A referendum on MMP

Despite being picked as the best system by a Citizen’s Jury (which would be a preferable way to draft electoral law in NZ than have Pete Hodgson do it) the voters of Ontario rejected MMP.  It got only 36.9% support and a majority in just 5/107 ridings.

Don Brash writes at the Centre for Political Research, that 11 years on it is time for another referendum on MMP.  I agree that the electoral system is smething which should be decided by the public, not by MPs. And that at the 2011 election, that will have been 15 years – more than long enough to have the public make an informed decision.

Now if it was a choice between going back to FPP or staying with MMP, I would vote to stay with MMP.  The fact I support the public having a say, doesn’t mean I back change. Don Brash also says he would not vote to go back to FPP.

The major advantages of MMP has been that every vote counts to some degree (if they make threshold) and that the use of List MPs has allowed for a far more balanced and diverse Parliament.   I would not surrender those lightly.

The downside has been the disproportionate power given to parties like NZ First who effectively choose the Government as often as not.

If there was another referendum,  it need not be MMP vs FPP.  I assume it would be a two stage process like in 92/93 where one would select a contender in one vote, and then have a direct face off.  I’d love to see say an STV vs MMP choice or even a SM vs MMP choice.

STV is not very well suited to choosing a health board or local authority members.  But it can work well with national elections, and with Mayoral elections.

GPS for Wellington buses and trains

The Dom Post reports that it looks likely that GPS will be installed on Wellington buses and trains, so that passengers can see how far away they are from their stop.

This is very common overseas and even in other NZ cities.  It is a good idea.

I’m a fairly regular bus user, and the standard timetables are not hugely reliable.  But being able to get an accurate prediction on how far away the next bus is, would I am sure encourage greater use of the buses.

Would be great if they also allow one to see the GPS info from a website.  Then you don’t have to get to the bus stop, to see how far away the bus is.  You can look it up and time your departure to coincide.

Listen to the economics teacher

Peter Lyons is a teacher of economics. He writes in the NZ Herald how Dr Cullen’s surpluses are more to do with being miserly than about wise management:

But the sheer size of this surplus represents an economic distortion largely due to over-taxation of the private sector.

A Budget surplus of about $8 billion equates to $4000 for every worker in the New Zealand economy.

A key implication of Dr Cullen’s Budget surplus can be illustrated using the analogy of a household.

In this household the wife (tax-paying public) is the primary income earner and the husband (Government) is a miserly hoarder.

The husband permits the wife a minimal amount for running the household each week.

Some weeks she is forced to borrow from the local loan shark just to make ends meet. The more she borrows the more interest she has to pay.

As she slides further into debt she de-velops a debtor mentality of living for the moment. She continues to borrow and spend.

Meanwhile her husband gleefully counts his hoardings acquired mainly from her income. He is reluctant to increase her allowance in case she becomes more extravagant in her spending.

A great analogy.  Dr Cullen is the abusive controlling husband.  He isgnores the fact that we earn the mone, not him.  He treats it all as his, and will only give back to us the amount he thinks we should have.

Some health and education professionals are now eligible for Working for Families assistance if they are not too proud to receive Government welfare.

There is something disturbing about middle-income-earners being reliant on Government assistance to be able to raise a family, particularly during a period of economic prosperity.

Indeed.  But this is what the Government wants – over 50% of all NZ families reliant on the state, to create a permanent majority in favour of ever increasing state welfare.

Dr Cullen need not be proud of his huge Budget surplus. It does not indicate prudent economic management. It represents economic distortion in the form of over-taxation.

It is also a contributing factor to the huge debt mountain the New Zealand public has accumulated over recent years.

It’s a sound point, not often made.  The Government goes on abotu the high level of private sector debt, but contributes to the problem by refusing to give the private sector (you and me) their over-taxation back.

Six police a day assaulted

I’m not one of those people who think being a police officer is just like any other job.  It’s one of the rare professions where getting assaulted, and risking serious harm, is a regular part of the job.

The Police annual report notes attacks on police officers are at a ten year high and there are now an average six assaults a day.

And Greg O’Connor is probably right that the increase in substance abuse is why so many people now try to bash the Police, rather than accept arrest etc.

I’ve got a hell of a lot of respect for any frontline Officer.  Knowing you will get assaulted 10 – 20 times in your career is not exactly an incentive.

Conservative Home covers Key in the UK

Conservative Home covers the latest meeting between John Key and David Cameron.

