Reminder: nominations close 1 pm for Kiwiblog Awards

You can still nominate people in the following categories:

  1. MP of the Year
  2. Labour MP of the Year
  3. National MP of the Year
  4. “Minor” Party MP of the Year
  5. Press Gallery Journalist of the Year
  6. Public Servant of the Year

You don’t need to nominate in all categories. Also feel free to state why, if you want to.

At around 1 pm I’ll select the finalists and launch a poll starting 2 pm today and finishing 24 hours later on 2 pm Tuesday.

All nominations are for “positive” awards, so treat them in that spirit.

Previous nominations are here.

Raybon Kan on NZ First

Raybon Kan has fun with the NZ First donation:

So New Zealand First has made a donation of $158,000 to Starship hospital. By coincidence, $158,000 is the precise amount of taxpayers’ money the auditor-general said New Zealand First spent illegally in the last election. Does this mean New Zealand First is off the hook?

It’s an interesting tactic if it works. If you’re done for fraud, can you just write a cheque to a charity and have it all go away? If you get a tax bill can you pay the exact amount to Starship? If you get a jail sentence can you sentence yourself to Starship? Why not take the money to one ward in Starship and get the kids to fight for it?

Every political party should try the same stunt. Take money from Parliamentary Services and write large cheques to whomever they want. Don’t call it misappropriation of public funds. Don’t call it embezzlement. Call it generosity.

But it’s easy to be generous with other people’s money. This is why politicians love stadiums that will be used once. It’s not their money.

Every MP should follow Winston’s lead. Then we’d see MMP in real action. Instead of having a government policy, or some legitimate reason to spend the money, each party should simply write cheques according to their own whim, and charge them to Parliamentary Services. Let the charities campaign for the misappropriated funds. Roll up! Roll up! Get your Parliamentary Services slush money here! It’s disturbing that a former treasurer thinks this is OK. Wouldn’t he be the first one up with a winebox full of documents if somebody else did this?

Shouldn’t he have some clue about the distinction between New Zealand’s money and New Zealand First’s money? Did nobody write him a memo on the subject? It’s an excusable mistake I suppose. New Zealand is such a similar name to New Zealand First. There’s only one word different. Of course, you’d get the cheque accounts confused.Then again, maybe that’s why he chose the name.

If Winston does not pick up the public mood on this one, he will be fighting a losing battle next year.  Instead of getting to debate NZ First’s policy achievements (1,000 extra police etc) they will be debating the $158,000 time after time.  If he donates it to another charity (if one can be found) the issue will not go away.

Free Trade deals for election year

Fran O’Sullivan covers the progress of free trade deals.

The NZ-China FTA is due to be completed in early 2008.  This will be a significant achievement for the Government and will have widespread support.

The intensity of the support will depend on the details.  For example the Aust-US FTA had so many exemptions, that it was barely worth having.

There is also a (small) chance that the US might announce we will be placed in the queue for a US FTA.  That would also be a significant achievement, and would be popular with business.

I think one of the bravest things Clark has done is to drive her party clearly into the ranks of the free trade supporters.  Many on the left are very suspicious of removing tariffs and see protectionism as good for NZ jobs.  Both Clark and Goff deserve praise for adopting a bipartisan trade policy, and keeping up the work of previous Governments.

Auckland City politics

Two good items from Cr Bhatnagar.

First he details how City Vision thought they could score some points by trying to perkbust something insignificant but symbolic such as the Koru Club cards for Councillors. They probably thought the C&R majority would resist. but not only did C&R vote to get rid of them, they commissioned a report on how the perk came about – and it was Hubbard and Hucker who introduced them in the last term. Wonderful own goal!

The other issue is more important, and that is the Council’s role in housing. I think Aaron has summed it up succintly:

C&R believes in trying to keep rates affordable for the many, rather than subsidising 100 houses for a few. In some ways, what we had last night was a clear contrast in ideology between the left and the right, so no surprises the passions were a little inflamed at times.

They were elected with a very clear mandate to reduce the amount rates have been rising by, and housing is very clearly a core responsibility of central Government. Local Government’s role is to set the rules around housing, not to be a landlord in my opinion.

Otherwise why not also have ratepayers start to fund local schools and hospitals also?

