Fairbrother vs Nash

Things seem to be getting fairly heated in Napier.

Incumbent Labour MP Russell Fairbrother, makes the Press for telling NZPA that Stuart Nash (his challenger) is adopted, and hence not a “blood relative” of former Labour PM Sir Walter Nash.

I doubt Fairbrother is making himself any friends by going around saying that.

By coincidence, there was a minor debate on the same issue in a related thread last week. Stuart Nash himself posts that he has never used the term “blood relative” but his father is the eldest son of the eldest son of Sir Walter, and that anyone claiming he is not really a Nash should try it on with his mother first to see her reaction.

As I said, I doubt Fairbrother’s tactics will go down well.

What’s wrong with the Bill

In this article the Herald looks at the Bill, and highlights the changes made at Select Committee.  The changes make the bill workable, but not desirable.

They have a good summary at the end, I reproduce here:

What’s wrong with the bill

It rewrites election laws in a partisan way.
New Zealand does not have a written constitution. It has a series of acts and conventions which make up our unwritten constitution. Electoral law is part of this, so it is usually changed in a bipartisan process – but not this time.

It expands the regulated spending period to almost a year.
The regulated period on free speech would expand from three months before an election to start on January 1 of election year – almost a third of the election cycle.

It doesn’t apply the same rules fairly.
The bill imposes new anonymous donation disclosure requirements on interest groups – but not political parties.

It could push some interest groups out of politics altogether.
A complicated compliance regime is imposed on interest groups that want to participate in elections. This may put them off participating at all.

It tilts the playing field in favour of the Government.
The tighter restrictions on candidates’ spending, seen in conjunction with the easing of parliamentary spending on communication, give sitting MPs an advantage.

And it gets even worse when you tie this into the changes for parliamentary spending, with parliamentary expenditure entirely exempted by the Bill.

Dom Post pokes fun

Saturday’s Dom Post editorial can’t resist directing its normal satire towards David Cunliffe with his declaration that he is now running things in Health.

Now whenever there is a problem, voters and opposition politicians will remind Mr Cunliffe that he is the man who says he is running things, and then inquire what he plans to do about the disaster of the day. Mr Cunliffe shows no doubts that he will be able to give an answer, and give a good one.

He is a man of not inconsiderable abilities. What became abundantly clear this week is that he is also a man not given to hiding his light under a bushel. Instead, his inclination is to clear-fell the area, set up some searchlights to add to his own brilliance, and issue invitations to a son et lumiere show.

When Mr Cunliffe has sorted out the health system – probably by Wednesday lunchtime at the latest – we don’t doubt he will be on the telephone to United Nations secretary general Ban Ki-moon and United States President George W Bush. After all, who else has the skills needed to settle the Iran crisis, come up with the perfect exit strategy for Iraq and deal with that spot of bother in Pakistan?

Heh.

Maori Seats Poll

I was just finishing off yesterday the monthly polling newsletter (which will cover all the public polls) and TVNZ released their Marae Digipoll which had all sorts of interesting material in there.

However, as is usual, the website only has top line details so I couldn’t access the full data.

But by coincidence I got a call from TVNZ today asking if I could comment for the six pm news on the results of the poll, which meant they sent me the full data. So I’ve spent some time today going through that.

Now the sample size for each electorate is small – an average of 95.  So care has to be taken with them.

Nevertheless in three of the four seats the Maori Party holds, their leads of 48% in Te Tai Tokerau, 20% in Te Tai Hauauru and 56% in Waiariki make them very safe.

In Tamaki Makaurau the Maori Party leads Labour by 5% on the electorate vote.   But as Sharples holds this seat, and the poll did not name the candidates, I don’t think anyone thinks he is at risk.

Then we turn to Te Tai Tonga which has Maori Party 44.3% and Labour 38.6%. Now on a small sample of 95, the probablity the Maori Party really is ahead is 73.0%.  By no means certain, but 3:1 likely.

