The terror evidence made public

In a fit of good timing, the NZ Herald editorial calls for the evidence against the Urewera 17 to be made public, and the Dom Post and the Press run editorials explaining that they are doing exactly that, and why.

I suspect the NZ Herald was calling for the Government to officially release the info, not for their competitors to do it!

The revelations might cause a few people to pause before they acclaim those arrested as peaceful heroes.

Secret surveillance of Urewera bush camp trainees reveals discussions about killing people for practice, throwing Molotov cocktails into gas-filled buildings, blowing up power stations, television networks and the Waihopai spy base.

Electronic bugs also revealed United States President George W Bush as a possible target, and a discussion about assassinating National leader John Key.

Police say their bugs also picked up talk of copying IRA and Iraqi guerrilla tactics by using hit-and-run squads for bush and urban warfare.

The affidavit says that, between November 2006 and September this year, six “quasi-military training camps” were held in the Ruatoki area. Police say the trainees planned to use small squads to commit terrorist acts.

Bugged conversations recorded talk of plans for urban and rural warfare, of killing police, removing Pakeha farmers, assassinating politicians and committing actions so brutal that the public would think al Qaeda was responsible.

The good news for John Key is they expect him to win the election. The bad news is they wanted him to serve just five days!!

In another bugged conversation, in a car on August 17, a suspect talks of killing Mr Key after the next election: “Get someone to assassinate the prime minister, the new one, next year’s one. Just been in office five days, bang … Yeah, John Key … just drop a bomb … Just wait till he visits somewhere and just blow them … They won’t even find you.”

The affidavit says surveillance of training camps shows:

· Vehicle ambushes and military-style drills with live rounds.

· “Terrifying” counter-interrogation training, including holding guns to participants’ backs and accusing one of being a police informant.

· How to throw Molotov cocktails.

· How to extract colleagues under rifle fire.

In the background to the affidavit, police say one trainee using the codename Bl@ckmask hacked into the National Party website in 2004.

The affidavit says police watched or recorded trainees leaving their homes around the country and heading toward Ruatoki, often picking up others en route. Police say they stopped following the suspects once they drove into Ruatoki, for fear of being discovered, but they installed video cameras on accessways and at campsites, and bugged a camp meal room and sleeping room.

At the last of the camps, police say surveillance picked up 18 people and 14 firearms.

14 firearms is a significant number.  I am looking forward to especially hearing from the peace activists who were present how having 14 firearms illegally used at a camp fits with the peace movement’s objectives.

Agree with Greens but should have happened earlier

The Herald reports:

The Green Party has called for the whole issue of election funding and parliamentary spending to be sent to a “Citizens’ Assembly” based on a Canadian model so ordinary citizens can make a decision.

Now I agree with this. But what a shame the Greens did not demand Labour do this back in 2006 and 2007 rather than support their draconian and anti-democratic Electoral Finance Bill which was developed secretly with no public input and no bipartisan parliamentary input.

If the Greens had insisted on this, then we would be having the debate we should be having.

Luckily John Key has said that after the EFB is repealed (if National wins) that replacement legislation will be developed with public participation and in a bipartisan manner.

The Greens are now saying:

“I agree the first version was appalling and I just can’t believe the minister let it through.”

What a pity that at the time they never said this. Instead they supported it all the way, claiming only minor changes were needed. And now the Greens are going to vote this new revised Bill into law without letting the public have any say on it – something the Human Rights Commission explicitly asked for.

A sensible regime for parliamentary spending

Broadly, there are three different ways you can have a parliamentary spending regime.  I want to canvass these options, after making something clear.

Almost every activity done by MPs for parliamentary purposes has a dual political purpose.  Every speech in Parliament, every speech to a conference, every press release, every survey, every policy paper, every publication, every constituent activity.  All of it can be quite legitimate, but all of it may help the MP or Party get votes at election time.

So does this mean one has effectively no rules at all, such as Labour and allies are legislating? Well, no – look at the options.

