Rodney on sedition and the Electoral Finance Bill

Rodney Hide gave a superb speech in support of repealing the sedition laws, and turns his guns on the Electoral Finance Bill:

But I want Mr Keith Locke to reflect on this. He said that it is important that in a free society, in a democratic society, even people who want to advocate hateful ideas, like bin Ladenism, should be entitled to do so. I agree with him.

So we can have a situation now where we are standing up and saying “Yes, it’s OK to advocate fascism, yes it’s OK to advocate bin Ladenism, but the Exclusive Brethren who attacked the Greens broke [no] law, so we’re going to change the law so they can’t do it.”

So what is special about election year? Suddenly in election year we are going to pass a law. We will not be seditious; we will just be in breach of our electoral laws. Where is the sense in that? We are passing a law here tonight, quite rightly, so that we can advocate what was commonly called sedition, but we are also contemplating passing a law that says we cannot put out a pamphlet saying we do not like the Government, we do not like the National Party, we do not like the Maori Party, or we do not like the ACT party. It does not even have to be untrue; it just becomes unlawful.

So have we not got this a bit skew-whiff? Because would not one be saying Stalinism and Fascism killed millions of people? I do not think the Exclusive Brethren could hurt a flea, actually. I do not think what they were advocating was dangerous. It was just their political views. It might be wacky. It might not be what one agrees with.

But surely in this House, if we can stand up here like Mr Locke says and say: “It’s OK to advocate Fascism, it’s OK to advocate Stalinism, and it’s OK to advocate bin Ladenism”, then surely it is OK to criticise the Greens. Surely it is OK to criticise Helen Clark. Surely it is OK to criticise the National Party and the ACT party, and surely in one’s criticism it must be OK to run off a few pamphlets and put them in a grateful nation’s letterbox so they can say “absolutely”.

Now they are scared of the people. They are scared of allowing New Zealanders to advocate their ideas and to spend what little money they have after the tax man has been and Michael Cullen has spent it, and to print a pamphlet and stick it in a neighbour’s letterbox.

Well said Rodney.

Jenny Rowan

I am quite puzzled by Lucyna’s post at NZ Conservative on the election of Jenny Rowan as Kapiti Coast Mayor. She says:

Well, as a voter in the Kapiti Coast District, I can say that I had absolutely no idea Jenny Rowan was an ‘out’ lesbian. Had I known she was a lesbian, I would not have put her down at number 2 on my voting form. As she never campaigned using “vote for me, I’m a lesbian”, I wouldn’t be surprised if many other Kapiti voters also had no idea. I also would not be surprised if she only lasts one term.

Well it is quite correct that Rowan did not campaign on the basis you should vote for her as she is a lesbian.  To quote the Herald on Sunday:

Openly lesbian, though determinedly not campaigning as such _ “it’s got nothing to do with me being mayor”

Now I think this is a commendable attitude. I didn’t vote for Kerry Prendergast because she is heterosexual, and I think it is great to have the sort of society where a candidate’s sexual orientation is about as interesting as their hair colour.

Not that it would have been hard for Lucyna to find out Jenny was a lesbian.  A quick Google search on her name has a reference in the top five hits.  Also on Jenny’s website she mentions her partner is Jools.

So while she did not campaign on it, she certainly didn’t hide it. What more does Lucyna want?  For her to warn people with a flashing homo alert badge at public meetings? Does she really believe that her sexual orientation alone is enough to get her thrown out of office after one term – regardless of how well she performs the job?

Later on, Lucyna makes a comment that:

Anyone who is sexually depraved is less likely to be able to make decisions for the good of all.

Now Lucyna obviously believes this and I don’t think there is much point debating a belief like that, but really to apply it as a litmus test where you won’t consider them at all, regardless of all the other qualities they may have?  Isn’t that rather umm
extreme?

Demerit Points

No this isn’t a post about the Police or the LTSA. It’s about how blog moderation will work. We’ve stolen the demerits concept from the Police.