David Cameron has had a fairly rough period since Gordon Brown took over, but he has weathered it well, and Brown is now the subject of intense criticism for his flip-flop on holding an early election.  He has also just agreed to cede more powers to the EU, despite having promised a referendum on such issues. So the next round of polls in the UK will be interesting. The last one has the Tories 7% ahead.

Dumbledore is gay

This will be reported around the world.  Even CNN has a story.

It’s not the only fantasy story where majro characters are gay, but it is not explicit. I’m a big fan of the Magician series by Raymond E. Feist and he was once asked on a mailing list I am on, about two male characters who lived together (Kulgan and Meecham).  When it was suggested they were just devoted friends, he laughed and said “Come on, two guys living together for 40 years – of course they’re gay”.

Of course there is no pleasing some people.  Some activists had complained that there were no gay characters in Rowling’s book, and now they are complaining that Dumbledore should have been outed earlier!

Oh dear

Hooton on Tax

Matthew Hooton addresses the trans-Tasman tax issue in his SST column:

Class hatred has been central to the government’s political strategy since 1999. The 39% tax rate on people earning more than $60,000 did not raise much revenue. It was designed merely as a symbolic attack on people Labour perceived as too financially successful.

Michael Cullen’s hatefulness boiled over right from the start, with his “we won, you lost, eat that” attack on employers. Sulkily, he cancelled the only tax cuts he ever promised because we weren’t grateful enough.

Matthew is not exagerrating.  Cullen has several times referred to the lack of gratitude as being a factor.  Don’t you love a Finance Minister who decides fiscal policy baed on how grumpy he is!

In Australia, John Howard has delivered tens of billions of dollars of tax cuts, while maintaining schools, hospitals and infrastructure at least as good as ours. His plan is that the first $20,000 of every Australian’s pay packet will soon be entirely tax-free. The lowest-earning Australians will pay nothing in tax. Students will pay nothing for their summer jobs. People earning less than $30,000 a year will pay just 5% in tax. Wealthier Australians will also benefit from these changes.

Our finance minister has slammed Howard’s proposals, saying they are “not the kind of programme you would expect to see from a Labour-led government”. Already Australians take home around 50% more than New Zealanders for the same work. For Cullen, it is a point of pride that he is actually promising to make that worse.

Yep we offer lower wages and higher taxes. What a great combination.

More on Terrorism arrests

The HoS has an article focusing mainly on claims from and about Jamie Lockett.

Bill Ralston wonders why he has not yet been raided.

The Hos Editorial says the Police had better have a  winning hand of cards.

Matt McCarten defends Iti:

The young idealists arrested with him were traipsing around his bush camp. No doubt they were firing guns and if the police say they set off napalm, I’m inclined to believe them. But does this mean that an eclectic group of Maori, political and environmental activists were being turned into a terrorist army?

Like most, I find it hard to think there was a conspiracy amongst all those arrested to set up a terrorist army.  But if people were breaking the firearms laws they need to be accountable for that.  If they regularly talked about using the illegal firearms they had collected to kill prominent NZers, well I don’t want a Police force which says “Nah, we don’t think they are serious”.  On the other hand it is an open question as to whether the evidence does add up, and whether they really needed to raid as aggressively as they did.

Sunday News asserts some top Maori or “Uncle Toms” were targets of the alleged terror attacks.   They also assert there was a definite plan:

“Each different splinter group was training under the one umbrella and they were going to carry out attacks on targets and infrastructure,” said our source.

“You would have had Tuhoe carrying out attacks on their selected targets, animal rights groups targeting their lot and the so-called `peace freaks’ carrying out their acts.

“There were a number of different groups at the table. They were going to wreak havoc according to their own agendas. They were going after a broad spectrum and broad range of targets.

I’d take this info more seriously if it was not in the Sunday News. But again will be interesting to see what is in the evidence.

The SST has a bit of a scoop with their lead story alleging Clark, Key and Bush were discussed as targets by those arrested.  They also have some detailes of what was allegedly seized:

The Star-Times, which broke the story on Fairfax Media’s Stuff website last Monday, understands the police have seized more than 20 guns, including AK-47s and other military-style semi-automatic rifles, as well as stab and bullet-resistant clothing, camouflage netting, bomb-making recipes and an IRA manual.

Of the 17 people arrested, about half have links with the Maori sovereignty movement, while most of the others are self-described anarchists.

Ralston on Electoral Finance Bill

Bill Ralston starts his column talking abot the police raids, but makes some strong points on the Electoral Finance Bill:

Aside from the weird anti-terrorism offensive, her Government is beginning to show some shockingly authoritarian traits. The Electoral Finance Bill is the kind of legislation Dr Goebbels would have endorsed. Under that bill only the Government (and maybe a political party or two) can issue propaganda.