  1. Have very tight rules all the time
  2. Have very liberal (anything goes) rules all the time
  3. Have relatively liberal rules most of the time, but much tighter rules during the period immediately before an election

(1) is an option.  It would mean however an end to all newsletters from MPs, all surveys, all pamphlets.  It would mean only the most basic documents such as a policy paper, or electorate office hour ads would be allowed. I don’t think it is the way to go.  However this is not the only alternative to disagreeing with option (2).

(2) is what Parliament is about to pass, with National and Maori Party against.  Apart from explicit solicitations for votes, money or members anything at all goes including blatant electioneering documents such an election pledge card produced during the election campaign, and after Parliament itself is dissolved.  The problem with this is obvious – especially with such spending being exempt from the Electoral Finance Bill spending caps.

(3) is what was the unofficial or de facto rule for many years.  A fairly liberal regime most of the time, but as the election got closer, a far more conservative regime where almost no publications would go out except the most basic (an ad for electorate office hours).

The Auditor-General himself said that the closer one gets to an election, the more likely it is a publication will be just electioneering.  There is a reason he focused on just the last 90 days – it wasn’t by chance.

One can argue about whether this tighter regime should be for 90 days or maybe just for the time period between Parliament being dissolved and an election – but the core issue is there should be one.  There is considerable exit poll data showing that the last 90 days is when many voters are most open to influence as they are starting to take notice.  In other words there is a considerable difference between a publication being sent to say every household two years before an election and two days before an election.

The good thing about the current Electoral Act is that it has no exemption for taxpayer funded publications, and this also acted as a brake on spending in the last 90 days.  In fact it also captured publications produced earlier in the year, but distributed during the last 90 days.

So if for example a year before the election National spent $100,000 of its parliamentary budget on 200,000  health policy pamphlets that would be okay.  But if it kept 50,000 of them in a box and distributed them during the last 90 days then$25,000 of the $100,000 would have to be included in their spending cap.

Labour twin new laws will not demand such an apportionment as parliamentary spending is exempt.  In fact the following scenario would now be legal.

Labour has $5.5 million per year to spend from its parliamentary budget.  Now say they spend $4 million per year on pamphlets – but not distribute most of them.  So after two years one could have $8 million of pamphlets sitting in boxes. Enough for one per voter in five key policy areas.

Then in year three Labour could spend $2 million on posting and delivering those $8 million of pamphlets to every voter.  It could effectively spend $10 million in the week before the election, and not one cent of it will count towards their spending limit.

This is why one needs a 90 day period and no exemptions for parliamentary spending.

NZ Herald on effects of EFB on broadcasters and Internet

The NZ Herald has an article quoting myself, Graeme Edgeler and Paul Norris on the effects of the current version of the EFB on radio broadcasters, You Tube etc.

One of the issues is whether playing Chris Knox’s Labour song would breach the Electoral Finance Bill.  My view is that a radio station could play it, but they couldn’t put it on their website on podcast it. Graeme thinks they might not be able to even play it live on the radio.

NZ First on taxpayer funding

NZ First was one of those parties who voted in favour of allowing taxpayer money to be used on pledge cards and newspaper ads during the last few weeks of an election campaign. And what is their reason:

New Zealand First deputy leader Peter Brown said: “We need the bill [the Appropriation … ] to protect us from the Auditor-General’s wisdom.”

Yes, this is an MP saying they should be exempt from the Auditor-General. This is an MP who props up the Government led by Helen Clark who is telling NZers not to worry about an exemption for Govt Depts because they need to be approved by the Auditor-General.

When I read someone saying they need to be protected from the Auditor-General, I wonder how many years they have been sentenced to.

Only National, the Maori Party and Gordon Copeland voted against a self serving law which would allow Labour to spend $2 million of taxpayer money the week before the election on material such as election pledge cards.

Parties in favour were Labour, Progressives, New Zealand First, Greens, United Future, Act, and Taito Phillip Field.

And the key thing to remember is that all this expenditure, will be exempt from spending limits in the Electoral Finance Bill. Labour could in fact spend $5 million of taxpayer funds during the last four weeks of the election campaign, and it wouldn’t breach the $2.4 million party spending limit as it will be exempt.

Update needed

The big red website is rather out of date.

When I used to be in charge of National’s website, I took it as a matter of pride that we would have the new rankings and portfolios done within hours.

