NZ First prefers Labour

Just as I have always regarded the Maori Party as ideologically closer to Labour, I think much the same of NZ First – and Ron Mark has confirmed this.  On Agenda today he said:

Labour’s probably the closest now to our economic policy than they’ve ever been

Now there is more to working together than economic policy, but that is pretty core.

It will be very interesting to see what policy NZ First adopts going into 2008.  Will it be to give first preference to the largest party again? Will it want coalition (Ron Mark indicated a preference for that) and on what terms?

To ensure a change of Government needs more than National getting more votes than Labour.  It requires National/ACT/United Future to get more votes than Labour/Progressive/Greens/Maori Party/NZ First. Because I suspect in a bidding contest, Labour will be more willing to do whatever it takes for a 4th term.  Student allowances for all Maori students – fine. An extra $20 a week for pensioners – fine. 

And let’s not forget what a huge advantage the Electoral Finance Bill will be to the Government, if passed.  The Government advertising campaigns will blossom, as everyone is restricted.

McCarten calls for Mallard to go

It’s interesting to see the commentators on this one.  Winston Peters and Bill Ralson are effectively defending Mallard and saying no big thing, while Matt McCarten is saying he must be dumped.  McCarten makes some salient points:

All the tut-tutting over this melee by their fellow MPs – and even the Prime Minister – is a bit disingenuous. After all, Mallard has been used – for over a decade now – as their resident pitbull to intimidate Labour’s enemies.

In recent times, Mallard has been used to deal to Labour’s opponents. The difference this time is that when Mallard was dished up some of his own medicine, he couldn’t handle it, lost his cool and physically retaliated.

The end came when Mallard called out the name of Brash’s alleged mistress. Brash was unnerved by Mallard’s hectoring. This whole affair ultimately resulted in Brash being dumped as leader and undermined his personal reputation and ended his political career.

At the time, the Labour Party was gloating over the success of Mallard’s taunts and behaviour.

Indeed. Clark, Cullen and co sat there smiling and smirking as Mallard and Benson-Pope did to Brash, what Henare did to Mallard.

This is probably the most serious assault that has ever occurred in Parliament. The media, in years gone by, referred to instances such as Jim Bolger throwing a pen in the chamber, Winston grabbing the arm of John Banks, or even Mallard flicking Bob Clarkson with a manila folder.

Indeed.  The Banks/Peters issue went to Privileges Committee and was for a much much less serious incident.

Recently, we have the House overwhelmingly passing a law outlawing the smacking of kids under any provocation, and on the other, we have a Government minister hitting a member of the Opposition in a fit of rage.

That’s why Clark doesn’t have any choice but to dump Mallard. Otherwise, the taunt of “hypocrite” would rightfully stick on her.

I’m not actually in the Mallard must be sacked camp. If the demotion is significant (loses front bench spot, loses significant portfolios) I think that is enough.

Vista and Office 2007

Peter Griffin’s blog on Vista, remninds me to share my own experiences.  The poor bastard tried running it on 512 MB memory.  I’ve got it running on a new PC nicely with 2 GB memory.  My rule of thumb is to always double the default amount of memory a new machine comes with.

So far Vista has been pretty good.  Minor things like showing the speed of a file copy/move and no of files remaining are useful. The whole look/feel is good also.  Have had problems with printer drivers though.  A lot of products are not yet ready for Vista so rushing in can backfire.

But while overall I like Vista, can I just say how much I hate Office 2007.  Nothing is where it should be.  It’s attempts to be helpful are frustrating to say the least.  After 12+ years of a standard look and feel to Office producsts, that is all gone.  I can’t do half of what I used to be able to do because I can’t find the effing commands.

Please can someone out there tell me there is a button you can push to make Office 2007 appear like Office 2003?  That would be a life saver.

Oh and don’t even start me off on the new file formats.  Grrrr. 

I hate Office 2007 so much I’ll probably put off getting a new laptop just to avoid having to migrate to Office 2007.

