Destiny NZ disbands

Yay. The Destiny NZ Party has disbanded.

However the party leader, Richard Lewis, will be co-leader of a new broader multi-denominational Christian party.

The other co-leader has been chosen but is a secret. So much for open and transparent democratic parties.

I don’t object in a general sense to a family values party. United Future has generally been a relatively benign example of one. My objections are when they more resemble Christian Heritage and are relatively extreme. It will be interesting to see who are the key people in this new party, and what policies they will have.

Labour no doubt will be hoping they are successful in getting 4.9% of the vote.

UPDATE: Gordon Copeland has announced he is the other co-leader.  It makes a lot of sense considering he has over a year to go in Parliament and can use that for profile.

I like Gordon.  He’s been on several Select Committees I have appeared before and is always diligent, and asks sensible questions rather than score points.  Motivated by his beliefs and I have no problem with that. I reserve judgement on his new party, but I’ll be frank – something that looks like a coalition with Destiny does not appeal greatly.  They got a mere 0.6% of the vote.  You need a much broader church than that to make 5%.

What will Archbishop Tamaki say?

Destiny Archbishop and Pontifex Minimus Brian Tamaki is making an announcement at 1 pm today about “his political future, and that of the Destiny New Zealand political party”.

So what will Brian announces.  Here are the options:

  1. He is going to become the Leader of the Destiny Political Party, replacing his flunkie Richard Lewis
  2. He is winding up the Destiny Political Party, so a broader church based grouping can be formed
  3. He spoke to Jesus, and Jesus has told him to become Prime Minister, so he is giving up his church role to work fulltime on the political role
  4. The Holy Trinity is expanding to be a Holy Quartet, as God e-mailed me to say they need a hand.  Currently negotiating if I sit on his right or left hand side.

Any other options?

Human Rights Commission on Electoral Finance Bill

Audrey Young has picked up the significance of the submission from the Human Rights Commission on the Electoral Finance Bill. She notes:

The commission is viewed as a liberal agency of state that rarely uses such strong language against anyone, let alone Government proposals.

So what does the Human Rights Commission say in their submission:

the Bill will infringe certain human rights – most obviously freedom of expression but also the right of all citizens to participate in the election process.

Pretty black and white.  The bill is a breach of human rights, and prevents freedom of expression and participation in the election process.

They then make a key point:

Given the significance of the changes to the electoral funding regime, there is a need for an extended public participation in a more neutral environment to allow for discussion, debate and contestation of core principles. This has not happened with the proposed legislation, and the opportunity for informed authorisation has been lost. The Commission therefore recommends that the Bill is either withdrawn or substantially redrafted to reflect a better balance between political participation and freedom of speech and controls on electoral financing.

They’re saying that restricing the rights of third parties is no minor things, and any law should be based on principles and policy which the public have had input into.  And this is crucial – we need the public debate, the forums, the seminars, the issues papers, the recommend.

Another great point is:

Democracy implies far more than the mere act of periodically casting a vote… it covers the entire process of participation by citizens in the political life of their country – UN Secretary General

In analysing one clause of the Bill, they say:

It will also limit lobby groups, for example, to expenditure under $5000 in promoting a particular cause (if not registered as third parties). It is difficult to see how this will promote the ability of civil society to participate in the political process and makes a mockery of clause 3(b) which refers to promoting participation by the public in parliamentary democracy.

But get this paragraph:

The combination of “election advertisement” in clause 5 and “regulated period” defined in clause 4 will have a chilling effect27on the expression of political opinion during an election year.

Now these are the sort of statements we are used to hearing from overseas human rights bodies about repressive regimes.  But this is the NZ Human Rights Commission on Helen Clark’s Electoral Finance Bill.

They specifically reject the year long ban on non regulated speech:

Currently the Electoral Act 1993 limits the regulation period during the run up to an election to 3 months. The Commission does not accept that extending the period to almost a year is justified.