If you get 100 or more demerits, then your right to drive post is suspended. Once the suspension is over, you go back to 0 points. Suspensions periods are as follows:

  1. 1st – 1 week
  2. 2nd – 2 weeks
  3. 3rd – 1 month
  4. 4th – 2 months
  5. 5th – 4 months

Now the demerits system allows us to distinguish between a minor offence, and say blatant disruption. Rather than have just a three strikes and you’re out system, this is more refined. The general guide to demerit points will be:

100 points – For highly defamatory comments
50 points – For grossly inflammatory comments with no redeeming quality
35 points – For blatant trolling, highly inflammatory comments
20 points – abusive language
10 points – posting off topic
5 points – For minor infractions, such as one inflammatory sentence in an otherwise good post

A moderator (or me) will edit a offending comment with  a demerit score. If we collectively feel a moderator has been too harsh or lenient, we’ll all vote on it and assign an average score.

Now this system may be crap, and if so I’ll scrap it.  But we’ll see how it goes.  Don’t expect that we will become the language police and hand demerits out for every profanity or swear word.  Generally the targetting will be done at the comments which are so over the top they scare other people off from commenting because they don’t want to get caught up into a flame war.

Also don’t post comments demanding that someone else’s comments be penalised.  You’ll just get yourself penalised that way.  Moderators will be following every thread – they don’t need you to point out a comment to them.  If you really really feel the need to point something out, then do it via e-mail to me.

Also don’t get too offended if you cop a demerit.  Think of it just like speeding.  Most of the time a bit of speeding over the limit does no harm, but occasionally you’ll get pinged as a way of reminding people not to get too over the top.

Clark arrested for burglary of John Key house

Australian Election on 24 November

John Howard has announced the election date – Saturday 24 November.

Labor have led consistently in the polls for 15 months.  It is hard to see how Kevin Rudd can not win.  And to be fair to Rudd, his policies are not too bad and he may be a decent PM.

But a lot can happen in six weeks.  Time will tell.

Recovering

Oh that was a good night (and day). We started off at the Play House at midday, and stayed there until 5 pm. That was the C&R function. Then we had the Banks function at Quality Inn Westend in Grey Lynn. That went through until midnight.

Now I had done the sensible thing and booked a room at the hotel, so I could crash easily and get up in time for my radio interview at 10 am. But sadly common sense went out the window when a bit after midnight someone suggested we head into town to do Karaoke. Yes, never a good idea. So we headed into town, and then ended up in a friend’s apartment at the Viaduct. Now this apartment was superbly located – above Soul Bar – so great view of the viaduct and beyond.

Eventually my survival instinct kicked in and I headed back to Grey Lynn. Not sure what time it was. Got woken up at 9.15 am (luckily) by Cameron needing to grab his gear he’d left in the room. Realise I have 30 minutes to get to Radio NZ. This is no mean feat. Especially as my condition could well be described as less than 100%. In fact somewhere around 10%.

On the way ring up a friend who may have a stat or two I want on the public service. She informs me I managed to ring her during the final minute of the World Cup semi-final. Whoops.

Anyway it was great to be such a fun election night party. To be honest not had a decent election night party since 1990. In 1993 it was pretty sober as office was almost lost. In 1996 Winston won (the real party came two months later when he made his choice). And 1999, 2002 and 2005 speak for themselves. 2002 especially was bloody miserable.

So while it is only local body politics, was nice to have some good results to celebrate.  Some photos from the bashes, taken on Whale Oil’s new iPhone.  I tell you, they are great (unlike the quality of the photos) and I can’t wait to get one!

banks1.JPG

Newly elected Crs Goldsmith and Bhatnagar with MP Jackie Blue.

banks2.JPG

Banks getting an update.