A fresh new front bench?

Ironically, the Mallard punch may turn into an opportunity for Labour to regain some political momentum.  All of Clark’s previous reshuffles have been very timid – almost non events.  Now, by necessity if not choice, she may end up with a very new and fresh front bench.

Maharey is retiring, and the consensus seems to be Mallard has to be at leats demoted off the front bench.  There is also talk of Anderton being asked to give up his spot, and there may be three vacancies.  Horomnia should be demoted on performance, but it would be unacceptable for Labout to not have a Maori MP on the front bench, and while Jones will probably make Cabinet, I doubt he will go straight to the front bench.

The three logical promotions are Parker, Cunliffe and Cosgrove – all relatively new and all performing relatively well.  But Lianne Dalziel is also a solid performer.  Now what may count against her is that she has been around for so long and is not quite a fresh face.  On the other hand having one third of the front bench female may go down well with traditional support groups.

I’ll make some firmer predictions on Tuesday for Wednesday’s reshuffle.

NZ First to pay it back

At long last, a year or so after other parties agreed to pay it back, NZ First has explicitly stated they will pay back the $186,000 of illegal expenditure.

But get this.  Their latest excuse for why it has not already been paid back is that the money is in a term deposit which only matures in November.

Hello, it is the simplest thing in the world to break a term deposit.  The only penalty is you gain less interest.  So really what NZ First are saying is we wish to continue to earn money on the $186,000.

When they finally do pay it back, I will calculate what the interest should have been.

Incidentially United Future are yet to pay all of their illegal expenditure back also.

Telecom’s fibre plans

I’m pleased to see Telecom commit to fibe deployment which will acheive speeds of up to 20 MB/sec within five years to all areas with 500 or more phone lines. That’s a pretty good investment in getting fibre to the node. Of course that is only a halfway house to having fibe to the home but nevertheless still good progress.

The article has a couple of sound bites from me, taken while driving back from Oamaru yesterday. Also had an interview with ZB on Thursday with Kate Hawkesbury on the Mallard affair. I think I was kinder on Trevor than Kate was!

How the Maori Party votes

Audrey Young reports from the Maori Party conference, and mentions that some analysis had been done on how often the Maori Party votes with and against the other parties.  The findings were:

  • Greens – 108 with, 55 against
  • Labour 89 with, 80 against
  • National 55 with, 112 against

I have always advocated that the Maori Party leans more to the left, and that analysis tends to support that.  That is not to say Natiional and the Maori Party can’t work together – of course they can.  But I recall certain bloggers from the left decrying the Maori Party as right wing conservatives etc etc.

What would be really fascinating is for someone to do the same analysis to all eight parties in Parliament.  How often do United Future vote with Labour?  How often do ACT vote with National? How often do Greens vote with National?

DPF still powerless

My laptop is still without power and likely to be so until Monday at the earliest.  Sigh.

A big thumbs up to ProSouth who e-mailed me last night after seeing my problem on the blog and arranged for me to come in and see them before their business normally opened today.  Now that’s great pro-active service! Sadly the exact cord needed they had just sold out of, and despite their superb efforts trying half a dozen diffferent places for me, there is no HP laptop cord anywhere in Dunedin it seems.

They then arranged the NZ distributor to courier a new one to me at Wellington tomorrow, but now they have had a delay and I won’t get it until next week. Wouldn’t be such a problem if I was at home, as I have spare PCs (and spare laptops!) there.

So once again blogging will be very infrequent.

Had a pleasant evening tonight.  I caught up with Roger Gnome at the good old Captain Cook and had some beer and nachos.  We were then joined by Luke of the Young Greens and by coincidence Bryce Edwards was there also so ended up a nice wee group.  The Cook was a lot less crowded than in my day!