They also refer to the muzzle your targets clause:

The Chief Electoral Officer cannot register third parties once the writ for a general election is issued: cl.17. As a result of how election advertisement is defined in cl.5, if a political party makes negative comments about a lobby group or particular ethnic group, the group itself would be unable to respond to the criticism during the writ period if it was not registered as a third party.

It is difficult to conceive of a greater limitation on freedom of speech than this.

They also quote approvingly from the Bell Gully opinion against the Bill.  Now some commenters here tried to smear Bell Gully as being funders of the National Party (which just displayed their own ignorance).  Will they alspo now try and smear the Human Rights Commission?

Finally we have their excellent conclusion:

A human rights approach to democratic government requires genuine participation. Genuine participation, in turn, requires an informed electorate. By limiting freedom of expression and creating a complex regulatory framework in the way it does, the Electoral Finance Bill unduly limits the rights of all New Zealanders to participate in the electoral process. The Commission therefore considers that the Bill is inherently flawed and should be withdrawn.

What more needs to be said.  Kill the Bill.

Now you see them, now you don’t

In the 2005 election year budget, Dr Cullen announced tax cuts.  And then because he was peeved we wer not grateful enough he cancelled them.

And then as he pre-announced a cut in the business  tax rate, he kept hinting this would be matched by personal tax cuts. But as reported by NZPA, he als cancelled the $1 billion of personal tax cuts he had been alluding to.

So that’s twice Cullen has announced or hinted at tax cuts and twice he has cancelled them.

But because they think we really are that stupid, you wait and see they’ll try again in 2008 and promise tax cuts.  Shame on us if we fall for it a third time.

Back in Wellington

Well I did just over 1,100 kms in the rental car and flew out from Timaru yesterday afternoon.  Timaru must have the smallest airport in NZ.  Ran into a Nat MP there so we chatted away waiting for the flight.  Only problem was when the boarding call was made, he had forgotten to check in as he had been busy chatting to me.  I won’t name Bill though as being forgetful is so unlike him 🙂

Have a huge amount of work waiting for me back in Wgtn so blogging will be light. I don’t think I have ever been busier with the polling company, and have just had to schedule on several extra shifts next week to match demand.  Problem is the poor staff are streteched so I’ve had to resort to an outraegous level of bribery (known as bonuses) so people will work every shift. It’s one of the more interesting challenges of running a polling company – getting exactly the right number of staff on for every poll.  Luckily Anna does most of it for me.

Just heading into a workshop today with Federated Farmers, Local Government NZ and various telcos and ISPs on rural broadband.  Basically trying to identify potential solutions, and associated costs, and also related issues like the TSO.

French pensions

Life is about to get interesting in France as President Nicolas Sarkozy looks set to tackle the unions over the special pension arrangements for some of their members.

Train drivers get to not only retire at age 50, they immediately get to continue on with their full wage for life.

72% of the public back reform of the pensions, but in the past the unions have paralysed the country in their fight to keep them.  It will be interesting to see if a compromise is achieved or  whether there will be a full head on confrontation.

When Night Falls

A Kiwi made independent film, When Night Falls, has its world premiere at the Paramount Theatre in Wellington this Tuesday and then goes to public release on Thursday at 20 cinemas including Rialto Auckland.

It’s a psychological thriller set in the Wairarapa in 1932, with (amongst others) two nurses and a serial killer. The director and producer is Alex Galvin.

There are still tickets available for the premiere (from the Paramount or 04 384 4080), which includes a complimentary glass of wine and nibbles from 7pm a d the Jazz band Otis playing from 7pm in the Paramount’s cafe area.

I’m looking forward to a good night.

Electoral Finance Bill submissions

I am hearing whispers from Parliament that Labour is 100% determined to get the Electoral Finance Bill passed into law, with the minimum of changes, and the Greens and NZ First are staying staunch to do so. The Select Committee is meeting outside its normal schedule so the Bill can be reported back in November.

The good thing is that there have been 579 submissions on the Bill – a very high number. One of the great new features of the Parliamentary website is you can read all the submissions on a bill online. A huge change from the days when they were secret and privileged.

