which would be $15,600.  The millionaire has effectively just made $15,600 through reduced tax, thanks to KiwiSaver.  They also get the $2,040 of government subsidies also.

So Dr Cullen has given CEOs who earn $1 million a year a $17,640 tax reduction.  People should remember this if he ever attacks actual tax cuts as favouring the rich.

Now I actually support KiwiSaver. because it has many positive benefits.  But it is undeniable it helps the rich by far the most.  And they will be the ones that are already saving, so it may not increase the levels of savings but just restructure their current savings to take advantage of the tax credits and deductions.

Hutt Valley High School

The Dom Post reports on further allegations regarding Hutt Valley High School, with an investigation finding one third of students had been bullied or abused. And half the teachers had also been abused.

Some current and former pupils of HVHS have commented on this previous thread defending the school and the principal.

Preview of Key’s Speech

Audrey Young in the NZ Herald covers the “leaked” policy from John Key’s speech today about providing free skills and sub-degree training to under 18 year old school leavers, as a step towards having everyone under 18 either in work or in education or training.

Colin Espiner in The Press also writes on the speech and the “youth guarantee” scheme which will give under 18s a universal educational entitlement.

I hope to have time to blog the speech itself this afternoon, once the actual details are known.

Who made then the fun police?

Who the hell put the Police in charge of costumes for the Sevens?  They have said they will not allow people in dressed as Borat in his swimsuit.  Don’t they have any effing criminals to catch?

Hell the Borat movie played  on TV on Christmas Day. And there were dozens of Borats last year.  I mean did the Police actually have any complaints from people actually at the Sevens last year who complained about the costumes?  Or have they just self appointed themselves as fashion police because they were bored?

Seriously, this is real thin end of the wedge stuff.  And we are talking about the Sevens, not the Santa Parade.

The Hive’s agenda is a good one

The Hive says the major focus of either party should be to lift NZ’s earnings compared to other OECD countries. I agree.  They say productivity growth is key, and note our productivity growth is at its lowest level ever.

They suggest some steps which would help:

  • tax cuts
  • huge infrastructure investment
  • bigger technology investment by business
  • world class broadband
  • less domination of the economy by Government
  • rationalisation of local government
  • moving in concert with the OECD on climate change policy response, not trying to be the leader

Nothing there I can disagree with.  Of course if you don’t try to be the climate change leader, then you won’t win awards from the UN. And hey that is much more important.

The reality is none of these steps by themselves will do the job.  You need an all of Government effort over all areas to really start to make a difference.  Kevin Rudd knows this and he is determined to increase the gap between Australia and NZ, not have it lessen.

What do we want – tax cuts – now!

The Herald Digi-Poll finds that tax cuts are cited as the most important election issue – a whopping 26%.  This is historically very high.  A year ago only 6% said tax cuts.

If Labour had put Goff into Finance, they would be in a much stronger position to be seen as delivering tax cuts because they actually think people deserve their own money back, rather than a desperate bribe just 12 months after they cancelled the last set of tax cuts.

On a purely personal note I hope Labour pledge as huge tax cuts as possible.  Because National will of course at least meet that, and so their tax cuts will be even larger than might otherwise have been the case.

Don’t Vote -Can’t Say-

The NZ Herald reports on how Andy Moore has pulled down his Don’t Vote Labour website, after the Electoral Commission said it was an offence to keep it up without an authorisation statement which would mean publishing his family’s address.

In a fit of irony the anonymous Idiot/Savant claims that Moore should not be able to advocate against the Government without listing his name and address. He also rails on about unlimited money when in fact Moore spent less than $50 on his website.

And I/S is wrong when he claims the EFA just updated the definition of an advertisement.  It has expanded to include protest placards, chalk slogans, posts into Usenet and even a press release if you publish it on your own website.