In Ikaroa-Rawhiti the Maori Party is 48.8% and Labour 42.9% on the candidate vote.  The probability the Maori Party is actually ahead is 72.6%.  So again around 3:1 likely.

Finally in Tainui it is a tie with each on 43.9%.  But the poll was done on the old Tainui boundary and the new seat of Hauraki-Waikato delivers around 250 more votes to the Maori Party.  So Maori Party on the new boundary would be slightly ahead in reality.

But all three seats are competitive, and it will come down to quality of candidates, policies and events between now and then.

Interestingly if the Maori Party does win all seven seats, then will probably have four overhang seats and hold the balance of power.  It is possible their support would allow a Government to be formed which had less votes for it, than there were for the parties opposed to it.

Ban imbeciles not fireworks

The Herald on Sunday hits the mark with its other editorial also.

Whenever a politician – or anyone else – utters the word “ban”, it’s a sure sign that an overreaction is in progress. That is certainly true of the suggestions aired during the annual fireworks season. Prime Minister Helen Clark said last weekend that fireworks sales could be banned if “people were going to carry on being absolutely ridiculous”. Her remarks were reported after a series of incidents, some of which disrupted her own domestic repose; she said that her leafy Mt Eden neighbourhood was like “downtown Kandahar”.

The gratuitous tastelessness of that particular comparison was regrettable, but the PM was issuing a challenge. And it’s worth noting that, even if only incidentally, the country called her bluff. Acting national fire commander Paul McGill said this year’s was the quietest Guy Fawkes night since records began in 1996. The number of callouts was down 40 per cent on last year, which was itself down 40 per cent on 2005.

A ban on private use of fireworks would be silly, and not just because accidents, as we saw at Alexandra Park, Auckland, can happen at public displays. Seizing on the objects that stupid people use stupidly makes no more sense than banning cars, knives, glass containers and matches – all of which are implicated in mayhem. The Clark administration, which has a busybody reputation, does not want “Let’s stamp out fun” as a campaign slogan. Better to be grateful that so many of us are sensible people.

I should note that I didn’t think John Key’s agreement than a ban was inevitable one day, was the right message either.  If we carry on banning things because of a small proportion misuse it, we’ll be a very sad society.

Finlay says pay journalists more

Finlay MacDonald says one answer to the problem of left-wing bias (I prefer to think of it as world-view rather than conscious bias) is to pay journalists more.

While simplistic, he is partly right.

Top print journalists should be able to earn six figure sums.

I’m on a NZ journalism mailing list and from that have got some idea of pay rates, and they’re pretty appalling for many.

Trotter to Minto

Hos on Tax Cuts

The HoS is in a sarcastic mood when they discuss Labour’s assertion they have always supported tax cuts:

Some people may well accept the Prime Minister’s assurance that she and her caucus wanted to deliver tax cuts earlier but “we have never had [Treasury] advice that made it possible”. Very probably some people believe in a flat Earth and Santa Claus, too. But there is likely to be a hard core of non-believers who dimly discern a connection to the fact that next year is election year.

Ouch – comparing people who believe the PM to people who believe in a flat Earth.

Clark’s claim about Treasury is at best misleading. Its briefing to the re-elected Clark Government in 2005 explicitly stated that years of fiscal frugality had left the Crown accounts, and in particular the debt ledger, in such good shape that there was room for tax cuts. Cullen famously dismissed that advice as “an ideological burp”, but, having just got hold of the purse-strings for another three years, he could afford such dismissiveness. With Labour trailing in the polls less than a year out from the vote, he is more disposed to largesse.

Of course they may repeat their 2005 trick and announce them the year before an election and cancel them after the election.

Meurant calls on Broad to resign

NRT on force used to arrest

No Right Turn blogs on the Mark Edwards case, where he ended up with a broken neck after Police wrestled him to the floor to arrest him.

