Colin James on year ahead

Colin James looks at the task ahead of Labour:

The contrast with the opening month of the three most recent election years is stark. In each of those years Labour came off large December poll leads, 15 per cent average against Jenny Shipley’s fraying Government in 1999 and 11-12 per cent over the National oppositions of Bill English and Don Brash in 2002 and 2005.

This election-year Labour comes off a December average 15 per cent deficit to National, the mirror-image of 1999. And the strong economic tailwinds of 2002 and 2005 have turned round into a light but freshening headwind.

He then goes through the strategy that Labour needs to follow, to close the gap, and then finally notes:

Add it up and stir in that Clark is a proven Prime Minister – Labour bosses see scope for optimism as their year opens. Clark argues, too, that Labour has held its core 1999 vote of 38.7 per cent in polls. That, she says, is a firm launchpad for a fourth term bid.

Actually Labour’s poll support averaged just over 37 per cent last year. And it ended the year going down, not up.

You can’t rule Clark out – she will fight to the end. But not since 1996’s 22 per cent starting deficit has her climb ahead been so steep.

I very much agree you can not rule Clark out.  It is hard to see how Labour can get more votes than National, but unless there is a clear National or National-ACT majority in Parliament (which could be as large as 125 MPs), Clark will try to negotiate a fourth term with the Maori, NZ First and United Future parties.  The Greens will, as usual, support Labour no matter how minor their policy gains.

Now Clark in going for a 4th term will be willing to offer far more than John Key going for his 1st term.  If NZ First demand all their MPs become Cabinet Ministers, plus say a 20% increase in NZ superannuation, there is no way National would agree as it would guarantee they are a one term Government.  However Clark knowing she is in her final term anyway, can agree to anything no matter how fiscally irresponsible.

Finally, I should point out again that the reference to Labour’s 1999 vote of 38.7% is somewhat misleading.  Because in 1999 you also had the Alliance get around 7%, and all that solid left vote would have gone to Labour since then.  Labour won office in 1999 because the clear left vote was 51% (including the Greens).  The clear left vote is currently around 42%.

Evil Facebook

The SST had a number of articles on Facebook this week, with the normal revelations that both murder victim Sophie Elliott and her alleged killer had Facebook profiles, and  Sophie’s father surprised by how openly Sophie discussed her social life on Facebook.

Incidentially I was having drinks with a friend yesterday who used to work with Elliott’s accused killer, Clayton Weatherston.  She described the shock upon hearing what he had allegedly done but, in what may be a commentary on our modern times, her first reaction was to remove him as a friend in Facebook.  Yeah I guess I wouldn’t want someone up on murder having my personal details either.

Anyway one of the articles in the SST was one by Guardian journalist Tom Hodgkinson, whose online rant was impressive only for its size and intensity. He labelled Facebook as evil, mainly it seems because one of its investors is someone he labels a libertarian neocon, whatever that is.

Anyway Peter Griffin does a sensible rebuttal to Hodgkinson’s hysteria:

I could rebut Hodgkinson on each of the points he makes, but I really don’t see any point in that. Yes, the people who put money into Facebook are capitalists, they want to make money, just like the Rockefellers and the Waltons and Bill Gates wanted to make money.

Yes, they monitor your activity on Facebook and target adverts at you accordingly – so does Google, Yahoo and most other large web companies. That’s called a business model. Yes they may be in favour of borderless capitalism but in the age of globalisation, barring a few despots and dictators, who isn’t? As for the extreme libertarianism, who really cares about the philosophical inclinations of Facebook’s backers? It’s your choice to set up a Facebook account and your choice to put on it whatever you want. It’s free to use and you can use it as much or as little as you please. If Facebook moves beyond the comfort zone of its users as it did last year with the Beacon advertising platform, it will get its fingers burnt, again.

And why does Facebook have to replace all that talking and eating and dancing and drinking with your friends? I quite like the fact that I can quickly check up on what friends and acquaintances, many of them spread wide around the world on OEs or more permanent stints abroad, are getting up to.

Indeed.  Facebook is great for keeping in touch with overseas friends, and I probably use it more often than any other medium for arranging face to face catchups with local friends.

The battle for Botany

Botany is the new seat created by the boundary redistribution.  On paper it is a fairly nice seat for National, so hence some keen interest in it.  Whale Oil blogs on the four candidates:

  •  Kit Parkinson
  • Youngshin Watkins
  • Pansy Wong
  • Ken Yee

The selection meeting is on 5 February.  I don’t know Youngshin, but know the other three to varying degrees.  The selection requires an absolute majority so if no one gets over 50% of the vote, the lowest polling drops out and delegates revote.

