Private lives now out of order

The Press reports that the Speaker, Margaret Wilson, plans to crack down on references to MPs private lives in Parliament.

Wilson said it had become clear that the punch-up between Mallard and Henare had come about because of the general conduct of MPs in the House, and she had instructed her officials to be stricter on behaviour.

“Offensive or unbecoming references to members’ private affairs have become all too common in the chamber. They create disorder and I and the other presiding officers intend to deal with them very firmly in future,” Wilson said.

Now I support the Speaker 100% in her decision to crack down, but I do wonder about the timing.

Couldn’t the Speaker have decided to crack down after Mallard and Benson-Pope started referring to Don Brash’s alleged affair in the House?  That would have been a sensible time to crack down.

Wouldn’t any of the several dozen times a Labour or NZ First MP has referred disparagingly to Nick Smith’s stress leave have been a good time to crack down?

Better late then never though.

General Debate 8 November 2007

Anthony & Cleopatra

I blogged a bit over three years ago about the superb “Masters of Rome” series by Colleen McCullough.  It is a fantastic series and is largely responsible for my interest in the old Roman Republic (which was far better than the Empire).

I’m surprised by how many other people have commented to me on how influential that series was to them.  It’s factual accuracy is almost unparalleled.  In fact it partly spoils other historical fiction from that era, as they are almost always less accurate.

She ended the series of six with the October Horse concluding at the Battle of Philippi which saw Octavian and Mark Anthony triumph over Brutus and Cassius – thus marking the end of the Republic in her eyes.

I always wanted her to do a further book, and it seems so have many other people – because she has.  I had no idea she was even working on a 7th book until I saw it for sale at Dymocks at the weekend.  Since then I have been making my way in my spare time.  It is very much up to her normal standard and is called Anthony & Cleopatra.

The book covers the years from the Battle of Philippi to the final confrontation between Octavian and Mark Anthony, with the victorious Octavian becoming Augustus – the first Roman Emperor (in practice, but not title).

The Masters of Rome series tends to appeal to fans of politics.  It’s a great mixture of politics, war, and law with some larger than life characters.  Fans of the series include Bob Carr, Henry Kissinger and Newt Gingrich.

So if you need a good Christmas present for a friend who enjoys politics – try buying them The First Man in Rome.  And if they already have the series, let them know that finally there is the seventh book, and they’ll be running down to the bookstore to buy it.

General Debate 07 November 2007

De Facto State Funding

Otago University Political Studies Lecturer Dr Bryce Edwards blogs on the move by Parliament to legalise pledge card type expenditure, labelling it as de facto back door political party state funding.

The illegal misuse of taxpayer funds by parliamentary parties to pay for their 2005 election campaigns was the biggest scandal to come out of that election. The Auditor-General Kevin Brady made a ruling – based on Crown Law advice – that $1.2m of taxpayer money had been illegally spent by most parties (and in particular the Labour Party). Despite promises to fix this problem to prevent it happening again, the Government has just announced a backroom deal has been reached that will actually make the matter worse by allowing the parliamentary parties even more scope to misuse the funding.

It was public outrage that caused Labour to pay back its pledge card and associated illegal expenditure, and to also drop plans for full state funding of political parties.  The challenge is to get the public to realise that Parliament is about to both legalise future pledge cards, exempt them from spending limits and allow for much greater abuse of parliamentary funds.

Bryce goes on to explain:

The Labour Government has cobbled together the support of a number of minor parties to push through new parliamentary spending rules that will ensure that the millions of dollars of taxpayer funds can more easily be used for party political purposes without the Auditor General being able to prevent or complain about their use.

And then Bryce looks at the overall effect of what Labour is doing:

The upshot of all of this – in the context of the current attempts to ‘reform’ political finance in NZ – is that it seems that the Labour Party and its supporting parties are combining three strategies to ensure their own advantage: [1] increasing their state funding; [2] ensuring the rules for the use of the funding still facilitate its party political use; and [3] using the Electoral Finance Bill to clamp down on any other groups spending their own money on politics. Combined together, these strategies are a formidable attempt to tilt the playing field in a certain direction whereby the Labour Party win and many others lose.

In other words, they are worried they can’t win a fair election, so they are changing the rules to ensure an unfair contest they can win.

Why did Winnie miss out?

A few people have commented that Winnie Laban was hard done by, remaining a Minister outside Cabinet while Steve Chadwick leapfrogs her to go straight into Cabinet.

Laban is a very gracious, well liked MP and Minister.  Never going to be a front bencher but does her duties diligently and well.