Incidentally his win, dents my record for predictions as back in February 2006 I said “Any possibility John Banks had of becoming Auckland Mayor again, has I suspect died with his idiotic comment on his talkback show that the Robert Hewitt survivial story is a hoax.” To be fair to me I had changed my mind by the end of 2006 as the Hubbard and City Vision fiascos continued.

banks3.JPG

Cameron Brewer and myself.  I think at one point in the evening I told Cameron that before he became Newmarket Business Association CEO, I wouldn’t have known if Newmarket even had a corner dairy 🙂

banks4.JPG

Re-elected Manukau Councillor Jami-Lee Ross and his partner who also got elected onto a community board.

banks5.JPG

Herald on Sunday Gossip Editor Rachel Glucina was a good sport and agreed to pose for a photo. She says she is a keen blog reader!

Wellington City Council

Finally have results for Wellington.  As expected Kerry Prendergast was re-elected.  What I find more interesting is the order in which people dropped off.

Now the vote totals don’t mean much, because of the way votes are redistributed, but it does look like a much larger victory for Kerry than last time – she avoided going into a final two person run-off, as in the 9th iteration she had more than Ahipene-Mercer and Pepperell combined.

John McGrath did very badly, being the first serious candidate to drop off. Rob Goulden also did far worse than last time.

The big winner, apart from Kerry, is Ray Ahipene-Mercer who came second.  He will be a major contender next time and he also may become Deputy Mayor as Alick Shaw lost his seat.

On Council, the results are:

Northern – Hayley Wain will be delighted by topping the poll, with Helene Ritchie a distant second.  Former Councillor Ngaire Best got re-elected, but at the expense of her former colleague Robert Armstrong.

Onslow-Western – I’m delighted Jo Coughlan got elected, and even better she replaced Jack Ruben.  Andy Foster and John Morrison got re-elected, which is no surprise.

Lambton – The big news is that Deputy Mayor Alick Shaw lost his seat, and lost heavily.  Fairly harsh for a hard working and dedicated guy, but I suspect what has happened is that despite being on the Labour ticket he was not supported by many on the left, while the Labour affiliation also turned off those on the right. He may have done better as an Independent.  Iona Pannett won, and I am not really surprised.  She did campaign very hard and even door knocked on my door.  Her left wing vote will be somewhat balanced by Jo Coughlan replacing Jack Ruben, so overall balance on Council not changed much.

Eastern – The incumbents of Ray Ahipene-Mercer, Rob Goulden and Leonie Hill all returned as expected.  Goulden was third which will concern him as he stood for Mayor also.

Southern – Again incumbents returned in Celia Wade-Brown and Bryan Pepperell.  No-one else came close.

Overall the Council may be less divided than previously.  The “disruptors” have not done very well, and lost one of their number.  Also Alick could be a bit inflammatory himself, responding to them, so his departure may lessen temperatures.  But on the other hand if this is Kerry’s last term expect some posturing as people seek profile so they can win next time.

Other NI Results

Former MP Bob Simcock has just been elected Hamilton Mayor with three times as many votes as his closest rival.

However current Labour MP Di Yates failed to even win one of the six Council seats in the Hamilton East ward. How embarrassing!!

Stuff has a useful summary of results and fuller results.

Good to see Lawrence Yule easily back in Hastings. He won by around 2:1.

David Ogden has benefited from vote splitting in Hutt City and won re-election with 7,137 just ahead of Ray Wallace.  Ken Laban only a bit further back than that.  I actually thought Laban wouldn’t be a bad choice, even though he’s Labour.

Jenny Rowan has won Kapita with Alan Milne retiring.

Former ACT MP Penny Webster has won the Mayoralty of Rodney.  Well done Penny.

Michael Laws has a pretty good 3,000 margin in his re-election, and over 50% of the vote.  His ticket though doesn’t seem to have a majority.

For Wellington Regional Council, the likely winners for Wellington City ward are Chris Laidlaw, Fran Wilde, Judith Aitken, Sally Baber and Paul Bruce.

Wellington City results not yet known, again thanks to STV.

