NZPA story on Electoral Finance Bill submissions

Stuff has been carrying the NZPA story on my submission, and Nicky Hager’s submission. I’ll comment on a few parts of it:

Election reform legislation would not stop the Exclusive Brethren’s “secret seven” spending hundreds of thousands of dollars campaigning against the Government, a committee of MPs has been told.

Parliament’s justice and electoral select committee is considering the Government’s Electoral Finance Bill which is designed to stop covert campaigns like that waged at the last election by seven wealthy Exclusive Brethren businessmen.

However its wide definitions of third parties and advertising have been criticised by social agencies, churches, unions and business groups, which say the bill would limit their existing advocacy activities.

Prominent blogger and former National Party staffer David Farrar today told MPs the bill would fail to stop groups like the Exclusive Brethren’s so-called “secret seven” spending hundreds of thousands of dollars on a political campaign.

I should point out I wasn’t suggesting making the bill even more draconian by having say an even lower third party limit.  My point was that they are justifying all these terrible restrictions on political speech on the basis it will stop the Brethren, and it actually won’t even do that.

Experience from countries like the US shows that the more restrictions you have,  the more dirty the funding becomes.  Because those absolutely dedicated to spending money will always find a way to do it, but Joe and Jane average are the ones who will be put off participating.  The US has a maximum donation limit of $2,000 yet money plays a far far bigger role in US politics than it does in NZ.

They would be able to do this by each registering as a third party and then spending $60,000 each – amounting to $420,000.

That is based on each of them only spending their own money – something they likely can do as they are generally wealthy business owners.  It would be illegal under the Bill for one person to give money to someone else to spend to avoid the cap, but if each person genuinely has the money themselves and wishes to register so they can spend $60,000 – well the EBs could have 20 members register as third parties and between them they could spend $1.2 million still.   So don’t believe the Government when they say this Bill is necessary as it will stop the EB.

Individuals, if they chose, could also sign up 500 people, register as a political party, then spend up to $1 million even if they did not stand any candidates.

There has been some interesting discussion in previous comments about this, if the Bill does proceed.  One could get 500 people and register a political party called “Oppossed to the Electoral Finance Act Party”.  That party would then appear on every ballot paper, reminding people as they vote about the law.  The party’s only aim could be to urge people to vote against MPs who voted for the Bill, and as a party it would have a $1 million spending cap.

Farrar, who runs the right-leaning Kiwiblog weblog, said there was little evidence that elections could be successfully “bought” and third parties that wanted to campaign would always find loopholes.

He believed the bill should be withdrawn and any changes to the electoral finance laws should begin with wide public consultation to build a consensus before a bill was drafted.

I f the committee decided the bill should proceed, they should recommend enforcement powers be taken away from the police and given to the Electoral Commission, he said.

The police failure to prosecute both Labour and National for Electoral Act breaches in 2005 had been “incompetent”, he said.

Indeed it was incompetent.  I should also point out that while I strongly advocate both parties should have been prosecuted, I certainly do not believe the level of “sin” was equal.   Labour’s action in ignoring three formal warnings from the Chief Electoral Officer (and in actually lying to him) was much more serious.  National for the broadcasting over-commitment should have been fined at least $100,000 to remove any gain from their mistake.  For Labour the maximum fine for corrupt practices is a pathethic $20,000, so I honestly believe jail time was appropriate.  And I think it would have been a very simple case before a Judge.  As previously documented the paper trail is damning.

Author Nicky Hager, whose book The Hollow Men, details many of the links between the Brethren campaign and National’s leadership at the time, said law changes to crack down on third party campaigns were necessary.

“This is the growth area in dodgy election campaigning and everything that can be done to control it would be an investment in not having dodgy electioneering in the future.”

Durign Nicky’s submission, he proved a point I had made in my arguments against extending the regulated speech period to all of election year. I had submitted that if you accept the rationale for all of election year, then at some future stage people will seek to extend this to say 18 months and eventually maybe the entire electoral cycle.

And indeed when asked by NZ First about what to do if National starts spending money say this year, Nicky Hager advocated that the regulated speech period should ideally apply 100% of the time.  Yes, every second of every hour of every day.

