Tinakori Hill

One nice thing about living in Thorndon is that Tinakori Hill is there.  Not so great if it blocks your sun, but great for those of us it doesn’t.

They have many trails from Thorndon going through the bush there.  A couple of weeks ago I decided to ascend it to the top, as previously I had just gone part of the way up.

tinakori1.JPG

This is a photo from around a third of the way up.  Most of the path is under bush, but it opens up for a few metres and you get this view.

tinakori2.JPG

If one carries on up, you eventually meet the Northern Walkway.

tinakori3.JPG

And after going to the top, and heading back down, by now closer to Wadestown, I cam across this little  patch of grass, which is very isolated and probably gets very few visitors. Has been marked as a good location for a future picnic.

I eventually want to walk along every trail and path on Tinakori Hill.  I just love the views you get and the fact you are in bush just five minutes away from the CBD. The town belt is a real treasure.

More on electoral fraud

I blogged yesterday on the lack of authentication in NZ for people when they both enrol and vote.  This was after reading No Right Turn lambasting the United Kingdom for their lack of controls.

No Right Turn  is aghast that one could possibly require the same level of proof to vote as to hire a video.   Poor people don’t have ID he thinks.  So I’m a bit confused. Electoral fraud is a bad thing in the UK, but a good thing here.

NRT goes on about disenfranchising voters, if one requires proof of identity to vote or enrol.  But he misses a key point.  Allowing people who are not eligible to vote, to vote, also disenfranchises voters because their illegal vote cancels out someone else’s legal vote.

If you vote for Candidate A, and an illegal voter votes for Candidate B, then that effectively cancels out your vote.  You have just been disenfranchised.  So someone illegally enrolling and/or voting is just as serious as preventing someone from enrolling or voting.

But what is really interesting is that I was partially incorrect in my statement that there are no checks on enrolment.  A reader e-mailed me and said there were some and to check out the Privacy Commission annual report.  And indeed he was correct – the Electoral Enrolment Centre does five sorts of data matching exercises.  Four to identify people who have not enrolled, and one to identify people who have enrolled who are not eligible to do so.

They data match records with the Immigration Service to check if people with limited duration visas or known overstayers do not stay on the roll. This won’t catch all illegal enrolments such as invented people, illegal immigrants not known to NZIS etc but it is good they do do this check.  Now how many illegal enrolments have there been?  Is it just a dozen or so?

Well in the last four years it has been almost 7,000 people.  And it is growing.  The figures (page 77 to 78) for each year ar:

  • 02/03 – 532
  • 04/05 – 1,078
  • 05/06 – 2,293
  • 06/07 – 3,095

So big kudos to the EEC for preventing almost 7,000 illegal votes which would have disenfranchised 7,000 legitimate voters.  Of course this is only a partial check, and won’t be catching them all.  For example if an illegal voter registers under a modified or fake name, then they might not get caught at all.  And if one illegally enrols close to the election, then they will not catch you in time to stop you voting.

I think there is an issue about why has there never been a prosecution for illegally enrolling?  The problem is growing rapidly, so obviously some deterents are needed.

Now while on this topic, also interesting to look at what the EEC does to identify people who have not enrolled.  Each year EEC spends around $200K to $250K on data matching to find unenrolled people. They compared 2,212,237 records in 2006.07 and from that sent out 296,338 invitations to enrol.  283,605 invites were delivered successfully and they resulted in 53,693 new or updated enrolments. It would be useful to know how many are new and how many updated, but anyway that was a 19% response rate which is pretty good.  An average cost of $4,04 per enrolment.

The number of enrolments per data match in 06/07 was:

  • DIA Citizenship Register – 271
  • LTNZ Drivers Licenses – 21,650
  • MOT Motor Vehicle Register – 16,990
  • MSD benefits and students – 14,782

Always good to learn new things, so thanks to the reader who directed me to the Privacy Commission.

Should I require ID to comment?

I’m just thinking aloud here, rather than seriously considering doing so, but the latest episode of “Sam Dixon” pretending to be a Christian right wing poster makes me wonder if I should require some sort of proof of identity to allow people to register to comment?

There are now over 1,500 registered commenters. The vast majority of course are no problem. But it is especially those who hide behind a fake identity who aim to disrupt.

