Espiner on National

I referred to National’s handling of the GP frees issue as “a bit sloppy”.  Colin Espiner is somewhat tougher, calling it “the mother of all clangers” and most amusingly:

I haven’t seen the Prime Minister looking this happy since Don Brash started talking about another MP’s testicles during a press conference.

Heh.

Ouch

You Tube politics is here to stay. An attack video with some footage of John Key at the Porirua markets with close ups of John sniffing various vegetables to check if they were fresh. I found it pretty funny, but of course I am not the target of it. Politicians are going to have to get used to these.

Support the Burmese

The military Government in Burma is truly one of the most nasty and repressive ones about. This week there have been awful reports of their supression of pro democracy forces.

If you are in Auckland then show your opposition to the regime:

When: Saturday, 29 September, 14:00
Where: Aotea Square, Auckland.

Hat Tip: The Standard

Hooton praises Labour

The Standard has highlighted this rare praise from Matthew Hooton:

PRESENTER: Ah, right, we better start with climate change policy announcement… How do you think it went, Matthew.

HOOTON: Well, I have to say it was probably the most successful policy announcement by a government in a democracy that I’ve ever heard of.

The Greens are now starting to complain a bit though.  However that probably reassures most NZers 🙂

Support the Free Speech Coalition

After scores of requests for something to be done about the Electoral Finance Bill, apart from hoping the Government does a Damascus and agrees to withdraw it, I am happy to announce the formation of the Free Speech Coalition.

Please support us in informing the public about this Bill, and what its effects on society will be.  The more the public know about this Bill, the more they will hate it.  But we need to be able to get them more aware of it – that is the aim of the Free Speech Coalition.  We have no major funders.  In fact we have no funders at all at this stage.  All expenses have been met by us personally.

So please help us to help yourselves.

Two more public Curia polls

Curia has had two more local government polls published by media organisations.

The Northern Advocate, Bay Report and Northland Age have published their poll for the Far North Mayoralty, which reveals Wayne Brown is narrowly ahead of incumbent Yvonne Sharp, but it is close.

Less close is the Wanganui Chronicle poll, which Laws Watch has scanned a table from in. Michael Laws is well in the lead.

I did declare to the Editor a potential conflict that Michael got me arrested 13 years ago, but that I was now well over it:-)

Not that I would anyway ever let personal views interfere with providing the best professional service I can.

Interestingly Laws had commissioned his own poll, and the topline results are very similiar.

We’ve also done polling for a number of mayoral candidates (never in the same area as one we are polling for a newspaper) so come election night on the 13th I’ll be following a dozen races with professional interest.

Quotes from Law Society Submission on Electoral Finance Bill

I’ve found the Law Society submission online. Some quotes:

The bill has serious defects, which mean it will not achieve its stated aims. Moreover, it is likely to curtail the legitimate expression of opinions while failing to curb (and potentially even incentivising) clandestine conduct in relation to the electoral process. The bill as a whole represents a backward step in the integrity of democracy in New Zealand.

 Okay not too positive.

The fact that redrafting and brokering is going on amongst political parties as to changes that will be promoted by the Government at the same time as submissions are being sought, excludes public participation and is an anathema to the Select Committee process.

It would be inappropriate to repair such a measure with a complex, negotiated Supplementary Order Paper even if this were referred to a Select Committee. A Supplementary Order Paper would not usually be subject to Bill of Rights Act certification by the Attorney-General. This is particularly important given that the opinion on Bill of Rights Act consistency given by the Crown Law Office in relation to the present bill does not seem to engage with the points raised in this submission.

That puts paid to the notion of lets just amend the Bill and all will be fine. 

Withdrawing the bill and starting again would enable a Regulatory Impact Statement and a list of those consulted to be added to the Explanatory Note. Both are notably absent from this bill.

Accordingly the Society submits that the current Bill should be abandoned and a process embarked upon whereby:

  • the principles to which New Zealand aspires in terrns of its democratic process are identified (clause 3(a) to (e) may indeed identify these);

  • the areas where current law fails to embody and protect these principles are determined; and

  • fair and practical solutions to these problems are formulated.

This is polite lawyer speak for “Kill the Bill”.