At least Labour have not had the problem of leadership changes. Whenever there was one looming I would discretely start preparing new material just in case there was a change. And hey then after the coup, we could have the website correct by the evening news.

Herald exposes website poll hacker

Now that’s quick service!

I blogged this morning that the Herald should publish the IP address of the person or persons multiple voting in their online polls, and they have.

A person at 222.152.66.116. (222-152-66-116.jetstream.xtra.co.nz) voted 5,000 times in around 10 minutes.

As I said this morning, this has now happened around ten times to online polls, and without fail it has always been someone changing a poll which wasn’t good for Labour to one which was good for Labour.

I wonder if the hacker has breached the computer crimes section of the Crimes Act and one could get a warrant to reveal the customer who was using the IP address at that time. I don’t want them prosecuted, but suspect revealing their identity would be incredibly interesting.

Anyway kudos to the Herald for taking the time to expose what happened, and for putting in steps to stop a repeat.

Brendon Burns for Christchurch Central

NZPA report that Brendon Burns has been nominated for Christchurch Central for Labour.

Brendon is the former head of the Comms section in the PM’s Office, and has stood twice in Kaikoura where he used to edit the local newspaper.

He would be a useful addition to their Caucus with his political management background.  However he might find life as a backbencher rather unfulfilling and would hope for a substantive role before long.

Not being a local, he may struggle to win the nomination.  It will be interesting to see if James Caygill is also standing.

Sigh – more online poll tampering

Really – when will the newspaper sites learn. Bohemian Tory blogs:

To the question “Is New Zealand becoming a less free and democratic country?” results were 87% YES 13% NO at lunchtime today. Now, at 5:15pm it is 28% YES 72% NO.

If newspaper polls are not going to stop easy multiple voting, the least they can do is monitor the polls for obvious vote rigging and publish the IP addresses the multiple votes came from.

What would also be interesting is to see the yes/no votes on a time series by hour.  I suspect that would show when the vote rigging occurs.

This is almost the 10th time this sort of thing has happened, and always the same pattern – a quick reversal of a consistent anti-Govt trend over the previous hours.

How’s this for irony?

Labour keep citing as justification for their draconian Electoral Finance Bill, the fact that National spent some money (it wasn’t in fact very much) outside the 90 day period on their billboards.

Labour of course have themselves spent money in the past outside the 90 day period.  It’s only when someone else does it, that it needs to be outlawed.

But here’s the irony.  Under Labour’s companion Appropriations Bill, National could have the taxpayer pay for a million dollars worth of billboards before and during the election campaign.  They wouldn’t have to change one word – just stick a crest on them.

Labour claim they are against big money in the campaign.  This is false.  They are all in favour of big money – they just want more of it by using taxpayer money.

Analysing the PM’s “assurances” on advertising

This is almost comical.  NZPA reports that the PM has said there is no need to worry about government agencies being exempted from the Electoral Finance Bill, because:

Government departments will err on the side of caution when promoting policies during election year, Prime Minister Helen Clark said today.

Are these the same Departments who have Ministers in charge of them who approve the advertising campaigns?  The same Departments whose Working for Families advertising in 2005 was so over the top, the Auditor-General had to step in and reduce it?

Are these the same Departments who sack staff members because they may refuse to implement huge taxpayer funded campaigns which align with the Government’s re-election campaign?

Miss Clark said government department promotion must be within guidelines approved by the auditor-general.

Is this the same Miss Clark who spent most of last year attacking the Auditor-General and is in the midst of passing a law to over-turn his decisions that her parliamentary spending was illegal?

“Government departments can’t electioneer.”

Of course Helen is changing the definiton of electioneer so activities like her election pledge card are now a public information service, not electioneering.

“… but I think you’ll find that come election year, particularly as the months go by, government advertising becomes pretty sparse.”

Wait a second.  Is Helen now saying that it does matter how close you are to an election?  Surely not because she is ramming through law changes which will allow her to have taxpayer funded newspaper ads appear the week of the election?

How stupid does she really take people for?

General Debate 13 November 2007

Boscawen on EFB

The Herald talks to John Boscawen on his opposition to the Electoral Finance Bill.  He notes that having spent $50,000 fighting against it, he is almost at the limit of what he could spend in election year.