Now I am not suggesting people should have to post under their actual name – absolutely not. There are many reasons why people don’t want to, and I respect that. But when you register a “username” on this blog, there is a voluntary field for actual name. I could make that field compulsory. Now no one who doesn’t have editor access to the blog (currently just me and the ISP system admin) would see the real names, and I am happy to provide some sort of privacy guarantee – maybe even with sanctions for me if privacy is breached.

Of course people like Dixon could also just invent a real name, but I could also make a requirement to provide residential address and/or contact phone number. These again would be absolutely hidden from public view (and I would see if one could encrypt them even) and would only be used by me to verify an identity when someone first registers.

I have no strong desire to create more work for myself (in fact if this happened I might hire someone to handle registrations for me, and pay them out of the advertising revenue) and I don’t want to create a disincentive for people to comment. I love the fact there are 1,500 registered commenters. But on the other hand, it may solve the problem of those seeking out just to disrupt.

Feedback is welcome.

UPDATE: I should point out that the vast majority of commenters can already be verified with their current details, because an e-mail address is compulsory to register and that often gives their real name

OCR stays at 8.25%

Should have caught on earlier

A recent commenter posting as Daedulus-X has been making some pretty extreme  comments this year.  He has incited hatred against Muslims, denigrated Hone Tuwhare, called Helen a lesbian, and protrayed himself as a devout Christian.

I should have twigged earlier, but finally checked his IP address today and it is the IP “Sam Dixon” used to post from.  So in fact it is a formerly prominent leftwing poster pretending to be someone else.  Dixon (not his real name) is also the Wikipedia vandal.

This is of course a fine example of the transparency that the supporters of the Electoral Finance Act say is essential.

40 Gb/s

Well in theory I now know how to build a 40 Gb/s ethernet connection!

That was the opening session at the NZNOG Conference in Dunedin.  Large turnout with over 100 people here.  The irony is that the wireless here is a bit slow at the moment as most of the 100 people are all trying to use it!

Just for the record

Selwyn College troubles

The troubles at Selwyn College seem to be increasing, with Chris Carter appointing a specialist advisor due to concern over their falling roll and more importantly their low level of student achievement.

I suspect eventually they may have to appoint a Commissioner – especially as the Board itself is explicitly criticised.

Fanuary

Oh dear.  Some things should not be emulated.

The Press reports on the controversy over Fanuary.  As most will know Movember is about encouraging men to grow a moustache in November to raise awareness of men’s health issues – especially prostrate cancer.

A group has set up Fanuary, and are “asking Kiwi women to go without bikini waxes in January – all in the name of raising awareness of women’s health, particularly gynaecological cancers”.

I just can’t see it catching on to the same extent.

The Standard Controversy

Well the controversy over The Standard being hosted on a Labour Party server made One News tonight.  It is probably worth revisiting this issue from the beginning.

Firstly, despite many people crediting me, it was actually Paul M, a commenter (and one who as far as I know is not a member of any political party, but is very computer literate) in this thread who investigated the hosting of The Standard, and published the link to a Labour Party server.

This was obviously reasonably significant, and all I did was highlight Paul’s comment in a new blog post, and  commented that this probably raises some issues for Labour under the E;ectoral Finance Act. The Labour Party President seemingly agrees with me as he said on TV that any expenses attributed to after 1 January would be included in Labour’s election return.

The blog post led to a fairly furious debate with 476 comments.   I actually only commented a couple of times on the primary issue – mainly to suggest that it would have been wise to disclose the hosting arrangements at the time they were made. Tane  (a Standard author) actually agreed with me on that.

Russell Brown blogged on the issue and describes it as messy, but not a scandal. Later in comments, says “I agree, it’s hypocritical, and that’s precisely their problem.”

Whale Oil has a go at estimating the costs of the commercial hosting of a “brand spanking new server cluster“.

On Wednesday Bill English puts out a press release on the issue asking for Labour to confirm the extent of its involvement.

Then on One News last night, Mike Williams said that Labour would include any costs post 1 January associated with The Standard and that “Labour Party activists” were probably behind it.