Now some could argue welfare, health and housing should not just be a central government concern, but a shared responsibility. That is a legitimate view. But the problem I have with that is it lessens accountability.

The more local government intervenes in the areas that traditionally are central Government’s the more it lets central Government off the hook. Because they can then blame local authorities for not contributing enough to schools or hospitals or houses in their area.

Public Address Word of the Year

Public Address have announced their word of the year as “Te Qaeda”.  The first use of it, according to Google, was by Seamonkey Madness at 4.08 pm on the day of the raids.

The overall top ten are:

1. Te Qaeda
2. Sub-prime
3. It’s business time
4. Sustainability
5. Reconditioning
6. Rotation
7. Smacking
8=. Not okay
8=. Carbon
10. Xtra Service

TV polls concur on Labour’s plight

By chance both TVNZ and TV3 had their final polls out tonight.  The TV3 poll tends to be harder on National – it only shows National winning 67 seats,  The One News poll has it at 70 seats.

There can be no doubt there are two major factors driving these results – the Electoral Finance Bill and Trevor Mallard.  The economic situation may be contributing also, but really Labour and their supporters have been acting suicidally.

Let’s look at the results in more detail:

National

Ine News has 54% and TV3 51%.  For TV3 this is National’s highest score since the series begun in 1996. Even Brash post Orewa only got to 42.5%.  National in fact never been above 43% with the TV3 poll until May this year,

Labour 

36% with TV3 and 35% with One News.

Last time Labour got lower than 36% with TV3 was in 1999.  It is also worth remembering that in 1999 the combined Lab/Alliance vote was 47%.  People keep discounting the 8% Alliance vote in 1999.  The left vote in 1999 was 52%.  On this poll it is either 36% or 41% depending on whether the Green vote is wasted or not. 

Greens

Three polls in a row have put the Greens under 5%.  Not probable they will be wiped out, but now not impossible.  They only got 5.6% last time.  Greens had been averaging 8% for much of 2007.  Their unprincipled support of the Electoral Finance Bill has probably cost them three MPs.

They have refused to stick up for any of their principles in capitulating to Labour’s demands, and most crucially have lost their brand as independent. And damage to a brand can be the hardest to repair.

NZ First

They had been gaining support for their stance on the Urewera 17 arrests etc, but have fallen back and are at or just over 2% in both polls.

Preferred PM

Clark is now behind Key on both TV3 and One News polls.

Electoral Finance Bill

It is interesting to look at the five parties (including Progressive) who are pushing the Electoral Finance Bill through Parliament.  On the One News poll their 65 seats would be reduced to 48 seats.  On the TV3 poll they would be 49 seats.

They still have a chance to do the right thing and vote it down on Tuesday. If they do not, then they have been warned that this will be an election year issue. Helen Clark has scoffed and scoffed at the opposition to the Bill and insisted it is a minor beltway issue.

Free speech is not a minor beltway issue.

Hooton on media regulation

Matthew Hooton writes in the SST about the prospects of media regulation if Helen Clark wins a fourth term. First he looks at why we have the Electoral Finance Bill:

If she wins a fourth term, Helen Clark’s next move will be to regulate what can and cannot be written in our newspapers or broadcast on our radios and TVs.

Back in the 90s, it was the unions that first became accustomed to running anti-government advertisements.

The teacher unions were prolific. Billboards lampooned ministers while newspaper advertisements said “vote public education”. Mysteriously, these would coincide with Labour prattling on about “privatisation”. Leftist health groups ran similar campaigns.

Even though these campaigns clearly benefited Labour, no action was taken against them by the Bolger government.

…

For the first time, Clark’s government came under the sort of concerted attack that National governments had always tolerated. Clark was determined that such criticism not be allowed to happen again.

Clark’s answer was the Electoral Finance Bill, written secretly by Cullen and Labour’s election strategist, Pete Hodgson, specifically to silence dissent. They took the most draconian parts of Canadian law and merged them with the most draconian parts of British law to create a monstrosity unknown in any genuine democracy.

While the initial draft of the legislation was an outrageous attack on free speech, the revised version is arguably worse in that it recklessly risks next year’s election being decided by the courts. Every newspaper in the country, whether left- or right-leaning, has condemned the bill and the government that dreamed it up.