Tapu Misa writes:

Is it time the Pacific Island community took another look at its devotion to Labour? After last week’s Cabinet reshuffle, even the faithful are beginning to wonder whether it’s time to spread the love around.

Laban is passionate about the portfolio, but she’ll have to work hard to make an impact from outside Cabinet. And the fact that Clark promoted others over her head doesn’t bode well.

The next day another group of Pacific leaders made their displeasure known to Radio New Zealand’s Richard Pamatatau. Labour had deceived Pacific voters, the very voters whose loyalty had won them the election in 2005, said youth leader Efeso Collins. Dr Sitaleki Finau, Pasifika director at Massey University, said Labour had shown what it really thinks of Pacific people. Putting the portfolio outside Cabinet would marginalise any policy and strategy work for Pacific people, he said. Labour had forgotten that Pacific people helped them squeeze home in 2005.

The win-win would have been to put Laban into Cabinet and make Steve Chadwick a Minister outside Cabinet.  Maybe Clark judged that Woman’s Affairs portfolio has to be in Cabinet but Pacific Island Affairs does not?

Curran to stand

Clare Curran has confirmed she will seek the Dunedin South candidacy for Labour. Good.

I think it is a healthy thing in all parties when there is a contest for the nomination – especially in safe seats where winning the nomination almost makes you the MP by default.

That makes three challengers to David Benson-Pope.  I wonder if he will withdraw and retire with some dignity rather than be thrown out?

Does anyone who knows, want to comment on how Labour selections cope with more than two candidates?  If no candidate has a majority of the seven votes, does the one with the least support drop out?

That is what happens in National.  There are generally 60 delegates and up to five candidates.  If none of them get 31 or more votes – a majority, the lowest polling one drops out and then everyone votes again.  One can end up with four rounds of voting on the selection night.

For a few years the rules had people rank the candidates, so that if no one got a majority, they merely reallocated the preferences of the lowest polling (like in Australia) until there was a winner.  It was a lot quicker, and mathmetically the same thing as multiple rounds of voting.

However members actually enjoyed the suspense of learning the result stage by stage, and revoting after learning who had been eliminated.  So the rules changed back a couple of years ago.

Enough is enough

The Herald reports that a private prosecution has been launched against Trevor Mallard over his punch to Tau Henare.

While Mr McCready has a legal right to pursue such a prosecution, I think it serves no useful value when the person hit doesn’t wish to complain.  Sure it would be different if it was domestic violence but Tau definitely ain’t Trevor’s missus 🙂

Hone Harawira on the law

In a debate on the Terrorism Suppression Amendment Bill today, Maori MP Hone Harawira said:

“I will not sit quietly by while the state forces terrorise my people…I will challenge the rule of law and I will oppose the rule of law if terrorism is a vehicle being used by the state forces of this country to terrorise Maori communities.”

Call me old fashioned but I think an MP stating they will oppose the rule of law is a very very bad thing.

Who said this?

Interesting Questions for today

2. JOHN KEY to the Prime Minister: Does she stand by her statement, in regard to a personal tax cut, that “I’d have liked to have done it earlier and I think all our Cabinet and caucus would have, but we’ve never had advice which made that possible”; if so, why?

4. Hon BILL ENGLISH to the Minister of Finance: Does he agree with the previous Minister of Justice that “The Electoral Finance Bill needs to align with the review of Parliamentary expenditure”; if so, why?

1. HEATHER ROY to the Chairperson of the Justice and Electoral Committee: What is the committee’s timetable in relation to the Electoral Finance Bill?

The Government Research Unit needs to come up with better patsies.  The Government has the prized No 1 spot today and they are wasting it on:

1. Hon MARK GOSCHE to the Minister of Transport: What reaction has she received to the launch of Sea Change, the draft domestic sea freight strategy?

I mean seriously – a draft domestic sea freight strategy.  Okay well like 99% of people I’ve now learnt we’ve got one. Zzzzzzzzzzzzz.

General Debate 6 November 2007

Australian election update

It still looks highly likely John Howard will lose office later this month.  The bookmakers are betting on a Labor victory, Labor have led in every poll for 14 months and Rudd is well ahead of Howard as Preferred PM.  When the incumbent PM isn’t even Preferred PM, you know you have trouble.

The Australian has quite a good article on where things stand.

The best hope for the Coalition may be the FPP type system (actualy more an IR system) where it all comes down to marginal seats.  This article does suggest they are doing better in the marginals. They key thing to remember for Australia is people do not vote uniformly. Results will be very different in the Queensland marginals compared to the NSW marginals.  A simple pendulum is too simple.