I imagine The Standard authors will be delighted with the extra traffic their site has got from the media attention.  On the other hand Labour itself may be less than happy that the way the issue is playing itself out in the media is that Labour looks hypocritical and undermining their own law where they insist on transparency.  That is certainly the way the discussion went on Breakfast TV this morning.  Darren Hughes deserves credit though for carefully pronouncing the term “internet protocol address” 🙂

As I said at the very beginning of this issue, it could have all been avoided with a disclosure statement at the time of the server change which said “We are temporarily being hosted for free on a server farm which also operates some Labour Party websites, and is in an IP range allocated to Labour”.

Election Fraud

No Right Turn blogs about a report a Council of Europe report criticising the UK electoral system as open to fraud:

Rather than having individual registration like New Zealand does, the UK handles electoral enrolment on a household level. Apparently, once a year they send someone round, and the “head of household” (itself a fairly archaic concept) tells them who lives there. The potential for the creation of bogus enrolments is obvious, and compounded by the limited ability of electoral officials to conduct checks. Throw in a recent move to push postal and proxy voting to boost enrolments, and the entire system is looking highly vulnerable. It needs to be dragged kicking and screaming into the 21st (or even 20th) century, before these flaws are exploited.

No Right Turn should be more worried about the massive vulnerability to fraud that the NZ electoral system has.  As least the UK one has face to face contact- we are far worse than that.

  • There is absolutely no check done of enrolments in NZ vs eligibility to enrol.
  • People aged under 18 could enrol, visitors can enrol, illegal immigrants can enrol, people on work visas can enrol.  Sure it is illegal to do so, but shouldn’t there be something as basic as a register of citizens and permanent residents that enrolment details can be checked against.
  • One could invent half a dozen fictitious people at your household and enrol them just by filling in and signing a form for each – no one will check signatures unless you are so stupid you send them all in together.
  • No proof of ID is required when enrolling
  • Even worse, no proof of ID is required when voting – anyone can turn up and vote claiming to be someone else.
  • If you cast votes on behalf of someone who didn’t themselves vote, you will probably never get caught.
  • If you know how someone is likely to vote and want to get it disqualified, then you could also cast a vote under their name at another polling booth, and both votes would be disqualified unless they do a full investigation.
  • You can enrol up until the day before the election, and then special vote the next day, giving parties and candidates no time to scrutinise if the enrolment is suspicious.

I can’t think of a system more open to abuse than one with no eligibility check for enrolment, no proof of ID for enrolment and no proof of ID for voting.

These will all be issues I hope can be covered off by a full review of the Electoral Act.

General Debate 23 January 2008

Ihug no more

I’m not overly impressed to read in the newspaper, rather than hear first hand from the ISP I have been with for 12 years, that the Ihug brand is disappearing in April.

I’ve been very loyal to the brand, even during periods where the service went sub-standard.  Part of it was my high regard for the owners Tim & Nick Wood.  It was cool having the ability to chat directly to your ISP owner in Usenet.

I also appreciated that they introduced flat rate Internet pricing, and forced other ISPs to follow suit.  And generally I liked supporting one of the small guys against the big telcos.

In more recent times I’ve also enjoyed working with some of the ISPs on the regulatory issues around broadband etc, and Ihug has been one of the leaders there.

Now this doesn’t mean I am going to get up and leave just because Ihug is disappearing into Vodafone.  The service is still generally bloody good (I haven’t had to call the helpdesk for a long long time) and the prices reasonable.  Data caps still too low, but not sure it is much better anywhere else, and the off peak start time of 2 am is annoyingly late.

Also Vodafone as a company has a pretty good record of innovation, and I am absolutely reliant on their Vodafone data card which is just marvellous for someone like me who travels around NZ a lot.

So very sad to see the Ihug brand disappear, but looking with interest to see what happens as Ihug merges fully into Vodafone. One nice thing they could look at is providing a discount package for people who use them for both ADSL broadband access and mobile Internet access.  They could market this as the home and away package.  Also maybe integrate their Blackberry data plans into a wider package also.

Vodafone get well over $300 a month revenue through the three services I use.  Telecom also tend to be up around the $300 a month mark for my home phone line rental and my 027 cellphone which I made a ridiculously large number of calls on.

Did Winston mislead the House?