South Island Results

Bob Parker has won the Christchurch Mayoralty. Exact figures not yet known.

1.43 – Parker 46,000, Wood 31,000. So much for a close race.

Results now online.

Jo Giles (former ACT) also got 14,000 votes for Mayor so CR Mayoral candidates did very well. The street cleaner got a massive 4,500 votes. Superb. Kyle Chapman got 673 and is third to last. Pity.

Tony Milne missed out on Council but got a creditable third place just 700 votes back. People say he campaigned very hard.

The Councillors are:

Independent – 7
Independent Citizens – 3
Chch 2021 – 2

Most of the independents are moderate to centre right, so not a good result for Christchurch 2021.

The Buller Mayor, Pat O’Dea has been defeated. He has been Mayor forever – he was Mayor when I was at university with his nephew 20 years ago!

Shadbolt has easily won again in Invercargill. No Dunedin result yet thanks to STV, but Peter Chin will win I am sure.

What’s interesting is that the five major cities – Auckland, Hamilton, Wellington, Christchurch and Dunedin are now headed by Mayors who are not from the left. In fact three of them are former National MPs or candidates!

Just looking at Canterbury Regional Council results. The Labour aligned Christchurch 2021 ticket won only two out of the eight positions they contested.  This may make it difficult for Kerry Burke to hang on as Chair.

Other Northern Results

Massive upset in North Shire with an anti rates increase candidate, Andrew Williams, beating Mayor George Wood by 1,700 votes.

Also in Far North Wayne Brown has crushed incumbent Yvonne Sharp with 8,894 to her 4,674.

Incumbent Mayors who had presided over spend and tax/rate binges are being punished big time.

In Manukau Len Brown has won as expected. A massive margin of 14,000 over Dick Quax. Arthur Anae did better than many expected to come third with 10,000. Willie Jackon right back in 4th on 7,400.

Up North, Whangarei’s Mayor Yvonne Sharp has also been thrashed by former Mayor Stan Semenoff who got 11,651 to her 5,951.

As expected Bob Harvey won in Waitakere, but Tamihere got around 75% of what Harvey got.  I suspect if Tamihere had declared several months earlier, it would have been significantly closer.  It’s a pretty good result for Tamihere all things considered.

Auckland City Council Results

12.55 – Just heard Banks by 10,000 votes!!

Also C&R won all seats in Hobson and Avondale-Roskill.

1.02 – City Vision and allies are being routed. With some results to come in, C&R and Banks already have a majority on Council. 12/20 from our initial results.

1.09 – Ward results are C&R have 2/2 in Eastern Bays, 4/4 in Avondale-Roskill, 3/3 Hobson, 1 in Tamaki (Sam) and 1 in Western Bays. None in Eden-Albert due to vote splitting.

On ARC, C&R have won 3/4 in Akl City, Christine Rankin has won in North Shore.

1.12 – Banks 44,085, Hubbard 33,786, Crow 4,948, Hinchliff 4,956, Swney 10,169.

1.14 – results now online.

1.17 – Faye Storer from Waiheke Island has lost by 11 votes to Denise Roche

5.25 – the C&R function is now over, and at 7 pm the Banks function starts.   As one can expect everyone is delighted, or stronger.  No-one expected the left would be reduced to five seats on Council.  Also the fact that even Mike Lee just held on to his ARC seat, and was the bottom polling Regional Councillor in his ward.  It will be interesting to see if he will be able to hold onto the Chairmanship over Michael Barnett who won far more votes than him in their ward.

Lots of thank you speeches from various people.   Aaron Bhatnagar held out for special praise for all his work both on the strategy, but also by personally topping Hobson Ward.

I’m backing Winston

On the issue of the ban on the Fijian soccer player, I’m with Winston and the Government.
For sanctions to work, they have to be effective and wide ranging.

Furthermore, if comparing the NZ Government to FIFA, I have to say that even Helen is a babe in arms when it comes to corruption, compared to FIFA.  They are the true professionals!