Media criticism of the government is likely to only get worse next year. The extraordinary arrogance and unpleasantness of key ministers, combined with clear failure across a range of policy areas, including health, mean that Labour is likely to face a media next year that is more sceptical of Clark, and perhaps even hostile, than any she has experienced before.

If she wins, Clark will be more determined that such criticism never be allowed to happen again.

The same arguments used to suppress criticism by paid advertising will be used to suppress criticism by the media. We will be told the media has been guilty of trying to influence public opinion “unduly”, whatever that means. Criticism of the government will be called “attack journalism” by “right-wing hacks”. It will be necessary to take “a closer look” at what is written and broadcast to stop the media “rorting” the next election.

Now you might think that this is all silly, that the Government would never try to control what the media can say. Well look at these warning signs:

Already, the threats have begun. Last year, Clark slammed this newspaper for giving me “endless column space”. This week, she broadened her attack to the media generally. Her foreign affairs minister, Winston Peters, has threatened darkly that he has news for the media, and “it’s all bad”. My colleague Chris Trotter, New Zealand’s most reliable harbinger of emerging leftist thought, says media policy has been a “sleeping dog” of this administration. He warned the media this week to “think long and hard before kicking them into snarling wakefulness” by editorialising against Labour.

It is difficult to believe that Clark, a former social democrat, would take us down this road. But, then again, it is difficult to believe how far she has already travelled. She is not taking us to North Korea, but she is heading to Singapore, where free speech and a free media are tolerated as long as they support the objectives of the ruling party, and where dissent is OK as long as no one hears it.

This gets pretty close to it.  Clark sees criticism of her and her Government as criticism of New Zealand.  Anyone who criticises her must have disloyal motives. They must be in the pay of wealthy or foreign interests, it is concluded.

PM popular in UK

Iain Dale’s blog is one of the most widely read in the UK. He’s a former staffer and candidate for the Tories, but takes an independent line which makes it a popular read from all sides.  However most readers would be Conservative.

Anyway he ran a competition asking readers to rate 13 world leaders from 1 to 10, and Helen Clark actually made the top half being in 6th place with a rating of 4.4.

The most favourite was Sarkozy, followed by Merkel.  Then Ireland’s Bertie Ahern and Canada’s Stephen Harper.

Both Clark and Rudd beat out George W Bush (and this is a conservative blosite poll!) and Vladimir Putin.

Could be a fun summer poll for Kiwiblog – get people to rate Rudd, Gordon Brown, Harper, Bush, Sarkozy and Merkel.   Not sure if enough NZers follow international politics enough to make it worthwhile.

Another option is to run our own Democratic and Republican primary.  I’m still backing Clinton on the Democratic side and Giuliani on the Republican side.

A great summer weekend

Not only is Wellington beautifully hot and sunny at the moment, the wind has gone away.  This means one can party outside until midnight and stay warm.

On Friday night had a party at the ginga’s place in Newtown.

newtown1.JPG

The scary thing about this photo is it was taken before they started drinking!

newtown2.JPG

Some girls from Fielding.  Despite that they are good sorts.

newtown3.JPG

And the dancing inside.

So was a good Friday night.  Then on Saturday had a pig-a-thon party.  What is a pig-a-thon?

pig1.JPG

Well this is it – two little pigs cooked in a home made spit roast for six hours.  Someone suggested the pigs be called Trevor and Mohammed, but it was agreed the name Trevor was offensive to many Wellingtonians. This led me to recount the story, seeing it was linked to religious insensitivity, of the time I told a group of reasonably devout church goers that I had nicknamed a database I used as “Jesus” because everytime one tried to delete someone from it, it would ressurect them the next time you used it.

Also on the religious side, I had a client call me during the pig-a-thon and his first statement was “Are you sure you’re half Jewish”. I thought he had learnt I was devouring some lovely pork and responded that I was only half Jewish in a bloodline sense, not in a religious sense and besides I like pork.  But he said that wasn’t what he was calling about – he was concerned I hadn’t cashed his cheque to me yet  🙂

pig2.JPG

Anyway back to the food, and this is the inside of one of the pigs – nicely stuffed with carrots and potatoes.

pig3.JPG

The food processing line.  It got carved, then sliced, then served. There were 6o or so people there and to be honest just the one pig was almost enough for them.  We did make it onto the second pig and also managed to turn the neigbour’s cat into a pig loving carnivore.

pig4.JPG

Alas, poor Yorick I knew him well.

