General Debate 5 November 2007

Ralston on National

Bill Ralston has some advice for National:

For example, National has a somewhat doctrinaire policy of lifting the cap on GPs’ fees.

That’s hardly a vote winner, especially when former Health Minister Pete Hodgson was able to beat his chest that Labour had halved of the cost of a GP visit, which was boosting the health of New Zealanders who no longer delayed going to the doctor.

National needs to learn the basic rule that anything that puts money in people’s pockets is good, anything that takes money out is bad. It’s hardly rocket science but, apart from tax cuts, the Nats don’t always get it.

Incidentially there isn’t really a cap at the moment, but that’s a debate for another day. Ralston’s point is well made.

John Key did hit the right note on law and order this week, for once not bungling a policy release. National is promising Tasers for the police, another 1000 frontline cops, tougher bail laws, better protection orders, compulsory DNA tests for criminals and a hardline approach to gangs. That will impress an increasingly jittery middle New Zealand.

Yes it was a smooth release.   Much relief I am sure 🙂

But the big issue for Ralston is interest rates:

National’s finance spokesman Bill English is also right on target when he hits on high interest rates. Michael Cullen came out on Friday saying, somewhat disingenuously, that he wasn’t planning an “election-year lolly scramble”. English struck back correctly pointing out that the Government’s $4 billion over-spending in the Budget was keeping interest rates high.

He quoted an ANZ bank report that says, “the biggest losers in an inflationary environment are middle- to low-income households”. That’s the kind of message he needs to push, because high interest rates are crucifying voters in the mortgage belt of the major cities.

Interest rates have been a major factor in Australian elections.  They haven’t been much of an issue in NZ for a while, as rates have been relatively low. But they could well be a big factor in 2008.

McCarten on Labour

Matt McCarten in the HoS looks at Labour over the last week:

Ordinary people who assault their colleagues are sacked on the spot. In fact, people get sacked for a lot less than what Mallard did. For example, I’m dealing with an employment case at the moment where a worker who was assaulted by another worker so he went home. On the way out, he impulsively kicked the offender’s car.

The next morning, the victim apologised to the offender for kicking his car and promised to pay for any damage. Both workers shook hands and made up. However they both got the sack: the offender for punching the victim, and the victim for damaging the offender’s car. On Friday, the Employment Authority upheld the employer’s decision to fire the victim on the grounds of safety. This week Mallard was appointed the new Minister of Labour responsible for this department that rules that this worker could be sacked for an offence for which he himself received a wrist smack. The irony and the unfairness is sickening. Even my very clever lawyer says that the victim has no chance of being reinstated, as employment law is clear, no matter what the provocation. Clearly the rules of behaviour that the rest of us abide by do not apply to politicians.

I suspect there are many in the union movement who have had employees in similiar situations.  I’m pretty sure none of the employees got effective promotions as a reward for their actions.

It’s an open secret now, with the resignation of Steve Maharey and the demotion of Mallard, that Phil Goff is Clark’s anointed successor. If Labour loses the election next year, Goff will be unanimously appointed to the party leadership. When you’ve got senior leaders of the party’s left wing articulating why Goff would make a good leader, you know it’s a done deal.

I said much the same thing a week ago. But I find it interesting that Andrew Little twice refers to Maharey’s retirement as a factor in his reconsidering to stand. The race may have just been re-opened.  The fact Clark didn’t appoint her most competent Minister to a senior domestic portfolio suggests she may not be too thrilled with the idea of Goff as sucessor.  To be fair to Clark though, I doubt she wants any talk of any successor.  Not that there is any threat to her leadership – a challenge is unimaginable prior to the election.

Definition of Racism

The Herald on Sunday attacks Winston Peters for his labelling those protesting against the Police actions were apartheid supporting racists.

Now what interests me isn’t the disagreement with how Peters has characterised the protesters, but the assertion:

Nor may Maori activists or their supporters sensibly be called racists. Racism has nothing to do with skin colour, and everything to do with power. Anyone who argues that those arrested in Tuhoe and elsewhere last month are more powerful than the state authority unleashed on them is deluded. Or trying to win votes by any means necessary.

This is a fascinating redefinition of racism. Basically it is an assertion that it is impossible to be racist unless you are powerful, and hence ipso facto Maori activists can not possibly be racist.