So think carefully about whose vision of New Zealand political life you support.

Subsidised by the French!

Very amused to read in the Independent Financial Review (only appeared in the onlien edition) that the French Government helped subsidise the costs of the NZ Parliamentary Rugby Team.  I think it is great the French taxpayer gets to pay!

The IFR also managed to dig up the names fo the full touring party – at 39 it has grown almost faster than the All Black  support crew!  They had former All Black and NZRFU Chairman Richie Guy as coach which is a coup.

Anyway full credit to the team for winning the parliamentary world cup.  I just wish the game was shown on Sky.

Dunne’s Driving Age Bill introduced with leave

Peter Dunne has had the rare honour of Parliament granting leave (any one MP can object to stop this) for his bill on raising the driving age to 16 to be introduced.  This means it will have a first reading when the House resumes in October.

The NZPA story states 87% of people in a recent NZ Herald poll agreed with raising the driving age.   Now I can’t find a recent scientific Herald Digi-Poll poll on this issue, so can only presume they are referring to this survey in March on the Herald website.

Please please do not refer to website surveys as polls, leaving the impression they are scientific random sample polls.

A fascinating piece of wonkery about the bill, is that even though Peter Dunne is promoting the driving age bill in his role as an MP, the mere fact he is a Minister means that under Standing Order 254 it automatically becomes a Government bill.  So a bill which has not been approved by Cabinet is now on the order paper as a Government bill, and it will be in the name of the Minister of Revenue for a transport bill!

Marc Ellis finally streaks himself

Labour adopts National climate change policy

It is no surprise that National has endorsed Labour’s emissions trading scheme.  It is closer to National’s  policy than to previous Labour policy.

  • It is a carbon emissions trading system rather than a carbon tax
  • Forest owners will get a portion of the carbon credits for their trees (something the Government has been refusing to do for years)

Incidentally I think the uncertainty over the price of carbon might mean that a tax is a better option at this stage, especially if one tied the tax to the actual level of warming.

No Right Turn has knowledgable analysis.  He points out that while Labour is setting targets for various sectors to be carbon neutral (such as electricity by 2025), the exemption for agriculture means that being “carbon neutral by 2040 in everything but agriculture” is actually less of a commitment than National’s proposed goal of 50% by 2050.

Auckland City Council flayed by Parliament

The Auckland City Council has been savaged in a report by Parliament’s Environment an Local Government Select Committee. Some extracts:

We consider Auckland City Council’s description of the price rises for Metrowater customers as “modest” and “small” in the Statement of Proposal to have been misleading and to have led to the anxiety and concerns behind the petition.

We consider that the scale of the charitable payments engineered by the city council from Metrowater undermined the intent of the constitution of Metrowater when it was established by the council. The council should have revised the constitution rather than abusing the provisions providing for charitable payments.

We consider that the council could have kept the public better informed about the charitable payments, the rise in water rates, and the decision made to direct the payment from Metrowater into upgrading Auckland’s stormwater system. In future the council should ensure that the public is better informed and that its decisionmaking process is transparent.

We consider that the use of charitable payments in this way, and to this extent, is not best practice, and emphasise our concern that it should not be adopted by other local authorities.

We strongly advise Auckland City Council to reconsider its requirement for
charitable payments from Metrowater in the years 2007 to 2017.

Now be aware this report was unanimous on a select committee with National, Labour and Green MPs. So for Dick Hubbard to claim it was politically motivated is self serving spin.

The Herald reports that the only person on the City Council left supporting the policy, after this report, is Dick Hubbard. Can one imagine another three years of such leadership? Brian Rudman labels the Mayor’s position as suicidal.

Oral Submission on the Electoral Finance Bill

Well I’m just back from making my oral submission on the Electoral Finance Bill.  Can’t complain at all about the treatment – all the questions were useful ones, and we went significantly over my allocated 15 minutes (mainly as I got long winded explaining how the bill wouldn’t even stop the Exclusive Brethren).

Anyway my oral submission is below.  I was on one after Nicky Hager and got to very briefly meet him afterwards. I imagine his submissions will be the main part of any reports.