As currently written, the bill would stop pressure groups and people from publicly taking political stands during an election year. Unless, of course, that pressure group is a trade union. The Council of Trade unions has grandly announced its intentions to campaign heavily for Labour-aligned policies next year and the CTU is confident the Electoral Finance Bill doesn’t apply.

A pile of potentially terrorist-aligned groups oppose the Government’s great leap forward for democracy. Notorious commie stirrers such as the Law Society want the bill scrapped, saying it is “a backward step and irredeemable”, adding that ordinary citizens could unwittingly break the law simply by taking part in debates on election issues. Well, the Law Society better stand by for a dawn raid from a load of men in black – and I don’t mean the All Blacks.

The Human Rights Commission, Education Institute and Post Primary Teachers Association have also attacked the bill as flawed and an assault on people’s rights. I expect their radical leaders to be whipped off to Guantanamo Bay at any moment.

Basically, the bill muzzles anyone from taking a stand during an election year on any political issue.

The pure evil genius in the Government’s Electoral Finance Bill is that while it restricts the amount interest groups could spend advertising their views on an issue, the Government could spend anything it likes pushing its own views. John Key made this point earlier in the week arguing that the Government could next year spend a fortune advertising how good, for example, its health policies were year but medical pressure groups could not reply that Labour’s policies had failed, because the bill would stop them from spending more than $60,000 on a campaign during an election year.

Ralston then goes on to say:

Still, the bill would stop the Exclusive Brethren bankrolling political parties, which is using a sledgehammer to crack a walnut. A little like unleashing armed police on a bunch of crackpots.

Actually here Ralston is wrong.  Clark personally deleted the provisions banning anonymous donations because she heeds them for Labour.

George W Bush and the Department of Homeland Security will be proud of Helen Clark this week.

Actually this is an interesting point.  Imagine the Bush Administration introduced the equivalent of the Electoral Finance Bill?  Every left wing group in the world would be condemning them as fascist dictators who are intent on suppressing dissent.

Some telemarketing advice

It really is a very bad idea, if you are trying to persuade people to swap phone providers from Telecom to someone else, not to call on a line which sounds like it originates from the other side of the world, complete with static, pauses and low volume.

I didn’t even stay on the line long enough to hear their name or prices.  My only though was if that is the quality of their phone lines, I sure as hell don’t want that on all my calls.

Rugby World Cup Final Survey

Kiwitube

Rudd backs massive tax cuts

As I have said many times, most left wing parties do not share NZ Labour’s ideological hatred of reducing tax. I doubt one could find another party in the world that has had surpluses as high as NZ’s, and they’ve refused to lower personal tax rates.

Australian Labor leader Kevin Rudd has endorsed almost every element of Peter Costello’s massive tax cuts. The only difference is with the rate for those earning over $180,000.

Rudd has also offered tax deductions for laptops and Internet connections if used for home education.

And his long-term plan through to 2013-14 would have Labor flatten the tax structure going from four rates of 15%, 30%, 35% and 40% to just 15%, 30% and 40%.

So no matter who wins in Australia, within a few years there will be 0% income tax for those earning up to $20,000.  Someone on $30,000 will pay only an average 5% tax.

And what do we have after years of massive surpluses?  A worker on $30,000 paying almost four times as much tax as one in Australia.

Growing concern over arrests

Chris Trotter did a strong column yesterday backing Police Commissioner Howard Broad, calling him a man of integrity.  I can’t find an online version to link to – but it should give sceptics some pause for thought.

It goes without saying that I don’t think there is anything beyond coincidence that Parliament was due to be debating a terrorism bill this week.  That bill already had overwhelming support, and the events of this week probably make it harder not easier to progress it.

But my concerns is growing that there may have been some over-reaching by Police.  I got a call yesterday letting me know that one of those arrested in Auckland was someone I have met socially.  Now he is an anarchist (and that’s no crime) but I find it very difficult to believe he was part of some planned violent action.

He’s a fairly young guy, and locked up in prison until November.  Now if he has broken the law, he will face consequences in court.  But the part that is concerning me more and more is the refusal of bail.  Sure that is reasonable to do if they really were part of some violent conspiracy.  But if they merely broke firearms laws at a camp a few months ago, why treat them differently to anyone else who is charged with firearm offences?