Now this guy was a large and by his own words drunk guy, and when having to wrestle someone to the ground who is resisting arrest, the chance of serious damage can’t be eliminated.  This isn’t to defend what happened in this case (I don’t know enough facts( but to recognise the risk.

So wouldn’t tasers have avoided what happened here?  Large drunk guy refusing to be arrested and leave the house where he was trespassing.  Rather than wrestle him to the ground risking both him and the police officers, a taser could have avoided what happened.

Air NZ lock out

The Dom Post reports that Air NZ has locked out 145 staff who won’t sign up to new terms and conditions.

The check-in staff and baggage handlers involved – members of the Service and Food Workers Union – have refused new terms and conditions, which they say will cost them up to $20,000 a year.

Now if I am reading this correctly, this means each individual staffer would earn $20,000 a year less.  That gives me two thoughts:

  1. I’d bloody well refuse to sign a new contract also if it meant my pay dropped by $20,000.
  2. How much does a baggage handler earn, if their earnings can drop by $20,000 and still be presumably high enough to attract new staff?

Camel Beauty Contests are evil

General Debate 10 November 2007

Will Benson-Pope go Independent?

The NZ Herald refers to speculation that David Benson-Pope might stand as an Independent if he does not get selected as the Labour candidate.

If he does, he wouldn’t be the first to do that. When Brian Neeson lost the Helensville nomination to John Key, Neeson eventually defected and stood as an Independent.

Of course both National and Labour nomination forms require you to swear that if unsuccessful you will not stand in opposition to the winning candidate. In fact you pledge to support them.

I’m a traditionalist when it comes to breaking a signed declaration and believe that doing so should make you ineligible to ever rejoin the party.

UPDATE: NZPA reports that Benson-Pope has now stated he will definitely not stand as an Independent is not selected as the Labour candidate.  Of course if he said anything else he would be sacked from the Caucus immediately, but I suspect he is telling the truth – he has been a long standing loyal member of Labour.

Dom Post on pledge card legalisation bill

Friday’s Dom Post Editorial lays into the The Appropriation (Continuation of Interim Meaning of Funding for Parliamentary Purposes) Bill.

The legislation is as outrageous as the spending that provoked it. It is every bit as outrageous as its companion measure, the Electoral Finance Bill, also before the House.

The former will allow political parties to spend their cut of the $14.6 million as they see fit; the latter will effectively deny all but Government MPs the opportunity to spend more than a pittance publicly advocating, backing or opposing policy.

Indeed.  It is a three part whammy:

  1. The EFB restricts how much one can criticise parties and MPs, extending the period of regulated speech
  2. The EFB exempts parliamentary spending
  3. The ACIMPPB removes restrictions on parliamentary expenditure in the last 90 days

The net effect is that you have de facto state funding of political parties, but even worse that their electioneering is exempt from electoral spending limits.

The Dom Post goes on to say:

It is incredible that any social democrat party would countenance such a move but when a party faces possible defeat, it can elevate ambition over ethics. Miss Clark seems to be calculating that the public interest in election spending is over – that, while voters got seriously angry in 2006, this latest row will be an overnight wonder.

National needs to ensure she is wrong.

Indeed.  National can not stop these two laws, but they should continue to remind the public of them right up until election day.

“I’m running this show”

I missed the House on Wednesday but I’ve had a couple of gallery journalists tell me that there was a priceless moment as David Cunliffe declared “I’m running this show”. The segment has found its way onto You Tube so enjoy:

General Debate 09 November 2007

NZ 5th best for gender gap

The World Economic Forum has published its 2007 rankings for 128 countries on the size of their gender gaps and NZ is in 5th place, as in the 5th smallest gender gap. That’s pretty good. Note however this is not a measure of how well off women are generally in each country – it is a measure of how they do compared to men.

So while the US may be in 31st place, you’d probably rather be a woman there than in Lesotho which is 26th.

