Random DPF mentions

Three recent items.

First I’m quoted in a story this morning in the Dom Post on another You Tube bullying episode. Basically saying the school needs to be using groups such as Netsafe to know what to do is stuff like this happens.  Netsafe have an excellent helpline which schools or students or parents can use.

Secondly the Northern Advocate has published the results of a poll my company did for them on the Whangarei mayoralty race.

Thirdly my book review of Chris Trotter’s book was in the Dom Post, weekend before last.  Enough time has lapsed that I hope they don’t mind me now posting a copy of it here.  It is mostly after the break.

 Chris Trotter introduces his book “No Left Turn” with a comparison of New Zealand to the legend of King Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table, with the history of the last 150 years being a string of battles between Arthurs and Mordreds.

This illustrates very clearly the angle that Trotter takes.  There is no belief in the common view that most politicians are decent people wanting decent outcomes, who just disagree on how best to achieve those outcomes.  No, this is a battle of good vs evil.  The men and women labeled “New Zealand Mordreds” are responsible for “plots and schemes and violent interventions, like those of the original Arthur’s evil kinsman, have all too often perverted the leader’s quest for perfection into a sordid scramble for wealth and status or, even worse, the desire for social vengeance”. 

Continue reading »

Blumsky to retire

I doubt anyone is surprised by Mark’s announcement today that he will retire at the next election.  He made clear a few months ago he wasn’t particularly enjoying the place.  I suspect he may have found it easier if he came in when National was in Government (Opposition can be quite soul destroying), but you generally never get to do without the other.

Mark talks about his friendship with MPs from other parties, and how he finds it hard to “hate” them.  I think that is slightly unfair on other MPs  to suggest they all hate their opponents.  In fact the old saying is your opponents are across the chamber, and your enemies in your own party!

What I think Mark is more alluding to, is that in politics you often have to do over people you quite like.  You don’t need to hate them, but you do need to fairly ruthlessly try and bring them down if they have stuffed up.  And that’s not the most pleasant thing to be doing.

When it is aimed at David Benson-Pope, who is near universally loathed, it isn’t an issue.  But it is a lot harder if it is someone like Damien O’Connor.  But it is important that Ministers are not held to a lesser standard just because they are more likeable.

Rickitt in UK news for shop lifting

The local media reported the shoplifting charges against Shortland Street actor Adam Rickitt.

However they missed the more news-worthy angle that Rickitt is also one of the hand selected “A-List” candidates for the UK Conservative Party.  I e-mailed top UK blogger Guido Fawkes, and now a story in the UK.

Throng’s TV Guide

A change of tune

2004

“Name calling tactics such as this have absolutely no place in modern day local body politics”

– Dick Hubbard, newspaper advertisement, 19/8/04

2007

“John Banks is a silver-tongued, split-tongue, snake-oil salesman.”

– Dick Hubbard, Panmure candidate meeting, 21/8/07

What’s that word starting with H again?

Hat Tip: Aaron B and Whale Oil

Other WCC Wards

I’ve had a few people ask me to share my thoughts on the other Wellington City wards, after my main WCC post, so will do so below.

Northern Ward

  1. Robert Armstrong – experienced, hard worker, doesn’t grand stand
  2. Hayley Wain – a new face who has taken her role seriously and deserves a second term
  3. Ngaire Best – a former Councillor, strong community links, sensible
  4. Ian Hutchings – another former Councillor who would be an asset.  Very strong on financial management and useful engineering background.
  5. Roger Ellis – would be a good Councillor but competing with other candidates.  Useful business and community background. Former United Future board member.
  6. Jonathan Fletcher – no profile but has sensible outlook and policies
  7. Tane Woodley – demoted as he goes on about peak oil, otherwise looks ok
  8. Mike Collett – too parochial – only focused on his ward
  9. Jim Candiliotis – no policies
  10. Helene Ritchie – Was sacked by Labour as Deputy Mayor in 1980s, not got better since.

Onslow-Western Ward

  1. Andy Foster – Andy doesn’t need my help to get elected.  Most in his ward know him.  He’s involved in almost every major issue and works hard to get results.
  2. John Morrison – A sensible Councillor and even potential Mayor one day.  Passionate about sports and rec especially but also about keeping costs down.
  3. Jo Coughlan – Jo would be a great Councillor.  Vibrant, intelligent, positive about Wellington and with good business and community experience.  I went to Otago Uni with Jo and she is a great sort.
  4. Jack Ruben – A crusader for causes but not a team player
  5. Pauline Scott – Waffly bio, hard to work out what she would do or vote on.