Having said that, I still think Labor will have a handy majority – may be as large as the Coalition now has.  But let’s see how the last three weeks go.

Missed his birthday wishes

You have to feel for James Sleep.  His birthday (15th I think?) was during the Labour Party conference and he had no less a person than the PM announce it was his birthday and wish him a happy birthday.  That’s pretty cool for any young political activist.

Alas poor James was in the bathroom when it happened!

Nice to be young enough to still see a birthday as a good thing 🙂

Fan Clubs

Jordan Carter blogs on the reaction from some people to the Herald story speculating he will stand for Parliament in 2008.

It goes without saying that Jordan and I disagree on most policy and political issues. We have very different world views.  We do agree in a few areas of course.

But Jordan is very right when he says he has developed an excellent career outside politics.  Jordan doesn’t exactly discuss all his job offers with me, but I’m well aware he has had numerous offers to work in the Beehive.  I think he has shown great wisdom in building up a private sector career.  I’m also somewhat biased, because I also benefit from the first class work Jordan does for InternetNZ.  His work is highly respected by not just InternetNZ, but also other sector groups, and various Government agencies.

In fact it amazes me how someone who is such a superb policy analyst, can be so wrong on so many policies 🙂

I also have to give Jordan a tick for being consistent and saying he still doesn’t support tax cuts – he realises Labour is doing them out of political necessity rather than conviction. Just as I don’t think anyone really thinks National loves the Cullen Fund or Kiwibank – it’s just an acceptance of the majority view. Politics is about the possible.

It’s a pity there is at times such vehemence against those with opposing views. My favourite nights out are when there is a mixture of lefties and righties – you get great debates, good arguments and oh yeah pretty drunk 🙂

It one of the reasons why I spend a fair bit of time debating issues in the comments, rather than just not participating.  I actually enjoy a good contest of ideas.  I’ve been doing it since 1996 when I discovered Usenet (which is incidentally how I first met Jordan).  It’s also why I started reading blogs and commenting on them before I decided to set up my own.

Latest Broadband Stats

The OECD has released it’s latest broadband stats.  Some good news for New Zealand as we have gone up one further place to 20th.  We were in 22nd for many years.  We now have 683,500 broadband connections which is a rate of 16.5 per 100 households. However the OECD average is 18.8 and the median is 21.7.  So some way still to go.

Our increase over the last year has been 4.94 per 100 homes which is the 9th highest (out of 30) growth rate.  That’s pretty good – we are catching up.

Fibre now represents 8% of all OECD broadband connections, and 36% of Japan’s, plus 31% of Korea’s.  Serious fibre rollout is the future.  Also Sweden has 16% fibre, Sloval Republic 16%, Denmark 9%.
Also get this – the price of fibe per MB/s of speed is:

  • DSL: USD 19.21
  • Cable: USD 18.96
  • Fiber to the home/building: USD3.75
  • Wireless: USD 18.69

The average download speed in the OECD is 13.7 Mb/s.  Sob.

Japan has the fastest speed – 93 Mb/s available. The average fibre speed is 77.1 Mb/s.

We are one of 20 countries with data caps, but only one of four countries which has every single package on offer data capped. The average data cap is 21GB in the OECD.

Some quite fascinating other data in the OECD stats.  They even have a bot infection rate per 100broadband subscribers.  Of 36 countries, we are 25th with a 1.1% rate. Poland has 6.8% infection, France 2.9%, Australia 1.7%.

Cullen backs Nash

Michael Cullen is one of those who has signed the nomination papers for Stuart Nash in Napier, despite the fact he is standing against the former electorate MP and current list MP Russell Fairbrother.

This is a significant event.

Now generally speaking signing a nomination paper doesn’t mean you support a candidate. It just means you want a contest. In National it is quite common for a core set of members to sign the nomination papers for all nominees in an electorate. I suspect it is the same in Labour. And Michael Cullen did say he was also happy to sign Fairbrother’s nomination form also – something missing from the Herald version of the NZPA story.

But while it is one thing for normal party members to sign nomination forms for challengers to an MP, I can’t recall having heard of an MP being willing to sign a nomination form for a challenger to one of their own colleagues.

I suspect things look grim for Fairbrother.

While talking things Labour, I hear on the grapevine that 2008 may not be too early for young Conor Roberts, contrary to my suggestion last week. Conor is one of those guys who almost everyone likes. A truly decent guy. Personally I think he should get some more work experience before trying to become an MP, but he’d be a credit
to any party if he stands.

UPDATE: Tukituki MP Craig Foss is enjoying the fight!

NZPA on Legalise Pledge Card legislation

The NZ Herald runs an NZPA story on the obscure legislation which will legalise Labour’s pledge card.