Mr Boscawen, an Act Party member since 1994, jokes he has found himself in the peculiar position of “spending thousands of dollars to promote the views of a former trade unionist” – referring to Chief Human Rights Commissioner Rosslyn Noonan, who has also called for the bill to be scrapped.

He says Ms Noonan is “principled and courageous” for speaking out against a bill that is promoted by the party which appointed her.

He said he would be prepared to spend up to $250,000 in his campaign against what he claims will set up “the most restrictive parliamentary democracy in the Western world”.

“I’m not rich. I am comfortable. I live on Paritai Drive, but I’m not even remotely close to the Rich List. You must surely understand we are talking about how democracy runs in New Zealand. You can’t put a price on that.”

John is prepared to fight this Bill, not just until it is passed, but right up until the next election.

The bill also prompted lawyer Colin Pidgeon, QC, to make the first select committee submission he has made as an individual.

He said it was “absolutely disastrous” legislation, and agreed that a singer could potentially breach the law by advocating in song for a position held by a political party.

I suspect for many people it was their first ever submission to a select committee.

LOL Cats

Condolences to the Goffs

As many NZers celebrated at the news that a Kiwi had got the VC saving a wounded comrade in Afghanistan, I am sure equally as many will feel a sense of sadness to hear an American New Zealander, Phil Goff’s nephew, was killed this week in Afghanistan.

Lieutenant Matthew Ferrara was serving with the United States Army and had graduated from West Point only in May 2005.

Any tragic death is hard to cope with.  It’s probably harder when your profile makes it a public event.  Condolences to the Goffs during this incredibly sad time, which reminds us the cost of freedom is sometimes considerable.

DIA to list child porn sites for voluntary blocking

The DIA has announced it will make available to ISPs a list of websites hosting child porn, allowing ISPs to black access to them.

A similar scheme operates in the UK (and other countries).  I was actually involved in helping set up a test of the UK filter by DIA, the Censorship Classification office and InternetNZ.

There were two major issues looked at.  The first is whether the UK filter blocked legitimate sites which did not have material deemed objectionable and illegal under NZ law.  In other words what was the false positive rate?

The second issue was what proportion of child porn sites were blocked?

With regard to the false positive rate, the good news is that it was basically zero.  Almost every site blocked was hosting material illegal under NZ law, and if I recall from the report this wasn’t borderline stuff (a child in a bath) but clearly hardcore illegal material.

In terms of how effective it was at blacking sources of child porn, it wasn’t terribly effective as the number and nature of sites changes daily, so the filter isn’t a universal solution that blocks everything illegal. But it does block some sites, without overextending itself to block legal sites. So that’s not a bad thing.

Since then DIA have also looked at other filtering solutions, and look to run their own filter list, based on info from overseas agencies, plus local reports.

This is really the only way to run a filter – to have it based on actual reports of illegal material, rather than have it “guess” if a site is objectionable based on text searches. One always gets too high a false positive rate using the latter approach. The list of banned sites will be basically updated daily, which is the only way to do it.

So all up, this looks to be a good step forward.  It is voluntary for ISPs, and won’t block all child porn sites, but it will be a useful tool in removing the profit from incredibly sick enterprises.

The Listener joins in …

Even The Listener joins in the queue to criticise the double rort of the Electoral Finance Bill and the Appropriation (Continuation of Interim Meaning of Funding for Parliamentary Purposes) Bill. Some quotes:

Proposed rules for election-year spending are blatantly unfair.

This week the government introduced to Parliament a measure called the Appropriation (Continuation of Interim Meaning of Funding for Parliamentary Purposes) Bill, which it intends to rush through before Christmas.

It might as well be called the “One Law for MPs Bill”. When combined with the Electoral Finance Bill, which is being considered by a select committee, it makes the rules on advertising in an election period markedly different for MPs than for all other New Zealanders.

The Electoral Finance Bill itself attracted widespread and deserved criticism for being anti-democratic. It establishes a regime that will come into effect on January 1, rather than the usual three months before an election. Everyone who produces material that could be construed as supporting or criticising a political party, or even a type of party, will be captured by the restrictions in the bill, including a cap on expenditure between January 1 and election day. The bill is likely to come back from the select committee with some changes, but nothing so far indicates that its fundamental affronts will be removed.