So that was a good afternoon and evening on Saturday.

yum1.JPG

Then on Sunday went along to a yum char at Regal in Courtenay Place, hosted by Keith Ng.  A superb feed, and a good way to use up a couple of hours on a lazy Sunday. The photo is of the left overs. We ate a huge amount and it was only $17 a person.
Now just waiting for my new bed to be delivered, and then out again tonight.  Oh I do enjoy summer.

Crapped on again

I was in the grounds of Parliament yesterday, being interviewed by Brian and Helen for their “Following Alexis West” documentary about NZ’s switch to MMP.

Around ten minutes into the interview and whooosh a pigeon craps on both Brian and myself.  I’m not sure the footage will make it into the final film, but as you can imagine my reaction wasn’t one of great pleasure.

Ironically it was only a couple of days earlier that I was recounting to someone at the press gallery party how I first met one of the PM’s press secs – being the last time I was crapped on.  I worked for a small firm that did advertising and PR for Porirua City Council and we arranged a photo op at a landfill for one of the Councillors. The journalist, Juli, worked for Porirua News and we both got crapped on by a pigeon.  We still argue about whether the bird was aiming for the PR person or the journalist.  Ironically Juli is now a press secretary (a version of PR) and I’m now a blogger (a neathandal version of the journalist species).

I suppose being crapped on every 12 years is not too bad a record, but frankly twice is more than enough.  It wouldn’t be so bad if I had a gun to retaliate with!

The Kiwiblog 2007 Awards

Seeing it is awards season, I figured I might as well join the fun, and am soliciting nominations for the categories below. Now these are going to all be positive awards because it’s meant to be a time of goodwill!

So make nominations below in the comments, and then on Monday we’ll start an actual vote. Feel free to nominate people who others have nominated as that will help me select short-lists for voting. The categories are:

  1. MP of the Year
  2. Labour MP of the Year
  3. National MP of the Year
  4. “Minor” Party MP of the Year
  5. Press Gallery Journalist of the Year
  6. Public Servant of the Year

You don’t need to nominate in all categories. Also feel free to state why, if you want to.

Will Shadbolt go to jail?

I didn’t think the actual ad run this month by the Invercargill City Council and other supporters of Southland Institute of Technology would cause problems under the Electoral Finance Bill/Act. But the ones planned for next month certainly would:

Invercargill Mayor Tim Shadbolt plans to spend $300,000 on an anti-government advertising campaign opposing the cuts, which he says will see an estimated $24m wiped out of the Southland economy each year.

He plans to use the slogan “Bring down the government” in a second series of newspaper advertisements to run next month.

The ads are likely to fall foul of the new Electoral Finance Act, which is expected to be passed into law on Tuesday. The new law will stop third parties from spending more than $120,000 on political advertising during an election year.

If Shadbolt is convicted, he will automatically lose his job as Mayor. Those planning to vote for the Electoral Finance Bill on Tuesday should reflect on whether they want to be associated with the electoral consequences of having a popular Mayor forced out of office due to him standing up for his local constituents against the central Government.

Spending $300,000 to fight a decision which will cost your community over $20 million is a very logical thing to do. And this is not a big wealthy person funding this – it is a democratic body on behalf of its 50,000 residents. It is stopping the Council from spending $6 per resident to fight a decision which affects their community.

And don’t anyone imagine that the Council’s action will not be near universally supported. They are fanatically passionate about the SIT in Invercargill and 95% of the population there will be cheering the Council on.

The Electoral Finance Bill may become the tombstone for those parties who support it.  I’ll leave the final words to former Labour Prime Minister Mike Moore:

The former Labour Prime Minister has today labelled the piece of legislation as fatally flawed. He says the restrictions in the electoral finance law, promised by the Government to be passed next week in Parliament, are without precedent in the free world.

Mike Moore says the bill is wrong in principle and in substance and will end up doing the opposite of what its authors expected.