Eastern Ward

  1. Ray Ahipene-Mercer – don’t agree with him on a few issues, but he is respected for his work, and his willingness to work as part of a team.
  2. Leonie Gill – not a high flyer, but well attuned to local issues.
  3. Ruth Gotlieb – had a good run in the past, but now on DHB also
  4. Rob Goulden – Rob’s policies are generally ones I agree with, but the real concern is his abaility to work with staff, the Mayor and other Councillors.  Rob would be higher if he hadn’t sued his own Council.
  5. Josie Bullock – gets marks for clear policies!
  6. Ian Macfarlane – is on the Executive of Grey Power
  7. Paul Bailey – unknown quantity

Southern Ward (2 spots)

  1.  Celia Wade-Brown – A Green Councillor but a good one.
  2. Rex Nairn- like his focus on accountability for expenditure and debt
  3. Ida Faiumu-Isa’ako – a strong community background
  4. Shelagh Noble – a town planner which can be both good and bad.somewhat wishy washy bio statement
  5. Bryan Pepperell – wants to keep penalising business, rates would skyrocket
  6. Bernie Harris – lots of buzz words, no specifics
  7. Lorraine Edwards -anti aquatic education centre
  8. John Robinson – also oppossed to the aquatic education centre

Community Boards

Won’t give rankings for them, but people who I think should get a high ranking are:

Tawa –  Ngaire Best, Graeme Sutton

Makara/Ohariu –  Andrew Falloon, Christine Grace, Ruth Paul

All just my views of course.  Any candidate who feels hard done by is welcome to make their case in the comments.

Minority ownership stakes in SOEs

National’s policy to consider allowing minority private sector investment in some SOEs has been public for months, so Bill English confirming it on Agenda is hardly anything new.  But it has allowed Clayton Cosgrove to predict the end of society etc etc.

First let us dispose of the nonsense about the Government needing the dividend stream from SOEs.  This overlooks that if the Govt sells say 10% of an SOE for $50 million, then that $50 million will generate a return either as it is invested into other things, or is used to retire debt.  Hell if one puts the proceeds of any sale into the Super Fund, you’d get a much better return.

The reason we have the Crown own certain SOEs is not just so that can make money out of it.  If that is the rationale, then the Crown would own every supermarket and every restaurant.

You have Crown ownership where it is  the most appropriate owner for that activity – usually because it is a monopoly also.  So the Crown owns Transpower because it is a monopoly.

Now allowing a minority private ownership means the Government still has overall control, and appoints the Board, but will give companies the ability to raise capital from private sources for investment etc, and the benefits of the discipline of being a publicly listed company.

One has to ask yourself, does the Crown need to own 100.0000% of:

  • A company which supplies testing and QA systems  for agricultural products
  • A company which provides food safety solutions
  • A company which owns farms
  • a coal mining company
  • a forestry company
  • a vehicle licensing company

If you say yes we must, then you should be prepared to argue for the state to own any garage in NZ, every forestry company, every source of power, every agricultural company.

My Wellington votes

Well I have the ballot paper, so time to vote.

Wellington City Mayoralty

The Mayoral election is pretty easy for me as I have known Kerry (and Rex) for a long time.  Not that I agree with Kerry on everything the Council has done – I do think spending has been too high, and the opposition to Transmission Gully annoyed me. And don’t even mention the Stock Exchange sign.

But none of the other candidates come close.  John McGrath looked good for a while but when your own brother disassociates himself from you, that’s not a good sign. And I’ve been surprised by the large number of people who have a negative impression of him. But would probably still be No 2 as I don’t believe in voting for candidates who are standing for both Mayor and Council.

Helene Ritchie will be ranked bottom.  People shouldn’t have to ask why. Probable order is:

  1. Kerry Predergast
  2. John McGrath
  3. Ray Ahipene-Mercer – the best of the Councillors standing for Mayor
  4. Rob Goulden – too many conflicts with others
  5. Bryan Pepperell – not a team player
  6. Jack Ruben – provides criticisms not solutions
  7. Nick Wang – single issue candidate
  8. Paul Bailey – unknown
  9. Carl Gifford – unknown
  10. Nick Kelly – communist
  11. Helene Ritchie – her 47th attempt at Mayor

Lambton Ward

I’m going to be a bit boring here and vote for the three incumbents – in order Ian McKinnon, Alick Shaw and Stephanie Cook.  They’re a balanced team with Ian non aligned but from a conservative background, Alick standing for Labour (but sensible) and Stephanie being Alliance/Green background.  All three make a good contribution, even if I obviously disagree with Alick and Stephanie on some issues.