Spent the morning in Dunedin, and had a quick trip to and back from Oamaru in the afternoon.  Due to being off e-mail the phones were going non stop and it was almost comical as I was literally having to place one phone down to answer another phone and swap between them, all while travelling along SH1.

Anyway has been a nice few days in the South – back to Wellington tomorrow.  Won’t be very bloody relaxing though as I have a s**t load of e-mails to wade through when reconnected.

What the bloggers say!

Three well known bloggers have their say on the Mallard affair.  Okay they’re actually press gallery journalists, but I’m quoting from their blogs.  First NZ Herald’s Audrey Young:

There has to be a punishment to fit the crime. He should not do anything rash like quit the cabinet or Parliament. That would be an overreaction. But he can’t do nothing.

He should relinquish his sports portfolio, apologise to the House, and then take a decent break.

Violence on the job is not compatible with fair play or any of the attributes with which good sportsmanship is attributed.

Then Martin Kay from the Dom Post:

As Labour’s bovver boy, senior Cabinet Minister Trevor Mallard is well-known for twisting the knife in the rawest nerves of his political opponents.

It was he, remember, who first alluded in Parliament to rumours that former National leader Don Brash was having an affair – a move which caused deep and continuing resentment among National’s ranks.

Now, it seems Mallard is much less prepared to take the medicine he has so readily dished out over many years as Labour’s main attack man.

He should have expected some mud to be slung in return. Parliament’s debating chamber is, after all, oval: what goes around inevitably comes around.

And finally Colin Espiner from The Press completes the Axis of Bloggers:

Mallard has also been employed as a bovver-boy by Labour with Clark’s full backing, so it could be argued it would be a little hypocritical to sack him for getting carried away. The owner must take some blame when an attack dog goes feral, after all.

Clark will also have to consider the fact that Mallard, like Maharey, has been a stalwart of Labour’s Left, which won’t be best pleased to see the pair replaced with the centre-Right crowd banging on the door for promotion.

One thing is sure. Mallard can kiss goodbye to whatever hopes remained of taking over the leadership of the party. And he’ll get a serious dressing down. It’s another setback to the party’s recovery in the polls and the public won’t be impressed.

Indeed the balance is shifting within Labour.  David B-P, Maharey and Mallard are all from the left faction. Two of the Ministers most likely to be promoted are not with the left faction. The front bench may be quite different in a week.

Tokelau rejects independence for the second time

This is getting to be really funny.  All the well meaning do gooders keep telling the Tokelau people that being a colony is bad and they should vote for independence.  And they were amazed when the vote a year or so ago missed out on the 66% super-majority by 6% or so.

So they held an another vote, because I mean how dare they vote the wrong way. And story after story told us there was absolutely no way this vote would fail. Yet it has, by 2% this time.

Priceless.

The Mallard Affair

Boy did I pick a bad time to lose my power supply.  Even wrose it arrived by courier today, and seems to have been damaged in transit.  So my laptop is still dead.  Am going to try and get a cord for it tomorrow but not sure chances of an HP laptop power cord is great in Dunedin.  It is possible I will be powerless until Monday, so blogging may be near zero, except for cyber cafe visits such as this one (McCafe in George Street).

Anyway onto Trevor.  I’m sure everyone has read the headlines. The real question now is what will Helen Clark do. And to answer that, we should ask this question.

What would Helen Clark be saying if a National MP had punched in the face/head a Labour MP?

I think we could all imagine.

What is surprisingly is how fragile Mallard is.  It is a classic case of being able to dish it out, but not take it.  I don’t know exactly what Tau Henare said but I think everyone understands it was very similar to what Trevor Mallard said when he taunted Don Brash about Diane Foreman. And here’s the moral of the story.  If Mallard had never broken the “rules” and said what he said about Brash, I am almost certain he would not have had similar stuff said to him.  But if you break the “rules” yourself, you can’t expect to suddenly be protected by them.