The Herald on Sunday argues for an unusual sociological definition of racism. The Oxford English Dictionary defines it as:

a belief or ideology that all members of each race possess characteristics or abilities specific to that race, especially to distinguish it as being either superior or inferior to another race or races

Webster’s says:

racism as a belief that race is the primary determinant of human traits and capacities and that racial differences produce an inherent superiority of a particular race, and that it is also the prejudice based on such a belief

The United Nations states it as:

the term “racial discrimination” shall mean any distinction, exclusion, restriction or preference based on race, color, descent, or national or ethnic origin which has the purpose or effect of nullifying or impairing the recognition, enjoyment or exercise, on an equal footing, of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the political, economic, social, cultural or any other field of public life.

None of these definitions come close to the HoS view that racism is nothing to do with skin colour and everything to do with power.  I do hope the HoS at some stage will expand on their view that by definition Maori activists can not be racists.

Defending her honour

The Labour Party seems to be adopting a policy that violence is okay when done to defend a woman’s honour. At least they have not yet signed up to honour killings!

First we had the PM defending what Trevor Mallard did by saying he was protecting a woman’s honour.

Now Sunday News reports that Labour Party activist Len Richards is also defending his actions on the ground he was trying to defend his wife’s honour.

What a good time for an anti-violence campaign.

Whale Oil has done a You Tube video commemorating all the recent Labour Party assaults.

Fraud psychic healer exposed

The Herald on Sunday is doing God’s work by exposing a psychic healer who hits on his clients victims. This one is a John Clarke.

I have nothing but contempt for these people. They not only effectively steal from vulnerable and distressed people, but they use the sessions to try and sleaze on them.

I’d happily have a law which says anyone who claims to be a psychic but can not pass a controlled test of their powers with at least a 50% accuracy rate should go to jail for fraud.  They really are parasites. Hell maybe even a 10% accuracy rate – I doubt any psychics would even manage that unless it was a multi-choice test.

It’s Union vs Union!

According to the SST, one of the people hit by Len Richards with the megaphone was Jared Phillips. Now Phillips is an organiser with the Unite Union, while Richards is associated with the Service and Food Workers Union.

Someone should be sent in to mediate between the warring Unions before things escalate.  But who can we send in?  Needs to be someone senior.

Hmmn, wait – I think I’ve got it.  Let’s send the Minister of Labour in.  The Minister is the ideal person to tell the unionists that they shouldn’t thump each other. Now who’s the new Minister again?

Reaction to Tax Cuts pledge

For those of us who believe in letting people keep more of their own earnings, Labour’s pledge to cut taxes is welcome.  National will feel obligated to come up with a bolder tax relief plan than Labour, so we end up getting more of our own money back than would otherwise have been the case.  If Labour win, we get something back, rather than nothing.  If National wins, we get a bigger tax cut than would probably have been the case otherwise.

The HoS has reactions from a few people:

Tax expert Craig Elliffe said tax cuts were long overdue. “Everyone, except Dr Cullen, has recognised we have been overtaxed for a long time. And I guess the logic is the tax cuts should be given to the people who have overpaid that tax.”

Indeed Dr Cullen has been the sole holdout for many years.

Parliament Open Day

Today is Open Day at Parliament.  If you are in Wellington, go along from 10 am onwards (last entry 3.30 pm).

On top of the normal tours, the Parliamentary Cafe will be open, an MPs office available for inspection and other areas not normally on public tours.  A good initiative by the Speaker.

Labour promises tax cuts

It’s now official – Labour will deliver tax cuts in 2008.  Helen Clark made the pledge at the Labour Party conference today.

Now this is the same Government who not only refused to give tax cuts five months ago, they actually cancelled the tax cuts announced in 2005.  So their sudden belief in tax cuts has nothing to do with the polls they claim, but after eight years of opposing tax cuts, they have by coincidence changed their minds in just five months.  Suddenly they claim the surpluses are large enough to be structural.

Well this is of course crap.  Even a moronic year ten economics student could have concluded some years ago that there was big enough surpluses for tax cuts.  I mean, for God’s sake we have the second largest fiscal surplus in the world.

Let’s take a look at the fiscal surplus projected in the last four budgets. These figures are the average of the Operating Surplus Projections less NZ Super Fund surplus, for the four projected years in each budget.  So the figure for 2004 is the average of the projections for 04/05 to 07/08.

2004 $4.68 billion
2005 $4.55 billion
2006 $3.81 billion
2007 $3.86 billion

What this clearly shows is that the projected surpluses in the 2007 BEFU are significantly below what they were in 2004 and 2005, and around the same as 2006.   In other words tax cuts were more affordable in 2004 and 2005, than they are today.