The second Green candidate, Iona Pannett, is campaigning hard.  And I give her kudos that she actually knocked on my door.  But having two out of three Ward Councillors from the Green Party would be unbalanced.   I want a Council that doesn’t go crazy with huge rates increases.

  1. Ian McKinnon
  2. Alick Shaw
  3. Stephanie Cook
  4.  Michael Durrant – for low rates
  5. Iona Pannett – would make the Council unbalanced but prospect for the future
  6. Ed Van Son – little known but focused on core services
  7. Callum Strong – little known, potentially anti all development
  8. Frank Lawton – unknown

Capital & Coast District Health Board

Generally I avoid voting for those actually employed or funded by the DHB, such as Doctors.  They generate terrible conflicts of interest and we have seen elsewhere how badly they get managed.   The seven I would put top are:

  1. Judith Aitken has a good reputation as a sensible administrator
  2. David Chamberlain has useful professional experience also
  3. John Cook – has significant NGO governance experience in the health field
  4. Gordon Strachan – has wide ranging governance experience
  5. Virginia Hope – has a medical background but employed by ESR not CCDHB and has experience on another DHB
  6. Felicity McLennan – looks ok on paper.
  7. Ruth Gotlieb – reliable
  8. Margaret Faulkner – has some useful experience but too ideological
  9. Donald Urquhart-Hay – highly respected doctor, but again some conflict
  10. Hayley Wain – has been a good City Councillor but prefer people serve on just one public board
  11. Kent Clark – made little impact as a Councillor
  12. Trisha Inglis – there just to get more money for Kapiti
  13. Michael Appleby – DHB not the place for Legalise Cannabis politics
  14. Sandra Patton – too ideological
  15. Karen Coutts – too party aligned
  16. Petra Van Den Munckoff – too party aligned and huge numbers of conflicts
  17. Peter Roberts – totally conflicted as employed by DHB, and former head of doctors union
  18. Coltyn Shaw – unqualified
  19. Adrian Webster – a retired and presumably bored “social justice advocate”
  20. Jim Delahunty – beware anyone describing themself as a “health activist”
  21. Helene Ritchie

Wellington Regional Council

We need five Councillors for the Wellington City ward.

  1. Fran Wilde – an superb Mayor, and a real doer.
  2. Judith Aitken – very solid
  3. Mike Gibson – keeps things lively, and is indpendent
  4. Hugh Barr – good conservation focus
  5. Bernard Darnton – would be a good voice for less regulation
  6. Sally Baber – incumbent, not heard anything bad
  7. Tony Coard – his technical background may be of use
  8. John Gilberthorpe – experienced
  9. Michael Fleming – looks to have solid background
  10. Chris Laidlaw – was not a successful MP
  11. Daran Ponter – talks about fast broadband access but this is a TLA not a RC issue
  12. Yvonne Legarth – seems a bit inexperienced
  13. Michael Appleby – perennial election candidate
  14. Paul Bruce – prefer parliamentary politics left out of Regional Council
  15. Matt Barclay – unknown
  16. Ian Hamlin -unknown
  17. Thomas Morgan – Thomas specialises in coming last

Feel free to post your own orders in the comments.

Nuke Kiwiblog

Okay’s here’s a great site that will appeal to the left especially.  You can spend hours inflicting nukes, floods and meteors on Kiwiblog.  One can also send in snails or dinosaurs, plus various bodily excretions.

Go to Net Disaster and put in the URL of the site you wish to destroy, and choose your preferred disaster.  Some of them you can aim yourself.  Lots and lots of fun.

The Brady Bunch

0566805700.jpg

Well this story puts the old Brady Bunch in a new context.

It has long been known that Greg once went on a date with his mum Carol, in real life.

But a new book reveals that sisters Marcia and Jen had a lesbian sex romp together.

I never knew the series was set in Tasmania!!

Birthday Pics

A few pics from the big 4-0 on the 11th.

db1.jpg

The amazing Spider Pig cake made by Aimee. If you don’t know who Spider Pig is, check Wikipedia. The theme song is very catchy.

bd2.jpg

Former flatmates Emma and Anna.

bd3.jpg

Creative genius and all around good guy John Ansell and Young Nats capo Alex Mitchell.

bd4.jpg ‘

Bill, Chris and myself.

bd5.jpg

A group of gate crashers who I have never met before! 🙂

bd6.jpg

And this will teach Gabby a lesson for having that one drink too many!