The vast majority are against the Bill, and I’m pleased to say I recognise many a familiar name from here.

Now this makes last Friday’s Dom Post editorial worth highlighting:

Seldom has a piece of legislation so spectacularly failed to achieve its objectives as the Electoral Finance Bill.

According to the bill’s preamble, its purpose is to “provide more transparency and accountability in the democratic process, prevent the undue influence of wealth, and promote participation in parliamentary democracy”. But the bill’s effect is to do almost the opposite.

Prime Minister Helen Clark’s promise last year to “clamp down” on anonymous donations has proved, in Shakespeare’s words, to be nothing more than “a tale told by an idiot, full of sound and fury, signifying nothing”.

The bill abysmally fails to live up to its promise to “promote participation in parliamentary democracy”.

The bill does almost the opposite, effectively creating a “licensing regime for political speech during an election year”. 

Even a person who wishes to make a placard to hold up at a public rally will need to make a statutory declaration before a solicitor, Justice of the Peace or notary public.

Had a past National government had the temerity to introduce such measures, Miss Clark and her Labour colleagues would have been the first to denounce its attack on free speech and participation in the democratic process.

That they have chosen not to see what everyone else sees shows just how desperate they are to cling to office.

In the wake of the outcry over the bill, Miss Clark has said changes will be made during the select committee process. But this is not a problem that can be solved with a better form of words.

The Government should go back to first principles. All that is needed is an open, transparent regime that requires all those who put significant sums into the political process to disclose their identities.

Another significant voice for the notion that should tell the Government to start again.

Clearwater Estate

Wotif.com is great for finding good prices for accommodation.  Often a hotel with surplus capacity will have huge discounts so one can get a nice room for an affordable price.

Through Wotif, I am staying at the Clearwater Resort just out of Christchurch.  It’s a gorgeous setting with a two level unit next to the lagoon, and with a balcony which catches all the late sun.

clear1.JPG

The lagoon.

clear2.JPG

Spent the late afternoon having some drinks with some friends on the balcony. Very nice.

Arthur’s Pass

On Friday I got to drive over Arthur’s Pass.  I think it might be my first time over there since I was a child.  It is a stunningly beautiful and rugged drive, and one every New Zealander should do at least once.

ap1.JPG

Driving between Greymouth and Hokitika one gets to cross this great bridge prior to the turn off (which is next to start of the Coast to Coast).  I love getting to drive along train tracks – the only problem was at the end of the bridge I started to follow the tracks instead of the road 🙂

ap2.JPG

How many places on Earth can you drive surrounded by scenery like this?  I’ve driven around Australia, the US, parts of the UK and we just don’t realise how lucky we are.

ap3.JPG

Had to grab this photo as I was driving along and saw this chute diverting the water from the road.

ap4.JPG

A few hundred metres later there was a lookout where one could get a photo also.  Great views as one is near the peak here.

ap5.JPG

At the lookout was this poor little fellow.  It was bloody cold.  After the peak I got to Arthur’s Pass hamlet where there birds everywhere.  Had a quick meal in the cafe to warm up.  This is right up close to the skifields.

ap6.JPG

After crossing the pass, the sun came out, and the views on the other side just as good.

It really should be a mandatory drive.  I won’t wait so long to do it again.

SST on Labour reshuffle

Two stories in the SST on Labour’s upcoming reshuffle.  The first looks at Margaret Wilson going to London next year, so a Minister being designated as her replacement in advance. Cullen (who would be great) and Burton are named, but Cullen likes his current job it seems.

They name the Ministers under scrutiny as Burton, Mallard, Tizard, Barker, O’Connor, Ririnui and Okeroa. The new Ministers likely to be Jones, Street and Chadwick.

In the second article they look more at portfolios. Hodgson’s bad performance in health suggests that maybe Goff could be given that job – which would also usefully help bury his leadership ambitions.

HOS supports higher rates

In a rather brave editorial, the Herald on Sunday attacks candidates promoting cuts in rates and hence local body expenditure.