 

Drink Driving Blitz

The SST reports on a drink driving blitz on Friday night which tested 52,000 vehicles and 335 drivers face prosecution.

I was one of those tested, on the on ramp to the Wellington motorway, driving back from a party in Newtown. The police officers were very professional and polite doing a pretty thankless job.

I’d been at the party for around four hours, and had only had three alcoholic drinks (whiskeys) before swapping to fruit juice, so I knew I was well under the limit. But despite that, you always get that nervous clenching feeling in your stomach, until such time as you get a result. Of course it came up negative.

It was the first time I had been breath tested in oh four or five years I think. And that is despite being a regular driver in the evenings.

It got me thinking about how often those who have multiple drink driving convictions, probably actually drive over the limit. If you have just one conviction it might be the only time you were ever over the limit, but what are the chances for multiple convictions.

You see I would estimate that you get breath tested only around one in 200 times you are out driving. So if for example you have four drink driving convictions, that suggests to me that person may have driven over the limit 500 to 1,000 times.

So personally I would actually advocate more resources for more frequent drink driving blitzes. People shouldn’t get away with driving drunk hundreds and hundreds of times.

Winston hates the Herald

Winston unleashes a torrent against the Herald:

Peters said the rejection came after “fuss” by “minions of foreign-owned interests”, referring to the country’s main newspaper owners, APN – publishers of the NZ Herald and the Herald on Sunday – and Fairfax.

“It’s all very well for a bunch of chardonnay-drinking, pinky-finger-lifting elitists to come up with their view. It’s the ultimate in elitist arrogance. There is no politics in this.”

It is typical Peters. Well if there is no politics in this, why not give the money back to the taxpayer to whom it is morally owed?

Matt McCarten is unimpressed also:

But of all of his antics, dropping off a cheque for $158,000 to Starship children’s hospital last week must be the most blatant example of cynical populism I can recall.

Mind you, the NZ First’s leader’s latest hypocrisy is consistent with his past behaviour. Peters has always had an uncanny knack of being able to take a strong principled position one moment and, with a straight face, do the exact opposite without claiming he has done anything wrong.

During the last election he defiantly claimed NZ First wouldn’t sell out for the baubles of office. Within weeks he was our Foreign Minister, claiming he wasn’t a member of the Government because he didn’t go to Cabinet meetings, and his other MPs remained on the backbenches.

The Auditor-General’s original charge was that our politicians had unethically used public money to buy votes. Peters has pulled off a breath-taking feat. Not only did he misuse money two years ago, but he is using the same money to fund publicity he hopes will get him elected again next year. It remains to be seen if enough New Zealanders vote for a party with this sort of morality compass.

One of the better summing ups I have seen.

Two more Labour candidates

The Standard (and it is one of the nice things that blogs are getting the info out) has news of two more Labour Party candidates.  Hamish McDouall in Whanganui and Kate Sutton in Epsom.

Hamish will be remembered by almost anyone aged over 25 as the student who was the first person to win Sale of the Century and the nation was enthralled watching him and willing him to win.  I remember the following year he stood for some role in student politics at Otago and and the audience would all sing the Sale theme when he got uo to speak at forums.

I’ve actually run into Hamish a couple of times over the years.  I doubt he remembers me, but his father was very involved at Red Cross where I worked, and I ended up sharing a car if memory serves me right.  From my limited dealings with Hamish, he is a very bright and highly personable guy, and I suspect he will be a more formidable challenge to National MP Chester Borrows than Jill Pettis would have been.

Kate Sutton is pretty well known in political circles.  As well as being Women’s Vice-President for Labour, she chairs a community board in Auckland.  Like her other former colleagues from student politics, a bit of a political animal.   She will not of course win Epsom, but will be hoping for a winnable List place (the irony for candidates such as Kate is the more electorate seats Labour loses, the better her chances will become).

I do have to say that overall the quality of Labour’s 2008 candidates is a big step up from the previous three elections.  If they had brought some of these people in, in 2005, they might be a fresher more popular Government by now.  The Suttons, Robertsons, McDoualls, Burns and Hipkins of the world are not going to be quiet bench warming MPs such as Ross Robertson or Ann Hartley. They’ll hit Parliament running, and if National is in Government, will face some very ambitious and competent opposition MPs.