However, the Electoral Finance Bill contains a provision that means it does not apply to MPs. Instead, they will be covered by the “One Law for MPs Bill”. This allows them to campaign next year, right up to the day before the election, using the generous taxpayer-funded allowances given to each party represented in Parliament. What is more, this spending will not be counted as part of each MP’s individual spending cap, nor towards a party’s spending cap.

It seems that Labour and its support parties, believing themselves to be far more cash-strapped than National, have found a way to legitimise election-period spending through their taxpayer-funded parliamentary budgets. Add such spending to the expensive ad campaigns to allegedly educate the public on policies like KiwiSaver or Working for Families, and next year Labour, in particular, will be bleeding a lucrative vein of taxpayer-funded publicity.

The public deserve better. Not only because the public are paying for it, but because it is unfair for incumbent MPs to have a legalised advantage and because, in election year, there should be a level of robust participation that the Electoral Finance Bill will inhibit.

The bill’s provisions are a shame and a shambles and New Zealand’s democracy will be poorer if they are passed.

One of the better Listener editorials.

Imagine you are a new Labour MP

It has been said many times that the Electoral Finance Bill is a bill for one election only – 2008.  It’s a desperate attempt by Helen Clark to retain power with the polls against her.

Let’s imagine what may happen if the EFB is passed, and National still wins in 2008.  What will life be like for new young Labour MPs?

  • They won’t be able to organise protest marches unless they get everyone to sign statutory declarations
  • The National Government could pass all the legislation it likes in 2011, and lobby groups will be severely restricted with their ability to campaign against it.
  • National Electorate MPs will be almost impossible to defeat as they can outspend their challengers by 4:1
  • The 2011 budget could have a $15 million advertising campaign to promote it, which will be automatically excluded from campaign limits.

This law so advantages the incumbents, that it could damn Labour once in Opposition to a long wait for re-election.

Luckily for them, John Key has again today pledged to scrap it in Government, despite the huge advantage it would give him.

Hooton on EFB

On National Radio today

Parliamentary Party Funding

People will (or should) be aware that Labour, NZ First, Greens, Progressive, United Future and ACT are about to vote to change the law so that they can spend their parliamentary budgets on election pledge cards and the like. Even worse, the law changes works in tandem with the Electoral Finance Bill, so that all the money they spend – even if done in the week before the election – is exempt from the spending limits in the Electoral Act.

So how much money are we talking about? Well from the 1st of December the parliamentary budgets available for pledge cards and the like increases to $16.2 million.

Here’s the breakdown of MPs for each party:

parlparties.JPG

The new funding formulas for each party are as follows:

  1. Leadership – $100,000 plus $64,320 per non Minister
  2. Party – $22,000 per MP
  3. MPs – $64,260 per Electorate MP and 40,932 per List MP

This means funding per party as follows:

parlfunding.JPG

Labour has less than National because they have 25 Ministers with Ministerial Offices out of which press secretaries and the like are funded. National has to fund all its non secretarial staff from its budget.  Field and Copeland may not get their leadership funding until such time as they declare a party affiliation.

Now I am the last person to advocate parliamentary parties shouldn’t have enough money to fund their staff and activities.  But that money should not be used on promoting parties during the 90 days before an election.  Under this new law, Labour and NZ First could spend their budgets on full page newspaper ads promoting themselves even after Parliament has been dissolved.

And as if that isn’t bad enough, all these millions of dollars can be spent, without even counting as expenditure under the Electoral Finance Bill.   Labour can now legally spend twice the $2.4 million limit.  They overspent by $800,000 last time.  This time they can overspend by millions and this little funding gerrymander makes it totally legal.

One could have two identical brochures.  One for say Labour and one for Party X which is not in Parliament.  They could have the exact same text – talking about how people will be better off under their economic policies.  Every word could be identical except substituting party names. But Labour’s pamphlet will be exempt from the spending limit if they spend their parliamentary budget on it (and stick a crest on), while Party X will have to count the cost of that pamphlet as part of their spending cap.