The selection for Port Hills was this weekend. Ruth Dyson has a reasonable majority there, but it could go on a big swing. Yet to hear who won that one.

Auckland Blogger Drinks

Wednesday evening sees blogger drinks in Auckland.  I was going to be up for them, but for my sins am in Dunedin instead. Details:

Start Time:

Wednesday, January 23, 2008 at 6:00pm

End Time:

Thursday, January 24, 2008 at 12:00am

Location:

Chapel Bar and Bistro

Street:

147 Ponsonby Rd

City/Town:

Auckland

Have fun.

interest.co.nz

A Fairfax media site called interest.co.nz has a mine of information on home affordability.  Sadly, most of it neagtive.

Check out their December newsletter. Some highlight or lowlights:

  • Mortgage payments on a median priced house are now 83.4% of the median income.  A year ago it was 72.5% and in 2003 it was 44.0%
  • To afford (payments no more than 40% of take home pay) a mortgage on a median priced house nor requires an after tax income of $1,396.86.  In 2003 this was only 632.71.  On a gross annual basis, it means you need household income of $107,200 to be able to afford a median priced house.
  • The median mortgage is now costing an extra $85 a week, compared to just one year ago, due to higher interest rates.
  • In Auckland the median mortgage payments are now 99% of the median wage.  Five years ago it was under 60%
  • In Wellington over five years the media mortgage payments have gone up from 47% to 87% of the median take home wage

A very useful site – well worth bookmarking.

Whoops – not just Domainz

I blogged on the 16th about an unfortunate captcha on the Domainz website.  As the screen shot below shows, it is a problem not just unique to Domainz.

actss.JPG

I guess that is one message which doesn’t need approval under the Electoral Finance Act 🙂

Happy 70th Jim

Green state of the nation and EFA

TVNZ covered the Green state of the planet speech on Waiheke Island last night, and it was good to see John Boscawen and some others handing out pamphlets to delegates about the Electoral Finance Act.

Probably the first ever time there have been protesters at a Green Party function!

It will be interesting to see how the Greens do in the polls this year, and whether they will climb back over the 5% threshold.

Sir Ed now at Holy Trinity Cathedral

Results of the Experiment

On Wednesday I turned comments off for the day, to see what impact it might have on stats if you didn’t have people reloading pages to see the latest comments.

The number of unique visits was totally unaffected (in fact above the average for the week), which is good as it shows that the stats package is not counting as a new visit, people returning to the site many times in one day.

The number of pageviews per visit though dropped from around 20,000 pageviews against a weekday average of 27,000.

So the very tenative conclusion I draw is that the comments don’t affect the number of visits greatly, but are responsible for around 25% of the pageviews.

A quarter of South Auckland foster parents quit

The Herald reports that the chair of the South Auckland Caregivers Association cites a quarter of foster parents have quit, because of concern over the changes to Section 59.

Other groups have said they have not detected  their foster parents leaving for the same reason, but South Auckland probably is a more challenging area than most.

Many foster parents could qualify for sainthood.  It is a very demanding emotionally challenging job.

There are now a whopping 5,049  children in the care of the state. I’m not sure what proportion of those are fostered out, but generally the more the better.

Houses in NZ least affordable in world

A new study has found NZ now has the least affordable houses in the world, with the largest gap between earnings and house prices.

Comparing median house prices to median wages, in NZ it takes 18 years and six months to pay for a home.

The low ranking is due to three factors.  After tax real wages have increased very slowly in the last few years. House prices have increased a lot, and mortgage rates are the developed world’s highest (off memory).

The Standard hosted by the Labour Party?

Paul M in this thread made the following comment:

it’s actually quite easy to see why The Standard reckons it costs nothing to run their blog, and, of course, who *really* pays for the blog.

www.thestandard.org.nz is hosted on a server at 202.74.226.119

A WHOIS on that IP address gives us:

inetnum: 202.74.226.112 – 202.74.226.127
netname: LABOURPARTY1-2DAY-NZ
descr: New Zealand Labour Party
country: NZ

Oh dear.

It appears their server is hosted on an IP block purchased by THE NZ LABOUR PARTY from 2Day. Personally I’d find it incredibly unlikely for Labour to pay to put up a “blog” with comments from what would appear to be professional comms people (”spindoctors” posting propaganda) without said comms people also being paid by Labour, or perhaps one of their Labour-affiliated member unions.

Now I have verified this information.  If you do a command line “ping www.thestandard.org.nz” it does indeed resolve to 202.74.226.119.

And if you go to APNIC and do a whois on that IP address,  it does indeed confirm that IP address is in a block registered to the NZ Labour Party.