Kiwis lead the world

New Zealand has topped the world in another global survey.

Is it best place to do business? No.  (2nd there) Is it best education system? No.

It’s female promiscuity.

Yes Kiwi women have an average 20.4 sexual partners compared to the global average of 7.3. Austrian men are at 29.3.  Kiwi blokes are back at 16.8 – still above global average of 13.2 for men.

We were the only country where women have more sexual partners than men.

And on behalf of the men, may I say thank you 🙂

Local Body Results

Moderators

As I have mentioned previously, it has been a long time since I’ve had the time to read all comments myself. Luckily some good people have offered to help me with the moderation. So they are not totally anonymous, I’m posting a short sentence on each. None of them post comments themselves a lot, but have been long-term readers.

Richard is a thirty something year old mainlander. Into fitness. Supports Binding CIRs.
David is a retired vet, a (very briefly) former PSA rep, who once voted for Winston. We forgive him this lapse 🙂 )

Jordan is a student, is involved with National, and pretty good with computers and other things.

Ray is a retired farmer, a “liberal” who has voted for every party there is (no, no not Social Credit I hope 🙂 ). Another mainlander.

We did have un-PC Lesbian as the fifth moderator but she got busy. A real pity, because apart from her fine sense of humour and judgement, we would have been extremely politically correct with both a gay and a lesbian as moderators!

The moderators have been discussing stuff on our mail list. It may help people for me to share what I posted:

Hard and fast rules are never going to work, as it is always a judgement call. I suggest we use this list to discuss actual potentially offending comments, and see what consensus we get on them. Sometimes one has to look at the context. Also I look at the person – are they someone who started off making genuinely good points, and they just got abusive when someone taunted them, or are they just a troll whose only purpose is to enrage people so the comments become unreadable.

I tend to regard the C word as never acceptable, except in the most extreme circumstances. The F word doesn’t worry me a lot but I tend to agree if directed at someone it is probably over the top. But there is a difference between say someone referring to effing idiots and calling someone directly a f**kwit.

I don’t like homophobic stuff, and have warned a few people about it. I also really really dislike anything speculating on an MP’s sexuality or their family. Ie the Peter Davis is gay nonsense.

One should also refer to the the Posting Policy. It may get more detailed in time to come.

As I am a believer in second (and third) chances, I am also going to reset everyone’s ban periods back to the start. If currently banned you need to see out the period of the ban, but after that the clock goes back to zero, so any further suspension will be for one week only, and then doubling each time there after.

If there are any complaints, I refer people to the first paragraph of the Posting Policy 🙂

It’s Senior Civil War

War has broken out amongst seniors.  Their beloved general has called some of them traitors.  A civil war looms.  From NZPA:

Wellington, Oct 12 NZPA – New Zealand First leader Winston Peters has accused a faction within Grey Power of running an orchestrated campaign against him and the SuperGold Card.

 Mr Peters today told an audience of Bay of Plenty Grey Power members he was aware some members had mounted a campaign against him and the card.

“We are also aware that there is a so called `ginger group’ within Grey Power that has run a fairly orchestrated campaign against the card and me personally,” he said.

Oh no, how dare they.  A senior citizen attacked Winston – personally.  They must be found and shot.

DPF on Radio NZ on Sunday

I’m part of a panel on with Chris Laidlaw on Sunday on Radio New Zealand from 10 am to 10.30 am.

We’re discussing “Honour and Accountability in the Public Service” and the panel is:

  • Rod Oram
  • Bob Gregory
  • probably a former State Services Commissioner
  • myself

Never been on with Chris Laidlaw before, so will be an interesting experience. It’s a good topic also.

Crown Operating Balance

opbal.JPG

This graph shows the operating balance or surplus, since we went back into positives (thanks to Ruth and Bill). Now you can see in the mid 1990s the level of surplus got pretty high – up to 4% of GDP, so taxes were lowered, and for around five years we had
a reasonable sensible level of surplus.