NZ was 7th in 2006, so a slight improvement. The only countries ahead of us are Sweden, Norway, Finland and Iceland. We scored 76.5% and the top score was 81.5%

They provide breakdowns by income groups. The lowest ranking for a high income country is Saudia Arabia in 124th at 56.5%. Japan is low also in 91st place at 64.5%

The top middle income country is Latvia in 13th at 73.3% and bottom is Turkey at 57.7%.

For lower middle incomes, Philippines is top at 6th and 76.3% and bottom is Morocco in 122nd at 56.8%.

Finally the top low income country is Tanzania in 34th place scoring 69.7%. Bottom is Yemen in 128th with 45.1%.

Oh yes Borat’s Kazahstan actually does quite well at 32nd place and 69.8%.

The largest downwards movement was Nicaragua who dropped 20 places and is now 90th.

The methodology used is interesting. The overall score is an average of four group scores – for Economic Participation and Opportunity, Educational Attainment, Health and Survival Subindex and Political Empowerment.

NZ was 8th for economic participation, 19th for educational attainment, 67th for health and 9th for political empowerment. The top scores in each category by the way was Mozambique for economic participation, shared for educational attainment, shared for health and Sweden for political empowerment.

Looking further at the raw data, one soon realises that the educational and health scores have almost no effect because all the countries are so close together. The top
score in education is 100% and the median score is 98.9%. Going to health the top score is 98.0% and the median is 97.6%.

So in reality these rankings (unless you rank very very low) tell us little on health and education because the difference between top and median is slight.

In economic participation the top score is 79.7% and the median is 63.9%.  So a reasonable range.

For political empowerment, the top score is 52.5% and median is 10.5%.

So in reality this gender gap ranking is primarily a ranking of political empowerment.  We see this because four countries which top the political empowerment section also top the overall survey.

So what makes up the scores in the four groupings?

The economic participation group measures labour force participation, wage equality, income, and no of professionals and managers – all comparing female to male.  This group has some effect on the overall ranking.

Education covers literacy rate, primary enrolments, secondary enrolments and tertiary enrolments.  As I said, almost no difference between the top half.

Health covers life expectancy and sex ratio at birth. Again no real difference in the top half.

Political empowerment covers the ratio of female legislators, the ratio of female Ministers and the ratio of female to make heads of states for the last 50 years.  I wonder if they counted the Queen or the GGs for us?

So mostly the rankings reflect how many female MPs and Ministers a country has. Now one of the good things of MMP has been the increase towards a more representative House.

So it’s a good result to be 5th, but it doesn’t mean women in NZ are massively different off to say women in the UK which is 11th.

Probably the best result is being 8th for economic participation which reflects the high labour participation arte for women.

Most ludicrous laws

The BBC reports on a competition to pick the most ludicrous laws

  • It is illegal to die in the Houses of Parliament (27%)
  • It could be regarded an act of treason to place a postage stamp bearing the British king or queen’s image upside-down (7%)
  • Eating mince pies on Christmas Day is banned (5%)
  • In the UK, a pregnant woman can legally relieve herself anywhere she wants (4%)
  • The head of any dead whale found on the British coast automatically becomes the property of the King, and the tail of the Queen (3.5%)
  • It is illegal not to tell the tax man anything you do not want him to know, but legal not to tell him information you do not mind him knowing (3%)
  • It is illegal to enter the Houses of Parliament wearing a suit of armour (3%)
  • Sadly in NZ we don’t have many outdated laws to the extent the UK and US do.

    Fairbrother spits the dummy

    It seems that having Michael Cullen support Stuart Nash’s challenge for the Napier nomination has broken the loyalty of Russell Fairbrother. This is one reason MPs generally do not sign nominations forms for challengers.

    Fairbrother refused to ask his patsy question in Parliament yesterday.  Now he is not the first MP to refuse to ask a patsy, but normally the MP will do his defiance act out of sight by telling the Whips he or she won’t do it, and not turning up to the House.

    To actually be present in the House, to have it down in your name, and to refuse to ask the question is not something I can recall.