So it appears that The Standard is hosted by the NZ Labour Party.  If this is the case, and the evidence is compelling, this raises real issues under the Electoral Finance Act.

I would suggest the blog’s expenses could well qualify as party advertising, as a blog hosted by the Labour Party can not be considered non-commercial.  They may be in breach of the law for not having a proper authorisation statement.

One also has to wonder who at Labour authorised the blog.  One can’t just use their IP address space without permission.  You need to have the username and password for their account with 2day.com.

Many many questions.  Hopefully some answers will be forthcoming.

$47 million a year on Govt “spin doctors”

The SST reports on how in just five years the number of communications staff working for the Government has increased from 210 to 448, with heir wage bill alone growing to $47 million.

But remember if you wish to criticise the Government in a way which could encourage people not to vote for them, you have to register once you spend $12,000, and yes that includes the cost of any staff who work on producing your message.

A great idea from Ralston

Bill Ralston writes in support of John Key’s suggestion that “the presence of around 40 bleeding, offal-filled crab pots just off the beach” might be helping attract the sharks, and laments that Jim Anderton rejected it out of hand. He also points out the Seafood Industry Council is hardly an uninterested party in this.

Anyway I like his solution to find out who is right:

When confronted by common sense, the Government and interest groups automatically assumed entrenched positions to block it.

To solve the debate, I suggest that Jim Anderton, his experts and the worthy members of the Seafood Industry Council be placed in lifejackets and tethered to the suppurating crab pots for 24 hours to test whether or not they attract sharks. If they survive, they were right, if not, then they posthumously owe John Key and the bathers at Omaha an apology.

Heh.

Wrong target

The HOS cites the tragic death of an Ashburton couple to call for a ban on cellphone use in cars.  The driver who killed them was texting.  It is worth noting though that he also was over the legal drink drive limit and also drove through a stop sign which is also illegal.

Did a cellphone kill them? No. A young 19 year old driver who was twice his legal drink drive limit who went through a red light did.

We already have a law which makes it an offence to use any object in a way which distracts you from safe driving. This covers all distractions such as food, drink, radio tuning, cigarette lighting, book reading etc.

Sending a text while driving is stupid and if a cop sees you doing it, you should be charged.  But that is different to saying it should be illegal to (for example) answer a call on a hands free cellphone while stuck in traffic and moving at 20 km/hr.

SST: A slap in the face

The SST has labelled the decision for no member of the Royal Family to attend Sir Edmund’s funeral as a slap in the face for all New Zealanders. While not quite literally true, they are on the money and I am reproducing the whole editorial as it makes the case so strongly:

Republicans will rejoice that the royals have declined to come to Sir Edmund Hillary’s funeral. Buckingham Palace has, at a stroke, infuriated all of New Zealand and turned mild monarchists into red-hot anti-royalists. As PR botches go, it’s epoch-making and hilarious. But as an insult to this country and its deepest values, it is unforgivable.

Hillary represents the best of us everyone has been saying so since he died and was loved like no other New Zealander. The palace denies that the royal refusal will be seen as a snub to Sir Ed, and demonstrates the gulf between the toffs at court and the people of these islands. It is not only an insult to Hillary, it is a slap in the face for all New Zealanders.

It is also a breathtaking piece of hypocrisy. Britain and its rulers welcomed Hillary’s conquest of Everest as the “crowning glory” of Elizabeth’s coronation in 1953. The bewildered beekeeper found himself transmogrified into a knight. Britain regarded him as an honorary Brit and celebrated his climb as though a Brit had done it.

The new queen was happy to accept Hillary’s colonial tribute to her glory, and later gave him the ultimate royal honour by making him a Knight of the Garter. This is the greatest of the gongs, a personal gift of the sovereign. When Hillary went to London in 2002 she greeted him like an old friend.

This is why it is hogwash for the palace to say that the governor-general, as the queen’s personal representative, will be an adequate ambassador at the funeral. Nobody believes that when the governor-general turns up to cut a ribbon or attend a big-wigs’ tea party that he is a sort of virtual royal presence. The people who listen to him giving yet another vacuous speech of good cheer do not suppose for a minute that they are somehow in the presence of the Queen of England. Sending the governor-general to the funeral of the greatest living New Zealander is therefore not a special enough royal gesture. It certainly is not a decent response to the death of a man feted as a hero not only in New Zealand but in Britain, and whose funeral will be televised in many countries around the world. “Oh, Satyanand can do it,” is not only a lazy response, it is a shameful one.

