General Debate 18 October 2007
So the IRB has found Wayne Barnes made a series of mistaken calls against the All Blacks, but none of them were significant despite not noticing a forward pass they scored a try off!
Discuss this or anything else!
By chance, at 10.45 am today Stats released their Labour productivity stats. Now this is an important indicator as it is one of the keys to keeping pace with Australia and other economies. I’ll quote directly from the Stats NZ release:
The strongest period of labour productivity growth was from 1997 to 2000, where solid output growth and declining labour input boosted productivity by 3.5 percent annually. From 2000 onwards, labour productivity growth has averaged 1.4 percent annually, compared with the 28-year average of 2.2 percent.
Now that 1.4% growth is pretty dismal. But it also drags down the overall 2.2% average. What was the labour productivty growth from March 91 to March 2000? It was 3.2% on average.
Oh and in case you were wondering about the other productivity indexes? Well capital productivity was 1.6% in 1990s compared to 0.0% since 2000. And multifactor productivity was 2.5% in 1990s compared to 0.7% since 2000.
So the IRB has found Wayne Barnes made a series of mistaken calls against the All Blacks, but none of them were significant despite not noticing a forward pass they scored a try off!
Discuss this or anything else!
If one believed some of the more hysterical commenters, the 1990s was a time of slavery and child labour and the average worker did far worse than under Labour. Sadly for their little fantasy world, the facts say something else.
Let’s look at our friend, the Quarterly Employment Survey from Stats NZ. And let’s look at the nine years from June 1990 to June 1999 under National and the eight years from June 1999 to June 2007 under Labour. The average ordinary-time weekly earnings were:
Gross average ordinary-time weekly earnings
1990: $502.95
1999: $639.96
2007: $846.19
So the average weekly earnings went up $137.01 under National and $194.74 under Labour. So wow maybe Labour is much better for the average worker. What was the increase as a percentage? National 27.2% vs Labour 32.2%. Still Labour ahead, and in one fewer year.
But is there something missing?? Yes, there is. A couple of things. We forgot to look at income tax. How much pay does the average worker get after tax is deducted. A quick check at the then tax tables and we have:
Net average ordinary-time weekly earnings
1990: $385.81
1999: $516.50
2007: $665.33
So the net average weekly earnings went up $130.69 under National and $139.76 under Labour. Hmmn not much of a difference. So what was the increase as a percentage? National 33.9% vs Labour 28.8%. An average of 3.76% per year vs 3.60% – almost no difference. So perhaps there is no difference.
But wait there’s still one further factor to take into account. One could buy a lot more in 1990 than you could in 2007 for the same wage. We need to inflation adjust. Now the CPI was 716 in 1990, 832 in 1999 and 1020 in 2007. So let’s look at real net average ordinary-time workings in June 2007 dollars.
Real net average ordinary-time weekly earnings
1990: $549.62
1999: $633.21
2007: $665.33
So the net average weekly earnings went up $83.59 under National and $33.90 under Labour. Yep the average worker in the nasty 90s ended up with an extra $84 a week while under caring kind Labour they are only $34 better off – an increase in weekly real take home pay of really just $4 every year.
And what was the increase as a percentage? National 15.2% vs Labour 5.1%. Yes the average worker’s take home pay went up 15% under National and a miserly 5% under Labour. Just 5% after eight years.
Now apologists will claim it has all gone into Working for Families etc. Well that only affects 20% of families. And regardless that is a separate comparison about welfare support. There were significant boosts in the 1990s to family support also.
This is what happens when you never ever reduce tax rates and you let inflation get away on you. It eats up all the extra income the average family gets.
So the next time someone drones on about how bad the 1990s were for the average worker. Just remember they were three times better than the last eight years.
Destiny New Zealand has basically renamed itself the Family Party and has co-opted former United Future MP Paul Adams as its co-leader instead of Gordon Copeland.
So is there any difference? Well yes there is. Copeland has strong religious convictions, and is politically naive, but basically a decent guy.
Paul Adams was the most extreme of the United Future MPs from 2002 to 2005. His views are pretty indistinguishable from Destiny.
The Family Party will do little better than Destiny. They will not be winning Mangere or Manukau East.
Future New Zealand will also get probably less than half a percent. This is good, as that means less wasted vote.
South Pacific Pictures kindly invited me to an advance media screening of the movie “We’re here to help“, which was on Monday night this week.
The movie is based in the true life story of Dave Henderson from Christchurch who fought and survived a five year battle with the IRD. After he threatened to “kick the fat arse” of an IRD officer who had insulted his girlfriend, his $64,000 refund turned into a $920,000 debt. It is a classic David vs Goliath battle.