Maharey on Goff

NZPA’s Grant Fleming has done an interesting interview with Steve Maharey.  Some extracts:

He was also reluctant to talk about Labour’s leadership post-Clark, but said he did not hold the view of some Labour members that Cabinet Minister Phil Goff was too right-wing to lead the party.

This is significant. In fact this is highly significant.  Maharey was long seen as the MP who would stop Goff becoming Leader.  To have Maharey publicly endorse him is not a minor thing.  I would even go so far as to say it is a sign the leadership sucession is close to settled.

To be fair to Goff, he deserves a chance at the top job. Even the left of Labour should be able to recognise that he has been a very competent Minister, and has not tried to undermine Clark since the unsuccessful attempt in the late 90s.

I actually think Goff could be electorally difficult for National.  He is reasonably right wing on law & order issues – often a weakness for Labour – and would throw away the ideological hatred of tax cuts.  Not because he is a proud devotee of tax cuts, but because he recognises their popularity when surpluses are so high.

Help Breast Cancer Research and Search

Electoral Finance Bill Submissions

Median Incomes over time

As I hoped, my analysis of how a worker on the average wage has done in the 1990s and 2000s was wildy sucessful as it induced rage from those quarters where facts get in the way of ideology.

Now one fair point raised was, how different is it if one uses median wage rather than mean wage.  The problem is there is no quarterly data series going back that far with median wage.

But we do have the census data.  And while the dates are not a perfect fit, they do still allow us to look at what happened to net real earnings of a fulltime employee on the median wage/income.

Now as before let’s look at gross nominal median FT income.

Gross nominal median FT income
1991 $25,100
2001 $32,400
2006 $38,400

Over the decade National was roughly  in office, median income went up $7,300 or 29.1%. A half decade under Labour and the increase is $6,000 or 18.5%.  The average per year in terms of growth then is 2.9% 1990s and 3.7% 2000s.

But now we take tax off, to get after tax income.

Net nominal median FT income
1991 $19,307
2001 $26,166
2006 $30,858

Over the decade National was roughly  in office, net median income went up $6,859 or 35.5%. A half decade under Labour and the increase is $4,692 or 17.9%.  The average per year in terms of growth then is 3.6% 1990s and 3.6% 2000s.

And then we adjust to get real figures taking into account inflation.  The CPI was 736 in 1991, 869 in 2001 and 985 in 2006.

Net real median FT income in March 2006$
1991 $25,839
2001 $29,659
2006 $30,858

Over the decade National was roughly  in office, net real median income went up $3,820 or 14.8%. A half decade under Labour and the increase is $1,199 or 4.0%.  The average per year in terms of growth then is 1.5% 1990s and 0.8% 2000s.

So a fulltime worker on the median income, has had their real after tax income go up only 4% over five years.  Around half of what it was in the 1990s.

Now the point of these posts is not to claim that magically workers do better under Party A than Party B, even though it is nice to wind up the chorus of dissent.  It was principally to rebut those exact claims from said chorus about how much better off the average worker is.  Because in terms of real after tax income they are not.

But the important point is to remind people why both low inflation and low taxes are important.  If you do not adjust tax brackets (at a minimum) then the higher level of tax you pay, plus inflation chews up your pay rises.

In fact if your pay rise is exactly the same as the inflation rate, then your real earnings drop because the average tax you pay increases.

Maharey to retire

Steve Maharey has announced he will both retire from Parliament at the next election, but also step down from Cabinet at the impending reshuffle.

This is a big event.  Not only is Maharey the highest ranked MP after the Leader and Deputy, he was probably the favourite to replace Clark as Leader.

He has been appointed Vice-Chancellor of Massey University, which isn’t a bad job at all to go into. Not quite as good as Prime Minister though.

This means they now need to find replacements for both Education and Social Development – two of the largest portfolios.

It also dramatically increases the chance of Phil Goff of becoming Labour Leader. If Labour do lose the next election, and Clark stands down, then there is only a year for alternatives to Goff to impress. That’s assuming Mallard isn’t a contender, but he may now be a contender again if it is him vs Goff.

Ha I was right

I pointed out on Tuesday that Dr Cullen was clearly wrong with his assertion that there was nothing in the Australian package for people earning under $30,000 a year.

He now admits he was wrong. But get this – he still tries to attack the package on the basis that those earning under $11,000 a year get nothing from it.  Ummm, that’s because in Australia they are already scheduled to be paying 0% income tax under the tax laws passed last year. So Dr Cullen is complaining that people who pay zero income tax do not get a tax cut. Why do we trust this man with our money?