They also have a good analysis of the problems of extending the regulated period: 

Informing people about the services available to them from their government is a necessary, important and proper function of government. However, when a restricted period (during which any criticism of government initiatives is a regulated election advertisement) is too long and spending limits are too low, the dissemination of information about government services provides an unacceptable advantage to the incumbent government. This is so even if used in good faith, though the advantage is easily amenable to abuse.

 An unacceptable advantage to the incumbent Government says it all.  Of course that is the unwritten primary purpose of the Bill.

They they deal to the regulations on issue advocacy:

The primary issue with this restriction is the potential for it to be used as a weapon for shutting down debate. Bizarrely, the regime seems to mean that the best way to take an issue off the table is to take a position on it. By taking a position on an issue a party or candidate ensures that any person or entity wishing to take the opposing view publicly will be required to go through the strict process of registering as a third party and then be limited to $60,000 in its spending. The net effect is a stifling of debate on important issues. Furthermore, the basic fact that collectively parties and candidates will be found to have “taken positions” on almost everything, entails the financial regulation of speech on almost all relevant issues at election time. The net effect is a stifling of political debate.Of course we are sure the Government never wanted to shut down debate on unpopular issues.  No no the “haters and wreckers” are embraced by Helen.

Then again the conclusion:

The broad purposes of the bill may well be admirable. However, it appears that its operative provisions have been formulated in a manner so divorced from these purposes that the bill will have the opposite effect to that which is intended. In this case a political compromise has resulted in a compromise of principles and this cannot be accepted in an area as important as regulation of the democratic process.

The Society considers that the bill goes no way towards increasing transparency or accountability in the democratic process. Conversely, it risks encouraging large anonymous donations to political parties and candidates in preference to open participation in public debate. In this way it promotes rather than prevents the undue influence of wealth.The rules regarding registration, disclosure, spending limits and related offences are so complex, vague and uncertain as to make participation in our parliamentary democracy an arduous and perhaps even legally dangerous undertaking for ordinary New Zealanders.

In conclusion, there is no one part of the bill that is problematic. Rather, the bill in its current form is a flawed attempt to achieve a legitimate social objective. Its cumulative defects make it irredeemable: the democratic deficit associated with use of the Supplementary Order Paper procedure (even if that were referred to the Select Committee) means that redemption ought not to be attempted in that way. Hence the bill ought not to proceed.

I’m not quite sure what irredeemable means (okay I do know) but it doesn’t sound like a good thing for the New Zealand Law Society to say about a proposed law.

The Select Committee has an easy job.  The oral submissions have now concluded.  All that is required is a half hour meeting to resolve that the Bill does not proceed.  Just do it!

Law Society says Kill the Bill

This is almost unprecedented.

The Law Society puts in a submission on most bills before Parliament.  But almost without exception they provide constructive suggestions as to how to improve the Bill. But in their own words:

“It’s very rare for the society to come to the view that a bill is bad and should not proceed further. But the Electoral Finance Bill is one such bill,”

They state:

“The rules regarding registration, disclosure, spending limits and related offences are so complex, vague and uncertain as to make participation in our parliamentary democracy a difficult undertaking for ordinary New Zealanders.

“The effect in our view will be to stifle debate on important issues at election time which is precisely when debate should be encouraged,”

Both the Human Rights Commission and the Law Society have said the Bill is so flawed that it should not proceed.  If Labour, Greens, NZ First and United Future insist on pressing ahead, despite this, they should be made to suffer the consequences.

DPF on Radio NZ

I’m on Checkpoint at some stage today discussing the Police and their decision to use a Wiki to consult on the new Police Act.  As one would expect, I’m very positive on the move.

What a pity the Electoral Finance Bill/Act isn’t also being consulted on by Wiki.  We could then actually turn it into something less retarded.

National’s Health Discussion paper

National released yesterday its discussion paper on health.  Some key points are:

  • Greater involvement by doctors, nurses and other health professionals in the public health system’s planning and operation
  • Relocating some hospital services to Integrated Family Health Centres, which would provide a fuller range of services closer to patients
  • Use of public-private partnerships to boost elective surgery availability and cut waiting lists
  • Investigate bonding and student-loan write-offs to boost the health workforce

The full paper is 51 pages long.