The film is highly enjoyable. They turn the story into a humourous, but with serious undertones, depiction of refusing to back down to bullies. Little gags like turning up the air conditioning in the IRD building got the audience smiling.
What I really liked was that they didn’t turn the IRD officials into one dimensional “bad” guys. Yes they were smarmy and lacking empathy, but they genuinely convinced themselves Henderson was dodgy and hence in their own minds justified everything they did to him.
The main characters are all well cast. Michael Hurst does a good Rodney Hide, even though he doesn’t feature as much as I expected. Miriama Smith nailed her part as girlfriend Kath Harper and Erik Thompson made Henderson a likeable rogue.
They have some nice features which resonate with anyone who deals with the IRD. The opening credits are all done by way of filling in IRD forms. And there is a particularly good section where Henderson tries to locate the IRD problem resolution service and gets bounced from office to office.
Overall it is a very good easy to watch film. About 80 minutes. The cast all perform their roles well, and the plot moves along at just the right pace. My biggest criticism would be that they could have handled better the IRD decision to back down. I would have had a couple of scenes showing the Commissioner reading the full report, being briefed on the latest questions in Parliament, and realising how badly exposed the Department was. It was not quite an anti-climax, but didn’t quite make its dramatic potential.
It wasn’t really an anti IRD film. They showed some good guys from the IRD also. It was a film really about bullies, and abuse of power. At times a sad film as Henderson is bankrupted and his partner leaves him. And finally a film with a wicked ending as we see the IRD Head Office in Christchurch renamed Henderson House.
Definitely worth going to.
Peter Dunne wrote a column today on the Electoral Finance Bill which ran in the Dominion Post. It is great to read that he has been listening to the concerns of thousands of New Zealanders over this Bill, and how it will affect human rights in NZ.
As it stands, under the Bill’s provisions, almost any group that dares to express an opinion that could be construed as political (in that reflects upon the policies of one or other political party) is potentially caught and required to register as a third party. This is clearly absurd, and reflects a level of control over society that even the KGB would have struggled to match.
It is little wonder that groups like the Human Rights Commission and the Law Society have condemned the Bill as a massive attack on free speech.
Peter proposes a number of changes around the definition of advertising and the third party limit. He says:
Unless the Electoral Finance Bill is radically rewritten along these lines, Labour will not get the support it needs to pass the legislation.
Now it is quite correct the bill does need radically rewriting. In fact more radical than even what Peter says, as he has not mentioned the ridicolous 11 month period of regulated speech, which would apply for 30% of our lives.
But the key point is, that even if suitable radical amendments can be drafted and agreed to, it is then a radically different Bill. And the public deserve the chance to have their say on a radically different Bill which will still regulate their rights to participate in the electoral process. So what I hope Peter does, if he thinks the Bill is now acceptable, is to move that submissions on the amended bill be called for – because it’s common sense to let the public have their say.
Dom Post has an article on how stoned drivers may be 2.5 times more dangerous than drunk driver.
I’ve been a long time supporter of testing for drugs as well as alcohol. However the problem is the testing. I understand cannabis can remain detectable for up to two months after use. Now I think it is fair to say that someone isn’t still impaired days after they had a joint.
The Police procedure of using a balance and co-ordination test, as a filter for a blood test sounds like a pretty pragmatic way to deal with it.
I’ve generally been a strong supporter of Helen Clark and Winston Peters with regard to Fiji – much to the dismay of some of my fellow bloggers. I don’t believe the ends justify the means, when the means is a coup.
But Clark was unwise to predict in advance of the South Pacific Forum that Bainimarama would be treated as a leper if he turned up. Even I know enough of Pacific culture to know this was most unlikely. And sure enough he has been given literally the royal treatment.
I was as surprised as anyone when Police executed their anti-terror raids on Monday. But I was even more surprised when the media named one of those arrested as Jamie Lockett, because by coincidence I had been speaking to him the day before on Sunday. This is assuming there are not two men called Jamie Lockett in Auckland, of similiar age and both in the security arena.
Now my dealings with Lockett have been pretty mundane. I mentioned a while back that I had been served with court papers asking me to reveal some IP addresses and e-mail addresses in an old thread. Lockett was acting on behalf of the party making that court request and I have been so busy it hadn’t been my highest priority, so he had called me half a dozen times to check on progress. Including last Friday and Sunday.
It appears that his phone has been monitored for some months, so I’m quite amused that the Police probably were listening in to his phone calls to me.