That is the question posed by the Hive.  Extracts:

1921 (2006). Rodney Hide to the Minister of Foreign Affairs (09 Mar 2006): Following his reply to Question for Written Answer No 1164 (2006), has the taxpayer paid any airfares for the Chef employed at the Official Residence in each of the last five years; if so, how much?
Rt Hon Winston Peters (Minister of Foreign Affairs) replied: The Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade has not paid any airfares for the Chef employed at the Official Residence in Paris in the last five years.

and

“Back in Auckland, Gayle had cooked her way up through various kitchens and ended up at a popular downtown bistro. When she saw the advertisement for the job of personal cook to New Zealand’s ambassador in Paris, it was a pinch-me-I’m-dreaming kind of moment. There was official skepticism about hiring somebody in her early 20s, and Gayle’s short spiked hair didn’t help the negotiations, but in the end she was hired. The job came with a plane ticket to Paris and an apartment on the top floor of the embassy.“

Sounds like someone should be doing followup questions.

When Democrats fight!

The Clinton vs Obama battle is getting personal. Look at these quotes from their debate:

Obama told the former first lady he was helping unemployed workers on the streets of Chicago when “you were a corporate lawyer sitting on the board at Wal-Mart.”

Moments later, Clinton said that she was fighting against misguided Republican policies “when you were practicing law and representing your contributor … in his slum landlord business in inner city Chicago.”

But there was a light moment, which was excellent:

Clinton and Edwards compared their records on helping to alleviate poverty, while Obama was asked if he agreed with the famed black novelist Toni Morrison who dubbed Bill Clinton “the first black president.”

Obama praised the former president’s “affinity” with black people but also drew laughs.

“I would have to investigate more of Bill’s dancing abilities and some of this other stuff before I accurately judge whether he was in fact a brother,” Obama said.

The delegate count for the Democrats is Clinton 236, Obama 149 and Edwards 50. But if you exclude the super delegates, Obama has picked up 38 delegates to 36 for Clinton.

Republicans has Romney 59, Huckabee 40 and McCain 36. Fred Thompson has pulled out and if Rudy doesn’t win Florida, he will be finished also.

Clinton is looking more likely at this point.  Obama should win South Carolina (10% ahead in polls), But Clinton is 19% ahead in Florida.  She won’t get delegates for Florida, but will give her momentum after losing South Carolina.

For Super Duper Tuesday, Clinton is ahead in the polls for California, New York and New Jersey.

The Republican outcome is much more difficult. Florida could go to McCain, Romney or Giuliani.  For Super Duper Tuesday, McCain is well ahead in California but Giuliani and McCain are both competitive in New York and New Jersey.

Money in local body politics

Early last year I studied the results and expenditure returns for the last four general election, to see what was the correlation between campaign expenditure and votes received.

I found that the spend per vote varied massively ranging from $1.24 (United Future in 2002) to $63.99 (Libertarianz in 2005).  Even putting aside parties that did not make it to Parliament, you have $34 a vote for Act in 2005 compared with $6.58 for the Greens.

Now Aaron Bhatnagar has taken a similar look at spending in the 2007 Auckland mayoral elections.

The spend per vote ranged from $1.49 to $37.15.  John Banks spent $67,800 for his approx 45,500 votes.  Labour’s John Hinchcliff spent almost as much at $64,000 but got only 5,151 votes.

So again it is empirical proof that people are not so stupid you can buy elections through advertising.  Of course money and advertising is somewhat helpful, and it does have some impact around the edges.  But the hysteria generated by some would have you think that it’s all about money to the exclusion of everything else.

Thank you very much for your kind donations

After the initial billboard launch in December, we have had a great response from supporters, and to date there have been 136 individual donations ranging from $10 to the Libertarianz very generously donating an invaluable $5692.13. Does this make us a front group for the Libertarianz? 🙂 The KilltheBill website has (or will have by the end of the day – I only updated the list last night and it needs to be placed on the site) an updated donors list and the extra donations allowed us to have some fun down in Invercargill.

By pure coincidence (they don’t have a lot of billboard sites down there), the billboard is opposite the Southland Institute of Technology. I only learnt this from the Southland Times reporter who rang up about the billboard, and had to confess to her that it was more good luck than cunning genius on our part. But as you can imagine it has gone down well there, and we have had many e-mails of support and even better more donations.