Just remember that the caring Dr Cullen will tax someone  earning $30,000 almost four times as much as the nasty Peter Costello.  Cullen will thump a low income worker on $30,000 with an average 19.1% tax compared to Peter Costello’s proposed 5.0% average tax.

No wonder he had to lie about the package.  It makes his lack of action look so much worse.

Horomia says Iti no terrorist

Maori Affairs Minister Parekura Horomia told TV3 yesterday that he doubted Tama Iti is a terrorist.  Really, Ministers of the Crowns should know better than to speculate.  They have a constitutional position other MPs do not.

Having said that, the Maori and Green parties would be wise to not be jumping to conclusions either, and demanding responses from Ministers.   Ministers should and generally are saying nothing, as to do so would undermine the judicial process.

CTU Campaign for Labour

The NZ Herald reports on the CTU’s plans to run a centralised focused campaign to re-elect a Labour Government. They state:

The union movement played a major role in Labour’s success in the 2005 election when it mobilised to get a large number of people out to vote in South Auckland.

Ms Kelly vowed the same thing would happen again, noting that “we tipped the balance in deciding the election outcome”.

This is the true value of the unions to Labour in the campaign period.  It’s not the extra advertising spend.  It’s the free labour.  There’s barely a union in the country that won’t be turning a blind eye to the fact that their staff are spending half their working days campaigning for Labour.  And all that staff time is of course excluded under the Electoral Finance Bill even though it’s value is immense.
And even their paid advertising will be exempt under the Electoral Finance Bill.  Let’s say the xxx Union does a glossy 10 page booklet explaining why its members should vote Labour.  They’re very careful to use language to show it is directed to members.

But hey they can’t control what their members do with it.  If a member ends up with 20 copies and leaves them in their workplace for non members – well that isn’t prohibited.  And if a non members reads all about how National is going to sell the children of workers into slavery, then hey all the better.

If the Select Committee does proceed with the Bill, it will be interesting to see if they widen the exemption for communicating with your members to employers able to communicate to their staff, or companies to their shareholders.

Family Party website

Heh check out who registered the domain name familyparty.org.nz and that will explain why their website is thefamilyparty.org.nz. You really should register a domain before you announce your party name!

Interestingly Paul Adams has already been demoted from co-leader to Deputy Leader.  It is still 100% Destiny Church in control with ArchDeanconess Brian Tamaki in actual control.

Start Over says Human Rights Commission

After publicity about how the Select Committee was not going to let the Human Rights Commission be heard from, they did get to do an oral submission today in a special session. I’ll quote from the NZPA article:

The Human Rights Commission told a select committee considering the Government’s Electoral Finance Bill that the impact of measures in the bill could have a deadening effect on democracy.

The commission wants the bill scrapped and started again.

If it has to stay wants to see the present three-month regulatory period limiting election spending kept instead of increasing it to the whole of an election year;

Chief Human Rights Commissioner Rosslyn Noonan said the cumulative effect of the measures in the bill meant it was incompatible with the Bill of Rights.

Active participation in the political process was vital to democracy and the bill’s provisions could stifle legitimate debate and political contributions for nearly a third of the electoral cycle, she said.

Prime Minister Helen Clark has previously indicated there could be changes to the definitions of electoral advertising, spending thresholds and time limitations. But Ms Noonan said any changes needed to be consulted on and the best way to do it was with a new bill.

“The commission’s preference is and remains that the … bill is withdrawn and redrafted to take into account the very substantial and in depth submissions of the over 600 submitters to this committee.”

The commission also thought there was an issue around the benefits the party in power had during election campaigns; advantages included being the mouthpiece of policy and having the infrastructure of government.

Incidentially Chief Commissioner Ros Noonan is a former Head of the NZEI Union and a former CTU official. Not someone who would go out of their way to over-hype how bad a Government bill is.

In their press release, they also deal with what to do if the Select Committee ignores the plea to drop the Bill and introduce a new one.

If the Committee decided to proceed by simply amending the bill, it was imperative that members of the public are given a further opportunity to scrutinise it and make submissions before it is referred back to Parliament, Ms Noonan said.

This is the challenge for Peter Dunne. If he ignores the advice of the Human Rights Commission that it is imperative that members of the public are given an opportunity to scrutinise and submit on a revised bill, then he will be guilty of standing up for Human Rights in Taiwan, but not in New Zealand. Dunne has said the bill need radical rewriting. I agree. And any radically different bill needs to have public scrutiny and input into it. Especially one that restricts the rights of the public to criticise or campaign against MPs. That makes it even more crucial there is public input.