So forget the nonsense that Treasury is to blame, and suddenly they have said tax cuts are now affordable.  Colin Espiner points out Treasury have been saying since at least 2005 that tax cuts are affordable.  Yes Treasury has been under estimating the surplus – but this has been known for some time.  In fact I have blogged about this for some years.

Anyway does Labour now promising tax cuts mean they can be called National-lite? 🙂

Labour Party Delegate whacks protester in head with megaphone

Telstra-Clear blocking Kiwiblog

I am sure it is a technical mishap, but I’ve had several Telstra-Clear customers complaint they can not reach Kiwiblog today.  They can ping it okay, but not view it in their browser.  One has tried multiple browsers.

I don’t think I can do anything at my end, so people will need to wait for TCL to fix whatever the problem is.

1,000 users

At times a few vocal people post so much that you might think only a couple of dozen people post comments on Kiwiblog.  But one of the good things about requiring registrations to comment, is one can count up how many commenters Kiwiblog has.

This morning Kiwiblog gained its 1000th registered commenter.  The prize goes to “Cranny” for being No 1,000.  His ID Number is actually 1,112 but 112 spam and duplicate users have been deleted over the months.

It’s a pity that WordPress doesn’t keep count of how many comments each commenter makes.  That would make for some interesting stats.  Anyone know a plugin which would do that?

The number of comments made hit 250,000 last week also.

Peter Dengate-Thrush elected Chairman of ICANN

I’m just heard the news and am incredibly pleased that Peter Dengate-Thrush has been elected to replace Vint Cerf as Chairman of ICANN – the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Number, which oversees primarily the domain name system which is so integral to the Internet.

Peter is a Wellington lawyer, and a former President of InternetNZ.  To say he has big shoes to fill is an under-statement.  Vint Cerf quite literally co-created the Internet, or at least the main protocol it runs on.

Peter’s election by his fellow board members is a tremendous recognition of his skills and all the hard work he has put into ICANN.  ICANN is a very imperfect beast, often (rightfully) criticised.  Peter has been a long standing “constructive critic” – standing up to ICANN when they are wrong, but helping ICANN to improve things.

ICANN is seen by some as too controlled by the US Government.  Having a New Zealander as its Chair will help with its international acceptability.  Incidentially the CEO is an Australian.

InternetNZ will be delighted to have one of its own, take the Chair – especially in the same week InternetNZ and ICANN finally reached their own agreement with regards to InternetNZ’s management of the .nz top level domain. We supported Peter when he stood for election to the Board three years ago, and while not having a vote in this election, have been quietly supportive and hoping he would win the election for Chair – not just because he is a Kiwi, but because he shares our values of being focused on registrants rights, openess, transparency and good governance.

The only sadness with Peter’s election, is a reminder that his wife Liz isn’t here to see him get elected.  Peter’s wife, father and brother were all killed in an car crash last year.  Liz had a few weeks earlier organised Peter’s 50th birthday party and it was stunningly clear how much they loved and were proud of each other.  If Liz were alive today I think she would be the proudest person alive.

Labour’s fresher faces

In a story mainly about George Hawkin’s recovery from cancer surgery (which happily looks to be successful) the NZ Herald listed at the very end a list of expected fresher faces as candidates. They were:

  • Andrew Little
  • Phil Twyford
  • Grant Robertson
  • Connor (sic) Roberts
  • Kate Sutton
  • Clare Curran
  • Stuart Nash
  • Paul Chalmers
  • Don Pryde
  • Jordan Carter
  • Hamish McCracken

Twyford, Nash, Chalmers and McCracken stood in 2005, so their inclusion is no surprise.  Not sure if they still qualify as fresh though.

I would be surprised if Jordan Carter or Conor Roberts stand in 2008.  I suspect the Herald has not spoken to them directly- especially hard as Jordan is in Brussels at the moment.

Little, Robertson, Curran, and Pryde have all publicly talked about their ambitions, so no detective work there.

Kate Sutton is the current Women’s Vice-President for Labour.  I don’t know if Kate will stand in 2008 or not, but would not be surprised.  She has already sought elected office at Auckland City Council, being elected to the Tamaki Community Board in 2004 and 2007.

The old unintended consequences rule

This was predictable.