The timing with the reshuffle is bad for Mallard.  Generally reshuffles get positive news for a Government.  Fresh blood etc. But now the focus will partly be on what happens to Trevor.  And if she doesn’t demote him (at a minimum) then the media focus will be on her lack of standards, and a good news story becomes a bad news story.

The significance of what has happened is quite profound though.  And again by coincidence of timing.

In just one week Phil Goff has gone from being an outside chance of the next Labour Leader, to the near undisputed Leader in Waiting.

Maharey, Mallard and Goff have always been the three heavyweight contenders. Other possibilities like Gosche and Benson-Pope have fallen by the wayside.  And others like Jones are far too new.  So amazingly in one week Maharey is out, and so effectively is Mallard.  Phil Goff can’t believe his luck.  And even better for Goff he genuinely had nothing to do with it.

General Debate 25 October 2007

Doh!

Flew into Invercargill last night.  Great timing as the wind power last night make Wellington look calm.

Anyway, more to the point I discover during the stop over in Christchurch that I left the power cord to the laptop at home.

I hope to be reunited with it today, or buy a new one, but it is probably no blogging today.  I’m just doing this on the hotel business centre. And later today I am driving to Gore and eventually Dunedin, and for some reason the Police don’t like it if I try to blog and drive at the same time.

Rodney on Electoral Finance Bill

Some good stuff on Rodney’s blog re the Electoral Finance Bill.

Firstly he notes the Bill is so restrictive that even the movie “We’re here to help” would potentially be banned under the Bill if it passed into law.

Also Rodney has stated that

The Human Rights Commission gave a powerful submission to the Justice an Electoral Committee last week.

The Commission stated the Electoral Finance Bill could have a “chilling effect on the expression of political opinion”, and then went on to say:

“The Bill in its current form represents a dramatic assault on two fundamental human rights that New Zealanders cherish; freedom of expression, and the right of informed citizens to participate in the election process. It requires radical change.”

Quite.

I have put the motion down that the Committee simply discharge the Bill. It’s that bad. That vote will be this week.

Failing that I have put the motion that officials redraft the Bill with the Commission’s help and we can the Commission back with the officials to reconsider the Bill.

I can’t imagine MPs will reject the Commission’s offer of help. It will be an interesting test of the government’s true motive.

Indeed it will. Incidentially I was asked on ZB this morning whether You Tube campaigning was a way around the Electoral Finance Bill, and I think they were surprised when I said the Bill casts it net so widely it will be illegal for someone to upload to You Tube a political video they have created at home for say $1, unless they go off to a JP and sign a solemn declaration about the limits of their activities, and then sends a copy of that affadavit to You Tube.

Also people should note that the NZ Institute of Chartered Accounts also submitted that the entire audit section of the Bill was unworkable and unenforceable – Whale Oil has the NBR articles on this.

So just consider how vastly different any amended Bill is going to be, if it will even be workable.   And also consider how the Government doesn’t want to give us a chance to have any input into the amended Bill.

An unpopular idea

Grant Robertson, on his campaign blog (and kudos to him for having one), says he was asked at one meeting what is a view he holds that would not be popular.

Now that’s a great question to ask candidates.  I hate popularists who only say what people want to hear, rather than what they believe.  Anyone on a National Party pre-selection or selection committee should think about asking that as a question.

Speaking personally, I have heaps of unpopular ideas.  Wide scale privatisation.  Abolishing PAYE. Means testing super etc.

Anyway Grant’s “unpopular” idea is having Te Reo Maori compulsory in schools.  While I don’t agree with Grant on having it compulsory (I think the act of compulsion makes it counter productive) I actually agree with him on some of what he says about settling grievances and having greater understanding.  Also nice to see some pragmatism on decolonisation and Treaty workshops (“not that helpful”).

The issue of redistribution is one more politically charged.  I would advocate that once historical grievances are settled, then any redistribution of income should be done regardless of race, but based on need.

General Debate 24 October 2007

Student Loans

On ZB tomorrow with Holmes

Had four phone calls today from media – on three different subjects. When it rains, it pours!