Legislation that would allow Labour and other parties to use taxpayer funds for pledge card-type campaigns at the next election was tabled in Parliament yesterday.

But Mr Brownlee said National was against the bill in principle because it gave a huge advantage to incumbent MPs and parties.

He said it was particularly galling that the Government appeared to be liberalising the rules for party spending when it was moving to clamp down on all other groups’ election spending through the Electoral Finance Bill.

From what I can tell, this Bill will not even be referred to select committee. They won’t even let the public have a say on whether taxpayer money should be spent on election pledge cards.

And as Gerry says, it is deeply troubling that Labour moves to liberalise its own spending, while clamping down on everyone outside Parliament.

Do you know what I would do if I was National?  Use their own parliamentary budget to fund a series of billboards and newspaper ads advising people  that billboards and ads like this will legally be able to be run even in the week before the election, funded by taxpayers, and not as party of a party’s spending limit.

Blaming Treasury not credible

It seems few people are falling for Helen Clark’s line that Treasury is to blame for no tax cuts in the last eight years.

First of all I know a fair few Treasury staff.  Yet to meet one who doesn’t think it is a good idea to cut taxes.  In fact they usually only disagree on whether a top rate of 25% or 20% is best.  Blaming Treasury for not being able to cut taxes is like blaming the Greens for the lack of a carbon tax.

The NZ Herald editorial accuses the PM of rewriting history.  She is.

The Government has been treating the surplus as structural for at least five years. It would not have set up the “Cullen fund” for superannuation if it believed surpluses could not be sustained. It was the Government’s choice to save or spend its annual excess revenue rather than permanently lower taxation. It always had the latter option and it is a bit rich now to blame advisers for the choices it made.

They also warn that the tax cuts must be genuine:

This time even Dr Cullen sounds resigned to finding “something for everybody”, though that means, he warns, not much for anybody. No matter, as long as the cut is not a selective “credit” like the family rebate a few years ago that only added to public liabilities. A genuine tax cutter does not differentiate between the overtaxed, he simply ceases to take more than he needs. Next year we might get it back.

Exactly the overtaxation should be refunded.

Brian Fallow writes on the same issue:

The Prime Minister’s attempt to blame the Treasury for the fact that we have not had personal income tax cuts already is hard to swallow.

Yes Treasury has been too conservative with their forecasts, but there has still been a surplus of surpluses from which tax cuts could be funded.

“It never hit him”

I actually feel sorry a bit for Labour.  Obviously Len Richards is not thinking of the party’s greater good, otherwise he would be shutting up.  But no he is determined to keep the megaphone incident alive, by now insisting that the megaphone never hit UNITE organiser Jared Phillips.

I suspect Mike Williams would happily wrap the megaphone around Mr Richards’ neck.

Wayne Brown takes charge

I can only admire Wayne Brown’s style as the new Mayor of Far North.  First of all we have his message to staff:

Promising “a massive cultural change”, he said staff were to “listen, ring back, help ratepayers, not hinder, look for solutions, not arguments”.

They were never to “insult, infuriate or demonise” ratepayers. Picking on the poor and disabled was not acceptable.

Apologies had to be made for stupid behaviour and mistakes – “and there have been plenty” – approvals should be sought rather than hearings, lawyers should be avoided, and plain English or Maori used where possible to inject “some special flavour” of the district.

Wayne Brown for King I say!

But then it gets even better:

Mr Brown, the outgoing Auckland District Health Board chairman and a Mangonui resident, scrapped all committees other than “a much-needed” audit and finance panel, which did not exist under the last council.

He scrapped every single committee!!  I wonder if in a year people will wonder what they ever did!

And then he looks at cost savings:

All council costs are to be reviewed to ensure they’re at least as low as in the private sector. All council meetings, both official and staff only, will be questioned for their “value” and more use made of “modern communications” to reduce staff, councillor and public travel.

Far North may end up with a Council which cuts rates!

After Wayne has had two terms up North, we should rotate him around the country!

The smoking backlash

The other day one of the ZB panel questions was whether the National Anthem should be compulsory in schools, and my response was nothing would be worse as compulsion tends to lead to a backlash, especially amongst younger people.

With that in mind, I view with interest the NZ Herald story that there has been a significant increase in smoking rates, despite the massive campaigns against smoking.

A Massey University survey for the Ministry of Health has found the number of people aged 15 to 45 who have smoked at least once in the previous year has increased from 31.1 per cent in 2003 to 35.8 per cent.

The survey may be a blip of course. It happens.