As the Government moves to ban certain types of party pills, that then leaves an unsatisfied demand which will look for alternatives.  And as the Herald reports, the next generation of pills may be as or more dangerous than the current ones.

Prohibition – in its 2,000th year of working unsuccessfully!

Free Rick Giles

Some blog readers may know Rick Giles who has been blogging for a while.

Well he is currently in detention in the United States, and has been for over a month.   And what is this terrible crime has has been charged with?  He thought his visitor’s visa expired on 27th September (it was actually 20 September) and on the 26th as he was preparing to leave to Canada, he asked a cop for directions to the bus station.  The cop noted he was a couple of days overdue and arrested him.

Read the full story over at Solo. While Rick was of course wrong to have over stayed by a couple of days, it is mind bloggling to think one can end up in jail for weeks on end for this.  It also sounds like he is getting little consular support.

He still has no court date, hasn’t even been formally arrested, is just held in detention.  It sounds like he will be released and deported in a week or so – after six weeks detention.

This should be a wake up call for anyone visiting the US – be very very careful with your visa dates.  The consequences can be dire.

But it also reflects badly on the US – there has to be a better way to handle immigration than this.  I mean six weeks detention for a couple of days overdue – shocking.

Bad Planning

A bad planning award to Singapore Air for introducing first class suites with double beds, but then failing to sound proof the cabins, with the end result that couples are asked to refrain from joining the mile high club.  Sort of defeats the whole point of having the suite and a double bed I would say!

Doctors lash Hodgson

Goodness – Pete Hodgson really seems to have riled the doctors’ union. Normally when a Minister retires, they find at least something nice to say. But instead we got:

“His behaviour and inertia in response to advice and alarm from many groups of doctors is mind-boggling,” Dr Brown told the association’s annual meeting in Wellington yesterday.

Health professional-led networks were the best way of improving patient care, yet despite numerous pleas from doctors’ organisations, Mr Hodgson had allowed boards to exclude senior doctors from any initiatives for joint or regional collaboration, he said.

It’s amazing what a difference a Minister can make. Annette King kept the sector groups happy so much better than Hodgson. At least this will make Cunliffe’s job easier – they now have lower expectations.

Made the A List!

Little may stand

Engineering, Printing and Manufacturing Union General Secretary Andrew Little is now re-considering whether to stand for Labour this election, after earlier deciding not to.

It will be a coup for Labour if they do get Little to stand this time.  He has been an incredibly effective union leader, with astute judgement as to when to bash an employer, and when to work constructively with them.  Because he does have a record of constructive engagement (unlike some other unions), then when he does bash an employer head on – it makes people think the employer is partially or primarily at fault.

He also helped save NZUSA from falling apart during his term as NZUSA President.  Before Andrew it was incredibly bloated with around 14 fulltime VPs and staff.  Not that all the credit for saving it goes to him, but he was a key player.

While it is by no means at all guaranteed (politics is often about events dear boy events) I would not be surprised to see Andrew as Labour Party Leader one day.

So why the potential change of mind for Andrew?  Is it because he now thinks they are more likely to win in 2008 and he could go straight into Cabinet?  Possible, but while the polls have tightened, they have not closed that much to make you give up a job you are dedicated to.

I wonder if it is the fall of Maharey and Mallard?  The reality is that at present, if Helen Clark goes in 2009, Phil Goff is the only viable choice to replace her.  In one week he went from long shot to heir in waiting.

Have the powers that be realised that if Andrew leaves off Parliament until 2011, it will be too late for him to be a viable alternative?  Even if Clark wins a 4th term, she would probably still step down somewhere form 2010 – 2012 as Labour Leader.

No one but Andrew knows why he is now reconsidering, but if you have made a decision already, there is usually a reason if you change your mind later.

It will be interesting to see what happens.

Parliament blocking blogs

I’ve just been notified that all blogspot blogs have been blocked at Parliament by Websense. Heh not just the Chinese Government censoring blogs 🙂

I wasn’t aware Parliament now has any sort of filter system. It didn’t when I was there. Or if they did, it was very invisible.

UPDATE: Sounds like it was primarily an IT problem and access will be restored. People should let me know next week if there are still problems.

UPDATE2: Now this is really silly. They’ve even blocked a blog run by an MP. Is it January 1st and the Electoral Finance Bill is already law?