Edmund and Elizabeth’s twosome was for many monarchists a kind of symbol of the close bonds between their countries. The fact that she can’t be bothered even to send a minor princeling or pint-sized princess to farewell him should tell even them that these bonds are broken. Most New Zealanders know that already. They no longer crowd to see visiting royals. They know that New Zealand is in practical terms a republic. But this astonishing insult should now spur us into making the break with the palace official. What better proof could there be that we no longer have anything in common with this bizarre institution?

Helen Clark won’t do anything, of course, because although she thinks the monarchy is absurd she is also desperately interested in hanging on to power. Till now, she has supposed that stirring up a debate over the monarchy would just cause her unnecessary trouble. But maybe this time around she is wrong. Maybe the Queen’s insult will really spark the start of a republican revolution. Maybe this time Clark will stand up for what she believes.

The Queen offers a memorial service in England for Hillary, as though this makes up for the royal absence at his real funeral. This just makes things worse. One can’t be bothered to go all the way down there, but one will light a candle in one’s chapel.

No, ma’am, it won’t do.

In a separate story, they also report on reaction quoting a UK royal correspondent who labels it an “astonishing” snub.

The Royal Family sent a member to the funerals of Norman Kirk and Keith Holyoake.  They have been badly advised in their decision not to attend Hillary’s.  There is no question that there were Royals available with no clashing engagements, and there was definitely time for a flight over to be arranged.

Clark office targeted by climate change protesters

NewstalkZB reports:

Protestors have clambered onto the roof of Helen Clark’s electoral office in Auckland to highlight what they say is her apparent hypocrisy over climate change.

The Save Happy Valley Coalition is angry a state-owned company is building an opencast coal mine on the West Coast. Protestor Alex Foulkes says on one hand politicians talk about carbon neutrality, while on the other they let Solid Energy rip up the earth, producing coal for China.

Protestors say they have had considerable support from people passing by. Mr Foulkes says more protests are in the pipeline, and the Government is all talk when it comes to climate change.

They have a point that not many people realise Helen Clark’s record on carbon emissions is eight times worse than George W Bush’s and twice as bad as John Howard’s.

The UN stats show that the increase from 2000 to 2005 in “Total aggregate anthropogenic emissions of CO2, CH4, N2O, HFCs, PFCs and SF6, including emissions/removals from land use, land-use change and forestry” is the following for each country:

  • United States 0.6%
  • Australia 2.3%
  • New Zealand 5.1%

Speaks for itself.

General Debate 19 January 2008

Sarah Hitchings

Quite by accident, I ended up watching “An Abbreviated Life” a couple of nights ago. It is a documentary about Sarah Hitchings who is 19 and has cystic fibrosis, which means her life expectancy is around 32.

I found the documentary truly captivating and especially Hitchings. It showed her warts and all – a lovely beautiful young woman, but also one with temper tantrums, frustrations, family stresses and of course her struggle to cope with cystic fibrosis.  The producers have done a superb job of letting it speak for itself without over dramatising it.

I really recommend people see the  documentary if it screens again.  Also to make a donation to Breath4CF.

No Royal for Sir Ed’s funeral

I am very surprised and very disappointed that no member of the Royal Family is coming to New Zealand for Sir Ed’s funeral.

Now I’m not saying this just because I’m a Republican.  My support for a republic is not because I think the Queen does a crap job.  In fact I have always praised her devotion and dedication.

But this is a seriously bad call.  Even putting aside the personal connection with Hillary ascent of Mt Everest coinciding with her coronation, it is the fact he is a Knight of the Garter.

This is the highest possible British honour, outranking all Knighthoods.  It was established in 1348 and is limited to 24 people worldwide, and unlike most honours is given at the personal discretion of the sovereign. Hillary was also unique in being the only member who was there for what he achieved rather than what offices he held, or being a royal.

I never expected the Queen personally to come, but the Royal Family has eight other senior members (excluding her husband) plus several members of the next generation who are also adults.  It is unbelievable that they didn’t think it was worth sending any one of them over for the funeral. Lewis Holden has checked their diaries and
you know it seems more important to launch the Lothians and Edinburgh Abstinence Programme!

Yes they will host a service in London, but that is not the same thing.

The 10th anniversary of the Drudge exclusive

Guide Fawkes blogs on how ten years ago to the day, Matt Drudge ran his story on Bill Clinton’s affair with Monica Lewinsky and changed not just Clinton’s presidency, but also the media.

While Drudge was not and is not a blog, he did lead the revolution to online media. Drudge still single handedly makes and breaks news.

Hat Tip: No Minister

Hawke’s Bay Today backing Dr Cullen

Hawke’s Bay Today’s editorial is on the issue of Dr Cullen telling an e-mailer to join those leaving to Australia.