I don’t know Lockett besides the phone calls (all of which were cordial) so can’t really offer any opinion on his alleged involvement. But it is a weird feeling to read that someone has been arrested on terrorism related charges, when you were on the phone to them just the day before.
Someone who does offer a bit more insight into things is Stephen Franks. Stephen blogs on his last encounter with Tame Iti and how it was somewhat frosty and threatening, which was a change from previous occasions.
Auckland University Education Dean John Langley calls for better research and evaluation of education initiatives. It’s a sensible article, and worth highlighting his five myths:
Langley asserts these myths have for decades permeated our policy-making and practice. I see little in what he says, which I can disagree with. For example:
Experience alone does not improve performance. What improves performance is knowledge, skills and how they are applied and interpreted by experience. Without better knowledge and skill, experience alone is a vacuum.
And finally I refer to:
Accepting everything and expecting nothing will neither help children learn nor enable them to reach full potential.
Indeed.
The Dominion Post appears to have a exclusive scoop, with sources revealing that police documents claim Tame Iti was planning to declare an IRA-style war on New Zealand, demanding independence for Tuhoe.
It sounds like the Police have been very vigilant with videos and photos of the training camp, and intercepted text messages.
The group allegedly included former NZ Army soldiers, and attempts were made to obtain a grenade launcher.
If this is correct, it certainly goes well well beyond a few guys mouthing off after some drinks. The issue isn’t so much whether or not Iti would or would not have been sucessful. The issue is how many people were willing to sign up to terrorist attacks on other New Zealanders.
Based on knowledge to date (and it is very incomplete, so hence no final judgements) it seems clear there was at least a small group based around Iti which was planning some horrific stuff. But whether all those arrested were aware of what Iti was planning is quite another matter.
Hopefully more information will come to light sooner rather than later, but the integrity of the judicial process is of course paramount.
NZPA has an article which quotes Dr Cullen:
Dr Cullen said there was nothing in the Australian tax cut package for those earning under $30,000 a year and just $20 a week for those earning up to $74,000 a year, but $128 a week for those on $200,000 a year.
“Not the kind of programme you would expect to see from a Labour-led government,” Dr Cullen said.
Okay – someone earning $30,000 a year pays $5,730 tax in NZ. Before this announcement they were going to end up in Australia paying only $2,850 tax. Once this package is fully implemented they will pay only $1,500 tax on $30,000 of income – a 5% average tax rate. This is what Cullen calls nothing?
A worker earning $30,000 in Australia wil have a takehome pay that is a whopping $81 a week higher than under Dr Cullen. Now that is a huge disparity. And it is $26 a week more than before the announcement.
Someone on $70,000 a year pays $18,570 tax in NZ. Before this announcement they were going to end up in Australia paying only $15,600 tax. Once this package is fully implemented they will pay only $13,900 tax on $70,000 of income – a 20% average tax rate. And that is $32 a week more than efore this package was announced.
Someone on $30,000 in Australia will be keeping 14.1% more of their income than in NZ. On $70,000 they will be keeping 6.6% more of their income. On $200,000 they will be keeping just 4.4% more of their income.
Dr Cullen says that giving lower income workers a higher percentage of their income, than wealthier people, is something one would not expect from a Labour-led Government. Well not his one for sure.
Peter Costello announced yesterday a massive plan of tax cuts. Every year over five years they will cut tax rates and move thresholds. It will mean that anyone who earns less than $1,090,000 a year will pay less income tax in Australia.
The first $20,000 of income will be tax free. Superb. Someone earning $40,000 will pay an average 20.2% in NZ and only 8.5% in Australia. Who wouldn’t you move there? You’ll pay almost $100 a week less tax if you earn $40,000
This table shows how much tax you will pay in Australia (once fully implemented) and in New Zealand. Almost painful to compare.
In Australia they will guarantee that for at least 45% of the population, the top marginal tax rate will be 15%. Yes 15% for almost half the population. In NZ only 21% pay 15% or less top marginal rate.
So by how much has Peter Costello cut taxes and how does this compare to Michael Cullen? Well Cullen has only increased personal tax rates, and has allowed fiscal drag to over-tax hundreds of thousands New Zealanders. So let’s look at Costello:
Yes Peter Costello will abolish income tax for those earning below $20,000, and slashed it by 75% for those on $30,000 and by 65% for those on $40,000. Even those on $50,000 face income tax reductions of 51% and the filthy nasty greedy rich on $60,000 get a 45% tax cut compared to a penalty tax in NZ.