I do of course think that having too many MPs  who are “professional politicians” and have never developed a significant (as in at least a decade) career outside politics is a flaw.  It will be interesting to see the final lineup.

Armstrong also give Clark Politician of the Year

John Armstrong has also (Transtasman did also) made Helen Clark his Politician of the Year.

I understand the rationale for doing so – that she is the only thing keeping the Government afloat, but I disagree with it.

And not just because she is Labour.  For her first six years as PM I would not quibble with awarding her various titles recognising her political skills. I am quite capable of being dispassionate on these issues and when I do ratings of Ministers (for example) often end up very close to what journalists do.

But I think it is obvious Clark has lost her judgement over the last 18 months.  Time an time again she has made the wrong decision and only backed down under huge pressure.  This started with the refusal to pay back the pledge card, and the attacks on the Auditor-General.  It was compounded with her defence and attempted whitewash of Taito Philip Field.  Then there was the total failure to recognise the unpopularity of the anti-smacking law.  She hung on to Benson-Pope well past his use by date,  and finally the dismissal of the Electoral Finance Bill as a beltway issue.

Yes I agree Clark remains Labour’s best and maybe only chance of success.  But in the all important party vote she has trailed by double digit leads most of the year, and  she has made a series of wrong calls.

I suspect Clark won just because there is really no standout candidate.  No major politician has had an error free year.   Anyway here are John’s overall picks:

  1. Politician of the Year: Helen Clark, then Bill English then Winston Peters
  2. Backbencher of the Year: Sue Bradford, then Te Ururoa Flavell
  3. Honest Toilers: Clayton Cosgrove, Tony Ryall and Chris Finlayson
  4. Brownie Points: Cullen for Kiwisaver, Peters for US relations, Key for smacking compromise
  5. Jury out on: Trevor Mallard, Chris Carter, Katherine Rich
  6. Biggest msicalculation: David Benson-Pope
  7. Biggest lapse of judgement: Damien O’Connor taking a suspended prison guard on a rugby trip to France
  8. Biggest blooper: John Key for “The Labour Government I lead”
  9. Self-sacrifice: Mark Burton for jumping before he was pushed
  10. Missing in action: Rodney Hide and Nandor Tanczos
  11. Best stunt: Hone Harawira going walkabout
  12. Kim Jong Il self-importance award: Gordon Copeland and Charles Chauvel
  13. Fashion Police Award: Lesley Soper for exotic dress sense
  14. Parliamentary etiquette award: Steve “fuck you” Maharey

Will the 9th floor cough up?

The latest Colin Espiner blog is interesting.

Earlier Colin blogged a response to an article on the PM’s address to a journalism conference.

One of the PM’s press secretaries, Juli Clausen, posted a comment which roasted Colin for blogging about an event at which he wasn’t present. Incidentially I think it is great that Juli posted a comment – press secretaries should respond if they feel something is inaccurate.

But here is where it now gets interesting.  Colin has asked for a copy of the transcript or tape of what the PM actually said.

The Prime Minister, who values her relationship with the gallery and has always gone to some lengths to preserve it – now wants to move on. But I’d like a transcript, or better still, a tape of her address to the journalists. Her office has one, but it won’t release it.

I suggest Colin asks for a copy under the Official Information Act.

More on Starship donation returned

  1. One can show your support for them at http://www.starship.org.nz/donation.
  2. Winston is still determined to give the money to anyone except The Parliamentary Service. Someone should set up an online petition we can sign saying we will never ever donate to whatever charity accepts his money as it is morally owed to the taxpayer.
  3. Remember United Future still owes around $50,000 also.  E-mail and phone them and ask when they will be paying.
  4. Notwithstanding (2) should the Free Speech Coalition write to Winston saying that we would be happy to accept his money 🙂

Starship gives money back to NZ First

Oh this has become a PR disaster for NZ First. Starship Hospital has now rejected their $158,000 donation:

“It’s most unfortunate that the money wasn’t given in the spirit of genuine philanthropy, but rather it appears to gain political capital and media leverage,” he said.

“We have decided it’s in the best interest of the Starship Foundation and the sick children of New Zealand to return the money to NZ First.”