Understandably some of the media focus has been the statement during the press conference that National does not plan to continue to cap GP fees.  I’ll touch on the process and the substance of this.

The political management has been a bit sloppy to not have this explicit in the discussion document or at least the accompanying material.   Any release of decisions or thinking should be done in a controlled structured way, not done because a journalist happens to ask the right question. This combined with the publicity over the policy to allow minority private ownership stakes in some SOEs makes it an untidy few days.  Again not that the substance is wrong (in fact it is good to see differences between Labour and National) but that it looks like policy is being revealed grudgingly.  The SOE stuff has been public for months and months and any questions on policy should always refer to the fact that this is not new.  MPs should have at hand that this was released publicly on x date by y, is on the website at z etc etc.

Anyway onto the substance of should GP fees be capped, and Tony Ryall answered this well:

“We think the Government’s price control affects the long-term viability of general practice. So people can have the price control, but they might not have a GP. That’s the reason we’ve indicated for a long time that we just don’t think they should have this.”

He said National would have a much more “trusting relationship and a relationship of mutual respect” with doctors, who had undertaken to pass on subsidies when they signed up for them.

And then John Key said:

National leader John Key also said fees would be controlled by “the market”. Asked what would stop rural doctors increasing their fees given they faced little competition, Mr Key said “country GPs aren’t exactly known for being rip-off merchants”.

Labour’s imposing price controls on GPs has been part a 20 year battle by Helen Clark (she tried in the 1980s) to effectively nationalise GPs and make them de facto state employees.  We’d be like the UK National Health Service and I suggest anyone who trumpets that service should be forced to go and use it.

The reality is we have a huge GP shortage, especially in rural areas.  The thought of GPs making themselves filthy rich because they are the only GP in say Haast is a joke.  We have real problems getting GPs into rural areas, even with the massive influx of foreign trained GPs.

GPs income relative to other professionals has, if I recall correctly, massively shrunk in the last 20 years.  It used to be a top profession to aim for, with top remuneration, but now some LLB students are earning more than a GP, before the med student even finishes study.

Another reason the state should not price set for GPs is not all practices are the same.  They have different property costs, different staff costs, different mixtures of patients, different average times per consultation etc.

Now a quiz question

I didn’t spot it myself, but several people e-mailed me to point out that Question 4 in yesterday’s Dominion Post five-minute quiz was:

“David Farrar hosts which popular New Zealand weblog?”

I guess the next step is to become a Trivial Pursuits question 🙂

The Republic of New Zealand

Yesterday was not just the 100th anniversary of the Dominion of New Zealand, but also of the Dominion newspaper.

In their 100th anniversary editorial they endorse New Zealand becoming a republic:

For New Zealand, the journey will inevitably include becoming a republic. It is a step that the country needs to take, and take soon, as part of redefining itself to reflect the realities of the 21st century. If anyone now proposed a system of government where the head of state lived half a world away, who visited about once every five years and who had the job solely because her father had it before her, there would be few takers.

An informal poll suggests about 40 per cent believe New Zealand should become a republic, though there are differences over timing. That it is not more is surprising in a nation that prides itself on its independence, on its democracy, and on its egalitarianism. The suspicion must be that the only reason that New Zealand keeps a monarch is a belief that it cannot do better. That is mistaken. There are issues to be worked through – how much power a president should have, how he or she should be chosen – but New Zealanders should have confidence in themselves to do that, and to have one of their own as head of state.

One of the major reasons I hear from people on why they don’t want a republic is they don’t want Helen Clark as President, and with even fewer checks and balances on her. Putting aside the Clark has shown the current checks and balances are non existent (she retrospectively amended the Electoral Act to protect a Labour Minister), it annoys me that people assume the sort of people who want to be PM would be President. But Clark herself was asked yesterday whether she would like to be President as if that was likely.

It would be very easy to have a requirement in the law establishing the NZ Head of State that no person who has ever been an MP can become President, and fur good measure require say at least 75% of Parliament to agree to any appointment (if an appointment model is used) to make sure any President has broad appeal and is not a partisan.

I suspect people don’t realise that the nominal Head of State (QEII) would never ever interfere in a NZ political dispute against the PM, and that the PM gets to appoint and sack unilaterally the de facto Head of State – the Governor-General.