It’s an interesting viewpoint that assumes every single cent of expenditure is on good things, and is not at all wasteful.  It assumes the tens of millions on consultants is all essential.  Without these, the Council might not be able to fix the roads and pick up the rubbish.

I can’t work out how spending $46 million a year on carbon credits (a commitment not asked for by central Government or in fact anyone) will help fix the roads.

The Herald on Sunday also backs Bruce Hucker, saying “Hubbard’s deputy, Bruce Hucker, was disowned by his City Vision colleagues when he stuck to his argument that ratepayers would have to accept a massive increase in water bills to pay for the upgrade of the city’s Victorian-era stormwater system.”

Now I might be wrong here, but I thought the issue was The Council was demanding of Metrowater the equivalent of special dividends to fund extra Council activities, well beyond the stormwater system.

$46 million more for Auckland ratepayers

The idiots at Auckland City Council voted last week to invent policy on the hoof and require Auckland City Council to be carbon neutral by 2020.

Now this decision is not based on any research or even costings.  An officials paper recommended to work on a “road map” to carbon reductions and examine “the possibility of achieving long-term carbon neutrality.”  Councillors led by Bruce Hucker stuck in the 2020 requirement.  John Hinchcliffe went even further and wanted it to be 2015 – totally carbon neutral in eight years!!

Incidentally the cost of purchasing carbon credits at the Treasury estimated price of $13.21 means ratepayers would have to pay an extra $46 million a year to achieve a target which was inserted at whim. Not even a cost vs benefit calculation in sight.

ACT in Wellington

Lindsay Mitchell has helpfully scanned in the regional breakdowns of the Fairfax poll. Lindsay is encouraged by ACT getting 6% in Wellington.

Now it is a good result, but one can read too much into it.  Regional breakdowns of National polls have high margins of error.  In fact I think these should always be published also.

Now the nationwide sample was 1,007.  Based on the fact that Wellington’s population is around 10% of NZ, I’d estimate their Wellington sample was around 100 people. Now this means a maximum margin of error of +/- 10.1% for those Wellington results.

Now ACT scored 6%, and the maximum margin of error is for a score of 50%, so what is the margin of error for a score of 6% in a sample of 100? It is +/- 4.8%.

So with 95% confidence ACT is between 1% and 11% in Wellington.  I suspect it is not at the very low end, as ACT have traditionally done relatively well on the party vote here.

DPF in the media

Finally located online a one off column I did for The Press on technology and New Zealand today.

Also my book review of Chris Trotter’s “No Left Turn” should be in the Dom Post today. Can’t see it online yet, so will seek permission to post it here eventually if it can’t be found on Stuff.

Misrepresented on TV One last night

Am somewhat annoyed at TVNZ after One News last night. They had a segment on Ahmed Zaoui, and as part of that said:

These blogs say it all.  “he should have been turned around at the border, his family will now arrive and all will go on a benefit and live in a state house”

With this statement credited to Kiwiblog website, and a photo of my blog showing my nickname and the blogname clearly.

Now I never made such a statement of course.  That comment was made in the comments section by a GD.  Attributing that comment to myself and Kiwiblog without making clear it was a comment, is the equivalent of TVNZ reciting a letter to the editor and making it seem like it was the editorial position of the newspaper which published it.

The same thing was done to Russell Brown with his Hard News site.  I suspect he is even more upset than me!

The TVNZ text version of their story is here. If you click on the video link under Headlines to the right on “Zaoui’s first day of freedom” you’ll see the footage.

So a plea to media – please always be careful in distinguishing between posts made by myself,  and comments made to those posts by others.  They are as I said comparable to an editorial and a letter to the editor.

New poll

Fairfax Media (Dom Post, Press etc) have finally started commissioning their own polls
– from Nielsen. This means there are now six lots of public political polls published.