Then in 2003 the level of surplus started to shoot up. And as was almost inevitable, it stayed massively high as Dr Cullen kept insisting that one could not afford to reduce tax. It reached almost 8% of GDP, which would be close to 25% of Crown Expenditure.

And remember when you look at the year just finished, that this is the year when Dr Cullen cancelled the chewing gum tax cuts because they could not be afforded.

Here’s a good game to try.  When the surplus got up to $5 billion I would ask friends in Labour if that was high enough to be able to reduce taxes.  They would always say no.  So I would then ask them to pick a level at which one could agree the surplus is big enough to lower taxes.  They wouldn’t.  I cheekily suggested a figure of $10 billion (never ever thinking one would ever get a surplus so large) and asked if they would agree taxes could be reduced at that level.  They demurred, with such fortunate vision on their part.

The only correct answer, as we have found, is “never”.

Mayoralty Polls

A lot of searching has dug up the following public Mayoralty polls. I’ve included them in also as a special section in the polling newsletter.

If I’ve missed any out, feel free to add them in as comments.

Waitakere: Herald Digipoll has Bob Harvey on 49% and John Tamihere on 32%

Auckland: Herald Digipoll has John Banks on 44% and Dick Hubbard on 35%

North Shore: Herald Digipoll has George Wood on 63% and Andrew Williams on 15%

Manukau: Herald Digipoll has Len Brown on 29%, Dick Quax 22% and Willie Jackson 16%

Hamilton: Waikato Times/Versus has Bob Simcock on 24% and then Roger Hennebry on 7%.

Christchurch: A Press/Opinions poll has Bob Parker on 42% and Megan Woods on 24%..

Far North: A Northern Advocate/Curia poll found a tight race with 34% for challenge Wayne Brown and 28% for Mayor Yvonne Sharp.

Whangarei: A Northern Advocate/Curia poll has former Mayor Stan Semenoff on 35% and Mayor Pamela Peters trailing on 19%.

South Taranaki: A Western Institute of Technology poll has Bryan Vickery on 10% and Steve Pivac on 9%.

Wanganui: A Wanganui Chronicle/Curia poll found 46% support for Mayor Michael Laws and 28% for John Martin.

Manawatu: A Manawatu Standard/Versus poll has Mayor Heather Tanguay on 38% and Jono Naylor on 30%.

Nelson: Nelson Mail has Kerry Marshall on 18% and 16%

Tasman: Nelson Mail has Richard Kempthorne on 32% incumbent John Hurley on 29%

Dunedin: A Curia poll found Mayor Peter Chin looking to be easily re-elected..

Nine scientific errors

As many will have seen,  a British Judge has found
the Gore “documentary” has “nine scientific errors” in it.  No surprise, as Gore is a politician not a scientist.  Eight of the nine errors are:

  1. The film claimed that low-lying inhabited Pacific atolls “are being inundated because of anthropogenic global warming” – but there was no evidence of any evacuation occurring
  2. It spoke of global warming “shutting down the ocean conveyor” – the process by which the gulf stream is carried over the north Atlantic to western Europe. The judge said that, according to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, it was “very unlikely” that the conveyor would shut down in the future, though it might slow down
  3. Mr Gore had also claimed – by ridiculing the opposite view – that two graphs, one plotting a rise in C02 and the other the rise in temperature over a period of 650,000 years, showed “an exact fit”. The judge said although scientists agreed there was a connection, “the two graphs do not establish what Mr Gore asserts”
  4. Mr Gore said the disappearance of snow on Mt Kilimanjaro was expressly attributable to human-induced climate change. The judge said the consensus was that that could not be established
  5. · The drying up of Lake Chad was used as an example of global warming. The judge said: “It is apparently considered to be more likely to result from … population increase, over-grazing and regional climate variability”
  6. · Mr Gore ascribed Hurricane Katrina to global warming, but there was “insufficient evidence to show that”
  7. · Mr Gore also referred to a study showing that polar bears were being found that had drowned “swimming long distances to find the ice”. The judge said: “The only scientific study that either side before me can find is one which indicates that four polar bears have recently been found drowned because of a storm”
  8. · The film said that coral reefs all over the world were bleaching because of global warming and other factors. The judge said separating the impacts of stresses due to climate change from other stresses, such as over-fishing, and pollution, was difficult