Helen Clark as PM is far more powerful in our constitutional monarchy than she would be under a Republic.

And while not wanting to beat up on Helen, I am disappointed she has one again declined an opportunity to show some leadership on this issue. Bolger knew in the 1990s that championing a Republic did risk losing support, but the whole reason you build up support is so you can spend it. Clark, I have no doubt, fully supports a Republic – but doesn’t want to expend any politcal capital on it.

The trouble with this approach is we have had republicanism by stealth, rather than by virtue of an informed and public debate. And this generates a backlash. Moves such as abolishing titular honours, changing the Oath, abolishing appeals to the Privy Council have all been done in an ad hoc fashion without a clear public mandate. Major constitutional changes should be decisions of the public, not just Parliament, in my opinion.

Anyway enough from me. Go and enjoy Dean Knight’s proclamation of a Republic.

proclamation.jpg

Police Act reviewed by Wiki

“We do not have this phenomenon”

I have to give kudos to Columba University for not giving the kid gloves treatment to Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.  As Liberty Scott reports he was given a deservedly tough time.

There is a tendency to romanticise and overlook the flaws of foes of the United States, because one may disagree with US policy towards that country.  But one exchange served well to remind us of how bad things are.

Ahmadinejad was asked about the treatment of homosexuals in Iran and replied

“In Iran we don’t have homosexuals like in your country,”

“In Iran we do not have this phenomenon, I don’t know who has told you that we have it,”

They certainly do their best to make this statement come true by executing homosexuals.  Of course they also execute female victims of rape.  Yes the victims.

Telecom to announce network sale today?

The Dom Post (which often gets very accurate leaks from Telecom) predicts that today the Government and Telecom will announce at 9 am that after their three way split into network, wholesale, the network division will be sold off as a separate company.

No details yet but I suspect the trade off for Telecom is a less rigourous regime between their wholesale and retail arms, in exchange for the sale of the bottleneck network and access section.

The devil will be in the detail but in principle I have been a long term advocate of structural separation.  This could be very exicting.  If done well the network company could become a Transpower type national grid on which a fibre to the home infrastructure could be built.

Hilarious related scene on TV One Breakfast as the business correspondent stated (twice) that Telecom had said they need to employ 700 million extra staff to cope with the split.  Paul and Pippa were in tears of laughter as they teased him over whether Telecom really will need to employ the entire population of the US and Europe.

Gaynz and English

The NZ Herald reports on a very upset Bill English, whose teenage (under 15) son has been attacked by Gaynz.com for statements on his Bebo page.

I think it is appalling to attack a child on the basis of his Bebo page, just because of who his father is. And I should point out that I am not going to allow any comments directly on the son. Young teenage boys don’t need to face a Spanish inquisition about what they may or may not have said on Bebo.

What I want to deal with is the actual target of the attack – Bill English. Gaynz.com has decided that his son is fair game in an attempt to get at Bill. They very clearly are trying to paint a picture that if a child has anti-gay views, then he must be reflecting his parents. This is total crap, and I can use myself as an example.

When I was at school, I was horribly conservative on “gay issues” and basically homophobic. I even circulated an anti HLRB petition at school (to my eternal shame) Now it is ridiculous to suggest my views in any way reflected my parents. I’m not going to open my own family up to debate, but accept my assertion that this is the case.

Now when I got to university my views liberalised massively, and I’m proud to have massively different views now and have supported campaigns such as that for civil unions, and even been the Returning Officer for the Gay Association of Professionals (which a good mate of mine helped establish, and they needed a non member to run their elections). And I can’t even count up how many friends are gay, lesbian or bisexual but off hand I would say at least a couple of dozen.

Anyway the point is not me establishing my “credentials”, but to highlight that my views have changed 180 degrees over time, and that in no way have they been a reflection of my parents views. God forbid they are ever held responsible for my views as a 14 year old or a 40 year old.

Now as I said, Bill is the one they are really going after. They are trying to paint him as some sort of guy who perhaps secretly rails against homosexuals and influences his kids this way. Now Bill doesn’t need me to defend him, and probably will even be pissed off I am talking about some personal stuff, but it really grates me how they paint such a false picture of him.