The Southland Times story was on Page 2 and also highlighted on the front page, and a photo of the billboard is here.

Incidentally the Free Speech Coalition was the first equal third party group to be registered. Just as well as we would have broken the law by now (and it is only January showing how ridiculously low the limits are) if we hadn’t. But do remember we are a small group with no paid staff at all, no office, no fundraiser and no resources except the donations we have received since we launched. We will be sending out individual acknowledgements to donors in the near future. Also once we have the time we’ll detail the costs per billboard. We aren’t required by law to do this until after the election, but plan to have regular disclosure.

UPDATE: Oh forgot to mention that on the flight to Christchurch yesterday I had a gentleman approach me (had not met him before) to say how supportive he was of the campaign and that he has a couple of spare billboard sites, including one by Parliament, which he could lend us.  Made my day!

On the brink?

The seriousness of the challenges facing the US economy, and by default, the world economy is highlighted by the reaction of the US Fed which made the biggest interest rate cut in 23 years – a whole 75 basis points.

Even more unusual the drop came outside the normal schedule of interest rate reviews.

It will be interesting to see what the Reserve Bank does tomorrow.  The US situation makes an increase in rates highly unlikely but the persisting high inflation means a decrease is also unlikely, so not much choice probably than no change.

The Hillary funeral

Travel meant that I missed some of the ceremonies, but what I did see of the service reinforced to me how special Hillary was.  And it wasn’t just for his physical feats, but as much about his humility and dedication to improving the lives of the Nepalese people.

I can’t actually recall an occasion where Hillary used his feats to raise money for himself through commercial endorsements.   It’s not that there is anything wrong with that per se, but it is part of what set Hillary apart – his attitude that it isn’t all about him.

It was also a useful reminder that Hillary was not just NZ’s favourite son, but a world figure in his own right.  Last night on CNN they had lengthy and repeated coverage of highlights from his funeral service – more extensive coverage than I can recall for anyone else outside the US who wasn’t a political leader.

Without wanting to restart the debate, it did reinforce in my mind the magnitude of the error in not having a Royal attend. There won’t be another such opportunity.  But let’s not restart that debate – you can do so at the Guardian if you want, which has a thread on the issue.

Hillary wasn’t necessarily unique, but it is difficult to see a another New Zealander achieving the same affection as we had for Hillary.  Legendary sports stars such as Colin Meads don’t really come close, despite his status as one of the greatest All Blacks.  Maybe Hillary was partly a product of his time, with the Everest ascent a few years after WWII, and the new world order was still being established.  And a feat of climbing higher than anyone else has ever climbed before, made you a near household name.

So the long farewell to Sir Ed is now effectively over. It hasn’t been a sad farewell, and nor should it be.  We owe a debt to the Hillary family for allowing their private loss to be shared openly as a public loss.  I think it is important to the public psyche that there was participation allowing a sense of closure, so now we can move on and look forward.

The trans-tasman gap

Bernard Hickey at Stuff has an excellent and informative blog post on the exodus to Australia, the net income gap and hiy it is not just about economics:

Behind every one of those 40,756 emigrants in the year to November there is a story. Many of these young, healthy, educated New Zealanders are leaving behind their family and friends. Sure, many will come back and some may actually be following their own families across the Tasman to recreate those networks of families and friends over there.

Often quietly, the Nanas and Grandads will be frustrated and pained. All that work to build a family and a future in New Zealand, then they miss out on the payoff: watching their grandkids growing up. They will cross their fingers and hope they come back.

Many of those who leave probably never imagine staying away. But they’ll get jobs and find partners and have kids and then do the hard calculations about whether it’s worth coming back. And then they won’t.

That’s because our economy is just not growing fast enough to increase wages to a level needed to tempt them back (or to just stop them from leaving in the first place).

Bernard also links to an NZIER excel calculator which calculates your net income in both Australia and NZ, and adjusts for stuff like ACC, WFF, medicare etc.  Useful.

In Dunedin

I am in Dunedin from this afternoon, until Friday afternoon.  Primarily to attend NZNOG.