Religious Discrimination

Matthew Hooton writes in the SST on the sinister language used by Labour in defending the Electoral Finance Bill:

This week, Steve Maharey, a man Labourites seriously promote as a potential prime minister, told parliament: “The intention of (the Electoral Finance Bill) is to capture people like the Exclusive Brethren, not the Catholic Church.” A potential Labour prime minister actually said that in our parliament, but it gets worse.

No less than the deputy prime minister, Michael Cullen, asked the justice minister to amend the bill so that the Catholic Church’s planned anti-poverty campaign would be allowed to proceed, on the grounds that it would support Labour’s Working for Families policy, in contrast to something the Brethren might say.

That, too, was actually said in our parliament. Our deputy prime minister and a potential Labour prime minister are openly arguing that some religious groups should be allowed to express their views, while others should not.

Labour often talk about how they will change the Bill so it won’t affect legitimate groups.  This suggests there are some groups which are illegitimate and should not be allowed to have a voice.  Matthew also provides some good quotes, worth reflecting on:

As an historian, Cullen must have read the words of Robert H Jackson, the chief prosecutor at the Nuremberg trials: “The price of freedom of religion, or of speech, or of the press, is that we must put up with a good deal of rubbish.”

Maharey has surely read Noam Chomsky: “Goebbels was in favour of free speech for views he liked. So was Stalin. If you’re in favour of free speech, then you’re in favour of freedom of speech precisely for views you despise. Otherwise, you’re not in favour of free speech.”

Both must have read George Orwell: “If liberty means anything at all, it means the right to tell people what they do not want to hear.”

This is absolutely correct.  There is no virtue in defending the right of free speech for views you agree with.  The virtue is in defending the rights of people whose views you despise and think are totally wrong.

Finally Matthew reminds us of a classic New Zealand movie, which some took to be aimed at showing what life in NZ under Muldoon could become:

Politically motivated sackings. Ministers deciding which religious groups should be allowed to speak. Bureaucrats being instructed to peddle propaganda for the ruling party. Registers of political activity. This is not a scene from Sleeping Dogs.

It’s our reality, today, under Clark.

Maybe Mike Moore had a point after all!

Garner and Clark

A brilliant move by TV3 to have Linda Clark join Duncan Garner on their new breakfast TV show for a weekly politics discussion.  They both have a wicked sense of humour so will be great for that relaxed timeslot.

That’s enough reason for me to program it into the My Sky.

Of course I remain a fan of TVNZ’s Breakfast also.  Paul Henry’s sarcasm and irreverence is a deligh, and it seems I am not alone in thinking so.  Facebook has a Paul Henry Appreciation Party, with over 200 members.

Policies include:

  • altering free speech laws to make criticising Paul Henry illegal
  • adding NCEA Level 1 Paul Henry Studies as a compulsory requirement for University Entrance
  • shifting the celebration of Christmas to Paul Henry’s birthday as it is a more appropriate date to celebrate the birth of our Saviour

I think Pippa Wenzel should read out some of the policies and comments on the show!

Knowledge now redundant in curriculum

As if NCEA hasn’t been bad enough, now the new curriculum due out in November will shift the focus from knowledge to skills. Knowledge we are told is no longer needed as according to the Ministry of Education:

“there’s no use (students) being little knowledge banks walking around on legs … We’ve got computers, we don’t need people walking around with them in their heads… People just have to get used to that.”

So how will this system work.  The SST gives us examples:

  •  Social science students will be marked for taking action to make their community a better place to live, rather than remembering facts about a society on the other side of the world
  • Science students might be tested on whether they know how to design an experiment, rather than whether they remember what the result should be

Now one knows how bad the situation is when both the PPTA and the Education Forum says the changes go too far.

So there is now no need for students to remember “facts, historic dates or periodic tables”.  By this logic there is no need to learn multiplication as we have calculators.

The Polish Women’s Party

Ralston this week

Oh I had forgotten how good a columnist Ralston is, with his having become a suit for so many years. First his take on the pan-Christian party:

What lunatic thought it was possible to unite a religion that’s been riven with rifts for 2000 years?

Let’s take a conservative Catholic like Copeland, lump him in with a charismatic Pentecostal pulpit-pounder like Tamaki, biff in the Sallies, the Anglicans, and some of the Pacific Island churches, and form one, single united Christian political vehicle.