I know Bill of course. I’ve known him since 1990, and pretty well since 1996. Bill is of course a person of faith, and it is important to him. But never in all the time I have known him has he ever expressed a negative view in private conversation on a person’s sexual orientation. To the contrary he has hired a number of staff who are gay or bisexual and they are fanatically devoted to him. At least one of his children’s godparents is gay. I could go on and give other examples, but I hope I have made my point.

Sure Bill did not vote for civil unions. And that is a legitimate issue on which to debate his views. But to try and smear him on the basis of some comments made on Bebo, allegedly by one of his young teenage sons, is not legitimate. It is unfair to Bill and more importantly it is grossly unfair to his children, who have to cope with all the associated shit.

Once again I warn people I will have a very low tolerance in this thread for inappropriate comments. Think twice before commenting.

UPDATE: No Right Turn labels the GayNZ story as despicable and vile.

Dominion Day as a holiday

The NZ Herald editorial is against Dominion Day (today) becoming New Zealand Day. Richard Long is all for it, but Colin James is unconvinced.

I have long held the view that we need both a Waitangi Day and New Zealand Day.  One shouldn’t see it as a choice between the two.

Colin has a point that Dominion Day may not be the best choice for a new New Zealand Day, and I’m very open minded on it being say the anniversary of the Statute of Westminster in November.

Impacts of Boundary Changes

Claire Trevett in the NZ Herald has a good article on the impact of the boundary changes.  A summary is:

  • Hamilton East and West now better for Labour
  • Taupo and Rotorua better for National and very winnable
  • West Coast-Tasman better for National and highly marginal
  • New Botany seat will go to National
  • Manurewa and Manukau East become safer forLabour
  • Port Hills becomes a safe urban Labour seat
  • Rangitata becomes more provincial than rural, helping Labour

Last election National got 2% less party vote than Labour.  If it maintains its current poll lead of over 10% then seats which were not marginal may become competitive, such as Hamilton West despite the less favourable boundaries.

Fair and Balanced

Last week I blogged about how a team challenging the vested interests at VUWSA had already faced an onslaught of staff lobbying against them in the elections, posters (allegedly produced by a political party’s youth section) labelling one member (who had left that party to join National) a “whore”, another rigged online poll etc.

Now voting started last Friday, and VUWSA has a rule you can’t basically campaign while voting so the A-Team has taken down their website etc to comply.

But surprising Salient this week had not one but five articles on the A-Team.  And these appear at a time when the candidates are banned from being able to publicly respond through say their website or through pamphlets. The issue includes stories on:

  • Accusations of racism against two A-Team members
  • A welfare column devoted to attacking the A-Team
  • Report of a lobby group formed just to oppose the A-Team
  • How the incumbent President would halve his pay if re-elected
  • An environmental group attacked the A-Team
  • Continued assertions the refund promised is illegal if fee paid for by student loan (despite the Govt saying they are fine with it)
  • A story on how the Returning Office appointed by the incumbent Exec has said the individual spending limit of $100 per candidate also applies to the A-Team so they are limited to spending just $100 over all 14 candidates.

Now I am not saying Salient should not carry negative stories on candidates.  All for freedom of the press.  But to carry an avalanche of negative stories during the period where candidates are banned from being able to publicly respond strikes me as grossly unfair.

And it gets even better.  Vic student Chris Bishop submitted an article to Salient which pointed out that the A-Team have done a good thing by running as they have got people debating issues which deserve debate such as whether clubs should get $300,000 of central funding.

But you know what.  Salient said they could not run it, as it was election week.  So they can run an avalanche of negative stories and columns attacking one group of candidates, but they won’t run even one column which doesn’t even endorse them but points out the good stuff they have done such as publish a full alternative budget in advance.

And people wonder why I am so cynical about a compulsory association running its own elections.

Anyway in the interest of balance, I reproduce below the column by Chris which Salient refused to run:

A-Team article for Salient

Christopher Bishop**

 

If you’re like me, you’ll have spent the past week or so being assailed with advertising by a group of students known as the A-Team. You won’t have been able to miss the chalk in the quad and by the bus-stop, posters everywhere you can look, speeches and DVDs prior to your lectures, free sausages in the quad, and students handing out cards, fliers, and handbills.