Oral Submission of David Farrar on the Electoral Finance Bill

I’d like to make just three points, and then move on to questions.

Firstly I think it would be incredibly unfortunate for this bill to pass into law without there having been a public policy process and debate, especially on the third party provisions.  I am astonished that a law which seeks to restrict political speech of non parliamentarians can emerge from the Government without even a single public policy document on which is it based.

Minor areas of law such as digital copyright often have three or four rounds of public consultation, before a bill based on agreed policy emerges.  And here we are not talking a minor area of law, but arguably our most vital constitutional Act.  Where are the policy papers, the options papers, the forums, the consultation, the attempt at consensus?  These are all meant to happen before, not after, a bill is introduced into Parliament.

To proceed without this process, greatly risks angering the public, which the April 2007 Colmar Brunton poll found to be against greater third party restrictions and in favour of banning anonymous and trust donations – the exact opposite of this Bill.

Secondly I wish to briefly talk about the Exclusive Brethren.  Their activities are often cited as the rationale for this Bill.  Well I have some bad news.  While this Bill will make participation in the political process near impossible for most New Zealanders, it will still allow the Exclusive Brethren to spend $500,000 urging people to vote against the parties they don’t like.  This Bill is so badly drafted it doesn’t even achieve its primary goal.  I’ll be happy to answer questions in a minute on how this works.

Finally though can I address the most important issue for the Electoral Act – that of enforcement – and the area where sadly the Bill doesn’t make any significant change.  If you do proceed with the Bill, then please please remove the Police as the enforcement agency for the Electoral Act.

There were massive breaches of the Electoral Act in 2005, and the Police investigation into them can only be described as abysmally incompetent.  They got the most basic details wrong and made blunder under blunder. And the final result was a terrible undermining of the unsung heroes of elections – our specialist electoral agencies.

National effectively pleaded guilty to the $100,000 over commitment of broadcasting funds.  They wrote to the Electoral Commission saying “We accept responsibility”.  The Electoral Commission wrote to the Police saying Please prosecute them, and there is no doubt National should have been prosecuted.  But the Police didn’t.

And even worse was Labour’s over spending.  The Chief Electoral Officer three times warned Labour prior to the election about the pledge card being considered an electoral advertisement. His advice was ignored, and he asked the Police to prosecute.  And they failed to even take the case to court.  I can’t think of an action which more undermines the authority of the Chief Electoral Officer, than having his explicit warnings disregarded and no action occurring.

So please consider this.  If the Police were not up to the job of even being able to decide if a pledge card “Encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for a party, how on Earth do we think they would cope with this new Act, where they have to decide whether a particular proposition is associated with a political party or not. 

The Police do an excellent job in many areas.  But electoral enforcement is not one of them, and again if you proceed please transfer the power of enforcement to the Electoral Commission.  It will at least ensure cases get to be heard by a Judge.

Very happy to now take questions.

Divorced already

I thought God didn’t approve of divorce, yet the speed of the marriage and divorce between Future NZ and Destiny NZ can only be compared to a Vegas wedding.  We won’t even inquire iinto whether it was consumated.

NZPA reports:

Independent MP Gordon Copeland says he cannot work with Richard Lewis from the former Destiny party, just two days after it was announced the two could co-lead a new pan-Christian political party.

Mr Copeland said he still planned to set up a new Christian party and while Mr Lewis could still be involved, the two could not be co-leaders as they were not on the “same page politically”.

Mr Copeland said he been consulting others who had advised him not to go ahead with the pairing of Mr Lewis and Destiny.

There had been a “breakdown of trust, not just with myself but for all the others involved in this process”.

He had been told that he “had no choice” but to cut ties “since Bishop Brian Tamaki and Richard did not adhere to the plan”.

I think we can now safely predict no religious party will be making 5% come the next election.

Great Quote

Whale Oil has this quote from Bill English in Parliament:

Hon Bill English: Can we now sum up the Minister’s and Labour’s position on tax cuts in the following way: he said he could not and he would not, then he said he cannot and he shall not, then he said he could and he would, and now he might when it is right, and why does he not listen to those New Zealanders who are telling him he is wrong and he is gone, and his Labour colleagues who are saying that he is tired and should be fired?