Most of these believers have been burning each other at the stake for centuries and it would be like expecting Sunnis and Shiites to form a coalition.

And then on ACC:

Of course, nuttiness is not confined to the minor parties. It seems to have spread through the Government and into its departments. National MP Anne Tolley raised the case of meat company Affco owing ACC a million bucks because one of its off-duty freezing workers was having a smoke in the company car park and was promptly shot by a gang member.

Unbelievably, ACC regards this as a work-related injury and wants the freezing company to fork out the loot.

Where in the wounded man’s job description was the clause saying, “As directed, you will be required to wander off site and get blown away by a bunch of passing criminals”?

Believe it or not, the minister in charge, Ruth Dyson, staunchly defended the lunacy from ACC, and Affco has wearily resigned itself to going back into meditation knowing it would not get any sense out of Government.

Dyson should have told ACC to pull their head in, and/or change the regulation so that gang related shootings in car parks are clearly not work related injuries.

Wendyl Nissen book

Interesting story in the HoS about how Aussie lawyers have pulped a book by Wendyl Nissen.  It seems the level of candour was too much for one of her formal bosses who pressured HarperCollins.

I did enjoy some opf the extracts in the HoS:

On hustling for an exclusive contract with Lorraine Cohen (which she eventually achieved):

“No, you cannot fly to Malaysia, disguise yourself as a nun and smuggle a contract into a prison to Lorraine Cohen,” said the boss. [Paul Dykzeul, head of ACP Magazines New Zealand at the time.]

“Actually I can do whatever the f**k I want to!”

Now that is dedication to getting the story!

By coincidence

Hilarious Kissing Test

Not a gaffe

I saw the headline which said Bush had made another gaffe and had accidentially stated Nelson Mandela was dead.  Now Bush does make lots of gaffes, and I am not saying he doesn’t.  But in this case, I don’t see how it is a gaffe – it was an analogy which no intelligent person could confuse.

In a speech defending his administration’s Iraq policy, Bush said former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein’s brutality had made it impossible for a unifying leader to emerge and stop the sectarian violence that has engulfed the Middle Eastern nation.

“I heard somebody say, Where’s Mandela?’ Well, Mandela’s dead because Saddam Hussein killed all the Mandelas,” Bush, who has a reputation for verbal faux pas, said in a press conference in Washington.

It is very clear he is using the name Mandela as a term for charismatic unifying leaders.

Amusing

Very amusing to read in Bridget Saunders blog that Aja Rock threw a glass of white wine over Ms Saunders, for reasons unknown.  And then when she said to Rock’s boyfriend:

“Honey, tell your girlfriend it’s not MY problem she’s put on weight!”

He then proceeded to throw a glass of red wine over her.

Super Debate

Brian Gaynor lambasts Muldoon for throwing out in 1975 the then 37 week old NZ compulsory superannuation scheme, replacing it with state funded national super. He points out the scheme would have been worth an estimated $240 billion today if left alone.

Gaynor supports KiwiSaver and wants National to commit to it. Again, I sort of agree but point out a big difference.  In 1975 it was a choice between universal state super and compulsory savings.  In 2008 we are being asked to fund universal state super, pre-fund future universal state super and also fund a semi-compulsory private savings scheme.  One of them has to fall away at some stage.

Banks 9% ahead

NBR on Internet campaigning

A very good article by Thomas and Young in NBR on the Internet and politics.  Blogs get a mention:

In a more mainstream way, for an indication of how Web 2.0 could play out, look no further than the website of Cameron Slater (son of former National party president John) who currently attends council subcommittee meetings that don’t attract any media attention and uploads digital footage (and voicemails left by mayor Dick Hubbard) along with scathing commentary.

New Zealand blogs rarely break stories. However, in contrast to the thesis of The Cult of the Amateur, which decries the dumbing down of the internet, the best bloggers are tireless and passionate.

The police report on Labour’s alleged breaches of the Electoral Act was ignored by newspapers until National Party activist David Farrar produced a comprehensive summary and index to the large file, and reproduced key pages on his well-trafficked site.

Any realistic “power list” produced in this country would include either Farrar or his fellow blogger and opinion leader Russell Brown.

The direct-to-the-public videos by Phil Goff, Mark Burton, John Key, Bill English and friends are carefully considered and delivered and unlikely to make waves.

The real potential they open up is for comments made today to be used against the politicians in the future.

Incidentially I think any and all power lists are crap.  I remember when I made a Telco/IT power list one year – it took me almost an hour to stop laughing.

Tasered for asking Kerry a question