Climate Change is an issue, but politicians and others often exaggerate the science, and go well beyond what the IPCC has concluded. And they try to make people forget the economics as well as the science.  We should be debating whether spending hundreds of billions on Kyoto is sensible, considering that by 2050 it will only reduce average mean temperature by 0.07 of a degree. Any meaningful action has to include China.

Versatile

Espiner on Tax Cuts

Heh I like satire.  Colin Espiner reviews all the reasons we have been told over the years we can’t have tax cuts:

Treasury’s books opening exercise yesterday thus took on a very familiar theme. Yes, there was more money than expected. Yes, we’re all paying more tax than ever before. Yes, those dire predictions that by now we’d be running cash deficits were wrong. Again. And no, you can’t have any of your money back. But maybe later. If we’re good. But probably not much.

Indeed the best sport to be had at the Treasury lock-up was playing a guessing game: what would Cullen’s excuse be this time for why no tax cuts?

To recap, we’ve had:

1: The country can’t afford them. 

2: The country can afford them, but it would mean slashing public spending in other areas.

3: The country can afford them without slashing spending but there are better ways of redistributing taxation, such as through Working for Families.

4: The Government can afford to do all of the above and give tax cuts but we can’t because the Reserve Bank would have to raise interest rates.

5: Tax cuts are fiscally possible without raising inflation but there is uncertainty over the US sub-prime housing market.

6: We’ll have to wait until the situation in Myanmar improves.

 OK I made the last one up but the rest are all true. Cullen surprised us with a new excuse, though. Which is:

We’ll have to wait to see whether the amounts of additional revenue we’re raking in are structural (permanent) rather than cyclical (a short-term situation).

This despite the fact that the trend has been pretty much unchanged since 1999. Since that time, the amount of tax collected has almost doubled, from around $30 billion a year to some $53 billion for the year ended June 2007.

Colin shouldn’t give Cullen ideas for additional excuses!

I get the feeling, though, that Cullen’s almost out of excuses and despite his ideological aversion to reducing taxes political necessity (or Helen Clark) is going to force his hand in 2008. The only question that remains is how big the cuts will be, and where they will be concentrated.

My pick is that the cuts will be across the board, and achieved through shifting the income thresholds at which each of the bands kick in. It’s possible, as some bloggers have suggested on this site, that Cullen could make the first $10,000 of income tax-free as a means of ensuring that lower-income Kiwis also get some real benefit from the cuts. I would imagine the 33c rate threshold would be increased from $38,000 to around $45,000 and the top 39c rate pushed up from $60,000 to $75,000 or $80,000.

I’m not going to try to estimate the costs of this here since I’ll probably get it wrong and it’s dependent on a number of factors, but suffice to say it would be between one and two billion dollars a year.

Let’s help calculate the costs of these things for Colin.

  1. First $10,000 of income tax free.  Well this one won’t happen as reducing the 15% rate to 0% would cost around $2.2 billion according to Treasury.
  2. 33c rate threshold moves from $38,000 to $45,000. Costs would be around $875 million annually.
  3. 39c rate moves from $60K to $75K . Only $300 million cost annually.

So (1) won’t happen but a combination of (2) and (3) is quite possible.

Muldoon Alert No 2

Tracy Watkins blogs on Winston Peters this week:

 Peters unfairly got it into his head that his troubles started when Espiner did a story about the emails; an accusation which somewhat skirted around the point that it was National which released the emails in the first place.

He then proffered as evidence of his TV One theory the fact that there were no parliamentary questions set down for him today on the troop saga – another omission for which he appeared to personally blame Espiner.