Regardless of your political orientation, one should be principled enough to say this is unjust.   It unfairly protects all incumbent parties and especially all incumbent Electorate MPs from competition.

October 2007 Polling Newsletter

The Curia October 2007 Polling Newsletter is out later today. It’s a whopping nine pages and reviews polls in New Zealand and Australia, plus the US, UK and Canada.

It is only available by e-mail and you can go to this subscription page to receive it in your inbox.

oct07polls.JPG

The gap between National and Labour has closed from 17% to 9% in just two months.

oct07seats.JPG

This new graph shows the projected seats for each “bloc”. It assumes no change in electorate seats.

The Herald Front Page

12front200.jpg

What a great cover for 200,000+ people to wake up to this morning.  Not great because it will damage the supporters of the Bill.  Great, because it may stop those supporters from doing permanent damage to NZ’s constitution by turning the Electoral Act into their private plaything.

Robertson wins Wellington Central nomination

According to The Standard, Charles Chauvel has withdrawn his nomination for Wellington Central, effectively giving Grant Robertson the nomination.

It’s a logical move for Chauvel, after the negative publicity from the 9th floor over the reshuffle. Someone there was obviously seriously leaking against him.

It’s a pity though in the sense there won’t be a healthy competition for a fairly safe seat. But  congratulations to Grant Robertson for his “victory”, and hopefully Grant will keep his blog going, even after he is confirmed.

“Democracy under attack”

Yes yes yes.  The NZ Herald takes they very rare but in this case necessary step of a front page editorial against the Electoral Finance Bill.

Audrey Young reports that the Government is moving to explicitly exempt Government advertising campaigns from the Electoral Finance Bill, even if their messages are such they would normally be covered.  This comes on top of exempting any expenditure from parliamentary budgets.

The front page editorial is here. It’s all very good, but some extracts:

When is the Government going to get this message: democracy is not a device to keep the Labour Party in power.

The Human Rights Commission has described the restrictions on election activity as a “dramatic assault” on fundamental rights which “undermines the legitimacy of political processes”.

The Law Society says the bill would “make participation in our parliamentary democracy an arduous and perhaps even legally dangerous undertaking for ordinary New Zealanders”.

In the face of near-universal condemnation, the bill should have been withdrawn. Instead it will be tweaked to dilute some of its worst features. But the attempt to restrict non-party participation in election discussion will remain.

Labour seems determined to use the time it has left to skew electoral laws in its favour.

Not only does it mean to make election debate the preserve of political parties, it has introduced this month a second electoral outrage – a bill to extend the law legalising the use of public money for political purposes that were ruled improper by the Auditor General after the last election.

The Clark Government’s refusal to bow to public opinion on this subject beggars belief. It was staggering enough last year that Helen Clark and her lieutenants could not understand why nobody else regarded their electoral pledge card as innocent information.

Now, having grudgingly repaid the public purse, they are hell-bent on giving themselves the right to raid it again.

If these bills become law, politics will be largely confined to registered parties, and they will have to be able to use parliamentary funds for election campaigns.

Both measures are designed to favour the party that has devised them. Labour fears independent campaigns by the likes of the Exclusive Brethren much more than National fears the efforts of the PPTA or the Council of Trade Unions. And Labour believes it needs public money to balance covert contributions to the National Party.

Parties have different advantages. If National has more well-heeled donors, Labour probably has the more committed and articulate foot soldiers.

National’s supposed advantages were of less urgent concern to Labour when it was polling well. Now in desperation it wants to screw the scrum. It has succumbed to the old conceit of the Left that the interests of the people are identical with its own.

The interests of any healthy democracy lie in unrestricted debate, not laws that favour incumbents with public finance and suppression of free speech.

If these bills pass, they will be Labour’s epitaph.

Indeed that is the challenge.  One can not stop the bills, but one can punish Labour (and allies) for passing them by reminding people of them time and time again right up until election day.

But what a superb editorial, and well done to the NZ Herald for making it front page.  These bills do matter, they do fundamentally skew our democratic framework.  They are the sort of laws, which if passed overseas, we would condemn.