Time permitting, I hope to do my usual visits to the Captain Cook and also to stroll around campus.  I love the Otago campus, and looking around always brings back great memories of my four years down there.

Were the Greens invited?

NewstalkZB reports:

The Green Party claims it was not invited to yesterday’s wreath-laying ceremony for Sir Edmund Hillary, but Internal Affairs has a different version of events.

Prime Minister Helen Clark and the leaders of National, United Future and Act all attended the ceremony at the Cathedral of Holy Trinity after Sir Edmund’s casket had arrived yesterday morning. No one from the Greens, Maori Party or New Zealand First attended.

Greens co-leader Jeanette Fitzsimons says she did not know the ceremony was even happening and did not receive an invitation. However, Internal Affairs says all party leaders were invited and the Greens had replied saying a representative would be there.

It will be a very bad look if the Greens were not invited.  But it will be an even worse look for the Greens if they have publicly alleged they were not invited, and in fact they were, and they just didn’t send anyone due to internal communications problems.

Damning with faint praise

Aaron Bhatnagar blogs on a proposed apartment block on Orakei Road.

He previously has described the proposed block as looking like “East-Germany-On-The-Sea”.  He’s now thinking that may have been inaccurate as there is nothing European about them.  He has a better analogy:

If Paris Hilton and Mohammed Al-Fayed were locked in a room and told they were not to be released until they had co-designed a set of apartment blocks, then the garages for the fleet of pink Bentley convertibles would probably look a little like what is proposed for the end of Orakei Rd. 

Oh dear.

Japan on Whaling

An interesting op ed in the Herald by the Japanese Commissioner to the International Whaling Commission:

In 1982, without any scientific justification and recommendation by its scientific committee, the International Whaling Commission passed the global moratorium on commercial whaling.

Since then, the normal rules of debate and treaty interpretation that are the basis for good international governance have too often been ignored by some IWC members. Differing opinions have become entrenched as polarised institutional discourse and rhetoric. With a lack of good faith negotiations, this raises serious questions about the IWC’s continued institutional legitimacy and whether it indeed has a future.

I fail to see how Japan’s blatant bribery of small or poor, and sometimes landlocked ,nations to join the IWC, just so they can vote for more whaling is an example of the good faith Minoru Morimoto complains about.

New Zealand has sacrificed the principles of science-based management and sustainable use that are the world standard as a political expediency to satisfy the interests of non-government organisations.

This is quite possibly true.

Article VIII of the Whaling Convention unequivocally provides the right to kill whales for research purposes and that “the killing, taking, and treating of whales in accordance with the provisions of this Article shall be exempt from the operation of this  Convention.” Japan’s research is of vital importance since regulations adopted by the IWC must, according to the Whaling Convention, “be based on scientific findings”.

While this is basically bullshit.  Everyone knows the 300 whales killed for scientific research purposes provide little research beyond confirming how delicious the whales are to those who like eating them.  None of the so called published research has iindicated one needs to kill 300 whales a year for the research.  And if the motivation was research they would dispose of the corpses not sell them.

It is time for some common sense to be brought into the debate. Many whale stocks in the world are abundant and commercial whaling can be managed on a sustainable basis.

To suggest that forests, fisheries and other natural living resources are able to be commercially managed but not whales makes no sense at all.

Indeed, and here I have some sympathy for the Japanese position.

There are enough whales for both those that want to watch them and those who see whales as contributing to continued dietary traditions for their children and grandchildren.

I fully respect the right of New Zealanders and Australians to oppose whaling for some “cuddly” reasons, but this does not give them the right to coerce others to end a perfectly legal and culturally significant activity that poses no threat to the species concerned.

And I have to admit, I suspect some of the opposition is based on the “cuddly factor”.  Some is probably based on the fact that the method of killing the whales is pretty inhumane, while some will be genuine fears about whale stocks.  I’m in the latter category, and it would be nice to get some independent voices on the issue, beyond the very polarised positions of our respective Governments.

Kylie googles potential dates

Stuff has an article on how Kylie Minogue finds dates by googling which hunky male celebrities are single.

I of course use this method also.   The moment Reese Witherspoon breaks up with someone, I get a Google Alert so that I know if I randomly bump into her, I can ask her out.

Sadly she is not in New Zealand often.