Anyway I’m on Newstalk ZB tomorrow morning with Paul Holmes to discuss the launch of the NZ You Tube site.  Will be on sometime between 7.30 am and 8.00 am.  Sound like we’ll be focusing both on the the technical aspects (faster downloads) and the wider impact of You Tube on politics.  Never been interviewed by Paul before, so looking forward to it.

A good Labour Weekend

I had nothing really planned in advance for Labour Weekend, and was quite looking forard to doing nothing, but in the end managed to have quite a bit of fun.

Friday night was Southpark DVDs.  We’re now up to Season Three.  Also watched Constantine on Cork King’s new amplified stereo system and 50″ flat screen.  It’s a great movie, with some great plot twists.  Tilda Swinton makes a wonderfully insane Gabriel. But was especially good viewing and listening to it with speakers that vibrated so powerfully the bookshelf almost fell down.

On Saturday had a party at Ginga’s place.  Now I had a bit of work to do Sunday so I resolved to be a good boy and leave by midnight.  Still I managed to get through with Auckland Girl the best part of a bottle of Vodka, and then headed home. But as I was walking through Manners Mall ran into a couple of mates who persuaded me I should come join them at Mollys for just one drink.  Having no willpower I agreed.

Sunday did not start well with me sleeping in until 11 am.  This would not be a problem except I had agreed to brunch at 11 with Boat Girl. Luckily when she rung me, and I answered the phone, she immediately detected my state as hungus overus and agreed to postpone.  Still second time I have stood her up which is most ungentlemanly. Will need to make it up.

Sunday night was a real treat.  I had dinner with Milo and Fausta, whom I had not seen for the best part of 20 years.  Milo and Fausta were final year at Otago Uni when I was first year and were the departing hierarchy of the Young Nats.  Fausta now describes herself as left wing (but not economically!) and Milo for his sins ended up on the Alliance Council briefly.  So as one can imagine it made for excellent dinner conversation which went on until midnight. Als, as they reminded me, my views had mellowed somewhat also.
Without trying to sound snobbish, it was great fun to have such an intellectual dinner conversation.  Now don’t get me wrong – I’m happy 95% of the time debating who killed who on Shortland Street and the day to day thrust of politics.  But it’s nice to have the more ethereal conversations and we all had fairly in depth knowledge of Roman Republicanism, political philosophers, etc, so it was a pretty high brow evening.  I really need to have more of these – I think the intellect stagnates if you don’t use it enough.  Milo and Fausta were also both former top level debaters so that helped the fun.

Monday saw me go from high brow to very low brow, going to see The Devil Dared Me To with Ginga and Cook Girl.   I barely stopped laughing non stop.  It’s a great NZ production and I’ve wanted to see the film since I saw a preview back in February.

After the movie then had some drinks with Ratty, Ratty’s immigrant girl and some others at the Courtenay Arms.  A very relaxing end to what turned out to be a reasonably full Labour Weekend.

When can Maharey resign?

Steve Maharey has said he will not resign, until he can avoid a by-election. What does this mean in practice. We look at S131 of the Electoral Act:

Notwithstanding anything in section 129 of this Act, no writ shall be issued for a by-election to supply a vacancy in the House of Representatives if—

a) The vacancy arises in the period of 6 months ending with the date of the expiration of the Parliament and a resolution that a writ not be issued to supply the vacancy is passed by a majority of 75 percent of all the members of the House of Representatives; or

(b) Following the tabling in the House of Representatives by the Prime Minister of a document informing the House that a general election is to be held within 6 months of the occurrence of the vacancy, a resolution is passed by a majority of 75 percent of all the members of the House of Representatives to the effect that a writ is not to be issued to supply the vacancy.

Now looking at (a) the writs were returned in 2005 on Thursday 6 October 2005.  That means Parliament expires on Monday 6 October 2008.  Six months prior to that is Sunday 6 April 2008.  So Maharey can resign anytime from 6 April onwards and avoid a by-election.