  • Colmar Brunton approx every month on TV One
  • TNS approx every two months on TV Three
  • Digi-Poll approx every month in the NZ Herald
  • Roy Morgan every two weeks on their website
  • UMR every month, but only released publicly every quarter
  • Nielsen, frequency unknown, in Fairfax newspapers

The substance is similar to others – National 14% ahead of Labour, Key 7% ahead of Clark as Preferred PM. They also ask who people think will govern after the next election (an important question as can be self fulfilling) and 62% say National to 26% for Labour.

The poll story also links through to a very lengthy story on Clark by Colin Espiner.

Oh and finally a note to Fairfax – you really should publish the sample szie and the date the poll was conducted over.  They are pretty crucial pieces of information.  The level of undecideds for the party vote would be useful also.

What will Clark do?

Audrey Young looks at the options for Helen Clark.  She notes that she has never before demoted Ministers during a parliamentary term.

Her options range from minimal change with Laban from outside to inside Cabinet and Street and Jones to outside to a full reshuffle with major portfolios exchanged.

Audrey does a hot and not list, being:

HOT

  • Cunliffe
  • Cosgrove
  • Mahuta (being somewhat generous here I would say)
  • Parker ( more impressed if he actually came out with some policy)
  • Laban
  • Street
  • Jones
  • Hughes
  • Chauvel

NOT

  • Burton
  • O’Connor
  • Barker
  • Samuels

I would add Hodgson and Cullen to NOT. Both capable but both unpopular in their current portfolios.

Shutting down Bebo debate

The Driving Age

The Herald reports that Annette King may seek a straw poll of MPs on whether to raise the driving age from 15 to 16.

Maurice Williamson is quoted as saying the argument against increasing it used to be you had to allow people old enough to leave school to be able to drive.  But as he notes the leaving age is now 16, not 15.

Incidentally the chance of crashing is, it seems, more related to how long you have been driving – not your age.  But the argument is I suppose that being a bit older will help you more whilist in the inexperienced phase.

I tend to support an increase, but doubt it will have a huge impact.  Enforcement of conditions of learner’s licenses might help more.

Incidentially minimum ages overseas are:

  • Australia 16 (in most areas)
  • Canada (14 to 16)
  • Europe (17 to 18)
  • India 18
  • Israel 18
  • Pakistan 18
  • China 18
  • Russia 18
  • Singapore 18
  • Switzerland 18
  • US (14 yrs 3 mths to 18 yrs)

The West Coast

 si1.JPG

As I mentioned, I am down in the South Island and on Wednesday after some work in Blenheim drove over to Nelson. Passed over this fairly still river.

si2.JPG

Some people need the obvious spelt out to them.

si3.JPG

Stayed at the Rutherford in Nelson and a nice view of Nelson and the sea from my room.

si4.JPG

The drive to Nelson was only 90 minutes, but on Thursday it was a four hour drive to Greymouth and just superb land to be driving through. This is the view from one lookout.

si5.JPG

And from the same lookout, on the other side.

si6.JPG

The mighty Buller river.

si7.JPG

Another great thing about driving on the Coast was the near total absence of revenue gatherers. Only saw one all day.  I was however amused by this sign, which I give credit is pretty effective.

si8.JPG

Instead of staying in Greymouth proper I stayed at a B&B up on Tasman View Road.  It was a windy and later stormy day.

Popped down to Hokitika where I had dinner with Andy from  Panda Sport.  He has a great set up down there on the Coast.  Went to Cafe de Paris and had Whitebait and Lamb Shanks – bloody delicious and the restaurant as good as almost any in Wellington.

Zaoui Winners

The big winner from the Zaoui affair has to be Deborah Manning.  Her advocacy on behalf of Zaoui has been tenacious and effective.  She has won against the Crown on multiple occassions.

If I was ever arrested by the Government for treason, then Manning is who I would try and get as my lawyer.  Of course with her political leanings she is more likely to be the Crown Prosecutor for my trial 🙂

The second winner is Warren Tucker.  He is winning plaudits for both the compromise and direct negotiations with Zaoui, but also actually holding a press conference.  I also urge people to read the SIS report into their decision – it provides some very useful info.

People should also read Zaoui’s undertaking to the SIS, which are not entirely trivial.