And what level of surplus does Australia have? In NZ we have had surpluses as high as 7% of GDP and Dr Cullen has still insisted there can be no tax cuts. Well the surplus in Australia is around 1.3% of GDP.
And what about inflation. To quote Costello:
Mr Costello said the tax cuts would not be inflationary and were designed to increase workforce participation by giving people greater rewards for work. “By getting more people into the workforce you will be taking pressure off inflation because you will be adding to the number of workers, getting one of the big capacity constraints out of the way,” Mr Costello told Sydney radio 2UE. “One of the problems that business has at the moment … is they are reporting, in some parts of the country, not enough workers.”
Mr Costello also said the changes would make Australia’s personal tax system more internationally competitive.
Interestingly Australia Labour have not ruled out matching the promise with a tax plan of their own.
Colin Espiner blogs that Labour’s energy strategy has significant risks:
Demand for power is growing at 2% a year. The energy strategy states this will fall to 1.5%, which is an arguable point, but even accepting this, that means that over the 18 years before 2025 the country will require 27% more energy than it currently has available just to maintain the status quo. Add immigration, economic growth, and Kiwis’ seemingly insatiable desire for new electronic gadgetry into the equation, and it’s starting to look a little dodgy.
Given that the security of our energy supply is already questionable (remember the cold showers and the brownouts every time there is a “dry year”?) and the Government’s decision to can the 500MW Rodney station has a whiff of political craziness about it.
It’s all very well steering the country down a path of energy sustainability, but I’m not sure voters yet realise what that will mean in practice. And placing the country’s energy security in jeopardy is foolhardy indeed.
I think the move to renewable energy sources is inevitable and desirable. But the timetable has to be one which guarantees security of supply. To place political motivations over timing ahead of security of supply is indeed foolish.
Alt Tv has been ordered off the air for five hours and fined $5,000 because they allowed racists text messages to be shown on screen.
Somewhat amusingly it is revealed that the reason the text messages got through is that the employee responsible for them was intoxicated!
Good God, the weapons alone seized seem to more than adequate justification for the raids yesterday. The Dom Post reports that naplam bombs, molotov cocktails and assault rifles are amongst the weapons seized.
One of the bombs was detonated eight days ago in a training exercise. This sounds like a lot more than just a few idiots mouthing off, with the Police alleging different cells planning to hit different targets in co-ordinated attacks.
In another story about the Wellington arrests, the four arrested are described as pacifists. How this will mesh with being charged with possessing firearms, large-calibre semi-automatic weapons, Molotov cocktails, shotguns and rifles I do not know. The most well armed pacifists I have heard of. Maybe they are Swiss?
I can’t believe we are reading about this happening in NZ, not some other country.
For general discussion on issues that don’t have a specific blog post about them. Normal rules of discourse still apply.
One of the great things about the blogosphere is that activists from all over the spectrum post, and hence it it a superb source of information.
Asher has a useful collection of details from during the day.
But it is the comment from Bomber that most intrigues me:
I’ve just come back from talking with some people in the activist community who have an idea of what is going on here, and if the allegations as I understand them are true, this country is about to get very, very, very angry.
Two things seem certain:
I: God forgive me, but as I understand it (and I’m open to being wrong, please let me be wrong) BUT the Police look like they were right to be concerned
2: There is going to be outrage when the full story gets out the likes of which talkback have never dreamt of.
This sounds very chilling. Half of me wants the Police to be wrong – on the grounds that then NZ doesn’t really have a group of individuals who were actually planning violence or assassination. But half of me wants the Police to be right – on the grounds that if they did stuff up, then confidence in the Police would be massively undermined. I guess whatever happens, NZ is worse off.
In preparation for the Electoral Finance Bill, the Government has pre-emptively arrested 17 Green Party and Maori Party activists today in a series of raids involving 300 police officers.
“Their protest activities will be illegal next year, so we figured we’d be pro-active and arrest them now to save time” said a Police spokesperson.
As another experiment towards a better commenting situation, I’m going to steal a device from Parliament and have one post per day which isn’t on a specific topic, but on anything else people find topical.
Generally there will be more latitude as to what one can say in the general debate thread (just like in Parliament) as they do not have to be tied to a specific issue. General rules of acceptable behaviour will still apply. But if you think the average wage increase is news, then post a comment here on what the news is, and what you think it means.
The counterpoint to having a general debate, if we’ll be less tolerant of people going off topic in the other threads.
Also doesn’t have to be political. One can discuss the rugby, the weather. Anything at all so long as it isn’t offensive, or breaches the posting policy, or is personally denigrating of people etc etc.