I’m by no means against public health campaigns. But this is a useful reminder that they can have little effect or even be counter productive.

UPDATE: On the subject of banning bad things, this other Herald story is fascinating.  For the first time in ages cannabis and P use is dropping.  Why?  because people are using legal drugs more, such as party pills.  So what is the Government about to do?  Ban party pills.  And guess what that might do to cannabis and P use then?  Okay – not as simple as that, but there are links.

Incidentally according to a 2001 report we’re a drug crazed lot. We are 2nd highest for cannabis, 2nd for amphetamines and 3rd for E.  Only average for cocaine and heroin though.

October Stats

Again rather busy so just some quick stats for Kiwiblog in October 2007.

Most unique visits in one day = 16,783

Increase in unique visits from Sep 07 = 10.7%

No of visits from Parliament = 6,932

Search Terms

kiwiblog 5826 11.9 %
computers internet blog 2421 4.9 %
david farrar 2346 4.8 %
all black jokes 1142 2.3 %
nicole begg 1034 2.1 %
farrar 684 1.4 %
kiwi blog 679 1.3 %
all blacks jokes 652 1.3 %
david p farrar 337 0.6 %
tame iti 308 0.6 %
david farrar blog 287 0.5 %
shane wenzel 259 0.5 %
www.kiwiblog.co.nz 256 0.5 %
kiwiblog.co.nz 247 0.5 %
nicole begg nude 234 0.4 %
reasons to stay in iraq 188 0.3 %
cactus kate 144 0.2 %
beat your boss 136 0.2 %
female israeli soldiers 131 0.2 %
south park series 11 123 0.2 %
hayley holt 112 0.2 %
kiwiblog nz 109 0.2 %
estonian women 98 0.2 %

Court date set for Electoral Finance Bill judicial review

Excellent news.  NZPA reports that the High Court at Wellington today agreed to urgently hear an application for a judicial review of the Electoral Finance Bill.

It has been set down for 27 November in Wellington.

Even better, the Judge has indicated that if the Government tries to progress the Bill before 27 November, the Court will consider an earlier date.

Now this action can not stop the Electoral Finance Bill being passed into law.   But it can get a decision that the Attorney-General and Crown Law were wrong to claim it does not breach the Bill of Rights.

Legalising the Pledge Card

The SST reveals the second part of Labour’s plan to skew the election rules for the next election.

The Auditor-General found last election that Labour had spent $800,000 of taxpayer money illegally. Labour is about to introduce a new law which will over-turn the Auditor-General’s (and Solicitor-General’s) interpretation of the electioneering and substitute a definition which will allow it to spend its parliamentary budget on another pledge card.

At the exact time that Labour and allies are seeking to restrict the money than can be spent by everyone else, they are throwing open the gates on their parliamentary spending. Under this new law, Labour could totally legally spent $2 million on advertising from its parliamentary budget in the week before the election, and not only have the taxpayer pay for it, but not have it count as election advertising under the Electoral Finance Bill.

The net effect of the Electoral Finance Bill and the Appropriation (Continuation of Interim Meaning of Funding for Parliamentary Purposes) Bill will be to legalise Labour’s illegal expenditure in 2005, and to criminalise what was legal expenditure in 2005 by other parties.

Now what do you call a country where the Government breaks the law, and then changes it so they can do the same thing again – but legally – while at the same time making illegal the previous legal activities of their critics?

This is one of those rare times where it is not hyperbole to label this as corrupt conduct. The Chief Electoral Officer, the Electoral Commission, the Auditor-General and the Solicitor-General all found the pledge card to be electioneering. A non-corrupt Government doesn’t vote with its mates to change the law to overturn the decisions of those impartial bodies of state.

Labour even voted to retrospectively amend the law last year to prevent a law suit on the pledge card, which would have allowed a High Court Judge to rule whether or not it was electioneering.

Can anyone really argue that an election pledge card should not be treated as an election expense? Well it won’t be under Labour’s two proposed laws.

Labour and other parliamentary parties will be able to use taxpayer funds to do full page newspaper ads the week before the election. So long as they do not explicitly ask for votes, they will be legal under labour’s new law.

On the day before the election Labour could spend one million dollars of taxpayer funding on say four fullpage advertisements in every newspaper in New Zealand. They could detail all of Labour’s proposed policies if re-elected, and all would be not only legally funded by the taxpayer, but would not even count as part of Labour’s election spending.

I hope National, and presumably at least ACT, fight this law with everything they have got. The Government plans to pass the law without even referring it to a select committee it seems (as not yet introduced and plans to pass by year end). They don’t want to have the public have a say. It’s up the the public and the media to demand they get a say.