The third winner is Helen Clark.  If the compromise has not occured, then she faced one of three scenarios:

  • The security risk certificate being struck down by the Inspector-General, which would cause a crisis of confidence in the SIS.
  • The certificate being upheld and the Minister intervening to stop Zaoui being deported, opening the Government up to massive criticism from NZ First and National for a waste of money and soft touch.
  • The certificate being upheld and Zaoui being deported with a massive protest from the left.

The fourth winner of course is Zaoui himself.

John Armstrong also looks at winners and losers. The NZ Herald editorial says a revised Immigration Act will be Zaoui’s legacy. Peter Metcalfe also reviews the case and notes how Zaoui’s interactions with the GIA were stronger than his supporters had claimed.

More on Electoral Finance Bill

A testy exchange in Parliament yesterday over a section which has had little attention – the protecting of incumbent MPs.

The current limit of $20,000 incl GST for the last 90 days is already incredibly low.  If you decided to do one direct mail letter to every voter, then your entire budget is gone.  This money has to cover your campaign launch, your hoardings, your publicity expenses, your advertisin, your car branding etc etc.

Now by extending the period you can spend $20,000 over, back to 1 January means that defeating an incumbent MP will become near impossible.  Because said MP has a taxpayer funded budget of $60,000 to spend to swamp the electorate with newsletters and adverts all talking about the good job he or she is doing.

Incumbents always have a huge advantage anyway.  This just makes the job of challenger even harder, as in Parliament Bill English asked “Is this a shoddy attempt to protect useless Labour MPs who are expecting to get rolled from their seats?” to which Cullen responded “stop National Party candidates with extraordinary deep pockets and who have been running around the business sector getting very large donations, spending vast sums of money getting their useless backsides back into this place”.

$20,000 is hardly a vast sum of money. Hell an MP can cover their own campaign with just a 3% tithe on their salary over three years.

Also of interest is these reports from teh hearings yesterday:

Also at the select committee hearing, former Electoral Commission chief executive Paul Harris picked holes in the bill, arguing it is too wide in its definition of election advertising and that it will likely catch activities not intended to influence an election. He also criticises the $60,000 spending cap on third parties as too severe. Dr Harris believes it should be benchmarked at a percentage figure of spending limits allowed to political parties. Dr Harris says another major failing of the proposed legislation is that it does not address anonymous donations to political parties. He says more transparency is needed.

He accepted there needed to be limits on how much third parties could spend but suggested a cap of $240,000 — 10 percent of what a political party could spend.

In my submission I suggested $250,00, so quite nice to see I am in the same ballpark as Dr Harris.

Business New Zealand has also taken a stand against the bill, with the lobby group’s economist, Stephen Summers, telling the Electoral Select Committee hearing it will affect the body’s ability to comment on policy. He describes the bill as restricting free speech. Mr Summers also condemned the way the bill has been presented to the public, saying consultation has been poor. He says the bill should not proceed, or should at least be delayed until after the next election so it can be improved to a satisfactory level.

Business New Zealand told the committee the “draconian” bill curtailed freedom of speech and should be thrown out, but if it wasn’t the cap needed to be raised and the election campaign period reduced.

Consultation has not been poor.  It has been non-existent! In fact it has been even worse than non-existent – the Minister has written to groups and lied about the Bill.

Public Transport subsidies

Sometimes there is a good economic case for public transport subsidies.  But other times it does not add up.  Such as the proposal in Wellington too spend $300 million on extra rail capacity which will remove only 100 cars a day from the roads at peak time.

We also see this in Auckland. Bus subsidies have gone up by 89% or $40 million.  Bus patronage has gone up only 1.2%.

Telstra-Clear tops ISP Survey

Eptiro, which specialises in measuring broadband performance, found Telstra-Clear the best (as they had their own network), followed by Slingshot and then Orcon.

Incidentally the place to live for good speeds is Fielding.  I was up there last week and the download speed on Xtra was over 6 Mb/sec. I never get that fast in Wellington.