This is an absolute humiliation.

General Debate 14 December 2007

ACT Party Leader resigns

The Shortland Street serial killer is ….

So tonight we find out the Shortland Street serial killer. I see two main possibilities.

If the leaked video clips do represents the three actual endings, then my pick is Luke Durvel.

If they were just planted by South Pacific Pictures to throw people off the trail, then I pick Joey.

I think Joey is more likely. Serial killers often are not the grumpy no mates types, but go out of their way to befriend everyone.

He’s just too clingy and needy. I hope it is him anyway as his character is so annoying.

Thursday’s episode suggest it could still be Scotty. And that was one of the three leaked endings.

The funniest twist would be if it was Yvonne!

We’ll find out soon.

UPDATE: And the serial killer is Joey!!

Yay I got it right. We see him about to strangle Tania.

Someone may turn up and he doesn’t attack her, but if he does attack her I presume she dies as next season he roams free for a few weeks it seems.

Hive Mentality in NBR

A mention of blogs in the National Business Review‘s Hive Mentality column:

4. Don’t sniff the potatoes

Technology promised to make every citizen with a cellphone a journalist. Instead, everyone is a potential stalker. As America gears up for its “YouTube election,” the combination of online and cellphone video is making its presence felt here too.

The left has scrambled, but made ground quickly in these tabloid stakes. The Standard, a Labour Party mouthpiece blog, has uploaded sly video footage of John Key sniffing vegetables in an unwieldy fashion at a market – the left-wing sequel to the Exclusive Brethren’s tasteless rubbish-rummaging of minister’s last year. The Standard also led the “John Key illegal downloads” story.

On the right, the National Party’s David Farrar made the early running online with careful analytical posts; Farrar’s talent is summarising complex issues for journalists simply but comprehensively, but not so much so that readers could come to a different conclusion to him.

It’s a pity I can’t post the whole column – it’s very good.

National reopens Selwyn nominations

National announced last night that it has decided to reopen nominations for Selwyn, after complaints of pressure on some candidates not to stand.

This is not a common occurrence.  I don’t think I can recall another selection where this has happened.

I know absolutely nothing about the details, beyond what I have read in the newspaper.   But what I can say is what my personal view is.

I think every seat not currently held by National should have an active selection contest.  Yes it can be challenging for managing parliamentary relationships, but overall the party gains members and supporters when we have contested selections for seats National does not hold.

Another reason I support contested selections, is that on current polling National could gain 55 – 60 MPs.  And with a policy that all but a maximum of five list candidates must also be electorate candidates, it means that even candidates in the most safe Labour seats have a significant chance of becoming MPs through the list.  And a healthy selection process can help ensure that National doesn’t end up with “dud” MPs as happened in 1990.

National of course also has a history of selection battles for sitting electorate MPs – John Key, Judith Collins and John Carter all won their seats by challenging for the nomination against an incumbent electorate MP.  And National is far better off for having had them do so.

The issue of List MPs is a bit different.  A List MP doesn’t hold a seat, even though they may have stood for it last time or be associated with it.  There isn’t the same stigma to stand against a List MP for a seat, as there is to actually challenge an Electorate MP.  For example Annabel Young faced a contested selection for Wellington Central despite being an existing List MP.

So National has a good healthy history of contested selections, and it is good to see the same will happen in Selwyn – safe seats especially should have a vigorous contest.

Disclosure

Some commenters on the left are always going on about the important of disclosure, and go into a fury if a Richard Long column (for example) doesn’t appear with a disclaimer that he used to work for Don Brash (as indeed did I).

And I noticed yesterday The Standard also finally managed to find a column in a newspaper in favour of the Electoral Finance Bill.

It is written by Simon Cunliffe, a senior ODT journalist.

Strangely though, they did not think it necessary to mention that Mr Cunliffe was just two months ago a press secretary to a Labour Minister.

Now I don’t think this in anyway diminishes the legitimacy of Simon Cunliffe’s opinion.  He has every right to write his honest opinion of the Electoral Finance Bill.

I just thought there was a double standard for those insisting every Richard Long column mention his previous job (which now was over two years ago) and not applying the same standard to someone who had a political role much more recently.