    Talking of Napier, Chris Tremain has challenged Michael Cullen to seek the Napier nomination for himself, so that the  public of Napier can get to directly vote on what they think of Cullen’s record on tax.

    Letter of the Week

    This letter from Bill Day to the Dominion Post has to win some sort of competition for best letter:

    I’m voting for the other Bill Day

    I refer to your article and photo of Wellingtonion of the Year finalist Bill Day.  Regretfully, there are two Bill Days in Wellington.

    The finalist Bill Day has devoted a lifetime to giving back to the community in areas such as the Life Flight Trust.  I, on the other hand am more known for the ruthless exploitation of land, labour and capital in pursuit of the profit motive, along with unsavoury recreational pursuits such as organising No Fat Chicks Tours to the Antarctic.

    Unfortunately, you used my photo.

    You are not the first to make this mistake.  Both of our fathers were also called Bill Day so this is the second generation of confusion.

    It all works out okay by me. I get cases of wine delivered at Christmas that were meant for him and he gets chased down the street by irate husbands that were after me.

    We should, though, acknowledge the real Bill Day, who has made our city a much better place and who will most certainly be getting my vote.

    BILL DAY
    Owhiro Bay

    The Bill Day who wrote the letter is the Seaworks Bill Day who won Entrepreneur of the Year in 2000.

    No prosecutions under the Terrorism Suppression Act

    The Solictor-General has decided not to authorise any charges under the Terrorism Suppression Act for the Urewera 17.

    This is a huge blow to Police credibility.  It is rare for the Solicitor-General to decline any request made by the Police.  Add to it, the use of the Act to justify the nature of the Police raids, and Commissioner Broad is in a very vulnerable position.

    This doesn’t mean those charged have not broken the law and done some stupid or bad things.  The evidence on that awaits a trial.  It also doesn’t mean the Police were wrong to arrest them.

    But it does most seriously call into question the need for 300 armed Police doing simultaneous raids around the country.

    There will be questions in Parliament next week, no doubt, on whether the Police Commissioner still has the confidence of the Minister. 

    Government to ram Electoral Finance Bill through

    NBR Reports:

    The government will ram through its draconian Electoral Finance Bill through Parliament by the end of next week – two months earlier than the Crown Law Office told the Wellington High Court.

    That will mean that from January 1 all political groups and third parties in next year’s elections will be subject to restrictions in the bill, which the Human Rights Commission called “a dramatic assault on … cherished rights to freedom of expression and the right to participate in democratic elections.”

    It also means that the bill will most likely be law before the High Court has had a chance to decide whether it will determine if the law breaches the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act.

    Crown Law officials told the High Court in Wellington on Monday that Parliament would not be considering the bill until January 25 next year. On that basis, the court said it would consider whether it can review the Crown law opinion in the last week of November.

    Although the chairwoman of the Justice and Electoral Select Committee, Labour MP Lynne Pillay, refused to confirm the bill’s timetable on Tuesday, the NBR understands the committee members’ reports have been drafted.

    Audrey Young explains the electoral spending gerrymander

    Before we turn to Audrey, first people might enjoy a couple of radio ads that have started playing on the radio today, by John Boscawen.

    johnbos_60_nov07.mp3

    johnbos_30_nov07.mp3

    The former is around 2 MB and the latter 1 MB so don’t pound them too much.

    Audrey’s Q&A is here.  Some extracts:

    What did the old law say?
    Spending parliamentary money on advertising that expressly solicited votes or money was banned, as it is now. The difference is the rules didn’t say “anything else goes” – which is the effect of the new law. The new application is at variance with the Auditor-General and the Solicitor-General who took the view of the old rules that political advertising could be deemed to be political advertising if it looked like political advertising.