The Grimes proposals

Arthur Grimes has made some interesting proposals on tax.  Grimes is the Chair of the Reserve Bank Board, but these are his personal proposals.  He advocates:

  • A 1% land tax
  • Increase GST to 15%
  •  0% income tax on the first $9,500 of income
  • 10% income tax from $9,500 to $38,000
  • 20% income tax on income over $38,000

Now what is the revenue affect on each proposal?

  • New Land Tax – $12 billion more (costed by Grimes)
  • Increase GST – $1.7 billion more
  • Decrease Bottom Rate – $3.3 billion less
  • Decrease Lower Middle Rate – $4.3 billion less
  • Decrease Upper Middle Rate – $1.7 billion less
  • Decrease Upper Rate – $2.9 billion less

The approximate loss of tax revenue is $12.1 billion against $13.7 billion in more tax, so it is definitely fiscally affordable. I’ve used the Treasury tax calculator but one should only use that for minor changes of 2% or 3% as it ignores some macro-economic factors.  I suspect Dr Grimes has done more precise calculations.  I suspect the loss on revenue won’t be as great as $12.1 billion because the desire to avoid the higher tax rates would diminish, and more income would be declared as taxable.

On the tax reduction side, I love the idea of a 0%, 10% and 20% structure.  I like the fact that most of the money will go on reducing the lower and the lower middle rates. Imagine earning $35,000 and paying only $2,550 in tax or an average 7.3%.

The biggie of course is the land tax.  I do share some of Dr Cullen’s concerns:

Finance Minister Michael Cullen, also at the meeting, questioned how people would pay the land tax if they owned property that was not earning an income, but he would not comment further.

A 1% land tax is pretty high.  On an average urban property it would be several thousand a year. Of course almost all land owners would probably get more back from the tax cuts.

On the other hand, land tends to appreciate faster than 1% per year, so land would still be a good investment, just less so.  The cashflow issue is more the problem.  I’m not sure taxing ownership rather than activity is a desirable thing.  Might start off on land but give the Greens a chance and you’ll be taxed for owning large easter eggs and non approved cars.

What I’d love to see happen, is for the Government to seriously investigate the proposal.  Do a proper costing of the numbers.  Produce scenarios on how it would affect people at various income levels and different levels of land ownership.  See if there is a way to make such a package work as a win-win.  Also most importantly see what effect it would have on increasing our economic growth and our national standard of living.  It’s not just about how to divide the pie up, it’s about trying to grow the pie faster so we can keep up with Australia.

General Debate 2 November 2007

Facing Off at 11

I’m on Newstalk ZB’s face off panel today from 11 to 12.  Always a fun event.  One of the othre three panelists is Charles Chauvel who I will have to tease about announcing his own promotion before the PM has confirmed it 🙂

Had fun yesterday on the TVNZ Good Morning political panel.  We mainly talked reshuffle but diverted briefly into the Mallard issue, and how the PM kept defending Mallard, despite supposedly reprimanding him.

I pointed out that the PM’s story had changed over the last week from Tau provoked Trevor,  to Tau grabbed Trevor’s tie, and then the latest was Tau grabbed Trevor’s tie and neck.  At this rate I expected by next week the story to be that Tau had delivered a flying kick to Trevor’s head, which is why Trevor punched him. Tau has pointed out that he only grabbed Trevor’s tie after Trevor hit him, and what is most telling is that Trevor himself isn’t publicly claiming the PM’s version of events is right.  This is just Clark spinning. If Tau really had grabbed Trevor by the throat first, then it would have been a cold day in hell before Trevor would have apologised for whacking him.

Anyway getting back to media stuff, I was also on ZB news yesterday morning commenting on the reshuffle. Many friends have complained to me how distuurbing it is to wake up to my voice 🙂

What I found interesting was how my comments were used.  When they interviewed me an hour or so after the reshuffle on Wednesday I played it pretty straight and listed what I thought was the positive aspects and the negative aspects.  Then on Thursday when I read a summary on NZPA of the ZB story, I thought hey they’ve only gone with my negative comment on how Mallard was really promoted not demoted.

But ironically, the actual audio, seems to have gone with mainly my positive comments.  I haven’t heard it myself but had a string of e-mails and calls semi-complaining that I was the only commentator saying positive things about the reshuffle.
So I thought it was rather ironic, that the web version seemed to emphasise my negative comments, while the audio version emphasised my positive comments.  This is of course a normal part of any sub-editing process.

Anyway need to now go and think about who to award Bouquet of the Week and Brickbat of the Week to.  Always the most fun part of being on the Faceoff panel.