I blogged on Friday a list of public mayoralty polls. Also interesting to see whether the polls reflected the results. If they do not, that is not necessarily a problem with the poll. It depends when it was taken, what events have happened since then etc.
One comment I will make though, is with such low turnouts, I personally always filter the random sample by asking respondents how likely they are to vote, and not proceeding with those less likely to vote. Far more people say they will vote than actually do at local body level. This may partly explain why the result in North Shore was so different to the Herald poll.
Waitakere: Herald Digipoll has Bob Harvey on 49% and John Tamihere on 32%. Result: Harvey won.
Manukau: Herald Digipoll has Len Brown on 29%, Dick Quax 22% and Willie Jackson 16%. Result: Brown won.
Far North: A Northern Advocate/Curia poll found a tight race with 34% for challenge Wayne Brown and 28% for Mayor Yvonne Sharp. Result: Brown won.
Whangarei: A Northern Advocate/Curia poll has former Mayor Stan Semenoff on 35% and Mayor Pamela Peters trailing on 19%. Result: Semenoff won.
South Taranaki: A Western Institute of Technology poll has
Wanganui: A Wanganui Chronicle/Curia poll found 46% support for Mayor Michael Laws and 28% for John Martin. Result: Laws won.
Manawatu: A Manawatu Standard/Versus poll has Mayor Heather Tanguay on 38% and Jono Naylor on 30%. Result: Naylor won easily .
Nelson: Nelson Mail has Kerry Marshall on 18% and Watson on 16%. Result: Marshall won.
Tasman: Nelson Mail has Richard Kempthorne on 32% incumbent John Hurley on 29%. Result: Kempthorne won.
Overall the polls were “right” in most races, but the result did differ in South Taranaki, in Palmerston North and in North Shore.
It appears that Ann Hartley is going to resign from Parliament, as she got elected to the North Shore City Council. I wonder if Di Yates planned to do the same, if she had been successful in Hamilton?
This will bring Louisa Wall into Parliament.
Incidentally Louisa currently works for (or did at the time of the last election) the Human Rights Commission. The same Commission which unequivocally called for the Electoral Finance Bill not to proceed. So will Louisa, as an MP, vote to ignore the advice of her former employer?
Fran O’Sullivan writes on the Air NZ Kuwait flights, and reveals that a month before the first flight, a report including info on the flights was sent not just to Winston Peters’ private secretary but also Phil Goff’s.
O’Sullivan also deals with the fact that it is unfair to blame public servants for breaching policy:
It is unfathomable that so many public servants did not twig that the flights countervened Government policy as Clark and her senior ministers now claim.
Either the bureaucrats are incompetent, in which case the tumbrils should roll. Or there is no clear Government policy on Iraq, as the Australians believe. Or the Government (which was angered that the Investigate story undercut its attacks on National leader John Key’s vacillating stance on Iraq) shifts policy according to how much domestic capital it believes it can extract.
I think the shifting policy theory holds true.
Bill Ralston also has some fun with the issue:
The fact that two top Foreign Affairs advisers in his office apparently couldn’t be buggered reading an email report from the Combined Threat Assessment Group (CTAG) telling them New Zealand had just become a bigger target for al Qaeda is a bit of a worry. CTAG consists of the cops, the military and the country’s various spy agencies and its job is to monitor terrorist threats. A kind of important job, really, yet these characters in Winston’s office probably yawned “Ho hum”, clicked on “Received” and went back onto Trade Me instead.
What other vital warnings have they overlooked? I can imagine the pair now frantically going through their inbox. “Hmmm, what else have we got? Oh, this one from the SIS last month. Bin Laden’s holidaying in Queenstown. I’ll ring Millbrook and see if he’s still there. Hang on, here’s another dated September 10, 2001, from the Waihopi spy base, saying “Warn the Americans something about airplane hijacks and the Twin Towers. Might delete that one.”
Weirdly, Winston Peters didn’t seem to care too much that his office doesn’t bother to read all of its email traffic, explaining that the CTAG report was buried in a mountain of paperwork and they couldn’t get through it all.
I have to say, that one would think a CTAG report would be fairly high priority for reading.
Dean Knight blogs his disapproval of the decision of Christchurch City Council to lease new premises, a couple of days before the election. Dean is a lawyer and covers the legal angle well.
I agree that they should not have voted on an issue like this so close to the election. In fact they voted after most people had voted, which makes it worse.
I wonder if a solution is to dissolve Councils once nominations for the elections close?
I mean the country survives very well with no Parliament for a couple of months. I am sure a city can survive being in caretaker mode for six weeks or so.