Obama’s Speech

National Review is one of the leading conservative voices in America. They are not fans of liberal politicians. So you know a speech is good when you get two of their online columnists saying this about Obama. First Peter Wehner:

Barack Obama’s speech tonight was simply exceptional — and a reminder of why he is one of the most remarkable political talents in our lifetime. He was able to speak in ways that seem to rise above conventional politics, even as he was able to masterfully push back against the Clinton attacks of the last several weeks. His capacity to touch and stir authentic emotions is remarkable. And unlike Clinton and especially Edwards, the Obama message is about unity, not divisions; and hopes rather than grievances.

Then K-Lo:

I tell you, he almost had me tonight until he talked about the war that shouldn’t have been authorized and reminded me there are real policy issues at stake in this election! But listening to his inspirational, rallying speech tonight it’s clear and obvious that if he’s the nominee, he will be tough to beat.

The second half of his speech is above. He is indeed quite inspiring at times, and I can understand very much how he is seen as a candidate for the future, not the past as Clinton is seen as. Of course policies and experience are very important, but Obama does remind us also of the power of leadership and inspiration.

Preferred PM Polls

I’ve never regarded the Preferred PM polls as particularly important because the PM almost always is the Preferred PM.  Nevertheless they can give some useful insight as to how the PM and Opposition Leader are doing.

Now Colmar Brunton has a Preferred PM series going  all the way back to 1984.   What I’ve done below is to combine the scores for different politicians into whether they were PM or Opposition Leader at the time.  Because generally that is who it is between.

prefpms1.JPG

Let’s look firstly at the PMs. Clark from 2000 to 2005 had a popularity higher than Lange at his peak.  And even now she has a popularity higher than any PM but Lange.  In other words still very formidable.

Going from the beginning Lange’s popularity started to fade straight after the 1987 election. He left office little over 20%.  Both Palmer and Moore got honeymoon bounces but they did not last long.

Bolger’s honeymoon lasted only weeks and his popularity dropped to below 10%. Desite that he won the 1993 election and had a modest recovery to a peak of 30% in 1996.  Coalition with Winston pushed him down and Shipley replaced him in 1997.

Shipley had a recovery to over 30% and had some modest  fluctations over her two years in office.

Clark came in already at 30% as Opposition Leader and by March 2000 made 48%.  The winter of discontent saw this fall back but then over the next two years just went up and up to an unprecedented 52%. This then fell back to 36%  against English and at the height of Orewa she was just ahead of Brash.  She then steadily recovered to peak at the 2005 election.

Since then downhill for her to 33% when Key took over.  What is interesting is that since Key became Opposition Leader,  her rating has stayed much the same (a small decrease over time) -it is more Key’s which has increased.

Now we turn to the Opposition Leaders.  Just as Clark has achieved unheard of ratings as PM, Key has polled higher than any other Opposition Leader in the last 23 years. The only one who has come close is Clark herself with a peak just before Bolger was rolled and just before she in fact became PM in the 1999 election.

Now going to the beginning of the Opposition Leaders we had Muldoon for a month before McLay who polled dismally and got rolled by Bolger in 1986. Bolger got his honeymoon but only to 16% or so and despite the 4th Labour Government falling apart never was the Preferred PM before he got the job.

Moore polled relatively well as Opposition Leader, beating Bolger most of his term. His rating itself wasn’t that high at 20%, due to other politicians (more on that later) scoring significantly.

Clark has appalling ratings and was at 5% for most of the next three years.  Her rating lifted to 17% just before the 1996 election.  She then polled at between 20% and 30% while National and NZ First had their stormy term in Government.

Shipley as Opposition Leader polled around 20% which once might have been an okay rating but not against a PM on 40%.  English had a very brief honeymoon and also was at close to 20% until his massive 2002 loss which pushed him to under 10%.

Brash has an initial boost to 15% on becoming Leader.  Orewa saw him soar to 32% – a then high for Opposition Leaders (but still behind Clark). This dropped away until May 2005 when a bad budget and a good campaign lifted him back up to 30% for the election.  After that it was all downhill until late 2006 when Key took over.  Key kept climbing over several months to 38% and has stayed above 30% since.