Put that on a pledge card!

Cheap and Nasty

Garth George opines:

In its third term this Labour-led Government will surely be remembered for style over substance or, to put it more bluntly, bullshit over benefit.

The latest and most outstanding example is the vaunted SuperGold card for us over-65s. Despite all the promises and publicity, it is not worth the plastic it is printed on.

It is less than a joke; what it offers is so pathetic as to be contemptible.

Where are the discounts on things essential to the elderly on strictly limited incomes? Like public transport, air fares, petrol and diesel, doctors’ visits, rates, electricity and gas, telephones, spectacles, false teeth, hearing aids and so on?

How come there are no discounts for services provided at a price by the Government itself? Why is it that businesses have to carry the cost?

Because, as usual, the Government wants someone else to pay for what has transpired to be nothing more than a cheap political publicity stunt.

Indeed what was meant to be a huge political success has become a laughing stock.

$4,000 a person consultation

33 weeks of mileage claims

Destiny’s Child

Best quip of the week goes to Colin Espiner who has labelled the new religious party, Destiny’s Child.

Colin is fairly scathing of the whole fiasco to date.

Dave at Big News also thinks Copeland should get out.

As I have said, I think Copeland is a decent guy. But if Brian Tamaki is going to be running this party by proxy, he needs to be very careful about what involvement may do to him.

Commenting on Rickards

In one of those rare moments, I actually partially agree with Helen Clark in her criticism of John Key for his comments on the Rickards case.

The Leader of the Opposition does have more latitude than say the PM in terms of commenting on individual disciplinary case, but nevertheless it is a somewhat dangerous habit to develop. Comments made can influence the outcome of a case, and one may find it hard as PM not to comment, if you have commented on similiar things as Opposition Leader.

The substance of what Key said, may well be absolutely correct.  It may be cheaper to negotiate a settlement than to keep paying him his full salary and package while it drags out over months and years. But that is a process best negotiated in private, not public.

It’s about the blocs

No Right Turn has a insightful post about what levels of support National and Labour need in order to be able to form a Government, taking into account wasted vote and likely partners.

NRT estimates that if National gets 46% or more, then it should be able to clearly form a centre right Government with support from ACT and United Future.  That is about right. Incidentially in the four polls so far this month average support is 48.5% so not a huge comfort margin – definitely no room for complacency.

Labour gets into a position where they could form a Labour-Green-Maori Government if they are at 40% or so.  Their current average is 36.5% – again not a long way off.

Of course the Maori Party might not go with Labour, and also NZ First may make 5%, but one would not want to rely on either of those two things.

A great premiere

I really enjoyed the premiere of When Night Falls last night. I had a couple of complementary tickets, but wouldn’t even hesitate a second at paying to see it.

A pleasure to run into Rodney there also, who rates it a must see.

The lead actor, Tania Nolan, is great and brings the plot to life.  Not a long movie at just under 90 minutes.  It does take a wee while to warm up, but once it really gets going the time flies by. And I just love the ending which was Soprano like.

Can’t believe they shot it on a $50,000 budget.   A great example of Kiwi can do at work.

So if you like a good thriller, and want to support a good local movie, check here for sessions. Thursday is the last day in Wellington, but it will be in Auckland and a dozen other centres also.

Skyhawks for Sale

Bomber on the Electoral Finance Bill

Not often I find myself quoting Bomber Bradbury, but he has taken a respite from his 2,457th Bush is Evil post 🙂 to comment on the Electoral Finance Bill:

Now I’m all in favour of curbing the excesses of money influence in democracy, a plutocracy is a real fear and is a direct outcome from unrestricted electoral financing rules, however Labour seem to have lost the plot on this. In the real areas they should work on, like anonymous donations, Labour have folded and seem hell bent on putting together a bunch of election rules that will give such a biased and vested advantage to the incumbent that anyone concerned with basic standards of democracy should be deeply worried about.

If National was trying to pull this crap people would be rioting in the streets, Labour have to be told they can’t run with this type of legislation especially if the rumours that they will force it through urgency are true.