He can resign safely before that date, but that will then require the PM to name the election date, or at least the latest date she will hold the election.  For example if he resigned on Thursday 20 March 2008, then Clark could table a document saying the latest date for an election would be Saturday 20 September 2008.  This last happened in 1996 when did such a declaration to avoid a by-election in Hawke’s Bay following the resignation of Michael Laws.

Austism Support in Australia

Russell Brown blogs over at humans.org.nz about autism support and the Australian election campaign.

Both Kevin Rudd and John Howard announced significant (read massive) funding packages for supporting families with autistic children.  This got into the usual argument over who is leading and who is following.  But then a useful suggestion:

Amid the bickering about who was cribbing from whom, Rudd made a sensible suggestion: whichever party won the election, both should unite on policy. I think the job for those of us who want to see greater attention to autism and education support here should be look for such a political consensus.

Not a bad idea.  While it is necessary to have policy differences in key areas – to give the public choice, it is sensible to not politicise every single area of policy.  That would be a nice challenge for the major parties in New Zealand – a bipartisan policy on support for families with autistic children.

General Debate 23 October 2007

The gift that keeps on giving

NZPA reports that David Benson-Pope is refusing to bow out of politics, despite his Cabinet sacking for lying, and has filed a nomination for his current seat of Dunedin South.

Can I say that all of us here at Kiwiblog are fully supportive of Mr Benson Pope’s desire to remain a Labour Party MP.   You go David – don’t let Helen bully you out.  She is reported as saying:

Prime Minister Helen Clark said nominations were open to early November and it remained to be seen whether someone would seek to challenge him.

Just because Helen wants you gone is no reason to go.  Hang out for Phil.  Yeah.

The working week

Today officially celebrates the 40 hour working week.  This is somewhat ironic as studies show 20% of employees now work over 50 hours a week.  But how much is this a problem and are more laws the answer?

I’m one of those who has never worked a 40 hour week, since finishing study. Even when I was an unqualified temporary administrative assistant at age 21, earning only a bit over $10 an hour, I would work longer than 9 – 5.  I saw my job as getting the work done.  I suspect it is partly because of that attitude I got five promotions in four years and I went from a temporary admin assistant to an acting departmental manager.

Not only have I never been paid penal rates for overtime (since uni), I’ve never been paid any rates.   And I suspect most of those who work over 50 hours a week are similiar – they are not getting paid hourly rates at all – but are on a salary.

Now sometimes the situation gets ridicolous.  Certainly at Parliament the hours could be gruesome.  I’ve never minded the odd 60 hour week, but when you are working extended hours like that week in, week out – it does piss you off.  A fairly major reason as to why I left Parliament is the desire for a better work/life balance.  But it wasn’t that anyone was forcing me to work such long hours – I just had the personality type where I would always try and take on extra work, and do more stuff.  No law is going to change that.

Incidentially my record for longest consecutive period of work is 63 hours without a sleep or break (apart from showers) when I was at the final phase of rolling out a major project.  My weekly maximum is 113 hours.  Again not healthy, but was a result of necessity.

Like most people I think those in lower level jobs should get paid per hour, and not to do so is exploitative. But at what level should hourly wages become an annual salary?  At the extreme end, the CEO of Telecom is expected to work more than a 40 hour week and he doesn’t get penal rates if there after 5 pm.

Even if people are on an annual salary, it is unhealthy to be constantly working 50 – 60+ hour weeks.  Sure, every so often for a major issue is fine, but your employer is under resourced if every evening and weekend you have to be in the office.  But again, I don’t think a law is the answer.  You can’t legislate for such different circumstances. I think the best thing is employees themselves being assertive, and making it clear that they will quit and go elsewhere unless their employer hires more staff. You can always threaten them under OSH also, as a safe workplace does include not having an unreasonable level of stress.