So why were both PM and Opp Ldr so low polling before 1997?  Because Peters, Anderton and to a degree Muldoon polled highly.  This next graph shows you the PM, Opposition Leader and highest polling other MP.

prefpmall.JPG

As one can see, up until 1997, other MPs polled highly, sometimes in fact above both the PM and Opposition Leader.  The graph above just shows the highest polling other MP, so who were the Preferred PMs who were neither PM or Opp Ldr?

From 1984 to 1988 it was Muldoon.  From mid 1988 to 1993 it was Winston Peters.  From 1994 and 1995 it was Jim Anderton, and it was Peters again in 1996.  If we want to look at the three individuals by themselves we have the below graph:

prefpmothers.JPG

First of all we have Muldoon in teal. He never outpolled the Pm after losing office but he did outpoll the National Opposition Leader up until 1987 and kept up some support until his death eight years after he left office.  Not many other ex PMs will ever claim that.

In black we have Winston.  He started to overshadow and outpoll Bolger in opposition in the late 80.  This faded away until he started to criticise his own Government in mid 1991. He became Preferred PM in 1993 but lost support in the run up to the election.

His Asian bashing pushed him back up in 1996 and he again became Preferred PM. This dropped away a but during 1996 as National polled strongly. The coalition saw his ratings drop below 10%.

He did then make a recovery from 2002 to 2005, but since 2005 has fallen far away.

Finally we have Jim Anderton.  Yes for a period of time he was our Preferred PM.  Don’t panic though – 30% once said they back Social Credit also.  Anderton polled a bit under 10% until 1993 and late 1993 he soared in the polls reaching 25% in July 1994.  But since then has all been a gradual downwards slope towards zero.

So all very interesting.  As I said at the beginning they are not that important overall.  The party vote is everything and the correlation between preferred PM rating and party vote rating is not that strong.  Bolger won three elections without polling highly. If I get bored one day I’ll do some graphs showing the party vote and the leader’s preferred PM rating for various parties.

Obama wins South Carolina by

Barack Obama has won South Carolina.  This was expected as 30% of the population are black (not that all support Obama but most do).  But what was not expected was the size of his victory – by 28% over Clinton.

The next race is Florida, which has no delegates at stake (as they broke the rules over timing) but has significant moral value and momentum.  But going into Super Duper Tuesday, both candidates remain viable.  And polls at this stage suggest Clinton might win more delegates but Obama more states.

If that happens then neither will concede and Edwards could become a Kingmaker.  But if Clinton’s lead with delegates is significan, pressure will be on Obama to withdraw for unity.

On the delegate count it is Clinton 230, Obama 152 and Edwards 61. However take away superdelegates and it is Clinton 48, Obama 63 and Edwards 26.

For the Republicans the count is Romney 73, McCain 38 and Huckabee 29.

Smacking Law Referendum Likely

The SST reports that it looks likely that opponents of the anti-smacking law will gain the 300,000 signatures they need to trigger a Citizens Initiated Referendum.

They have to do it by 1 March 2008. Now just because on paper they have over 10% of the eligible voters, doesn’t mean they automatically succeed. A proportion of the signatures are always found to be invalid.

The Government will have a dilemma over the timing of any referendum. The Clerk of the House has two months, or until the end of April to determine the the petition has enough signatures. Then the Government sets a date within 12 months.

Now the most logical thing to do is include it with the general election, which will be only six months off.  But Labour may not want people voting on the anti-smacking law at the same time as they vote for a party. So they may try to hold the referendum earlier.

But this will cost significantly more money to have it as a separate election.  So Labour would be accused of wasting taxpayer money for its own electoral purposes.  The ballpark estimate is this increases the cost from around $1.5 million to $10 million.  Will the Govt has a convincing reasons for spending an extra $8.5 million rather than just have the referendum with the election?