As Bomber says, there would be riots from the left if National introduced such a bill.  What will be amusing is if Labour passes the EFB, but still loses the 2008 election.  I suspect they’ll be the first ones up asking for it to be repealed once they are not the Government.

I mean just imagine – National could introduce bulk funding in 2011, and the PPTA couldn’t spend more than $60,000 fighting against it.  Even better also get rid of zoning the same year, and the PPTA having already spent $60,000 fighting bulk funding, will then not be able to spend even a single cent fighting zoning abolishment.

I have absolutely no desire to work in a future Government (I enjoy self employment far too much), but you know if the Electoral Finance Bill is passed, and National does gain office in 2008, I might seek a position just for 2011 as being in charge of introducing laws which will piss off Labour, yet leave them and their allies unable to campaign against them.  Think of the fun one could have in such a role.  One could do laws to:

  • Rename Labour Day, National Day
  • Privatise the entire prison service
  • Bulk fund all schools
  • Buy an aircraft carrier
  • Remove union monopoly on collective contracts
  • Make donations to the Business Round Table tax deductible

And Labour and its allies will be banned from effectively being able to campaign against any of them!!

And for the record I am only serious about three of the six above.  And no I won’t say which thre!

The battle for VUWSA

When the entrenched interests in any unaccountable organisation get challenged, things always get very dirty. And so it has been in VUWSA with the vested interests being up in arms at the emergence of the A-Team ticket for the VUWSA elections.

We have seen posters describing one (female) candidate as a whore, a rigged Salient online poll with Young Labour providing instructions to people on how to vote multiple times, and most extraordinary of all an open letter from the VUWSA staff, through Salient, basically telling students to vote for anyone but the A-Team. In almost any other organisation the staff would be sacked for grossly unethical behaviour such as this.

There has been screeds of debate on the Salient blog on the A-team and obviously not everyone supports their policy of reducing the fee by $25 (which is just taking it back to what it was two years ago) and most of the debate has been focused on that.

I find it refreshing that a a group standing for student office have actually listed up front what their policies are (The main policy of another Presidential candidate seems to be to provide free printing on campus for students. Of course the chance of getting the university to agree to this is oh well around 0.1%.), and even do an alternate budget. In recent years Executives haven’t managed to put together a budget until 70% of the way through the year the budget is for!!

Also overlooked is what is probably their most significant policy:

Electronic referenda so all students on campus can participate in VUWSA decision making

This has the potential to dramatically increase the ability of students to have a say on VUWSA policies and decisions. Currently decisions are made by around 50 – 70 regulars in the Quad on behalf of 20,000 students. Students not studying on the Kelburn campus, mature students, post grads etc all are effectively disenfranchised as it is so difficult for them to get to the Quad at lunchtime to vote. But clicking on a link in an e-mail and spending 30 seconds voting online is something many students would happily do.

If VUWSA had voluntary membership, they would have brought in electronic referenda years ago as a way to increase participation, and give members a reason to stay members. But with the lack of accountability that compulsion brings, there is no incentive for those who benefit from the status quo to actually involve more students.

Electronic referenda will mean many hundreds, maybe even thousands of students, will get to make decisions currently made by a few dozen people.

And such a change might just make the difference between an association which survives and prospers under VSM and one which is such a discredited joke that no one would join it if they had a chance.

You see the irony is that the A Team’s policies are what may save VUWSA. People don’t realise that 2008 may be the last year that VUWSA is compulsory. No, not because the A Team will call a referendum on VSM (they have no power to do so and are not going to do so), but because National is currently 10% to 17% ahead of Labour in the polls, and one could well see legislation along the Australian model bring in voluntary membership on all campuses.

Now ask yourself? Based on the antics of the Executive this year, how many people would pay $125 to VUWSA if they had a choice?

But a reduced fee, to an Association which regularly gives you an opportunity to vote on matters of policy, that allows you to vote on what items in the budget should be included or not, which focuses on student issues rather than who should be the Government of Palestine – well a hell of a lot more people might choose to stay members of that sort of VUWSA.

2008 may be the final year where VUWSA has a chance to gets it house in order, so it can survive in the future.