Dr Cullen is unrepentant: “Rude writers can expect that kind of response,” he said. And who can blame him?

What did the writer expect? It’s bit rich sneering at someone then complaining when he replies in kind.

Mr Middleton told Dr Cullen he was doing “a wonderful job splitting New Zealand families and reducing our Kiwi population … and how proud you must be as Minister of Finance in the final months of office. But then again just like the Electoral Finance Bill you will neither see nor listen”.

As hectoring, unredeemed by wit, the letter doesn’t bear repeating but for the fact its author believes it merited serious consideration.

Those who regularly receive abusive emails – newspaper editors among them – soon appreciate the diminishing returns from submitting to the impulse to deliver well-deserved ripostes to rude people. Satisfaction is short lived. Trading insults with one who demands a higher standard of conduct than his own is guaranteed to perpetuate the abuse.

The universal truth is that having opinions others don’t share inevitably draws attention from folk who can’t express themselves without being offensive.

In such an event, a serene silence is what’s called for – or at the most, a simple receipt.

Regardless of whether Dr Cullen might reasonably be held answerable for the exodus across the Tasman, there’s a limit to what a person should have to endure.

Clearly Mr Cullen understands far better than Mr Middleton that you don’t dish it out if you aren’t prepared to take it.

I tend to be pretty sympathetic to Dr Cullen on this one.  The e-mail was pretty antagonistic, and the response was just in a similiar vein.

And on the positive side, I think it is great the Deputy PM and Finance Minister responds to public e-mails.  Very few countries would have that happen.

Transgender changes at school?

The Press reports on a call from the Human Rights Commission calling for law changes to recognise the rights of transgender people, including the right to change gender at schools.

Firstly I absolutely accept that transsexuals genuinely feel they have been born into the wrong body, and that changing genders is the best thing for them.  I think Georgina Beyer is an excellent example of someone doing that sucessfully.  I’ve also known a couple of “trans” (one whom you would never have guessed she was born a he) so please don’t bother posting if you think they are deviant or sick, because they’re not.  They’re lovely well adjusted people, the ones I know.

Having said that, I am very cautious about the whole idea of changing genders at school.  To put it mildly, changing your gender is no minor decision (yes I know it isn’t a decision internally, but I mean externally) and like many major things such as marrying or voting you probably shouldn’t do as a child.  Georgina Beyer for example didn’t “change” genders until she was well into adulthood I think. In your teenage years sexual identity can be more fluid that later in life. Having said that, I do appreciate for some teenagers they will be certain.

I’d be interested to know whether there is a huge number of people at school wanting to change their genders.  Yes a couple of examples are given in the news report, but is there a need for central govt to set policy for every school on how to handle what may be very very rare circumstances?

It seems since 1995, only 114 have legally changed gender, which is around 10 people a year.

The wider issue of discrimination is somewhat vexed also. The reality is that if someone who has outwardly been one gender for many years, suddenly turns up to work as a different gender, then there will be reactions.  It might even affect their job if they were for example in a sales role.  Now of course one would hope things would be worked out in a sensible manner, such as employee talking through with the employer that they plan to change their external gender, and the employer working with them as to how to best manage that in a work sense.

Georgina Beyer of course had a private member’s bill on this issue, and she was pressured into dropping it by the Government.  I’m not convinced myself legislation as opposed to education is the answer.

The need for fibre

TUANZ Head Ernie Newman looks to the future in a Herald op-ed:

… But catching up is not enough.

As telecommunications increases its role as a dominant force in our lives, a small country like New Zealand has a vast amount to gain in productivity and lifestyle terms from taking the extra step to be an early adopter.

In the 21st century this means replacing copper wires with fibre optic cable.

… Fibre to the home – the replacement of the old pair of twisted copper wires with fibre optic cable all the way to the customer’s premises – is motoring ahead in many developed countries.

It offers almost unlimited bandwidth for “triple play” – video, voice and data across phone lines.

Unlike copper, service quality does not degenerate when it gets a few kilometres from the exchange or street cabinet – rural New Zealand, please sit up and take notice!

Read the whole article.  Ernie proposes a potential division of responsibilities for getting fibre to the home.  That telcos get fibre to the street cabinets, that local bodies and power companies get fibre from  cabinets to letter boxes and that customers pay for getting it from the letterbox to the house.

That’s now at all a bad suggestion.

Copper is 20th century technology and fibre is 21st.  There is no doubt that one day NZ, like all developed countries, will have a fibre running to basically all premises in the country.  But do we want to have this happen by 2040 or 2020?