 

You may have been annoyed by the advertising. You may think their policy of advocacy, accountability, and a $25 refund for every student is brilliant. You may think they’re going to gut clubs and rep groups, and so the price isn’t worth it. But whatever your political affiliations, I think it’s worth pondering just what the A-Team has done in this election. In my opinion they have fundamentally changed the way elections are, and will be, fought at Vic from now on.

 

They have invigorated a moribund students’ association where turn-out in elections had fallen to less than 1 per cent of all students. Most importantly, they have fundamentally challenged the political framework that VUWSA has long-operated under. With their policies on clubs and rep groups, the A-Team have started an important, and long overdue debate at Victoria about the proper role and function of a students’ association in a user-pays world.

Continue reading »

Auckland building owner threatened over billboard

Whale Oil has a disturbing story about how allegedly a building owner who had an anti City Vision billboard on their site was threatened by a City Council Officer to remove the billboard, or their funding will be curtailed.

It is worth noting that the building owner was not the organisation that commissioned the billboard.  They just have the space available for commercial hire.

Ruapehu has erupted

Ruapehu erupted a short time ago. Geo Net has data.

It began erupting tonight after 8 pm and is spilling lahars down two sides of the mountain. Early reports are of two injuries and one person trapped on the mountain. No evacuations yet but the roads are closed.One lahar ran down through the western boundary of the Whakapapa skifield on the mountain.

A geologist who monitored the eruption said it was like the eruption of June 17, 1996, which also occurred without warning. I was actually on the mountain for that one!

Final 2008 Boundaries

The Representation Commission has published the final boundaries for the 2008 election.  One can view maps at this link. I suggest people tick general (new) and general (existing) to get the best view.

Tne new seat is now called Botany. It takes in parts of Manukau East and parts of Clevedon and now leaves Pakuranga alone.  I think it will be a National seat on paper, but have yet to do a proper calculation. Maurice will be pleased that Pakuranga is largely left alone.

Seats which change their name are:

  1. Clevedon becomes Papakura
  2. Port Waikato becomes Hunua
  3. Piako becomes Waikato
  4. Ohariu-Belmont becomes Ohariu
  5. Rakaia becomes Selwyn
  6. Banks Peninsula becomes Port Hills
  7. Aoraki becomes Rangitata
  8. Otago becomes Waitaki
  9. Tainui becomes Hauraki-Waikato

Oh yes they have added macrons to 11 Electorate names.  Ohariu is now Ōhariu.  That will create problems with domain names based on the electorates!

Overall pretty good for National as they now hold Taupo on paper, should win Botany, and retain their existing seats.  Not had time to check but I suspect marginal seats like Otaki , West Coast-Tasman and Rotorua may be a bit more favourable now for National.

Republican Debate

100 years ago tomorrow (Wednesday) New Zealand effectively gained independence and become a Dominion instead of a Colony.

Incidentally 26 September is the day I would like to turn into New Zealand Day, keeping Waitangi Day also.

Anyway no better day than the 100th anniversary of (sort of) independence to have a debate on republicanism.

So in Auckland on Wednesday from 6 pm, there is a debate between the Republican Movement and the Monarchists League (plus Auckland University Debating Society) on whether it is time for us to become a republic.

The (free) debate is at the Pioneer Women’s Hall, cnr High Street and Freyberg Place, Auckland.

blog.nz?

I’d be interested in hearing back from any bloggers especially about whether they would be likely to use a blog.nz address, if it was available.  Would people see it as a good identifier for their blogs, or does the address not really matter much?

Note I’m asking in a purely personal capacity, not on behalf of any of the bodies involved in deciding such things.

Personally I’d quite like kiwi.blog.nz 🙂

Compulsory Third Party Car Insurance

I’ve looked into the pros and cons of mandatory third party car insurance several times over the years.  There are good points on both sides of the debate.

The Government is doing the right thing by not legislating immediately and issuing a public discussion document.  That way one will collect all the arguments and see if there is a consensus on whether to proceed.

Of course this shows up their behaviour on the Electoral Finance Bill to be all the worse.  One has a public discussion document on third party car insurance, but not on the rights of the public to criticise politicians!!!!