And finally enjoy this You Tube video that the A Team put together.

Xtra and Spam

Jenny Keown in The Independent covers another issue relating to Xtra’s new e-mail system.  Their spam filters have become far more unreliable.

I’ve been helping several people who have Xtra accounts and in every case, two things have happened.  The first is that far more spam is getting through the filter.  But the second is worse – a lot of legitimate e-mail is being blocked as spam.

One MP who uses Xtra not only had all the e-mails from the Leader’s Office never turn up, as they were caught as spam, but even e-mails from the MP’s parliamentary address to their Xtra address had been tagged as spam.

Now to be fair to Xtra, their package of new features is damn good.  Being able to set up sub-accounts is great, and backing up files online also good.  But the transition issues means many users may not hang around to discover the good stuff.

Gang shooting ruled a cost for the employer

How ridiculous. The Mongrel Mob in Wairoa gunned down an off duty employee of Affco in Affco’s car park.

And the ACC are calling it a work related injury and want Affco to pay for the associated healthcare costs.

Maybe Affco should have put up some posters saying “Would employees please arrange for any gang shootings to take place on the road rather than the car park”.

I’ve not got a section in my company’s OSH policy on gang shootings.  I must add one in.

Household rubbish tax

The Herald has a story on how the new household rubbish tax may bring in $30 million a year for the Government.

Now as a general principle I have to say that there can be considerable merit in imposing taxes on “bad” things such as pollution and rubbish rather than “good” things such as earnings.

But the problem is every time the Government comes out with a new tax, we don’t get a corresponding drop in other taxes. Hence all that happens is the Government always gets more and more money.

It would be nice to have some taxation responsibility bill which mandate that every new  or increased tax must be fiscally offset by reducing an existing tax.

Striking because they’re paid too much

Well this is a new reason for a strike. The Maritime Union is going on strike to protest against the Ports of Auckland voluntarily giving its members a 3.25% pay rise.

The Union president has said “his members were incensed that the company paid the money into their bank accounts without their permission.”

There are many things which an employer could do to incense me.  Giving me extra money voluntarily is not one of them.

Of course a union has every right to strike if a collective has expired, in furtherance of their pay claims.  But  having the employer voluntarily giving you an increase as an interim measure until the pay claim is settled, is hardly repressive.

Government funded advertising

The Electoral Reform Bill is only one half of Labour’s proposed re-election plan.  They couldn’t quite find a way to say no one but Labour can spend much money next year, so instead they put in draconian restrictions on third parties and political parties, while simultaneously planning a series of Government funded publicity campaigns which will swamp the airwaves.

National in Parliament yesterday tabled comments showing how taxpayer funded call centres will inform people asking that “The Labour-led Government has invested $2.2 billion over the past six years to help make primary care more affordable for everyone”.

Now let’s not pretend that anyone is a virgin when it comes to Government publicity campaigns.  They occur under all parties, and will do so in the future.  And some are very necessary, while others less so.

I’m not particularly convinced that one needs three years of television ads telling people it is now cheaper to visit the doctor.   One could do a much better job with a personalised direct mail letter, giving people local details of PHOs etc.

Is calling her “Pumpkin” racist?

David McLoughlin has just made what I consider to be a very good post to a mailing list we are on:

Am I the only one whose parental hackles are raised by the media’s universal decision to call the three-year-old abandoned at Spencer St Station in Melbourne by her father, “Pumpkin” ?

This little girl has a name. She is Qian Xun Xue. The media all know this but reporters continue to insist her name is Pumpkin.

Why does our profession act like a pack and seize on a name like this?
It is not any name she is or has ever been called by her family and friends. It is a name the media has by osmosis decided she will be called, doubtless forever more. I find it quite dehumanising of her.

I wonder if her name was Sally or Susan or Kiri whether she would be called a vegetable.

I didn’t actually realise her actual name was known.  David is quite right that the moment her name was known, it should be used.

And while I am very wary about labelling anything racist, as that is far too often used as a device to close down debate, I have to say that I think there is a degree of that here – if her name was Susan Brown, rather than Qian Xun Xue, I suspect she would not be referred to as Pumpkin.