Now, while most journalists would give their right arm for a shot at writing up the day’s list of parliamentary questions, the arcane rules of Parliament insist that these remain the preserve of the opposition.

Peters then insisted that Espiner either start behaving responsibly or stay home.

It’s never been entirely clear whether those same arcane rules allow MPs to toss journalists out of the parliamentary precinct on a whim. But if anyone was inclined to run a test case, it would be Peters.

I suspect the difference between Muldoon and Peters is that Muldoon just wanted to ban some journalists, while Winston would happily ban them all if he could 🙂

The ASPAs

At the weekend I had the great pleasure of attending the ASPAs, the awards of the Aotearoa Student Press Association. The function was held at Massey University in the old War Pavilion complex. Later it ended up in town.

Traditionally it is a battle to the death between heavyweights Salient and Critic, but this year the awards were shared all around, with small and large newspapers all doing well. And Craccum won the overall prize.

The list of all the winners is on Facebook. Fairfax were one of the sponsors (they liked the idea of having unpaid news editors :-), and Sean Plunket the MC.

At times I felt like a relic from the Smithsonian, as one of the attendees – upon me introducing myself, exclaimed “Are you THE David Farrar”. I was both flattered and appalled 🙂

aspa1.JPG

A camera shy Nicola Kean, who was the primary organiser of the Awards Night. She and the others did a great job.

aspa2.JPG

Radio NZ’s Sean Plunket who managed the sometimes rowdy crowd well. He also gave a short yet meaningful speech on journalism.

aspa3.JPG

One of the Craccum editors, accepting Newspaper of the Year Award.

aspa4.JPG

Critic’s Kate Newton who won Best Columnist of the Year. Kate holds the job I used to hold on Critic so had a good chat with her. I especially enjoyed the exchange when she asked me why I was attending the ASPAs and I explained I was not there as a blogger, but I was one of the category judges. She asked which category I had been a Judge for and with a smile I said I was one of the (three) judges for Best Columnist.

aspa5.JPG

A fashion disaster – matching shoes!

aspa6.JPG

Salient Editor Steve Nicoll and two others whose name I am afraid I can not recall. The one in blue edits one of the smaller newspapers in Auckland I think.

aspa7.JPG

To save infringements of the drink driving laws, ASPA laid on a bus to take people into town, where we headed to The Kumara. It was a short yet fun bus trip. Young Chris Bishop was going to be a piker and head home until he realised his father, John Bishop, was heading into town and was going to show him up!

aspa8.JPG

Dancing and drinking at the Kumara. We also had a pleasure of a police raid – not searching for underage drinkers though, but some escaped criminal. They took Bishop Sr outside for questioning which amused me!

aspa9.JPG

I left The Kumara a bit after midnight and headed to Gabby’s place where we had a fun cocktail mixing party until around 3 am. Pictured above are Gabby and Argentinian flatmate Marina.

So all in all ended up being one of the better Saturday nights in recent times. Very happy to be an ASPA judge again!

Privately Built Schools in Australia

One News had an excellent informative and non hysterical item tonight on how the NSW Labor Government has allowed the private sector to build and maintain schools, and lease them back to schools on a thirty year lease to own arrangement.

It’s proven so good in NSW, other states are taking it up.

What works so well for the schools, is they have a service level agreement with the owners, with financial penalties.  So the school is freed up to concentrate on the core task of educating students, and the private business takes care of the maintenace etc.

If graffiti lasts for more than an hour, the owner is penalised.  Likewise if mroe than x toilets are not working, they get fine.  So the building owner has a real incentive to provide first class service.

And the state auditor-general has calculated this partnerships will save the taxpayer $60 million.

So you have one party which says, hey if this model worked in NSW we’ll be at least open minded enough to try it and use it if it will result in better schools for our kids, at less cost.

And you have another party which swears they would rather die first than allow this to happen.

So which party is concerned about kids and which party is concerned about votes?