    So what has changed?
    To understand the extent of how things have changed, and will change, we have to identify the different regimes under which spending rules applied and will apply, inside Parliament and outside Parliament. The pledge card was of concern under two regimes: whether the Parliamentary Service, which paid the invoices for the card, met the conditions under the Public Finance Act 1989 of expenditure voted to it (the Auditor-General found it didn’t); and whether the card breached requirements of election expenditure under the Electoral Act, which applies to all electoral contestants. The Electoral Commission found overspending, but the police did not press charges. The police recommended that Parliament’s rules be changed to prevent such expenditure on the pledge card.

    This is a useful reminder.  While the Police stuffed up their invetsigation, they did have a very useful recommendation.  They recommended that basically all advertising from parliamentary budgets be banned for the final 90 days.  The Government is doing the absolute opposite and allowing everything except an explicit solicitation for votes to be run.

    How would the pledge card be treated again under each of the regimes?
    It would now be a lawful use of parliamentary funds. But under proposals in the Electoral Finance Bill, such advertising expenditure will no longer be allowed to be scrutinised by the Chief Electoral Officer or the Electoral Commission alongside other election contestants. That is because the EFB expressly exempts “any publications that relate to a member of Parliament in his or her capacity as a member of Parliament” from being counted as an election expense.

    This is the double whammy.  Not only are Labour legalising their use of taxpayer money on  such blatant electioneering, but they are exempting such expenditure from even counting as election spending.

    Winners and losers?
    Sitting MPs will have a huge advantage over non-parliamentary parties and candidates. The immunity on their spending runs for the entire three years of an election cycle. Their opponents have restrictions placed on their advertising from January 1 of election year.

    Each party, or an individual MP, could run, say, a $15,000 newspaper and radio tax-payer funded campaigns on their policies funded by Parliamentary Service – at any time of an election cycle up to election day.

    For example:

    * Only Labour will protect health services.
    * Only National will give you meaningful tax cuts.
    * Only New Zealand First cares about the elderly.
    * Only the Greens will save the Earth.

    And even worse the $20,000 limit a challenger has, now has to bs spread over 11 months instead of 90 days.  This is the ultimate in protecting incumbent MPs – they can spend many many times more than their challengers.

    Something else to consider if that MPs can pool their money totally legally.  So if this bill is passed, six Labour MPs in safe seats could transfer $30,000 of their $60,000 budgets to Mark Burton.  Burton could then spend $240,000 of taxpayer money on promoting what he has done for Taupo, while his out of Parliament challenger can only spend $20,000.

    Many people, especially on the left (but including me), decry the US political system where boundary gerrymandering has left 85% of US House seats uncompetitive.  When House Reps win a seat, they often hold if for life. They should decry the same thing happening here – with the gerrymander being funding instead of boundaries.  In the US the gerrymander happens because they allow politicians not bureaucrats to set the boundaries.  Our gerrymander is allowing incumbent MPs to rewrite both the Electoral Act and the Parliamentary spending legislation to suit the incumbents, instead of democracy.

    So if you are against our political system becoming “Americanised” oppose both the Electoral Finance Bill and the Appropriations Bill.

    Even if you support state funding of political parties, you surely do not support that the expenditure of those funds should be exempt from the spending caps under the Electoral Act?

    We’re here to help now open for the public

    The world premiere of “We’re here to help” was in Christchurch Tuesday night.  I got to see an advance copy around three weeks ago at a media screening, which I reviewed.

    I was kindly also invited to the première but sadly couldn’t attend as I had a meeting of the Parliamentary Internet Caucus (which in a coincidence of good timing had Peter Dengate-Thrush as the guest speaker.  We had booked Peter in some months ago and by chance his election as Chairman of ICANN occurred just a few days earlier, so his talk on Internet Governance was even more relevance) wearing my InternetNZ hat.

    There’s a short story in The Press about the movie, which opens for the public today. Even though in the article Dave Henderson is taking a swipe at Labour MPs for not turning up, people shouldn’t think this is a political film which only “righties” will enjoy.  It isn’t.  In fact the obstinate Minister displayed in the film is a National Minister. The political backdrop to the film is fairly minor – it is primarily about a fight against the bureaucracy.